KMKyle McLean

Kyle McLean

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Kyle McLean has a total of 49 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Large Language Model Technologies in Policing

    by Alexis R. Fabila, Ian T. Adams, Kyle McLean

    Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly framed as the next technological “revolution” in policing, promising faster report writing, automated transcription, and improved accountability. This chapter evaluates that claim by focusing on large language models (LLMs) and related language-processing tools used for police documentation and body-worn camera (BWC) review. Across randomized trials, agency pilots, and evidence from adjacent professional domains, findings converge on a consistent pattern: AI-assisted report writing rarely produces measurable time savings. Instead, LLMs shift work from drafting to verification and correction, offsetting speed gained during initial text generation. This dynamic helps explain a central adoption puzzle: why departments continue to adopt tools that do not reduce workload. AI's influence is better understood across two dimensions of value: efficiency (time and workload) and behaviour and professionalism (how officers communicate and how work is documented and reviewed). While efficiency gains are scarce, emerging evidence suggests AI can improve behaviour and professionalism when embedded in supervisory routines, including transcript-based feedback systems that shape officer communication and reduce substandard professionalism. AI drafting tools may also improve documentation clarity and accessibility for officers who struggle with writing. Rather than transforming policing through administrative acceleration, AI appears more likely to reshape documentation practices, supervisory review, and feedback structures. Four structural constraints shape implementation: workflow disruption, legal and evidentiary complications, uneven digital literacy, and underdeveloped governance. Whether AI produces meaningful value depends on how agencies address these conditions through transparency, institutional readiness, and rigorous evaluation.

  • Bad is bad, good is not bad, and great is good: validating AI classifications of police professionalism

    by Ian T. Adams, Kyle McLean, Paige Vaughn, Alexis Fabila, Geoffrey P. Alpert

    1. Artificial intelligence (AI) tools that analyze body-worn camera (BWC) footage are reshaping how police agencies monitor officer conduct (Brayne, 2017; Kellogg et al., 2020; Padilla & Adams, 202...


  • Open Access

    Assessing “Reasonable” Police Uses of Force After Barnes v. Felix : How Time Framing Affects Public Perceptions

    by Scott M. Mourtgos, Ian T. Adams, Kyle McLean, Seth Stoughton, Geoffrey P. Alpert

    Recent Supreme Court doctrine rejects a narrow “moment of threat” lens in favor of evaluating police use-of-force under the totality of the circumstances. Whether expanding the temporal frame changes how reasonableness and culpability are assigned remains unclear. We test this question using a nationally stratified experiment fielded the day Barnes v. Felix was decided (N = 2,401). Participants were randomly assigned to view one of three temporally distinct dashcam clips from the Barnes incident: a four-second final frame, a thirteen-second partial-context clip, or an approximately two-minute totality-of-circumstances clip. Respondents then evaluated officer reasonableness, responsibility, criminal liability, and internal discipline. Expansion beyond the final frame reduced perceived reasonableness and increased punitiveness. However, effects were non-linear: limited additional context produced the strongest condemnation, while full context tempered reactions. Temporal framing shapes public evaluations of police use-of-force, with the direction and magnitude of effects dependent on what the selected temporal frame reveals.


  • Open Access

    Artificial intelligence in police research: a preliminary examination of feasibility and replication

    by Kyle McLean, Jeffrey Rojek, Justin Nix

    Objectives: This manuscript tests whether artificial intelligence (AI) review of body-worn camera footage replicates the findings of a randomized-controlled trial of police de-escalation training using systematic social observation (SSO). Methods: Body-worn camera video that was previously analyzed using SSO was subjected to review by an AI program. The study then replicates the analysis of the randomized-controlled trial using outcomes generated by AI. The results are compared to those of the original study. Results: All five measures produced by the AI correlated with at least one SSO measure, though several SSO measures appeared completely unrelated to any measure produced by AI. The analysis of treatment effects by AI reaches the same conclusion as the original study. Conclusions: SSO provides greater nuance to understanding police interactions but is weakened by its time-consuming and expensive nature. AI provides a promising avenue for conducting similar analyses more quickly and efficiently.


  • Open Access

    A Good College Essay but a Bad Police Report: A Triple-Blind Expert Evaluation of AI-Assisted Police Reporting

    by Ian T. Adams, Matt Barter, Kyle McLean, Jr. Irick A. Geary, Alexis Fabila, Josh McCrain

  • Open Access

    Bad Is Bad, Good Is Not Bad, and Great Is Good: Validating AI Classifications of Police Professionalism

    by Ian T. Adams, Kyle McLean, Paige Vaughn, Alexis Fabila, Geoffrey Alpert

    Artificial intelligence (AI) tools that analyze body-worn camera footage are increasingly used to monitor and improve police behavior, yet the behavioral measures these systems generate have not been validated against human perception. We conduct the first human-perception validation of an AI-based police professionalism measure using a nationally representative sample of 3,020 U.S. adults recruited through Prolific. Respondents watched body-worn camera videos pre-classified by Truleo’s natural language processing system as Below Standard, Standard, or High professionalism and rated officer professionalism and respectful communication. Cross-classified multilevel models reveal that respondents rate Below Standard encounters 0.87 points lower than Standard encounters on a three-point professionalism scale (p < .001), a shift of approximately 44% of the scale range. However, respondents cannot distinguish between Standard and High professionalism as classified by the algorithm. This asymmetry reflects a negativity bias: obviously unprofessional conduct (hostility, directed profanity, disrespect) is immediately recognizable, while the positive behavioral markers that separate adequate from exemplary professionalism are not apparent to untrained observers in brief video clips. The pattern holds across both outcome measures, is robust to ordinal regression, persists after controlling for video duration, and is not meaningfully moderated by respondent demographics or attitudes. These results provide partial validation: agencies deploying AI-based body-worn camera review can treat Below Standard flags as reliable and actionable, while recognizing that the upper-tier distinction between adequate and exemplary performance requires human judgment.


  • An Implementation Science Approach to Assess Law Enforcement Deflection Programs

    by Stanley N. Ratemo, Emily Suiter, Kyle McLean, Naomi Shneibaum, Bryan Lee Miller


  • Open Access

    Somebody’s going to emergency, somebody’s going to jail: pre-booking diversion and officer discretion

    by Kyle McLean, Emily Suiter, Naomi Shneibaum, Bryan Lee Miller

    The opioid use epidemic has resulted in dramatic increases in drug overdoses and deaths. Traditional criminal justice approaches to drug use focus on makin

  • Open Access

    Large Language Model Technologies in Policing: Early Lessons in Artificial Intelligence from Research and Practice

    by Alexis R. Fabila, Kyle McLean, Ian T. Adams

    Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly framed as the next technological “revolution” in policing, promising faster report writing, automated transcription, and improved accountability. This chapter evaluates that claim by focusing on large language models (LLMs) and related language-processing tools used for police documentation and body-worn camera (BWC) review. Across randomized trials, agency pilots, and evidence from adjacent professional domains, findings converge on a consistent pattern: AI-assisted report writing rarely produces measurable time savings. Instead, LLMs shift work from drafting to verification and correction, offsetting speed gained during initial text generation. This dynamic helps explain a central adoption puzzle: why departments continue to adopt tools that do not reduce workload. AI’s influence is better understood across two dimensions of value: efficiency (time and workload) and behavior and professionalism (how officers communicate and how work is documented and reviewed). While efficiency gains are scarce, emerging evidence suggests AI can improve behavior and professionalism when embedded in supervisory routines, including transcript-based feedback systems that shape officer communication and reduce substandard professionalism. AI drafting tools may also improve documentation clarity and accessibility for officers who struggle with writing. Rather than transforming policing through administrative acceleration, AI appears more likely to reshape documentation practices, supervisory review, and feedback structures. Four structural constraints shape implementation: workflow disruption, legal and evidentiary complications, uneven digital literacy, and underdeveloped governance. Whether AI produces meaningful value depends on how agencies address these conditions through transparency, institutional readiness, and rigorous evaluation.