Elizabeth Chatterjee
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Elizabeth Chatterjee has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Sneha Krishnan
University of Oxford Oxford UK
2 shared publications - Anne Murphy
Lancaster University Management School
1 shared publication - Antoine Acker1 shared publication
- Heidi Pauwels
University of Washington
1 shared publication - Lukas Becker1 shared publication
M. Eaton
Royal Asiatic Society, Stephenson Way, London NW, HD UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 31 January 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Past & Present
- Vol. 268 (1) , 181-224
Dams and the Deep Earth: The 1967 Koyna Earthquake and Human Agency in the Anthropocene
On 11 December 1967, a large earthquake devastated the village of Koynanagar in Maharashtra, western India. Many blamed the new Koyna hydroelectric dam nearby. Prompting international inquests, Koyna became perhaps the world’s most famous case of reservoir-induced seismicity, a novel type of earthquake triggered by human activities. We use the dam’s history to explore the emergent consciousness of human geophysical agency that characterizes the Anthropocene, the putative new epoch when humans have become a planetary-scale ‘force of Nature’. The dam was explicitly designed as a geotechnical assemblage, a blending of technology, mountain topography, monsoon waters and rock. Striking a supposedly stable region, the 1967 earthquake revealed the more-than-human unpredictability of this composite. Scientists began to trace a radically new form of human agency at work, which owed its effects to complex chains of causality that extended deep underground and backward into deep history. Yet there was remarkably little policy fallout. Dam construction only accelerated in seismically active areas. The debates over reservoir-induced seismicity showed that human geotechnical agency could be read in diametrically opposed ways: as a source of anxiety or hubris, or simply irrelevant to practical policy making, thereby presaging today’s debates over human planetary stewardship in the Anthropocene.
- 31 January 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Past & Present
- Vol. 268 (1) , 181-224
Dams and the Deep Earth: The 1967 Koyna Earthquake and Human Agency in the Anthropocene
On 11 December 1967, a large earthquake devastated the village of Koynanagar in Maharashtra, western India. Many blamed the new Koyna hydroelectric dam nearby. Prompting international inquests, Koyna became perhaps the world’s most famous case of reservoir-induced seismicity, a novel type of earthquake triggered by human activities. We use the dam’s history to explore the emergent consciousness of human geophysical agency that characterizes the Anthropocene, the putative new epoch when humans have become a planetary-scale ‘force of Nature’. The dam was explicitly designed as a geotechnical assemblage, a blending of technology, mountain topography, monsoon waters and rock. Striking a supposedly stable region, the 1967 earthquake revealed the more-than-human unpredictability of this composite. Scientists began to trace a radically new form of human agency at work, which owed its effects to complex chains of causality that extended deep underground and backward into deep history. Yet there was remarkably little policy fallout. Dam construction only accelerated in seismically active areas. The debates over reservoir-induced seismicity showed that human geotechnical agency could be read in diametrically opposed ways: as a source of anxiety or hubris, or simply irrelevant to practical policy making, thereby presaging today’s debates over human planetary stewardship in the Anthropocene.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The American Historical Review
- Vol. 129 (3) , 1311-1313
Stephen G. Gross and Andrew Needham, ed. New Energies: A History of Energy Transitions in Europe and North America.
Energy history today stands on the cusp of emergence as a full-grown subfield, boasting a dedicated journal and producing a reliable outflow of workshops, conference panels, and other symptoms of adolescence. As the landmark collection New Energies acknowledges, much of the recent surge of interest has been motivated by the contemporary climate crisis. To some extent sidelining its earlier associations with business history and the history of technology, the putative “new energy history” of the past decade has developed in close alliance with environmental history. Setting their face firmly against critiques of presentism, editors Stephen Gross and Andrew Needham accordingly urge attention to previous transformations in societal energy regimes in order to excavate “a past usable for the present moment” (8). The 13 chapters that follow provide powerful evidence of the intellectual vibrancy and thematic range of this new energy history. As its subtitle suggests, the volume’s guiding concept is the “energy transition,” a term borrowed from climate policy analysts now increasingly foraying onto historians’ terrain. Gross and Needham’s introduction eloquently demolishes the idea that past transitions have historically proven smooth and linear, the “age of wood” seamlessly giving way to the “age of coal” and on to the “age of oil” or the atom. It is by now a virtual truism of historical research that energy transitions have typically been protracted and contested. At least in the medium term, new fuels have not so much replaced older sources but amplified their use within an overall trend of ever-intensifying resource use, a “layering” that creates “new and ‘hybrid’ forms of energy provision, energy services, and energy consumption” (15). The proliferation of working horses well into the “age of steam” is the classic example, but in this volume it appears most starkly in the hidden persistence of coal.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The American Historical Review
- Vol. 129 (3) , 1311-1313
Stephen G. Gross and Andrew Needham, ed. New Energies: A History of Energy Transitions in Europe and North America.
Energy history today stands on the cusp of emergence as a full-grown subfield, boasting a dedicated journal and producing a reliable outflow of workshops, conference panels, and other symptoms of adolescence. As the landmark collection New Energies acknowledges, much of the recent surge of interest has been motivated by the contemporary climate crisis. To some extent sidelining its earlier associations with business history and the history of technology, the putative “new energy history” of the past decade has developed in close alliance with environmental history. Setting their face firmly against critiques of presentism, editors Stephen Gross and Andrew Needham accordingly urge attention to previous transformations in societal energy regimes in order to excavate “a past usable for the present moment” (8). The 13 chapters that follow provide powerful evidence of the intellectual vibrancy and thematic range of this new energy history. As its subtitle suggests, the volume’s guiding concept is the “energy transition,” a term borrowed from climate policy analysts now increasingly foraying onto historians’ terrain. Gross and Needham’s introduction eloquently demolishes the idea that past transitions have historically proven smooth and linear, the “age of wood” seamlessly giving way to the “age of coal” and on to the “age of oil” or the atom. It is by now a virtual truism of historical research that energy transitions have typically been protracted and contested. At least in the medium term, new fuels have not so much replaced older sources but amplified their use within an overall trend of ever-intensifying resource use, a “layering” that creates “new and ‘hybrid’ forms of energy provision, energy services, and energy consumption” (15). The proliferation of working horses well into the “age of steam” is the classic example, but in this volume it appears most starkly in the hidden persistence of coal.
- 1 June 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The American Historical Review
- Vol. 129 (2) , 429-466
Late Acceleration
The energy crisis of the early 1970s briefly opened up a radically new horizon of energetic possibilities that played out differently around the world. For India, that energy crisis did not begin with the famous Arab oil embargo of 1973. Instead, like many poor oil-importing nations, it experienced the first oil shock as merely one component of a broader climate-food-energy emergency that reverberated throughout the political system. This crisis brought a twinned set of fateful changes. By June 1975, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi had resorted to imposing a constitutional dictatorship—the Emergency—for the first and only time in independent India’s existence, one among a series of coups and authoritarian takeovers that swept the Global South. Less noticed was a second transformation with planetary ramifications. Rising popular expectations collided with the energy crisis to impel a state-led embrace of coal, despite elite reservations about the environmental damage that would follow. Analyzing these dynamics is crucial to understanding India’s intensifying coal dependence, and its rapidly rising carbon emissions, in the decades that followed. Only when we accurately recognize the forces that created and hold carbon-intensive energy regimes in place can we begin to see how they might be dislodged.
- 1 June 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The American Historical Review
- Vol. 129 (2) , 429-466
Late Acceleration
The energy crisis of the early 1970s briefly opened up a radically new horizon of energetic possibilities that played out differently around the world. For India, that energy crisis did not begin with the famous Arab oil embargo of 1973. Instead, like many poor oil-importing nations, it experienced the first oil shock as merely one component of a broader climate-food-energy emergency that reverberated throughout the political system. This crisis brought a twinned set of fateful changes. By June 1975, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi had resorted to imposing a constitutional dictatorship—the Emergency—for the first and only time in independent India’s existence, one among a series of coups and authoritarian takeovers that swept the Global South. Less noticed was a second transformation with planetary ramifications. Rising popular expectations collided with the energy crisis to impel a state-led embrace of coal, despite elite reservations about the environmental damage that would follow. Analyzing these dynamics is crucial to understanding India’s intensifying coal dependence, and its rapidly rising carbon emissions, in the decades that followed. Only when we accurately recognize the forces that created and hold carbon-intensive energy regimes in place can we begin to see how they might be dislodged.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Comparative Studies in Society and History
- Vol. 66 (3) , 528-556
Towards an Energetics of Class: Comparing Energy Protests in India and the United States
From Iran and Mozambique to France’s Gilets jaunes, consumer energy protests are ubiquitous today. Little historical scholarship has so far explored such “fuel riots,” the problematic moniker bestowed by contemporary policy scholars. This article argues for disaggregating the homogenous crowd of so-called rioters, instead analyzing why particular socioeconomic groups persistently take to the streets. To do this, it sketches an energy-centered approach to class with both structural and subjective axes. This analytic is applied to a comparative history of two of the best-documented energy protests of the last half-century. During the 1970s, independent truckers blocked American highways to protest the high price of motor fuel. A decade later, half a million North Indian farmers mobilized to demand cheaper and more reliable electricity. Half a world apart, the two movements shared key characteristics. They were the expression of specific class fractions whose material interests were conditioned by heavy dependence on state-mediated energy supplies. Awkwardly located between big capital and wage labor, both truckers and farmers owned stakes in the carbon-intensive means of production that left them exposed to volatility in energy quality and pricing. Both mobilized in reaction to perceived breaches of state-centered moral economies of energy which threatened this dependence, leveraging their power to interrupt supplies within the circulatory systems of fossil fuel society. Even as both movements failed in their own terms, their political resistance helped to lock in place consumer subsidies for cheap carbon-intensive energy. Such energy protests deserve a central role in our environmental histories of fossil fuel society.
- 1 April 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Comparative Studies in Society and History
- Vol. 66 (3) , 528-556
Open AccessTowards an Energetics of Class: Comparing Energy Protests in India and the United States
From Iran and Mozambique to France’s Gilets jaunes, consumer energy protests are ubiquitous today. Little historical scholarship has so far explored such “fuel riots,” the problematic moniker bestowed by contemporary policy scholars. This article argues for disaggregating the homogenous crowd of so-called rioters, instead analyzing why particular socioeconomic groups persistently take to the streets. To do this, it sketches an energy-centered approach to class with both structural and subjective axes. This analytic is applied to a comparative history of two of the best-documented energy protests of the last half-century. During the 1970s, independent truckers blocked American highways to protest the high price of motor fuel. A decade later, half a million North Indian farmers mobilized to demand cheaper and more reliable electricity. Half a world apart, the two movements shared key characteristics. They were the expression of specific class fractions whose material interests were conditioned by heavy dependence on state-mediated energy supplies. Awkwardly located between big capital and wage labor, both truckers and farmers owned stakes in the carbon-intensive means of production that left them exposed to volatility in energy quality and pricing. Both mobilized in reaction to perceived breaches of state-centered moral economies of energy which threatened this dependence, leveraging their power to interrupt supplies within the circulatory systems of fossil fuel society. Even as both movements failed in their own terms, their political resistance helped to lock in place consumer subsidies for cheap carbon-intensive energy. Such energy protests deserve a central role in our environmental histories of fossil fuel society.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 229-243
Fossil fuels from extraction to emissions
When fossils became fuels, the path towards the current crisis of climate change might seem to have been set. However, their use as energy sources and the unfolding of the current climate crisis was neither inevitable nor predetermined, but rather the result of complex historical processes and decisions. To truly understand the all-encompassing position fossil fuels have come to take in modern societies, we must understand their entire lifecycle from extraction to emission and how these processes engendered dynamics of dependency and domination on our way into the Anthropocene. By approaching this topic from diverse perspectives located within the Global South, this chapter highlights the global and interconnected character of this phenomenon. In re-mapping the historical structures underlying fossil fuel expansion, the chapter shows that they paradoxically centre both on processes of empire making and unmaking and in patterns of colonial resource exploitation continuing in altered forms in the construction of postcolonial developmental regimes. In this way the aim is not only to tease out the genealogy of the climate crisis, but also to demonstrate the importance and utility of history as a discipline within environmental debates, helping understand our current situation and our future still unknown.
- 6 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 229-243
Fossil fuels from extraction to emissions
When fossils became fuels, the path towards the current crisis of climate change might seem to have been set. However, their use as energy sources and the unfolding of the current climate crisis was neither inevitable nor predetermined, but rather the result of complex historical processes and decisions. To truly understand the all-encompassing position fossil fuels have come to take in modern societies, we must understand their entire lifecycle from extraction to emission and how these processes engendered dynamics of dependency and domination on our way into the Anthropocene. By approaching this topic from diverse perspectives located within the Global South, this chapter highlights the global and interconnected character of this phenomenon. In re-mapping the historical structures underlying fossil fuel expansion, the chapter shows that they paradoxically centre both on processes of empire making and unmaking and in patterns of colonial resource exploitation continuing in altered forms in the construction of postcolonial developmental regimes. In this way the aim is not only to tease out the genealogy of the climate crisis, but also to demonstrate the importance and utility of history as a discipline within environmental debates, helping understand our current situation and our future still unknown.
- Open Access
- 4 April 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Global History
- Vol. 18 (3) , 439-460
The poor woman’s energy: Low-modernist solar technologies and international development, 1878–1966
Solar energy often appears a resource without a history, perpetually novel and promising futuristic abundance. This overlooks a long episode of ‘low-modernist’ solar research in and for the global South. Focusing especially on India and detouring through Mexico, two important arenas for early solar experimentation, this article traces an alternative history of solar technologies as austere everyday fixes for developing countries. In parallel with the well-known postcolonial focus on high-modernist energy mega-projects, the narrow transnational community of solar experts retained a competing tendency to think small. At its heart lay a dualistic conception of the modern energy economy: flexible and resource-intensive grid electricity for urban centres, inferior off-grid devices to meet the minimal and static needs of the rural poor. This impoverished, feminized Third World projected user base resulted in persistent underinvestment and failed commercialization, helping to explain why solar technologies did not take off earlier. While solar experts emphasized the regional exceptionalism of the arid tropics, the teleological linkage between modernity and ever-rising energy abundance was rejuvenated from below as rural communities began to imagine the high-energy good life as a universal aspiration.
- 4 April 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Global History
- Vol. 18 (3) , 439-460
Open AccessThe poor woman’s energy: Low-modernist solar technologies and international development, 1878–1966
Solar energy often appears a resource without a history, perpetually novel and promising futuristic abundance. This overlooks a long episode of ‘low-modernist’ solar research in and for the global South. Focusing especially on India and detouring through Mexico, two important arenas for early solar experimentation, this article traces an alternative history of solar technologies as austere everyday fixes for developing countries. In parallel with the well-known postcolonial focus on high-modernist energy mega-projects, the narrow transnational community of solar experts retained a competing tendency to think small. At its heart lay a dualistic conception of the modern energy economy: flexible and resource-intensive grid electricity for urban centres, inferior off-grid devices to meet the minimal and static needs of the rural poor. This impoverished, feminized Third World projected user base resulted in persistent underinvestment and failed commercialization, helping to explain why solar technologies did not take off earlier. While solar experts emphasized the regional exceptionalism of the arid tropics, the teleological linkage between modernity and ever-rising energy abundance was rejuvenated from below as rural communities began to imagine the high-energy good life as a universal aspiration.
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 April 2023
- Published by University of California Press in Current History
- Vol. 122 (843) , 123-130
India’s Oligarchic State Capitalism
Almost nine years into Narendra Modi’s premiership, there is little sign of an ideological commitment to the free market at the apex of the Indian state. Instead, this article characterizes India’s developmental model as a form of state capitalism, structured by the government’s direct influence on economic relationships. The Modi government took office in the midst of a legitimacy crisis generated by the state-dominated financial system. In response, it has fostered an increasingly oligarchic state capitalism, aiming to mobilize private resources through a narrow alliance of state and business interests. This strategy entails serious economic distortions and political risks.
- 1 April 2023
- Published by University of California Press in Current History
- Vol. 122 (843) , 123-130
Top Cited PapersIndia’s Oligarchic State Capitalism
Almost nine years into Narendra Modi’s premiership, there is little sign of an ideological commitment to the free market at the apex of the Indian state. Instead, this article characterizes India’s developmental model as a form of state capitalism, structured by the government’s direct influence on economic relationships. The Modi government took office in the midst of a legitimacy crisis generated by the state-dominated financial system. In response, it has fostered an increasingly oligarchic state capitalism, aiming to mobilize private resources through a narrow alliance of state and business interests. This strategy entails serious economic distortions and political risks.
- 1 August 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 59 (15) , 3222-3224
Book review: Demanding Development: The Politics of Public Goods Provision in India’s Urban Slums
- 1 August 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 59 (15) , 3222-3224
Book review: Demanding Development: The Politics of Public Goods Provision in India’s Urban Slums
- Open Access
- 29 March 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society
- Vol. 31 (2) , b1-b5
JRA volume 31 issue 2 Cover and Back matter
- 29 March 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society
- Vol. 31 (2) , b1-b5
Open AccessJRA volume 31 issue 2 Cover and Back matter
- 19 February 2020
- Published by Wiley in Development and Change
- Vol. 53 (1) , 58-83
New Developmentalism and its Discontents: State Activism in Modi's Gujarat and India
Regimes around the world are experimenting with combinations of economic liberalization and revived state‐activist strategies, producing ‘new developmentalist’ hybrids. This article suggests that a distinctive variant of new developmentalism is emerging in India. Its paradigmatic example crystallized in Gujarat, before and during Narendra Modi's tenure as Chief Minister (2001–14), and was taken national during Modi's first term as India's Prime Minister (2014–19). While scholars have highlighted the aggressively pro‐business industrial policy of the ‘Gujarat model’, closer examination reveals that this state intervention was more direct and extensive than previously acknowledged. The state took on a diversity of functions, particularly focused on infrastructure. These included not only classic developmental activities such as midwifing new industries or supporting select private enterprises, but also corrective functions: disciplining consumers, compensating reform losers, and repairing the bureaucratic apparatus. Today, in the face of predictions of radical deregulation or corporate rule, this reinvented statism is visible at the all‐India level. However, its history also illustrates the brittleness of India's new developmentalism, including its tendencies towards incumbency bias, resource misallocation, and debt. Political responses have often weakened accountability rather than tackling underlying problems. Both in India and elsewhere, the sustainability of new developmentalism appears uncertain.
- 19 February 2020
- Published by Wiley in Development and Change
- Vol. 53 (1) , 58-83
New Developmentalism and its Discontents: State Activism in Modi's Gujarat and India
Regimes around the world are experimenting with combinations of economic liberalization and revived state‐activist strategies, producing ‘new developmentalist’ hybrids. This article suggests that a distinctive variant of new developmentalism is emerging in India. Its paradigmatic example crystallized in Gujarat, before and during Narendra Modi's tenure as Chief Minister (2001–14), and was taken national during Modi's first term as India's Prime Minister (2014–19). While scholars have highlighted the aggressively pro‐business industrial policy of the ‘Gujarat model’, closer examination reveals that this state intervention was more direct and extensive than previously acknowledged. The state took on a diversity of functions, particularly focused on infrastructure. These included not only classic developmental activities such as midwifing new industries or supporting select private enterprises, but also corrective functions: disciplining consumers, compensating reform losers, and repairing the bureaucratic apparatus. Today, in the face of predictions of radical deregulation or corporate rule, this reinvented statism is visible at the all‐India level. However, its history also illustrates the brittleness of India's new developmentalism, including its tendencies towards incumbency bias, resource misallocation, and debt. Political responses have often weakened accountability rather than tackling underlying problems. Both in India and elsewhere, the sustainability of new developmentalism appears uncertain.