MBMichael A. Barone

Michael A. Barone

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Michael A. Barone has a total of 69 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    No Free Lunch in Competency-Based Health Professions Education: Exploring Trade-Offs, Value, and Shared Investment in Health Professions Education

    by Denise H. Rhoney, Michael A. Barone, Holly Caretta-Weyer, Laura Edgar, Daniel J. Schumacher, John Q. Young, Roberta Ladenheim, Kelly J. Caverzagie, For the International Competency-Based Health Professions Education Collaborators

    Background/Problem: Competency-Based Health Professions Education (CBHPE) aims to improve workforce readiness, patient safety, and equity, but achieving these outcomes requires sustained investment. The “No Free Lunch” (NFL) rule underscores that value cannot be realized without visible costs, which can be financial, cultural, temporal, and structural. Although costs are ideally shared across the health professions education and health care ecosystem, interest holders often invest unevenly despite broad benefits. As a result, many programs and institutions struggle to implement and sustain CBHPE, even as adoption grows globally.Purpose/Approach: This paper examines how “value” and return on investment (ROI) in CBHPE are conceptualized across learners, faculty, institutional leaders, governments/funders, clinical systems, accreditors/regulators, professional organizations, and patients/communities. The authors describe tensions regarding who invests and who benefits, identify practical trade-offs, and highlight opportunities for alignment across settings, including low-resource contexts. We propose an interest-holder-informed framework that links typical investments to forms of value/ROI to support explicit, context-sensitive cost-sharing.Key Insight: Value in CBHPE is contextual, shaped by the mission of the interest holder, the time horizon for returns, and available resources. Because benefits are often diffuse or delayed, ROI may be difficult to demonstrate, reinforcing underinvestment. Value must ultimately be judged by benefit to patients and communities.Conclusion: CBHPE cannot rely on the goodwill of those closest to implementation. Sustainability requires clear articulation of value, shared responsibility for costs that are proportional to benefits, and alignment between goals and resources among interest holders. CBHPE should be treated as long-term infrastructure for better care, not a temporary reform.


  • Open Access

    Introducing the Next Era in Assessment

    by Alina Smirnova, Michael A. Barone, Sondra Zabar, Adina Kalet

    In this introduction, the guest editors of the “Next Era in Assessment” special collection frame the invited papers by envisioning a next era in assessment of medical education, based on ideas developed during a summit that convened professional and educational leaders and scholars. The authors posit that the next era of assessment will focus unambiguously on serving patients and the health of society, reflect its sociocultural context, and support learners’ longitudinal growth and development. As such, assessment will be characterized as transformational, development-oriented and socially accountable. The authors introduce the papers in this special collection, which represent elements of a roadmap towards the next era in assessment by exploring several foundational considerations that will make the next era successful. These include the equally important issues of (1) focusing on accountability, trust and power in assessment, (2) addressing implementation and contextualization of assessment systems, (3) optimizing the use of technology in assessment, (4) establishing infrastructure for data sharing and data storage, (5) developing a vocabulary around emerging sources of assessment data, and (6) reconceptualizing validity around patient care and learner equity. Attending to these priority areas will help leaders create authentic assessment systems that are responsive to learners’ and society’s needs, while reaping the full promise of competency-based medical education (CBME) as well as emerging data science and artificial intelligence technologies.


  • Open Access

    Digital Evidence: Revisiting Assumptions at the Intersection of Technology and Assessment

    by Andrew E. Krumm, Saad Chahine, Abigail M. Schuh, Daniel J. Schumacher, Sondra Zabar, Brian C. George, Kayla Marcotte, Stefanie S. Sebok-Syer, Michael A. Barone, Alina Smirnova

    The increasing use of technology in health care and health professions education is an invitation to examine how digital sources of evidence are used in making assessment claims. In this paper, we describe how four sets of terms—primary and secondary data; structured and unstructured data; development and use; and deterministic and generative—can aid in examining how data from digital sources are used in evaluating what learners know and can do. Drawing on multiple examples, this paper shows how the four sets of terms can help both developers and users of technology-based assessment systems.


  • Without medical education, a learning healthcare system cannot learn

    by Michael A Barone, Carol Carraccio, Alison Lentz, Robert Englander

    In 2020, Scobie et al published, ‘Implementing LHS in the UK NHS…’, based on a decade of efforts to use electronic health data to improve healthcare.3 Despite the US and UK LHS goal to improve healthcare, the 2021 Commonwealth Fund Report did not reflect progress.4 The Commonwealth Fund data are an important snapshot of healthcare quality and outcomes in 10 developed countries. The US and UK ranked 10 and 9, respectively, for healthcare outcomes.4 While we focus on the US and UK, we believe the worldwide need for healthcare optimisation, illustrated by the international shortfall of managing the COVID pandemic, make improving the LHS a universal call to action.2


  • Open Access

    The Next Era of Assessment: Building a Trustworthy Assessment System

    by Holly A. Caretta-Weyer, Alina Smirnova, Michael A. Barone, Jason R. Frank, Tina Hernandez-Boussard, Dana Levinson, Kiki M. J. M. H. Lombarts, Kimberly D. Lomis, Abigail Martini, Daniel J. Schumacher, et al.

    Assessment in medical education has evolved through a sequence of eras each centering on distinct views and values. These eras include measurement (e.g., knowledge exams, objective structured clinical examinations), then judgments (e.g., workplace-based assessments, entrustable professional activities), and most recently systems or programmatic assessment, where over time multiple types and sources of data are collected and combined by competency committees to ensure individual learners are ready to progress to the next stage in their training. Significantly less attention has been paid to the social context of assessment, which has led to an overall erosion of trust in assessment by a variety of stakeholders including learners and frontline assessors. To meaningfully move forward, the authors assert that the reestablishment of trust should be foundational to the next era of assessment. In our actions and interventions, it is imperative that medical education leaders address and build trust in assessment at a systems level. To that end, the authors first review tenets on the social contextualization of assessment and its linkage to trust and discuss consequences should the current state of low trust continue. The authors then posit that trusting and trustworthy relationships can exist at individual as well as organizational and systems levels. Finally, the authors propose a framework to build trust at multiple levels in a future assessment system; one that invites and supports professional and human growth and has the potential to position assessment as a fundamental component of renegotiating the social contract between medical education and the health of the public.


  • Advancing anti-oppression and social justice in healthcare through competency-based medical education (CBME)

    by Jamiu O. Busari, Linda Diffey, Karen E. Hauer, Kimberly D. Lomis, Jonathan M. Amiel, Michael A. Barone, Karen Schultz, H. Carrie Chen, Arvin Damodaran, David A. Turner, et al.

    Competency-based medical education (CBME) focuses on preparing physicians to improve the health of patients and populations. In the context of ongoing health disparities worldwide, medical educators must implement CBME in ways that advance social justice and anti-oppression. In this article, authors describe how CBME can be implemented to promote equity pedagogy, an approach to education in which curricular design, teaching, assessment strategies, and learning environments support learners from diverse groups to be successful. The five core components of CBME programs - outcomes competency framework, progressive sequencing of competencies, learning experiences tailored to learners' needs, teaching focused on competencies, and programmatic assessment - enable individualization of learning experiences and teaching and encourage learners to partner with their teachers in driving their learning. These educational approaches appreciate each learner's background, experiences, and strengths. Using an exemplar case study, the authors illustrate how CBME can afford opportunities to enhance anti-oppression and social justice in medical education and promote each learner's success in meeting the expected outcomes of training. The authors provide recommendations for individuals and institutions implementing CBME to enact equity pedagogy.


  • Open Access

    The Associations Between United States Medical Licensing Examination Performance and Outcomes of Patient Care

    by John Norcini, Irina Grabovsky, Michael A Barone, M. Brownell Med Anderson, Ravi S. Ma Pandian, Alex J. Mechaber

    Purpose The United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) comprises a series of assessments required for the licensure of United States MD-trained graduates as well as those who are trained internationally. Demonstration of a relationship between these examinations and outcomes of care is desirable for a process seeking to provide patients with safe and effective health care. Method This was a retrospective cohort study of 196,881 hospitalizations in Pennsylvania over a 3-year period (January 1, 2017–December 31, 2019), for 5 primary diagnoses: heart failure, acute myocardial infarction, stroke, pneumonia, or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. The 1,765 attending physicians for these hospitalizations self-identified as family physicians or general internists. A converted score based on USMLE Step 1, Step 2 Clinical Knowledge, and Step 3 scores was available and the outcome measures were in-hospital mortality and log length of stay (LOS). The research team controlled for characteristics of patients, hospitals, and physicians. Results For in-hospital mortality, the adjusted odds ratio was 0.94 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.90, .99; P < .02). Each standard deviation increase in the converted score was associated with a 5.51% reduction in the odds of in-hospital mortality. For log LOS, the adjusted estimate was 0.99 (95% CI = 0.98, 0.99; P < .001). Each standard deviation increase in the converted score was associated with a 1.34% reduction in log LOS. Conclusions Better provider USMLE performance was associated with lower in-hospital mortality and shorter log LOS for patients, although the magnitude of the latter is unlikely to be of practical significance. These findings add to the body of evidence that examines the validity of the USMLE licensure program.


  • Open Access

    How the Quadruple Aim Widens the Lens on the Transition to Residency

    by Michael A. Barone, Jessica L. Bienstock, Elise Lovell, John R. Gimpel, Grant L. Lin, Jennifer Swails, George C. Mejicano

    Medical education is interconnected with the health of the population. In recent years, reforms in undergraduate medical education (UME) and graduate medical education (GME) have attempted to align physician training outcomes with complexities in medical practice. Concerningly, UME and GME have not always worked in concert toward this aim. Various stages of medical education and practice remain siloed, and health outcomes in the United States lag behind other developed nations.1The Quadruple Aim, a framework highlighting the goals of lower costs, improved patient outcomes, improved care team experiences, and improved patient experiences, is accepted as a compass to optimize health system performance.2 Systems improvement goals in medical education should align with goals for health care, such as those in the Quadruple Aim.The Coalition for Physician Accountability recently convened the UME-GME Review Committee (UGRC) to address challenges in the UME-GME transition—including complexity, negative impact on well-being, costs, and inequities—and to make recommendations to improve the transition. In addition to individual members representing diverse perspectives, 10 organizations associated with medical education provided representatives. Among the guiding principles for the work were optimizing fit between applicants and programs to ensure the highest quality health care for patients and communities, and increasing trust between medical schools and residency programs. The work resulted in 34 recommendations across 9 themes.3When one considers the Quadruple Aim, it becomes clear that the UGRC recommendations, if implemented, have potential for direct and indirect positive impacts on patients, with indirect impacts being mediated through improved experiences and well-being of learners transitioning into residency (applicants) as well as residency program staff and faculty. Residency program directors are in the unique position of training the next generation of physicians and advancing the health of the public through the development of a sustainable, diverse, and competent workforce. Reviewing the UGRC recommendations through the lens of the Quadruple Aim demonstrates the importance of optimizing the UME-GME transition and emphasizes each medical educator's obligation to continuously improve this complex process to positively affect patients and all involved stakeholders. The Box provides guiding principles of the UGRC, and the Table provides themes, selected recommendations, and suggested actions program directors and others may take to improve the UME-GME transition. The online supplementary data provides additional detail about the UGRC's recommendations.The current transition places significant financial burdens on debt-laden applicants and overstretched residency program staff. Graduates from Liaison Committee on Medical Education–accredited schools have median educational debt from $200,000 to $215,000.4 Electronic Residency Application Service fees are substantial based on average numbers of applications submitted. Registration for the National Resident Matching Program and costs for interviewing and away rotations add to expenses. Applicants commit time reviewing suboptimal advising resources, preparing applications, and interviewing, all of which detracts time from their final year of medical school. Yet the stakes of not matching far outweigh monetary and opportunity costs, and applicant behavior has reflected this with year-over-year increases in applications submitted and programs ranked.5 In parallel, residency programs are overwhelmed by the volume of applications. The cost of recruitment and selection, measured in faculty time as well as financial expenditures, pulls resources from education and patient care.The UGRC recommendations address these problems. Recommendations for continued virtual interviews during the COVID-19 pandemic, and for ongoing studies on the benefits and disadvantages of in-person interviews and away rotations, are directed at controlling costs. Recommendations centered on providing low-cost, trustworthy program information in an easily accessible database will allow applicants to create a feasible application plan. If pilot programs that are aimed at helping students identify goals and reducing application numbers continue to gain support, costs may further be reduced for applicants and residency programs.Data suggest that physician racial and gender concordance is associated with better patient outcomes.6,7 Unfortunately, many aspects of the current UME-GME transition perpetuate inequities among applicants and disadvantage underrepresented in medicine (UIM) applicants applying for residency positions. UGRC recommendations aimed at decreasing the overemphasis on grades or examination scores can help mitigate the influence of minimal differences in group performance on residency selection.8 Recommendations focused on equity are aimed at mitigating structural biases toward UIM applicants as well as international and osteopathic applicants, many of whom struggle with belonging.9The UGRC recommendations also call for faculty development in anti-racism, avoiding bias, and ensuring equity.Residents serve critical roles in the delivery of care, and their ability to do so is affected by their clinical readiness and personal well-being.10 Ensuring applicant-program compatibility is critical to optimizing training. Many of the UGRC recommendations aimed at matching applicants and programs with corresponding mutual interests have the capacity to improve the experience of all members of the care team. In addition, UGRC recommendations focused on the availability of inclusive and trustworthy advising materials can help applicants find programs that fit their goals and needs. Recommendations aimed at improving resident onboarding and coaching can optimize both trainee well-being and, by extension, patients' experiences of care. For residency...


  • Blue Skies With Clouds: Envisioning the Future Ideal State and Identifying Ongoing Tensions in the UME–GME Transition

    by Karen E Hauer, Pamela M Williams, Julie S Byerley, Jennifer L Swails, Michael A Barone

    The transition from medical school to residency in the United States consumes large amounts of time for students and educators in undergraduate and graduate medical education (UME, GME), and it is costly for both students and institutions. Attempts to improve the residency application and Match processes have been insufficient to counteract the very large number of applications to programs. To address these challenges, the Coalition for Physician Accountability charged the Undergraduate Medical Education to Graduate Medical Education Review Committee (UGRC) with crafting recommendations to improve the system for the UME–GME transition. To guide this work, the UGRC defined and sought stakeholder input on a “blue-skies” ideal state of this transition. The ideal state views the transition as a system to support a continuum of professional development and learning, thus serving learners, educators, and the public, and engendering trust among them. It also supports the well-being of learners and educators, promotes diversity, and minimizes bias. This manuscript uses polarity thinking to analyze 3 persistent key tensions in the system that require ongoing management. First, the formative purpose of assessment for learning and growth is at odds with the use of assessment data for ranking and sorting candidates. Second, the function of residents as learners can conflict with their role as workers contributing service to health care systems. Third, the current residency Match process can position the desire for individual choice—among students and their programs—against the workforce needs of the profession and the public. This Scholarly Perspective presents strategies to balance the upsides and downsides inherent to these tensions. By articulating the ideal state of the UME–GME transition and anticipating tensions, educators and educational organizations can be better positioned to implement UGRC recommendations to improve the transition system.


  • In Reply to D’Eon and Kleinheksel

    by Katie L. Arnhart, Monica M. Cuddy, David Ma Johnson, Michael A Barone, Aaron Young