Bibiana Comesaña-Gándara
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Bibiana Comesaña-Gándara has a total of 121 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Johannes Carolus Jansen
Institute on Membrane Technology, Italy
11 shared publications - Ángel Emilio Lozano
Institute of Polymer Science and Technology, ICTP, CSIC, C/Juan de la Cierva, 3, Madrid 28006, Spain
9 shared publications - Alessio Fuoco
National Research Council of Italy – Institute on Membrane Technology “Enrico Drioli” (CNR-ITM), Via P. Bucci 17/C, 87036 Rende (CS), Italy
8 shared publications - Mariolino Carta
Department of Chemistry, Swansea University, College of Science, Grove Building, Singleton Park, Swansea SA2 8PP, UK
8 shared publications - Antonio Hernandez
Institute of Sustainable Processes, University of Valladolid, 47011 Valladolid, Spain
7 shared publications - Elisa Esposito
Institute on Membrane Technology, Italy
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 6 October 2025
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in ACS Applied Polymer Materials
- Vol. 7 (20) , 13626-13636
Tailored Catalysts Based on Polymers of Intrinsic Microporosity for Asymmetric Aza-Henry Reaction of Pyrazolinone Ketimines in Batch and Flow
We report the design and application of heterogeneous organocatalysts based on polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIMs) for the asymmetric aza-Henry reaction of N-Boc-protected pyrazolinone ketimines with nitromethane. Two copolymers (PIM-10 and PIM-20) incorporating a flexible isatin-derived monomer were synthesized and postfunctionalized with a quinine-derived thiourea. The resulting materials, PIM-10-TU and PIM-20-TU, exhibited high thermal stability, tailored porosity, and effective enantioselective catalytic performance in batch- and continuous-flow conditions. PIM-10-TU showed superior activity and recyclability, achieving full conversion in 2–4 h and affording β-nitroamine derivatives in up to 87% yield and 85:15 er. Flow experiments enabled gram-scale synthesis with short residence times and a sustained efficiency. The synthetic utility of the chiral aminopyrazolones was demonstrated via derivatization to ureas and thioureas without erosion of the enantiopurity. This study highlights the potential of PIM-supported organocatalysts as robust and recyclable platforms for asymmetric synthesis under sustainable conditions.
- 6 October 2025
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in ACS Applied Polymer Materials
- Vol. 7 (20) , 13626-13636
Open AccessTailored Catalysts Based on Polymers of Intrinsic Microporosity for Asymmetric Aza-Henry Reaction of Pyrazolinone Ketimines in Batch and Flow
We report the design and application of heterogeneous organocatalysts based on polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIMs) for the asymmetric aza-Henry reaction of N-Boc-protected pyrazolinone ketimines with nitromethane. Two copolymers (PIM-10 and PIM-20) incorporating a flexible isatin-derived monomer were synthesized and postfunctionalized with a quinine-derived thiourea. The resulting materials, PIM-10-TU and PIM-20-TU, exhibited high thermal stability, tailored porosity, and effective enantioselective catalytic performance in batch- and continuous-flow conditions. PIM-10-TU showed superior activity and recyclability, achieving full conversion in 2–4 h and affording β-nitroamine derivatives in up to 87% yield and 85:15 er. Flow experiments enabled gram-scale synthesis with short residence times and a sustained efficiency. The synthetic utility of the chiral aminopyrazolones was demonstrated via derivatization to ureas and thioureas without erosion of the enantiopurity. This study highlights the potential of PIM-supported organocatalysts as robust and recyclable platforms for asymmetric synthesis under sustainable conditions.
- Open Access
Evaluation of Imidazolium Ionenes: Solid–Solid Phase Change Materials as Heat Sinks
Overheating in miniaturized electronic devices can reduce their useful life, where conventional heat sinks are insufficient. The utilization of ionenes as solid–solid phase change materials is proposed to enhance thermal dissipation without the risk of leakage. In this work, a series of imidazolium ionenes with structural modifications in their aromatic core and aliphatic chain length were synthesized. The synthesis was carried out using the respective monomers diimidazole and alkyl dibromide, followed by counterion bromide exchange using lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide, with yields over 90% in all cases. Thermal characterizations showed that all ionenes are heat-resistant, with degradation temperatures between 421 °C and 432 °C; moreover, they all presented only a solid–solid transition (Tg) as a phase change, between 59 °C and 28 °C, which varied depending on the aromatic core used and the length of the aliphatic chain. The obtained ionenes were introduced into an experimental device with an operating temperature of 40 °C, to be evaluated as solid–solid phase change materials in heat sinks. These demonstrated an average decrease in operating temperature of 9 °C compared to the device without ionenes. On the other hand, the stability of the ionenes was analyzed over 10 thermal cycles at 40 °C at a heating rate of 5 °C/min. This analysis demonstrated that the ionenes did not present changes or degradation during the evaluated cycles. These findings demonstrate that imidazolium ionenes are promising solid–solid phase change materials for use as efficient and self-repairing heat sinks in compact electronic devices.
Open AccessEvaluation of Imidazolium Ionenes: Solid–Solid Phase Change Materials as Heat Sinks
Overheating in miniaturized electronic devices can reduce their useful life, where conventional heat sinks are insufficient. The utilization of ionenes as solid–solid phase change materials is proposed to enhance thermal dissipation without the risk of leakage. In this work, a series of imidazolium ionenes with structural modifications in their aromatic core and aliphatic chain length were synthesized. The synthesis was carried out using the respective monomers diimidazole and alkyl dibromide, followed by counterion bromide exchange using lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide, with yields over 90% in all cases. Thermal characterizations showed that all ionenes are heat-resistant, with degradation temperatures between 421 °C and 432 °C; moreover, they all presented only a solid–solid transition (Tg) as a phase change, between 59 °C and 28 °C, which varied depending on the aromatic core used and the length of the aliphatic chain. The obtained ionenes were introduced into an experimental device with an operating temperature of 40 °C, to be evaluated as solid–solid phase change materials in heat sinks. These demonstrated an average decrease in operating temperature of 9 °C compared to the device without ionenes. On the other hand, the stability of the ionenes was analyzed over 10 thermal cycles at 40 °C at a heating rate of 5 °C/min. This analysis demonstrated that the ionenes did not present changes or degradation during the evaluated cycles. These findings demonstrate that imidazolium ionenes are promising solid–solid phase change materials for use as efficient and self-repairing heat sinks in compact electronic devices.
- Open Access
- 28 April 2025
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Journal of Materials Chemistry A
- Vol. 13 (23) , 17865-17876
Unravelling the origin of enhanced CO 2 selectivity in amine-PIM-1 during mixed gas permeation
CO 2 is partially chemisorbed on amine-PIM-1, and this leads to enhanced CO 2 selectivity by increasing sorption-driven affinity (physisorption/chemisorption) and modifying the pore-size distribution.
- 28 April 2025
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Journal of Materials Chemistry A
- Vol. 13 (23) , 17865-17876
Open AccessUnravelling the origin of enhanced CO 2 selectivity in amine-PIM-1 during mixed gas permeation
CO 2 is partially chemisorbed on amine-PIM-1, and this leads to enhanced CO 2 selectivity by increasing sorption-driven affinity (physisorption/chemisorption) and modifying the pore-size distribution.
- Open Access
Gas Permeability through Polyimides: Unraveling the Influence of Free Volume, Intersegmental Distance and Glass Transition Temperature
The relationships between gas permeability and free volume fraction, intersegmental distance, and glass transition temperature, are investigated. They are analyzed for He, CO2, O2, CH4, and N2 gases and for five similar polyimides with a wide range of permeabilities, from very low to extremely high ones. It has been established here that there is an exponential relationship between permeability and the free volume fraction, and between permeability and the most probable intersegmental distance as measured by WAXS; in both cases, with an exponential coefficient that depends on the kinetic gas diameter as a quadratic polynomial and with a preexponential positive constant. Moreover, it has been proven that the intersegmental distance increases linearly with the free volume fraction. Finally, it has been established that the free volume fraction increases with the glass transition temperature for the polymers tested, and that they depend on each other in an approximate linear way.
Open AccessGas Permeability through Polyimides: Unraveling the Influence of Free Volume, Intersegmental Distance and Glass Transition Temperature
The relationships between gas permeability and free volume fraction, intersegmental distance, and glass transition temperature, are investigated. They are analyzed for He, CO2, O2, CH4, and N2 gases and for five similar polyimides with a wide range of permeabilities, from very low to extremely high ones. It has been established here that there is an exponential relationship between permeability and the free volume fraction, and between permeability and the most probable intersegmental distance as measured by WAXS; in both cases, with an exponential coefficient that depends on the kinetic gas diameter as a quadratic polynomial and with a preexponential positive constant. Moreover, it has been proven that the intersegmental distance increases linearly with the free volume fraction. Finally, it has been established that the free volume fraction increases with the glass transition temperature for the polymers tested, and that they depend on each other in an approximate linear way.
- Open Access
- 26 April 2023
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Polymer Chemistry
- Vol. 14 (19) , 2363-2373
Polymers of intrinsic microporosity containing aryl-phthalimide moieties: synthesis, modeling, and membrane gas transport properties
High-performance polymers for membrane gas separation require the careful design of the structure-porous relationship. In this work, five phthalimide-based polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIMs) were obtained via the double nucleophilic aromatic substitution with the commercially available 5,5′,6,6′-tetrahydroxy-3,3,3′,3′-tetramethylspirobisindane (TTSBI) monomer. The phthalimide monomers were synthesized considering different sizes and positions of the alkyl-substituents to evaluate their influence on the physical properties of the polymers and their potential use as gas separation membranes. Four polymers were soluble in the low-boiling solvents chloroform and tetrahydrofuran, facilitating the casting of self-standing films to evaluate their gas separation properties. The thermally stable membranes showed 5% weight lost between 537 °C and 549 °C. As powders, these four polymers showed apparent BET surface areas ranging from 434 to 661 m2 g−1. The experimental BET surface areas correlated with those obtained by molecular simulation models of the synthesized polymers. A linear function is proposed as a tool to predict, with a known uncertainty, the surface area values of this type of polymer from the corresponding computational models. As a trend, increasing the volume of the ortho-substituent in the aryl-phthalimide group increases the permeability of the membranes, reaching generally better performances than Matrimid® and close to those of PIM-1, considering their place on the Robeson diagrams of the O2/N2, CO2/CH4 and CO2/N2 gas pairs. Aging studies between 63 and 122 days showed a decrease in permeability, accompanied by the typical increase in selectivity that tends to move the data parallel to the upper Robeson limits.
- 26 April 2023
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Polymer Chemistry
- Vol. 14 (19) , 2363-2373
Open AccessPolymers of intrinsic microporosity containing aryl-phthalimide moieties: synthesis, modeling, and membrane gas transport properties
High-performance polymers for membrane gas separation require the careful design of the structure-porous relationship. In this work, five phthalimide-based polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIMs) were obtained via the double nucleophilic aromatic substitution with the commercially available 5,5′,6,6′-tetrahydroxy-3,3,3′,3′-tetramethylspirobisindane (TTSBI) monomer. The phthalimide monomers were synthesized considering different sizes and positions of the alkyl-substituents to evaluate their influence on the physical properties of the polymers and their potential use as gas separation membranes. Four polymers were soluble in the low-boiling solvents chloroform and tetrahydrofuran, facilitating the casting of self-standing films to evaluate their gas separation properties. The thermally stable membranes showed 5% weight lost between 537 °C and 549 °C. As powders, these four polymers showed apparent BET surface areas ranging from 434 to 661 m2 g−1. The experimental BET surface areas correlated with those obtained by molecular simulation models of the synthesized polymers. A linear function is proposed as a tool to predict, with a known uncertainty, the surface area values of this type of polymer from the corresponding computational models. As a trend, increasing the volume of the ortho-substituent in the aryl-phthalimide group increases the permeability of the membranes, reaching generally better performances than Matrimid® and close to those of PIM-1, considering their place on the Robeson diagrams of the O2/N2, CO2/CH4 and CO2/N2 gas pairs. Aging studies between 63 and 122 days showed a decrease in permeability, accompanied by the typical increase in selectivity that tends to move the data parallel to the upper Robeson limits.
- Open Access
Thermally Rearranged Mixed Matrix Membranes from Copoly(o-hydroxyamide)s and Copoly(o-hydroxyamide-amide)s with a Porous Polymer Network as a Filler—A Comparison of Their Gas Separation Performances
Copoly(o-hydroxyamide)s (HPA) and copoly(o-hydroxyamide-amide)s (PAA) have been synthesized to be used as continuous phases in mixed matrix membranes (MMMs). These polymeric matrices were blended with different loads (15 and 30 wt.%) of a relatively highly microporous porous polymer network (PPN). SEM images of the manufactured MMMs exhibited good compatibility between the two phases for all the membranes studied, and their mechanical properties have been shown to be good enough even after thermal treatment. The WAX results show that the addition of PPN as a filler up to 30% does not substantially change the intersegmental distance and the polymer packing. It seems that, for all the membranes studied, the free volume that determines gas transport is in the high end of the possible range. This means that gas flow occurs mainly between the microvoids in the polymer matrix around the filler. In general, both HPA- and PAA-based MMMs exhibited a notable improvement in gas permeability, due to the presence of PPN, for all gases tested, with an almost constant selectivity. In summary, although the thermal stability of the PAA is limited by the thermal stability of the polyamide side chain, their mechanical properties were better. The permeability was higher for the PAA membranes before their thermal rearrangement, and these values increased after the addition of moderate amounts of PPN.
Open AccessThermally Rearranged Mixed Matrix Membranes from Copoly(o-hydroxyamide)s and Copoly(o-hydroxyamide-amide)s with a Porous Polymer Network as a Filler—A Comparison of Their Gas Separation Performances
Copoly(o-hydroxyamide)s (HPA) and copoly(o-hydroxyamide-amide)s (PAA) have been synthesized to be used as continuous phases in mixed matrix membranes (MMMs). These polymeric matrices were blended with different loads (15 and 30 wt.%) of a relatively highly microporous porous polymer network (PPN). SEM images of the manufactured MMMs exhibited good compatibility between the two phases for all the membranes studied, and their mechanical properties have been shown to be good enough even after thermal treatment. The WAX results show that the addition of PPN as a filler up to 30% does not substantially change the intersegmental distance and the polymer packing. It seems that, for all the membranes studied, the free volume that determines gas transport is in the high end of the possible range. This means that gas flow occurs mainly between the microvoids in the polymer matrix around the filler. In general, both HPA- and PAA-based MMMs exhibited a notable improvement in gas permeability, due to the presence of PPN, for all gases tested, with an almost constant selectivity. In summary, although the thermal stability of the PAA is limited by the thermal stability of the polyamide side chain, their mechanical properties were better. The permeability was higher for the PAA membranes before their thermal rearrangement, and these values increased after the addition of moderate amounts of PPN.
- Open Access
Thin Film Composite Membranes Based on the Polymer of Intrinsic Microporosity PIM-EA(Me2)-TB Blended with Matrimid®5218
In this work, thin film composite (TFC) membranes were fabricated with the selective layer based on a blend of polyimide Matrimid®5218 and polymer of intrinsic microporosity (PIM) composed of Tröger’s base, TB, and dimethylethanoanthracene units, PIM-EA(Me2)-TB. The TFCs were prepared with different ratios of the two polymers and the effect of the PIM content in the blend of the gas transport properties was studied for pure He, H2, O2, N2, CH4, and CO2 using the well-known time lag method. The prepared TFC membranes were further characterized by IR spectroscopy and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The role of the support properties for the TFC membrane preparation was analysed for four different commercial porous supports (Nanostone Water PV 350, Vladipor Fluoroplast 50, Synder PAN 30 kDa, and Sulzer PAN UF). The Sulzer PAN UF support with a relatively small pore size favoured the formation of a defect-free dense layer. All the TFC membranes supported on Sulzer PAN UF presented a synergistic enhancement in CO2 permeance, and CO2/CH4 and CO2/N2 ideal selectivity. The permeance increased about two orders of magnitude with respect to neat Matrimid, up to ca. 100 GPU, the ideal CO2/CH4 selectivity increased from approximately 10 to 14, and the CO2/N2 selectivity from approximately 20 to 26 compared to the thick dense reference membrane of PIM-EA(Me2)-TB. The TFC membranes exhibited lower CO2 permeances than expected on the basis of their thickness—most likely due to enhanced aging of thin films and to the low surface porosity of the support membrane, but a higher selectivity for the gas pairs CO2/N2, CO2/CH4, O2/N2, and H2/N2.
Open AccessThin Film Composite Membranes Based on the Polymer of Intrinsic Microporosity PIM-EA(Me2)-TB Blended with Matrimid®5218
In this work, thin film composite (TFC) membranes were fabricated with the selective layer based on a blend of polyimide Matrimid®5218 and polymer of intrinsic microporosity (PIM) composed of Tröger’s base, TB, and dimethylethanoanthracene units, PIM-EA(Me2)-TB. The TFCs were prepared with different ratios of the two polymers and the effect of the PIM content in the blend of the gas transport properties was studied for pure He, H2, O2, N2, CH4, and CO2 using the well-known time lag method. The prepared TFC membranes were further characterized by IR spectroscopy and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The role of the support properties for the TFC membrane preparation was analysed for four different commercial porous supports (Nanostone Water PV 350, Vladipor Fluoroplast 50, Synder PAN 30 kDa, and Sulzer PAN UF). The Sulzer PAN UF support with a relatively small pore size favoured the formation of a defect-free dense layer. All the TFC membranes supported on Sulzer PAN UF presented a synergistic enhancement in CO2 permeance, and CO2/CH4 and CO2/N2 ideal selectivity. The permeance increased about two orders of magnitude with respect to neat Matrimid, up to ca. 100 GPU, the ideal CO2/CH4 selectivity increased from approximately 10 to 14, and the CO2/N2 selectivity from approximately 20 to 26 compared to the thick dense reference membrane of PIM-EA(Me2)-TB. The TFC membranes exhibited lower CO2 permeances than expected on the basis of their thickness—most likely due to enhanced aging of thin films and to the low surface porosity of the support membrane, but a higher selectivity for the gas pairs CO2/N2, CO2/CH4, O2/N2, and H2/N2.
- Open Access
- 25 February 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 12 (5) , 2391
Biodegradable Solvents: A Promising Tool to Recover Proteins from Microalgae
The world will face a significant protein demand in the next few decades, and due to the environmental concerns linked to animal protein, new sustainable protein sources must be found. In this regard, microalgae stand as an outstanding high-quality protein source. However, different steps are needed to separate the proteins from the microalgae biomass and other biocompounds. The protein recovery from the disrupted biomass is usually the bottleneck of the process, and it typically employs organic solvents or harsh conditions, which are both detrimental to protein stability and planet health. Different techniques and methods are applied for protein recovery from various matrices, such as precipitation, filtration, chromatography, electrophoresis, and solvent extraction. Those methods will be reviewed in this work, discussing their advantages, drawbacks, and applicability to the microalgae biorefinery process. Special attention will be paid to solvent extraction performed with ionic liquids (ILs) and deep eutectic solvents (DESs), which stand as promising solvents to perform efficient protein separations with reduced environmental costs compared to classical alternatives. Finally, several solvent recovery options will be analyzed to reuse the solvent employed and isolate the proteins from the solvent phase.
- 25 February 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 12 (5) , 2391
Open AccessBiodegradable Solvents: A Promising Tool to Recover Proteins from Microalgae
The world will face a significant protein demand in the next few decades, and due to the environmental concerns linked to animal protein, new sustainable protein sources must be found. In this regard, microalgae stand as an outstanding high-quality protein source. However, different steps are needed to separate the proteins from the microalgae biomass and other biocompounds. The protein recovery from the disrupted biomass is usually the bottleneck of the process, and it typically employs organic solvents or harsh conditions, which are both detrimental to protein stability and planet health. Different techniques and methods are applied for protein recovery from various matrices, such as precipitation, filtration, chromatography, electrophoresis, and solvent extraction. Those methods will be reviewed in this work, discussing their advantages, drawbacks, and applicability to the microalgae biorefinery process. Special attention will be paid to solvent extraction performed with ionic liquids (ILs) and deep eutectic solvents (DESs), which stand as promising solvents to perform efficient protein separations with reduced environmental costs compared to classical alternatives. Finally, several solvent recovery options will be analyzed to reuse the solvent employed and isolate the proteins from the solvent phase.
- Open Access
Polymer Membranes for Gas Separation
Over the past decade, polymeric membranes have been widely investigated for a variety of industrial gas separation applications
Open AccessPolymer Membranes for Gas Separation
Over the past decade, polymeric membranes have been widely investigated for a variety of industrial gas separation applications
- Open Access
Gas Permeability, Fractional Free Volume and Molecular Kinetic Diameters: The Effect of Thermal Rearrangement on ortho-hydroxy Polyamide Membranes Loaded with a Porous Polymer Network
Mixed-matrix membranes (MMMs) consisting of an ortho-hydroxy polyamide (HPA) matrix, and variable loads of a porous polymer network (PPN) were thermally treated to induce the transformation of HPA to polybenzoxazole (β-TR-PBO). Two different HPAs were synthesized to be used as a matrix, 6FCl-APAF and tBTpCl-APAF, while the PPN used as a filler was prepared by reacting triptycene and trifluoroacetophenone. The permeability of He, H2, N2, O2, CH4 and CO2 gases through these MMMs are analyzed as a function of the fraction of free volume (FFV) of the membrane and the kinetic diameter of the gas, allowing for the evaluation of the free volume. Thermal rearrangement entails an increase in the FFV. Both before and after thermal rearrangement, the free volume increases with the PPN content very similarly for both polymeric matrices. It is shown that there is a portion of free volume that is inaccessible to permeation (occluded volume), probably due to it being trapped within the filler. In fact, permeability and selectivity change below what could be expected according to densities, when the fraction of occluded volume increases. A higher filler load increases the percentage of inaccessible or trapped free volume, probably due to the increasing agglomeration of the filler. On the other hand, the phenomenon is slightly affected by thermal rearrangement. The fraction of trapped free volume seems to be lower for membranes in which the tBTpCl-APAF is used as a matrix than for those with a 6FCl-APAF matrix, possibly because tBTpCl-APAF could approach the PPN better. The application of an effective medium theory for permeability allowed us to extrapolate for a 100% filler, giving the same value for both thermally rearranged and non-rearranged MMMs. The pure filler could also be extrapolated by assuming the same tendency as in the Robeson’s plots for MMMs with low filler content.
Open AccessGas Permeability, Fractional Free Volume and Molecular Kinetic Diameters: The Effect of Thermal Rearrangement on ortho-hydroxy Polyamide Membranes Loaded with a Porous Polymer Network
Mixed-matrix membranes (MMMs) consisting of an ortho-hydroxy polyamide (HPA) matrix, and variable loads of a porous polymer network (PPN) were thermally treated to induce the transformation of HPA to polybenzoxazole (β-TR-PBO). Two different HPAs were synthesized to be used as a matrix, 6FCl-APAF and tBTpCl-APAF, while the PPN used as a filler was prepared by reacting triptycene and trifluoroacetophenone. The permeability of He, H2, N2, O2, CH4 and CO2 gases through these MMMs are analyzed as a function of the fraction of free volume (FFV) of the membrane and the kinetic diameter of the gas, allowing for the evaluation of the free volume. Thermal rearrangement entails an increase in the FFV. Both before and after thermal rearrangement, the free volume increases with the PPN content very similarly for both polymeric matrices. It is shown that there is a portion of free volume that is inaccessible to permeation (occluded volume), probably due to it being trapped within the filler. In fact, permeability and selectivity change below what could be expected according to densities, when the fraction of occluded volume increases. A higher filler load increases the percentage of inaccessible or trapped free volume, probably due to the increasing agglomeration of the filler. On the other hand, the phenomenon is slightly affected by thermal rearrangement. The fraction of trapped free volume seems to be lower for membranes in which the tBTpCl-APAF is used as a matrix than for those with a 6FCl-APAF matrix, possibly because tBTpCl-APAF could approach the PPN better. The application of an effective medium theory for permeability allowed us to extrapolate for a 100% filler, giving the same value for both thermally rearranged and non-rearranged MMMs. The pure filler could also be extrapolated by assuming the same tendency as in the Robeson’s plots for MMMs with low filler content.