Hayley Hirsh
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Hayley Hirsh has a total of 39 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Minghao Zhang
Nano Engineering Department University of California San Diego La Jolla CA 92093‐0418 USA
7 shared publications- Ying Shirley Meng
University of Chicago
7 shared publications - Andrej Singer
Cornell University
3 shared publications Enyue Zhao
3 shared publicationsJacob P. C. Ruff
Cornell High Energy Synchrotron Source Cornell University Ithaca NY 14853 USA
3 shared publications- Jason J. Huang
Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York 14853, United States
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 24 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in Advanced Energy Materials
- Vol. 12 (12)
Disorder Dynamics in Battery Nanoparticles During Phase Transitions Revealed by Operando Single‐Particle Diffraction (Adv. Energy Mater. 12/2022)
- 24 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in Advanced Energy Materials
- Vol. 12 (12)
Open AccessDisorder Dynamics in Battery Nanoparticles During Phase Transitions Revealed by Operando Single‐Particle Diffraction (Adv. Energy Mater. 12/2022)
- 29 December 2021
- Published by Wiley in Advanced Energy Materials
- Vol. 12 (5) , 2103196
Revisiting Discharge Mechanism of CFx as a High Energy Density Cathode Material for Lithium Primary Battery
Lithium/fluorinated graphite (Li/CFx) primary batteries show great promise for applications in a wide range of energy storage systems due to their high energy density (>2100 Wh kg–1) and low self‐discharge rate (x cathode is indeed promising, the discharge reaction mechanism is not thoroughly understood to date. In this article, a multiscale investigation of the CFx discharge mechanism is performed using a novel cathode structure to minimize the carbon and fluorine additives for precise cathode characterizations. Titration gas chromatography, X‐ray diffraction, Raman spectroscopy, X‐ray photoelectron spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy, cross‐sectional focused ion beam, high‐resolution transmission electron microscopy, and scanning transmission electron microscopy with electron energy loss spectroscopy are utilized to investigate this system. Results show no metallic lithium deposition or intercalation during the discharge reaction. Crystalline lithium fluoride particles uniformly distributed with x layers, and carbon with lower sp2 content similar to the hard‐carbon structure are the products during discharge. This work deepens the understanding of CFx as a high energy density cathode material and highlights the need for future investigations on primary battery materials to advance performance.
- 29 December 2021
- Published by Wiley in Advanced Energy Materials
- Vol. 12 (5) , 2103196
Revisiting Discharge Mechanism of CFx as a High Energy Density Cathode Material for Lithium Primary Battery
Lithium/fluorinated graphite (Li/CFx) primary batteries show great promise for applications in a wide range of energy storage systems due to their high energy density (>2100 Wh kg–1) and low self‐discharge rate (x cathode is indeed promising, the discharge reaction mechanism is not thoroughly understood to date. In this article, a multiscale investigation of the CFx discharge mechanism is performed using a novel cathode structure to minimize the carbon and fluorine additives for precise cathode characterizations. Titration gas chromatography, X‐ray diffraction, Raman spectroscopy, X‐ray photoelectron spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy, cross‐sectional focused ion beam, high‐resolution transmission electron microscopy, and scanning transmission electron microscopy with electron energy loss spectroscopy are utilized to investigate this system. Results show no metallic lithium deposition or intercalation during the discharge reaction. Crystalline lithium fluoride particles uniformly distributed with x layers, and carbon with lower sp2 content similar to the hard‐carbon structure are the products during discharge. This work deepens the understanding of CFx as a high energy density cathode material and highlights the need for future investigations on primary battery materials to advance performance.
- 15 December 2021
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in ACS Energy Letters
- Vol. 7 (1) , 261-266
Structure-Selective Operando X-ray Spectroscopy
- 15 December 2021
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in ACS Energy Letters
- Vol. 7 (1) , 261-266
Structure-Selective Operando X-ray Spectroscopy
- Open Access
Disorder Dynamics in Battery Nanoparticles During Phase Transitions Revealed by Operando Single-Particle Diffraction
Structural and ion-ordering phase transitions limit the viability of sodium-ion intercalation materials in grid scale battery storage by reducing their lifetime. However, the combination of phenomena in nanoparticulate electrodes creates complex behavior that is difficult to investigate, especially on the single nanoparticle scale under operating conditions. In this work, operando single-particle x-ray diffraction (oSP-XRD) is used to observe single-particle rotation, interlayer spacing, and layer misorientation in a functional sodium-ion battery. oSP-XRD is applied to Na$_{2/3}$[Ni$_{1/3}$Mn$_{2/3}$]O$_{2}$, an archetypal P2-type sodium-ion positive electrode material with the notorious P2-O2 phase transition induced by sodium (de)intercalation. It is found that during sodium extraction, the misorientation of crystalline layers inside individual particles increases before the layers suddenly align just prior to the P2-O2 transition. The increase in the long-range order coincides with an additional voltage plateau signifying a phase transition prior to the P2-O2 transition. To explain the layer alignment, a model for the phase evolution is proposed that includes a transition from localized to correlated Jahn-Teller distortions. The model is anticipated to guide further characterization and engineering of sodium-ion intercalation materials with P2-O2 type transitions. oSP-XRD therefore opens a powerful avenue for revealing complex phase behavior in heterogeneous nanoparticulate systems.
Open AccessDisorder Dynamics in Battery Nanoparticles During Phase Transitions Revealed by Operando Single-Particle Diffraction
Structural and ion-ordering phase transitions limit the viability of sodium-ion intercalation materials in grid scale battery storage by reducing their lifetime. However, the combination of phenomena in nanoparticulate electrodes creates complex behavior that is difficult to investigate, especially on the single nanoparticle scale under operating conditions. In this work, operando single-particle x-ray diffraction (oSP-XRD) is used to observe single-particle rotation, interlayer spacing, and layer misorientation in a functional sodium-ion battery. oSP-XRD is applied to Na$_{2/3}$[Ni$_{1/3}$Mn$_{2/3}$]O$_{2}$, an archetypal P2-type sodium-ion positive electrode material with the notorious P2-O2 phase transition induced by sodium (de)intercalation. It is found that during sodium extraction, the misorientation of crystalline layers inside individual particles increases before the layers suddenly align just prior to the P2-O2 transition. The increase in the long-range order coincides with an additional voltage plateau signifying a phase transition prior to the P2-O2 transition. To explain the layer alignment, a model for the phase evolution is proposed that includes a transition from localized to correlated Jahn-Teller distortions. The model is anticipated to guide further characterization and engineering of sodium-ion intercalation materials with P2-O2 type transitions. oSP-XRD therefore opens a powerful avenue for revealing complex phase behavior in heterogeneous nanoparticulate systems.
- 30 May 2021
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2021-01 (3) , 236
Role of Electrolyte in Stabilizing the Solid Electrolyte Interface of Hard Carbon As an Anode for Sodium-Ion Batteries
Hard carbon (HC) is an attractive anode material for sodium-ion batteries (NIBs) because it can be made from biomass or plastic, has a high capacity of ~300 mAh/g, and an extremely low average voltage near 0V. When fabricated with cathodes free of Li, Ni, and Co, NIBs using HC anodes are a promising approach for grid storage because they are energy-dense, sustainable, and have a low cost of energy. In order for these batteries to become a practical long-life solution, the issues of low first coulombic efficiency and poor rate performance of HC in conventional carbonate electrolytes need to be addressed. Two mechanisms that potentially cause these issues to occur are changes to the HC structure affecting sodium storage and the formation of the solid electrolyte interface (SEI). The proper selection of electrolyte is critical for controlling these mechanisms. To observe and characterize these mechanisms, we compared HC using a conventional carbonate electrolyte, 1M NaPF6 in propylene carbonate (PC), with a high performing glyme based electrolyte, 1M NaBF4 in tetraethylene glycol dimethyl ether (TEGDME). Compared to the poor rate capability of HC in PC electrolyte, HC in TEGDME electrolyte shows an excellent rate capability of ~265 mAh/g at C/20 and ~260 mAh/g at C/3. Titration gas chromatography and Raman spectroscopy were used to show that the HC with either electrolyte had the same sodium storage mechanism with no “stuck” sodium in the HC structure after the first cycle. These observations suggest that SEI formation is responsible for the irreversible capacity differences. The SEI formation was explored with scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy-dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS), and x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The PC electrolyte’s SEI is found to be thick, fluffy, irregular and composed of polyesters, alkyl carbonates, NaxPFyOz, and NaF. The TEGDME electrolyte’s SEI is found to be thin, conformal, uniform, and composed of polyethers, sodium alkoxides, NaxBFyOz, and NaF. Additionally, the PC electrolyte’s SEI is rate dependent with more unstable products formed at high rates whereas the TEGDME electrolyte’s SEI is not rate dependent. These findings show that HC anode’s rate capability is controlled by the quality of the SEI formed by the electrolyte rather than the HC material structure. This model of rate and electrolyte dependent SEI indicates that SEI engineering is a pathway to improve HC as an anode for long-life grid-level NIBs. Figure 1
- 30 May 2021
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2021-01 (3) , 236
Role of Electrolyte in Stabilizing the Solid Electrolyte Interface of Hard Carbon As an Anode for Sodium-Ion Batteries
Hard carbon (HC) is an attractive anode material for sodium-ion batteries (NIBs) because it can be made from biomass or plastic, has a high capacity of ~300 mAh/g, and an extremely low average voltage near 0V. When fabricated with cathodes free of Li, Ni, and Co, NIBs using HC anodes are a promising approach for grid storage because they are energy-dense, sustainable, and have a low cost of energy. In order for these batteries to become a practical long-life solution, the issues of low first coulombic efficiency and poor rate performance of HC in conventional carbonate electrolytes need to be addressed. Two mechanisms that potentially cause these issues to occur are changes to the HC structure affecting sodium storage and the formation of the solid electrolyte interface (SEI). The proper selection of electrolyte is critical for controlling these mechanisms. To observe and characterize these mechanisms, we compared HC using a conventional carbonate electrolyte, 1M NaPF6 in propylene carbonate (PC), with a high performing glyme based electrolyte, 1M NaBF4 in tetraethylene glycol dimethyl ether (TEGDME). Compared to the poor rate capability of HC in PC electrolyte, HC in TEGDME electrolyte shows an excellent rate capability of ~265 mAh/g at C/20 and ~260 mAh/g at C/3. Titration gas chromatography and Raman spectroscopy were used to show that the HC with either electrolyte had the same sodium storage mechanism with no “stuck” sodium in the HC structure after the first cycle. These observations suggest that SEI formation is responsible for the irreversible capacity differences. The SEI formation was explored with scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy-dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS), and x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The PC electrolyte’s SEI is found to be thick, fluffy, irregular and composed of polyesters, alkyl carbonates, NaxPFyOz, and NaF. The TEGDME electrolyte’s SEI is found to be thin, conformal, uniform, and composed of polyethers, sodium alkoxides, NaxBFyOz, and NaF. Additionally, the PC electrolyte’s SEI is rate dependent with more unstable products formed at high rates whereas the TEGDME electrolyte’s SEI is not rate dependent. These findings show that HC anode’s rate capability is controlled by the quality of the SEI formed by the electrolyte rather than the HC material structure. This model of rate and electrolyte dependent SEI indicates that SEI engineering is a pathway to improve HC as an anode for long-life grid-level NIBs. Figure 1
- 1 April 2021
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in Journal of the Electrochemical Society
- Vol. 168 (4) , 040539
The Negative Impact of Transition Metal Migration on Oxygen Redox Activity of Layered Cathode Materials for Na-Ion Batteries
Rechargeable sodium ion batteries with high energy density are a promising technology to address the demand for grid storage. Cathode materials with oxygen redox activity exhibit higher energy density than expected from Na-ion removal and charge compensation solely by transition metal redox. One strategy to enable oxygen redox in materials is to alter the oxygen environment through transition metal layer ordering. In this work, we report the investigation of oxygen redox activity induced by transition metal ordering in P2-type Na 0.8 Li 0.12 Ni 0.22 Mn 0.66 O 2 cathode synthesized by carbonate co-precipitation. Irreversible oxygen activity was observed and correlated with Ni migration that resulted in the loss of transition metal ordering in the structure. Calculated density of states shows that after Ni migration, the number of unoccupied states of O above Fermi level decreases, inhibiting the reduction of oxygen during sodiation. This paper provides insights on how Ni migration has a detrimental effect on transition metal ordering and reversibility of oxygen redox at high voltage.
- 1 April 2021
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in Journal of the Electrochemical Society
- Vol. 168 (4) , 040539
The Negative Impact of Transition Metal Migration on Oxygen Redox Activity of Layered Cathode Materials for Na-Ion Batteries
Rechargeable sodium ion batteries with high energy density are a promising technology to address the demand for grid storage. Cathode materials with oxygen redox activity exhibit higher energy density than expected from Na-ion removal and charge compensation solely by transition metal redox. One strategy to enable oxygen redox in materials is to alter the oxygen environment through transition metal layer ordering. In this work, we report the investigation of oxygen redox activity induced by transition metal ordering in P2-type Na 0.8 Li 0.12 Ni 0.22 Mn 0.66 O 2 cathode synthesized by carbonate co-precipitation. Irreversible oxygen activity was observed and correlated with Ni migration that resulted in the loss of transition metal ordering in the structure. Calculated density of states shows that after Ni migration, the number of unoccupied states of O above Fermi level decreases, inhibiting the reduction of oxygen during sodiation. This paper provides insights on how Ni migration has a detrimental effect on transition metal ordering and reversibility of oxygen redox at high voltage.
- Top Cited Papers
- 6 July 2020
- Published by Wiley in Advanced Energy Materials
- Vol. 10 (32) , 2001274
Sodium‐Ion Batteries Paving the Way for Grid Energy Storage
The recent proliferation of renewable energy generation offers mankind hope, with regard to combatting global climate change. However, reaping the full benefits of these renewable energy sources requires the ability to store and distribute any renewable energy generated in a cost‐effective, safe, and sustainable manner. As such, sodium‐ion batteries (NIBs) have been touted as an attractive storage technology due to their elemental abundance, promising electrochemical performance and environmentally benign nature. Moreover, new developments in sodium battery materials have enabled the adoption of high‐voltage and high‐capacity cathodes free of rare earth elements such as Li, Co, Ni, offering pathways for low‐cost NIBs that match their lithium counterparts in energy density while serving the needs for large‐scale grid energy storage. In this essay, a range of battery chemistries are discussed alongside their respective battery properties while keeping metrics for grid storage in mind. Matters regarding materials and full cell cost, supply chain and environmental sustainability are discussed, with emphasis on the need to eliminate several elements (Li, Ni, Co) from NIBs. Future directions for research are also discussed, along with potential strategies to overcome obstacles in battery safety and sustainable recyclability.
- 6 July 2020
- Published by Wiley in Advanced Energy Materials
- Vol. 10 (32) , 2001274
Top Cited PapersSodium‐Ion Batteries Paving the Way for Grid Energy Storage
The recent proliferation of renewable energy generation offers mankind hope, with regard to combatting global climate change. However, reaping the full benefits of these renewable energy sources requires the ability to store and distribute any renewable energy generated in a cost‐effective, safe, and sustainable manner. As such, sodium‐ion batteries (NIBs) have been touted as an attractive storage technology due to their elemental abundance, promising electrochemical performance and environmentally benign nature. Moreover, new developments in sodium battery materials have enabled the adoption of high‐voltage and high‐capacity cathodes free of rare earth elements such as Li, Co, Ni, offering pathways for low‐cost NIBs that match their lithium counterparts in energy density while serving the needs for large‐scale grid energy storage. In this essay, a range of battery chemistries are discussed alongside their respective battery properties while keeping metrics for grid storage in mind. Matters regarding materials and full cell cost, supply chain and environmental sustainability are discussed, with emphasis on the need to eliminate several elements (Li, Ni, Co) from NIBs. Future directions for research are also discussed, along with potential strategies to overcome obstacles in battery safety and sustainable recyclability.
- 1 May 2020
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2020-01 (2) , 242
Elucidating the Redox Mechanism of Battery Cathode Materials Made from Earth-Abundant Elements
Sodium ion batteries (NIBs) are a promising technology for grid storage due to the natural abundance, low cost, and suitable redox potential (-2.71 V vs. SHE) of Na. Exploration of NIB cathode materials that include abundant and inexpensive elements, has led to the investigation of sodium iron manganese oxides. However, these materials suffer from low electrochemical reversibility during cycling, and their reaction mechanisms are unresolved, presenting an obstacle for their further optimization. In literature, three different reaction mechanisms have been reported for sodium iron manganese cathodes including 1) Fe 2+/3+, 2) Fe 3+/4+, and 3) oxygen redox. Additionally, the reported redox measurements are ex situ, which leaves uncertainty if the oxidation state of these materials changes between electrochemical cycling and redox measurement. Herein, for the first time we combine operando x-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) and computation method to report the redox mechanisms of P2-Na2/3FexMn1-xO2 (x=1/4, 1/3, 1/2). The redox mechanism and capacity retention of these cathode materials is found to be dependent on the Fe content. When x=1/4, 1/3 the redox mechanism is Fe 2+/3+ and Mn 3+/4+, and the material exhibits high capacity retention. When x=1/2, the redox mechanism is Fe 3+/4+ and Mn 3+/ 4+, and the material shows poor capacity retention. These results indicate that improved reversibility of sodium iron manganese oxides can be obtained by limiting the amount of the Fe 3+/4+ redox through reducing the Fe content. These results will contribute to the rational design of long lifetime cathode materials made from earth-abundant elements. Figure 1
- 1 May 2020
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2020-01 (2) , 242
Elucidating the Redox Mechanism of Battery Cathode Materials Made from Earth-Abundant Elements
Sodium ion batteries (NIBs) are a promising technology for grid storage due to the natural abundance, low cost, and suitable redox potential (-2.71 V vs. SHE) of Na. Exploration of NIB cathode materials that include abundant and inexpensive elements, has led to the investigation of sodium iron manganese oxides. However, these materials suffer from low electrochemical reversibility during cycling, and their reaction mechanisms are unresolved, presenting an obstacle for their further optimization. In literature, three different reaction mechanisms have been reported for sodium iron manganese cathodes including 1) Fe 2+/3+, 2) Fe 3+/4+, and 3) oxygen redox. Additionally, the reported redox measurements are ex situ, which leaves uncertainty if the oxidation state of these materials changes between electrochemical cycling and redox measurement. Herein, for the first time we combine operando x-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) and computation method to report the redox mechanisms of P2-Na2/3FexMn1-xO2 (x=1/4, 1/3, 1/2). The redox mechanism and capacity retention of these cathode materials is found to be dependent on the Fe content. When x=1/4, 1/3 the redox mechanism is Fe 2+/3+ and Mn 3+/4+, and the material exhibits high capacity retention. When x=1/2, the redox mechanism is Fe 3+/4+ and Mn 3+/ 4+, and the material shows poor capacity retention. These results indicate that improved reversibility of sodium iron manganese oxides can be obtained by limiting the amount of the Fe 3+/4+ redox through reducing the Fe content. These results will contribute to the rational design of long lifetime cathode materials made from earth-abundant elements. Figure 1
- 17 July 2019
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in Journal of the Electrochemical Society
- Vol. 166 (12) , A2528-A2535
Meso-Structure Controlled Synthesis of Sodium Iron-Manganese Oxides Cathode for Low-Cost Na-Ion Batteries
- 17 July 2019
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in Journal of the Electrochemical Society
- Vol. 166 (12) , A2528-A2535
Meso-Structure Controlled Synthesis of Sodium Iron-Manganese Oxides Cathode for Low-Cost Na-Ion Batteries
- 1 February 2019
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2019-03 (2) , 118
Meso-Structure Controlled Synthesis of Sodium Iron-Manganese Oxides for Na-Ion Batteries
Increasing deployment of large scale electric storage applications would benefit from the development of inexpensive batteries. Na-ion batteries (NIBs) are of great interest since their cathodes can be made from inexpensive and abundant materials such as sodium, iron, and manganese. However, existing iron and manganese oxide cathodes lack the electrochemical performance, including capacity retention, required for these NIB applications and significant improvement is needed. Prior work on lithium ion battery cathodes demonstrates that meso-structured materials can improve electrochemical performance for batteries. Incorporating spherical meso-structured materials in lithium ion battery cathodes was shown to improve capacity retention. To emulate this approach in NIB cathode materials, a synthesis method for producing pure phase spherical meso-structured sodium iron manganese oxide is first needed. No literature has been found that describes a method for this synthesis. Key synthesis parameters to be controlled include the choice of method, material precursors, pH of reaction, calcination time, and cooling rate. In this work we demonstrate a modified co-precipitation method to synthesize spherical meso-structure pure phase P2-Na0.67Fe1/4Mn3/4O2 (see Figure 1) and we report initial characterization of the electrochemical performance of this material. The key parameter found to control the formation of a spherical meso-structure is the cooling rate applied during synthesis. The slow cooled material forms spherical meso-structures while the quenched material has no ordered meso-structure. Additionally, the spherical meso-structured material shows increased capacity, improved cyclability, and reduced polarization. The electrochemical performance enhancement is attributed to higher surface area, reduced surface concentration of sodium carbonate, and lower internal resistance during cycling. Further exploring the synthesis and mechanisms of meso-structured materials offers a path for improving Na-ion battery cathodes. Figure 1
- 1 February 2019
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2019-03 (2) , 118
Meso-Structure Controlled Synthesis of Sodium Iron-Manganese Oxides for Na-Ion Batteries
Increasing deployment of large scale electric storage applications would benefit from the development of inexpensive batteries. Na-ion batteries (NIBs) are of great interest since their cathodes can be made from inexpensive and abundant materials such as sodium, iron, and manganese. However, existing iron and manganese oxide cathodes lack the electrochemical performance, including capacity retention, required for these NIB applications and significant improvement is needed. Prior work on lithium ion battery cathodes demonstrates that meso-structured materials can improve electrochemical performance for batteries. Incorporating spherical meso-structured materials in lithium ion battery cathodes was shown to improve capacity retention. To emulate this approach in NIB cathode materials, a synthesis method for producing pure phase spherical meso-structured sodium iron manganese oxide is first needed. No literature has been found that describes a method for this synthesis. Key synthesis parameters to be controlled include the choice of method, material precursors, pH of reaction, calcination time, and cooling rate. In this work we demonstrate a modified co-precipitation method to synthesize spherical meso-structure pure phase P2-Na0.67Fe1/4Mn3/4O2 (see Figure 1) and we report initial characterization of the electrochemical performance of this material. The key parameter found to control the formation of a spherical meso-structure is the cooling rate applied during synthesis. The slow cooled material forms spherical meso-structures while the quenched material has no ordered meso-structure. Additionally, the spherical meso-structured material shows increased capacity, improved cyclability, and reduced polarization. The electrochemical performance enhancement is attributed to higher surface area, reduced surface concentration of sodium carbonate, and lower internal resistance during cycling. Further exploring the synthesis and mechanisms of meso-structured materials offers a path for improving Na-ion battery cathodes. Figure 1