SSSana Saeed

Sana Saeed

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Sana Saeed has a total of 75 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Perspectives of faculty, students and patients on clinical skills teaching in undergraduate medical education in Pakistan: a qualitative study

    by Fadieleh A Sohail, Marium Iqbal, Marib Ghulam Rasool Malik, Sana Saeed

    Objectives: To explore the challenges and opportunities in clinical skills teaching and learning among faculty, final-year medical students and patients at a private medical university in Pakistan, within the context of a low- and middle-income country (LMIC) medical education system. Design: An exploratory descriptive qualitative design using inductive thematic analysis utilising in-depth interviews and focus group discussions, framed within a metaphorical lens. Setting: A single private-sector tertiary care teaching hospital and affiliated undergraduate medical college in an urban setting in Pakistan. Participants: A total of 48 participants were included in the study: 12 clinical faculty members representing various disciplines and levels of experience, 16 final-year medical students and 10 house officers and 10 patients from adult inpatient wards. Participants were purposively selected to ensure maximum variation in perspectives. Results: Six key metaphorical themes emerged, each reflecting both the challenges and opportunities within the clinical learning journey: (1) The Safety Harness—simulation as an opportunity for structured, risk-free skill development, yet limited by authenticity; (2) The Underwater Life—the irreplaceable but unpredictable nature of bedside learning in fostering empathy and communication; (3) The Stormy Seas—systemic and cultural barriers such as patient availability, gender constraints and limited faculty resources; (4) The Ship—students navigating self-development amid evolving expectations, digital distractions and shifting motivations; (5) The Engine Room Tools—balancing diverse teaching modalities while seeking optimal time distribution between simulation and bedside learning; and (6) The Guiding Compass—the pivotal role of clinical teachers as mentors and professional exemplars. Triangulated perspectives revealed that while structured simulation and bedside experiences complement one another, significant institutional, ethical and pedagogical challenges persist, many amplified by the realities of resource-limited LMIC settings. Conclusions: This study underscores the complexities of clinical teaching and learning in an LMIC context, highlighting the need for a balanced, context-sensitive model that integrates simulation with authentic bedside exposure, supported by mentorship and reflective practice. Addressing structural and faculty-related barriers is essential to advancing equitable, patient-centred clinical education in resource-constrained environments.


  • Open Access

    Assessing the impact of faculty development workshops: a change initiative in medical education in Pakistan

    by Tabassum Zehra, Sana Saeed, Marib Ghulam Rasool Malik, Rahila Ali, Amber Sultan, Muhammed Tariq

    Faculty development is pivotal to enhancing pedagogical skills among health professionals. The current cross-sectional study was planned to evaluate satisfaction as well as short-term and long-term impacts of faculty development workshops on academic practices through a continuous faculty development programme. Data was collected through post-workshop evaluations, and follow-up questionnaires. Over four years, 28 workshops engaged 164 participants. High satisfaction was reported, with 65(76.5%) to 76(89.4%) strongly agreeing on factors, like gaining new knowledge, clarity, relevance and participation. Most respondents of the follow-up questionnaire reported fair to great eagerness for further learning 44(91.7%). Perceived challenges included preoccupation with work commitments 30(62.5%) and lack of institutional support 18(39.6%). Positive correlations highlighted the link between workshop satisfaction and self-reported change. Key Words: Health professional education, Medical education, Medical educators, Teachers.

  • Open Access

    Role play versus video-based learning for interprofessional communication and teamwork skills in nursing and medical students: a mixed-methods study in Pakistan

    by Syed Muhammad Azfar, Sana Saeed, Sadia Masood, Syeda Rubaba Azim, Mukhtiar Baig, Marib Ghulam Rasool Malik

    Effective interprofessional communication (IPC) is crucial for patient safety. However, IPC training is often insufficient in medical and nursing education in Pakistan. This study compares the effectiveness of Video-Based Learning (VBL) and Role Play (RP) in enhancing IPC and teamwork skills among undergraduate medical and nursing students. A mixed-method approach encompassed a quasi-experimental design with focused group discussions. 64 participants were randomly divided into two groups (n = 32 each), each receiving training through either VBL or RP. The study employed the Communication and Teamwork Skills (CATS) assessment instrument utilized by two independent raters to evaluate improvements in coordination, situational awareness, cooperation, and communication skills before and after the interventions. Additionally, focus group discussions provided qualitative insights regarding the teaching strategies. Both RP and VBL significantly improved IPC and teamwork skills compared to baseline. RP showed greater enhancements across coordination, cooperation, and situational awareness compared to VBL. (p < 0.001). In the VBL group, significant improvements were observed in coordination (pre: 5.46 ± 1.93, post: 7.90 ± 2.50, p < 0.001), situational awareness (pre: 2.62 ± 1.07, post: 3.68 ± 1.78, p = 0.006), and communication (pre: 4.75 ± 3.57, post: 11.28 ± 3.72, p < 0.001), but not in cooperation (pre: 7.06 ± 3.24, post: 8.21 ± 2.57, p = 0.119). The RP group showed significant improvements in coordination (pre: 6.28 ± 2.58, post: 12.40 ± 2.62, p < 0.001), situational awareness (pre: 3.06 ± 2.21, post: 5.65 ± 1.51, p < 0.001), cooperation (pre: 8.09 ± 4.07, post: 13.46 ± 3.58, p < 0.001), and communication (pre: 4.25 ± 4.22, post: 13.15 ± 6.33, p < 0.001). Qualitatively, both methods were perceived as engaging and interactive, with the hands-on component in RP regarded by the participants as very valuable to actively practice their skills in a simulated environment. RP significantly outperforms VBL in enhancing IPC and teamwork skills, making it a superior tool for healthcare education. The findings suggest that RP’s practical, interactive nature makes it a more effective tool for teaching IPC and teamwork in medical and nursing education. Integrating RP activities into the curriculum could enhance communication and teamwork skills among students. Evaluating the longitudinal impact of this integration on patient care could be an area for future research.


  • Open Access

    Cultivating compassion in care: evaluating a compassion-training intervention and exploring barriers to compassionate care in postgraduate medical education in Pakistan: a mixed-methods study

    by Marib Ghulam Rasool Malik, Sana Saeed, Bisma Aziz, Shahzil Abdur Rehman Malik, Syed Ahsan Ali, Fareed Shaikh, Shahzadi Resham, Amna Subhan Butt, Qamar Riaz

    Compassionate patient care is essential for improving patient outcomes and enhancing healthcare experience. However, in lower-middle-income countries (LMICs) like Pakistan, systemic barriers and a lack of structured curricula hinder its consistent delivery. This study evaluates a targeted compassion-training intervention for residents in a tertiary care hospital and explores barriers to its implementation. Given shared challenges like resource constraints, high patient loads, and gaps in formal training, these findings have broader implications for integrating structured compassion-based education across LMICs. This quasi-experimental mixed-methods study was conducted with first-year residents over a one-year period (November 2023 - October 2024). A 4-hour compassion-training session was delivered to develop compassion as a clinical competency. Quantitative data on satisfaction and self-reported compassion competence were collected using the Sinclair Compassion Questionnaire-Healthcare Provider Competence Self-Assessment (SCQ-HCPCSA) and analyzed via paired t-tests. Qualitative data from focused group discussions (FGDs) exploring barriers and facilitators underwent thematic analysis. 204 residents participated. Baseline compassion competence was 4.03 ± 0.54, with no demographic variations (p > 0.05). Participants rated sessions highly for interest (4.54 ± 0.65), relevance (4.50 ± 0.82), and interactivity (4.68 ± 0.61). Post-training, compassion competence significantly improved to 4.58 ± 0.47 (p < 0.001), with all SCQ-HCPCSA items showing significant improvements (p < 0.001). Qualitative findings revealed key barriers to practicing compassionate care, including time constraints, high workloads, and compassion fatigue, particularly in high-pressure specialties like surgery and intensive care. Institutional factors like documentation inefficiencies, financial pressures, and hierarchical workplace culture also limit compassionate care delivery. Culturally specific challenges emerged, including language barriers, differences in patient expectations, and perceptions of compassion as a transactional service in a largely out-of-pocket healthcare system. Facilitators of compassionate care included interdisciplinary collaboration, supportive senior staff, and effective communication strategies. Targeted compassion-training interventions can enhance compassionate care among physicians. To ensure long-term impact, postgraduate medical education programs should formally integrate structured curricula, alongside institutional policy reforms that reduce administrative burdens and promote interdisciplinary collaboration. Future studies should explore long-term retention of training effects and assess scalability of similar curricula across diverse healthcare settings, particularly in other lower-middle-income countries. Not applicable.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Navigating the integration of artificial intelligence in the medical education curriculum: a mixed-methods study exploring the perspectives of medical students and faculty in Pakistan

    by Muhammad Ahsan Naseer, Sana Saeed, Azam Afzal, Sobia Ali, Marib Ghulam Rasool Malik

    The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into medical education is poised to revolutionize teaching, learning, and clinical practice. However, successful implementation of AI-based tools in medical curricula faces several challenges, particularly in resource-limited settings like Pakistan, where technological and institutional barriers remain significant. This study aimed to evaluate knowledge, attitudes, and practices of medical students and faculty regarding AI in medical education, and explore the perceptions and key barriers regarding strategies for effective AI integration. A concurrent mixed-methods study was conducted over six months (July 2023 to January 2024) at a tertiary care medical college in Pakistan. The quantitative component utilized a cross-sectional design, with 236 participants (153 medical students and 83 faculty members) completing an online survey. Mean composite scores for knowledge, attitudes, and practices were analyzed using non-parametric tests. The qualitative component consisted of three focus group discussions with students and six in-depth interviews with faculty. Thematic analysis was performed to explore participants’ perspectives on AI integration. Majority of participants demonstrated a positive attitude towards AI integration. Faculty had significantly higher mean attitude scores compared to students (3.95 ± 0.63 vs. 3.81 ± 0.75, p = 0.040). However, no statistically significant differences in knowledge (faculty: 3.53 ± 0.66, students: 3.55 ± 0.73, p = 0.870) or practices (faculty: 3.19 ± 0.87, students: 3.23 ± 0.89, p = 0.891) were found. Older students reported greater self-perceived knowledge (p = 0.010) and more positive attitudes (p = 0.016) towards AI, while male students exhibited higher knowledge scores than females (p = 0.025). Qualitative findings revealed key themes, including AI’s potential to enhance learning and research, concerns about over-reliance on AI, ethical issues surrounding privacy and confidentiality, and the need for institutional support. Faculty emphasized the importance of training to equip educators with the necessary skills to effectively integrate AI into their teaching. This study highlights both the enthusiasm for AI integration and the significant barriers that must be addressed to successfully implement AI in medical education. Addressing technological constraints, providing faculty training, and developing ethical guidelines are critical steps toward fostering the responsible use of AI in medical curricula. These findings underscore the need for context-specific strategies, particularly in resource-limited settings, to ensure that medical students and educators are well-prepared for the future of healthcare.


    • 1 January 2025
      • Vol. 13  (1) , 49-58
    Open Access

    Transforming Education: Case-Based Integrated Learning Development and Implementation - A Mixed Methods Study at a Private Medical College.

    by Rahila Ali, Azam Afzal, Sara Shakil, Amber Sultan, Shazia Babar, Javeria Rehman, Marib Ghulam Rasool Malik, Mohammad Shahzaib Qadir, Sadaf Khan, Sana Saeed

    Case-based learning (CBL) is widely used in medical education to bridge theory and practice, but traditional methods often struggle to sustain student engagement and promote critical thinking. To address these challenges, Case-Based Integrated Learning (CBIL) was developed as a novel approach combining immersive and interactive learning techniques. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of CBIL in enhancing engagement, critical thinking, and clinical reasoning among medical students, and explore faculty experiences regarding the pedagogy. An explanatory-sequential mixed-methods study was conducted in a private medical college in Pakistan. Quantitative data were collected through faculty (n=35) and student (n=122) evaluation surveys, and analyzed using descriptive statistics (mean, standard deviation, frequencies, and percentages). Qualitative data from focused group discussions (FGD) with faculty were analyzed thematically. A committee of clinical faculty and medical educationists developed four CBIL prototypes. Faculty from various clinical specialties were trained on CBIL concepts and lesson planning, and the prototypes were used to develop engaging cases for subsequent sessions. Participants included faculty from diverse disciplines and students in their third and fourth years of medical school. The faculty considered the training very effective (overall satisfaction 5.17±0.89 out of 6), with a vast majority being very satisfied with its relevance (86%, n=30) and structure (91%, n=32). Among students, 95% (n=116) were satisfied with the developed cases. Most of them were also satisfied with the clarity (92%, n=112) and applicability of the cases (96%, n=117). In FGD, facilitators expressed satisfaction with CBIL formats as it provided opportunities for engagement, in-depth analyses, and discussions. Interactive formats like CBIL can engage students by allowing opportunities for interaction, discussion, and peer-learning. This promotes improved understanding and critical thinking. Further exploration of the effectiveness and impacts on the learning of various interactive formats of case-based learning is essential.


  • Open Access

    Using School-Based Teleconsultation Services to Make Community Health Services Accessible in Semirural Settings of Pakistan: Sequential Explanatory Mixed Methods Study

    by Saleema Gulzar, Shirin Rahim, Khadija Dossa, Sana Saeed, Insiyah Agha, Shariq Khoja, Rozina Karmaliani

    Background: In Pakistan’s remote areas, quality health care and experienced professionals are scarce. Telehealth can bridge this gap by offering innovative services like teleconsultations. Schools can serve as effective platforms for introducing these services, significantly improving health service access in semirural communities. Objective: This study aims to explore the feasibility of introducing school-based teleconsultation services (TCS) to strengthen community health in a semirural area of Karachi, Pakistan. Methods: This study used a mixed methods design. A total of 393 students were enrolled for the quantitative component, while 35 parents, teachers, and community stakeholders participated in the qualitative arm (focused group discussion). Proportional computation for the quantitative data was done using SPSS (version 24; IBM Corp), while qualitative data underwent thematic analysis. Results: A total of 1046 successful teleconsultations were provided for 393 students over 28 months. The demographic data showed that the mean age of the students availing TCS was 9.24 (SD 3.25) years, with the majority being males (59.3%, 233/393). Only 1.24% (13/1046) of cases required referrals. The qualitative analysis yielded three themes: (1) transformation of the health care experience, (2) escalating demands for teleconsultation, and (3) the psychological aspect of care. Conclusions: This study demonstrated the efficacy of integrating TCS in a semiurban school in Karachi to address health care accessibility gaps. Implementing TCS through the school platform improved the overall health status of school children while reducing school absences and financial burdens on families. The study highlighted TCS’s cost-effectiveness, time efficiency, and quality, with community support for 24/7 availability, expansion to adults, and a reimbursement model. School health nurse-led TCS offers a scalable solution to health care challenges, enhancing health outcomes for school-going children in Pakistan and globally, particularly in low- and middle-income countries, where accessibility is a major issue.


  • Open Access

    Transforming the delivery of care from “I” to “We” by developing the crisis resource management skills in pediatric interprofessional teams to handle common emergencies through simulation

    by Sana Saeed, Nagwa Nashat Hegazy, Marib Ghulam Rasool Malik, Qalab Abbas, Huba Atiq, Muhammad Maisam Ali, Aashir Aslam, Yasmin Hashwani, Farzana Bashir Ahmed

    Background: The healthcare system is highly complex, and adverse events often result from a combination of human factors and system failures, especially in crisis situations. Crisis resource management skills are crucial to optimize team performance and patient outcomes in such situations. Simulation-based training offers a promising approach to developing such skills in a controlled and realistic environment. Methods: This study employed a mixed-methods (quantitative-qualitative) design and aimed to assess the effectiveness of a simulation-based training workshop in developing crisis resource management skills in pediatric interprofessional teams at a tertiary care hospital. The effectiveness of the intervention was evaluated using Kirkpatrick’s Model, focusing on reaction and learning levels, employing the Collaboration and Satisfaction about Care Decisions scale, Clinical Teamwork Scale, and Ottawa Global Rating Scale for pre- and post-intervention assessments. Focused group discussions were conducted with the participants to explore their experiences and perceptions of the training. Results: Thirty-nine participants, including medical students, nurses, and residents, participated in the study. Compared to the participants’ pre-workshop performance, significant improvements were observed across all measured teamwork and performance components after the workshop, including improvement in scores in team communication (3.16 ± 1.20 to 7.61 ± 1.0, p < 0.001), decision-making (3.50 ± 1.54 to 7.16 ± 1.42, p < 0.001), leadership skills (2.50 ± 1.04 to 5.44 ± 0.6, p < 0.001), and situation awareness (2.61 ± 1.13 to 5.22 ± 0.80, p < 0.001). No significant variations were observed post-intervention among the different teams. Additionally, participants reported high levels of satisfaction, perceived the training to be highly valuable in improving their crisis resource management skills, and emphasized the importance of role allocation and debriefing. Conclusions: The study underscores the effectiveness of simulation-based training in developing crisis resource management skills in pediatric interprofessional teams. The findings suggest that such training can impact learning transfer to the workplace and ultimately improve patient outcomes. The insights from our study offer additional valuable considerations for the ongoing refinement of simulation-based training programs. There is a need to develop more comprehensive clinical skills evaluation methods to better assess the transferability of these skills in real-world settings. The potential challenges unveiled in our study, such as physical exhaustion during training, must be considered when refining and designing such interventions.


  • Open Access

    Barriers to medical consultation and strategies for enhancing the prevention and reporting of child abuse: a cross-sectional survey of caregivers of paediatric patients at a tertiary care center in Karachi, Pakistan

    by Sana Saeed, Mohammad Umer Junaid, Marib Ghulam Rasool Malik, Hareem Rauf, Muhammad Osama Khan, Kishwar Enam

    Review articles highlighting importance of various issues in the domain of public health, drug and medical education

  • Open Access

    Care for the caregiver: an exploration of caregiver burden of children with chronic medical conditions at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi, Pakistan – a mixed-methods study

    by Sana Saeed, Marib Ghulam Rasool Malik, Maryam Hameed Khan, Shahzil Abdur Rehman Malik, Bisma Aziz

    Objectives Caregiver burden often goes unrecognised and can substantially affect caregivers’ physical, psychological and financial well-being, thereby impacting quality of care. This study investigates burden among caregivers of children with chronic medical conditions in a tertiary care hospital in Pakistan. The study aims to assess the extent of burden, explore influencing factors and recommendations for interventions. Design Mixed-methods study, comprising of an in-person paper-based survey, employing the Zarit Burden Interview scale to assess burden scores. Qualitative component included thematic analysis of semi-structured in-depth interviews with caregivers. Participants 383 caregivers of children admitted to the inpatient paediatric services at our tertiary care centre were surveyed. In-depth interviews were conducted with 19 caregivers. Results The survey revealed a mean burden score of 35.35±15.14, with nearly half of the participants (46%, n=177) experiencing mild burden, while 37% (n=140) reporting moderate-to-severe burden. The most common diagnosis was cancer (24%, n=92), while the highest burden (42.97±15.47) was noted for congenital cardiac disease. Greater burden was significantly associated with lower caregiver education, young age of the child at diagnosis and increased number of hospital visits (pConclusions The study elucidates the multifaceted nature of caregiver burden in the context of paediatric chronic illnesses in Pakistan. Interventions should emphasise financial aid, educational support and development of system-level changes to improve access to resources and medical care coordination. These insights call for policy and practice integration to support caregivers effectively.