Sophie Caillon
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Sophie Caillon has a total of 81 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Antoine Doncieux
CEFE, CNRS, Université de Montpellier, EPHE, IRD, Montpellier, France
4 shared publications - Delphine Renard
CEFE, CNRS, Université de Montpellier, EPHE, IRD, Montpellier, France
4 shared publications - Doyle McKey
Centre d’Ecologie Fonctionnelle et Evolutive (CEFE), CNRS, Univ Montpellier, EPHE, IRD, Montpellier 34293, France
4 shared publications - Isabelle Boulangeat
Univ. Grenoble Alpes, INRAE, LESSEM St‐Martin‐d'Hères France
3 shared publications - Ismael Vaccaro
Institució Milà i Fontanals (IMF), Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (CSIC)
3 shared publications Kenneth Iain MacDonald
CEFE, CNRS, Université de Montpellier, EPHE, IRD, Montpellier, France
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 24 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 8 (5) , 1817-1828
Harvesting of two alpine Artemisia : Effects of an amateur practice on wild plant dynamics
Societal Impact Statement: Wild plants are consumed all over the world, and knowledge of the effects of harvesting is necessary to ensure the sustainability of this activity. Our 3‐year study of two closely related alpine Artemisia species in the Southern Alps revealed a positive impact of harvesting at the plant scale and on the short term. The response of plants to harvesting interacts with ecological conditions of the site and differs between the two species. A long‐term understanding of plant dynamics at the plant and population scales is now required to fully assess the impact of harvesting practices and propose adapted conservation measures. Summary: Characterizing the dynamics of wild harvested plants is essential to assess the sustainability of such practices. In extreme environments offered by high mountains, both ecological (e.g., vegetation cover and climate) and sociological (e.g., frequentation and harvesting practices) conditions show marked variation in space and time. Little is known however about how variation in harvesting and ecological conditions affects the dynamics of high‐mountain plants, due to practical difficulties of monitoring (e.g., low accessibility) and the need to conduct multisite studies. Here, we assess the effect of variation in social‐ecological conditions on the dynamics of two alpine Artemisia species, whose stems are harvested to flavour tea, wine or liqueur. We monitored plants of Artemisia glacialis and Artemisia umbelliformis in 39 sites of the Southern Alps during three consecutive years (2021–2023). Mortality is low in the 3 years of study. Harvesting has a positive effect on plant stem production from year to year for both species, but for A. glacialis , both the effects of harvesting and the transition from vegetative to flowering status are mediated by variation in ecological conditions. The effect of harvesting on plant dynamics at the plant scale and on the short‐term is positive. Further studies are needed to assess whether this result is repeated at the population scale and for long‐term dynamics. Variation between the two closely related species illustrates that it is not possible to conclude on the sustainability of harvesting for one species based on the dynamics of a closely related species.
- 24 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 8 (5) , 1817-1828
Open AccessHarvesting of two alpine Artemisia : Effects of an amateur practice on wild plant dynamics
Societal Impact Statement: Wild plants are consumed all over the world, and knowledge of the effects of harvesting is necessary to ensure the sustainability of this activity. Our 3‐year study of two closely related alpine Artemisia species in the Southern Alps revealed a positive impact of harvesting at the plant scale and on the short term. The response of plants to harvesting interacts with ecological conditions of the site and differs between the two species. A long‐term understanding of plant dynamics at the plant and population scales is now required to fully assess the impact of harvesting practices and propose adapted conservation measures. Summary: Characterizing the dynamics of wild harvested plants is essential to assess the sustainability of such practices. In extreme environments offered by high mountains, both ecological (e.g., vegetation cover and climate) and sociological (e.g., frequentation and harvesting practices) conditions show marked variation in space and time. Little is known however about how variation in harvesting and ecological conditions affects the dynamics of high‐mountain plants, due to practical difficulties of monitoring (e.g., low accessibility) and the need to conduct multisite studies. Here, we assess the effect of variation in social‐ecological conditions on the dynamics of two alpine Artemisia species, whose stems are harvested to flavour tea, wine or liqueur. We monitored plants of Artemisia glacialis and Artemisia umbelliformis in 39 sites of the Southern Alps during three consecutive years (2021–2023). Mortality is low in the 3 years of study. Harvesting has a positive effect on plant stem production from year to year for both species, but for A. glacialis , both the effects of harvesting and the transition from vegetative to flowering status are mediated by variation in ecological conditions. The effect of harvesting on plant dynamics at the plant scale and on the short‐term is positive. Further studies are needed to assess whether this result is repeated at the population scale and for long‐term dynamics. Variation between the two closely related species illustrates that it is not possible to conclude on the sustainability of harvesting for one species based on the dynamics of a closely related species.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 4 (12) , pgaf390
Farmers hold diverse and connected values towards crops
Considerations of yield and profit often drive decision-making in agriculture, but these are not the only values farmers ascribe to crops. Recognizing the multiple values farmers use to choose crops and their management holds potential as a leverage point for sustainable transformations. To assess the diversity of values attributed by farmers towards individual crops, mixes of crops, and agroecosystems, we conducted a literature review of 125 studies published between 2010 and 2022. We analyzed 1,716 unique reports of value ascribed by farmers to 135 crop species across 67 countries and 20 agroecosystems. Farmers' values towards crops are diverse and connect economic, agronomic, social, cultural, and ecological dimensions of agriculture. While yield and profit are the values most frequently reported by farmers, social and cultural values, such as identity and cultural preferences, are also often considered as vitally important. Although most reviewed studies examined smallholder farmers and values assigned to single crops, results indicate that values vary across farm size and market orientation and across crop types. We also show that external forces, such as markets, policies, and climate change, interact with farmers' values to influence their management of crops. Finally, this review shows that researchers in different disciplines highlight different values, and that the complexity underpinning farmers' decisions about crops can be enlightened by interdisciplinary approaches. The article thus supports and extends the recommendation of IPBES to integrate diverse values linking farmers and crops into research and policy.
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 4 (12) , pgaf390
Open AccessFarmers hold diverse and connected values towards crops
Considerations of yield and profit often drive decision-making in agriculture, but these are not the only values farmers ascribe to crops. Recognizing the multiple values farmers use to choose crops and their management holds potential as a leverage point for sustainable transformations. To assess the diversity of values attributed by farmers towards individual crops, mixes of crops, and agroecosystems, we conducted a literature review of 125 studies published between 2010 and 2022. We analyzed 1,716 unique reports of value ascribed by farmers to 135 crop species across 67 countries and 20 agroecosystems. Farmers' values towards crops are diverse and connect economic, agronomic, social, cultural, and ecological dimensions of agriculture. While yield and profit are the values most frequently reported by farmers, social and cultural values, such as identity and cultural preferences, are also often considered as vitally important. Although most reviewed studies examined smallholder farmers and values assigned to single crops, results indicate that values vary across farm size and market orientation and across crop types. We also show that external forces, such as markets, policies, and climate change, interact with farmers' values to influence their management of crops. Finally, this review shows that researchers in different disciplines highlight different values, and that the complexity underpinning farmers' decisions about crops can be enlightened by interdisciplinary approaches. The article thus supports and extends the recommendation of IPBES to integrate diverse values linking farmers and crops into research and policy.
- Open Access
- 26 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 8 (1) , 353-364
Effect of seed circulation systems on the spread and diversity of Xanthomonas phaseoli pv. manihotis infecting cassava crops of the Colombian Caribbean
Social Impact Statement: Cassava is a lifeline for millions of people across the tropics, but its productivity is at risk from a disease called Cassava Bacterial Blight (CBB). In this study, we explore how the everyday practices of farmers exchanging cassava cuttings—a long‐standing tradition—can shape how the disease spreads and evolves in the Colombian Caribbean. By combining knowledge from socio‐cultural studies, plant pathology, and genetics, we reveal an often‐overlooked reality: plant diseases can spread through human activities. Our findings shed new light on CBB epidemiology and emphasize the importance of incorporating farmers' practices and local economies into the development of effective, sustainable disease control strategies. Summary: Although our knowledge about the prevalence of CBB and the diversity of Xpm populations has deepened in recent years, the role played by the seed circulation system on pathogen dispersal is still unknown. In this paper, our objective is to determine the influence of the social network shaping seed circulation on the dispersion and diversity of the pathogen at the local scale. Cassava is particularly interesting as planting material is often scarce at the time of the planting season, and diseases may not be fully visible, making it hard to control the phytosanitary condition of the propagative material. We used interdisciplinary methods based on ethnoecology, epidemiology, ecology, social network analysis, and genetics that included semi‐structured interviews with farmers, coupled with molecular genotyping of cassava plants and Xpm . Our findings highlight two main effects of local seed circulation on Xpm spread and diversity: (1) a high diversity of the pathogen at the scale of the evaluated village, and (2) greater genetic similarities of the pathogen between farmers that exchanged cuttings, regardless of the geographic distance between the fields. This study reveals the multifactorial nature of Xpm diversity and spread within a single village. By combining genetic, agricultural, and social data, it shows the value of interdisciplinary approaches to understand plant pathogen dynamics. The findings support the design of locally adapted disease control strategies. Unlike studies focused solely on genetic data, this work emphasizes the importance of integrating sociocultural factors, particularly for seedborne pathogens and crops where seed circulation systems are a determining factor.
- 26 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 8 (1) , 353-364
Open AccessEffect of seed circulation systems on the spread and diversity of Xanthomonas phaseoli pv. manihotis infecting cassava crops of the Colombian Caribbean
Social Impact Statement: Cassava is a lifeline for millions of people across the tropics, but its productivity is at risk from a disease called Cassava Bacterial Blight (CBB). In this study, we explore how the everyday practices of farmers exchanging cassava cuttings—a long‐standing tradition—can shape how the disease spreads and evolves in the Colombian Caribbean. By combining knowledge from socio‐cultural studies, plant pathology, and genetics, we reveal an often‐overlooked reality: plant diseases can spread through human activities. Our findings shed new light on CBB epidemiology and emphasize the importance of incorporating farmers' practices and local economies into the development of effective, sustainable disease control strategies. Summary: Although our knowledge about the prevalence of CBB and the diversity of Xpm populations has deepened in recent years, the role played by the seed circulation system on pathogen dispersal is still unknown. In this paper, our objective is to determine the influence of the social network shaping seed circulation on the dispersion and diversity of the pathogen at the local scale. Cassava is particularly interesting as planting material is often scarce at the time of the planting season, and diseases may not be fully visible, making it hard to control the phytosanitary condition of the propagative material. We used interdisciplinary methods based on ethnoecology, epidemiology, ecology, social network analysis, and genetics that included semi‐structured interviews with farmers, coupled with molecular genotyping of cassava plants and Xpm . Our findings highlight two main effects of local seed circulation on Xpm spread and diversity: (1) a high diversity of the pathogen at the scale of the evaluated village, and (2) greater genetic similarities of the pathogen between farmers that exchanged cuttings, regardless of the geographic distance between the fields. This study reveals the multifactorial nature of Xpm diversity and spread within a single village. By combining genetic, agricultural, and social data, it shows the value of interdisciplinary approaches to understand plant pathogen dynamics. The findings support the design of locally adapted disease control strategies. Unlike studies focused solely on genetic data, this work emphasizes the importance of integrating sociocultural factors, particularly for seedborne pathogens and crops where seed circulation systems are a determining factor.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Natures Sciences Sociétés
- Vol. 33 (3) , 305-317
Dossier « Les professionnels de la montagne face aux transitions socio-environnementales » – Les agents d’espaces naturels face aux changements socio-environnementaux et institutionnels : le cas des génépis dans le parc national du Mercantour
Les législations mises en œuvre dans les parcs nationaux évoluent au gré de changements institutionnels et socio-environnementaux. Ces territoires, en interaction avec les acteurs qui les utilisent ou les gèrent, peuvent être considérés comme des socio-écosystèmes. Les agents des parcs nationaux jouent un rôle central dans ces systèmes, en tant que sentinelles des dynamiques écologiques et sociales du parc, tout en ayant pour mission d’appliquer des réglementations peu dynamiques et parfois décalées. La gestion d’une plante patrimoniale comme le génépi attise des visions contradictoires entre utilisateurs et gestionnaires. Nous nous intéressons ici plus spécifiquement à la manière dont les agents du parc national du Mercantour vivent les changements affectant le socio-écosystème de « cueillette des génépis », que ce soit l’évolution des populations de génépi, des pratiques de cueillette, de leur métier ou de l’institution « parc national ». Les entretiens soulignent la diversité de vécus au sein de ce territoire, reflétée par les dysfonctionnements de la réglementation de cueillette que chaque agent identifie.
- 1 July 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Natures Sciences Sociétés
- Vol. 33 (3) , 305-317
Open AccessDossier « Les professionnels de la montagne face aux transitions socio-environnementales » – Les agents d’espaces naturels face aux changements socio-environnementaux et institutionnels : le cas des génépis dans le parc national du Mercantour
Les législations mises en œuvre dans les parcs nationaux évoluent au gré de changements institutionnels et socio-environnementaux. Ces territoires, en interaction avec les acteurs qui les utilisent ou les gèrent, peuvent être considérés comme des socio-écosystèmes. Les agents des parcs nationaux jouent un rôle central dans ces systèmes, en tant que sentinelles des dynamiques écologiques et sociales du parc, tout en ayant pour mission d’appliquer des réglementations peu dynamiques et parfois décalées. La gestion d’une plante patrimoniale comme le génépi attise des visions contradictoires entre utilisateurs et gestionnaires. Nous nous intéressons ici plus spécifiquement à la manière dont les agents du parc national du Mercantour vivent les changements affectant le socio-écosystème de « cueillette des génépis », que ce soit l’évolution des populations de génépi, des pratiques de cueillette, de leur métier ou de l’institution « parc national ». Les entretiens soulignent la diversité de vécus au sein de ce territoire, reflétée par les dysfonctionnements de la réglementation de cueillette que chaque agent identifie.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 7 (5) , 922-933
Human–nature relationships through the lens of reciprocity: Insights from Indigenous and local knowledge systems
In the context of climate change, biodiversity decline and social injustice, reciprocity emerges as a way of living and being in this world that holds transformative potential. Concepts of reciprocity vary and are enacted in specific cultural practices grounded in Indigenous and local knowledge systems. This editorial synthesises first‐hand evidence of how practising reciprocity can result in positive reciprocal contributions between people and nature. It also offers a theoretical justification of why considering reciprocity can lead to more equitable, inclusive and effective conservation and sustainability policy and practices, contributing to curving the colonial baggage of academic inquiry and development action. Nurturing reciprocal relations between people, especially between academics and Indigenous Peoples and local communities, is a necessary first step to identifying pathways whereby living in harmony with nature can be achieved.
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 7 (5) , 922-933
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessHuman–nature relationships through the lens of reciprocity: Insights from Indigenous and local knowledge systems
In the context of climate change, biodiversity decline and social injustice, reciprocity emerges as a way of living and being in this world that holds transformative potential. Concepts of reciprocity vary and are enacted in specific cultural practices grounded in Indigenous and local knowledge systems. This editorial synthesises first‐hand evidence of how practising reciprocity can result in positive reciprocal contributions between people and nature. It also offers a theoretical justification of why considering reciprocity can lead to more equitable, inclusive and effective conservation and sustainability policy and practices, contributing to curving the colonial baggage of academic inquiry and development action. Nurturing reciprocal relations between people, especially between academics and Indigenous Peoples and local communities, is a necessary first step to identifying pathways whereby living in harmony with nature can be achieved.
- Open Access
- 8 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Agriculture and Human Values
- Vol. 42 (3) , 1247
Correction to: Unpacking farmers’ multiple values in grapevine variety choice
- 8 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Agriculture and Human Values
- Vol. 42 (3) , 1247
Open AccessCorrection to: Unpacking farmers’ multiple values in grapevine variety choice
- Open Access
- 19 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Agriculture and Human Values
- Vol. 42 (3) , 1225-1245
Unpacking farmers’ multiple values in grapevine variety choice
Understanding farmers’ values that underpin crop choices is pivotal for designing effective and adequate sustainable agricultural policies. While significant attention has been given to the agronomic, economic and socio-cultural values of smallholder farmers in the Global South, the plural values held by commercial farmers in the Global North—specifically ascribed to perennial crops—remain underexplored. Here, we adopt an emic perspective to investigate farmers’ values involved in past and anticipated choices of grapevine varieties in the Gaillac region (southwestern France). We conducted 35 interviews with farmers, and recorded 962 expressions of values for 50 cultivated grapevine varieties. Using a mixed deductive-inductive approach, we classified these values, and identified groups of farmers and varieties based on shared values using a network analysis. Farmers’ expressions of values were grouped into five domains: wine-growing (21.9%, e.g., yield), wine-making (21.8%, e.g., organoleptic properties), economics (20.7%, e.g., specific market), sense-based (23.7%, e.g., attachment to place), and external factors (11.9%, e.g., varietal regulations). Results suggest that the diversity and variation of values held by different groups of farmers and groups of varieties are key to supporting the high level of crop diversity observed at both farm and vineyard scales. Specifically, the feelings of attachment and sense of belonging to the Gaillac region are effective triggers in the maintenance of local grapevine varieties. Our research emphasizes the diverse place-based values attributed to crops, and highlights the importance of integrating sense-based values in developing biodiversity-based policies.
- 19 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Agriculture and Human Values
- Vol. 42 (3) , 1225-1245
Open AccessUnpacking farmers’ multiple values in grapevine variety choice
Understanding farmers’ values that underpin crop choices is pivotal for designing effective and adequate sustainable agricultural policies. While significant attention has been given to the agronomic, economic and socio-cultural values of smallholder farmers in the Global South, the plural values held by commercial farmers in the Global North—specifically ascribed to perennial crops—remain underexplored. Here, we adopt an emic perspective to investigate farmers’ values involved in past and anticipated choices of grapevine varieties in the Gaillac region (southwestern France). We conducted 35 interviews with farmers, and recorded 962 expressions of values for 50 cultivated grapevine varieties. Using a mixed deductive-inductive approach, we classified these values, and identified groups of farmers and varieties based on shared values using a network analysis. Farmers’ expressions of values were grouped into five domains: wine-growing (21.9%, e.g., yield), wine-making (21.8%, e.g., organoleptic properties), economics (20.7%, e.g., specific market), sense-based (23.7%, e.g., attachment to place), and external factors (11.9%, e.g., varietal regulations). Results suggest that the diversity and variation of values held by different groups of farmers and groups of varieties are key to supporting the high level of crop diversity observed at both farm and vineyard scales. Specifically, the feelings of attachment and sense of belonging to the Gaillac region are effective triggers in the maintenance of local grapevine varieties. Our research emphasizes the diverse place-based values attributed to crops, and highlights the importance of integrating sense-based values in developing biodiversity-based policies.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Ethnobiology
- Vol. 45 (2) , 155-163
Invisible Landscapes, Invisible People: Juniper Picking at the End of the Line
This article documents the activities of two of the last juniper berry pickers of the Catalan Pyrenees. We describe how their work has been affected by rural depopulation, hyperregulation, and climate change. Junipers mostly grow in open pastures that are being colonized by bushes and trees. Their berries are sold to one of the main Catalan gin-making companies. Juniper berry pickers, thus, conduct their work in transitional areas: pastures in the process of becoming forests. Working in areas perceived as “lost,” in transition, or worthless scrubland by most rural and urban populations has affected how the pickers are perceived. Indeed, these forms of foraging go largely unseen by most users of the mountains and, despite the fact that they gather these cones for large commercial companies, they seem to operate at the margins of mainstream perceptibility.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Ethnobiology
- Vol. 45 (2) , 155-163
Open AccessInvisible Landscapes, Invisible People: Juniper Picking at the End of the Line
This article documents the activities of two of the last juniper berry pickers of the Catalan Pyrenees. We describe how their work has been affected by rural depopulation, hyperregulation, and climate change. Junipers mostly grow in open pastures that are being colonized by bushes and trees. Their berries are sold to one of the main Catalan gin-making companies. Juniper berry pickers, thus, conduct their work in transitional areas: pastures in the process of becoming forests. Working in areas perceived as “lost,” in transition, or worthless scrubland by most rural and urban populations has affected how the pickers are perceived. Indeed, these forms of foraging go largely unseen by most users of the mountains and, despite the fact that they gather these cones for large commercial companies, they seem to operate at the margins of mainstream perceptibility.
- Open Access
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Trends in Ecology & Evolution
- Vol. 40 (4) , 315-319
Stewardship underpins sustainable foraging
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Trends in Ecology & Evolution
- Vol. 40 (4) , 315-319
Open AccessStewardship underpins sustainable foraging
- Open Access
- 5 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 7 (5) , 1073-1085
Navigating human–plant reciprocity: Commercial harvesting by professionals of a medicinal plant fosters multi‐actor landscape management
Studies of human–nature relationships increasingly recognise not only nature's contributions to people but also the positive contributions of human practices to ecosystems. The concept of reciprocal contributions emphasises positive human–nature relationships. But trade‐offs between natural elements implies that human favouring of one element (e.g. via the protection of its habitat) can be detrimental to others. Discussing the concept of reciprocal contributions encourages us to rethink human management of landscape by shifting from a primary focus on instrumental values associated with plant extraction, to relational values related to the multiple interests of human and non‐human actors. To study how relational values are integrated into the configuration of multifunctional landscapes, we focused on professional harvesters of Arnica montana. We asked what role professional harvesters play in the stewardship of their harvesting sites through reciprocal relations with plants, landscapes and other actors to shape the future of plant and landscape sustainability. We show that even though professional harvesters live far from their harvesting sites, they develop both a strong attachment to them, and an experience‐based ecological knowledge of the relationships between arnica and other plant species and the environment. This attachment and experience‐based knowledge provide harvesters with legitimacy in the eyes of other actors (e.g. cattle farmers, managers of natural areas, pharmaceutical and cosmetic laboratories) and allow them to play the role of mediator between these other actors and the harvested plant in order to influence the management of the environment—for example by burning, mowing or grazing. This creates a reciprocal benefit with this particular species, but also with other co‐occurring species. Integrating the interests of the harvesters with those of other stakeholders requires negotiation and the search for synergies between values. Synthesis and applications. Within the framework of ‘reciprocal contributions’, we argue that human engagement in reciprocal relations with specific species is read as a form of care that privileges the maintenance of certain lives over others; trade‐offs between plants but also between plants, animals, landscape and humans have to be incorporated in the theoretical framework. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- 5 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
- Vol. 7 (5) , 1073-1085
Open AccessNavigating human–plant reciprocity: Commercial harvesting by professionals of a medicinal plant fosters multi‐actor landscape management
Studies of human–nature relationships increasingly recognise not only nature's contributions to people but also the positive contributions of human practices to ecosystems. The concept of reciprocal contributions emphasises positive human–nature relationships. But trade‐offs between natural elements implies that human favouring of one element (e.g. via the protection of its habitat) can be detrimental to others. Discussing the concept of reciprocal contributions encourages us to rethink human management of landscape by shifting from a primary focus on instrumental values associated with plant extraction, to relational values related to the multiple interests of human and non‐human actors. To study how relational values are integrated into the configuration of multifunctional landscapes, we focused on professional harvesters of Arnica montana. We asked what role professional harvesters play in the stewardship of their harvesting sites through reciprocal relations with plants, landscapes and other actors to shape the future of plant and landscape sustainability. We show that even though professional harvesters live far from their harvesting sites, they develop both a strong attachment to them, and an experience‐based ecological knowledge of the relationships between arnica and other plant species and the environment. This attachment and experience‐based knowledge provide harvesters with legitimacy in the eyes of other actors (e.g. cattle farmers, managers of natural areas, pharmaceutical and cosmetic laboratories) and allow them to play the role of mediator between these other actors and the harvested plant in order to influence the management of the environment—for example by burning, mowing or grazing. This creates a reciprocal benefit with this particular species, but also with other co‐occurring species. Integrating the interests of the harvesters with those of other stakeholders requires negotiation and the search for synergies between values. Synthesis and applications. Within the framework of ‘reciprocal contributions’, we argue that human engagement in reciprocal relations with specific species is read as a form of care that privileges the maintenance of certain lives over others; trade‐offs between plants but also between plants, animals, landscape and humans have to be incorporated in the theoretical framework. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.