SZSholpan Zhandossova

Sholpan Zhandossova

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Sholpan Zhandossova has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    PEACEKEEPING AS A FOREIGN POLICY INSTRUMENT OF EMERGING STATES

    by Rustem Kadyrzhanov, Moldir Almaz, Sholpan Zhandossova

    This article examines United Nations peacekeeping as an instrument of foreign policy for emerging states. It argues that peacekeeping has evolved beyond its traditional role of maintaining international peace and security and increasingly serves wider diplomatic, strategic, and institutional purposes. In contemporary international relations, participation in peacekeeping missions enables states not only to contribute to conflict management and post-conflict stabilization, but also to enhance their international visibility, strengthen their political legitimacy, and project the image of responsible actors within multilateral frameworks. The study is based on a qualitative analysis of academic literature, policy documents, and official materials related to United Nations peacekeeping and the foreign policy practices of emerging states. Particular attention is given to Kazakhstan as the main case study, while the experiences of Turkey and Brazil are used comparatively in order to identify different models of peacekeeping engagement. The comparative analysis demonstrates that these states use peacekeeping in distinct ways depending on their strategic ambitions, institutional capacities, and domestic political contexts. Kazakhstan represents a cautious and gradual model focused on controlled international visibility, institutional learning, and the accumulation of operational experience. Turkey demonstrates a broader and more diversified approach that combines military participation with police contribution, mediation, and peacebuilding initiatives. Brazil illustrates a more leadership-oriented model, especially during its active participation in MINUSTAH, when peacekeeping became part of a more ambitious strategy of international projection.The findings show that participation in peacekeeping missions contributes to strengthening a state’s international standing, expanding diplomatic engagement, and enhancing institutional and military capacities. The study concludes that peacekeeping functions as an important but differentiated foreign policy instrument for emerging states, the political meaning and practical effectiveness of which depend on both international recognition and domestic capacity.

  • State policy and multiple religious identity in Kazakhstan: a political science analysis

    by Sh.м. Zhandossova, L.N. Тoktarbekova

    The article investigates the intersection of state religious policy and the phenomenon of multiple religious identity in the Republic of Kazakhstan from a political science perspective. Kazakhstan presents a distinctive governance case: a constitutionally secular post-Soviet state that simultaneously mobilizes Islamic cultural heritage as a national identity resource while maintaining a restrictive regulatory environment for non-institutional religious practice. Drawing on a mixed-methods research design that integrates legislative corpus analysis (1991-2024), comparative governance indices, open-access nationwide survey data, and expert interviews, the study demonstrates that the prevailing managed-pluralism governance model generates a structural paradox: informal religious plurality proliferates as citizens navigate constrained institutional channels. The analysis reveals that those religious cleavages – between believers and non-believers, and between adherents of traditional and non-traditional religions – are perceived as among the sharpest social divisions in contemporary Kazakhstan, ranking above ethnic and linguistic divides. The article advances a conceptual typology of state approaches to religious identity governance, constructs a Regulatory Restriction Index to trace policy trajectory across three distinct phases, and formulates evidence-based policy recommendations oriented toward deliberative pluralism. The findings contribute to comparative political science literature on religion-state relations in post-Soviet Central Asia and to broader debates on the governance of religious diversity in transitional democracies.Keywords: multiple religious identity; state religious policy; Kazakhstan; political secularism; governance; Islam; identity politics.

  • Open Access

    Between security and belonging: state policy on religious extremism, political values and the politics of identity

    by Natalya Seitakhmetova, Sholpan Zhandossova

    State responses to religious extremism do not unfold in a political vacuum. They are shaped by, and in turn reshape, the constellation of political values that a given polity holds dear—liberty, security, equality, tolerance, and national cohesion—as well as the identities through which citizens and officials make sense of those values. This article examines the reciprocal relationship between counter-extremism policy, political values, and collective identity. Drawing on comparative case analysis of six countries (United Kingdom, Germany, Sweden, Kazakhstan, Morocco, and the United States), in which primary legislative documents and official policy programs constitute the core evidential base, triangulated against quantitative survey data (WVS, V-Dem, GTI) for contextual characterization, and comparative evidence from Western Europe, Central Asia, and North America, we argue that the design and legitimation of anti-extremism frameworks is fundamentally a value-laden process in which states negotiate tensions between liberal commitments to religious freedom and security imperatives, while simultaneously constructing—and contesting—narratives about who belongs to the political community. The comparative analysis shows that value-dominant contexts—distinguished along the emancipative versus survival orientation axis—are systematically associated with divergent policy architectures, and that coercive securitization models are linked, across all examined cases, to greater community alienation and diminished cooperation with state institutions when compared with prevention-through-integration approaches. We further argue that the identitarian dimension of counter-extremism policy has been underexplored in comparative perspective—specifically, the interaction between political values, collective identity, and policy design across different institutional contexts, and that attending to it illuminates why technically similar measures produce divergent social outcomes across different political contexts. The findings carry implications for democratic governance, minority rights, and the legitimacy of the liberal state.


  • Open Access

    Religion As an Instrument of Politics and Ideology in the International Relations of Post-Soviet Central Asia

    by M.M. Nurov, E.K. Aliyarov, Sh.M. Zhandossova

    This article analyzes religion as an instrument of politics and ideology in the international relations of the five post-Soviet states of Central Asia. The study examines how Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan are instrumentalizing the religious factor to achieve foreign policy goals, strengthen the ideological foundations of power and international positioning in the context of globalization and transnational religious influences. Theoretically, the work is based on the concepts of religious diplomacy, «soft power» and securitization, demonstrating the transformation of religion from a marginalized element of the Soviet era into a multifunctional political and ideological resource. Across the region, religion is mobilized to legitimize power, construct national identity, justify authoritarian governance through security-centered discourses, and enhance symbolic capital in the international arena. A comparative perspective reveals distinct national models of religious instrumentalization. Kazakhstan employs interfaith dialogue as a soft-power mechanism and a means of strengthening international reputation. Uzbekistan leverages Islamic cultural heritage for diplomatic and economic benefit. Tajikistan uses religious regulation as an ideological rationale for authoritarian consolidation. Kyrgyzstan illustrates competition among political actors for influence over religious discourse. Turkmenistan incorporates religion into a personalized ideology that underpins isolationism. The article argues that these patterns are shaped by each state’s historical experience, regime type, ethno-religious composition, and geopolitical position. Key words: religion, politics, ideology, international relations, Central Asia, instrumentalization of religion, religious diplomacy, soft power, post-Soviet transformation.

  • RELIGIOUS AND SECULAR PARADIGMS OF JUSTICE

    by Laura Toktarbekova, Natalyа Seitakhmetova, Sholpan Zhandossova

    This article presents a comparative analysis of religious and secular paradigms of justice. The first part examines key concepts of justice in Christianity, Islam, Judaism, and Buddhism: as a divine attribute and moral ideal in the Abrahamic religions, and as the law of karma in Buddhism. The analysis highlights the role of mercy and forgiveness in the Christian tradition, rationalism and ethical imperative in Islam through adherence to Sharia, the combination of pragmatism and charity in Judaism, and the non-violent, tolerant order in Buddhist doctrine. The second part of the article analyzes the major paradigms of secular theories: utilitarianism, libertarianism, John Rawls’s liberal egalitarianism, the approaches and concepts of Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum, and deliberative democracy. It is emphasized that each paradigm focuses on different aspects of justice: individual and collective well-being, individual freedom and rights, equality of opportunity, and access to educational, social, and political resources.

  • Open Access

    GLOBAL TRENDS AND LOCAL FEATURES OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF MODERN CIVIL SOCIETY

    by Sh.M. Zhandossova, M.M. Nurov, Zh.Z. Kuanyshbayeva

    This study examines the complex dynamics of civil society development in the modern world, characterized by the interaction of global trends and local features. The work is devoted to a comprehensive analysis of the evolution of institutions of civic participation in the context of a changing system of international relations. The purpose of the research is to identify and scientifically analyze the systemic relationships between global trends and local trajectories of civil society development. The work is aimed at identifying key global trends in the development of civil society, conducting a comparative analysis of regional models of civic participation and studying the impact of digitalization on the transformation of forms of civic engagement. The research methodology is based on an interdisciplinary approach integrating theoretical concepts and methods of political science, sociology and international relations. Systematic, comparative, institutional and constructivist approaches are used, as well as methods of content analysis. The main results of the study demonstrate ambiguous and contradictory trends in the development of civil society, due to the dialectic of global and local. The key mechanisms of adaptation of universal models of civic participation to specific socio-cultural and political contexts, as well as the impact of global crises on the institutional development of civil society in various regional contexts, have been identified. The value of the research lies in systematizing knowledge about the transformation of traditional forms of civic engagement under the influence of digitalization and globalization, as well as in identifying new opportunities for transnational cooperation between non-state actors in a changing international environment.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Kazakh Women’s Visual Religious Identity and Islamic Agency on Instagram

    by Laura Toktarbekova, Sholpan Zhandossova, Madina Bektenova

    This research study analyzes the strategies and forms of religious agency exhibited by Kazakh Muslim women within the social networking platform Instagram. This analysis is situated within the broader context of the digital transformation of religious practices that is currently underway. The authors explore the intricate interplay between Islamic norms, traditional Kazakh cultural codes and the global digital media landscape through the lens of visual content, social media posts, narratives and account descriptions of Kazakh women. Utilizing content analysis and visual analysis techniques, they examine the dynamics between these cultural elements and the representation of women in the context of digital media. The results of the study demonstrate that the Instagram platform offers Muslim women novel opportunities to express their religious identity, visually demonstrate piety and consolidate their position in public space. The authors determine the changing nature of the Islamic Women's Agency in post-Soviet Kazakhstan by analyzing the manifestation of religious and gender identity in social networks based on visualization. The research findings offer a substantial contribution to the understanding of the digital transformation of Muslim women's self-expression practices in modern Kazakh society. This work demonstrates the evolution of religious practices in the digital age and the innovative ways in which Muslim women are establishing new forms of agency within the virtual realm. The findings of the study demonstrate that the Instagram platform can be regarded not only as a medium for self-expression, but also as a space for the emergence of novel forms of Islamic women's agency in post-Soviet Kazakhstan.


  • Open Access

    ҚАЗАҚСТАНДАҒЫ ИСЛАМДЫҚ САНАНЫҢ РАДИКАЛДАНУЫ: СЕБЕПТЕРІ, КӨРІНІСТЕРІ ЖӘНЕ АЛДЫН АЛУ ШАРАЛАРЫ

    by Шолпан Жандосова

    Аталған мақала қазіргі Қазақстандағы исламдық сананың радикалдану процестерін жан-жақты талдауға арналған. Зерттеуде радикалды діни идеологиялардың таралуына әсер ететін әлеуметтік-экономикалық, тарихи-мәдени және психологиялық факторлар анықталады. Жұмыста қазақстандық қоғамдағы діни радикализмнің негізгі көріністері, олардың қазіргі әлеуметтік-саяси жағдайға әсері қарастырылады. Автор радикалды діни идеологияның таралуына ықпал ететін негізгі себептерді, атап айтқанда, әлеуметтік теңсіздік, жұмыссыздық, тарихи сананың бұзылуы, дәстүрлі құндылықтардың дағдарысы және діни сауаттылықтың төмен деңгейін анықтайды. Зерттеуде діни радикализмнің алдын алу мен қарсы тұрудың тиімді шаралары ұсынылады, оның ішінде білім беру бағдарламаларын жетілдіру, діни сауаттылықты арттыру, дәстүрлі ислам құндылықтарын насихаттау, әлеуметтік-экономикалық даму бағдарламаларын іске асыру және радикалды топтардың идеологиясына карсы тұру шаралары қарастырылады. Жұмыста қазақстандық қоғамның рухани қауіпсіздігін қамтамасыз ету үшін мемлекеттік органдар мен діни ұйымдардың, азаматтық қоғам институттарының өзара әрекеттестігі талданады. Аталған мақала ғылыми объективтілік, жүйелілік және кешенді тәсіл қағидаттарына негізделген тарихи-салыстырмалы, әлеуметтік-психологиялық, институционалдық, жүйелі және саяси-құқықтық талдау әдістерін қолданады. Осы әдістердің кешенді түрде қолданылуы радикалдану үдерістеріне қарсы іс-қимылдардың тиімді тәсілдерін айқындауға мүмкіндік берді. Жұмыстың ғылыми және практикалық маңыздылығы Қазақстанның діни қауіпсіздігін қамтамасыз ету саласындағы мемлекеттік саясатты жетілдіруге қосқан үлесімен анықталады.

  • THE INFLUENCE OF DIGITALIZATION ON RELIGIOUS IDENTITY: SOCIO-POLITICAL CONTEXT

    by Natalya Seitakhmetova, Sholpan Zhandossova

    This study aims to explore the process of religious identity formation in the context of increasing digitalization and changes in the socio-political environment. The findings show a shift in religious authority structures; the traditional hierarchies are being replaced by new decentralized digital networks and user-generated content. From the present study, it becomes clear that social media and other digital communication tools help form hybrid religious identities, combining traditional religious practices and the new digital culture. Three ways in which digitalization affects religious identity are through virtual community formation, algorithmic content curation and interactive ritual practices. The study also examines how socio-political factors, such as the state regulation of digital spaces and content, influence the digital expression of religious identity. The comparison of cultures reveals different trends in the adoption of digital religious practices in various political systems and cultural environments. Quantitative and qualitative methods, including analysis, synthesis, historical-formal methods and generalization, were used in this study to analyze the relationship between digital technologies and religious identity formation. The study analyzed the advantages and disadvantages of Internet-mediated religious practices in various churches while making specific reference to the Republic of Kazakhstan. Thus, the results show how the development of technology influences modern religious identity and interpersonal religious relations and, therefore, contributes to the discussion of digital religion and social change.


  • Open Access

    Секьюритизация религии в Центральной Азии: баланс между национальной безопасностью и свободой вероисповедания

    by Ш.м. Жандосова

    В данной статье исследуется процесс секьюритизации религии в странах Центральной Азии, фокусируясь на поиске оптимального баланса между обеспечением национальной безопасности и сохранением конституционного права на свободу вероисповедания. Анализ основывается на изучении законодательной базы, статистических данных и экспертных оценок, что позволяет всесторонне рассмотреть трансформацию государственной политики в религиозной сфере. Исследование концентрируется на механизмах контроля религиозной деятельности и их влиянии на общество. Особое внимание уделяется потенциальным рискам радикализации верующих, которые могут возникнуть в результате чрезмерного государственного регулирования. Методология работы включает сравнительный анализ, контент-анализ нормативных документов и медиа-материалов, а также статистический анализ демографических данных. Результаты исследования демонстрируют двойственность последствий секьюритизации религии в регионе. С одной стороны, этот процесс способствует снижению рисков религиозного экстремизма, что является позитивным фактором для обеспечения национальной безопасности. С другой стороны, жесткие меры контроля могут провоцировать рост социальной напряженности и радикализацию отдельных групп верующих, что создает новые вызовы для государственной политики. На основе полученных данных в статье предлагаются рекомендации по совершенствованию государственной политики в религиозной сфере. Эти рекомендации учитывают необходимость соблюдения тонкого баланса между обеспечением безопасности и защитой свободы совести. Предлагаемые меры направлены на создание более гибкой и инклюзивной системы регулирования религиозной деятельности, которая могла бы эффективно противодействовать экстремизму, не ущемляя при этом права законопослушных верующих. В заключение подчеркивается важность дальнейших исследований в данной области для разработки эффективных стратегий управления религиозной сферой в условиях меняющейся геополитической и социальной реальности Центральной Азии. Ключевые слова: секьюритизация религии, Центральная Азия, национальная безопасность, свобода вероисповедания, религиозная политика, радикализация, государственное регулирование