Christopher Grant Thomas
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Christopher Grant Thomas has a total of 53 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
R. Lee MacDonald
Department of Radiation Oncology, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, M4N 3M5, Canada
5 shared publications- Ravi S. Menon
Centre for Functional and Metabolic Mapping, Robarts Research Institute Western University London Ontario Canada
5 shared publications - Alasdair Syme
Dalhousie University
4 shared publications Alasdair Syme
Department of Physics and Atmospheric Science Dalhousie University Halifax Nova Scotia Canada
3 shared publicationsBrian Little
Department of Medical Physics Nova Scotia Health Authority Halifax Nova Scotia Canada
3 shared publicationsLucy Ward
Department of Radiation Oncology Dalhousie University Halifax Canada
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 June 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 25 (9) , e14396
Serial and parallel organ‐at‐risk‐specific noncoplanar arc optimization for small versus large target volumes in liver SBRT
Noncoplanar arc optimization has been shown to reduce OAR doses in SRS/SRT and has the potential to reduce doses to OARs in SBRT. Extracranial targets have additional considerations, including large OARs and, in the case of the liver, volume constraints on the healthy liver. Considering pathlengths through OARs that encompass target volumes may lead to specific dose reductions as in the encompassing healthy liver tissue. These optimizations must also leverage delivery efficiency and trajectory sampling to ensure ease of clinical translation. The purpose of this research is to generate optimized static‐couch arcs that separately consider serial and parallel OARs and arc delivery efficiency, with a trajectory sampling metric, towards the aim of reducing dose to OARs and the surrounding healthy liver tissue. Separate BEV cost maps were created for parallel, and serial OARs by means of a fast ray‐triangle intersection algorithm. An additional BEV cost map was created for the liver which, by definition, encompasses the liver tumors. The individual costs of these maps were summed and combined with the sampling metric for 100 000 random combinations of arc trajectories. A search algorithm was applied to find an arc trajectory solution that satisfied BEV cost and sampling optimization, while also ensuring an efficient delivery was possible with a low number of arcs. This method of arc selection was evaluated for 16 liver SBRT patients characterized by small and large target volumes. Comparisons were made with a clinical arc template of coplanar arcs. Dosimetric plan quality was evaluated using published guidelines and metrics from RTOG1112. Four of five plan quality metrics for the liver were significantly reduced when planned with optimized noncoplanar arcs. Median (range) reductions of the volumes receiving 10, 18, and 21 Gy were found of 140.4 (295.8) cc (p = 0.001), 28.2 (230.6) cc (p = 0.002) and 18.5 (155.5) cc (p = 0.04). A significant increase in median (range) dose to the right kidney of 0.2 ± 0.9 Gy (p = 0.03) was also found using optimized noncoplanar arcs, which was below the tolerance of 10 Gy for all cases. The average number of arcs chosen was 4 ± 1. Optimizing serial and parallel OARs separately during static couch noncoplanar arc selection significantly reduced the dose to the liver during SBRT using a moderate number of arcs.
- 18 June 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 25 (9) , e14396
Open AccessSerial and parallel organ‐at‐risk‐specific noncoplanar arc optimization for small versus large target volumes in liver SBRT
Noncoplanar arc optimization has been shown to reduce OAR doses in SRS/SRT and has the potential to reduce doses to OARs in SBRT. Extracranial targets have additional considerations, including large OARs and, in the case of the liver, volume constraints on the healthy liver. Considering pathlengths through OARs that encompass target volumes may lead to specific dose reductions as in the encompassing healthy liver tissue. These optimizations must also leverage delivery efficiency and trajectory sampling to ensure ease of clinical translation. The purpose of this research is to generate optimized static‐couch arcs that separately consider serial and parallel OARs and arc delivery efficiency, with a trajectory sampling metric, towards the aim of reducing dose to OARs and the surrounding healthy liver tissue. Separate BEV cost maps were created for parallel, and serial OARs by means of a fast ray‐triangle intersection algorithm. An additional BEV cost map was created for the liver which, by definition, encompasses the liver tumors. The individual costs of these maps were summed and combined with the sampling metric for 100 000 random combinations of arc trajectories. A search algorithm was applied to find an arc trajectory solution that satisfied BEV cost and sampling optimization, while also ensuring an efficient delivery was possible with a low number of arcs. This method of arc selection was evaluated for 16 liver SBRT patients characterized by small and large target volumes. Comparisons were made with a clinical arc template of coplanar arcs. Dosimetric plan quality was evaluated using published guidelines and metrics from RTOG1112. Four of five plan quality metrics for the liver were significantly reduced when planned with optimized noncoplanar arcs. Median (range) reductions of the volumes receiving 10, 18, and 21 Gy were found of 140.4 (295.8) cc (p = 0.001), 28.2 (230.6) cc (p = 0.002) and 18.5 (155.5) cc (p = 0.04). A significant increase in median (range) dose to the right kidney of 0.2 ± 0.9 Gy (p = 0.03) was also found using optimized noncoplanar arcs, which was below the tolerance of 10 Gy for all cases. The average number of arcs chosen was 4 ± 1. Optimizing serial and parallel OARs separately during static couch noncoplanar arc selection significantly reduced the dose to the liver during SBRT using a moderate number of arcs.
- 25 December 2023
- Published by Wiley in Alzheimer's & Dementia
- Vol. 19 (S23)
NIA’s qualitative message testing: optimizing how to communicate Alzheimer’s and related dementia research with the public
Background: Communicating the latest advances in Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias (AD/ADRD) research to the public is part of the NIH National Institute on Aging’s mission and strategic directions plan. To further this goal, the NIA Office of Communications and Public Liaison obtained insights from focus groups and in‐depth interviews (IDIs) to optimize language used in public outreach efforts.Method: NIA contracted the public opinion company Edge Research to conduct a qualitative study. NIA messages about AD/ADRD research were tested in five focus groups and six IDIs. Of the focus groups, three were with at‐risk Individuals (people with family history) and two were with caregivers for someone with Alzheimer’s or a related dementia. The six IDIs were with individuals who were experiencing symptoms of dementia or who had been diagnosed by their doctor with early signs of Alzheimer’s or a related dementia. The messages tested relayed information about AD/ADRD research basics, progress, future direction, and clinical trial participation.Result: The results suggested that current NIA messaging communicates many key ideas and information as intended and that government sources of information about dementia generally are trusted. Nevertheless, even among those who are symptomatic, have a family history, or who spend their days as a caregiver, knowledge about AD/ADRD is imperfect and sometimes vague. Additionally, respondents could not recall information about the latest in dementia research; and they were hesitant to participate in clinical trials in part because of a misconception that all trials involve a medication.Conclusion: The results reinforced the need for ongoing efforts to communicate about AD/ADRD research to the public. NIA is incorporating feedback and recommendations in current and future materials.
- 25 December 2023
- Published by Wiley in Alzheimer's & Dementia
- Vol. 19 (S23)
NIA’s qualitative message testing: optimizing how to communicate Alzheimer’s and related dementia research with the public
Background: Communicating the latest advances in Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias (AD/ADRD) research to the public is part of the NIH National Institute on Aging’s mission and strategic directions plan. To further this goal, the NIA Office of Communications and Public Liaison obtained insights from focus groups and in‐depth interviews (IDIs) to optimize language used in public outreach efforts.Method: NIA contracted the public opinion company Edge Research to conduct a qualitative study. NIA messages about AD/ADRD research were tested in five focus groups and six IDIs. Of the focus groups, three were with at‐risk Individuals (people with family history) and two were with caregivers for someone with Alzheimer’s or a related dementia. The six IDIs were with individuals who were experiencing symptoms of dementia or who had been diagnosed by their doctor with early signs of Alzheimer’s or a related dementia. The messages tested relayed information about AD/ADRD research basics, progress, future direction, and clinical trial participation.Result: The results suggested that current NIA messaging communicates many key ideas and information as intended and that government sources of information about dementia generally are trusted. Nevertheless, even among those who are symptomatic, have a family history, or who spend their days as a caregiver, knowledge about AD/ADRD is imperfect and sometimes vague. Additionally, respondents could not recall information about the latest in dementia research; and they were hesitant to participate in clinical trials in part because of a misconception that all trials involve a medication.Conclusion: The results reinforced the need for ongoing efforts to communicate about AD/ADRD research to the public. NIA is incorporating feedback and recommendations in current and future materials.
- 21 July 2023
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 68 (15) , 155011
Static couch non-coplanar arc selection optimization for lung SBRT treatment planning
Objective . Non-coplanar arc geometry optimizations that take advantage of beam’s eye view (BEV) geometric overlap information have been proven to reduce dose to healthy organs-at-risk (OARs). Recently, a metric called mean arc distance (MAD) has been developed that quantifies the arc geometry sampling of 4 π space. The purpose of this research is to combine improved BEV overlap information with MAD to generate static couch lung stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) treatment plans deliverable on a C-arm linear accelerator. Approach . An algorithm utilizing the Moller–Trumbore ray-triangle intersection method was employed to compute a cost surrogate for dose to overlapping OARs using distances interpolated onto a PDD. Cost was combined with MAD for 100 000 random combinations of arc trajectories. A pathfinding algorithm for arc selection was created, balancing the contributions of MAD and 4 π cost for the final trajectory. This methodology was evaluated for 18 lung SBRT patients. Cases were also planned with arcs from a clinical treatment template protocol for dosimetric and plan quality comparison. Results were evaluated using dose constraints in the context of RTOG0915. Main results . Five of six OARs had maximum dose reductions when planned with the arc trajectory optimization algorithm. Significant maximum dose reductions were found for esophagus (7.41 ± 0.91 Gy, p = 0.00019), trachea (5.56 ± 1.55 Gy, p = 0.0025), spinal cord (2.87 ± 1.13 Gy, p = 0.039), large bronchus (3.47 ± 1.49 Gy, p = 0.0075), and aorta (3.13 ± 0.99 Gy, p = 0.012). Mean dose to contralateral lung was also significantly reduced (0.50 ± 0.06 Gy, p = 0.00019). There were two significant increases in OAR doses: mean dose to ipsilateral lung (0.40 ± 0.09, p = 0.00086) and V5 Gy to ipsilateral lung (1.95 ± 0.70%, p = 0.011). Paddick conformity index increased by 0.03 ± 0.02 ( p = 0.14), remaining below a limit of 1.2 for both techniques. Significance . Static couch non-coplanar optimization yielded maximum dose reductions to OARs while maintaining target conformity for lung SBRT.
- 21 July 2023
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 68 (15) , 155011
Static couch non-coplanar arc selection optimization for lung SBRT treatment planning
Objective . Non-coplanar arc geometry optimizations that take advantage of beam’s eye view (BEV) geometric overlap information have been proven to reduce dose to healthy organs-at-risk (OARs). Recently, a metric called mean arc distance (MAD) has been developed that quantifies the arc geometry sampling of 4 π space. The purpose of this research is to combine improved BEV overlap information with MAD to generate static couch lung stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) treatment plans deliverable on a C-arm linear accelerator. Approach . An algorithm utilizing the Moller–Trumbore ray-triangle intersection method was employed to compute a cost surrogate for dose to overlapping OARs using distances interpolated onto a PDD. Cost was combined with MAD for 100 000 random combinations of arc trajectories. A pathfinding algorithm for arc selection was created, balancing the contributions of MAD and 4 π cost for the final trajectory. This methodology was evaluated for 18 lung SBRT patients. Cases were also planned with arcs from a clinical treatment template protocol for dosimetric and plan quality comparison. Results were evaluated using dose constraints in the context of RTOG0915. Main results . Five of six OARs had maximum dose reductions when planned with the arc trajectory optimization algorithm. Significant maximum dose reductions were found for esophagus (7.41 ± 0.91 Gy, p = 0.00019), trachea (5.56 ± 1.55 Gy, p = 0.0025), spinal cord (2.87 ± 1.13 Gy, p = 0.039), large bronchus (3.47 ± 1.49 Gy, p = 0.0075), and aorta (3.13 ± 0.99 Gy, p = 0.012). Mean dose to contralateral lung was also significantly reduced (0.50 ± 0.06 Gy, p = 0.00019). There were two significant increases in OAR doses: mean dose to ipsilateral lung (0.40 ± 0.09, p = 0.00086) and V5 Gy to ipsilateral lung (1.95 ± 0.70%, p = 0.011). Paddick conformity index increased by 0.03 ± 0.02 ( p = 0.14), remaining below a limit of 1.2 for both techniques. Significance . Static couch non-coplanar optimization yielded maximum dose reductions to OARs while maintaining target conformity for lung SBRT.
- Open Access
- 2 September 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 23 (11) , e13765
Comparison of anatomically informed class solution template trajectories with patient‐specific trajectories for stereotactic radiosurgery and radiotherapy
Class solution template trajectories are used clinically for efficiency, safety, and reproducibility. The aim was to develop class solutions for single cranial metastases radiotherapy/radiosurgery based on intracranial target positioning and compare to patient‐specific trajectories in the context of 4π optimization. Template trajectories were constructed based on the open‐source Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI) average brain. The MNI brain was populated with evenly spaced spherical target volumes (2 cm diameter, N = 243) and organs‐at‐risk (OARs) were identified. Template trajectories were generated for six anatomical regions (frontal, medial, and posterior, each with laterality dependence) based on previously published 4π optimization methods. Volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) treatment plans generated using anatomically informed template 4π trajectories and patientspecific 4π trajectories were compared against VMAT plans from a standard four‐arc template. Four‐arc optimization techniques were compared to the standard VMAT template by placing three spherical targets in each of six anatomical regions of a test patient. This yielded 54 plans to compare various plan quality metrics. Increasing plan technique complexity, the total number of OAR maximum dose reductions compared to the standard arc template for the 6 anatomical classes was 4+/−2 (OFIXEDc) and 7+/−2 (OFIXEDi). In 65.6% of all cases, optimized fixed‐couch positions outperformed the standard‐arc template. Of the three comparisons, the most complex (OFIXEDi) showed the greatest statistical significance compared to the least complex (VMATi) across 12 plan quality metrics of maximum dose to each OAR, V12Gy, total plan Monitor Units, conformity index, and gradient index (p < 0.00417). In approximately 70% of all cases, 4π optimization methods outperformed the standard‐arc template in terms of maximum dose reduction to OAR, by exclusively changing the arc geometry. We conclude that a tradeoff exists between complexity of a class solution methodology compared to patient‐specific methods for arc selection, in the context of plan quality improvement.
- 2 September 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 23 (11) , e13765
Open AccessComparison of anatomically informed class solution template trajectories with patient‐specific trajectories for stereotactic radiosurgery and radiotherapy
Class solution template trajectories are used clinically for efficiency, safety, and reproducibility. The aim was to develop class solutions for single cranial metastases radiotherapy/radiosurgery based on intracranial target positioning and compare to patient‐specific trajectories in the context of 4π optimization. Template trajectories were constructed based on the open‐source Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI) average brain. The MNI brain was populated with evenly spaced spherical target volumes (2 cm diameter, N = 243) and organs‐at‐risk (OARs) were identified. Template trajectories were generated for six anatomical regions (frontal, medial, and posterior, each with laterality dependence) based on previously published 4π optimization methods. Volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) treatment plans generated using anatomically informed template 4π trajectories and patientspecific 4π trajectories were compared against VMAT plans from a standard four‐arc template. Four‐arc optimization techniques were compared to the standard VMAT template by placing three spherical targets in each of six anatomical regions of a test patient. This yielded 54 plans to compare various plan quality metrics. Increasing plan technique complexity, the total number of OAR maximum dose reductions compared to the standard arc template for the 6 anatomical classes was 4+/−2 (OFIXEDc) and 7+/−2 (OFIXEDi). In 65.6% of all cases, optimized fixed‐couch positions outperformed the standard‐arc template. Of the three comparisons, the most complex (OFIXEDi) showed the greatest statistical significance compared to the least complex (VMATi) across 12 plan quality metrics of maximum dose to each OAR, V12Gy, total plan Monitor Units, conformity index, and gradient index (p < 0.00417). In approximately 70% of all cases, 4π optimization methods outperformed the standard‐arc template in terms of maximum dose reduction to OAR, by exclusively changing the arc geometry. We conclude that a tradeoff exists between complexity of a class solution methodology compared to patient‐specific methods for arc selection, in the context of plan quality improvement.
- 13 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 49 (3) , 1407-1416
Patient‐specific collision zones for 4π trajectory optimized radiation therapy
Purpose: The 4π methodology determines optimized noncoplanar subarcs for stereotactic radiation therapy that minimize dose to organs‐at‐risk. Every combination of treatment angle is examined, but some angles are not appropriate as a collision would occur between the gantry and the couch or the gantry and the patient. Those combinations of couch and gantry angles are referred to as collision zones. A major barrier to applying 4π to stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) is the unknown shape of the collision zones, which are significant as patients take up a large volume within the 4π sphere. This study presents a system that determines patient‐specific collision zones, without additional clinical steps, to enable safe and deliverable noncoplanar treatment trajectories for SBRT patients.Methods: To augment patient's computed tomography (CT) scan, full body scans of patients in treatment position were acquired using an optical scanner. A library of a priori scans (N = 25) was created. Based on the patients' treatment position and their body dimensions, a library scan is selected and registered to the CT scan of the patient. Next, a model of the couch and immobilization equipment is added to the patient model. This results in a patient model that is then aligned with a model of the treatment LINAC in a “virtual treatment room,” where both components can be rotated to test for collisions. To test the collision detection algorithm, an end‐to‐end test was performed using a cranial phantom. The registration algorithm was tested by comparing the registered patient collision zones to those generated by using the patient's matching scan.Results: The collision detection algorithm was found to have a 97.80% accuracy, a 99.99% sensitivity, and a 99.99% negative predictive value (NPV). Analysis of the registration algorithm determined that a 6 cm buffer was required to achieve a 99.65% mean sensitivity, where a sensitivity of unity is considered to be a requirement for safe treatment delivery. With a 6 cm buffer, the mean accuracy was 86.70% and the mean NPV was 99.33%.Conclusions: Our method of determining patient‐specific collision zones can be accomplished with minimal user intervention based on an a priori library of body surface scans, thus enabling the safe application of 4π SBRT.
- 13 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 49 (3) , 1407-1416
Patient‐specific collision zones for 4π trajectory optimized radiation therapy
Purpose: The 4π methodology determines optimized noncoplanar subarcs for stereotactic radiation therapy that minimize dose to organs‐at‐risk. Every combination of treatment angle is examined, but some angles are not appropriate as a collision would occur between the gantry and the couch or the gantry and the patient. Those combinations of couch and gantry angles are referred to as collision zones. A major barrier to applying 4π to stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) is the unknown shape of the collision zones, which are significant as patients take up a large volume within the 4π sphere. This study presents a system that determines patient‐specific collision zones, without additional clinical steps, to enable safe and deliverable noncoplanar treatment trajectories for SBRT patients.Methods: To augment patient's computed tomography (CT) scan, full body scans of patients in treatment position were acquired using an optical scanner. A library of a priori scans (N = 25) was created. Based on the patients' treatment position and their body dimensions, a library scan is selected and registered to the CT scan of the patient. Next, a model of the couch and immobilization equipment is added to the patient model. This results in a patient model that is then aligned with a model of the treatment LINAC in a “virtual treatment room,” where both components can be rotated to test for collisions. To test the collision detection algorithm, an end‐to‐end test was performed using a cranial phantom. The registration algorithm was tested by comparing the registered patient collision zones to those generated by using the patient's matching scan.Results: The collision detection algorithm was found to have a 97.80% accuracy, a 99.99% sensitivity, and a 99.99% negative predictive value (NPV). Analysis of the registration algorithm determined that a 6 cm buffer was required to achieve a 99.65% mean sensitivity, where a sensitivity of unity is considered to be a requirement for safe treatment delivery. With a 6 cm buffer, the mean accuracy was 86.70% and the mean NPV was 99.33%.Conclusions: Our method of determining patient‐specific collision zones can be accomplished with minimal user intervention based on an a priori library of body surface scans, thus enabling the safe application of 4π SBRT.
- Open Access
- 16 March 2021
- Published by Wiley in NMR in Biomedicine
- Vol. 34 (6) , e4512
Investigation of BOLD contrast in fMRI using multi‐shot EPI
- 16 March 2021
- Published by Wiley in NMR in Biomedicine
- Vol. 34 (6) , e4512
Open AccessInvestigation of BOLD contrast in fMRI using multi‐shot EPI
- 28 October 2019
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 47 (2) , 307-316
Toward the combined optimization of dynamic axes (CODA) for stereotactic radiotherapy and radiosurgery using fixed couch trajectories
Purpose: To develop a novel system for patient‐specific combined optimization of couch, collimator, and gantry angles for use in volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) treatment planning. The system was designed to produce highly compact dose distributions by extensively sampling the 4π space. Automated fixed couch trajectory planning was used to reduce normal tissue doses by avoiding beams‐eye‐view (BEV) overlap with organs‐at‐risk (OARs) and improve monitor unit (MU) efficiency through collimator angle optimization.Methods: By merging distinct BEV objective functions used to optimize the couch rotation angle and collimator angle, a three‐dimensional (3D) cost space (the CODA cube) was constructed with axes of gantry, couch, and collimator rotation angles. At each voxel in this CODA cube, the cost of implementing this combination of axes positions in fixed couch trajectories was quantified. The CODA cube was sampled and explored using a modified constrained Bellman‐Ford algorithm to suggest low‐cost fixed candidate arcs on each plane of the space, from which 10‐arcs are chosen throughout the 3D space using a k‐means clustering algorithm. These fixed couch trajectories were then imported into the Eclipse treatment planning system (v.11) and inverse‐optimized according to clinical standards. Eight artificial cranial targets were contoured in a test‐patient anatomy, and seven treatment plans were generated from combinations of three and four targets. The CODA cube optimized plans were compared to standard 4‐arc VMAT plans for cranial stereotactic radiotherapy/surgery that were optimized for the same sets of targets; maximum dose to each OAR, V12Gy to normal brain, conformity, and total MUs were compared. Both planning methods were inverse‐optimized with identical dosimetric objectives.Results: CODA plans resulted in a reduction in maximum dose to OARs of 20.6% (P < 0.01), with maximum brainstem dose decreased by 2.63 Gy (P = 0.031) on average when compared to the standard arc arrangement. The mean reduction in total MU was 8.6% (P = 0.156), the mean increase in the inverse of the van’t Riet conformation number was 0.1%, (P = 0.67) and the mean decrease in normal brain tissue receiving 12 Gy or higher was 3.9% (P = 0.16), when compared to the standard VMAT arc configuration (n = 7).Conclusions: The optimization of couch, collimator, and gantry angles simultaneously using a 3D optimization space achieved improvement on multiple clinical metrics when compared to the standard VMAT arc configuration. A statistically significant sparing to OAR maximum doses was seen. Combining these optimizations may yield superior results to independent optimization.
- 28 October 2019
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 47 (2) , 307-316
Toward the combined optimization of dynamic axes (CODA) for stereotactic radiotherapy and radiosurgery using fixed couch trajectories
Purpose: To develop a novel system for patient‐specific combined optimization of couch, collimator, and gantry angles for use in volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) treatment planning. The system was designed to produce highly compact dose distributions by extensively sampling the 4π space. Automated fixed couch trajectory planning was used to reduce normal tissue doses by avoiding beams‐eye‐view (BEV) overlap with organs‐at‐risk (OARs) and improve monitor unit (MU) efficiency through collimator angle optimization.Methods: By merging distinct BEV objective functions used to optimize the couch rotation angle and collimator angle, a three‐dimensional (3D) cost space (the CODA cube) was constructed with axes of gantry, couch, and collimator rotation angles. At each voxel in this CODA cube, the cost of implementing this combination of axes positions in fixed couch trajectories was quantified. The CODA cube was sampled and explored using a modified constrained Bellman‐Ford algorithm to suggest low‐cost fixed candidate arcs on each plane of the space, from which 10‐arcs are chosen throughout the 3D space using a k‐means clustering algorithm. These fixed couch trajectories were then imported into the Eclipse treatment planning system (v.11) and inverse‐optimized according to clinical standards. Eight artificial cranial targets were contoured in a test‐patient anatomy, and seven treatment plans were generated from combinations of three and four targets. The CODA cube optimized plans were compared to standard 4‐arc VMAT plans for cranial stereotactic radiotherapy/surgery that were optimized for the same sets of targets; maximum dose to each OAR, V12Gy to normal brain, conformity, and total MUs were compared. Both planning methods were inverse‐optimized with identical dosimetric objectives.Results: CODA plans resulted in a reduction in maximum dose to OARs of 20.6% (P < 0.01), with maximum brainstem dose decreased by 2.63 Gy (P = 0.031) on average when compared to the standard arc arrangement. The mean reduction in total MU was 8.6% (P = 0.156), the mean increase in the inverse of the van’t Riet conformation number was 0.1%, (P = 0.67) and the mean decrease in normal brain tissue receiving 12 Gy or higher was 3.9% (P = 0.16), when compared to the standard VMAT arc configuration (n = 7).Conclusions: The optimization of couch, collimator, and gantry angles simultaneously using a 3D optimization space achieved improvement on multiple clinical metrics when compared to the standard VMAT arc configuration. A statistically significant sparing to OAR maximum doses was seen. Combining these optimizations may yield superior results to independent optimization.
- 24 October 2018
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 45 (12) , 5597-5607
Intra‐arc binary collimation algorithm for the optimization of stereotactic radiotherapy treatment of multiple metastases with multiple prescriptions
Purpose To design and implement a novel treatment planning algorithm based on a modification of dynamic conformal arc (DCA) therapy for the treatment of multiple cranial metastases with variable prescription doses. Methods A workflow was developed in which separate dose matrices were calculated for each target at each control point (i.e. the MLC was fit conformally to that single target). A cost function was used to quantify the relative contributions of each dose matrix in the plan to the overall plan objectives. Simulated annealing was used to allow for the inclusion or exclusion of individual dose matrices at each control point. The exclusion of individual targets at a given control point is termed intra‐arc binary collimation (iABC) in this work and is accomplished by closing the MLCs over the target for a duration specified by simulated annealing optimization. Dynamic collimator motions were employed to minimize the variation between the idealized dose matrices (i.e. perfectly collimated targets) and actual dose matrices (i.e. MLC apertures that include quantities of non‐target tissue due to the relative orientations of targets in the field). An additional simulated annealing optimization was performed to weight the relative contributions of dose at each control point (referred to as the monitor unit distribution (MUD)) to improve compliance with plan objectives. The algorithm was tested on seven previously‐treated multiple metastases patients and plans were compared to the clinically‐treated VMAT plans. Results Treatment plans generated with iABC used an average of 2716 (34%) fewer MU in the total plan than VMAT (p = 0.01). All normal tissue metrics for all plans and all patients were clinically acceptable. There were no statistically significant differences in any normal tissue dose metrics. Normalized prescription target coverage accuracy for all targets was 3% better on average for VMAT plans when compared to iABC (p = 0.07), and 14% better on average for iABC when compared to optimized DCA (p = 0.03). Conclusion A novel method of aperture and dose distribution design has been developed to significantly increase the MU efficiency of single isocentre treatment of multiple metastases with variable prescription doses when compared to VMAT, and which improves target coverage accuracy significantly when compared to optimized DCA. By applying a DCA approach to subsets of targets across control points, a hybrid method of treatment delivery has been developed that combines the efficiency of dynamic conformal treatments and the dosimetric flexibility of VMAT.
- 24 October 2018
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 45 (12) , 5597-5607
Intra‐arc binary collimation algorithm for the optimization of stereotactic radiotherapy treatment of multiple metastases with multiple prescriptions
Purpose To design and implement a novel treatment planning algorithm based on a modification of dynamic conformal arc (DCA) therapy for the treatment of multiple cranial metastases with variable prescription doses. Methods A workflow was developed in which separate dose matrices were calculated for each target at each control point (i.e. the MLC was fit conformally to that single target). A cost function was used to quantify the relative contributions of each dose matrix in the plan to the overall plan objectives. Simulated annealing was used to allow for the inclusion or exclusion of individual dose matrices at each control point. The exclusion of individual targets at a given control point is termed intra‐arc binary collimation (iABC) in this work and is accomplished by closing the MLCs over the target for a duration specified by simulated annealing optimization. Dynamic collimator motions were employed to minimize the variation between the idealized dose matrices (i.e. perfectly collimated targets) and actual dose matrices (i.e. MLC apertures that include quantities of non‐target tissue due to the relative orientations of targets in the field). An additional simulated annealing optimization was performed to weight the relative contributions of dose at each control point (referred to as the monitor unit distribution (MUD)) to improve compliance with plan objectives. The algorithm was tested on seven previously‐treated multiple metastases patients and plans were compared to the clinically‐treated VMAT plans. Results Treatment plans generated with iABC used an average of 2716 (34%) fewer MU in the total plan than VMAT (p = 0.01). All normal tissue metrics for all plans and all patients were clinically acceptable. There were no statistically significant differences in any normal tissue dose metrics. Normalized prescription target coverage accuracy for all targets was 3% better on average for VMAT plans when compared to iABC (p = 0.07), and 14% better on average for iABC when compared to optimized DCA (p = 0.03). Conclusion A novel method of aperture and dose distribution design has been developed to significantly increase the MU efficiency of single isocentre treatment of multiple metastases with variable prescription doses when compared to VMAT, and which improves target coverage accuracy significantly when compared to optimized DCA. By applying a DCA approach to subsets of targets across control points, a hybrid method of treatment delivery has been developed that combines the efficiency of dynamic conformal treatments and the dosimetric flexibility of VMAT.
- 27 November 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 45 (1) , 5-17
Dynamic collimator trajectory algorithm for multiple metastases dynamic conformal arc treatment planning
Purpose: To develop an algorithm for dynamic collimator positioning to optimize beam's eye view (BEV) fitting of targets in dynamic conformal arc (DCA)‐based radiotherapy procedures, of particular use in multiple metastases stereotactic radiosurgery procedures.Methods: A trajectory algorithm was developed to dynamically modify the angle of the collimator as a function of arc‐based control point to provide optimized collimation of target volume(s). Central to this algorithm is a concept denoted herein as “whitespace” defined as any nontarget area in the BEV that is not covered by any collimation system and is open to exposure from the radiation beam. Calculating whitespace at all collimator angles and every control point, a two‐dimensional topographical map depicting the tightness‐of‐fit of the MLC was generated. A bidirectional gradient trajectory algorithm identified a number of candidate trajectories of continuous collimator motion. Minimization of integrated whitespace was used to identify an optimal solution for the navigation of the parameter space. Plans with dynamic collimator trajectories were designed for multiple metastases targets and were compared with fixed collimator angle dynamic conformal arc (DCA) plans and standard VMAT plans.Results: Algorithm validation was performed on simple test cases with known solutions. The whitespace metric showed a strong correlation (R2 = 0.90) with mean dose to proximal normal tissue. Seventeen cases were studied using our algorithm to generate dynamic conformal arc (DCA) plans with optimized collimator trajectories for three and four target SRS patients and comparing them to DCA plans generated with optimized fixed collimator angles per arc and standard VMAT plans generated via template. Optimized collimator trajectories were found to produce a reduction in monitor units of up to 49.7 ± 5.1% when compared to VMAT across 17 patients, and all organ‐at‐risk and normal brain metrics were found to be superior or comparable.Conclusion: Dynamic collimator trajectories have the potential to improve DCA deliveries through increased efficiency, especially in the treatment of multiple cranial metastases. Implementation of this technology should not be hindered by mechanical safety considerations as collimator motions do not modify or introduce any new risks of collisions with patients.
- 27 November 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 45 (1) , 5-17
Dynamic collimator trajectory algorithm for multiple metastases dynamic conformal arc treatment planning
Purpose: To develop an algorithm for dynamic collimator positioning to optimize beam's eye view (BEV) fitting of targets in dynamic conformal arc (DCA)‐based radiotherapy procedures, of particular use in multiple metastases stereotactic radiosurgery procedures.Methods: A trajectory algorithm was developed to dynamically modify the angle of the collimator as a function of arc‐based control point to provide optimized collimation of target volume(s). Central to this algorithm is a concept denoted herein as “whitespace” defined as any nontarget area in the BEV that is not covered by any collimation system and is open to exposure from the radiation beam. Calculating whitespace at all collimator angles and every control point, a two‐dimensional topographical map depicting the tightness‐of‐fit of the MLC was generated. A bidirectional gradient trajectory algorithm identified a number of candidate trajectories of continuous collimator motion. Minimization of integrated whitespace was used to identify an optimal solution for the navigation of the parameter space. Plans with dynamic collimator trajectories were designed for multiple metastases targets and were compared with fixed collimator angle dynamic conformal arc (DCA) plans and standard VMAT plans.Results: Algorithm validation was performed on simple test cases with known solutions. The whitespace metric showed a strong correlation (R2 = 0.90) with mean dose to proximal normal tissue. Seventeen cases were studied using our algorithm to generate dynamic conformal arc (DCA) plans with optimized collimator trajectories for three and four target SRS patients and comparing them to DCA plans generated with optimized fixed collimator angles per arc and standard VMAT plans generated via template. Optimized collimator trajectories were found to produce a reduction in monitor units of up to 49.7 ± 5.1% when compared to VMAT across 17 patients, and all organ‐at‐risk and normal brain metrics were found to be superior or comparable.Conclusion: Dynamic collimator trajectories have the potential to improve DCA deliveries through increased efficiency, especially in the treatment of multiple cranial metastases. Implementation of this technology should not be hindered by mechanical safety considerations as collimator motions do not modify or introduce any new risks of collisions with patients.
- 3 January 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 44 (1) , 17-27
Overlap-guided fixed-patient support positioning optimization for cranial SRT
To investigate potential dosimetric improvements through the optimization of fixed-couch rotational position in cranial cancer stereotactic treatments. Using previously delivered cranial stereotactic radiotherapy plans treated at the Nova Scotia Health Authority (NSHA), we have redesigned the treatment arrangement to find the optimal couch rotation positions based on the reduction of overlap between organs-at-risk of exposure (OARs) and target volume (PTV). Maintaining the gantry arrangements from the delivered treatment, the couch positions were determined based on a cost function analysis of accumulation of overlap score from an equation developed by Yang et al.[1] and refined by MacDonald et al.[2] The algorithm incorporates factors for radiation dose sensitivities of each OAR, depth of both OARs and target (PTV) volumes, and orthogonality of the 3D vector between OAR and PTV in the case of proximal OAR position. The plan evaluation was conducted on 16 acoustic neuroma patients treated with stereotactic radiotherapy plans at the NSHA. Maximum and mean doses to the OARs were reduced by approximately 14.30% ± 2.86% and 19.25% ± 2.10%, respectively, with application of this optimization technique as compared to the delivered treatment plans. In addition, PTV conformity and homogeneity were improved with application of this optimization technique. This variation of the existing delivery techniques with guidance from a PTV-OAR overlap cost function analysis technique can yield significant dosimetric improvements with no increase to delivery or planning time.
- 3 January 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 44 (1) , 17-27
Overlap-guided fixed-patient support positioning optimization for cranial SRT
To investigate potential dosimetric improvements through the optimization of fixed-couch rotational position in cranial cancer stereotactic treatments. Using previously delivered cranial stereotactic radiotherapy plans treated at the Nova Scotia Health Authority (NSHA), we have redesigned the treatment arrangement to find the optimal couch rotation positions based on the reduction of overlap between organs-at-risk of exposure (OARs) and target volume (PTV). Maintaining the gantry arrangements from the delivered treatment, the couch positions were determined based on a cost function analysis of accumulation of overlap score from an equation developed by Yang et al.[1] and refined by MacDonald et al.[2] The algorithm incorporates factors for radiation dose sensitivities of each OAR, depth of both OARs and target (PTV) volumes, and orthogonality of the 3D vector between OAR and PTV in the case of proximal OAR position. The plan evaluation was conducted on 16 acoustic neuroma patients treated with stereotactic radiotherapy plans at the NSHA. Maximum and mean doses to the OARs were reduced by approximately 14.30% ± 2.86% and 19.25% ± 2.10%, respectively, with application of this optimization technique as compared to the delivered treatment plans. In addition, PTV conformity and homogeneity were improved with application of this optimization technique. This variation of the existing delivery techniques with guidance from a PTV-OAR overlap cost function analysis technique can yield significant dosimetric improvements with no increase to delivery or planning time.