Beth Hardie
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Beth Hardie has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kyle Treiber
Centre of Analytic Criminology, University of Cambridge
4 shared publications - Neema Trivedi-Bateman
Department of Criminology, Sociology, and Social Policy, Loughborough University, Loughborough, UK
3 shared publications - Chae Rose
College of Healthcare Sciences, Department of Psychology, James Cook University, Townsville, Australia
2 shared publications - Gabriela Diana Roman
Centre of Analytic Criminology, University of Cambridge
2 shared publications - Katie Hiu Hei Tu
Centre of Analytic Criminology, University of Cambridge
2 shared publications Kyle Treiber
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 November 2026
- Published by Knowledge Futures in CrimRxiv
Shaping Personal Morality in Context: An Analytic Review of Moral Education Interventions for Rule-Breaking through Situational Action Theory
Objectives: Two analytic reviews are planned drawing on the literature search described in this protocol: one on interventions targeting personal morality within the home context, and one on interventions targeting personal morality within the school context. Each analytic review will (1) collect and analyse literature focusing on how interventions in the respective context target personal morality as it is conceptualized in SAT; (2) examine the extent to which they do so through key mechanisms of moral education and moral engagement (the application of personal morality to the moral context) as specified in SAT; (3) evaluate the link between engaging these mechanisms and interventions’ effectiveness; and (4) explore the implications for enhancing interventions’ efficacy and impact. Background: Crime is an enduring social problem, yet we lack a clear and shared understanding of what causes it and how to effectively prevent it. Situational Action theory (SAT) is a general, dynamic and mechanism-based explanation of crime as moral action (acts of rule-breaking) that has been empirically tested and supported across many international contexts (see Hardie & Rose 2025). SAT identifies personal morality as a key personal characteristic that shapes people’s perception of action alternatives when they encounter different moral contexts, and is fundamental in determining whether or not people see crime as an acceptable alternative. This review explores if personal morality, the process of moral education through which it is acquired, and its engagement in action settings as specified in SAT provide a foundation for current intervention practices targeting crime and its causes in family and school contexts, and if this can enhance future intervention practices. Despite growing interest in moral education interventions in school and family settings, the evidence base remains fragmented, and no synthesis has examined this literature through the analytical lens of SAT. Methods: A systematic search of electronic databases (PsycINFO, Web of Science, Scopus, ERIC, Criminal Justice Abstracts, CENTRAL) will identify relevant studies. Studies of any design reporting primary data on interventions targeting moral development will be eligible, with the proposed reviews focusing on interventions involving children, adolescents, or young adults in school or family settings. Data will be extracted and coded according to a pre-specified framework drawing on SAT constructs. A narrative synthesis will be conducted following SWiM guidelines; meta-analysis is not planned given the anticipated heterogeneity of interventions and outcome measures. Risk of bias will be assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). Expected conclusions: The review is expected to identify a range of interventions targeting moral education and moral engagement that vary in their theoretical grounding, target mechanisms, and delivery contexts. Applying SAT as an analytical lens is anticipated to reveal gaps between current intervention practice and theory-informed understanding of how personal morality develops and is applied to moral contexts. The review will provide a platform for improved, theoretically coherent crime prevention strategies centred on moral education and moral engagement.
- 5 November 2026
- Published by Knowledge Futures in CrimRxiv
Open AccessShaping Personal Morality in Context: An Analytic Review of Moral Education Interventions for Rule-Breaking through Situational Action Theory
Objectives: Two analytic reviews are planned drawing on the literature search described in this protocol: one on interventions targeting personal morality within the home context, and one on interventions targeting personal morality within the school context. Each analytic review will (1) collect and analyse literature focusing on how interventions in the respective context target personal morality as it is conceptualized in SAT; (2) examine the extent to which they do so through key mechanisms of moral education and moral engagement (the application of personal morality to the moral context) as specified in SAT; (3) evaluate the link between engaging these mechanisms and interventions’ effectiveness; and (4) explore the implications for enhancing interventions’ efficacy and impact. Background: Crime is an enduring social problem, yet we lack a clear and shared understanding of what causes it and how to effectively prevent it. Situational Action theory (SAT) is a general, dynamic and mechanism-based explanation of crime as moral action (acts of rule-breaking) that has been empirically tested and supported across many international contexts (see Hardie & Rose 2025). SAT identifies personal morality as a key personal characteristic that shapes people’s perception of action alternatives when they encounter different moral contexts, and is fundamental in determining whether or not people see crime as an acceptable alternative. This review explores if personal morality, the process of moral education through which it is acquired, and its engagement in action settings as specified in SAT provide a foundation for current intervention practices targeting crime and its causes in family and school contexts, and if this can enhance future intervention practices. Despite growing interest in moral education interventions in school and family settings, the evidence base remains fragmented, and no synthesis has examined this literature through the analytical lens of SAT. Methods: A systematic search of electronic databases (PsycINFO, Web of Science, Scopus, ERIC, Criminal Justice Abstracts, CENTRAL) will identify relevant studies. Studies of any design reporting primary data on interventions targeting moral development will be eligible, with the proposed reviews focusing on interventions involving children, adolescents, or young adults in school or family settings. Data will be extracted and coded according to a pre-specified framework drawing on SAT constructs. A narrative synthesis will be conducted following SWiM guidelines; meta-analysis is not planned given the anticipated heterogeneity of interventions and outcome measures. Risk of bias will be assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). Expected conclusions: The review is expected to identify a range of interventions targeting moral education and moral engagement that vary in their theoretical grounding, target mechanisms, and delivery contexts. Applying SAT as an analytical lens is anticipated to reveal gaps between current intervention practice and theory-informed understanding of how personal morality develops and is applied to moral contexts. The review will provide a platform for improved, theoretically coherent crime prevention strategies centred on moral education and moral engagement.
- Open Access
- 5 November 2026
- Published by Knowledge Futures in CrimRxiv
Cognitive nurturing for rule-guided action: An analytic review of intervention practices
Objectives: An analytic review of interventions targeting the ability to exercise self-control will draw on the literature search described in this protocol. This analytic review will (1) gather and examine literature that focuses on how interventions in the various contexts target the ability to exercise self-control as it is conceptualized in SAT; (2) evaluate the extent to which they achieve this through key mechanisms of cognitive nurturing and exercising self-control as specified in SAT; (3) assess the relationship between engaging these mechanisms and interventions’ effectiveness; and (4) examine the implications for improving interventions’ efficacy and impact. Background: Crime is a persistent social problem; however, there remains a lack of clarity and consensus on what causes it and how to effectively prevent it. Situational Action theory (SAT) provides a general, dynamic and mechanism-based account of crime as moral action (consisting of rule-breaking behaviors) that has received empirical testing and supported across a range of international contexts (see Hardie & Rose 2025; Wikström and Treiber forthcoming). SAT identifies the ability to exercise self-control as a core personal characteristic that shapes people’s action choices when they encounter conflicting rule-guidance. This review explores if self-control, its nurturing, and its exercise as conceptualized within SAT can establish a framework for current intervention practices targeting crime and its causes, and if this can improve subsequent intervention practices. While there is substantial interest in interventions that target the development of capacities and skills to exercise self-control, the core evidence is still fragmented, and no synthesis has evaluated this literature through SAT’s analytical lens. Methods: Relevant studies will be identified through a systematic search of electronic databases (PsycINFO, Web of Science, Scopus, ERIC, Criminal Justice Abstracts, CENTRAL). Studies of various design presenting interventions targeting the ability to exercise self-control, including the underlying cognitive capacities that support it will be eligible. A pre-specified framework grounded in SAT constructs will be used to extract and code data. A narrative synthesis will be carried out in line with SWiM guidelines; meta-analysis is not anticipated given the expected variation of interventions and outcome measures. Risk of bias will be evaluated employing the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). Expected conclusions: The review intends to highlight various interventions targeting the development and exercise of self-control that vary in their theoretical grounding, target mechanisms, and delivery contexts, but fail to differentiate individual capacities that support the exercise of self-control from the active exercise of self-control, and place particular emphasis on strengthening inhibition and consideration of consequences. Employing SAT as an analytical lens is expected to uncover limitations between current intervention practice and theory-informed understanding of the ability to exercise self-control as the ability to manage action choices under conflicting rule-guidance and resist external pressures to break personal rules, how it develops and is exercised, and its conditional relevance. The review will present a structure for enhanced, theoretically consistent crime prevention strategies focused on the ability to exercise self-control.
- 5 November 2026
- Published by Knowledge Futures in CrimRxiv
Open AccessCognitive nurturing for rule-guided action: An analytic review of intervention practices
Objectives: An analytic review of interventions targeting the ability to exercise self-control will draw on the literature search described in this protocol. This analytic review will (1) gather and examine literature that focuses on how interventions in the various contexts target the ability to exercise self-control as it is conceptualized in SAT; (2) evaluate the extent to which they achieve this through key mechanisms of cognitive nurturing and exercising self-control as specified in SAT; (3) assess the relationship between engaging these mechanisms and interventions’ effectiveness; and (4) examine the implications for improving interventions’ efficacy and impact. Background: Crime is a persistent social problem; however, there remains a lack of clarity and consensus on what causes it and how to effectively prevent it. Situational Action theory (SAT) provides a general, dynamic and mechanism-based account of crime as moral action (consisting of rule-breaking behaviors) that has received empirical testing and supported across a range of international contexts (see Hardie & Rose 2025; Wikström and Treiber forthcoming). SAT identifies the ability to exercise self-control as a core personal characteristic that shapes people’s action choices when they encounter conflicting rule-guidance. This review explores if self-control, its nurturing, and its exercise as conceptualized within SAT can establish a framework for current intervention practices targeting crime and its causes, and if this can improve subsequent intervention practices. While there is substantial interest in interventions that target the development of capacities and skills to exercise self-control, the core evidence is still fragmented, and no synthesis has evaluated this literature through SAT’s analytical lens. Methods: Relevant studies will be identified through a systematic search of electronic databases (PsycINFO, Web of Science, Scopus, ERIC, Criminal Justice Abstracts, CENTRAL). Studies of various design presenting interventions targeting the ability to exercise self-control, including the underlying cognitive capacities that support it will be eligible. A pre-specified framework grounded in SAT constructs will be used to extract and code data. A narrative synthesis will be carried out in line with SWiM guidelines; meta-analysis is not anticipated given the expected variation of interventions and outcome measures. Risk of bias will be evaluated employing the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). Expected conclusions: The review intends to highlight various interventions targeting the development and exercise of self-control that vary in their theoretical grounding, target mechanisms, and delivery contexts, but fail to differentiate individual capacities that support the exercise of self-control from the active exercise of self-control, and place particular emphasis on strengthening inhibition and consideration of consequences. Employing SAT as an analytical lens is expected to uncover limitations between current intervention practice and theory-informed understanding of the ability to exercise self-control as the ability to manage action choices under conflicting rule-guidance and resist external pressures to break personal rules, how it develops and is exercised, and its conditional relevance. The review will present a structure for enhanced, theoretically consistent crime prevention strategies focused on the ability to exercise self-control.
- Open Access
- 24 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in International Criminology
- p. 1-21
Rewriting the Divide: Child-Centred Participation and Theoretically Informed and Evidence-Based Intervention Design
This paper contributes to debates on problematic, dominant criminological narratives by foregrounding children’s own accounts of the support they need to thrive, informing ongoing efforts to support their individual and moral development. Drawing on community-based, participatory focus groups and individual and small-group interviews with 58 children aged 10–17 attending youth centres in Cambridge (UK), the study departs from deficit-oriented, adult-led explanations that frame children primarily through risk, mental disorders, or criminalisation. The findings rework prevailing criminological intervention approaches in two ways. First, using reflexive thematic analysis, the study centres children’s lived knowledge to identify trust, belonging, voice, agency, relational consistency of care, emotional support, and autonomy as central to what makes interventions trustworthy, accessible, engaging, and effective, whilst overly didactic, rigid, or authoritarian approaches were identified as key barriers to participation and effectiveness. These accounts move beyond adult assumptions about children’s needs, showing that effective support is grounded in relational, dialogic, autonomy-supportive environments rather than deficit-oriented models. Second, the paper argues that centring children’s perspectives is necessary but not sufficient: interventions must also be theoretically informed and evidence based. Rather than treating participatory and evidence-informed approaches as competing paradigms, the study offers data supporting their integration, combining child-centred qualitative insight with theoretically specified explanations of behaviour. Implications are discussed for the ongoing development of the school-based SATNAV:Compass youth intervention programme. This reconstruction of recommended intervention design approaches retains the strengths of existing traditions whilst addressing their limitations, offering a direction for future intervention research and practice.
- 24 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in International Criminology
- p. 1-21
Open AccessRewriting the Divide: Child-Centred Participation and Theoretically Informed and Evidence-Based Intervention Design
This paper contributes to debates on problematic, dominant criminological narratives by foregrounding children’s own accounts of the support they need to thrive, informing ongoing efforts to support their individual and moral development. Drawing on community-based, participatory focus groups and individual and small-group interviews with 58 children aged 10–17 attending youth centres in Cambridge (UK), the study departs from deficit-oriented, adult-led explanations that frame children primarily through risk, mental disorders, or criminalisation. The findings rework prevailing criminological intervention approaches in two ways. First, using reflexive thematic analysis, the study centres children’s lived knowledge to identify trust, belonging, voice, agency, relational consistency of care, emotional support, and autonomy as central to what makes interventions trustworthy, accessible, engaging, and effective, whilst overly didactic, rigid, or authoritarian approaches were identified as key barriers to participation and effectiveness. These accounts move beyond adult assumptions about children’s needs, showing that effective support is grounded in relational, dialogic, autonomy-supportive environments rather than deficit-oriented models. Second, the paper argues that centring children’s perspectives is necessary but not sufficient: interventions must also be theoretically informed and evidence based. Rather than treating participatory and evidence-informed approaches as competing paradigms, the study offers data supporting their integration, combining child-centred qualitative insight with theoretically specified explanations of behaviour. Implications are discussed for the ongoing development of the school-based SATNAV:Compass youth intervention programme. This reconstruction of recommended intervention design approaches retains the strengths of existing traditions whilst addressing their limitations, offering a direction for future intervention research and practice.
- Open Access
- 16 October 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Social Sciences
- Vol. 15 (10) , 711
Introducing SATNAV:Compass in Schools—A Preventative Morality-Focused Intervention Programme
Morality is central to explanations of youth rule-breaking, yet few interventions have systematically translated criminological theories of morality into theoretically specified, evidence-informed programmes. This report provides the first comprehensive account of SATNAV:Compass, a pioneering morality-focused intervention designed to promote positive youth development and reduce problem behaviour among adolescents. Grounded in Situational Action Theory and multidisciplinary evidence, the intervention translates theoretically specified mechanisms into four interconnected intervention strands: moral rules and emotions, empathy, emotion regulation, and self-control and peer resistance. SATNAV:Compass addresses each strand via evidence-based interactive small-group weekly activities. In this programme report, we present details of the implementation, process evaluation, and intended outcomes. Since 2023, SATNAV:Compass has been developed and iteratively refined across 15 trials in 9 schools with students aged 11–14. Across these trials, 2085 students completed initial screening with 602 selected for trial samples (308 programme, 294 control; 13 of the trials employed randomised controlled designs with crime-propensity-matched groups). Process evaluation findings demonstrate strong feasibility and acceptability and inform iterative programme refinement. Impact evaluation on key metrics is ongoing; early emerging indicators include increased intentions to apply learned strategies in rule-breaking situations, reduced social isolation, and improved relationships. Elsewhere, we have documented our approach and the development of the programme from conception to evaluation, establishing a transparent line of sight between theory, evidence, target causal factors, mechanisms of change, and programme content. This report summarises this development approach but focusses on establishing implementation foundations for rigorous evaluation and wider application of SATNAV:Compass in the UK and internationally. Combined, these outputs provide a rare and valuable model for future school-based interventions.
- 16 October 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Social Sciences
- Vol. 15 (10) , 711
Open AccessIntroducing SATNAV:Compass in Schools—A Preventative Morality-Focused Intervention Programme
Morality is central to explanations of youth rule-breaking, yet few interventions have systematically translated criminological theories of morality into theoretically specified, evidence-informed programmes. This report provides the first comprehensive account of SATNAV:Compass, a pioneering morality-focused intervention designed to promote positive youth development and reduce problem behaviour among adolescents. Grounded in Situational Action Theory and multidisciplinary evidence, the intervention translates theoretically specified mechanisms into four interconnected intervention strands: moral rules and emotions, empathy, emotion regulation, and self-control and peer resistance. SATNAV:Compass addresses each strand via evidence-based interactive small-group weekly activities. In this programme report, we present details of the implementation, process evaluation, and intended outcomes. Since 2023, SATNAV:Compass has been developed and iteratively refined across 15 trials in 9 schools with students aged 11–14. Across these trials, 2085 students completed initial screening with 602 selected for trial samples (308 programme, 294 control; 13 of the trials employed randomised controlled designs with crime-propensity-matched groups). Process evaluation findings demonstrate strong feasibility and acceptability and inform iterative programme refinement. Impact evaluation on key metrics is ongoing; early emerging indicators include increased intentions to apply learned strategies in rule-breaking situations, reduced social isolation, and improved relationships. Elsewhere, we have documented our approach and the development of the programme from conception to evaluation, establishing a transparent line of sight between theory, evidence, target causal factors, mechanisms of change, and programme content. This report summarises this development approach but focusses on establishing implementation foundations for rigorous evaluation and wider application of SATNAV:Compass in the UK and internationally. Combined, these outputs provide a rare and valuable model for future school-based interventions.
- Open Access
- 5 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Adolescence
Goal‐Driven Dynamic Change in Parental Monitoring and Adolescent Information Management: A Novel Conceptual Model and Simulation
To be effective, adolescents' parents must have basic knowledge about what their children do, who they spend their time with, and what they care about. There is broad consensus that parental monitoring facilitates adolescent information sharing and that information sharing is the most important factor predicting parents' knowledge of their adolescents' lives (Liu et al. 2020). Nonetheless, under some circumstances, vicious cycles can develop in which adolescents react to parents' attempts to gain information by becoming more secretive and parents, in turn, respond to adolescents' secrecy by becoming more intrusive (Hawk et al. 2013, 2016). Despite developmentalists' fundamental interest in the study of change, most current conceptual models of monitoring are static. Specifically, theories have little to say about what would initiate change in stable family systems. This paper integrates what we have learned about parental monitoring, adolescent information sharing, and parents' knowledge in the last decades (e.g., Gingo 2024; Liu et al. 2020) with older models of parenting practice, style, and adolescents' willingness to be socialized (Cumsille et al. 2010; Darling and Steinberg 1993). It then incorporates insights from a model of monitoring borrowed from criminology (Hardie 2021a, 2022, 2024). This integrated model focuses attention on parents' goals and their ability to assess the success of their efforts as a mechanism driving change. A series of deterministic dynamic systems models illustrates predictions from this model about how parental monitoring and knowledge, adolescent information sharing, and outcomes unfold over time under different circumstances.
- 5 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Adolescence
Open AccessGoal‐Driven Dynamic Change in Parental Monitoring and Adolescent Information Management: A Novel Conceptual Model and Simulation
To be effective, adolescents' parents must have basic knowledge about what their children do, who they spend their time with, and what they care about. There is broad consensus that parental monitoring facilitates adolescent information sharing and that information sharing is the most important factor predicting parents' knowledge of their adolescents' lives (Liu et al. 2020). Nonetheless, under some circumstances, vicious cycles can develop in which adolescents react to parents' attempts to gain information by becoming more secretive and parents, in turn, respond to adolescents' secrecy by becoming more intrusive (Hawk et al. 2013, 2016). Despite developmentalists' fundamental interest in the study of change, most current conceptual models of monitoring are static. Specifically, theories have little to say about what would initiate change in stable family systems. This paper integrates what we have learned about parental monitoring, adolescent information sharing, and parents' knowledge in the last decades (e.g., Gingo 2024; Liu et al. 2020) with older models of parenting practice, style, and adolescents' willingness to be socialized (Cumsille et al. 2010; Darling and Steinberg 1993). It then incorporates insights from a model of monitoring borrowed from criminology (Hardie 2021a, 2022, 2024). This integrated model focuses attention on parents' goals and their ability to assess the success of their efforts as a mechanism driving change. A series of deterministic dynamic systems models illustrates predictions from this model about how parental monitoring and knowledge, adolescent information sharing, and outcomes unfold over time under different circumstances.
- Open Access
A Proof of Concept of the Virtual Reality Process Tracing Approach for the Study of Offender Decision Making in the Context of Situational Action Theory
The present study demonstrates the use and validity of the Virtual Reality Process Tracing Approach (VRPTA) using Situational Action Theory as a case study. It represents an innovative method combining immersive, high-fidelity filmed virtual reality (VR) scenarios, real-time decision-making, and process tracing to gain insight into decision processes. The scenario featured an opportunity to steal a £50 note. A total of 61 participants from the SATNAV:Compass programme, aged 11 to 14, were recruited from three schools in England. Results indicate that 3D, 180-degree VR scenarios successfully elicit real-time decision-making; participants found the scenarios realistic and reported a sense of presence, and their scenario responses have criterion-related validity (i.e., relationship with real-world behaviour). Participants’ reports about the extent to which crime was perceived as an alternative and whether it necessitated deliberation were validated using markers of deliberative choice: response times, decision confidence, and perceived difficulty. Independent-samples t-tests showed that those who reported deliberating about engaging in crime were slower to decide, were less confident in their decisions and found them more difficult to make. Furthermore, preliminary graphical and statistical analyses showed that whether participants perceived crime as the only action alternative, deliberated about it, or did not consider it at all, largely depended on their level of personal morality. This suggests that strong (law-relevant) personal morality acts as a filter for the perception of criminal action alternatives. At weaker levels, individuals were more likely to deliberate about stealing the money, in which case self-control and deterrence processes became relevant, whilst at the weakest levels they chose crime in a habitual manner. This novel use of immersive methods extends our understanding of cognitive decision-making processes beyond the classical input-output paradigm.
Open AccessA Proof of Concept of the Virtual Reality Process Tracing Approach for the Study of Offender Decision Making in the Context of Situational Action Theory
The present study demonstrates the use and validity of the Virtual Reality Process Tracing Approach (VRPTA) using Situational Action Theory as a case study. It represents an innovative method combining immersive, high-fidelity filmed virtual reality (VR) scenarios, real-time decision-making, and process tracing to gain insight into decision processes. The scenario featured an opportunity to steal a £50 note. A total of 61 participants from the SATNAV:Compass programme, aged 11 to 14, were recruited from three schools in England. Results indicate that 3D, 180-degree VR scenarios successfully elicit real-time decision-making; participants found the scenarios realistic and reported a sense of presence, and their scenario responses have criterion-related validity (i.e., relationship with real-world behaviour). Participants’ reports about the extent to which crime was perceived as an alternative and whether it necessitated deliberation were validated using markers of deliberative choice: response times, decision confidence, and perceived difficulty. Independent-samples t-tests showed that those who reported deliberating about engaging in crime were slower to decide, were less confident in their decisions and found them more difficult to make. Furthermore, preliminary graphical and statistical analyses showed that whether participants perceived crime as the only action alternative, deliberated about it, or did not consider it at all, largely depended on their level of personal morality. This suggests that strong (law-relevant) personal morality acts as a filter for the perception of criminal action alternatives. At weaker levels, individuals were more likely to deliberate about stealing the money, in which case self-control and deterrence processes became relevant, whilst at the weakest levels they chose crime in a habitual manner. This novel use of immersive methods extends our understanding of cognitive decision-making processes beyond the classical input-output paradigm.
- Open Access
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in International Criminology
- p. 1-13
Examining Conditional Relevance in Situational Action Theory Using Generalised Additive Modelling
Tests of Situational Action Theory’s (SAT) conditional relevance of controls have typically relied on linear parametric interaction terms or comparisons across categorised moral configuration groups. While these approaches have contributed to our understanding of SAT, they may also constrain how the effects of controls (e.g. self-control and deterrence) vary across the moral configurations implied by the theory. In contrast, the present study reanalyses survey data on self-reported speeding collected from 919 Australian drivers to examine the use of a generalised additive modelling approach. Here, the effects of self-control, perceived certainty of detection, and perceived severity of punishment were permitted to vary nonlinearly across the morality–moral context space. Results indicated substantial nonlinear variation in the relevance of self-control across moral configurations, whereas certainty displayed a largely linear effect and severity showed little systematic influence. However, although this more flexible approach was better able to capture the underlying morality–moral context space than traditional linear approaches, the emerging patterns did not align with theoretical expectations regarding the conditional relevance of controls, nor did they more closely approximate those observed in the prior analysis of the same data. These findings suggest that the challenge in examining the conditional relevance of controls likely reflects not only modelling complexities, but also broader measurement challenges, both of which require further investigation.
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in International Criminology
- p. 1-13
Open AccessExamining Conditional Relevance in Situational Action Theory Using Generalised Additive Modelling
Tests of Situational Action Theory’s (SAT) conditional relevance of controls have typically relied on linear parametric interaction terms or comparisons across categorised moral configuration groups. While these approaches have contributed to our understanding of SAT, they may also constrain how the effects of controls (e.g. self-control and deterrence) vary across the moral configurations implied by the theory. In contrast, the present study reanalyses survey data on self-reported speeding collected from 919 Australian drivers to examine the use of a generalised additive modelling approach. Here, the effects of self-control, perceived certainty of detection, and perceived severity of punishment were permitted to vary nonlinearly across the morality–moral context space. Results indicated substantial nonlinear variation in the relevance of self-control across moral configurations, whereas certainty displayed a largely linear effect and severity showed little systematic influence. However, although this more flexible approach was better able to capture the underlying morality–moral context space than traditional linear approaches, the emerging patterns did not align with theoretical expectations regarding the conditional relevance of controls, nor did they more closely approximate those observed in the prior analysis of the same data. These findings suggest that the challenge in examining the conditional relevance of controls likely reflects not only modelling complexities, but also broader measurement challenges, both of which require further investigation.
- 12 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in International Criminology
- Vol. 6 (1) , 114-132
The Morality of Speeding and the Conditional Relevance of Controls
- 12 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in International Criminology
- Vol. 6 (1) , 114-132
The Morality of Speeding and the Conditional Relevance of Controls
- Open Access
- 8 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Justice Quarterly
- Vol. 43 (3) , 579-609
Revisiting Bad Apples and Bad Barrels: Person × Setting Interactions in Corruption
- 8 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Justice Quarterly
- Vol. 43 (3) , 579-609
Open AccessRevisiting Bad Apples and Bad Barrels: Person × Setting Interactions in Corruption
- Open Access
Revisiting bad apples and bad barrels: Person × Setting interactions in corruption
The divide between individual (bad apples) and structural (bad barrels) explanations runs deep through corruption research. This divide is bridged when individual corruption propensities and corruptive settings are studied in relation to one another, as proposed by the interactive approach and Situational Action Theory. A factorial experiment combined with a survey of public administration students (n = 577) tested hypothesized person-setting interactions in corrupt decision-making. Participants’ characteristics related to corruption differently across various organizational moral climates. Personal morality and self-control were strongly and negatively correlated with corruption, and their combined effect increased in a criminogenic setting. In neutral and criminogenic settings, monetary incentives were less salient than benevolent corruption which benefitted a likeable briber. The study concludes that corruption is better understood as an outcome of person-setting interaction. Bad apples are contextualized by their barrels and bad barrels are defined by their apples.
Open AccessRevisiting bad apples and bad barrels: Person × Setting interactions in corruption
The divide between individual (bad apples) and structural (bad barrels) explanations runs deep through corruption research. This divide is bridged when individual corruption propensities and corruptive settings are studied in relation to one another, as proposed by the interactive approach and Situational Action Theory. A factorial experiment combined with a survey of public administration students (n = 577) tested hypothesized person-setting interactions in corrupt decision-making. Participants’ characteristics related to corruption differently across various organizational moral climates. Personal morality and self-control were strongly and negatively correlated with corruption, and their combined effect increased in a criminogenic setting. In neutral and criminogenic settings, monetary incentives were less salient than benevolent corruption which benefitted a likeable briber. The study concludes that corruption is better understood as an outcome of person-setting interaction. Bad apples are contextualized by their barrels and bad barrels are defined by their apples.