Didier Lazaro
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Didier Lazaro has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Angelica Sicard
DPHY ONERA Université de Toulouse Toulouse France
16 shared publications S. Bourdarie
ONERA, The French Aerospace Lab Toulouse France
10 shared publicationsD. Boscher
ONERA, The French Aerospace Lab, Toulouse, France
9 shared publicationsG. Rolland
CNES, Toulouse, France
8 shared publicationsR. Ecoffet
CNES, French Space Agency, Toulouse, France
8 shared publications- Vincent Maget
ONERA/DPHY, Université de Toulouse, Toulouse, F31055, France
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 10 March 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science
- Vol. 69 (7) , 1527-1532
In-Flight Measurements of Radiation Environment Observed by Eutelsat 7C (Electric Orbit Raising Satellite)
Measurements of particle fluxes (protons and electrons) obtained with the Influence sur les Composants Avancées des Radiations de l’Espace for New Generation (ICARE_NG) monitor on the Eutelsat 7C orbit [Electric Orbit Raising to Geostationary Orbit (GEO)] are presented. Several comparisons are proposed with other instruments [magnetic electron ion spectrometer (MagEIS), relativistic proton spectrometer (RPS), and magnetospheric particle sensors high (MPSH)] and radiation models (AEP8, International Radiation Environment Near Earth (IRENE), and Global Radiation Earth ENvironment (GREEN)). Significant discrepancies have been found, especially with AEP8 model. The measurements when the satellite is in its operational orbit (GEO) have also been compared with the International Geostationary Electron (IGE) model and an excellent agreement is observed. For calculating fluxes from ICARE_NG outputs, two methods have been developed and their results are compared to consolidate our interpretations.
- 10 March 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science
- Vol. 69 (7) , 1527-1532
In-Flight Measurements of Radiation Environment Observed by Eutelsat 7C (Electric Orbit Raising Satellite)
Measurements of particle fluxes (protons and electrons) obtained with the Influence sur les Composants Avancées des Radiations de l’Espace for New Generation (ICARE_NG) monitor on the Eutelsat 7C orbit [Electric Orbit Raising to Geostationary Orbit (GEO)] are presented. Several comparisons are proposed with other instruments [magnetic electron ion spectrometer (MagEIS), relativistic proton spectrometer (RPS), and magnetospheric particle sensors high (MPSH)] and radiation models (AEP8, International Radiation Environment Near Earth (IRENE), and Global Radiation Earth ENvironment (GREEN)). Significant discrepancies have been found, especially with AEP8 model. The measurements when the satellite is in its operational orbit (GEO) have also been compared with the International Geostationary Electron (IGE) model and an excellent agreement is observed. For calculating fluxes from ICARE_NG outputs, two methods have been developed and their results are compared to consolidate our interpretations.
- Open Access
- 8 March 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science
- Vol. 69 (7) , 1533-1540
GREEN Upper Envelope Model for Energetic Electrons
The Global Radiation Earth Environment (GREEN) model is a mean model, dependent on the solar cycle, that provides proton and electron flux in the radiation belts. However, it is well known that the intensity of solar cycles is variable and the effects on proton and electron fluxes may vary from cycle to cycle. The aim of this study is, therefore, to develop a GREEN “Upper Envelope” model, which considers the variation from one solar cycle to another and gives the maximum flux for each year of the solar cycle. In this study, the “Upper Envelope” is presented for electrons only.
- 8 March 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science
- Vol. 69 (7) , 1533-1540
Open AccessGREEN Upper Envelope Model for Energetic Electrons
The Global Radiation Earth Environment (GREEN) model is a mean model, dependent on the solar cycle, that provides proton and electron flux in the radiation belts. However, it is well known that the intensity of solar cycles is variable and the effects on proton and electron fluxes may vary from cycle to cycle. The aim of this study is, therefore, to develop a GREEN “Upper Envelope” model, which considers the variation from one solar cycle to another and gives the maximum flux for each year of the solar cycle. In this study, the “Upper Envelope” is presented for electrons only.
- 21 February 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science
- Vol. 69 (7) , 1565-1573
Infer Electron Space Environment Along EOR Mission Profile From LEO Measurements: Application to EUTELSAT 7C
The Earth’s electron radiation environment is extremely dynamic. It reacts strongly to magnetic storms, increasing in some hours by several orders of magnitude in a large energy range and decreasing slowly in the recovery phase of the storm. For the purpose of spacecraft Electrical Orbit Raising (EOR), to bring the ion thruster propulsion-based satellites from the launcher injection orbit to the geostationary orbit, it is important to estimate the electron fluxes they can encounter during this long transfer phase. Using correlation between high-energy electron measurements at LEO and near equator, a methodology is presented and validated to infer the daily average flux encountered by the EUTELSAT 7C spacecraft during its EOR phase.
- 21 February 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science
- Vol. 69 (7) , 1565-1573
Infer Electron Space Environment Along EOR Mission Profile From LEO Measurements: Application to EUTELSAT 7C
The Earth’s electron radiation environment is extremely dynamic. It reacts strongly to magnetic storms, increasing in some hours by several orders of magnitude in a large energy range and decreasing slowly in the recovery phase of the storm. For the purpose of spacecraft Electrical Orbit Raising (EOR), to bring the ion thruster propulsion-based satellites from the launcher injection orbit to the geostationary orbit, it is important to estimate the electron fluxes they can encounter during this long transfer phase. Using correlation between high-energy electron measurements at LEO and near equator, a methodology is presented and validated to infer the daily average flux encountered by the EUTELSAT 7C spacecraft during its EOR phase.
- Open Access
- 23 November 2021
- Published by EDP Sciences in Journal of Space Weather and Space Climate
- Vol. 11, 55
OMEP-EOR: A MeV proton flux specification model for electric orbit raising missions
Electric Orbit Raising (EOR) for telecommunication satellites significantly reduced on-board fuel mass at the price of extended transfer durations. These relatively long transfers, which usually span a few months, cross large spans of the radiation belts, resulting in significant exposure of the spacecraft to space radiations. Since they are not very populated, the radiation environment of intermediate regions of the radiation belts is less constrained than on popular orbits such as low Earth orbit or geostationary orbit in standard environment models. In particular, there is a need for more specific models for the MeV energy range proton fluxes, responsible for solar arrays degradations, and hence critical for EOR missions. ONERA has developed a specification model of proton fluxes dedicated for EOR missions as part of the ESA ARTES program. This model can estimate the average proton fluxes between 60 keV and 20 MeV on arbitrary trajectories on the typical duration of EOR transfers. A global statistical model of the radiation belts was extracted from the Van Allen Probes RBSPICE data. For regions with no or low sampling, simulation results from the Salammbô radiation belt model were used. Special care was taken to model the temporal dynamics of the belts on the considered mission durations. A Gaussian Process model was developed, allowing to compute the distribution of the average fluxes on arbitrary mission durations analytically. Satellites trajectories can be flown in the resulting global distribution, yielding the proton flux spectrum distribution as seen by the spacecraft. We show the results of the model on a typical EOR trajectory. The obtained fluxes are compared to the standard AP8 model, the AP9 model and validated using the THEMIS satellites data. We illustrate the expected effect on solar cell degradation, where our model shows an increase of up to 20% degradation prediction compared to AP8.
- 23 November 2021
- Published by EDP Sciences in Journal of Space Weather and Space Climate
- Vol. 11, 55
Open AccessOMEP-EOR: A MeV proton flux specification model for electric orbit raising missions
Electric Orbit Raising (EOR) for telecommunication satellites significantly reduced on-board fuel mass at the price of extended transfer durations. These relatively long transfers, which usually span a few months, cross large spans of the radiation belts, resulting in significant exposure of the spacecraft to space radiations. Since they are not very populated, the radiation environment of intermediate regions of the radiation belts is less constrained than on popular orbits such as low Earth orbit or geostationary orbit in standard environment models. In particular, there is a need for more specific models for the MeV energy range proton fluxes, responsible for solar arrays degradations, and hence critical for EOR missions. ONERA has developed a specification model of proton fluxes dedicated for EOR missions as part of the ESA ARTES program. This model can estimate the average proton fluxes between 60 keV and 20 MeV on arbitrary trajectories on the typical duration of EOR transfers. A global statistical model of the radiation belts was extracted from the Van Allen Probes RBSPICE data. For regions with no or low sampling, simulation results from the Salammbô radiation belt model were used. Special care was taken to model the temporal dynamics of the belts on the considered mission durations. A Gaussian Process model was developed, allowing to compute the distribution of the average fluxes on arbitrary mission durations analytically. Satellites trajectories can be flown in the resulting global distribution, yielding the proton flux spectrum distribution as seen by the spacecraft. We show the results of the model on a typical EOR trajectory. The obtained fluxes are compared to the standard AP8 model, the AP9 model and validated using the THEMIS satellites data. We illustrate the expected effect on solar cell degradation, where our model shows an increase of up to 20% degradation prediction compared to AP8.
- 26 June 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science
- Vol. 47 (8) , 3776-3782
Internal Charging Issues Met During Electric Orbit Raising and in GPS-Like MEO Environment
This paper was dedicated to the experimental characterization and numerical assessment of the possible risk of charging during the electric orbit raising (EOR). Different elements [printed circuit board (PCB), ethylene tetrafluoroethylene wires (ETFE)] considered at risk in representative electron environment have been tested to assess their charging behavior and any risks of electrostatic discharges in this environment. This task has been performed in the GEODUR irradiation test facility installed at Office National d'Etudes et de Recherches Aérospatiales (Toulouse, France) and equipped with a 2.5-MeV electron accelerator. The samples have been irradiated with an electron spectrum representative of the maximum spectrum (in regard of electron flux) met during the EOR behind 1-mm shielding. This experimental study revealed high charging kinetics on the different elements over successive cycles that led to the initiation of several electrostatic discharges on PCB, located on metallic floating parts. This paper demonstrated the risk of high charging and electrostatic discharge (ESD) risks during EOR on sensitive components. These discharges could affect the electronics operation and damage the insulators. The final step of this paper was to perform numerical simulation for internal charging assessment in global positioning system (GPS)-type orbit on different space used materials with a dedicated tool that takes into account the temporal evolution of high energy electron fluxes. Then we demonstrated a strong evolution of internal charging with the radiation environment, which has been ascribed to the influence of radiation-induced conductivity (RIC). Strong discrepancies from one material to the other have been observed later on the temporal evolution of the surface potential.
- 26 June 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science
- Vol. 47 (8) , 3776-3782
Internal Charging Issues Met During Electric Orbit Raising and in GPS-Like MEO Environment
This paper was dedicated to the experimental characterization and numerical assessment of the possible risk of charging during the electric orbit raising (EOR). Different elements [printed circuit board (PCB), ethylene tetrafluoroethylene wires (ETFE)] considered at risk in representative electron environment have been tested to assess their charging behavior and any risks of electrostatic discharges in this environment. This task has been performed in the GEODUR irradiation test facility installed at Office National d'Etudes et de Recherches Aérospatiales (Toulouse, France) and equipped with a 2.5-MeV electron accelerator. The samples have been irradiated with an electron spectrum representative of the maximum spectrum (in regard of electron flux) met during the EOR behind 1-mm shielding. This experimental study revealed high charging kinetics on the different elements over successive cycles that led to the initiation of several electrostatic discharges on PCB, located on metallic floating parts. This paper demonstrated the risk of high charging and electrostatic discharge (ESD) risks during EOR on sensitive components. These discharges could affect the electronics operation and damage the insulators. The final step of this paper was to perform numerical simulation for internal charging assessment in global positioning system (GPS)-type orbit on different space used materials with a dedicated tool that takes into account the temporal evolution of high energy electron fluxes. Then we demonstrated a strong evolution of internal charging with the radiation environment, which has been ascribed to the influence of radiation-induced conductivity (RIC). Strong discrepancies from one material to the other have been observed later on the temporal evolution of the surface potential.
- 14 June 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science
- Vol. 66 (7) , 1738-1745
New Model for the Plasma Electrons Fluxes (Part of GREEN Model)
A new specification model of low energy electrons fluxes, included in GREEN model, has been developed at ONERA. This model is based on several data sets, from low altitudes with NOAA-POES measurements to higher altitudes with POLAR, THEMIS and LANL measurements. It provides mean electron fluxes versus L, B/Beq, MLT and energy (for energies between 0.19 keV and few 10s of keV). In this paper, the model is compared to AE9/SPM model and Van Allen Probe measurements.
- 14 June 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science
- Vol. 66 (7) , 1738-1745
New Model for the Plasma Electrons Fluxes (Part of GREEN Model)
A new specification model of low energy electrons fluxes, included in GREEN model, has been developed at ONERA. This model is based on several data sets, from low altitudes with NOAA-POES measurements to higher altitudes with POLAR, THEMIS and LANL measurements. It provides mean electron fluxes versus L, B/Beq, MLT and energy (for energies between 0.19 keV and few 10s of keV). In this paper, the model is compared to AE9/SPM model and Van Allen Probe measurements.
- Open Access
- 4 July 2018
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Annales Geophysicae
- Vol. 36 (4) , 953-967
GREEN: the new Global Radiation Earth ENvironment model (beta version)
GREEN (Global Radiation Earth ENvironment) is a new model (in beta version) providing fluxes at any location between L∗= 1 and L∗= 8, all along the magnetic field lines, for all local times and for any energy between 1 keV and 10 MeV for electrons and between 1 keV and 800 MeV for protons. This model is composed of global models (AE8 and AP8, and SPM for low energies) and local models (SLOT model, OZONE and IGE-2006 for electrons, and OPAL and IGP for protons). GREEN is not just a collection of various models; it calculates the electron and proton fluxes from the most relevant existing model for a given energy and location. Moreover, some existing models can be updated or corrected in GREEN. For examples, a new version of the SLOT model is presented here and has been integrated in GREEN. Moreover, a new model of proton flux in geostationary orbit (IGP) developed a few years ago is also detailed here and integrated in GREEN. Finally a correction of the AE8 model at high energy for L ∗ < 2.5 has also been implemented. The inputs of the GREEN model are the coordinates of the points and the date (year, month, day, UTC) along an orbit, the particle species (electron or proton) and the energies. Then GREEN provides fluxes all along the given orbit, depending on the solar cycle and other magnetic parameters such as L ∗ , B mirror and B eq .
- 4 July 2018
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Annales Geophysicae
- Vol. 36 (4) , 953-967
Open AccessGREEN: the new Global Radiation Earth ENvironment model (beta version)
GREEN (Global Radiation Earth ENvironment) is a new model (in beta version) providing fluxes at any location between L∗= 1 and L∗= 8, all along the magnetic field lines, for all local times and for any energy between 1 keV and 10 MeV for electrons and between 1 keV and 800 MeV for protons. This model is composed of global models (AE8 and AP8, and SPM for low energies) and local models (SLOT model, OZONE and IGE-2006 for electrons, and OPAL and IGP for protons). GREEN is not just a collection of various models; it calculates the electron and proton fluxes from the most relevant existing model for a given energy and location. Moreover, some existing models can be updated or corrected in GREEN. For examples, a new version of the SLOT model is presented here and has been integrated in GREEN. Moreover, a new model of proton flux in geostationary orbit (IGP) developed a few years ago is also detailed here and integrated in GREEN. Finally a correction of the AE8 model at high energy for L ∗ < 2.5 has also been implemented. The inputs of the GREEN model are the coordinates of the points and the date (year, month, day, UTC) along an orbit, the particle species (electron or proton) and the energies. Then GREEN provides fluxes all along the given orbit, depending on the solar cycle and other magnetic parameters such as L ∗ , B mirror and B eq .
- 1 September 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1-6
Is Carrington event in 1859 really worse than other recent extreme events?
The goal of this study is to try to answer the question: is Carrington event the worst event of all time? First, a state of the art on the 1859 Carrington event will be conducted, including recalling the sequence of events and the various data available. Then the second part will be devoted to the study of magnetic activity during the Carrington event in comparison with other more recent events. A KEquivalent index was calculated from magnetic data measured by the ground stations during the 1859 events and during other remarkable events in the space age. Moreover a correlation between this KEquivalent index and the tri-hour index Kp have been done. The result of this study seems to show that Carrington event was really an extreme event but some more recent events are roughly comparable.
- 1 September 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1-6
Is Carrington event in 1859 really worse than other recent extreme events?
The goal of this study is to try to answer the question: is Carrington event the worst event of all time? First, a state of the art on the 1859 Carrington event will be conducted, including recalling the sequence of events and the various data available. Then the second part will be devoted to the study of magnetic activity during the Carrington event in comparison with other more recent events. A KEquivalent index was calculated from magnetic data measured by the ground stations during the 1859 events and during other remarkable events in the space age. Moreover a correlation between this KEquivalent index and the tri-hour index Kp have been done. The result of this study seems to show that Carrington event was really an extreme event but some more recent events are roughly comparable.
- 1 March 2016
- Published by American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) in Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets
- Vol. 53 (2) , 304-316
Severe Geostationary Environments: Numerical Estimation of Spacecraft Surface Charging from Flight Data
This paper defines a series of severe plasma environments in terms of spacecraft surface charging in geostationary orbit. In-flight plasma measurements are used to extract environments associated with large absolute spacecraft potentials and fluxes. An exhaustive list of events is selected over 15 years of Los Alamos National Laboratory data between the 1990s and 2000s. Electron spectra are compared to the literature and guidelines, especially the strong event measured by the Spacecraft Charging at High Altitude satellite in 1979. The impact on a telecommunications spacecraft of such charging environments is simulated numerically with the Spacecraft Plasma Interaction Software. The correlation between the model results and the instrument data indicates that the numerical approach is reliable for estimating charging risks in operational conditions. Measured environments are ranked on their susceptibility to generate significant charging and electrostatic discharge risks.
- 1 March 2016
- Published by American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) in Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets
- Vol. 53 (2) , 304-316
Severe Geostationary Environments: Numerical Estimation of Spacecraft Surface Charging from Flight Data
This paper defines a series of severe plasma environments in terms of spacecraft surface charging in geostationary orbit. In-flight plasma measurements are used to extract environments associated with large absolute spacecraft potentials and fluxes. An exhaustive list of events is selected over 15 years of Los Alamos National Laboratory data between the 1990s and 2000s. Electron spectra are compared to the literature and guidelines, especially the strong event measured by the Spacecraft Charging at High Altitude satellite in 1979. The impact on a telecommunications spacecraft of such charging environments is simulated numerically with the Spacecraft Plasma Interaction Software. The correlation between the model results and the instrument data indicates that the numerical approach is reliable for estimating charging risks in operational conditions. Measured environments are ranked on their susceptibility to generate significant charging and electrostatic discharge risks.
- 26 August 2015
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science
- Vol. 43 (9) , 2849-2855
Analysis of Charging Kinetics on Space Dielectrics Under Representative Worst Case Geostationary Conditions
Prediction of the surface charging behavior of the materials used in space often raises concerns about the definition of the applied electron energy spectrum used for irradiation during testing. Radiation-induced conductivity (RIC) cannot be discarded for a proper qualification of these materials. But RIC level is significantly dependent upon radiation dose and dose rate. We have demonstrated that for some energy spectra, severe potentially hazardous charging levels were predicted by models when radiation history was ignored. However, the charging effect is strongly smoothed by the radiation history of the material. We have been able therefore to reveal in this paper that a good electric qualification of space materials under electron irradiation requires the definition of realistic electron energy spectrum and implies to take into account radiation history in space.
- 26 August 2015
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science
- Vol. 43 (9) , 2849-2855
Analysis of Charging Kinetics on Space Dielectrics Under Representative Worst Case Geostationary Conditions
Prediction of the surface charging behavior of the materials used in space often raises concerns about the definition of the applied electron energy spectrum used for irradiation during testing. Radiation-induced conductivity (RIC) cannot be discarded for a proper qualification of these materials. But RIC level is significantly dependent upon radiation dose and dose rate. We have demonstrated that for some energy spectra, severe potentially hazardous charging levels were predicted by models when radiation history was ignored. However, the charging effect is strongly smoothed by the radiation history of the material. We have been able therefore to reveal in this paper that a good electric qualification of space materials under electron irradiation requires the definition of realistic electron energy spectrum and implies to take into account radiation history in space.