PSPatrick M. Shober

Patrick M. Shober

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Patrick M. Shober has a total of 239 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Asteroidal Activity among Meteor Datasets: Confirmed New “Rock-comet” Stream and Search for a Tidal-disruption Signature

    by Patrick M. Shober

    Asteroid activity (e.g., thermo-mechanical breakdown, impacts, rotational shedding, tidal disruption) can inject meteoroids into near-Earth space and leave detectable signatures in orbit catalogs. We searched for such recent signatures using orbit-similarity statistics and explicit null-hypothesis testing applied to shower-removed, asteroidal video-meteor datasets. Our sample comprises 235,271 meteors and fireballs from four all-sky video networks (Global Meteor Network, GMN, Cameras for All-sky Meteor Surveillance, CAMS, European viDeo Meteor Observation Network Database, EDMOND, and SonotaCo). For meteors we use the geocentric dissimilarity criterion D N and construct kernel density estimator (KDE)-based sporadic null realizations to evaluate (i) global cumulative similarity distributions and (ii) localized D N -conditioned ( D N < 0.015) pair-excess maps in the ( U , λ ⊙ ) plane; we additionally apply DBSCAN ( ϵ = 0.03, min _ samples = 2 ) to isolate the coherent, statistically significant structures. We find no survey-consistent, stream-like signature in the Earth-like, low-inclination region expected for a distinct recent tidal-disruption family; instead, significant-bin membership implies, under our adopted detection thresholds and binning, a conservative combined upper limit of ≤53/235,271 ( ≤2.3 × 10 −4 ) for sporadic asteroidal meteors plausibly attributable to a detectable recent tidal-disruption-like contribution. In contrast, we confirm the detection of a new diffuse southern Virginid-region stream: GMN exhibits a local z -score of 6.32 relative to the KDE-null mean in the U − λ ⊙ phase space (global significance of 5.3 σ ), with weaker supporting excess in SonotaCo and EDMOND. DBSCAN isolates N = 282 members (243 GMN plus additional SonotaCo, CAMS, and EDMOND) on a low-perihelion, asteroidal orbit ( q = 0.22 ± 0.01 au, i = 12 . ° 3 ± 1 . ° 8, T J = 4.6 ± 0.3) consistent with near-Sun thermo-mechanical “rock-comet” activity.


  • Open Access

    Asteroidal activity amongst meteor datasets: Confirmed new "rock-comet" stream and search for a tidal disruption signature

    by Patrick M. Shober

    Asteroid activity (e.g., thermo-mechanical breakdown, impacts, rotational shedding, tidal disruption, etc.) can inject meteoroids into near-Earth space and leave detectable signatures in orbit catalogs. We searched for such recent signatures using orbit-similarity statistics and explicit null-hypothesis testing applied to shower-removed, asteroidal video-meteor datasets. Our sample comprises 235{,}271 meteors and fireballs from four all-sky video networks (GMN, CAMS, EDMOND, and SonotaCo). For meteors we use the geocentric dissimilarity criterion $D_N$ and construct KDE-based sporadic null realizations to evaluate (i) global cumulative similarity distributions and (ii) localized $D_N$-conditioned ($D_N<0.015$) pair-excess maps in the $(U,λ_\odot)$ plane; we additionally apply DBSCAN ($ε=0.03$, $\mathrm{min\_samples}=2$) to isolate the coherent, statistically significant structures. We find no survey-consistent, stream-like signature in the Earth-like, low-inclination region expected for a distinct \emph{recent} tidal-disruption family; instead, significant-bin membership implies, under our adopted detection thresholds and binning, a conservative combined upper limit of $\leq 53/235{,}271$ ($\leq 2.3\times10^{-4}$) for sporadic asteroidal meteors plausibly attributable to a detectable recent tidal-disruption-like contribution. In contrast, we confirm the detection of a new diffuse southern Virginid-region stream: GMN exhibits a local z-score of 6.32 relative to the KDE-null mean in the $U-λ_\odot$ phase space (global significance of 5.3~$σ$), with weaker supporting excess in SonotaCo and EDMOND. DBSCAN isolates $N=282$ members (243 GMN plus additional SonotaCo, CAMS, and EDMOND) on a low-perihelion, asteroidal orbit ($q=0.22\pm0.01$ au, $i=12.3^{\circ}\pm1.8^{\circ}$, $T_J=4.6\pm0.3$) consistent with near-Sun thermo-mechanical ``rock-comet'' activity.

  • Open Access

    A Near-Earth Object Model Calibrated to Earth Impactors

    by Sophie E. Deam, Hadrien A. R. Devillepoix, David Nesvorný, Patrick M. Shober, Eleanor K. Sansom, Jim Albers, Eric Anderson, Zouhair Benkhaldoun, Peter G. Brown, Luke Daly, et al.

    The population of Earth-impacting meteoroids and their size-dependent orbital elements are key to understanding the origin of meteorites and informing planetary defense efforts. Outstanding questions include the role of collisions in depleting meteoroids on highly evolved orbits and the relative importance of delivery resonances. Those depend on size, with current dynamical models considering only asteroids larger than 10 m in diameter. Based on 1202 sporadic meteoroids observed by the Global Fireball Observatory, we created a debiased model of the near-Earth meteoroid population in the 10 g–150 kg size range (approximately 1 cm–0.5 m in diameter) as they dynamically evolved from the main asteroid belt onto Earth-crossing orbits. The observed impact population is best matched with a collisional half-life decreasing from 3 Myr for meteoroids of 0.6 kg (7 cm) or higher to 1 Myr below this size, extending to the model lower bound of 10 g. Placing our results in context with near-Earth object models for larger sizes, we find that the inner main belt continues to dominate feeding the small 1–10 m diameter population primarily via the ν 6 secular resonance and the 3:1J mean-motion resonance. We also evaluated the potential significance of physical processes other than collisions on Earth-impacting meteoroids, such as low-perihelion disruptions from thermal stresses.

  • Open Access

    Comparing the data-reduction pipelines of FRIPON, DFN, WMPL, and AMOS: Case study of the Geminids

    by P. M. Shober, J. Vaubaillon, S. Anghel, H. A. R. Devillepoix, F. Hlobik, P. Matlovič, J. Tóth, D. Vida, E. K. Sansom, T. Jansen-Sturgeon, et al.

    Context . The number of meteor observation networks has expanded rapidly due to declining hardware costs, enabling professional and amateur groups to contribute substantial datasets. An accurate data reduction remains challenging, however, because variations in processing methods can significantly affect the trajectory reconstructions and orbital interpretations. Aims . Our goal is to thoroughly compare four professionally produced meteor data-reduction pipelines (FRIPON, DFN, WMPL, and AMOS) by reprocessing FRIPON Geminid observations. This analysis can be used for a comparison with other data-reduction methods. Methods . We processed a dataset of 5 84 Geminid fireballs observed by FRIPON between 2016 and 2023. The single-station astrometric data were converted into the global fireball exchange (GFE) standard format for uniform processing. We assessed variations in trajectory, velocity, and radiant and orbital element calculations in the pipelines and compared them to previously published Geminid measurements. Results . The radiant and velocity solutions provided by the four data-reduction pipelines are all within the range of previously published values, with some nuances. Particularly, the radiants estimated by WMPL, DFN, and AMOS are nearly identical, but FRIPON reports a systematic shift in right ascension (−0.3°) that is caused by an improper handling of the precession. Additionally, the FRIPON data-reduction pipeline also tends to overestimate the initial velocity (+0.3 km s −1 ), which is due to the deceleration model used as the velocity solver. The FRIPON velocity method relies on a well-constrained deceleration profile, but for the Geminids, many are low-deceleration events, which leads to an overestimation of the initial velocity. At the other end of the spectrum, the DFN tends to predict lower velocities, in particular, for poorly observed events. This velocity shift vanishes for the DFN when we considered Geminids alone with at least three observations or more, however. The primary difference identified in the analysis concerns the velocity uncertainties. Although all four pipelines achieved similar residuals between their trajectories and observations, their velocity uncertainties varied systematically. WMPL outputs the lowest values, followed by AMOS, FRIPON, and DFN. Conclusions . From this Geminid case study, we find that the default FRIPON data-reduction methods, while adequate for meteoritedropping events, are not optimal for all cases. Specifically, FRIPON tends to overestimate velocities for low-deceleration events because the fit is less strongly constrained, and the nominal radiants are not correctly output in J2000. On the other hand, the other data-reduction pipelines (DFN, WMPL, and AMOS) produce consistent results, provided that the observational data are sufficiently robust, that is, more than ∼50 data points from at least three observers. A key takeaway is that we need to reevaluate how the velocity uncertainties are estimated. Our results show that the uncertainty estimates vary systematically in different pipelines, even though the goodness-of-fit statistics is generally similar. The increasing availability of impact observations from varying sources (radar, video, photo, seismic, infrasound, satellite, telescopic, etc.) calls for greater collaboration and transparency in data-reduction practices.


  • Open Access

    Determining the statistical significance of meteorite–asteroid pairs using geocentric parameters

    by P. M. Shober

    Context. Orbital similarity between precisely observed meteorite falls and near-Earth asteroids (NEAs) has been presented for decades as evidence that some meteorites are coming directly from these asteroids. However, analysis of the statistical significance of these pairings is mixed. Based on osculating orbital elements, there is no evidence of statistically significant clustering; however, some analyses that account for secular perturbations suggest that streams are present. Aims. We tested the statistical significance of meteorite-dropping fireballs and NEA clustering using the DN similarity function based on four geocentric quantities (U, θ, ϕ, and λ⊙). Methods. We calculated the cumulative similarity found between 46 meteorite falls, 535 potential meteorite-dropping fireballs, and 20 516 NEAs maintained by NEODyS-2, along with 34 836 NEAs maintained by NASA/JPL HORIZONS. Statistical significance was estimated either by (1) using a kernel density estimation-based method to estimate the sporadic background distribution and thus draw random samples or (2) applying a uniform random solar longitude (λ⊙). Each comparison to the synthetic sporadic population was repeated to estimate the 3σ region for which the cumulative similarity distribution is consistent with random association levels. Results. The observed DN cumulative similarity distribution of 46 instrumentally observed meteorite falls, 535 potential meteoritedropping fireballs, and over 30 k NEA radiants (estimated using six different radiant methods) reveals no statistically significant excess of similarity between the populations consistent with streams. Conclusions. Based on nearly 600 fireball observations and geocentric impact parameters, we find there is no statistically significant clustering between meteorite falls and NEAs. If some meteorites arrive in streams, they make up less than ~0.1% of all falls. Recent asteroid or meteoroid physical processes could still explain features found in meteorites, but this activity is not producing distinguishable orbital streams or pairs.


  • What falls versus what we recover: Quantifying search and recovery bias for orbital meteorites

    by Patrick M. Shober, Jeremie Vaubaillon, Hadrien A. R. Devillepoix, Eleanor K. Sansom, Sophie E. Deam, Simon Anghel, Francois Colas, Pierre Vernazza, Brigitte Zanda, Sylvain Bouley

    Instrumentally determined pre‐atmospheric orbits of meteorites offer crucial constraints on the provenance of extraterrestrial material and the dynamical pathways that deliver it to Earth. However, recovery efforts are focused on larger and slower impacts due to their higher survival probabilities and ease of detection. In this study, we investigate the prevalence of these biases in the population of recovered meteorites with known orbits. We compiled a data set of 75 meteorites with triangulated trajectories and compared their orbits to 538 potential 1 g meteorite‐dropping fireballs detected by the Global Fireball Observatory, the European Fireball Network, and the Fireball Recovery and InterPlanetary Observation Network. Our results reveal that objects with small semi‐major axis values (a1.8 au) appear 2–3 more often than expected. The current sample of meteorites with known orbits does not reflect the sources of meteorites in our collections, and it is essential to account for search and recovery biases to obtain a more representative understanding of meteorite source contributions.


  • Open Access

    Perihelion history and atmospheric disruption: The Primary Culprits of the Missing Carbonaceous Chondrites

    by Patrick Shober, Hadrien A. R. Devillepoix, Jeremie Vaubaillon, Simon Anghel, Sophie E. Deam, Eleanor K. Sansom, Francois Colas, Brigitte Zanda, Pierre Vernazza, Phil Bland

    Hydrated, carbonaceous asteroids constitute the majority of the main‑belt [1], whereas carbonaceous chondrites form just ≈4% of the >83,000 meteorites in collections [2]. Additionally, recent meteoroid transfer models from young asteroid families predict >50% of the meteoroid impacts at the top of the atmosphere should be carbonaceous in composition, a mismatch often ascribed—to their inherent material fragility [2,3]. MethodsTo test whether Earth’s atmosphere drives the mismatch between the predicted carbonaceous meteoroid flux and the recovered carbonaceous meteorite flux, we compared the orbital distributions of a debiased sporadic asteroidal impact population against those of meteorite‑dropping fireballs. We assembled 7,982 top‑of‑atmosphere sporadic impacts (≥ 10 g) from five global networks (EDMOND, CAMS, GMN, EFN, FRIPON), spanning 19 camera systems across 39 countries. Meteor showers were removed using the Valsecchi DN 20 km/s), a regime normally more hostile to meteorite survival—nonetheless endure atmospheric passage more often than slower, less cohesive bodies, demonstrating that intrinsic strength gained from thermal processing outweighs the disadvantage of increased ablation [4]. Even so, once past the thermal fragmentation filter, only about 30-50% of kilogram‑scale meteoroids survive to deposit substantial fragments on the ground (see Supplementary Figure 9 in [4]), confirming that atmospheric breakup remains a significant sieve.Together, the combined action of solar heating and atmospheric entry preferentially delivers low‑porosity, thermally resilient carbonaceous fragments that have avoided—or survived—severe thermal fatigue. This dual filtering mechanism naturally accounts for the anomalously short cosmic‑ray exposure ages of CI and CM chondrites [3,4] and their pronounced scarcity among collected meteorites [2,3]. References: [1] DeMeo, F. E. and B. Carry. (2014) Nature 505:629–634. [2] Brož, M., et al. (2024) Astronomy & Astrophysics 689:A183. [3] Scherer, P. and L. Schultz. (2000) Meteoritics & Planetary Science 35.1: 145-153. [4] Shober P.M. et al. (2025) Nature Astronomy 14:1-4

  • Perihelion history and atmospheric survival as primary drivers of the Earth’s meteorite record

    by Patrick M. Shober, Hadrien A. R. Devillepoix, Jeremie Vaubaillon, Simon Anghel, Sophie E. Deam, Eleanor K. Sansom, Francois Colas, Brigitte Zanda, Pierre Vernazza, Phil Bland


  • Open Access

    Perihelion history and atmospheric survival as primary drivers of the Earth`s meteorite record

    by Patrick M. Shober, Hadrien A. R. Devillepoix, Jeremie Vaubaillon, Simon Anghel, Sophie E. Deam, Eleanor K. Sansom, Francois Colas, Brigitte Zanda, Pierre Vernazza, Phil Bland

    Models predict that more than half of all impacting meteoroids should be carbonaceous, reflecting the abundance of carbon-rich asteroids in the main belt and near-Earth space. Yet carbonaceous chondrites represent only about 4% of meteorites recovered worldwide. Here we analyse 7,982 meteoroid impacts and 540 potential meteorite falls from 19 global observation networks and demonstrate that intense thermal stress at low perihelion distances coupled with the filtering effect of Earth`s atmosphere explains this mismatch. Meteoroids repeatedly subjected to intense thermal cycling near the Sun fracture and weaken, removing the most friable objects even before atmospheric entry. Our data also show that tidally disrupted meteoroid streams produce especially fragile fragments that rarely survive to the ground. Consequently, compact, higher-strength, thermally cycled bodies dominate the meteorite record. These findings reconcile the predicted carbonaceous flux with its scarcity in collections, underscoring how orbital evolution and atmospheric filtering shape the materials that reach Earth`s surface.

  • Open Access

    Unraveling the Origins of JFC-like Bodies: A Comparative Study of Comets and Meteoroids

    by Patrick Shober, Jeremie Vaubaillon, Gonzalo Tancredi, Hadrien Devillepoix, Eleanor Sansom, Sophie Deam, Simon Anghel, Francois Colas, Silvia Martino

    Jupiter-family comets (JFCs) originate from the Kuiper belt and scattered disk, characterized by short orbital periods and frequent interactions with Jupiter. Their icy composition and a chaotic transition to the inner solar system result in short dynamic and physical lifetimes. These features make JFCs key subjects for understanding the migration of celestial bodies and possibly the delivery of organic materials to the early Earth. Numerous studies of fireballs have historically posited a substantial contribution of large objects from JFC orbits, suggesting a significant presence of cometary material in the near-Earth environment. However, this prevalent belief necessitates a thorough re-examination, as the physical evolution of comets and the mechanisms governing their disintegration remain subjects of debate. Understanding the population of meteoroids and comets is crucial for evaluating this population's physical breakdown and evolution. Current dust models suggest that fragmentation and disintegration of comets play a significant role in populating the zodiacal cloud. However, the larger centimeter-meter scale debris observed by fireball networks has been shown to resemble more asteroidal sources dynamically, indicating that comets might be breaking down directly only into dust-sized fragments. This study extends the scope of existing research by conducting a detailed analysis of both JFCs and comet-like fireball observations, aiming to elucidate the origins and dynamics of objects on JFC-like orbits across varying size scales. Utilizing extensive data from four major fireball networks (DFN, EFN, FRIPON, MORP) and ephemeris data of JFCs, the research comprises 646 fireball orbits and 661 JFCs. Methods include orbital stability analysis over 10,000 years, Lyapunov lifetime estimation, debiased NEO model source region estimation, meteorite fall identification, and meteor shower analysis.The analysis reveals that most meteoroids on JFC-like orbits do not align dynamically with typical JFCs. Instead, they predominantly originate from stable orbits in the outer main asteroid belt, challenging the notion that centimeter-to-meter scale meteoroids on JFC-like orbits primarily derive from JFCs. Furthermore, a subset of 24 JFCs in near-Earth orbits displayed unexpected orbital stability, suggesting a presence of asteroidal interlopers from the outer main belt within the JFC population.Our study demonstrates significant dynamical differences between kilometer-scale JFCs and smaller meteoroids. While the larger JFCs frequently encounter Jupiter and have dynamic, transient orbits, the smaller meteoroids detected by fireball networks originate primarily from stable orbits, indicating a predominant influence of asteroidal material from the outer main belt. This finding challenges conventional assumptions about the origins of JFC-like debris observed on Earth and highlights the complexity and diversity of the small-body environment in our solar system.