Kelly Swarts
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Kelly Swarts has a total of 170 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Edward S. Buckler
Institute for Genomic Diversity, Cornell University , Ithaca, NY 14853
9 shared publications - Maria Cinta Romay
Institute for Genomic Diversity, Cornell University , Ithaca, NY 14853
8 shared publications - Miguel Vallebueno-Estrada
Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences
5 shared publications - Bruce F. Benz
Biology Department Texas Wesleyan University Fort Worth TX 76105 USA
3 shared publications - Ivan Lopez-Valdivia
Leibniz Institute of Plant Genetics & Crop Plant Research (IPK) OT Gatersleben, Corrensstr 3, 06466 Seeland, Germany
3 shared publications - James Brendan Holland
Department of Crop and Soil Sciences North Carolina State University Raleigh North Carolina USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology Resources
- Vol. 26 (5) , e70150
Unified Multi‐Caller Ensemble ( UME ) Generates an Unbiased Maize Haplotype Map for Variable Coverage Whole Genome Data
We present a novel diversity‐focused haplotype map (HapMap) that characterizes over 64.5 million maize ( Zea mays ssp. mays ) single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) genotyped across 818 individuals from diverse backgrounds. This HapMap aims to balance the variation obtained from domesticated landraces and inbred lines, outgroup Zea spp. and more distant Tripsacum spp. in order to minimize ascertainment bias for diversity studies. Included individuals derive from public data from various experimental setups and coverages, which is challenging for standard SNP callers to accommodate. We provide evidence of coverage biases associated with standard callers that influence resulting variation and introduce a novel approach called Unified Multi‐Caller Ensemble (UME), which enhances variant calling accuracy in low‐coverage and mixed‐coverage genomic datasets. UME corrects for coverage bias resulting from inter‐sample coverage heterogeneity by leveraging evidence from variant callers with orthogonal strategies, re‐calibrating the error probabilities across callers to minimize the impact of error biases inherent to a given caller. It outperforms individual strategies and excels in de novo variant calling, taking advantage of instances of higher depth reads, even in low coverage individuals, while preserving biologically informative variant relationships across coverage levels. An important feature of UME is the independence from population allele frequencies in the discovery panel, thus avoiding ascertainment bias resulting from unbalanced input genetic diversity. Discovered variants are less affected by ascertainment bias because no population filtering is used, and the full diversity of SNPs is retained in the final variant call set to maximize the utility of the dataset for production calling newly sequenced samples. We present a strategy for filtering the recalibrated error profiles that relies on maximizing demographic signals to retain genetic relationships within the population while reducing sequencing error. After the variant discovery phase, we employ the UME production stage, which enriches genotype calling across all coverage levels, benefiting low‐coverage samples. Error introduced in this process is removed through subsequent filtering. Using this approach, we generated a coverage bias‐controlled maize HapMap database, providing a comprehensive representation of maize accessions and emphasizing landrace diversity. This diverse panel of domesticated maize and outgroups from across the Americas enables accurate genotyping in low‐coverage samples while offering crucial context for interpreting diversity, particularly for natural diversity and paleogenomic analyses.
- 28 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology Resources
- Vol. 26 (5) , e70150
Open AccessUnified Multi‐Caller Ensemble ( UME ) Generates an Unbiased Maize Haplotype Map for Variable Coverage Whole Genome Data
We present a novel diversity‐focused haplotype map (HapMap) that characterizes over 64.5 million maize ( Zea mays ssp. mays ) single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) genotyped across 818 individuals from diverse backgrounds. This HapMap aims to balance the variation obtained from domesticated landraces and inbred lines, outgroup Zea spp. and more distant Tripsacum spp. in order to minimize ascertainment bias for diversity studies. Included individuals derive from public data from various experimental setups and coverages, which is challenging for standard SNP callers to accommodate. We provide evidence of coverage biases associated with standard callers that influence resulting variation and introduce a novel approach called Unified Multi‐Caller Ensemble (UME), which enhances variant calling accuracy in low‐coverage and mixed‐coverage genomic datasets. UME corrects for coverage bias resulting from inter‐sample coverage heterogeneity by leveraging evidence from variant callers with orthogonal strategies, re‐calibrating the error probabilities across callers to minimize the impact of error biases inherent to a given caller. It outperforms individual strategies and excels in de novo variant calling, taking advantage of instances of higher depth reads, even in low coverage individuals, while preserving biologically informative variant relationships across coverage levels. An important feature of UME is the independence from population allele frequencies in the discovery panel, thus avoiding ascertainment bias resulting from unbalanced input genetic diversity. Discovered variants are less affected by ascertainment bias because no population filtering is used, and the full diversity of SNPs is retained in the final variant call set to maximize the utility of the dataset for production calling newly sequenced samples. We present a strategy for filtering the recalibrated error profiles that relies on maximizing demographic signals to retain genetic relationships within the population while reducing sequencing error. After the variant discovery phase, we employ the UME production stage, which enriches genotype calling across all coverage levels, benefiting low‐coverage samples. Error introduced in this process is removed through subsequent filtering. Using this approach, we generated a coverage bias‐controlled maize HapMap database, providing a comprehensive representation of maize accessions and emphasizing landrace diversity. This diverse panel of domesticated maize and outgroups from across the Americas enables accurate genotyping in low‐coverage samples while offering crucial context for interpreting diversity, particularly for natural diversity and paleogenomic analyses.
- Open Access
- 30 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in New Phytologist
- Vol. 248 (1) , 339-353
In silico analysis of the evolution of root phenotypes during maize domestication in Neolithic soils of Tehuacán
Summary: Roots are essential for plant adaptation to changing environments, yet the role of roots in crop domestication remains unclear. This study examined the evolution of root phenotypes from teosinte to maize, a transition resulting in reduced nodal root number (NRN), multiseriate cortical sclerenchyma (MCS), and increased seminal root number (SRN). We reconstructed the root phenotypes of maize and teosinte, as well as the environments of the Tehuacán Valley over the last 18 000 yr using a combination of ancient DNA, paleobotany, and functional‐structural modeling. Our models reveal that increasing Holocene atmospheric CO2 concentrations favored the appearance of reduced NRN and MCS between 12 000 and 8000 yr before present (yrBP), promoting deeper root systems. The advent of irrigation by 6000 yrBP switched nitrogen distribution from topsoil to subsoil domains, a change that increased the utility of reduced NRN and MCS. Comparison of allelic frequencies among ancient samples ranging from 5500 to 500 yrBP suggests that increased SRN may have appeared c. 3500 yrBP, coinciding with a period of increased human population, agricultural intensification, and soil degradation. Our results suggest that root phenotypes that enhance plant performance under nitrogen stress are important for maize adaptation to changing agricultural practices in the Tehuacán Valley.
- 30 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in New Phytologist
- Vol. 248 (1) , 339-353
Open AccessIn silico analysis of the evolution of root phenotypes during maize domestication in Neolithic soils of Tehuacán
Summary: Roots are essential for plant adaptation to changing environments, yet the role of roots in crop domestication remains unclear. This study examined the evolution of root phenotypes from teosinte to maize, a transition resulting in reduced nodal root number (NRN), multiseriate cortical sclerenchyma (MCS), and increased seminal root number (SRN). We reconstructed the root phenotypes of maize and teosinte, as well as the environments of the Tehuacán Valley over the last 18 000 yr using a combination of ancient DNA, paleobotany, and functional‐structural modeling. Our models reveal that increasing Holocene atmospheric CO2 concentrations favored the appearance of reduced NRN and MCS between 12 000 and 8000 yr before present (yrBP), promoting deeper root systems. The advent of irrigation by 6000 yrBP switched nitrogen distribution from topsoil to subsoil domains, a change that increased the utility of reduced NRN and MCS. Comparison of allelic frequencies among ancient samples ranging from 5500 to 500 yrBP suggests that increased SRN may have appeared c. 3500 yrBP, coinciding with a period of increased human population, agricultural intensification, and soil degradation. Our results suggest that root phenotypes that enhance plant performance under nitrogen stress are important for maize adaptation to changing agricultural practices in the Tehuacán Valley.
- Open Access
A maize near-isogenic line population designed for gene discovery and characterization of allelic effects
In this study we characterized a panel of 1,264 maize near-isogenic lines (NILs), developed from crosses between 18 diverse inbred lines and the recurrent parent B73, referred to as nested NILs (nNILs). 884 of the nNILs were genotyped using genotyping-by-sequencing (GBS). Subsequently, 24 of these nNILs, and all the parental lines, were re-genotyped using a high-density SNP chip. A novel pipeline for calling introgressions, which does not rely on knowing the donor parent of each nNIL, was developed based on a hidden Markov model (HMM) algorithm. By comparing the introgressions detected using GBS data with those identified using chip data, we optimized the HMM parameters for analyzing the entire nNIL population. A total of 2,972 introgressions were identified across the 884 nNILs. Individual introgression blocks ranged from 21 bp to 204 Mbp, with an average size of 17 Mbp. By comparing SNP genotypes within introgressed segments to the known genotypes of the donor lines we determined that in about one third of the lines, the identity of the donors did not match expectation based on their pedigrees. We characterized the entire nNIL population for three foliar diseases. Using these data, we mapped a number of quantitative trait loci (QTL) for disease resistance in the nNIL population and observed extensive variation in effects among the alleles from different donor parents at most QTL identified. This population will be of significant utility for dissecting complex agronomic traits and allelic series in maize. Significance Statement The study reports the characterization of a publicly available population of 1,264 maize near-isogenic lines largely derived from a single recurrent parent and 18 donor lines. This population is likely to be of significant utility for the characterization of allelic series at loci of interest.
Open AccessA maize near-isogenic line population designed for gene discovery and characterization of allelic effects
In this study we characterized a panel of 1,264 maize near-isogenic lines (NILs), developed from crosses between 18 diverse inbred lines and the recurrent parent B73, referred to as nested NILs (nNILs). 884 of the nNILs were genotyped using genotyping-by-sequencing (GBS). Subsequently, 24 of these nNILs, and all the parental lines, were re-genotyped using a high-density SNP chip. A novel pipeline for calling introgressions, which does not rely on knowing the donor parent of each nNIL, was developed based on a hidden Markov model (HMM) algorithm. By comparing the introgressions detected using GBS data with those identified using chip data, we optimized the HMM parameters for analyzing the entire nNIL population. A total of 2,972 introgressions were identified across the 884 nNILs. Individual introgression blocks ranged from 21 bp to 204 Mbp, with an average size of 17 Mbp. By comparing SNP genotypes within introgressed segments to the known genotypes of the donor lines we determined that in about one third of the lines, the identity of the donors did not match expectation based on their pedigrees. We characterized the entire nNIL population for three foliar diseases. Using these data, we mapped a number of quantitative trait loci (QTL) for disease resistance in the nNIL population and observed extensive variation in effects among the alleles from different donor parents at most QTL identified. This population will be of significant utility for dissecting complex agronomic traits and allelic series in maize. Significance Statement The study reports the characterization of a publicly available population of 1,264 maize near-isogenic lines largely derived from a single recurrent parent and 18 donor lines. This population is likely to be of significant utility for the characterization of allelic series at loci of interest.
- Open Access
Population genomics of Marchantia polymorpha subspecies ruderalis reveals evidence of climate adaptation
Sexual reproduction results in the development of haploid and diploid cell states during the life cycle. In bryophytes the dominant multicellular haploid phase produces motile sperm that swim through water to the egg to effect fertilization from which a relatively small diploid phase develops. In angiosperms, the reduced multicellular haploid phase produces non-motile sperm that is delivered to the egg through a pollen tube to effect fertilization from which the dominant diploid phase develops. These different life cycle characteristics are likely to impact the distribution of genetic variation among populations. However, little is known about the distribution of genetic variation among populations of bryophytes. To understand how genetic variation is distributed among populations of a bryophyte and to establish the foundation for population genetics research in bryophytes, we described the genetic diversity of collections of Marchantia polymorpha subspecies ruderalis , a cosmopolitan ruderal liverwort. We explored genetic diversity of this species using 78 genetically unique (non-clonal) accessions from a total of 209 collected from 37 sites in Europe and Japan. There was no detectable population structure among European populations but significant genetic differentiation between Japanese and European populations. By associating genetic variation across the genome with global climate data, we identified summer temperature and precipitation as climate factors influencing the frequency of adaptative alleles. We speculate that the requirement for water through which motile sperm swim imposes a constraint on the life cycle to which the plant genetically adapts.
Open AccessPopulation genomics of Marchantia polymorpha subspecies ruderalis reveals evidence of climate adaptation
Sexual reproduction results in the development of haploid and diploid cell states during the life cycle. In bryophytes the dominant multicellular haploid phase produces motile sperm that swim through water to the egg to effect fertilization from which a relatively small diploid phase develops. In angiosperms, the reduced multicellular haploid phase produces non-motile sperm that is delivered to the egg through a pollen tube to effect fertilization from which the dominant diploid phase develops. These different life cycle characteristics are likely to impact the distribution of genetic variation among populations. However, little is known about the distribution of genetic variation among populations of bryophytes. To understand how genetic variation is distributed among populations of a bryophyte and to establish the foundation for population genetics research in bryophytes, we described the genetic diversity of collections of Marchantia polymorpha subspecies ruderalis , a cosmopolitan ruderal liverwort. We explored genetic diversity of this species using 78 genetically unique (non-clonal) accessions from a total of 209 collected from 37 sites in Europe and Japan. There was no detectable population structure among European populations but significant genetic differentiation between Japanese and European populations. By associating genetic variation across the genome with global climate data, we identified summer temperature and precipitation as climate factors influencing the frequency of adaptative alleles. We speculate that the requirement for water through which motile sperm swim imposes a constraint on the life cycle to which the plant genetically adapts.
- Open Access
In silico analysis of the evolution of root phenotypes during maize domestication in Neolithic soils of Tehuacán
Summary: Roots are essential for plant adaptation to changing environments, yet the role of roots in crop domestication remains unclear. This study examines the evolution of root phenotypes from teosinte to maize, a transition resulting in reduced nodal root number (NRN), multiseriate cortical sclerenchyma (MCS), and increased seminal root number (SRN). We reconstructed the root phenotypes of maize and teosinte, as well as the environments of the Tehuacan Valley over the last 18,000 years using a combination of ancient DNA, paleobotany, and functional-structural modeling. Our models reveal that increasing Holocene atmospheric CO 2 concentrations favored the appearance of reduced NRN and MCS between 12000 to 8000 years before present (yBP), promoting deeper root systems. The advent of irrigation by 6000 yBP switched nitrogen distribution from topsoil to subsoil domains, a change which increased the utility of reduced NRN and MCS. Comparison of allelic frequencies among ancient samples ranging from 5500 to 500 yBP suggest that increased SRN may have appeared around 3500 yBP, coinciding with a period of increased human population, agricultural intensification, and soil degradation. Our results suggest that root phenotypes that enhance plant performance under nitrogen stress were important for maize adaptation to changing agricultural practices in the Tehuacan Valley. Classification: Physiology & Development
Open AccessIn silico analysis of the evolution of root phenotypes during maize domestication in Neolithic soils of Tehuacán
Summary: Roots are essential for plant adaptation to changing environments, yet the role of roots in crop domestication remains unclear. This study examines the evolution of root phenotypes from teosinte to maize, a transition resulting in reduced nodal root number (NRN), multiseriate cortical sclerenchyma (MCS), and increased seminal root number (SRN). We reconstructed the root phenotypes of maize and teosinte, as well as the environments of the Tehuacan Valley over the last 18,000 years using a combination of ancient DNA, paleobotany, and functional-structural modeling. Our models reveal that increasing Holocene atmospheric CO 2 concentrations favored the appearance of reduced NRN and MCS between 12000 to 8000 years before present (yBP), promoting deeper root systems. The advent of irrigation by 6000 yBP switched nitrogen distribution from topsoil to subsoil domains, a change which increased the utility of reduced NRN and MCS. Comparison of allelic frequencies among ancient samples ranging from 5500 to 500 yBP suggest that increased SRN may have appeared around 3500 yBP, coinciding with a period of increased human population, agricultural intensification, and soil degradation. Our results suggest that root phenotypes that enhance plant performance under nitrogen stress were important for maize adaptation to changing agricultural practices in the Tehuacan Valley. Classification: Physiology & Development
- Open Access
Unified Multi-caller Ensemble (UME) generates an unbiased maize haplotype map for variable coverage whole genome data
We present a novel diversity-focused haplotype map (HapMap) that characterizes over 64.5 million maize ( Zea mays ssp . mays ) single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) genotyped across 818 individuals from diverse backgrounds. This HapMap aims to balance the variation obtained from domesticated landraces and inbred lines, outgroup Zea spp. and more distant Tripsacum spp. in order to minimize ascertainment bias for diversity studies. Included individuals derive from public data from various experimental setups and coverages, which is challenging for standard SNP callers to accommodate. We provide evidence of coverage biases associated with standard callers that influence resulting variation and introduce a novel approach called Unified Multi-Caller Ensemble (UME), which enhances variant calling accuracy in low-coverage and mixed-coverage genomic datasets. UME corrects for coverage bias resulting from inter-sample coverage heterogeneity by leveraging evidence from variant callers with orthogonal strategies, re-calibrating the error probabilities across callers to minimize the impact of error biases inherent to a given caller. It outperforms individual strategies and excels in de novo variant calling, taking advantage of instances of higher depth reads, even in low coverage individuals, while preserving biologically informative variant relationships across coverage levels. An important feature of UME is the independence from population allele frequencies in the discovery panel, thus avoiding ascertainment bias resulting from unbalanced input genetic diversity. Discovered variants are unbiased because no population filtering is used, and the full diversity of SNPs is retained in the final variant call set to maximize the utility of the dataset for production calling newly sequenced samples. We present a strategy for filtering the recalibrated error profiles that relies on maximizing demographic signals to retain genetic relationships within the population while reducing sequencing error. After the variant discovery phase, we employ the UME production stage, which enriches genotype calling across all coverage levels, benefiting low-coverage samples. Error introduced in this process is removed through subsequent filtering. Using this approach, we generated a coverage bias-controlled maize HapMap database, providing a comprehensive representation of maize accessions and emphasizing landrace diversity. This diverse panel of domesticated maize and outgroups from across the Americas enables accurate genotyping in low-coverage samples while offering crucial context for interpreting diversity, particularly for natural diversity and paleogenomic analyses.
Open AccessUnified Multi-caller Ensemble (UME) generates an unbiased maize haplotype map for variable coverage whole genome data
We present a novel diversity-focused haplotype map (HapMap) that characterizes over 64.5 million maize ( Zea mays ssp . mays ) single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) genotyped across 818 individuals from diverse backgrounds. This HapMap aims to balance the variation obtained from domesticated landraces and inbred lines, outgroup Zea spp. and more distant Tripsacum spp. in order to minimize ascertainment bias for diversity studies. Included individuals derive from public data from various experimental setups and coverages, which is challenging for standard SNP callers to accommodate. We provide evidence of coverage biases associated with standard callers that influence resulting variation and introduce a novel approach called Unified Multi-Caller Ensemble (UME), which enhances variant calling accuracy in low-coverage and mixed-coverage genomic datasets. UME corrects for coverage bias resulting from inter-sample coverage heterogeneity by leveraging evidence from variant callers with orthogonal strategies, re-calibrating the error probabilities across callers to minimize the impact of error biases inherent to a given caller. It outperforms individual strategies and excels in de novo variant calling, taking advantage of instances of higher depth reads, even in low coverage individuals, while preserving biologically informative variant relationships across coverage levels. An important feature of UME is the independence from population allele frequencies in the discovery panel, thus avoiding ascertainment bias resulting from unbalanced input genetic diversity. Discovered variants are unbiased because no population filtering is used, and the full diversity of SNPs is retained in the final variant call set to maximize the utility of the dataset for production calling newly sequenced samples. We present a strategy for filtering the recalibrated error profiles that relies on maximizing demographic signals to retain genetic relationships within the population while reducing sequencing error. After the variant discovery phase, we employ the UME production stage, which enriches genotype calling across all coverage levels, benefiting low-coverage samples. Error introduced in this process is removed through subsequent filtering. Using this approach, we generated a coverage bias-controlled maize HapMap database, providing a comprehensive representation of maize accessions and emphasizing landrace diversity. This diverse panel of domesticated maize and outgroups from across the Americas enables accurate genotyping in low-coverage samples while offering crucial context for interpreting diversity, particularly for natural diversity and paleogenomic analyses.
- Open Access
- 21 July 2023
- Published by Wiley in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 14 (9) , 2233-2242
Automation of tree‐ring detection and measurements using deep learning
Core samples from trees are a critical reservoir of ecological information, informing our understanding of past climates, as well as contemporary ecosystem responses to global change. Manual measurements of annual growth rings in trees are slow, labour‐intensive and subject to human bias, hindering the generation of big datasets. We present an alternative, neural network‐based implementation that automates detection and measurement of tree‐ring boundaries from coniferous species. We trained our Mask R‐CNN extensively on over 8000 manually annotated ring boundaries from microscope‐imaged Norway Spruce Picea abies increment cores. We assessed the performance of the trained model after post‐processing on real‐world data generated from our core processing pipeline. The CNN after post‐processing performed well, with recognition of over 98% of ring boundaries (recall) with a precision in detection of 96% when tested on real‐world data. Additionally, we have implemented automatic measurements based on minimum distance between rings. With minimal editing for missed ring detections, these measurements were 98% correlated with human measurements of the same samples. Tests on other three conifer species demonstrate that the CNN generalizes well to other species with similar structure. We demonstrate the efficacy of automating the measurement of growth increment in tree core samples. Our CNN‐based system provides high predictive performance in terms of both tree‐ring detection and growth rate determination. Our application is readily deployable as a Docker container and requires only basic command line skills. Additionally, an easy re‐training option allows users to expand capabilities to other wood types. Application outputs include both editable annotations of predictions as well as ring‐width measurements in a commonly used .pos format, facilitating the efficient generation of large ring‐width measurement datasets from increment core samples, an important source of environmental data.
- 21 July 2023
- Published by Wiley in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 14 (9) , 2233-2242
Open AccessAutomation of tree‐ring detection and measurements using deep learning
Core samples from trees are a critical reservoir of ecological information, informing our understanding of past climates, as well as contemporary ecosystem responses to global change. Manual measurements of annual growth rings in trees are slow, labour‐intensive and subject to human bias, hindering the generation of big datasets. We present an alternative, neural network‐based implementation that automates detection and measurement of tree‐ring boundaries from coniferous species. We trained our Mask R‐CNN extensively on over 8000 manually annotated ring boundaries from microscope‐imaged Norway Spruce Picea abies increment cores. We assessed the performance of the trained model after post‐processing on real‐world data generated from our core processing pipeline. The CNN after post‐processing performed well, with recognition of over 98% of ring boundaries (recall) with a precision in detection of 96% when tested on real‐world data. Additionally, we have implemented automatic measurements based on minimum distance between rings. With minimal editing for missed ring detections, these measurements were 98% correlated with human measurements of the same samples. Tests on other three conifer species demonstrate that the CNN generalizes well to other species with similar structure. We demonstrate the efficacy of automating the measurement of growth increment in tree core samples. Our CNN‐based system provides high predictive performance in terms of both tree‐ring detection and growth rate determination. Our application is readily deployable as a Docker container and requires only basic command line skills. Additionally, an easy re‐training option allows users to expand capabilities to other wood types. Application outputs include both editable annotations of predictions as well as ring‐width measurements in a commonly used .pos format, facilitating the efficient generation of large ring‐width measurement datasets from increment core samples, an important source of environmental data.
- Open Access
- 26 May 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Agricultural and Forest Meteorology
- Vol. 322
The Last Trees Standing: Climate modulates tree survival factors during a prolonged bark beetle outbreak in Europe
- 26 May 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Agricultural and Forest Meteorology
- Vol. 322
Open AccessThe Last Trees Standing: Climate modulates tree survival factors during a prolonged bark beetle outbreak in Europe
- Open Access
Heritable and Climatic Sources of Variation in Juvenile Tree Growth in an Austrian Common Garden Experiment of Central European Norway Spruce Populations
We leveraged publicly available data on juvenile tree height of 299 Central European Norway spruce populations grown in a common garden experiment across 24 diverse trial locations in Austria and weather data from the trial locations and population provenances to parse the heritable and climatic components of juvenile tree height variation. Principal component analysis of geospatial and weather variables demonstrated high interannual variation among trial environments, largely driven by differences in precipitation, and separation of population provenances based on altitude, temperature, and snowfall. Tree height was highly heritable and modeling the covariance between populations and trial environments based on climatic data led to more stable estimation of heritability and population × environment variance. Climatic similarity among population provenances was highly predictive of population × environment estimates for tree height.
Open AccessHeritable and Climatic Sources of Variation in Juvenile Tree Growth in an Austrian Common Garden Experiment of Central European Norway Spruce Populations
We leveraged publicly available data on juvenile tree height of 299 Central European Norway spruce populations grown in a common garden experiment across 24 diverse trial locations in Austria and weather data from the trial locations and population provenances to parse the heritable and climatic components of juvenile tree height variation. Principal component analysis of geospatial and weather variables demonstrated high interannual variation among trial environments, largely driven by differences in precipitation, and separation of population provenances based on altitude, temperature, and snowfall. Tree height was highly heritable and modeling the covariance between populations and trial environments based on climatic data led to more stable estimation of heritability and population × environment variance. Climatic similarity among population provenances was highly predictive of population × environment estimates for tree height.
- Open Access
Domestication and lowland adaptation of coastal preceramic maize from Paredones, Peru
Archaeological cobs from Paredones and Huaca Prieta (Peru) are phenotypically indistinguishable from modern maize. This contrasts with the earliest Mexican macro-specimens from Guila Naquitz and San Marcos, which are phenotypically intermediate even though they date more recently in time. These observations suggest at least two alternative scenarios, one in which maize was domesticated earlier than previously thought in the lowland Mesoamerica, followed by rapid lowland dispersal to Peru, and another in which maize was independently domesticated in South America and subsequently lost, as current evidence supports a single origin for all modern maize. To gain insights into the origins of ancient Peruvian maize, we sequenced DNA from three Paredones specimens dating 6775 to 5000 calibrated years before present (BP) and conducted comparative analyses with two teosinte subspecies ( Zea mays ssp. mexicana and parviglumis ) and extant maize, including highland and lowland landraces from Mesoamerica and South America. We show that Paredones maize originated from the same domestication event as Mexican maize and was domesticated by 6775 BP, implying rapid dispersal followed by improvement. Paredones maize show minimal levels of gene flow from mexicana , smaller than those observed in teosinte parviglumis . It also harbors significantly fewer alleles previously found to be adaptive to highlands, but not of alleles adaptive to lowlands, supporting a lowland migration route. Our overall results imply that Paredones maize originated in Mesoamerica, arrived in Peru without mexicana introgression through a rapid lowland migration route, and underwent improvements in both Mesoamerica and South America. Significance Statement: The coastal Peruvian preceramic sites of Paredones and Huaca Prieta provide the earliest known maize macro-remains. Found more than 3,800 km away from the maize center of origin and presenting a phenotypically modern cob constitution relative to their antiquity, these specimens represent a paradox for understanding maize evolution and dispersal. We show that Paredones maize originated in Mesoamerica, like all known maize, and arrived in South America without introgression from the teosinte mexicana . Since modern maize has substantial contributions from mexicana , it raises the question of when mexicana introgression spread to South America. Paredones maize preferentially shares adaptive allelic diversity with lowland Mesoamerican samples, suggesting a migration route probably associated with a coastal corridor previously identified with archeological findings.
Open AccessDomestication and lowland adaptation of coastal preceramic maize from Paredones, Peru
Archaeological cobs from Paredones and Huaca Prieta (Peru) are phenotypically indistinguishable from modern maize. This contrasts with the earliest Mexican macro-specimens from Guila Naquitz and San Marcos, which are phenotypically intermediate even though they date more recently in time. These observations suggest at least two alternative scenarios, one in which maize was domesticated earlier than previously thought in the lowland Mesoamerica, followed by rapid lowland dispersal to Peru, and another in which maize was independently domesticated in South America and subsequently lost, as current evidence supports a single origin for all modern maize. To gain insights into the origins of ancient Peruvian maize, we sequenced DNA from three Paredones specimens dating 6775 to 5000 calibrated years before present (BP) and conducted comparative analyses with two teosinte subspecies ( Zea mays ssp. mexicana and parviglumis ) and extant maize, including highland and lowland landraces from Mesoamerica and South America. We show that Paredones maize originated from the same domestication event as Mexican maize and was domesticated by 6775 BP, implying rapid dispersal followed by improvement. Paredones maize show minimal levels of gene flow from mexicana , smaller than those observed in teosinte parviglumis . It also harbors significantly fewer alleles previously found to be adaptive to highlands, but not of alleles adaptive to lowlands, supporting a lowland migration route. Our overall results imply that Paredones maize originated in Mesoamerica, arrived in Peru without mexicana introgression through a rapid lowland migration route, and underwent improvements in both Mesoamerica and South America. Significance Statement: The coastal Peruvian preceramic sites of Paredones and Huaca Prieta provide the earliest known maize macro-remains. Found more than 3,800 km away from the maize center of origin and presenting a phenotypically modern cob constitution relative to their antiquity, these specimens represent a paradox for understanding maize evolution and dispersal. We show that Paredones maize originated in Mesoamerica, like all known maize, and arrived in South America without introgression from the teosinte mexicana . Since modern maize has substantial contributions from mexicana , it raises the question of when mexicana introgression spread to South America. Paredones maize preferentially shares adaptive allelic diversity with lowland Mesoamerican samples, suggesting a migration route probably associated with a coastal corridor previously identified with archeological findings.