Céline Villa
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Céline Villa has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Roland Brémond
CoSys Lab Université Gustave Eiffel Champs‐sur‐Marne France
7 shared publications E Saint-Jacques
Université Gustave Eiffel, CoSys Lab, Champs-sur-Marne, France
2 shared publicationsF Eymond
Université Gustave Eiffel, CoSys Lab, Champs-sur-Marne, France
2 shared publicationsFrançois Eymond
2 shared publications- Laurine Peter
CoSys/PICS-L, Université Gustave Eiffel
2 shared publications - Andrea Simone
Department of Civil, Chemical, Environmental, and Materials Engineering—DICAM, School of Engineering, University of Bologna, 40126 Bologna, Italy
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 14 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Vol. 68 (5) , 617-631
Outdoor Lighting Quality for Pedestrians at Night: The Effects of Reduced Light Levels
Objective: The aim of this field study was to explore the effects of a light reduction strategy on various qualitative and quantitative outdoor lighting quality criteria. Background: Several outdoor lighting quality criteria have been highlighted in previous work related to perception and evaluation from pedestrians. Previous studies revealed that a decrease of horizontal illuminance impacts criteria, and that individual moderators need to be considered. Method: 70 participants had to walk on different footpaths with a reduced luminous flux at night. They completed a questionnaire and tasks about perception and evaluation of outdoor lighting quality. Results: The results highlight an effect of the luminous flux and/or footpath on each criterium excepted discomfort from glare. A reduced luminous flux of 50% increases perceived visibility, visual acuity, and overall lighting quality compared to a flux at 10%. Differences in layout impact perceived visibility, perceived safety and overall lighting quality. Women have a lower perceived safety score than men, which is reflected in both quantitative and qualitative content. Elderly people have poorer visual acuity and mention brightness and darkness less often when describing the footpaths. Conclusions: Through the mixed quantitative and qualitative approach conducted, the results confirm the impact of the lighting levels reduction on outdoor lighting criteria and are closely dependent on the context and location chosen. Applications: Taking into account the individual variability in decision-making processes could help local authorities to conduct policies of light reduction to limit the impact on the environment and to adapt urban lighting to everyone.
- 14 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Vol. 68 (5) , 617-631
Outdoor Lighting Quality for Pedestrians at Night: The Effects of Reduced Light Levels
Objective: The aim of this field study was to explore the effects of a light reduction strategy on various qualitative and quantitative outdoor lighting quality criteria. Background: Several outdoor lighting quality criteria have been highlighted in previous work related to perception and evaluation from pedestrians. Previous studies revealed that a decrease of horizontal illuminance impacts criteria, and that individual moderators need to be considered. Method: 70 participants had to walk on different footpaths with a reduced luminous flux at night. They completed a questionnaire and tasks about perception and evaluation of outdoor lighting quality. Results: The results highlight an effect of the luminous flux and/or footpath on each criterium excepted discomfort from glare. A reduced luminous flux of 50% increases perceived visibility, visual acuity, and overall lighting quality compared to a flux at 10%. Differences in layout impact perceived visibility, perceived safety and overall lighting quality. Women have a lower perceived safety score than men, which is reflected in both quantitative and qualitative content. Elderly people have poorer visual acuity and mention brightness and darkness less often when describing the footpaths. Conclusions: Through the mixed quantitative and qualitative approach conducted, the results confirm the impact of the lighting levels reduction on outdoor lighting criteria and are closely dependent on the context and location chosen. Applications: Taking into account the individual variability in decision-making processes could help local authorities to conduct policies of light reduction to limit the impact on the environment and to adapt urban lighting to everyone.
- 1 November 2025
- Published by International Commission on Illumination
- p. 161-170
DISABILITY GLARE FROM PHOTOVOLTAIC PANELS IN AIRPORTS
The recent development of renewable energies leads to an increasing number of photovoltaic panels (PVPs) deployed worldwide, including around airports. However, solar ray reflections on PVPs may produce glare, both for pilots on approach and for air traffic controllers (ATCs), impairing their visibility of, respectively the runway threshold and objects along the runway. Regulation standards on PVPs around airports vary across countries but unexpectedly, the visibility of relevant targets has not been considered so far as a rationale in order to control the glare from PVPs in airports. In this paper, we compute the visibility of targets we defined for pilots and ATCs in a few reference scenarios, using Adrian’s formula and a Contrast Sensitivity Function. Then, we assess, from the CIE formula of the equivalent veiling luminance, the impairment of the visibility in presence of disability glare, as a first tentative step towards regulating PVPs around airports regarding disability glare.
- 1 November 2025
- Published by International Commission on Illumination
- p. 161-170
DISABILITY GLARE FROM PHOTOVOLTAIC PANELS IN AIRPORTS
The recent development of renewable energies leads to an increasing number of photovoltaic panels (PVPs) deployed worldwide, including around airports. However, solar ray reflections on PVPs may produce glare, both for pilots on approach and for air traffic controllers (ATCs), impairing their visibility of, respectively the runway threshold and objects along the runway. Regulation standards on PVPs around airports vary across countries but unexpectedly, the visibility of relevant targets has not been considered so far as a rationale in order to control the glare from PVPs in airports. In this paper, we compute the visibility of targets we defined for pilots and ATCs in a few reference scenarios, using Adrian’s formula and a Contrast Sensitivity Function. Then, we assess, from the CIE formula of the equivalent veiling luminance, the impairment of the visibility in presence of disability glare, as a first tentative step towards regulating PVPs around airports regarding disability glare.
- 1 November 2025
- Published by International Commission on Illumination
- p. 1174-1181
INVESTIGATING FACIAL EMOTION RECOGNITION: TWO FIELD EXPERIMENTS
The objective of this paper is to explore the use of the Facial Emotion Recognition (FER) task (inspired by a laboratory task) on field experiments to assess lighting quality for pedestrians in urban space and to investigate the relationship with reassurance after dark. The task consists in identifying a facial emotion from a given distance during a given observation time. Two field experiments were conducted with different experimental designs, protocols and panels. One experiment also involved elderly people. The results show a luminance plateau above 0.1 cd/m² on average, i.e. the rate of correct responses did not increase above a sign luminance of 0.1 cd/m². For elderly participants, the proportion of correct responses increases when the sign luminance was greater than 0.5 cd/m². The results also show that the rate of “I don’t know” responses may discriminate the darkest lighting conditions and may be related to perceived safety.
- 1 November 2025
- Published by International Commission on Illumination
- p. 1174-1181
INVESTIGATING FACIAL EMOTION RECOGNITION: TWO FIELD EXPERIMENTS
The objective of this paper is to explore the use of the Facial Emotion Recognition (FER) task (inspired by a laboratory task) on field experiments to assess lighting quality for pedestrians in urban space and to investigate the relationship with reassurance after dark. The task consists in identifying a facial emotion from a given distance during a given observation time. Two field experiments were conducted with different experimental designs, protocols and panels. One experiment also involved elderly people. The results show a luminance plateau above 0.1 cd/m² on average, i.e. the rate of correct responses did not increase above a sign luminance of 0.1 cd/m². For elderly participants, the proportion of correct responses increases when the sign luminance was greater than 0.5 cd/m². The results also show that the rate of “I don’t know” responses may discriminate the darkest lighting conditions and may be related to perceived safety.
- 4 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Lighting Research & Technology
- Vol. 58 (6-7) , 746-758
Forecasting the performance of luminescent road markings from laboratory measurements: Towards standardization
The application of luminescent road markings is becoming more and more widespread to enhance the visibility of road markings and improve visual guidance in unlit areas. However, luminescent road markings are more or less visible during the night depending on the light emission due to photoluminescence. Current standards on road marking are not suitable for such innovation, and new methodologies, considering the variable visual performance of luminescent road markings, are required towards regulations. In this context, the present paper proposes a model which predicts the cumulative time during which a luminescent road marking is brighter than a traditional one taken as reference. It uses as input the luminance decay curve in the dark of the luminescent markings obtained in standard and reproducible conditions in laboratory, its reflection properties and the nighttime illumination. The model was validated using a dataset of 18-month recordings in outdoor conditions. It performs well ( R 2 = 0.83) even if it underestimates the performance in some favourable conditions. These results are promising in view of future recommendations to ensure the suitability of luminescent road markings at a given location knowing the year-long distribution of the average horizontal illuminance during the night.
- 4 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Lighting Research & Technology
- Vol. 58 (6-7) , 746-758
Forecasting the performance of luminescent road markings from laboratory measurements: Towards standardization
The application of luminescent road markings is becoming more and more widespread to enhance the visibility of road markings and improve visual guidance in unlit areas. However, luminescent road markings are more or less visible during the night depending on the light emission due to photoluminescence. Current standards on road marking are not suitable for such innovation, and new methodologies, considering the variable visual performance of luminescent road markings, are required towards regulations. In this context, the present paper proposes a model which predicts the cumulative time during which a luminescent road marking is brighter than a traditional one taken as reference. It uses as input the luminance decay curve in the dark of the luminescent markings obtained in standard and reproducible conditions in laboratory, its reflection properties and the nighttime illumination. The model was validated using a dataset of 18-month recordings in outdoor conditions. It performs well ( R 2 = 0.83) even if it underestimates the performance in some favourable conditions. These results are promising in view of future recommendations to ensure the suitability of luminescent road markings at a given location knowing the year-long distribution of the average horizontal illuminance during the night.
- Open Access
- 19 November 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Results in Engineering
- Vol. 24
Method to predict the performance of luminescent road markings over a year
- 19 November 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Results in Engineering
- Vol. 24
Open AccessMethod to predict the performance of luminescent road markings over a year
- 13 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in LEUKOS
- Vol. 19 (4) , 368-388
Modelling the Probability of Discomfort Due to Glare at All Levels: The Case of Outdoor Lighting
To limit glare, lighting engineers need to estimate the level of discomfort produced by a lighting installation. Outdoor, most discomfort glare models predict a mean level of discomfort on a judgment scale, which corresponds to a “mean road user.” However, in real life, the inter-individual variability of the sensitivity to glare is large; predicting the mean discomfort does not describe the full pattern of responses in a population. We propose a methodology to model the Discomfort Level, computing the probabilities that an observer reports any of the levels of a discomfort scale. This methodology is demonstrated for outdoor lighting, where no probabilistic model is available. Using a dedicated psychophysical experiment, we extend the results of a previous study where a formula was proposed to compute the Glare Excitation due to a multi-source stimulus, at the Borderline between Comfort and Discomfort (BCD), with a background luminance consistent with outdoor lighting. This formula is first extended to other discomfort levels and background luminance levels, and strengthened thanks to a different experimental protocol and to the use of up to 10 glare sources simultaneously. From this experiment, a formula of the Glare Excitation is proposed in the range of outdoor lighting. Then, a probabilistic model of the Discomfort Level is proposed, allowing computing the probability of ratings at each level of an ordinal scale from the Glare Excitation computed with our formula. It is hoped that the proposed model avoids most of the modeling methodological caveats of previous discomfort glare models.
- 13 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in LEUKOS
- Vol. 19 (4) , 368-388
Modelling the Probability of Discomfort Due to Glare at All Levels: The Case of Outdoor Lighting
To limit glare, lighting engineers need to estimate the level of discomfort produced by a lighting installation. Outdoor, most discomfort glare models predict a mean level of discomfort on a judgment scale, which corresponds to a “mean road user.” However, in real life, the inter-individual variability of the sensitivity to glare is large; predicting the mean discomfort does not describe the full pattern of responses in a population. We propose a methodology to model the Discomfort Level, computing the probabilities that an observer reports any of the levels of a discomfort scale. This methodology is demonstrated for outdoor lighting, where no probabilistic model is available. Using a dedicated psychophysical experiment, we extend the results of a previous study where a formula was proposed to compute the Glare Excitation due to a multi-source stimulus, at the Borderline between Comfort and Discomfort (BCD), with a background luminance consistent with outdoor lighting. This formula is first extended to other discomfort levels and background luminance levels, and strengthened thanks to a different experimental protocol and to the use of up to 10 glare sources simultaneously. From this experiment, a formula of the Glare Excitation is proposed in the range of outdoor lighting. Then, a probabilistic model of the Discomfort Level is proposed, allowing computing the probability of ratings at each level of an ordinal scale from the Glare Excitation computed with our formula. It is hoped that the proposed model avoids most of the modeling methodological caveats of previous discomfort glare models.
- 26 August 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Lighting Research & Technology
- Vol. 55 (4-5) , 459-473
Characterization of luminescent road markings
Photoluminescent paints for road marking application have been evaluated through laboratory measurements and visibility computations. The luminance decay in the dark was measured after constant excitation during at least 6 hours. To study the effect of night-time lighting conditions, luminance was measured under a constant low illumination (simulating moon and light pollution), and a periodic lighting, simulating automotive traffic. Measurements were also carried out on luminescent road marking applied on real pavement in a full-scale mock-up. Then, possible uses and limits of photoluminescent road markings were investigated through visibility computations based on the COST 331 model. Findings suggest luminescent road markings could strengthen the visual guidance of drivers on the road with traffic by increasing the visibility distance beyond the headlamp beams during the first few hours of the night, and in unlit areas such as bicycle paths, but the performance depends on the night-time illumination level.
- 26 August 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Lighting Research & Technology
- Vol. 55 (4-5) , 459-473
Characterization of luminescent road markings
Photoluminescent paints for road marking application have been evaluated through laboratory measurements and visibility computations. The luminance decay in the dark was measured after constant excitation during at least 6 hours. To study the effect of night-time lighting conditions, luminance was measured under a constant low illumination (simulating moon and light pollution), and a periodic lighting, simulating automotive traffic. Measurements were also carried out on luminescent road marking applied on real pavement in a full-scale mock-up. Then, possible uses and limits of photoluminescent road markings were investigated through visibility computations based on the COST 331 model. Findings suggest luminescent road markings could strengthen the visual guidance of drivers on the road with traffic by increasing the visibility distance beyond the headlamp beams during the first few hours of the night, and in unlit areas such as bicycle paths, but the performance depends on the night-time illumination level.
- 1 August 2022
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Transport
- Vol. 175 (5) , 275-283
The shape of road markings for visibility computations
Road markings visibility is usually assessed by means of the visibility level (VL). Several models have been developed to calculate the visibility distance on the road (Detect/PCDetect, Carve/Tarvip, Cost 331 and CIE 73). These models all approximate the visibility of a marking by estimating the diameter of an ‘equivalent’ disc. In this process, speculative hypotheses are made to calculate this diameter, labelled the equivalent area hypothesis, the equivalent perimeter hypothesis or the equivalent width hypothesis. To compare these hypotheses, a psychophysical experiment was conducted with eight participants and 120 stimuli. It was found that the merit of each hypothesis changed with the diameter of the equivalent disc. Above 0·1°, all the hypotheses gave good results, but the equivalent area hypothesis was found to be the best. Below 0·1°, the equivalent width hypothesis was more accurate, but further investigations are still needed.
- 1 August 2022
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Transport
- Vol. 175 (5) , 275-283
The shape of road markings for visibility computations
Road markings visibility is usually assessed by means of the visibility level (VL). Several models have been developed to calculate the visibility distance on the road (Detect/PCDetect, Carve/Tarvip, Cost 331 and CIE 73). These models all approximate the visibility of a marking by estimating the diameter of an ‘equivalent’ disc. In this process, speculative hypotheses are made to calculate this diameter, labelled the equivalent area hypothesis, the equivalent perimeter hypothesis or the equivalent width hypothesis. To compare these hypotheses, a psychophysical experiment was conducted with eight participants and 120 stimuli. It was found that the merit of each hypothesis changed with the diameter of the equivalent disc. Above 0·1°, all the hypotheses gave good results, but the equivalent area hypothesis was found to be the best. Below 0·1°, the equivalent width hypothesis was more accurate, but further investigations are still needed.
- 26 August 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in LEUKOS
- Vol. 18 (4) , 459-474
Discomfort Glare from a Cyclic Source in Outdoor Lighting Conditions
Many models of discomfort glare have been proposed for outdoor lighting applications. Most of them were built from data collected in the laboratory in static situations, with motionless light sources, which main characteristics (luminance, size and position) were constant over time. However, on the road at night, drivers are moving with multiple sources around them. To fill the gap between static situations and more realistic ones, four psychophysic experiments were carried out in a laboratory to investigate the impact of the cyclic variations of several light source characteristics (its luminance, eccentricity and solid angle) on the discomfort glare. The temporal frequencies have been chosen representative of outdoor lighting conditions, up to 2.6 Hz. No impact of the dynamics of the glare source was found, except for a source with variable luminance at a low frequency ( ).- 26 August 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in LEUKOS
- Vol. 18 (4) , 459-474
Discomfort Glare from a Cyclic Source in Outdoor Lighting Conditions
Many models of discomfort glare have been proposed for outdoor lighting applications. Most of them were built from data collected in the laboratory in static situations, with motionless light sources, which main characteristics (luminance, size and position) were constant over time. However, on the road at night, drivers are moving with multiple sources around them. To fill the gap between static situations and more realistic ones, four psychophysic experiments were carried out in a laboratory to investigate the impact of the cyclic variations of several light source characteristics (its luminance, eccentricity and solid angle) on the discomfort glare. The temporal frequencies have been chosen representative of outdoor lighting conditions, up to 2.6 Hz. No impact of the dynamics of the glare source was found, except for a source with variable luminance at a low frequency ( ).