RDRoel Dobbe

Roel Dobbe

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Roel Dobbe has a total of 85 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Design Practices for Public Algorithmic Systems: Grounded in Technocratic and Businesslike Logics

    by Sem Nouws, Marijn Janssen, Roel Dobbe

    Algorithmic and AI systems employed in public administration often manifest technocratic and efficiency premises which may conflict with the democratic and socio-technical fundaments of algorithmic practices in government. Partially, these premises are infused into these public algorithmic systems during the design process. This paper conducts a case study in a consortium of Dutch public organisations that reshapes design practices of algorithmic systems to uncover institutional logics underlying these practices. Our observations and interviews at the consortium of 13 public organisations revealed four design practices that deviate from sociotechnical design practices: (1) distance from politics, (2) underrate the input from non-technical experts, (3) operate on a procurement-oriented dynamic, and (4) follow a chronological phasing combined with agile or scrum practices. Through abductive reasoning, we derived the technocratic and businesslike logics that shaped these design practices. These institutional logics clash with the socio-technical, political, and material nature of public algorithmic systems. To arrive at more responsible, accountable and ethical use of these systems in government, public organisations need to modify their design practices. Our findings provide initial insights into the institutional logics required to change design practices, while also underscoring the complexity of altering routines and practices that are deeply rooted in organisational structures and cultures.

  • Open Access

    Group fairness in power systems computation: Evaluating disparities in grid capacity between households with and without rooftop solar

    by Eva de Winkel, Flin Verdaasdonk, Zofia Lukszo, Werner van Westering, Mark Neerincx, Roel Dobbe


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Big AI's Regulatory Capture: Mapping Industry Interference and Government Complicity

    by Abeba Birhane, Riccardo Angius, William Agnew, Harshvardhan J Pandit, Bhaskar Mitra, Roel Dobbe, Zeerak Talat


  • Open Access

    Values, tensions, and regulatory strategies in electricity grid tariff regulation

    by Eva de Winkel, Atay Kozlovski, Zofia Lukszo, Mark Neerincx, Roel Dobbe

    With increasing grid congestion and growing interconnection queues, regulators are considering revisions to existing governance instruments for guiding grid operator behavior, such as grid tariff regulation, to address the challenges of the energy transition. In revising these instruments, regulators translate societal values, such as affordability, reliability, and sustainability, into regulatory mechanisms. This study examines how both the regulator and stakeholders interpret and prioritize values during the consultation process for new grid tariff regulation in the Netherlands. Consultation documents from 17 organizations and the regulator’s draft proposal were analyzed using a structured approach that distinguishes between value interpretations, value tensions, and strategies for addressing these tensions. The analysis reveals that stakeholders consistently broaden the value landscape beyond the regulator’s initial framing, for example, by considering affordability in terms of total household energy bills rather than solely grid tariffs, and sustainability as full decarbonization rather than electrification alone. Besides, five key value tensions shaping grid tariff design were identified: availability of grid capacity versus affordability; cost allocation to current versus future users; predictability of grid tariffs versus flexibility to adapt regulation; timeliness versus efficiency of grid investments; and efficient use of existing capacity versus reliability. The draft regulation demonstrates an orientation that prioritizes availability and timely investment over affordability and efficiency, whereas stakeholders did not present such a clear prioritization. The findings further show that grid tariff regulation entails navigating choices among multiple defensible value orientations, reflected in both differing interpretations of values and strategies for addressing value tensions.

  • Open Access

    Understanding AI Trustworthiness: A Scoping Review of AIES & FAccT Articles

    by Siddharth Mehrotra, Jin Huang, Xuelong Fu, Roel Dobbe, Clara I. Sánchez, Maarten de Rijke

    Background: Trustworthy AI serves as a foundational pillar for two major AI ethics conferences: AIES and FAccT. Current research often adopts techno-centric approaches, focusing primarily on technical attributes such as accuracy, reliability, robustness, and fairness, while overlooking the sociotechnical dimensions critical to understanding AI trustworthiness in real-world contexts. Objectives: This scoping review aims to examine how the AIES and FAccT communities conceptualize, measure, and validate AI trustworthiness, identifying major gaps and opportunities for advancing a holistic understanding of trustworthy AI systems. Methods: We conduct a scoping review of the AIES and FAccT conference proceedings to date, systematically analyzing how trustworthiness is defined, operationalized, and applied across different research domains. Our analysis focuses on conceptualization approaches, measurement methods, verification and validation techniques, application areas, and underlying values. Results: While significant progress has been made in defining technical attributes such as transparency, accountability, and robustness, our findings reveal critical gaps. Current research often predominantly emphasizes technical precision at the expense of social and ethical considerations. The sociotechnical nature of AI systems remains less explored and trustworthiness emerges as a contested concept shaped by those with the power to define it. Conclusions: An interdisciplinary approach combining technical rigor with social, cultural, and institutional considerations is essential for advancing trustworthy AI. We propose actionable measures for the AI ethics community to adopt holistic frameworks that genuinely address the complex interplay between AI systems and society, ultimately promoting responsible technological development that benefits all stakeholders.


  • Open Access

    Burying the Lead: Adjusting Goals to Manage Functional Limitations of AI Tools in Healthcare

    by Jacqueline Kernahan, Richard Bartels, Mark De Reuver, Daniel Oberski, Roel Dobbe

    Artificial intelligence based tools are being developed for decision support in healthcare, however, they are frequently found to lack the required functionality to achieve the clinical goals for which they were built. This results in wasted time, money and resources for hospitals attempting to implement and operate such tools. To determine how functionality issues can be resolved prior to tool implementation, it is necessary to understand why such tools are being designed and then built. Our research focuses on clinical decision support tools with functionality issues arising from target variable invalidity. In this paper, we analyze published articles which present clinical decision support tool designs related to clinical goals. These tools use machine learning models trained on electronic health record data. We find that design decisions driven by data availability can introduce construct invalidity in clinical decision support tool designs, leading to an inability of the tool to address the clinical goal. We observe that alternative goals to the main clinical goal are used to justify continued development. We show that functional limitations of the tool related to the clinical goal can be obscured by imprecise terminology in the model’s stated functionality. Finally, we highlight the need for reconsidered approaches to dataset creation, defining success criteria, and the reporting and transparency of research outcomes as they relate to clinical goals.


  • Open Access

    The Socratic Dialogue as a Method for Virtue Ethics in AI: A Case Study

    by Maarten Wilders, Íñigo Martínez de Rituerto de Troya, Roel Dobbe

    This paper investigates how the Socratic Dialogue can cultivate moral virtues among AI practitioners, focusing on core virtues identified by Hagendorff as essential to ethical AI practice: justice, care, honesty, responsibility, practical wisdom (phronesis), and fortitude. Using a case study conducted at a financial bank’s transaction monitoring department, we examine how structured ethical deliberation cultivates the dispositions needed to navigate moral complexity in AI ethics. Seven participants, including data scientists, legal specialists, and ethics experts, engaged in a facilitated Socratic Dialogue centered on an ethical dilemma involving AI-driven detection of financial fraud and terrorist activity. Through abductive analysis, we found that tensions emerged within key virtues, illustrating the complexities of ethical decision-making in AI systems. Through the collective nature of the dialogue, participants developed a more refined and context-sensitive understanding of key virtues, exploring what it means to be just, caring, honest, or responsible in practice by navigating within them. This process cultivated practical wisdom not as a solitary trait, but as a relational capacity fostered through shared reflection and moral reasoning. Additionally, the method strengthens fortitude, encouraging AI practitioners to voice ethical concerns despite situational pressures. While challenges remain, such as time investment, facilitation demands, and existing power imbalances, the Socratic Dialogue offers a promising foundation for virtue-oriented AI ethics that moves beyond compliance frameworks toward deeper moral engagement.


  • Open Access

    Environmental impacts of artificial intelligence in health care: considerations and recommendations

    by Cristina Richie, Saba Hinrichs-Krapels, Roel Dobbe, Paddy French, Jonathan C. J. Wei, J. C. Diehl, Ran Kong

    Purpose (stating the main purposes and research question): Anthropogenic resource use contributes to pollution, violent conflict over scarce resources, loss of biodiversity, and diminished quality of life for humans. Moreover, the “safe” amount of carbon dioxide—350 parts per million—has been exceeded. The health care industry is responsible for 4–5% of total world emissions,[i] which is similar to the global food sector.[ii] Health care carbon emissions come from health care infrastructures, supply chains and health care delivery. Increasingly, health care delivery is reliant on technologies which require the use of artificial intelligence to provide supportive care, such as triage algorithms, electronic patient records, and robotics.[iii] While these technological innovations have advanced health care significantly, they also contribute to the negative effects on the environment, among others, through carbon emissions. The environmental impacts of artificial intelligence (AI) in health care—in particular—are understudied. This research seeks to fill this gap. Methods: Our team ran an exploratory search in Scopus and PubMed to identify studies that integrate environmental sustainability, artificial intelligence, and health. Results: Our research initially yielded 735 studies. 77 of these studies focused on an environmental concern of a health technology or AI-application in a health care setting, but most of the articles in this subset addressed lowering energy consumption of a specific technology, such as a sensor or monitoring technology. Conclusions: While there have been studies looking at AI in health care; sustainability in AI; and sustainability in health care, little attention has been paid to the interface between all three. [i] Karliner, J., Slotterback, S., Boyd, R., Ashby, B., & Steele, K. 2019. Health Care’s Climate Footprint: How the Health Sector Contributes to the Global Climate Crisis and Opportunities for Action Healthcare Without HarmARUP; September. [ii] Pichler, P. P., Jaccard, I. S., Weisz, U., & Weisz, H. 2019 International Comparison of Health Care Carbon Footprints, Environmental Research Letters 14, no. 6: 064004. [iii] Khaliq, Abdul, Ali Waqas, Qasim Ali Nisar, Shahbaz Haider, and Zunaina Asghar. 2022. Application of AI and robotics in hospitality sector: A resource gain and resource loss perspective. Technology in Society 68: 101807.