IWIda K. Westerberg

Ida K. Westerberg

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Ida K. Westerberg has a total of 96 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Rapid rating curve uncertainty estimation using hydraulic modeling: use of UAV-derived data and impacts of gauging strategies on uncertainty in hydrological signatures

    by Ida K. Westerberg, Valentin Mansanarez, Steve Lyon, Norris Lam, Joakim Hållén, Reinert Huseby Karlsen

    The rapid development of UAV-based river surveying is creating new opportunities to efficiently survey river reaches and collect high-resolution topographic, hydraulic, and surface velocity data for hydraulic rating-curve modeling and discharge estimation. Hydraulic rating-curve modeling provides a physically based approach that can reduce extrapolation uncertainty and constrain rating curves with fewer stage–discharge gaugings. However, despite these advances, how such UAV-derived data can be integrated into rating-curve uncertainty estimation frameworks and the impact of different calibration-gauging datasets on uncertainty in derived hydrological signatures is largely unexplored, limiting understanding of the method's operational potential. This study provides the first application of the RUHM framework (Rating curve Uncertainty estimation using Hydraulic Modeling) using UAV-derived data and the first quantification of how RUHM-modeled rating-curve and discharge uncertainties propagate to hydrological signatures under different gauging strategies. We applied RUHM at two sites in northern Sweden. At the Rakkurijärvi site, RUHM was applied using UAV-derived data from LiDAR, Structure from Motion (SfM) photogrammetry, and surface-velocimetry videos together with bathymetric and water-surface slope data. At the Röån site, RUHM was evaluated under nine gauging scenarios to assess their impacts on uncertainty in hydrological signatures. RUHM constrained rating-curve uncertainty across the full flow range at Rakkurijärvi using only three calibration gaugings, with similar results for SfM and LiDAR topography; using UAV-derived discharge for calibration increased uncertainty but still yielded a reliable rating curve. At the Röån site, rating-curve, discharge, and hydrological signature uncertainties were generally well constrained when calibration included low- to mid-flow stage–discharge gaugings, including for extreme-flow and flow-variability metrics, but the resulting signature distributions did not necessarily overlap for all metrics. These results show that RUHM, combined with UAV-based surveys, can support rapid and cost-effective estimation of rating curves and their uncertainty using relatively few gaugings, while also demonstrating how gauging strategy influences the uncertainty in hydrological signatures derived from hydraulically modeled rating curves and discharge estimates. The approach is best suited to sites with near one-dimensional hydraulic conditions and a stable stage–discharge relation, and we found that careful flight planning was needed to obtain high quality UAV data.


  • Open Access

    RUHM: An open-source tool for rapid stage–discharge Rating curve Uncertainty estimation using Hydraulic Modelling and UAV data

    by Ida Westerberg, Reinert Karlsen, Valentin Mansanarez, Axel Lavenius

    We present RUHM (Rating curve Uncertainty estimation using Hydraulic Modelling), a new open-source tool for rapid estimation of stage–discharge rating curves and their uncertainty at river discharge monitoring stations. A rating curve models the relation between stage (water level) and discharge at a river location and is used to derive discharge time series from water level at most discharge monitoring stations worldwide. However, many stage-discharge field gaugings are needed to estimate rating curves and their uncertainty using traditional approaches. RUHM combines a 1D hydraulic model with Bayesian inference and uncertainty estimation techniques to more rapidly estimate a rating curve and its associated uncertainty with a minimum of three low to middle flow gaugings. The data needed to use RUHM can be effectively collected using drone/UAV (Unmanned Aerial Vehicle) surveys, reducing field efforts compared with traditional approaches. Our open-source implementation of RUHM is written in Python and features a graphical user interface, a user manual, two workflows for pre-processing UAV-derived and/or traditionally surveyed data to generate the RUHM input data files, and example datasets with UAV data. Applications of RUHM to Swedish stations show well-constrained and robust uncertainty estimates where the 1D-flow assumption holds, and wider uncertainty intervals where it does not.

  • Open Access

    Can we use soft information to estimate discharge data uncertainty for large samples of catchments?

    by Ida Westerberg, Gemma Coxon

    Understanding how data uncertainties impact on our analyses is essential to draw the right conclusions about hydrological processes and their change in space and time. However, understanding the impact of data uncertainties is challenging when working with large numbers of catchments: data uncertainty estimates are rarely available from data providers and producing such estimates requires substantial efforts.In the absence of such ‘hard’ information about data uncertainty, Westerberg and Karlsen (2024), suggested using ‘soft’ information to qualitatively estimate discharge data uncertainty and to summarise the soft information in a generalized perceptual model of uncertainty. They use three categories of soft information: station characteristics, climate and flow regime, and catchment characteristics. An example of soft information about the flow regime is that there are rare extreme high flows, this impedes high flow gauging and therefore increases high flow uncertainty. Another example of a climate characteristic is the presence of river ice-cover that increases low flow uncertainty.In this study, we take the generalized perceptual model of discharge data uncertainty from Westerberg and Karlsen and translate it into catchment and station metadata from the Camels-GB dataset (Coxon et al., 2020) and the UK National River Flow Archive (https://nrfa.ceh.ac.uk). This enables us to evaluate how useful soft information is to identify stations with low and high data uncertainty by comparing it to the ‘hard’ uncertainty estimates at hourly and daily time scales from previous detailed stage–discharge rating curve uncertainty analyses (Coxon et al., 2015; Westerberg et al., 2016). We explore which metadata are most useful as soft information about high and low flow uncertainty respectively and recommend useful metadata on discharge data uncertainty to be included in large sample datasets. Coxon, G., J. Freer, I. K. Westerberg, T. Wagener, R. Woods, and P. J. Smith (2015), A novel framework for discharge uncertainty quantification applied to 500 UK gauging stations, Water Resour. Res., 51, 5531–5546, doi:10.1002/2014WR016532.Westerberg, I. K., T. Wagener, G. Coxon, H. K. McMillan, A. Castellarin, A. Montanari, and J. Freer (2016), Uncertainty in hydrological signatures for gauged and ungauged catchments, Water Resour. Res., 52, 1847–1865, doi:10.1002/2015WR017635.Coxon, G., Addor, N., Bloomfield, J. P., Freer, J., Fry, M., Hannaford, J., Howden, N. J. K., Lane, R., Lewis, M., Robinson, E. L., Wagener, T., and Woods, R. (2020): CAMELS-GB: hydrometeorological time series and landscape attributes for 671 catchments in Great Britain, Earth Syst. Sci. Data, 12, 2459–2483, https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-12-2459-2020.Westerberg, I. K., & Karlsen, R. H. (2024). Sharing perceptual models of uncertainty: On the use of soft information about discharge data. Hydrological Processes, 38(5), e15145. https://doi.org/10.1002/hyp.15145

  • Open Access

    Sharing perceptual models of uncertainty – on the use of soft information about discharge data uncertainty

    by Ida Westerberg, Reinert Huseby Karlsen

    Many hydrologists face the situation that they have no, or very limited, information about the uncertainty in the discharge data they are using. Data uncertainty is rarely communicated by monitoring agencies and data providers – and is often not available on request. This means that data users typically treat data as if they are error-free, whereas in reality there can be large uncertainties and errors.However, the absence of metadata and ‘hard’ information about data uncertainty does not mean that there is no information about the data uncertainty. Instead, we can use other types of ‘soft’ information to understand the likelihood that discharge data in a particular location are uncertain. For example, if high flows are of short duration (i.e., a few hours) and the rainfall-runoff lag time is short, it is practically quite difficult to manage to gauge high flows, leading to likely extrapolation of stage–discharge rating curves and large high flow uncertainty. A second example is if a river is ice-covered during the winter season, then most of the winter water-level time series is subjectively estimated, leading to substantial uncertainty in winter low flows. Such soft information about data uncertainty is well known by field hydrologists and data uncertainty experts but is not as commonly known in the wider hydrological community. In this presentation we focus on uncertainty in discharge data calculated from stage–discharge rating curves and aim to share – and to encourage sharing – of soft information about data uncertainty sources, to promote more informed decisions on data uncertainty in hydrological studies.We summarize the soft information about discharge data uncertainty as a perceptual model of uncertainty. Our perceptual model divides the soft information into three categories: station characteristics, climate and flow regime, and catchment characteristics. For each category we present and describe different types of soft information, the uncertainty sources and impacts they can inform us about, and sources for each soft information type (e.g., photos, satellite images, land use). We find that soft information can inform us about three main types of uncertainty sources: uncertainty related to the hydraulic control, uncertainty related to incomplete gauging of the full flow range, and uncertainty due to measurement error.Our generalised perceptual model can be seen as a smorgasbord of information about uncertainty sources, where the soft information can be considered as relevant to a particular dataset and can inform us if high or low data uncertainty is likely. We believe that a key benefit of the type of generalized perceptual model of uncertainty we present is to facilitate dialogue on, and understanding of, possible sources of observational uncertainties and their impacts. We encourage others to complement our perceptual model of discharge data uncertainty based on experience from different regions and for other discharge monitoring techniques such as index-velocity stations or drone/camera-based methods.

  • Open Access

    Rapid streamflow monitoring with drones

    by Ida Westerberg, Valentin Mansanarez, Steve Lyon, Norris Lam

    Accurate and reliable streamflow monitoring data are urgently needed for many new locations to tackle the on-going climate emergency, where we now see increasingly severe impacts on society from extreme flows. Yet, traditional river monitoring methods depend on empirical rating-curve methods for which it typically takes many years or decades to obtain reliable data, in particular for extreme flows. This gap between increasing needs and current monitoring capabilities calls for new methods to be developed.Drones provide an unprecedented ability to measure both the physical and hydraulic characteristics of a river in an efficient manner. Topography, water surface slope, surface water velocity and even bathymetry can be derived from drone images and drone lidar data. We exploited this potential by incorporating drone data into the framework for Rating curve Uncertainty estimation using Hydraulic Modelling (RUHM). The RUHM framework combines a one-dimensional hydraulic model with Bayesian inference and together with drone data it allows us to efficiently estimate a reliable rating curve and its associated uncertainty based on as few as three gaugings.We present our results from applying RUHM to Swedish gauging stations where we model rating curves and streamflow based on drone data. We primarily used low-cost camera drones to collect both the input (DEM, vegetation, bathymetry) and calibration data (water surface slope, surface velocity) for the hydraulic model, but also tested the capabilities of drone lidar data. Our aim was to estimate reliable rating curves with RUHM based only on data from the drone flights. We assessed the uncertainty in the drone-derived model input and calibration data compared to traditional fieldwork techniques, as well as their impact on the RUHM-modelled rating curves and streamflow results.We find that careful planning of when to fly the drone is important for obtaining good-quality model input and calibration data. Using a combination of drone camera and drone lidar data we were able to obtain all the data needed for RUHM from the drone flights. Extreme low and high flows were reliably modelled with RUHM with constrained uncertainty based on as few as three low and middle flow gaugings, without the need for gauging extreme flows. We conclude that using RUHM with drone data is an efficient and promising alternative to traditional streamflow monitoring methods, being much less time-consuming and costly, as well as involving fewer risks to field staff.


  • Open Access

    The RUHM framework for rapid rating curve uncertainty estimation: comparison to power-law methods and potential using drone-derived data

    by Ida Westerberg, Valentin Mansanarez, Stephen Lyon, Norris Lam

    Climate change, together with other natural and anthropogenic drivers lead to changes in streamflow patterns that are now occurring with increasing frequency. At the same time traditional streamflow monitoring methods are time-consuming and costly so that it typically takes many years of significant field efforts to establish reliable streamflow data for a new location or for stations with major temporal changes to the stage—discharge relation. To provide timely and reliable streamflow data to tackle these changes to the hydrological regime and their impacts on society’s water management requires new cost-effective monitoring methods that can rapidly produce data with low uncertainty. Hydraulically modelled rating curves are a promising alternative to traditional power-law methods as they need much fewer calibration gaugings, but they are associated with additional uncertainty sources in the hydraulic knowledge and these need to be assessed.We present the Rating curve Uncertainty estimation using Hydraulic Modelling (RUHM) framework which was developed to rapidly estimate rating curves and their uncertainty. The RUHM framework combines a one-dimensional hydraulic model with Bayesian inference to incorporate information from both hydraulic knowledge and the calibration gauging data. In this study we compare RUHM and the Bayesian power-law method BaRatin in application to a Swedish site using nine different gauging strategies associated with different costs. We compare results for the two methods in terms of accuracy, cost and time required for establishing rating curves. We found that rating curves with low uncertainty could be modelled with fewer gaugings for RUHM compared to BaRatin. As few as three gaugings were needed with RUHM if these gaugings covered low and medium flows, whereas high flow gaugings were not necessary. This makes the RUHM method both cost effective and time efficient as low and medium flows occur more frequently than high flows. When using all gaugings (i.e., a high-cost gauging strategy), the uncertainty for RUHM and BaRatin was similar. The results for this Swedish site show that hydraulic rating curve uncertainty estimation is a promising tool for quickly estimating rating curves and their uncertainties. Finally, we discuss the potential of using RUHM together with drone-derived data to make field efforts even more efficient.

  • Impacts of observational uncertainty on analysis and modelling of hydrological processes: Preface

    by Hilary K. McMillan, Gemma Coxon, Anna E. Sikorska‐Senoner, Ida K. Westerberg


  • Hydrological model calibration with uncertain discharge data

    by Ida K. Westerberg, Anna E. Sikorska-Senoner, Daniel Viviroli, Marc Vis, Jan Seibert

    Discharge data used to calibrate and evaluate hydrological models can be highly uncertain and this uncertainty affects the conclusions that we can draw from modelling results. We investigated the role of discharge data uncertainty and its representation in hydrological model calibration to give recommendations on methods to account for data uncertainty. We tested five different representations of discharge data uncertainty in calibrating the HBV-model for three Swiss catchments, ranging from using no information to using full empirical probability distributions for each time step. We developed a new objective function to include discharge data uncertainty, as quantified by these distributions directly in calibration to hydrological time series. This new objective function provided more reliable results than using no data uncertainty or multiple realizations of discharge time series. We recommend using the new objective function in combination with empirical or triangular distributions of the discharge data uncertainty.


  • Open Access

    Comparison of rating-curve uncertainty estimation using hydraulic modelling and power-law methods

    by Ida Westerberg, Valentin Mansanarez, Steve Lyon, Norris Lam

    Establishing reliable rating curves and thereby reliable streamflow monitoring records is fundamental to much of hydrological science and water management practice. Cost-effective methods that enable rapid rating curve estimation with low uncertainty are needed given diminishing monitoring resources and increasing human-driven changes to the water cycle. Traditional power-law rating curves rely on numerous gaugings to estimate rating curves and their associated uncertainty. Hydraulically-modelled rating curves are a promising alternative to power-law methods as they rely on fewer gaugings, but they are associated with additional uncertainty sources in the hydraulic knowledge (bed slope, roughness, topography and vegetation), which need to be assessed.Our aim with this study was to compare power-law and hydraulic-model based methods for estimating rating curves and their uncertainty. We focused on assessing their accuracy as well as the costs and time required for establishing rating curves. We compared the Rating curve Uncertainty estimation using Hydraulic Modelling (RUHM) framework with the Bayesian power-law method BaRatin. The RUHM framework combines a one-dimensional hydraulic model with Bayesian inference to incorporate information from both hydraulic knowledge and the calibration gauging data. We applied both methods to the 584 km2 River Röån station in Sweden under nine different gauging strategies associated with different costs. The gauging strategies differed in the number and flow magnitude of the gaugings used as well as the probability of observing the gauged flows.We found that rating curves with low uncertainty could be modelled with fewer gaugings using the RUHM framework compared to BaRatin. As few as three gaugings were needed for RUHM if these gaugings covered low and medium flows, making the estimation both cost effective and time efficient. When using all the gaugings available (i.e. a high-cost gauging strategy), the uncertainty for RUHM and BaRatin was similar at the Röån station. Furthermore, we found that BaRatin needed gaugings with lower probability of occurrence (i.e. covering a larger part of the flow range) than needed when using hydraulic modelling (low and middle flow gaugings with high probability of occurrence gave good results). The results for this Swedish site show that hydraulic rating curve uncertainty estimation is a promising tool for quickly estimating rating curves and their uncertainties. In particular, it is useful for previously ungauged or remote sites, or at stations where there have been major temporal changes to the stage–discharge relation.