RERandal J. Elder

Randal J. Elder

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Randal J. Elder has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Inventory Auditing Standards: Insights from AAERs and CAMs

    by Paul Caster, Randal J. Elder, Diane J. Janvrin, Erika Paulius

    SUMMARY: The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) recently added inventory to its standard-setting agenda (PCAOB 2023b) to address recent economic developments and concerns that inventory audit standards have not significantly changed since 1939. Existing inventory standards primarily address inventory observation and inventory quantities. We provide insights into inventory audit issues by examining Accounting and Auditing Enforcement Releases (AAERs) from 2000 to 2022. We supplement this by reviewing critical audit matters (CAMs) from 2019 to 2023 to examine inventory audit risks and problem areas identified by auditors. The most common inventory issue in CAMs and AAERs involves obsolescence. Although many AAERs involve pricing and observation issues, these are rarely identified in CAMs. Our research highlights inventory areas where frauds and other significant misstatements have occurred. Audit practitioners can use these results to communicate these significant risks and revise audit procedures to address these risks. Data Availability: Data are available from the public sources cited in the text.

  • Open Access

    Voluntary Adoption of Internal Audit by NASDAQ Firms and Its Impact on Internal Control Reporting

    by Omar Watts, Randal Elder, Michael Hyman

    NASDAQ firms are not required to have an internal audit function. We exploit this voluntary setting to provide further insight into internal audit's role as a governance function. We search proxy statements and other sources to identify whether NASDAQ firms have an internal audit function. Firms with a higher risk profile are more likely to have an internal audit function, whereas smaller/resource constrained firms are less likely to invest in internal audit. NASDAQ firms with an internal audit function are more likely to report a material weakness under Sarbanes‐Oxley Section 302 or 404, indicating that internal audit reduces information asymmetry by communicating internal control issues.

  • Nonaudit Services and Governmental Financial Reporting Quality, Audit Quality, and Audit Efficiency: Evidence from the North Carolina Municipal Audit Market

    by Alfred A. Yebba, Randal J. Elder, Ayalew Lulseged

    SUMMARY: We analyze the association between nonaudit services and upcharges, additional fees charged at the conclusion of the audit, and audit/financial reporting quality for North Carolina municipal governments. Nonaudit services are allowed with appropriate safeguards for audits under AICPA auditing standards, including governmental audits. The impact of the auditor providing financial statement preparation services on audit/reporting quality is mixed. These services are associated with a higher likelihood of a government receiving the GFOA CAE, a proxy for high reporting quality. However, these services are associated with a higher likelihood of receiving a letter of deficiency from the government monitoring agency, a proxy for low reporting quality. Auditor provided bookkeeping services are positively associated with on time reporting. Upcharges are negatively associated with the CAE award, but also negatively associated with letters of findings, suggesting upcharges help address reporting problems to comply with state reporting requirements. Data Availability: Data are available from the authors on request. JEL Classifications: M42; M48.

  • Open Access

    Comments by the Ad Hoc Task Force of the Auditing Standards Committee of the Auditing Section of the American Accounting Association on the Proposed Auditing Standard, the Auditor’s Use of Confirmation, and Other Proposed Amendments to PCAOB Standards

    by Colleen M. Boland, Paul Caster, Randal J. Elder, Diane Janvrin

    SUMMARY: On December 20, 2022, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) issued a request for comment on its proposed auditing standard, The Auditor’s Use of Confirmation, and Other Proposed Amendments to PCAOB Standards. The proposed auditing standard describes principles-based requirements that apply to paper-based and electronic confirmations, improves integration with risk assessment standards, requires confirmation for cash held by third parties, and carries over existing requirements regarding confirming accounts receivable. Further, it considers additional audit procedures when using negative confirmation requests and clarifies certain activities where the auditor should not use an internal auditor to provide direct assistance. The proposed standard is important, as the audit confirmation process touches nearly every audit. The comment period ended on February 20, 2023. This commentary summarizes the participating members’ views on the questions posed by the PCAOB. Data Availability: Proposed Auditing Standard—The Auditor’s Use of Confirmation, and Other Proposed Amendments to PCAOB Standards, including questions for respondents, is available at PCAOB Proposes New Standard for the Auditor’s Use of Confirmation | PCAOB (https://pcaobus.org/).

  • Auditing nonprofit entities

    by Randal J. Elder, Alfred A. Yebba

    Auditing plays a key monitoring role in nonprofit governance. We discuss the demand for nonprofit sector auditing, including state and federal audit requirements; audit outcomes; impacts of audit outcomes on donor decisions; issues concerning audit quality; and other measures associated with audit performance including audit pricing and delivery of non-audit services. We summarize several broad lines of nonprofit audit research and draw parallels with findings from the governmental sector and commercial audit markets. Nonprofit audit research addresses questions such as (1) the cost of audit requirements and determinants of overall audit costs; (2) voluntarily contracting for auditing services; (3) impacts of auditing on reporting quality; (4) audit risk factors unique to nonprofit auditing; and (5) nonprofit internal control environments, including controls to prevent and detect fraud. Lastly, we identify opportunities for future research.


  • An Exploration of Bank Confirmation Process Automation: A Longitudinal Study

    by Paul Caster, Randal J. Elder, Diane J. Janvrin

    This exploratory study examines automation of the bank confirmation process using a longitudinal dataset from the largest third-party U.S. confirmation service provider, supplemented with informal interviews with practitioners. We find a significant increase in electronic confirmation use in the U.S. and internationally. Errors requiring reconfirmation were less than 2 percent of all electronic confirmations. Errors made by auditors were almost five times more likely than errors by bank employees. Most auditor errors involved use of an invalid account number, although invalid client contact, invalid request, and invalid company name errors increased recently. Big 4 auditors made significantly more confirmation errors than did auditors at non-Big 4 national firms. Error rates and error types do not vary between confirmations initiated in the U.S. and those initiated internationally. Three themes emerged for future research: authentication of evidence, global differences in technology use, and technology adoption across firms of different sizes.


  • Open Access

    The Introduction of State Regulation and Auditor Retendering in School Districts: Local Audit Market Structure, Audit Pricing, and Internal Control Reporting

    by Randal J. Elder, Alfred A. Yebba

    SUMMARY: The impacts of auditor retendering or rotation mandates and auditor selection have been a regulatory concern for some time. However, finding suitable research settings to examine these policies has been a challenge. This paper reports the results of a study (Elder and Yebba 2020) that explores the consequences of implementing a retendering policy in a local governmental audit market. The study finds an association between periodic retendering and auditor concentration, including the growth of fee premium specialization within the market. We also find changes in quality associated with these mandates, including greater auditor effort, evidenced through higher audit fees and longer reporting delays, and improved documentation of internal controls evidenced through increased reporting of control deficiencies. Collectively, we provide evidence that periodic retendering of audit services may provide a suitable level of quality enhancement while not forcing auditees to absorb audit inefficiencies common with a rotation policy.


  • Research Initiatives in Accounting Education: Managing Academic Programs

    by Susan M. Albring, Randal J. Elder

    This essay discusses select aspects of managing an academic program including quality and quantity of students and student recruitment, curricular development, measuring program quality and department performance, funding, and accreditation that affect the quality of accounting education. We include a broad overview of how the topics are interrelated and discuss observable output measures of program quality including CPA exam and other standardized test results, student placement, and longer-term measures of career success. We discuss select research to identify current knowledge and research related to managing an academic program. We also suggest unanswered research questions related to managing an academic program to encourage future research in this area. Many of these research questions are particularly important as accounting appears to be entering a period of declining enrollment and resources.


  • The Effects of State-Level GAAP Regulation on Municipal Audit Markets, Reporting Quality, and Audit Fees

    by Alfred A. Yebba, Randal J. Elder

    We examine the effects of financial statement disclosure regulation on auditor market concentration, reporting quality, and audit pricing. We compare auditor industry concentration levels for municipalities reporting under the Single Audit Act in the state of Michigan, which requires GAAP reporting, with concentration rates in Pennsylvania, which has unregulated reporting. We find an association between a comprehensive GAAP disclosure policy and auditor concentration. The disclosure-regulated state also has higher demand for auditor specialization and reporting quality, as evidenced through lower reporting of material weaknesses and shorter reporting lags. Specialist auditors in both environments are associated with greater reporting of control exceptions, but specialization is only associated with shorter reporting lags with disclosure regulation. Using a small sample of survey data for one year, we find evidence that audit pricing is lower in the regulated state, and that specialist pricing varies based on regulation and each specialist audit firm's market positioning.


  • Unexpected Fees and the Prediction of Material Weaknesses in Internal Control Over Financial Reporting

    by Susan M. Albring, Randal J. Elder, Xiaolu Xu

    We investigate whether prior year unexpected audit fees help predict new material weaknesses in internal control over financial reporting reported under Section 404 of the Sarbanes–Oxley Act (SOX). Predicting material weaknesses may be useful to investors and other financial statement users because these disclosures have adverse economic impacts on disclosing firms. Unexpected fees are significantly associated with material weaknesses reported under Section 404, even after controlling for Section 302 disclosures and other factors associated with internal control weaknesses. Unexpected fees are associated with company-level weaknesses but are not significantly associated with account-specific weaknesses, consistent with differences in the nature and severity of the two types of material weaknesses. Our results are consistent with unexpected audit fees containing information on unobserved audit costs and client control risks, which help predict future internal control weaknesses.