CBChristopher J. Bambic

Christopher J. Bambic

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Christopher J. Bambic has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Local models of two-temperature accretion disc coronae – II. Ion thermal conduction and the absence of disc evaporation

    by Christopher J Bambic, Eliot Quataert, Matthew W Kunz, Yan-Fei Jiang

    We use local stratified shearing-box simulations with magnetic field-aligned thermal conduction to study an idealized model of the coupling between a cold, radiatively efficient accretion disc, and an overlying, hot, two-temperature corona. Evaporation of a cold disc by conduction from the hot corona has been proposed as a means of mediating the soft-to-hard state transitions observed in X-ray binary systems. We model the coronal plasma in our local disc patch as an MHD fluid subject to both free-streaming ion conduction and a parametrized cooling function that captures the collisional transfer of energy from hot ions to colder, rapidly cooling leptons. In all of our models, independent of the initial net vertical magnetic flux (NF) threading the disc, we find no evidence of disc evaporation. The ion heat flux into the disc is radiated away before conduction can heat the disc’s surface layers. When an initial NF is present, steady-state temperature, density, and outflow velocities in our model coronae are unaffected by conduction. Instead of facilitating disc evaporation, thermal conduction is more likely to feed the disc with plasma condensing out of the corona, particularly in flows without NF. Our work indicates that uncertainties in the amount of NF threading the disc hold far greater influence over whether or not the disc will evaporate into a radiatively inefficient accretion flow compared to thermal conduction. We speculate that a change in net flux mediates disc truncation/evaporation.


  • Open Access

    Local models of two-temperature accretion disc coronae. II. Ion thermal conduction and the absence of disc evaporation

    by Christopher J. Bambic, Eliot Quataert, Matthew W. Kunz, Yan-Fei Jiang

    We use local stratified shearing-box simulations with magnetic field-aligned thermal conduction to study an idealized model of the coupling between a cold, radiatively efficient accretion disc, and an overlying, hot, two-temperature corona. Evaporation of a cold disc by conduction from the hot corona has been proposed as a means of mediating the soft-to-hard state transitions observed in X-ray binary systems. We model the coronal plasma in our local disc patch as an MHD fluid subject to both free-streaming ion conduction and a parameterized cooling function that captures the collisional transfer of energy from hot ions to colder, rapidly cooling leptons. In all of our models, independent of the initial net vertical magnetic flux (NF) threading the disc, we find no evidence of disc evaporation. The ion heat flux into the disc is radiated away before conduction can heat the disc's surface layers. When an initial NF is present, steady-state temperature, density, and outflow velocities in our model coronae are unaffected by conduction. Instead of facilitating disc evaporation, thermal conduction is more likely to feed the disc with plasma condensing out of the corona, particularly in flows without NF. Our work indicates that uncertainties in the amount of NF threading the disc hold far greater influence over whether or not the disc will evaporate into a radiatively inefficient accretion flow compared to thermal conduction. We speculate that a change in net flux mediates disc truncation/evaporation.

  • Open Access

    Local models of two-temperature accretion disc coronae. I. Structure, outflows, and energetics

    by Christopher J. Bambic, Eliot Quataert, Matthew W. Kunz

    We use local stratified shearing-box simulations to elucidate the impact of two-temperature thermodynamics on the thermal structure of coronae in radiatively efficient accretion flows. Rather than treating the coronal plasma as an isothermal fluid, we use a simple, parameterized cooling function that models the collisional transfer of energy from the ions to the rapidly cooling leptons. Two-temperature models naturally form temperature inversions, with a hot, magnetically dominated corona surrounding a cold disc. Simulations with net vertical flux (NF) magnetic fields launch powerful magnetocentrifugal winds that would enhance accretion in a global system. The outflow rates are much better converged with increasing box height than analogous isothermal simulations, suggesting that the winds into two-temperature coronae may be sufficiently strong to evaporate a thin disc and form a radiatively inefficient accretion flow under some conditions. We find evidence for multiphase structure in the corona, with broad density and temperature distributions, and we propose criteria for the formation of a multiphase corona. The fraction of cooling in the surface layers of the disc is substantially larger for NF fields compared to zero net-flux configurations, with moderate NF simulations radiating ${\gtrsim}30$ per cent of the flow's total luminosity above two midplane scale-heights. Our work shows that NF fields may efficiently power the coronae of luminous Seyfert galaxies and quasars, providing compelling motivation for future studies of the heating mechanisms available to NF fields and the interplay of radiation with two-temperature thermodynamics.

  • Open Access

    Local models of two-temperature accretion disc coronae – I. Structure, outflows, and energetics

    by Christopher J Bambic, Eliot Quataert, Matthew W Kunz

    We use local stratified shearing-box simulations to elucidate the impact of two-temperature thermodynamics on the thermal structure of coronae in radiatively efficient accretion flows. Rather than treating the coronal plasma as an isothermal fluid, we use a simple, parametrized cooling function that models the collisional transfer of energy from the ions to the rapidly cooling leptons. Two-temperature models naturally form temperature inversions, with a hot, magnetically dominated corona surrounding a cold disc. Simulations with net vertical flux (NF) magnetic fields launch powerful magnetocentrifugal winds that would enhance accretion in a global system. The outflow rates are much better converged with increasing box height than analogous isothermal simulations, suggesting that the winds into two-temperature coronae may be sufficiently strong to evaporate a thin disc and form a radiatively inefficient accretion flow under some conditions. We find evidence for multiphase structure in the corona, with broad density and temperature distributions, and we propose criteria for the formation of a multiphase corona. The fraction of cooling in the surface layers of the disc is substantially larger for NF fields compared to zero net-flux configurations, with moderate NF simulations radiating ≳30 per cent of the flow’s total luminosity above two mid-plane scale heights. Our work shows that NF fields may efficiently power the coronae of luminous Seyfert galaxies and quasars, providing compelling motivation for future studies of the heating mechanisms available to NF fields and the interplay of radiation with two-temperature thermodynamics.


  • AGN feeding and feedback in M84: from kiloparsec scales to the Bondi radius

    by C J Bambic, H R Russell, C S Reynolds, A C Fabian, B R McNamara, P E J Nulsen

    We present the deepest Chandra observation to date of the galaxy M84 in the Virgo Cluster, with over 840 ks of data provided by legacy observations and a recent 730 ks campaign. The increased signal-to-noise ratio allows us to study the origins of the accretion flow feeding the supermassive black hole in the centre of M84 from the kiloparsec scales of the X-ray halo to the Bondi radius, RB. Temperature, metallicity, and deprojected density profiles are obtained in four sectors about M84’s active galactic nucleus (AGN), extending into the Bondi radius. Rather than being dictated by the potential of the black hole, the accretion flow is strongly influenced by the AGN’s bipolar radio jets. Along the jet axis, the density profile is consistent with ne ∝ r−1; however, the profiles flatten perpendicular to the jet. Radio jets produce a significant asymmetry in the flow, violating a key assumption of Bondi accretion. Temperature in the inner kiloparsec is approximately constant, with only a slight increase from 0.6 to 0.7 keV approaching RB, and there is no evidence for a temperature rise imposed by the black hole. The Bondi accretion rate |$\dot{M}_{\rm B}$| exceeds the rate inferred from AGN luminosity and jet power by over four orders of magnitude. In sectors perpendicular to the jet, |$\dot{M}_{\rm B}$| measurements agree; however, the accretion rate is >4σ lower in the North sector along the jet, likely due to cavities in the X-ray gas. Our measurements provide unique insight into the fuelling of AGN responsible for radio mode feedback in galaxy clusters.


  • Open Access

    AGN Feeding and Feedback in M84: From Kiloparsec Scales to the Bondi Radius

    by C. J. Bambic, H. R. Russell, C. S. Reynolds, A. C. Fabian, B. R. McNamara, P. E. J. Nulsen

    We present the deepest Chandra observation to date of the galaxy M84 in the Virgo Cluster, with over 840 kiloseconds of data provided by legacy observations and a recent 730 kilosecond campaign. The increased signal-to-noise allows us to study the origins of the accretion flow feeding the supermassive black hole in the center of M84 from the kiloparsec scales of the X-ray halo to the Bondi radius, $R_{\rm B}$. Temperature, metallicity, and deprojected density profiles are obtained in four sectors about M84's AGN, extending into the Bondi radius. Rather than being dictated by the potential of the black hole, the accretion flow is strongly influenced by the AGN's bipolar radio jets. Along the jet axis, the density profile is consistent with $n_e \propto r^{-1}$; however, the profiles flatten perpendicular to the jet. Radio jets produce a significant asymmetry in the flow, violating a key assumption of Bondi accretion. Temperature in the inner kiloparsec is approximately constant, with only a slight increase from 0.6 to 0.7 keV approaching $R_{\rm B}$, and there is no evidence for a temperature rise imposed by the black hole. The Bondi accretion rate $\dot{M}_{\rm B}$ exceeds the rate inferred from AGN luminosity and jet power by over four orders of magnitude. In sectors perpendicular to the jet, $\dot{M}_{\rm B}$ measurements agree; however, the accretion rate is $> 4 σ$ lower in the North sector along the jet, likely due to cavities in the X-ray gas. Our measurements provide unique insight into the fueling of AGN responsible for radio mode feedback in galaxy clusters.


  • MHD-PIC Simulations of Cosmic-Ray Scattering and Transport in Inhomogeneously Ionized Plasma

    by Christopher J. Bambic, Xue-Ning Bai, Eve C. Ostriker

    Cosmic rays (CRs) have critical impacts in the multiphase interstellar medium (ISM), driving dynamical motions in low-density plasma and modifying the ionization state, temperature, and chemical composition of higher-density atomic and molecular gas. We present a study of CR propagation in inhomogeneously ionized plasma, addressing CR transport issues that arise in the cloudy ISM. Using one-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) particle-in-cell simulations that include ion–neutral drag to damp Alfvén waves in a portion of the simulation domain, we self-consistently evolve the kinetic physics of CRs and background gas MHD. By introducing a damping region in our periodic domain, our simulations break translational symmetry and allow the emergence of spatial gradients in the CR distribution function. A spatial gradient opposite to the CR flux forms across the fully ionized region as a result of pitch angle scattering. We connect our results with CR hydrodynamics formulations by computing the wave–particle scattering rates as predicted by quasilinear, fluid, and Fokker–Planck theory. For momenta where the mean free path is short relative to the box size, we find excellent agreement among all scattering rates. However, we also find evidence of a reduced scattering rate for less energetic particles that are subject to the μ = 0 barrier in our simulations. Our work provides a first-principles verification of CR hydrodynamics when particles stream down their pressure gradient and opens a pathway toward comprehensive calibrations of transport coefficients from self-generated Alfvén wave scattering with CRs.


  • Efficient Production of Sound Waves by AGN Jets in the Intracluster Medium

    by Christopher J. Bambic, Christopher S. Reynolds

    We investigate the interaction between active galactic nucleus (AGN) jets and the intracluster medium (ICM) of galaxy clusters. Specifically, we study the efficiency with which jets can drive sound waves into the ICM. Previous works focused on this issue model the jet–ICM interaction as a spherically symmetric explosion, finding that ≲12.5% of the blast energy is converted into sound waves, even for instantaneous energy injection. We develop a method for measuring sound wave energy in hydrodynamic simulations and measure the efficiency of sound wave driving by supersonic jets in a model ICM. Our axisymmetric fiducial simulations convert ≳25% of the jet energy into strong, long-wavelength sound waves that can propagate to large distances. Vigorous instabilities driven by the jet–ICM interaction generate small-scale sound waves that constructively interfere, forming powerful large-scale waves. By scanning a parameter space of opening angles, velocities, and densities, we study how our results depend on jet properties. High-velocity, wide-angle jets produce sound waves most efficiently, yet the acoustic efficiency never exceeds 1/3 of the jet energy—an indication that equipartition may limit the nonlinear energy conversion process. Our work argues that sound waves may compose a significant fraction of the energy budget in cluster AGN feedback and underscores the importance of properly treating compressive wave dissipation in the weakly collisional, magnetized ICM.


  • AGN feedback in the Phoenix cluster

    by C Pinto, C J Bambic, J S Sanders, A C Fabian, M McDonald, H R Russell, H Liu, C S Reynolds

    Active galactic nuclei (AGNs) release a huge amount of energy into the intracluster medium, with the consequence of offsetting cooling and star formation (AGN feedback) in the centres of cool-core clusters. The Phoenix cluster is among the most massive clusters of galaxies known in the Universe. It hosts a powerful starburst of several hundreds of solar masses per year and a large amount of molecular gas in the centre. In this work we use the high-resolution Reflection Grating Spectrometer (RGS) onboard XMM–Newton to study the X-ray-emitting cool gas in the Phoenix cluster and the heating–cooling balance. We detect for the first time evidence of O viii and Fe xxi–xxii emission lines, the latter demonstrating the presence of gas below 2 keV. We find a cooling rate of $$350\pm _{200}^{250}\, {\text M}_{\odot }\, {\rm yr}^{-1}$$ below 2 keV (at the 90 per cent confidence level), which is consistent with the star formation rate in this object. This cooling rate is high enough to produce the molecular gas found in the filaments via instabilities during the buoyant rising time. The line broadening indicates that the turbulence (∼300 km s−1 or less) is below the level required to produce and propagate the heat throughout the cool core. This provides a natural explanation for the coexistence of large amounts of cool gas, star formation, and a powerful AGN in the core. The AGN activity may be either at a young stage or in a different feedback mode, due to a high accretion rate.


  • Suppression of AGN-driven Turbulence by Magnetic Fields in a Magnetohydrodynamic Model of the Intracluster Medium

    by Christopher J. Bambic, Brian J. Morsony, Christopher S. Reynolds

    We investigate the role of active galactic nucleus (AGN) feedback in turbulent heating of galaxy clusters. Specifically, we analyze the production of turbulence by g-modes generated by the supersonic expansion and buoyant rise of AGN-driven bubbles. Previous work that neglects magnetic fields has shown that this process is inefficient, with less than 1% of the injected energy ending up in turbulence. This inefficiency primarily arises because the bubbles are shredded apart by hydrodynamic instabilities before they can excite sufficiently strong g-modes. Using a plane-parallel model of the intracluster medium (ICM) and 3D ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) simulations, we examine the role of a large-scale magnetic field that is able to drape around these rising bubbles, preserving them from hydrodynamic instabilities. We find that while magnetic draping appears better able to preserve AGN-driven bubbles, the driving of g-modes and the resulting production of turbulence is still inefficient. The magnetic tension force prevents g-modes from transitioning into the nonlinear regime, suppressing turbulence in our model ICM. Our work highlights the ways in which ideal MHD is an insufficient description for the cluster feedback process, and we discuss future work such as the inclusion of anisotropic viscosity as a means of simulating high β plasma kinetic effects. These results suggest the hypothesis that other mechanisms of heating the ICM plasma such as sound waves or cosmic rays may be responsible for the observed feedback in galaxy clusters.