Lucio Baggio
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Lucio Baggio has a total of 96 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Franck Montmessin
LATMOS/IPSL UVSQ Université Paris‐Saclay Sorbonne Université CNRS Guyancourt France
20 shared publications - Oleg Korablev
Space Research Institute (IKI) Russian Academy of Sciences (RAS) Moscow Russia
20 shared publications - Franck Lefèvre
LATMOS Sorbonne Université UVSQ Paris‐Saclay CNRS Paris France
19 shared publications - Juan Alday
Instituto de Astrofisica de Andalucía
19 shared publications - Kevin Sutherland Olsen
Department of Physics University of Oxford Oxford UK
16 shared publications - Alexander Trokhimovskiy
Space Research Institute (IKI) Moscow Russia
13 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 August 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 129 (8)
Relationships Between HCl, H2O, Aerosols, and Temperature in the Martian Atmosphere: 1. Climatological Outlook
Detecting trace gases such as hydrogen chloride (HCl) in Mars' atmosphere is among the primary objectives of the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) mission. Terrestrially, HCl is closely associated with active volcanic activity, so its detection on Mars was expected to point to some form of active magmatism/outgassing. However, after its discovery using the mid‐infrared channel of the TGO Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ACS MIR), a clear seasonality was observed, beginning with a sudden increase in HCl abundance from below detection limits to 1–3 ppbv in both hemispheres coincident with the start of dust activity, followed by very sudden and rapid loss at the southern autumnal equinox. In this study, we have investigated the relationship between HCl and atmospheric dust by making comparisons in the vertical distribution of gases measured with ACS and aerosols measured co‐located with the Mars Climate Sounder (MCS). This study includes HCl, water vapor, and ozone measured using ACS MIR, water vapor and temperature measured with the near infrared channel of ACS, and temperature, dust opacity, and water ice opacity measured with MCS. In part 1, we show that dust loading has a strong impact in temperature, which controls the abundance of water ice and water vapor, and that HCl is very closely linked to water activity. In part 2, we investigate the quantitative correlations between each quantity and discuss the possible source and sinks of HCl, their likelihood given the correlations, and any issues arising from them.
- 27 August 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 129 (8)
Open AccessRelationships Between HCl, H2O, Aerosols, and Temperature in the Martian Atmosphere: 1. Climatological Outlook
Detecting trace gases such as hydrogen chloride (HCl) in Mars' atmosphere is among the primary objectives of the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) mission. Terrestrially, HCl is closely associated with active volcanic activity, so its detection on Mars was expected to point to some form of active magmatism/outgassing. However, after its discovery using the mid‐infrared channel of the TGO Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ACS MIR), a clear seasonality was observed, beginning with a sudden increase in HCl abundance from below detection limits to 1–3 ppbv in both hemispheres coincident with the start of dust activity, followed by very sudden and rapid loss at the southern autumnal equinox. In this study, we have investigated the relationship between HCl and atmospheric dust by making comparisons in the vertical distribution of gases measured with ACS and aerosols measured co‐located with the Mars Climate Sounder (MCS). This study includes HCl, water vapor, and ozone measured using ACS MIR, water vapor and temperature measured with the near infrared channel of ACS, and temperature, dust opacity, and water ice opacity measured with MCS. In part 1, we show that dust loading has a strong impact in temperature, which controls the abundance of water ice and water vapor, and that HCl is very closely linked to water activity. In part 2, we investigate the quantitative correlations between each quantity and discuss the possible source and sinks of HCl, their likelihood given the correlations, and any issues arising from them.
- Open Access
- 27 August 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 129 (8)
Relationships Between HCl, H2O, Aerosols, and Temperature in the Martian Atmosphere: 2. Quantitative Correlations
The detection of hydrogen chloride (HCl) in the atmosphere of Mars was among the primary objectives of the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) mission. Its discovery using the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite mid‐infrared channel (ACS MIR) showed a distinct seasonality and possible link to dust activity. This paper is part 2 of a study investigating the link between HCl and aerosols by comparing gas measurements made with TGO to dust and water ice opacities measured with the Mars Climate Sounder (MCS). In part 1, we showed, and compared, the seasonal evolution of vertical profiles of HCl, water vapor, temperature, dust opacity, and water ice opacity over the dusty periods around perihelion (solar longitudes 180°–360°) across Mars years 34–36. In part 2, we investigated the quantitative correlations in the vertical distribution between each quantity, as well as ozone. We show that there is a strong positive correlation between HCl and water vapor, which is expected due to fast photochemical production rates for HCl when reacting with water vapor photolysis products. We also show a strong positive correlation between water vapor and temperature, but are unable to show any correlation between temperature and HCl. There are weak correlations between the opacities of dust and water ice, and dust and water vapor, but only very low correlations between dust and HCl. We close with a discussion of possible sources and sinks and that interactions between HCl and water ice are the most likely for both, given the inter‐comparison.
- 27 August 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 129 (8)
Open AccessRelationships Between HCl, H2O, Aerosols, and Temperature in the Martian Atmosphere: 2. Quantitative Correlations
The detection of hydrogen chloride (HCl) in the atmosphere of Mars was among the primary objectives of the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) mission. Its discovery using the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite mid‐infrared channel (ACS MIR) showed a distinct seasonality and possible link to dust activity. This paper is part 2 of a study investigating the link between HCl and aerosols by comparing gas measurements made with TGO to dust and water ice opacities measured with the Mars Climate Sounder (MCS). In part 1, we showed, and compared, the seasonal evolution of vertical profiles of HCl, water vapor, temperature, dust opacity, and water ice opacity over the dusty periods around perihelion (solar longitudes 180°–360°) across Mars years 34–36. In part 2, we investigated the quantitative correlations in the vertical distribution between each quantity, as well as ozone. We show that there is a strong positive correlation between HCl and water vapor, which is expected due to fast photochemical production rates for HCl when reacting with water vapor photolysis products. We also show a strong positive correlation between water vapor and temperature, but are unable to show any correlation between temperature and HCl. There are weak correlations between the opacities of dust and water ice, and dust and water vapor, but only very low correlations between dust and HCl. We close with a discussion of possible sources and sinks and that interactions between HCl and water ice are the most likely for both, given the inter‐comparison.
- Open Access
- 5 March 2024
- Published by Wiley
Relationships between HCl, H2O, aerosols, and temperature in the Martian atmosphere Part I: climatological outloo
Detecting trace gases such as hydrogen chloride (HCl) in Mars' atmosphere is among the primary objectives of the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) mission. Terrestrially, HCl is closely associated with active volcanic activity, so its detection on Mars was expected to point to some form of active magmatism/outgassing. However, after its discovery using the mid-infrared channel of the TGO Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ACS MIR), a clear seasonality was observed, beginning with a sudden increase in HCl
- 5 March 2024
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessRelationships between HCl, H2O, aerosols, and temperature in the Martian atmosphere Part I: climatological outloo
Detecting trace gases such as hydrogen chloride (HCl) in Mars' atmosphere is among the primary objectives of the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) mission. Terrestrially, HCl is closely associated with active volcanic activity, so its detection on Mars was expected to point to some form of active magmatism/outgassing. However, after its discovery using the mid-infrared channel of the TGO Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ACS MIR), a clear seasonality was observed, beginning with a sudden increase in HCl
- 11 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Astronomy
- Vol. 7 (7) , 867-876
Photochemical depletion of heavy CO isotopes in the Martian atmosphere
- 11 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Astronomy
- Vol. 7 (7) , 867-876
Photochemical depletion of heavy CO isotopes in the Martian atmosphere
- Open Access
- 4 January 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Photochemistry on Mars reduces the abundance of heavy isotopes in atmospheric CO and their escape efficiency to space
The atmosphere of Mars is enriched in heavy isotopes with respect to Earth as a result of the escape of the atmosphere to space over billions of years. Estimating the enrichment in heavy isotopes due to atmospheric escape requires a rigorous understanding of all atmospheric processes that contribute to the evolution of isotopic ratios between the lower and upper atmosphere, where escape processes take place. Using a combination of vertical profiles from the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter) with the predictions of a photochemical model, we provide evidence for a new process of photochemistry-induced fractionation that depletes the heavy isotopes of C and O in CO. Accounting for this new source of fractionation, we find that only a fraction of ≈12% of the atmosphere needs to have been lost to space through CO photochemical escape to explain the enrichment of 13C/12C in CO2 measured by the Curiosity Rover.
- 4 January 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessPhotochemistry on Mars reduces the abundance of heavy isotopes in atmospheric CO and their escape efficiency to space
The atmosphere of Mars is enriched in heavy isotopes with respect to Earth as a result of the escape of the atmosphere to space over billions of years. Estimating the enrichment in heavy isotopes due to atmospheric escape requires a rigorous understanding of all atmospheric processes that contribute to the evolution of isotopic ratios between the lower and upper atmosphere, where escape processes take place. Using a combination of vertical profiles from the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter) with the predictions of a photochemical model, we provide evidence for a new process of photochemistry-induced fractionation that depletes the heavy isotopes of C and O in CO. Accounting for this new source of fractionation, we find that only a fraction of ≈12% of the atmosphere needs to have been lost to space through CO photochemical escape to explain the enrichment of 13C/12C in CO2 measured by the Curiosity Rover.
- Open Access
- 27 December 2022
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 127 (12)
A Two Martian Years Survey of Water Ice Clouds on Mars With ACS Onboard TGO
The middle infrared (MIR) channel of the atmospheric chemistry suite (ACS) instrument onboard the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter ESA‐Roscosmos mission has performed Solar occultation measurements of the Martian atmosphere in the 2.3–4.2 μm spectral range since March 2018, which now covers two Martian years (MY). We use the methodology previously developed for the study of the MY 34 global dust storm (GDS) (Stcherbinine et al., 2020, https://doi.org/10.1029/2019je006300 ) to monitor the properties (effective radii, extinction, and altitude) of the Martian water ice clouds over the first two Martian years covered by ACS‐MIR. The observations encompass the period L s = 163° in MY 34 to L s = 181° in MY 36. We determine that the typical altitude of the clouds varies by 20–40 km between the summer and winter, with a maximum extension up to 80 km during summer in the midlatitudes. Similarly, we also note that for a limited temporal range, the altitude of the clouds also varies by 20–40 km between the polar regions and the midlatitudes. We also compare observations acquired during the MY 34 GDS to observations from the same period in MY 35, using the latter as a reference to characterize the effects of this GDS on the clouds' properties. In addition, we compare our retrievals with the predictions of the Mars planetary climate model, which shows a reasonable agreement overall for the altitude of the clouds, although the model usually predicts lower altitudes for the top of the clouds.
- 27 December 2022
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 127 (12)
Open AccessA Two Martian Years Survey of Water Ice Clouds on Mars With ACS Onboard TGO
The middle infrared (MIR) channel of the atmospheric chemistry suite (ACS) instrument onboard the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter ESA‐Roscosmos mission has performed Solar occultation measurements of the Martian atmosphere in the 2.3–4.2 μm spectral range since March 2018, which now covers two Martian years (MY). We use the methodology previously developed for the study of the MY 34 global dust storm (GDS) (Stcherbinine et al., 2020, https://doi.org/10.1029/2019je006300 ) to monitor the properties (effective radii, extinction, and altitude) of the Martian water ice clouds over the first two Martian years covered by ACS‐MIR. The observations encompass the period L s = 163° in MY 34 to L s = 181° in MY 36. We determine that the typical altitude of the clouds varies by 20–40 km between the summer and winter, with a maximum extension up to 80 km during summer in the midlatitudes. Similarly, we also note that for a limited temporal range, the altitude of the clouds also varies by 20–40 km between the polar regions and the midlatitudes. We also compare observations acquired during the MY 34 GDS to observations from the same period in MY 35, using the latter as a reference to characterize the effects of this GDS on the clouds' properties. In addition, we compare our retrievals with the predictions of the Mars planetary climate model, which shows a reasonable agreement overall for the altitude of the clouds, although the model usually predicts lower altitudes for the top of the clouds.
- Open Access
- 24 October 2022
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 127 (10)
Seasonal Changes in the Vertical Structure of Ozone in the Martian Lower Atmosphere and Its Relationship to Water Vapor
The mid‐infrared channel of the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ACS MIR) onboard the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter is capable of observing the infrared absorption of ozone (O3) in the atmosphere of Mars. During solar occulations, the 003←000 band (3,000‐3,060 cm−1) is observed with spectral sampling of ∼0.045 cm−1. Around the equinoxes in both hemispheres and over the southern winters, we regularly observe around 200–500 ppbv of O3 below 30 km. The warm southern summers, near perihelion, produce enough atmospheric moisture that O3 is not detectable at all, and observations are rare even at high northern latitudes. During the northern summers, water vapor is restricted to below 10 km, and an O3 layer (100–300 ppbv) is visible between 20 and 30 km. At this same time, the aphelion cloud belt forms, condensing water vapor and allowing O3 to build up between 30 and 40 km. A comparison to vertical profiles of water vapor and temperature in each season reveals that water vapor abundance is controlled by atmospheric temperature, and H2O and O3 are anti‐correlated as expected. When the atmosphere cools, over time or over altitude, water vapor condenses (observed as a reduction in its mixing ratio) and the production of odd hydrogen species is reduced, which allows O3 to build up. Conversely, warmer temperatures lead to water vapor enhancements and ozone loss. The LMD Mars Global Climate Model is able to reproduce vertical structure and seasonal changes of temperature, H2O, and O3 that we observe. However, the observed O3 abundance is larger by factors between 2 and 6, indicating important differences in the rate of odd‐hydrogen photochemistry.
- 24 October 2022
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 127 (10)
Open AccessSeasonal Changes in the Vertical Structure of Ozone in the Martian Lower Atmosphere and Its Relationship to Water Vapor
The mid‐infrared channel of the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ACS MIR) onboard the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter is capable of observing the infrared absorption of ozone (O3) in the atmosphere of Mars. During solar occulations, the 003←000 band (3,000‐3,060 cm−1) is observed with spectral sampling of ∼0.045 cm−1. Around the equinoxes in both hemispheres and over the southern winters, we regularly observe around 200–500 ppbv of O3 below 30 km. The warm southern summers, near perihelion, produce enough atmospheric moisture that O3 is not detectable at all, and observations are rare even at high northern latitudes. During the northern summers, water vapor is restricted to below 10 km, and an O3 layer (100–300 ppbv) is visible between 20 and 30 km. At this same time, the aphelion cloud belt forms, condensing water vapor and allowing O3 to build up between 30 and 40 km. A comparison to vertical profiles of water vapor and temperature in each season reveals that water vapor abundance is controlled by atmospheric temperature, and H2O and O3 are anti‐correlated as expected. When the atmosphere cools, over time or over altitude, water vapor condenses (observed as a reduction in its mixing ratio) and the production of odd hydrogen species is reduced, which allows O3 to build up. Conversely, warmer temperatures lead to water vapor enhancements and ozone loss. The LMD Mars Global Climate Model is able to reproduce vertical structure and seasonal changes of temperature, H2O, and O3 that we observe. However, the observed O3 abundance is larger by factors between 2 and 6, indicating important differences in the rate of odd‐hydrogen photochemistry.
- Open Access
- 14 February 2022
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Seasonal changes in the vertical structure of ozone in the Martian lower atmosphere and its relationship to water vapour
The mid-infrared channel of the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ACS MIR) onboard the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter is capable of observing the infrared absorption of ozone (O3) in the atmosphere of Mars. During solar occulations, the 003-000 band (3000-3060 cm-1) is observed with spectral sampling of ˜0.045 cm-1. Around the equinoxes in both hemispheres and over the southern winters, we regularly observe around 200-500 ppbv of O3 below 30 km. The warm southern summers, near perihelion, produce enough atmospheric moisture that O3 is not detectable at all, and observations are rare even at high northern latitudes. During the northern summers, water vapour is restricted to below 10 km, and an O3 layer (100-300 ppbv) is visible between 20-30 km. At this same time, the aphelion cloud belt forms, condensing water vapour and allowing O3 to build up between 30-40 km. A comparison to vertical profiles of water vapour and temperature in each season reveals that water vapour abundance is controlled by atmospheric temperature, and H2O and O3 are anti-correlated as expected. When the atmosphere cools, over time or over altitude, water vapour condenses (observed as a reduction in its mixing ratio) and the production of odd hydrogen species is reduced, which allows O3 to build up. Conversely, warmer temperatures lead to water vapour enhancements and ozone loss. The LMD Mars Global Climate Model is able to reproduce vertical structure and seasonal changes of temperature, H2O, and O3 that we observe. However, the observed O3 abundance is larger by a factor of 2-6, indicating important differences in the rate of odd-hydrogen photochemistry.
- 14 February 2022
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Open AccessSeasonal changes in the vertical structure of ozone in the Martian lower atmosphere and its relationship to water vapour
The mid-infrared channel of the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ACS MIR) onboard the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter is capable of observing the infrared absorption of ozone (O3) in the atmosphere of Mars. During solar occulations, the 003-000 band (3000-3060 cm-1) is observed with spectral sampling of ˜0.045 cm-1. Around the equinoxes in both hemispheres and over the southern winters, we regularly observe around 200-500 ppbv of O3 below 30 km. The warm southern summers, near perihelion, produce enough atmospheric moisture that O3 is not detectable at all, and observations are rare even at high northern latitudes. During the northern summers, water vapour is restricted to below 10 km, and an O3 layer (100-300 ppbv) is visible between 20-30 km. At this same time, the aphelion cloud belt forms, condensing water vapour and allowing O3 to build up between 30-40 km. A comparison to vertical profiles of water vapour and temperature in each season reveals that water vapour abundance is controlled by atmospheric temperature, and H2O and O3 are anti-correlated as expected. When the atmosphere cools, over time or over altitude, water vapour condenses (observed as a reduction in its mixing ratio) and the production of odd hydrogen species is reduced, which allows O3 to build up. Conversely, warmer temperatures lead to water vapour enhancements and ozone loss. The LMD Mars Global Climate Model is able to reproduce vertical structure and seasonal changes of temperature, H2O, and O3 that we observe. However, the observed O3 abundance is larger by a factor of 2-6, indicating important differences in the rate of odd-hydrogen photochemistry.
- Open Access
- 3 February 2022
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 658, A86
No detection of SO2, H2S, or OCS in the atmosphere of Mars from the first two Martian years of observations from TGO/ACS
Context. The detection of sulphur species in the Martian atmosphere would be a strong indicator of volcanic outgassing from the surface of Mars. Aims. We wish to establish the presence of SO2, H2S, or OCS in the Martian atmosphere or determine upper limits on their concentration in the absence of a detection. Methods. We perform a comprehensive analysis of solar occultation data from the mid-infrared channel of the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite instrument, on board the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter, obtained during Martian years 34 and 35. Results. For the most optimal sensitivity conditions, we determine 1σ upper limits of SO2 at 20 ppbv, H2S at 15 ppbv, and OCS at 0.4 ppbv; the last value is lower than any previous upper limits imposed on OCS in the literature. We find no evidence of any of these species above a 3σ confidence threshold. We therefore infer that passive volcanic outgassing of SO2 must be below 2 ktons day−1.
- 3 February 2022
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 658, A86
Open AccessNo detection of SO2, H2S, or OCS in the atmosphere of Mars from the first two Martian years of observations from TGO/ACS
Context. The detection of sulphur species in the Martian atmosphere would be a strong indicator of volcanic outgassing from the surface of Mars. Aims. We wish to establish the presence of SO2, H2S, or OCS in the Martian atmosphere or determine upper limits on their concentration in the absence of a detection. Methods. We perform a comprehensive analysis of solar occultation data from the mid-infrared channel of the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite instrument, on board the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter, obtained during Martian years 34 and 35. Results. For the most optimal sensitivity conditions, we determine 1σ upper limits of SO2 at 20 ppbv, H2S at 15 ppbv, and OCS at 0.4 ppbv; the last value is lower than any previous upper limits imposed on OCS in the literature. We find no evidence of any of these species above a 3σ confidence threshold. We therefore infer that passive volcanic outgassing of SO2 must be below 2 ktons day−1.
- Open Access
- 17 December 2021
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 126 (12)
Isotopic Composition of CO2 in the Atmosphere of Mars: Fractionation by Diffusive Separation Observed by the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter
Isotopic ratios in atmospheric CO2 are shaped by various processes throughout Mars' history, and can help understand what the atmosphere of early Mars was like to sustain liquid water on its surface. In this study, we monitor the O and C isotopic composition of CO2 between 70 and 130 km for more than half a Martian year using solar occultation observations by the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite onboard the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter. We find the vertical trends of the isotopic ratios to be consistent with the expectations from diffusive separation above the homopause, with average values below this altitude being consistent with Earth‐like fractionation (δ13C = −3 ± 37‰; δ18O = −29 ± 38‰; and δ17O = −11 ± 41‰). Using these measurements, we estimate that at least 20%–40% of primordial C on Mars has escaped to space throughout history. The total amount of C lost from the atmosphere is likely to be well in excess of this lower limit, due to carbonate formation and further sink processes. In addition, we propose a photochemical transfer of light O from H2O to CO2 to explain the larger enrichment in the ratio in H2O than in CO2.
- 17 December 2021
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
- Vol. 126 (12)
Open AccessIsotopic Composition of CO2 in the Atmosphere of Mars: Fractionation by Diffusive Separation Observed by the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter
Isotopic ratios in atmospheric CO2 are shaped by various processes throughout Mars' history, and can help understand what the atmosphere of early Mars was like to sustain liquid water on its surface. In this study, we monitor the O and C isotopic composition of CO2 between 70 and 130 km for more than half a Martian year using solar occultation observations by the Atmospheric Chemistry Suite onboard the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter. We find the vertical trends of the isotopic ratios to be consistent with the expectations from diffusive separation above the homopause, with average values below this altitude being consistent with Earth‐like fractionation (δ13C = −3 ± 37‰; δ18O = −29 ± 38‰; and δ17O = −11 ± 41‰). Using these measurements, we estimate that at least 20%–40% of primordial C on Mars has escaped to space throughout history. The total amount of C lost from the atmosphere is likely to be well in excess of this lower limit, due to carbonate formation and further sink processes. In addition, we propose a photochemical transfer of light O from H2O to CO2 to explain the larger enrichment in the ratio in H2O than in CO2.