Marco Zaccagnini
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Marco Zaccagnini has a total of 90 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Andrew J. West
The Canadian Society of Respiratory Therapists
8 shared publications - Aliki Thomas
School of Physical and Occupational Therapy, McGill University, Montreal, Canada
6 shared publications - Tim Dubé
Department of Family Medicine and Emergency Medicine, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Université de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, Canada
5 shared publications - Ian D. Graham
Integrated Knowledge Translation Research Network, Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, Ottawa, Canada
4 shared publications - Mika Nonoyama
Hospital for Sick Children
4 shared publications - André Bussières
Département chiropratique, Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières, Trois-Rivières, Canada
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Research Policy and Systems
Evidence-informed person-centred practice: an integrative framework for evidence use in healthcare
- 25 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Research Policy and Systems
Open AccessEvidence-informed person-centred practice: an integrative framework for evidence use in healthcare
- Open Access
- 11 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Implementation Science Communications
- Vol. 7 (1)
Knowledge mobilization planning guides: a pragmatic synthesis and content analysis
Knowledge mobilization (KMb) aims to bridge the gap between research evidence and real-world application. While researchers, practitioners, and policymakers are increasingly expected to engage in KMb, many lack formal training and rely on publicly available guides. Despite their widespread use, little is known about the quality, evidence base, or development processes of these resources. This study examined the availability, content, and construction of online KMb guides relevant to health disciplines. We conducted a pragmatic synthesis simulating how individuals typically search for KMb resources, using Google Plain to identify freely accessible, English-language guides offering concrete planning steps. Inclusion was based on relevance to health-related audiences, such as researchers, clinicians, managers, and policymakers. Two reviewers screened the first 50 results per search string, with calibration exercises to ensure consistency. Data were extracted using a piloted tool and analyzed through conventional content analysis to identify themes and guide characteristics. The search was conducted in two time periods (pre-2019 and 2019-2025), yielding 52 eligible guides, of which 42 were available for full extraction. Most guides originated from Canada (69%) and used "knowledge translation" as the primary term (43%). Only a third cited evidence to support their guidance (33%) or effectiveness of strategies (24%), and none included a process for future updates. Most guides clearly outlined planning steps (91%) and were visually accessible (88%). Common steps included selecting a KMb method (93%), identifying the audience (86%), and evaluating the process (81%). Few addressed plan sustainability (19%). This review found significant variability in the quality, transparency, and theoretical grounding of publicly available KMb guides. Many lacked clear development methods, cited evidence, or plans for updates, limiting their credibility and long-term usefulness. Only a minority referenced KMb theories or provided evidence to support their recommendations. We developed a meta-guide and reflective questions to support the creation and evaluation of more transparent and evidence-informed KMb resources.
- 11 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Implementation Science Communications
- Vol. 7 (1)
Open AccessKnowledge mobilization planning guides: a pragmatic synthesis and content analysis
Knowledge mobilization (KMb) aims to bridge the gap between research evidence and real-world application. While researchers, practitioners, and policymakers are increasingly expected to engage in KMb, many lack formal training and rely on publicly available guides. Despite their widespread use, little is known about the quality, evidence base, or development processes of these resources. This study examined the availability, content, and construction of online KMb guides relevant to health disciplines. We conducted a pragmatic synthesis simulating how individuals typically search for KMb resources, using Google Plain to identify freely accessible, English-language guides offering concrete planning steps. Inclusion was based on relevance to health-related audiences, such as researchers, clinicians, managers, and policymakers. Two reviewers screened the first 50 results per search string, with calibration exercises to ensure consistency. Data were extracted using a piloted tool and analyzed through conventional content analysis to identify themes and guide characteristics. The search was conducted in two time periods (pre-2019 and 2019-2025), yielding 52 eligible guides, of which 42 were available for full extraction. Most guides originated from Canada (69%) and used "knowledge translation" as the primary term (43%). Only a third cited evidence to support their guidance (33%) or effectiveness of strategies (24%), and none included a process for future updates. Most guides clearly outlined planning steps (91%) and were visually accessible (88%). Common steps included selecting a KMb method (93%), identifying the audience (86%), and evaluating the process (81%). Few addressed plan sustainability (19%). This review found significant variability in the quality, transparency, and theoretical grounding of publicly available KMb guides. Many lacked clear development methods, cited evidence, or plans for updates, limiting their credibility and long-term usefulness. Only a minority referenced KMb theories or provided evidence to support their recommendations. We developed a meta-guide and reflective questions to support the creation and evaluation of more transparent and evidence-informed KMb resources.
- Open Access
- 8 April 2026
- Published by The Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada in Canadian Medical Education Journal
- Vol. 17 (4) , 83-89
How do academic institutions assess and demonstrate their social mission? A scoping review protocol
- 8 April 2026
- Published by The Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada in Canadian Medical Education Journal
- Vol. 17 (4) , 83-89
Open AccessHow do academic institutions assess and demonstrate their social mission? A scoping review protocol
- Open Access
- 22 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (10) , 1084-1091
Reprioritising consultation in scoping reviews: Clarifying purposes and practices
The consultation stage of scoping reviews, originally proposed by Arksey and O'Malley and further developed by Levac et al and the Joanna Briggs Institute, remains a conceptually ambiguous and inconsistently applied component of knowledge synthesis. In this context, consultation refers to the planned, purposeful engagement with knowledge users to elicit input on priorities, interpretation and gaps and to inform dissemination strategies. Although consultation has been framed as a means to validate findings or inform dissemination, it is often treated as an optional or peripheral activity, if included at all. In this manuscript, we revisit the consultation stage as an integral, collaborative and methodologically embedded feature of scoping reviews, one that warrants the same reflexivity, rigour and transparency as other stages of the process. Drawing from recent critiques in the health professions education literature and our own experience conducting knowledge syntheses, we position consultation not as a standalone study or superfluous add‐on but as a dialogical, contextually responsive strategy for engaging knowledge users meaningfully. We offer practical guidance on how to design and execute consultations with methodological intentionality, aligned with the scoping review's epistemological stance and research objectives. Through case examples from our work and additional strategies drawn from the literature, we highlight how consultation can enhance the credibility, usability and relevance of review findings. We also reflect on the ethical and epistemic considerations of consultation, including issues of authorship and the challenges that arise when feedback diverges from review findings. In doing so, we call for a shift in how the consultation stage is conceptualised, designed and reported in scoping reviews. Rather than viewing consultation as a symbolic or confirmatory gesture, we argue that it should be embraced as a dynamic, humanising process that deepens interpretation, challenges assumptions and expands the real‐world applicability of scoping review findings.
- 22 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (10) , 1084-1091
Open AccessReprioritising consultation in scoping reviews: Clarifying purposes and practices
The consultation stage of scoping reviews, originally proposed by Arksey and O'Malley and further developed by Levac et al and the Joanna Briggs Institute, remains a conceptually ambiguous and inconsistently applied component of knowledge synthesis. In this context, consultation refers to the planned, purposeful engagement with knowledge users to elicit input on priorities, interpretation and gaps and to inform dissemination strategies. Although consultation has been framed as a means to validate findings or inform dissemination, it is often treated as an optional or peripheral activity, if included at all. In this manuscript, we revisit the consultation stage as an integral, collaborative and methodologically embedded feature of scoping reviews, one that warrants the same reflexivity, rigour and transparency as other stages of the process. Drawing from recent critiques in the health professions education literature and our own experience conducting knowledge syntheses, we position consultation not as a standalone study or superfluous add‐on but as a dialogical, contextually responsive strategy for engaging knowledge users meaningfully. We offer practical guidance on how to design and execute consultations with methodological intentionality, aligned with the scoping review's epistemological stance and research objectives. Through case examples from our work and additional strategies drawn from the literature, we highlight how consultation can enhance the credibility, usability and relevance of review findings. We also reflect on the ethical and epistemic considerations of consultation, including issues of authorship and the challenges that arise when feedback diverges from review findings. In doing so, we call for a shift in how the consultation stage is conceptualised, designed and reported in scoping reviews. Rather than viewing consultation as a symbolic or confirmatory gesture, we argue that it should be embraced as a dynamic, humanising process that deepens interpretation, challenges assumptions and expands the real‐world applicability of scoping review findings.
- Open Access
- 22 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Advances in Health Sciences Education
- Vol. 31 (4) , 1-25
Unpacking educational approaches for social accountability in health professions education: a scoping review
Health systems worldwide continue to face health inequities rooted in social, political, and economic structures. In response, health professions education (HPE) programs are increasingly aiming to prepare learners for socially accountable practice. Despite this growing attention, social accountability remains ambiguously defined and inconsistently taught, assessed, and enacted across curricula. The aim of this scoping review was to map the breadth and depth of educational approaches within HPE that promote social accountability. A scoping review was conducted following Arksey and O’Malley’s six-stage framework and the Joanna Briggs Institute methodology. MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, ERIC, APA PsycINFO, and Education Source were searched for articles published from January 2000 to May 2020, with an updated search in 2024. Screening involved a calibration exercise at both title/abstract and full-text stages. Descriptive numerical analysis and reflexive thematic analysis were employed, supported by knowledge user consultation. Most articles originated in North America (n = 179; 82%) and focused on undergraduate medical education (n = 157; 71.7%), especially among future physicians (n = 122; 55.7%). Common strategies included reflection-based learning (n = 90; 41.1%), small group learning (n = 82; 37.4%), and didactic lectures (n = 80; 36.5%). Many studies described using multimodal approaches (n = 85; 38.8%). Educational approaches emphasized experiential, reflective, and community-engaged learning and were grouped into ten overarching categories. These were organized using the Guideline for Reporting Evidence-based practice Educational interventions and Teaching (GREET). By synthesizing how educational approaches to social accountability are reported, this review offers a basis for reflection, dialogue, and further inquiry into their development, delivery, and integration in HPE curricula.
- 22 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Advances in Health Sciences Education
- Vol. 31 (4) , 1-25
Open AccessUnpacking educational approaches for social accountability in health professions education: a scoping review
Health systems worldwide continue to face health inequities rooted in social, political, and economic structures. In response, health professions education (HPE) programs are increasingly aiming to prepare learners for socially accountable practice. Despite this growing attention, social accountability remains ambiguously defined and inconsistently taught, assessed, and enacted across curricula. The aim of this scoping review was to map the breadth and depth of educational approaches within HPE that promote social accountability. A scoping review was conducted following Arksey and O’Malley’s six-stage framework and the Joanna Briggs Institute methodology. MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, ERIC, APA PsycINFO, and Education Source were searched for articles published from January 2000 to May 2020, with an updated search in 2024. Screening involved a calibration exercise at both title/abstract and full-text stages. Descriptive numerical analysis and reflexive thematic analysis were employed, supported by knowledge user consultation. Most articles originated in North America (n = 179; 82%) and focused on undergraduate medical education (n = 157; 71.7%), especially among future physicians (n = 122; 55.7%). Common strategies included reflection-based learning (n = 90; 41.1%), small group learning (n = 82; 37.4%), and didactic lectures (n = 80; 36.5%). Many studies described using multimodal approaches (n = 85; 38.8%). Educational approaches emphasized experiential, reflective, and community-engaged learning and were grouped into ten overarching categories. These were organized using the Guideline for Reporting Evidence-based practice Educational interventions and Teaching (GREET). By synthesizing how educational approaches to social accountability are reported, this review offers a basis for reflection, dialogue, and further inquiry into their development, delivery, and integration in HPE curricula.
- Open Access
- 24 November 2025
- Published by Canadian Society of Respiratory Therapists in Canadian Journal of Respiratory Therapy
- Vol. 61, 283-292
When life looks like easy street, there’s danger at your door : Why the respiratory therapy profession should evolve
Background: Healthcare systems are rapidly transforming in response to demographic pressures, changing funding models, technological advances, and new models of care. As a result, professions must adapt in parallel to remain relevant. In Canada, respiratory therapy stands at an inflection point. Respiratory Therapists (RTs) provide essential and complex care across diverse clinical settings, yet the profession remains anchored in traditional roles. Questions remain about whether RTs are evolving in step with broader system changes, and what may be lost if they do not. Methods: This paper originates from a panel at the 2025 Canadian Society of Respiratory Therapists annual conference. We used narrative methodology and composite narrative techniques to synthesize the reflections of four clinician–researcher panelists into a unified account. Drawing on clinical, professional, policy, and research perspectives, we co-constructed a narrative that highlights shared insights, tensions, and opportunities in the profession. Results: We identified multiple sources of tension. RTs engage with evidence daily, yet most of this evidence comes from other health professions. This reliance constrains the development of RT-specific frameworks, guidelines, and research agendas. Additionally, scholarship in respiratory therapy often remains undervalued and narrowly defined, treated as an optional activity rather than a core part of professional identity. Finally, structural, cultural, and organizational barriers, further restrict the integration of evidence and scholarship into routine work. Discussion: Moving forward requires deliberate action to embed scholarship and evidence generation within the respiratory therapy profession. We suggest that strengthening research literacy at entry-to-practice, creating formal roles for clinical scholars, recognizing scholarly work within career structures and innovation incubators and interprofessional collaborations can position RTs as co-creators of solutions to health system challenges. By embracing these suggestions, the profession can evolve in step with health system change, enhance its influence, and secure its relevance in the future of healthcare.
- 24 November 2025
- Published by Canadian Society of Respiratory Therapists in Canadian Journal of Respiratory Therapy
- Vol. 61, 283-292
Open AccessWhen life looks like easy street, there’s danger at your door : Why the respiratory therapy profession should evolve
Background: Healthcare systems are rapidly transforming in response to demographic pressures, changing funding models, technological advances, and new models of care. As a result, professions must adapt in parallel to remain relevant. In Canada, respiratory therapy stands at an inflection point. Respiratory Therapists (RTs) provide essential and complex care across diverse clinical settings, yet the profession remains anchored in traditional roles. Questions remain about whether RTs are evolving in step with broader system changes, and what may be lost if they do not. Methods: This paper originates from a panel at the 2025 Canadian Society of Respiratory Therapists annual conference. We used narrative methodology and composite narrative techniques to synthesize the reflections of four clinician–researcher panelists into a unified account. Drawing on clinical, professional, policy, and research perspectives, we co-constructed a narrative that highlights shared insights, tensions, and opportunities in the profession. Results: We identified multiple sources of tension. RTs engage with evidence daily, yet most of this evidence comes from other health professions. This reliance constrains the development of RT-specific frameworks, guidelines, and research agendas. Additionally, scholarship in respiratory therapy often remains undervalued and narrowly defined, treated as an optional activity rather than a core part of professional identity. Finally, structural, cultural, and organizational barriers, further restrict the integration of evidence and scholarship into routine work. Discussion: Moving forward requires deliberate action to embed scholarship and evidence generation within the respiratory therapy profession. We suggest that strengthening research literacy at entry-to-practice, creating formal roles for clinical scholars, recognizing scholarly work within career structures and innovation incubators and interprofessional collaborations can position RTs as co-creators of solutions to health system challenges. By embracing these suggestions, the profession can evolve in step with health system change, enhance its influence, and secure its relevance in the future of healthcare.
- Open Access
- 29 October 2025
- Published by Canadian Society of Respiratory Therapists in Canadian Journal of Respiratory Therapy
- Vol. 61, 244-261
Knowledge, attitudes and behaviours of evidence-informed practice in respiratory therapy: A cross-sectional survey
Background: Using evidence to guide clinical practice is recognized as the cornerstone of safe, effective, and patient-centred care and is embedded within the national competency framework of respiratory therapists (RTs) as evidence-informed practice (EIP). However, how this competency is enacted in practice remains unclear. RTs, like many health professionals, encounter challenges in enacting EIP and are influenced by individual, contextual, and organizational factors. As part of a broader program of research, our team conceptualized EIP in respiratory therapy as comprising three interrelated components: reflective practice, shared decision-making, and research awareness. In this study, we examined the current knowledge, attitudes, and behaviours of RTs in Canada related to these three core components of EIP. Methods: We surveyed credentialed RTs across Canada to assess their knowledge, attitudes and behaviours relating to three components of EIP: reflective practice, shared decision-making, and research awareness. Participants were randomly assigned to complete one of three surveys, each of which related to one of the components. We used a simple-randomized, stratified sampling to enhance generalizability, and analyzed the data using descriptive statistics, one-way ANOVA, and exploratory analyses of demographic and practice-related variables. We analyzed open-ended responses using qualitative content analysis. Results: The three surveys were accessed 442 times. After removing non-responses and incomplete data, we analyzed the data from 288 participants (response rate = 10.2%). Out of the possible 100 score, shared decision-making yielded the highest mean knowledge score ( M = 86.4, SD = 6.4), while research awareness scored highest for attitudes ( M = 81.4, SD = 13.4) and behaviours ( M = 78.3, SD = 10.4). Reflective practice showed the lowest mean scores across domains (knowledge M = 40.6; attitudes M = 53.3; behaviours M = 61.3). ANOVAs indicated significant group differences across all domains ( p < .001). Using the open-ended responses, 79.2% of participants emphasized that research evidence is the most significant feature of EIP. The open-ended responses related to training needs for EIP focused on condition- or population-specific application (29.5%), preferred formats, such as journal clubs, webinars, and modules (24.7%), and skills for engaging with research (21.2%). Exploratory analyses suggested some differences in knowledge, attitudes and behaviours of EIP by gender, race, geography, practice setting, age, and years in practice. Discussion: RTs in Canada demonstrated variable knowledge, attitudes and behaviours across all components of EIP. While reflective practice stood out as the component with the lowest scores across knowledge, attitudes, and behaviours, scores in all three components indicated room for improvement. Together, these findings highlight that all areas of EIP require strengthening through contextually relevant educational strategies to better support RTs in enacting EIP.
- 29 October 2025
- Published by Canadian Society of Respiratory Therapists in Canadian Journal of Respiratory Therapy
- Vol. 61, 244-261
Open AccessKnowledge, attitudes and behaviours of evidence-informed practice in respiratory therapy: A cross-sectional survey
Background: Using evidence to guide clinical practice is recognized as the cornerstone of safe, effective, and patient-centred care and is embedded within the national competency framework of respiratory therapists (RTs) as evidence-informed practice (EIP). However, how this competency is enacted in practice remains unclear. RTs, like many health professionals, encounter challenges in enacting EIP and are influenced by individual, contextual, and organizational factors. As part of a broader program of research, our team conceptualized EIP in respiratory therapy as comprising three interrelated components: reflective practice, shared decision-making, and research awareness. In this study, we examined the current knowledge, attitudes, and behaviours of RTs in Canada related to these three core components of EIP. Methods: We surveyed credentialed RTs across Canada to assess their knowledge, attitudes and behaviours relating to three components of EIP: reflective practice, shared decision-making, and research awareness. Participants were randomly assigned to complete one of three surveys, each of which related to one of the components. We used a simple-randomized, stratified sampling to enhance generalizability, and analyzed the data using descriptive statistics, one-way ANOVA, and exploratory analyses of demographic and practice-related variables. We analyzed open-ended responses using qualitative content analysis. Results: The three surveys were accessed 442 times. After removing non-responses and incomplete data, we analyzed the data from 288 participants (response rate = 10.2%). Out of the possible 100 score, shared decision-making yielded the highest mean knowledge score ( M = 86.4, SD = 6.4), while research awareness scored highest for attitudes ( M = 81.4, SD = 13.4) and behaviours ( M = 78.3, SD = 10.4). Reflective practice showed the lowest mean scores across domains (knowledge M = 40.6; attitudes M = 53.3; behaviours M = 61.3). ANOVAs indicated significant group differences across all domains ( p < .001). Using the open-ended responses, 79.2% of participants emphasized that research evidence is the most significant feature of EIP. The open-ended responses related to training needs for EIP focused on condition- or population-specific application (29.5%), preferred formats, such as journal clubs, webinars, and modules (24.7%), and skills for engaging with research (21.2%). Exploratory analyses suggested some differences in knowledge, attitudes and behaviours of EIP by gender, race, geography, practice setting, age, and years in practice. Discussion: RTs in Canada demonstrated variable knowledge, attitudes and behaviours across all components of EIP. While reflective practice stood out as the component with the lowest scores across knowledge, attitudes, and behaviours, scores in all three components indicated room for improvement. Together, these findings highlight that all areas of EIP require strengthening through contextually relevant educational strategies to better support RTs in enacting EIP.
- Open Access
- 17 September 2025
- Published by Canadian Society of Respiratory Therapists in Canadian Journal of Respiratory Therapy
- Vol. 61, 218-232
Establishing research priorities for the Respiratory Therapy profession in Canada: A modified Delphi study
Background: Respiratory therapists (RTs) play an important role in delivering care across diverse clinical settings. However, the research questions guiding the profession remain underdeveloped and often shaped by external professions. To address this gap, we conducted a national Delphi study to identify research priorities directly informed by the RT profession in Canada. Methods: We used a modified Delphi method, informed by a prior qualitative study, which aimed to identify and prioritize research needs across RT practice domains. We developed and distributed a list of 74 research items categorized into four domains to RTs across Canada through two rounds of online surveys. Consensus for items was defined as ≥70% agreement in Round 1 and ≥80% agreement in Round 2. Subgroup analyses were conducted by primary practice setting. Results: In Round 1, 286 participants reviewed 74 items and identified 11 (14.8%) as priorities. After incorporating open-ended feedback, some statements were combined, resulting in 53 statements carried forward. In Round 2, 165 participants reviewed 53 items and identified an additional 11 items (20.7%) as important. These topics reflect the breadth of RT practice, including airway management, rapid response teams, personalized ventilation strategies, and system-level contributions. Workforce sustainability issues such as burnout, staffing ratios, and retention were also identified. Subgroup analyses revealed meaningful variation in research priorities across different practice areas in Round 1 and 2. Conclusion: This study presents a profession-driven research agenda for respiratory therapy in Canada. These findings can inform future research, continuing professional development, and policy advocacy aligned with the profession’s evolving roles and contexts.
- 17 September 2025
- Published by Canadian Society of Respiratory Therapists in Canadian Journal of Respiratory Therapy
- Vol. 61, 218-232
Open AccessEstablishing research priorities for the Respiratory Therapy profession in Canada: A modified Delphi study
Background: Respiratory therapists (RTs) play an important role in delivering care across diverse clinical settings. However, the research questions guiding the profession remain underdeveloped and often shaped by external professions. To address this gap, we conducted a national Delphi study to identify research priorities directly informed by the RT profession in Canada. Methods: We used a modified Delphi method, informed by a prior qualitative study, which aimed to identify and prioritize research needs across RT practice domains. We developed and distributed a list of 74 research items categorized into four domains to RTs across Canada through two rounds of online surveys. Consensus for items was defined as ≥70% agreement in Round 1 and ≥80% agreement in Round 2. Subgroup analyses were conducted by primary practice setting. Results: In Round 1, 286 participants reviewed 74 items and identified 11 (14.8%) as priorities. After incorporating open-ended feedback, some statements were combined, resulting in 53 statements carried forward. In Round 2, 165 participants reviewed 53 items and identified an additional 11 items (20.7%) as important. These topics reflect the breadth of RT practice, including airway management, rapid response teams, personalized ventilation strategies, and system-level contributions. Workforce sustainability issues such as burnout, staffing ratios, and retention were also identified. Subgroup analyses revealed meaningful variation in research priorities across different practice areas in Round 1 and 2. Conclusion: This study presents a profession-driven research agenda for respiratory therapy in Canada. These findings can inform future research, continuing professional development, and policy advocacy aligned with the profession’s evolving roles and contexts.
- 28 May 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Respiratory Care
- Vol. 70 (10) , 1305-1322
Characteristics of Rapidly Manufactured Ventilators: A Scoping Review
Many health care systems worldwide were ill-prepared for the mass-casualty surge caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Mechanical ventilator shortages prompted the production of rapidly manufactured ventilators (RMVs). However, without standards to develop them, the effectiveness and safety of RMVs remain uncertain. The purpose of this study was to map the breadth and depth of the literature on RMVs and provide suggestions for effective and safe designs. A scoping review, following the Joanna Briggs Institute guidelines, was completed. A search of 9 electronic databases and Google Scholar was completed in April 2022 and updated in 2024. Dual screening and data extraction were conducted using predefined criteria based on 6 previously published RMV guidance documents. Results were collated into descriptive summaries and tables and used to develop the suggested standards. There were 66 RMVs described within 66 articles. The majority (60, 91%) of articles were published post-COVID-19 (2020), with 24 (36%) from the United States. Four designs were identified: 18 (27%) electro-pneumatic (E-P), 27 (41%) automatic compression of manual resuscitator (MR), 6 (9%) automatic compression of MR with E-P components (E-P and MR), and 15 (23%) “other.” The E-P designs mimicked conventional ventilators and MR designs incorporated an MR with a motor and arm. Four RMV characteristic categories emerged from the data: operating features, performance features, other features outside routine use, and engineering features. There was significant variability in the RMV designs. Eleven suggestions regarding RMV design, performance, and testing were developed. This study provides preliminary information to inform the standardization of RMV designs to guide future manufacturing for effective and safe use. Although pandemic urgency has waned, RMV utility may extend to future mass-casualty scenarios (eg, natural disasters, wars) and in low- and middle-income countries, which often lack sufficient resources even under normal conditions.
- 28 May 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Respiratory Care
- Vol. 70 (10) , 1305-1322
Characteristics of Rapidly Manufactured Ventilators: A Scoping Review
Many health care systems worldwide were ill-prepared for the mass-casualty surge caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Mechanical ventilator shortages prompted the production of rapidly manufactured ventilators (RMVs). However, without standards to develop them, the effectiveness and safety of RMVs remain uncertain. The purpose of this study was to map the breadth and depth of the literature on RMVs and provide suggestions for effective and safe designs. A scoping review, following the Joanna Briggs Institute guidelines, was completed. A search of 9 electronic databases and Google Scholar was completed in April 2022 and updated in 2024. Dual screening and data extraction were conducted using predefined criteria based on 6 previously published RMV guidance documents. Results were collated into descriptive summaries and tables and used to develop the suggested standards. There were 66 RMVs described within 66 articles. The majority (60, 91%) of articles were published post-COVID-19 (2020), with 24 (36%) from the United States. Four designs were identified: 18 (27%) electro-pneumatic (E-P), 27 (41%) automatic compression of manual resuscitator (MR), 6 (9%) automatic compression of MR with E-P components (E-P and MR), and 15 (23%) “other.” The E-P designs mimicked conventional ventilators and MR designs incorporated an MR with a motor and arm. Four RMV characteristic categories emerged from the data: operating features, performance features, other features outside routine use, and engineering features. There was significant variability in the RMV designs. Eleven suggestions regarding RMV design, performance, and testing were developed. This study provides preliminary information to inform the standardization of RMV designs to guide future manufacturing for effective and safe use. Although pandemic urgency has waned, RMV utility may extend to future mass-casualty scenarios (eg, natural disasters, wars) and in low- and middle-income countries, which often lack sufficient resources even under normal conditions.
- Open Access
- 9 January 2025
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 14 (1) , 974-990
The Use of Micro-Credentials in Health Professions Education: A Scoping Review
Background: Healthcare professionals must continuously update their competencies to keep pace with evolving clinical practices; however, traditional continuing professional development (CPD) methods often have limited impact on competency and performance. Micro-credentials have emerged as a flexible and personalized alternative to traditional CPD, yet little is known about how they are designed, implemented, and evaluated in health professions education. As educational systems invest heavily in micro-credentials, a clearer understanding of their educational value is essential. Methods: Using a scoping review guided by Arksey and O’Malley’s six-stage framework and PRISMA-ScR guidelines, we systematically searched seven databases (inception–December 2024) and conducted a structured grey literature review. We examined the instructional design features, pedagogical underpinnings, assessment strategies, and reported impacts of micro-credentials. Results: We included 19 peer-reviewed papers and 35 websites describing health-related micro-credentials. Most studies were published in 2024 (42.1%), originated from the United States (42.1%), and nearly half (47.4%) provided only descriptive accounts. A wide range of instructional design features were identified, though pedagogical theories were rarely stated. Assessment strategies predominantly emphasized summative approaches (e.g., multiple-choice knowledge checks), with limited focus on higher-level competency assessment. Reported outcomes were primarily improvements in knowledge, confidence, or engagement, with no clear evidence of the distinct value of micro-credentials as a teaching modality. Discussion: Current literature offers limited evaluation of micro-credentials and often lacks theory-informed design. We infer a pedagogical foundation aligned with constructivist, context-sensitive, and stage-based principles, which may inform the development of future micro-credential programs.
- 9 January 2025
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 14 (1) , 974-990
Open AccessThe Use of Micro-Credentials in Health Professions Education: A Scoping Review
Background: Healthcare professionals must continuously update their competencies to keep pace with evolving clinical practices; however, traditional continuing professional development (CPD) methods often have limited impact on competency and performance. Micro-credentials have emerged as a flexible and personalized alternative to traditional CPD, yet little is known about how they are designed, implemented, and evaluated in health professions education. As educational systems invest heavily in micro-credentials, a clearer understanding of their educational value is essential. Methods: Using a scoping review guided by Arksey and O’Malley’s six-stage framework and PRISMA-ScR guidelines, we systematically searched seven databases (inception–December 2024) and conducted a structured grey literature review. We examined the instructional design features, pedagogical underpinnings, assessment strategies, and reported impacts of micro-credentials. Results: We included 19 peer-reviewed papers and 35 websites describing health-related micro-credentials. Most studies were published in 2024 (42.1%), originated from the United States (42.1%), and nearly half (47.4%) provided only descriptive accounts. A wide range of instructional design features were identified, though pedagogical theories were rarely stated. Assessment strategies predominantly emphasized summative approaches (e.g., multiple-choice knowledge checks), with limited focus on higher-level competency assessment. Reported outcomes were primarily improvements in knowledge, confidence, or engagement, with no clear evidence of the distinct value of micro-credentials as a teaching modality. Discussion: Current literature offers limited evaluation of micro-credentials and often lacks theory-informed design. We infer a pedagogical foundation aligned with constructivist, context-sensitive, and stage-based principles, which may inform the development of future micro-credential programs.