TETero Erkkilä

Tero Erkkilä

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Tero Erkkilä has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Democratic Control and Legitimacy of Finnish European Union Policy Process in Crisis Test: Trust, Openness, and the NextGenerationEU

    by Laura Nordström, Tero Erkkilä, Henrik Peiponen

    Crisis management tests the openness of decision‐making. This threatens the EU's weak democratic legitimacy. Simultaneously, on the national level, Nordic EU decision‐making is considered democratic. However, this model system is understudied, especially in a crisis that highlights its limitations. We analyzed the Finnish EU policy process’ throughput legitimacy during the covid crisis through one case, the EU recovery instrument NextGenerationEU 2020–2021 decision‐making. Our qualitative content analysis of documents and interviews shows that the process lacks throughput legitimacy, as transparency, accountability, openness, and inclusiveness before the Parliamentary proceedings are limited. Democratic legitimacy is sought through elite consensus and parliamentary control instead of societal dialogue. Our synthesis of throughput legitimacy and national democratic control demonstrates the impact of context. In Finland, this indicates the paradox of openness: in a system based on trust, there is no pressure to increase openness. Moreover, the boundaries of throughput and input legitimacy are unclear and need reconsideration.

  • Open Access

    Global models and post-Brexit discourses: ‘Singapore on Thames’ or ‘Nordic Scotland’?

    by Tero Erkkilä, Meng-Hsuan Chou, Juho Mölsä

    We analyse the rise of ‘Singapore on Thames’ and ‘Nordic Scotland’ discourses in post-Brexit UK as reflective of invented national models constructed with global policy scripts and rankings. The UK’s withdrawal from the European Union led the country to search for its new global identity and place in the global economy. Addressing the uncertain future, political actors referred to Singapore as a potential model for post-Brexit UK, idealising the Southeast Asian City State’s competitive institutional arrangements. Brexit also gave momentum for aspirations of Scottish independence with Nordic countries and welfare state acting as a starkly contrasting model for independent Scotland. Our article critically analyses the cognitive and normative aspects of the Singapore on Thames and Nordic Scotland discourses. We identify two modalities for referencing numerically constructed policy models, as means of anticipation or politicisation, blurring the communicative and coordinative variants of the analysed policy discourses and contributing to their failure.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Algorithmic Governance: Experimental Evidence on Citizens' and Public Administrators' Legitimacy Perceptions of Automated Decision‐Making

    by Jaakko Hillo, Isak Vento, Tero Erkkilä

    This article investigates legitimacy perceptions of automated decision‐making (ADM) among public administrators and citizens. Views of public administrators, who exercise discretion over policy implementation, reflect readiness to integrate AI into decision‐making. Governing by AI ought also to be responsive to the view of citizens, whose support democratic governing ultimately rests on. As AI use in governing grows, understanding the elite‐mass opinion congruence is crucial, and incongruence suggest misalignment between citizen preferences and policy implementation. Using randomized survey experiments conducted among Finnish toplevel public administrators (N = 842) and a representative sample of citizens (N = 3245), we compare the legitimacy effects of algorithmic transparency and human discretion over decision‐making in the context of child protection services. Transparency and human discretion enhance perceived legitimacy, with larger treatment effects among administrators. The study concludes that ADM legitimacy theories extend to a Nordic welfare context.


  • Hybridity and non-human agency in digital governance: a case of human-centricity

    by Tero Erkkilä, Konstantinos Kostas

    ‘Human-centric AI’ has become a core concept of responsible algorithmic governance. Digital transformation is associated with the complexification of governance, with questions such as how to regulate automation technologies due to the ‘black-box’ nature of AI. Moreover, the use of algorithms is blurring human agency in public decision-making, raising the question of accountability. The notion of ‘human-centric AI’ is proposed as a means for empowering people amidst the increasing automation of society. In governance strategies, human-centricity is portrayed as a design principle to break from ‘organisation-centricity’. We analyse human-centricity as an instance of hybridity, implying public and private actors as well as human and non-human agency. Our analysis shows paradoxical features of human-centricity in Finnish digital governance. Instead of enhancing accountability, human-centricity is used as an argument for designing seamless rapid service allocation in public governance for the individual citizen or removing organisational boundaries (both public and private), hence blurring accountability relations.

  • Open Access

    Nordic legal overseers and institutional openness in crises: Challenges and adaptation during the COVID‐19 pandemic

    by Tero Erkkilä, Juho Mölsä, Ella Vähäniitty

    We analyze challenges and adaptation strategies of Nordic legal overseers, the Parliamentary Ombudsmen and Chancellors of Justice in Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden, amid the COVID‐19 crisis. We study how the accountability capacities of the legal overseers were affected when standard practices of inclusive decision‐making were severed, and how they adapted to these challenges. Furthermore, we seek to understand what explains observed variation in the degree of challenges and needed adaptation measures. The observed challenges include increased and sometimes politicized caseload, limited expertise in medical field and conflicting or underdefined mandates among the institutions. The challenges and adaptation were conditioned by institutional traditions and ad‐hoc arrangements in crisis management. In Finland and Sweden, the legal overseers became prominent sites for legal and public accountabilities of crisis governance and experienced more acute organizational challenges from increased and politicized caseloads as actors were seeking alternative accountability forums when participation and openness were severed. In Norway and Denmark, where other institutions were prominent in overseeing crisis governance and its legality, the legal overseers had a more pressing need to adapt for an evolving organizational landscape with new ad‐hoc arrangements to oversee crisis management. Contributing to institutional approach on accountability and ombudsman research, we find a dynamic relationship between the government openness and legal oversight where the constraints for openness in crisis governance led to various challenges for the legal overseers' accountability capacities but to which they adapted by promoting openness as a right as well as an enabling mechanism for other accountability institutions.


  • AI and transparency

    by Ville Aula, Tero Erkkilä

    This chapter critically explores how the concept of transparency is used in the emerging scholarly and policy debates on AI systems, focusing on its political character. The concept of transparency has evolved over time, containing democratic and economic connotations, but is now gaining new technical interpretations in the context of AI systems. This conceptual shift is important, because the emerging sociotechnical understanding of algorithmic transparency foregrounds specific framings of policy problems while deprioritizing others. As a political concept algorithmic transparency hence carries the potential to be instrumentalized for promoting technical and ethical solutions to AI instead of considering its broader democratic and economic aspects. We conclude that current scholarly and policy debates on algorithmic transparency fall short on establishing actual institutional arrangements through which civil society actors and key stakeholders could control the use of algorithmic and AI applications.


  • Politics and policy of Artificial Intelligence

    by Inga Ulnicane, Tero Erkkilä

    While recent discussions about Artificial Intelligence (AI) as one of the most powerful technologies of our times tend to portray it as a predominantly technical issue, it also has major social, political and cultural implications. So far these have been mostly studied from ethical, legal and economic perspectives, while politics and policy have received less attention. To address this gap, this special issue brings together nine research articles to advance the studies of politics and policy of AI by identifying emerging themes and setting out future research agenda. Diverse but complementary contributions in this special issue speak to five overarching themes: understanding the AI as co‐shaped by technology and politics; highlighting the role of ideas in AI politics and policy; examining the distribution of power; interrogating the relationship between novel technology and continuity in politics and policy; and exploring interactions among developments at local, national, regional and global levels. This special issue demonstrates that AI policy is not an apolitical field that can be dealt with just by relying on knowledge and expertise but requires an open debate among alternative views, ideas, values and interests.


  • Open Access

    Global indicators and AI policy: Metrics, policy scripts, and narratives

    by Tero Erkkilä

    Artificial intelligence (AI) has become a global policy issue that is actively governed by international actors producing governance indicators. This article argues that despite the arguments about disruptions to governance and policy due to AI, the global rankings increasingly constitute a strong path dependence on AI policy, leading to conformity with existing policies and institutional practices of economic competitiveness. By analyzing the composition and data sources of global indices in competitiveness, innovation, human capital, and artificial intelligence, I will show how the global rankings now evolve by sharing data and concepts. Consequently, these metrics and related policy scripts promote the seeming continuity of current activities of global competitiveness. AI is discussed as a “revolution” but framed as a matter of “competitiveness,” “openness,” and “talent competition,” implying standard perceptions of economic competitiveness and innovation. There is also a narrative element in the policy script, as the future policies on AI are promoted with references to history that also project the past into the future. My article concludes that while path‐dependent policy indicators and related future narratives give a sense of orientation, they are problematic as they portray a seeming continuity of activities in times of disruptions, delimiting policy alternatives such as AI ethics.