Joost M. Tinbergen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Joost M. Tinbergen has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alexia Mouchet
Department of Evolutionary Biology and Environmental Studies University of Zurich Zürich Switzerland
1 shared publication - Allison M. Roth
Department of Biology, McGill University, Montreal, QC, H3A 1B1, Canada
1 shared publication Christiaan Both
Conservation Ecology Group, Groningen Institute for Evolutionary Life Sciences (GELIFES), University of Groningen, P.O. Box 11103, Groningen, The Netherlands
1 shared publicationElla F. Cole
Edward Grey Institute, Department of Zoology, University of Oxford, Oxford OX1 3PS, United Kingdom
1 shared publication- Erik Matthysen
Evolutionary Ecology Group, Department of Biology, University of Antwerp, Wilrijk, Belgium
1 shared publication I. Pen
Conservation Ecology Group, Groningen Inst. for Evolutionary Life Sciences (GELIFES), Univ. of Groningen Groningen the Netherlands
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 November 2024
- Published by Netherlands Ornithologists' Union in Ardea
- Vol. 112 (2) , 1-20
The Importance of Ambient Temperature Correction for Estimating Seasonality of Caterpillar Abundance Through Frass-Fall
Caterpillars are important as food for many insectivorous birds. Their availability is highly seasonal in temperate regions. Global warming is known to advance this seasonality and can change the selection pressure on the seasonal timing of avian reproduction. Time series on caterpillar abundance and timing are often based on quantifying caterpillar faeces (called frass). Accurate estimates of caterpillar abundance and timing within and between years require temperature correction, the topic of this study. To estimate caterpillar abundance, we measured the rate of caterpillar frass production under tree crowns. To calculate the frass to caterpillar biomass conversion factor we kept wild caught caterpillars of a number of abundant species in cages outside and fed them daily with fresh leaves (Quercus robur or Betula sp.) in two studies, Dwingelderveld (Dv) and Hoge Veluwe (HV), in different time periods. We monitored caterpillar body mass and frass production on a 24-h time base to calculate the conversion factor as a function of temperature, study site, tree species and caterpillar species. One study (HV) concerned a reanalysis of earlier published data. The conversion factor strongly depended on ambient temperature, almost doubling from around 8 to 15 when daily temperatures reduced from 15 to 10°C, and differed somewhat between study areas and caterpillar species. Yet in 20 of 34 published studies that estimated seasonality in caterpillar abundance on the basis of frass fall, temperature was not corrected for. We illustrate the importance of the temperature correction of frass to mass conversion factors by comparing variation in raw frass data and temperature corrected caterpillar biomass estimates during the spring for 12 nest boxes in 16 years in the Dwingelderveld. We advise temperature correction of frass fall based estimates of caterpillar abundance in woodland, preferably based on local measurements in the study area and period.
- 1 November 2024
- Published by Netherlands Ornithologists' Union in Ardea
- Vol. 112 (2) , 1-20
The Importance of Ambient Temperature Correction for Estimating Seasonality of Caterpillar Abundance Through Frass-Fall
Caterpillars are important as food for many insectivorous birds. Their availability is highly seasonal in temperate regions. Global warming is known to advance this seasonality and can change the selection pressure on the seasonal timing of avian reproduction. Time series on caterpillar abundance and timing are often based on quantifying caterpillar faeces (called frass). Accurate estimates of caterpillar abundance and timing within and between years require temperature correction, the topic of this study. To estimate caterpillar abundance, we measured the rate of caterpillar frass production under tree crowns. To calculate the frass to caterpillar biomass conversion factor we kept wild caught caterpillars of a number of abundant species in cages outside and fed them daily with fresh leaves (Quercus robur or Betula sp.) in two studies, Dwingelderveld (Dv) and Hoge Veluwe (HV), in different time periods. We monitored caterpillar body mass and frass production on a 24-h time base to calculate the conversion factor as a function of temperature, study site, tree species and caterpillar species. One study (HV) concerned a reanalysis of earlier published data. The conversion factor strongly depended on ambient temperature, almost doubling from around 8 to 15 when daily temperatures reduced from 15 to 10°C, and differed somewhat between study areas and caterpillar species. Yet in 20 of 34 published studies that estimated seasonality in caterpillar abundance on the basis of frass fall, temperature was not corrected for. We illustrate the importance of the temperature correction of frass to mass conversion factors by comparing variation in raw frass data and temperature corrected caterpillar biomass estimates during the spring for 12 nest boxes in 16 years in the Dwingelderveld. We advise temperature correction of frass fall based estimates of caterpillar abundance in woodland, preferably based on local measurements in the study area and period.
- 7 July 2021
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 118 (28)
Heterogeneous selection on exploration behavior within and among West European populations of a passerine bird
Significance: A key question in behavioral ecology is whether individual differences in behavior are adaptive rather than merely representing “noise around an adaptive mean.” We show strong evidence for spatial and temporal variation in survival and recruitment selection both within and among West European great tit ( Parus major ) populations, implying that spatiotemporal variation in environmental conditions contributes to the maintenance of animal personality variation. The majority of the variance in selection was attributable to large-scale geographical variation, selecting for local adaptation in behavior. Temporal variation was also important, counteracting spatially driven local adaptation. Our study thereby demonstrates the importance of acknowledging both large- and small-scale geographical and temporal variation to understand the biological processes maintaining variation in animal behavior.
- 7 July 2021
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 118 (28)
Heterogeneous selection on exploration behavior within and among West European populations of a passerine bird
Significance: A key question in behavioral ecology is whether individual differences in behavior are adaptive rather than merely representing “noise around an adaptive mean.” We show strong evidence for spatial and temporal variation in survival and recruitment selection both within and among West European great tit ( Parus major ) populations, implying that spatiotemporal variation in environmental conditions contributes to the maintenance of animal personality variation. The majority of the variance in selection was attributable to large-scale geographical variation, selecting for local adaptation in behavior. Temporal variation was also important, counteracting spatially driven local adaptation. Our study thereby demonstrates the importance of acknowledging both large- and small-scale geographical and temporal variation to understand the biological processes maintaining variation in animal behavior.
- Open Access
- 18 July 2019
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Avian Biology
- Vol. 50 (8)
Sea buckthorn berries Hippophae rhamnoides L. predict size and composition of a great tit population Parus major L
In seasonal environments variation in food abundance in the non‐breeding season is thought to affect songbird population dynamics. In a unique tit‐sea buckthorn berry system we can estimate the berry abundance and both the tit consumption and population dynamics. Six hundred nest boxes were available to great and blue tits Cyanistes caeruleus for breeding in spring and roosting in winter. We followed the dynamics including the recapture histories of individually marked great tits from 2008 to 2014. In each year we estimated 1) the winter sea buckthorn berry availability, 2) an index of berry consumption in December based on the colour of the faeces of roosting birds, 3) the number of breeding great and blue tits, 4) both recapture probability and the return rate of the great tits and 5) immigration rates. December berry abundance positively predicted the number of breeding pairs of both species in the subsequent season and great tit return rates in the second half of the winter. There was support for a sex specific berry effect on the adult return rate in the great tit: female return rate was associated less strongly to berry abundance than male return rate. This skewed the sex ratio of the local breeders in the following breeding season. Intriguingly, annual berry consumption in December was not related to berry abundance, and individuals consuming more berries tended to have slightly lower return rates. Reproductive rate was not related to berry abundance. There was hardly support for a relation between immigration rates of first year breeders and berry abundance. Taken together these results imply that berry stock not only affected population size but also the population composition through sex specific exchange with the surroundings. Since population density covaried with berry abundance, density dependent effects provide an alternative explanation for the patterns observed.
- 18 July 2019
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Avian Biology
- Vol. 50 (8)
Open AccessSea buckthorn berries Hippophae rhamnoides L. predict size and composition of a great tit population Parus major L
In seasonal environments variation in food abundance in the non‐breeding season is thought to affect songbird population dynamics. In a unique tit‐sea buckthorn berry system we can estimate the berry abundance and both the tit consumption and population dynamics. Six hundred nest boxes were available to great and blue tits Cyanistes caeruleus for breeding in spring and roosting in winter. We followed the dynamics including the recapture histories of individually marked great tits from 2008 to 2014. In each year we estimated 1) the winter sea buckthorn berry availability, 2) an index of berry consumption in December based on the colour of the faeces of roosting birds, 3) the number of breeding great and blue tits, 4) both recapture probability and the return rate of the great tits and 5) immigration rates. December berry abundance positively predicted the number of breeding pairs of both species in the subsequent season and great tit return rates in the second half of the winter. There was support for a sex specific berry effect on the adult return rate in the great tit: female return rate was associated less strongly to berry abundance than male return rate. This skewed the sex ratio of the local breeders in the following breeding season. Intriguingly, annual berry consumption in December was not related to berry abundance, and individuals consuming more berries tended to have slightly lower return rates. Reproductive rate was not related to berry abundance. There was hardly support for a relation between immigration rates of first year breeders and berry abundance. Taken together these results imply that berry stock not only affected population size but also the population composition through sex specific exchange with the surroundings. Since population density covaried with berry abundance, density dependent effects provide an alternative explanation for the patterns observed.
- 1 December 2016
- Published by Netherlands Ornithologists' Union in Ardea
- Vol. 104 (3) , 239-252
Local Black TernChlidonias nigerPopulation Trends in Relation to Nest Platform Provisioning
The population of Black Terns in The Netherlands strongly declined in the period from 1950 to 1980. In recent years numbers have been more stable. The supply of artificial nest platforms has successfully attracted breeding Black Terns, and 80% now breed on platforms. In this paper we describe the development in numbers and breeding success of a Black Tern population in The Netherlands over the period 1982–2015, where ample nest platforms have been supplied over time. Using this database we question whether we can increase the breeding population by supplying platforms. We are uncertain whether tern numbers responded to an increase in nest platforms, or whether researchers responded to an increase in tern numbers by putting out more nest platforms. We analyse (1) settlement and breeding success in relation to nesting substrate, (2) the covariation between breeding numbers and platform numbers over time and space, and (3) the density dependence of settlement and breeding success. Against this background we analyse whether the annual change in platform numbers is followed by a change in tern numbers, as would be expected if there was a causal link between the two. We show that in our study area reproduction on artificial platforms was higher than on natural substrate and that the tern population in the whole study area increased over the study period. This increase in numbers was associated with an increase in the number of platforms, as expected when platforms affect tern numbers. Settlement in the first year after introduction of the platforms was higher, but in later years there was no correlation between annual change in the number of platforms and annual change in the number of breeding pairs. We did not detect a decline in the number of fledglings produced per pair with increasing tern breeding density. In conclusion, although the general pattern suggests positive effects of platform numbers on tern numbers, we are strictly speaking not able to show that supplying nest platforms caused the increase in the local Black Tern population over the study period. The answer awaits large scale experiments with control areas and individually marked birds to quantify survival and dispersal.
- 1 December 2016
- Published by Netherlands Ornithologists' Union in Ardea
- Vol. 104 (3) , 239-252
Local Black TernChlidonias nigerPopulation Trends in Relation to Nest Platform Provisioning
The population of Black Terns in The Netherlands strongly declined in the period from 1950 to 1980. In recent years numbers have been more stable. The supply of artificial nest platforms has successfully attracted breeding Black Terns, and 80% now breed on platforms. In this paper we describe the development in numbers and breeding success of a Black Tern population in The Netherlands over the period 1982–2015, where ample nest platforms have been supplied over time. Using this database we question whether we can increase the breeding population by supplying platforms. We are uncertain whether tern numbers responded to an increase in nest platforms, or whether researchers responded to an increase in tern numbers by putting out more nest platforms. We analyse (1) settlement and breeding success in relation to nesting substrate, (2) the covariation between breeding numbers and platform numbers over time and space, and (3) the density dependence of settlement and breeding success. Against this background we analyse whether the annual change in platform numbers is followed by a change in tern numbers, as would be expected if there was a causal link between the two. We show that in our study area reproduction on artificial platforms was higher than on natural substrate and that the tern population in the whole study area increased over the study period. This increase in numbers was associated with an increase in the number of platforms, as expected when platforms affect tern numbers. Settlement in the first year after introduction of the platforms was higher, but in later years there was no correlation between annual change in the number of platforms and annual change in the number of breeding pairs. We did not detect a decline in the number of fledglings produced per pair with increasing tern breeding density. In conclusion, although the general pattern suggests positive effects of platform numbers on tern numbers, we are strictly speaking not able to show that supplying nest platforms caused the increase in the local Black Tern population over the study period. The answer awaits large scale experiments with control areas and individually marked birds to quantify survival and dispersal.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2009
- Published by Netherlands Ornithologists' Union in Ardea
- Vol. 97 (1) , 89-98
Ineividual variation in Parental Provisioning Behaviour Predicts Survival of Cape Gannet Chicks Under Poor Conditions
Cape Gannets Morus capensis are declining in numbers in all breeding colonies at the southern African west coast, potentially caused by deteriorating food availability. The behavioural responses of Individuals to changing conditions can provide insights into the mechanisms that drive population dynamics. We studied the relationship between parental provisioning behaviour and the breeding success of Cape Gannets breeding at Ichaboe Island (Namibia) in two years with different nesting success, to assess the potential role of variation in food availability in explaining variation in chick survival. in 2006/07 parents delayed the onset of breeding and visited nests at a lower frequency than in 2005/06, indicating that food availability was limited. Within the years Individual differences in provisioning rate but not in parental condition were associated with chick growth and survival. These associations remained present when controlling for seasonal changes. Predation, not starvation, was the main cause of mo...
- 1 April 2009
- Published by Netherlands Ornithologists' Union in Ardea
- Vol. 97 (1) , 89-98
Open AccessIneividual variation in Parental Provisioning Behaviour Predicts Survival of Cape Gannet Chicks Under Poor Conditions
Cape Gannets Morus capensis are declining in numbers in all breeding colonies at the southern African west coast, potentially caused by deteriorating food availability. The behavioural responses of Individuals to changing conditions can provide insights into the mechanisms that drive population dynamics. We studied the relationship between parental provisioning behaviour and the breeding success of Cape Gannets breeding at Ichaboe Island (Namibia) in two years with different nesting success, to assess the potential role of variation in food availability in explaining variation in chick survival. in 2006/07 parents delayed the onset of breeding and visited nests at a lower frequency than in 2005/06, indicating that food availability was limited. Within the years Individual differences in provisioning rate but not in parental condition were associated with chick growth and survival. These associations remained present when controlling for seasonal changes. Predation, not starvation, was the main cause of mo...
- 2 November 2005
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 74 (6) , 1112-1120
Biased estimates of fitness consequences of brood size manipulation through correlated effects on natal dispersal
Summary: Dispersal of parents and offspring in relation to manipulated brood size were analysed in the great titParus major(L.) to study the potential confusion between dispersal and survival. The study area consisted of eight woodlots interspersed with nonbreeding habitat. The maximum distance between nestboxes was 10 km. The brood size of pairs with similar clutch size and laying date was manipulated in 3 years when chicks were 2 days old (1995, 1997 and 1998). Three nestlings were removed from one and added to another brood while a third was kept as a control. Offspring were measured, weighed and marked and breeding birds were captured and marked to allow dispersal estimates. For the offspring, dispersal was estimated as the distance between the natal nestbox and the nestbox of first breeding (natal dispersal distance) and, for the parents, as the distance between breeding boxes in two subsequent seasons (breeding dispersal distance). Natal dispersal distance was positively affected by brood size manipulation. This effect was more pronounced in males than in females. Breeding dispersal distance was not affected by manipulation. The practical consequence of this finding is that fitness estimates used to measure selection on brood size did depend on the spatial scale of the study area. For the Lauwersmeer population measured selection pressure changed from positive to stabilizing when I restricted the spatial scale of recovery. Other brood size manipulation experiments may suffer from similar biases in their fitness estimates. The biological consequence of this finding is that, if clutch size has a heritable component, local adaptation of clutch size will depend on the spatial heterogeneity of the habitat.
- 2 November 2005
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 74 (6) , 1112-1120
Biased estimates of fitness consequences of brood size manipulation through correlated effects on natal dispersal
Summary: Dispersal of parents and offspring in relation to manipulated brood size were analysed in the great titParus major(L.) to study the potential confusion between dispersal and survival. The study area consisted of eight woodlots interspersed with nonbreeding habitat. The maximum distance between nestboxes was 10 km. The brood size of pairs with similar clutch size and laying date was manipulated in 3 years when chicks were 2 days old (1995, 1997 and 1998). Three nestlings were removed from one and added to another brood while a third was kept as a control. Offspring were measured, weighed and marked and breeding birds were captured and marked to allow dispersal estimates. For the offspring, dispersal was estimated as the distance between the natal nestbox and the nestbox of first breeding (natal dispersal distance) and, for the parents, as the distance between breeding boxes in two subsequent seasons (breeding dispersal distance). Natal dispersal distance was positively affected by brood size manipulation. This effect was more pronounced in males than in females. Breeding dispersal distance was not affected by manipulation. The practical consequence of this finding is that fitness estimates used to measure selection on brood size did depend on the spatial scale of the study area. For the Lauwersmeer population measured selection pressure changed from positive to stabilizing when I restricted the spatial scale of recovery. Other brood size manipulation experiments may suffer from similar biases in their fitness estimates. The biological consequence of this finding is that, if clutch size has a heritable component, local adaptation of clutch size will depend on the spatial heterogeneity of the habitat.