Sean Colin-Ellerin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Sean Colin-Ellerin has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mukund Rangamani
University of California
11 shared publications - Chi-Ming Chang
Tsinghua University
8 shared publications - Cheng Peng
University of Chinese Academy of Sciences
4 shared publications - Donald Marolf
Department of Physics University of California 93106 Santa Barbara CA USA
3 shared publications - Xi Dong
Department of Physics University of California 93106 Santa Barbara CA USA
3 shared publications - Zhencheng Wang
Department of Physics University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign 61801 Urbana IL USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2025 (9) , 1-105
Generalized entropy of gravitational fluctuations
The corrections to holographic entanglement entropy from bulk quantum fields in a classical gravitational background are now well understood. They lead, in particular, to unitary Page curves for evaporating black holes. However, the correct treatment of quantum fluctuations of the metric, including graviton excitations, is a longstanding problem. We provide a gauge-invariant prescription for the generalized entropy of gravitons in anti-de Sitter space in terms of areas and bulk entanglement entropy, generalizing the quantum extremal surface prescription to accommodate fluctuations in the semiclassical spacetime geometry. This task requires a careful treatment of the area operator on the graviton Hilbert space and the definition of a “quantum extremal gauge” in which the extremal surface is unperturbed. It also requires us to determine the correct vacuum modular Hamiltonian for the graviton field, which we fix by requiring that it doesn’t contain a boundary term in extremal gauge. We check our prescription with an explicit computation of the vacuum-subtracted generalized entropy of states containing a graviton in an AdS-Rindler background. Our results exactly match vacuum-subtracted von Neumann entropies for stress-tensor excited states in holographic conformal field theory with d > 2 dimensions. We also use covariant phase space techniques to give a partial proof of our prescription when the entanglement wedge for the background spacetime has a bifurcate Killing horizon. Along the way, we identify a class of perturbative graviton states that have parametrically larger generalized entropy, in the small G N expansion, than any low-energy excitations of an ordinary quantum field.
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2025 (9) , 1-105
Open AccessGeneralized entropy of gravitational fluctuations
The corrections to holographic entanglement entropy from bulk quantum fields in a classical gravitational background are now well understood. They lead, in particular, to unitary Page curves for evaporating black holes. However, the correct treatment of quantum fluctuations of the metric, including graviton excitations, is a longstanding problem. We provide a gauge-invariant prescription for the generalized entropy of gravitons in anti-de Sitter space in terms of areas and bulk entanglement entropy, generalizing the quantum extremal surface prescription to accommodate fluctuations in the semiclassical spacetime geometry. This task requires a careful treatment of the area operator on the graviton Hilbert space and the definition of a “quantum extremal gauge” in which the extremal surface is unperturbed. It also requires us to determine the correct vacuum modular Hamiltonian for the graviton field, which we fix by requiring that it doesn’t contain a boundary term in extremal gauge. We check our prescription with an explicit computation of the vacuum-subtracted generalized entropy of states containing a graviton in an AdS-Rindler background. Our results exactly match vacuum-subtracted von Neumann entropies for stress-tensor excited states in holographic conformal field theory with d > 2 dimensions. We also use covariant phase space techniques to give a partial proof of our prescription when the entanglement wedge for the background spacetime has a bifurcate Killing horizon. Along the way, we identify a class of perturbative graviton states that have parametrically larger generalized entropy, in the small G N expansion, than any low-energy excitations of an ordinary quantum field.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2025 (5) , 1-89
Generalized entropy of photons in AdS
This work analyzes the quantum corrections to holographic entanglement entropy at first subleading order in G N due to photon excited states in AdS. We compute the vacuum-subtracted von Neumann entropy of a U(1) current excited state for a polar cap region on the cylinder in any large-N, strongly-coupled CFT d holographically dual to weakly-coupled Einstein gravity for any dimension d > 2. We then quantize a Maxwell field in AdS d+1 dual to the U(1) current and consider a photon excited state whose vacuum-subtracted generalized entropy for the entanglement wedge is calculated. In order to factorise the Maxwell Hilbert space in AdS, we construct an extended Hilbert space and the corresponding electromagnetic edge modes. We find exact agreement between the CFT entanglement entropy and AdS generalized entropy without the inclusion of entropy of the edge modes. Finally, we show via explicit calculation that the contribution to the vacuum-subtracted von Neumann entropy from electromagnetic edge modes indeed vanishes, which is crucial for consistency with known holographic entropy formulas.
- 6 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2025 (5) , 1-89
Open AccessGeneralized entropy of photons in AdS
This work analyzes the quantum corrections to holographic entanglement entropy at first subleading order in G N due to photon excited states in AdS. We compute the vacuum-subtracted von Neumann entropy of a U(1) current excited state for a polar cap region on the cylinder in any large-N, strongly-coupled CFT d holographically dual to weakly-coupled Einstein gravity for any dimension d > 2. We then quantize a Maxwell field in AdS d+1 dual to the U(1) current and consider a photon excited state whose vacuum-subtracted generalized entropy for the entanglement wedge is calculated. In order to factorise the Maxwell Hilbert space in AdS, we construct an extended Hilbert space and the corresponding electromagnetic edge modes. We find exact agreement between the CFT entanglement entropy and AdS generalized entropy without the inclusion of entropy of the edge modes. Finally, we show via explicit calculation that the contribution to the vacuum-subtracted von Neumann entropy from electromagnetic edge modes indeed vanishes, which is crucial for consistency with known holographic entropy formulas.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2025 (3) , 1-48
Gravitons on the edge
We study free graviton entanglement between Rindler wedges in the Minkowski vacuum state via the Euclidean path integral. We follow Kabat’s method for computing the conical entropy, using the heat kernel on the cone with the tip removed, whose resulting von Neumann entropy for photons correctly predicted electromagnetic edge modes. We find that, in addition to the bulk graviton contributions, the conical entropy has a contact term that can be attributed to a vector field anchored to the (d – 2)-dimensional (Euclidean) Rindler horizon whose contribution equals d – 2 times Kabat’s contact term for photons. We suggest that graviton edge modes are hence the d – 2 large diffeomorphisms which act internally within the Rindler horizon. Along the way, we address several known issues regarding graviton entanglement. We furthermore sketch how our results may be used to study edge modes in closed bosonic string theory.
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2025 (3) , 1-48
Open AccessGravitons on the edge
We study free graviton entanglement between Rindler wedges in the Minkowski vacuum state via the Euclidean path integral. We follow Kabat’s method for computing the conical entropy, using the heat kernel on the cone with the tip removed, whose resulting von Neumann entropy for photons correctly predicted electromagnetic edge modes. We find that, in addition to the bulk graviton contributions, the conical entropy has a contact term that can be attributed to a vector field anchored to the (d – 2)-dimensional (Euclidean) Rindler horizon whose contribution equals d – 2 times Kabat’s contact term for photons. We suggest that graviton edge modes are hence the d – 2 large diffeomorphisms which act internally within the Rindler horizon. Along the way, we address several known issues regarding graviton entanglement. We furthermore sketch how our results may be used to study edge modes in closed bosonic string theory.
- Open Access
Disordered vector models: from higher spins to incipient strings
We present a one-parameter family of large $N$ disordered models, with and without supersymmetry, in three spacetime dimensions. They interpolate from the critical large $N$ vector model dual to a classical higher spin theory, towards a theory with a classical string dual. We analyze the spectrum and OPE data of the theories. While the supersymmetric model is always well-behaved the non-supersymmetric model is unitary only over a small parameter range. We offer some speculations on the origin of strings from the higher spins.Open AccessDisordered vector models: from higher spins to incipient strings
We present a one-parameter family of large $N$ disordered models, with and without supersymmetry, in three spacetime dimensions. They interpolate from the critical large $N$ vector model dual to a classical higher spin theory, towards a theory with a classical string dual. We analyze the spectrum and OPE data of the theories. While the supersymmetric model is always well-behaved the non-supersymmetric model is unitary only over a small parameter range. We offer some speculations on the origin of strings from the higher spins. - Open Access
- 29 June 2022
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Letters
- Vol. 129 (1) , 011603
Disordered Vector Models: From Higher Spins to Incipient Strings
We present a one-parameter family of large disordered models, with and without supersymmetry, in three spacetime dimensions. They interpolate from the critical large vector model dual to a classical higher spin theory toward a theory with a classical string dual. We analyze the spectrum and operator product expansion data of the theories. While the supersymmetric model is always well-behaved the nonsupersymmetric model is unitary only over a small parameter range. We offer some speculations on the origin of strings from the higher spins.- 29 June 2022
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Letters
- Vol. 129 (1) , 011603
Open AccessDisordered Vector Models: From Higher Spins to Incipient Strings
We present a one-parameter family of large disordered models, with and without supersymmetry, in three spacetime dimensions. They interpolate from the critical large vector model dual to a classical higher spin theory toward a theory with a classical string dual. We analyze the spectrum and operator product expansion data of the theories. While the supersymmetric model is always well-behaved the nonsupersymmetric model is unitary only over a small parameter range. We offer some speculations on the origin of strings from the higher spins. - Open Access
Bootstrapping Quantum Extremal Surfaces I: The Area Operator
Quantum extremal surfaces are central to the connection between quantum information theory and quantum gravity and they have played a prominent role in the recent progress on the information paradox. We initiate a program to systematically link these surfaces to the microscopic data of the dual conformal field theory, namely the scaling dimensions of local operators and their OPE coefficients. We consider CFT states obtained by acting on the vacuum with single-trace operators, which are dual to one-particle states of the bulk theory. Focusing on AdS$_3$/CFT$_2$, we compute the CFT entanglement entropy to second order in the large $c$ expansion where quantum extremality becomes important and match it to the expectation value of the bulk area operator. We show that to this order, the Virasoro identity block contributes solely to the area operator.Open AccessBootstrapping Quantum Extremal Surfaces I: The Area Operator
Quantum extremal surfaces are central to the connection between quantum information theory and quantum gravity and they have played a prominent role in the recent progress on the information paradox. We initiate a program to systematically link these surfaces to the microscopic data of the dual conformal field theory, namely the scaling dimensions of local operators and their OPE coefficients. We consider CFT states obtained by acting on the vacuum with single-trace operators, which are dual to one-particle states of the bulk theory. Focusing on AdS$_3$/CFT$_2$, we compute the CFT entanglement entropy to second order in the large $c$ expansion where quantum extremality becomes important and match it to the expectation value of the bulk area operator. We show that to this order, the Virasoro identity block contributes solely to the area operator. - Open Access
- 29 November 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2021 (11) , 1-58
A 3d disordered superconformal fixed point
We initiate the study of a three dimensional disordered supersymmetric field theory. Specifically, we consider a $$ \mathcal{N} $$ = 2 large N Wess-Zumino like model with cubic superpotential involving couplings drawn from a Gaussian random ensemble. Taking inspiration from analyses of lower dimensional SYK like models we demonstrate that the theory flows to a strongly coupled superconformal fixed point in the infra-red. In particular, we obtain leading large N spectral data and operator product coefficients at the critical point. Moreover, the analytic control accorded by the model allows us to compare our results against those derived in the conformal bootstrap program and demonstrate consistency with general expectations.- 29 November 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2021 (11) , 1-58
Open AccessA 3d disordered superconformal fixed point
We initiate the study of a three dimensional disordered supersymmetric field theory. Specifically, we consider a $$ \mathcal{N} $$ = 2 large N Wess-Zumino like model with cubic superpotential involving couplings drawn from a Gaussian random ensemble. Taking inspiration from analyses of lower dimensional SYK like models we demonstrate that the theory flows to a strongly coupled superconformal fixed point in the infra-red. In particular, we obtain leading large N spectral data and operator product coefficients at the critical point. Moreover, the analytic control accorded by the model allows us to compare our results against those derived in the conformal bootstrap program and demonstrate consistency with general expectations. - Open Access
- 4 November 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2021 (11) , 1-41
Bootstrapping quantum extremal surfaces. Part I. The area operator
Quantum extremal surfaces are central to the connection between quantum information theory and quantum gravity and they have played a prominent role in the recent progress on the information paradox. We initiate a program to systematically link these surfaces to the microscopic data of the dual conformal field theory, namely the scaling dimensions of local operators and their OPE coefficients. We consider CFT states obtained by acting on the vacuum with single-trace operators, which are dual to one-particle states of the bulk theory. Focusing on AdS3/CFT2, we compute the CFT entanglement entropy to second order in the large c expansion where quantum extremality becomes important and match it to the expectation value of the bulk area operator. We show that to this order, the Virasoro identity block contributes solely to the area operator.
- 4 November 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2021 (11) , 1-41
Open AccessBootstrapping quantum extremal surfaces. Part I. The area operator
Quantum extremal surfaces are central to the connection between quantum information theory and quantum gravity and they have played a prominent role in the recent progress on the information paradox. We initiate a program to systematically link these surfaces to the microscopic data of the dual conformal field theory, namely the scaling dimensions of local operators and their OPE coefficients. We consider CFT states obtained by acting on the vacuum with single-trace operators, which are dual to one-particle states of the bulk theory. Focusing on AdS3/CFT2, we compute the CFT entanglement entropy to second order in the large c expansion where quantum extremality becomes important and match it to the expectation value of the bulk area operator. We show that to this order, the Virasoro identity block contributes solely to the area operator.
- Open Access
A 3d disordered superconformal fixed point
We initiate the study of a three dimensional disordered supersymmetric field theory. Specifically, we consider a $\mathcal{N}=2$ large $N$ Wess-Zumino like model with cubic superpotential involving couplings drawn from a Gaussian random ensemble. Taking inspiration from analyses of lower dimensional SYK like models we demonstrate that the theory flows to a strongly coupled superconformal fixed point in the infra-red. In particular, we obtain leading large $N$ spectral data and operator product coefficients at the critical point. Moreover, the analytic control accorded by the model allows us to compare our results against those derived in the conformal bootstrap program and demonstrate consistency with general expectations.Open AccessA 3d disordered superconformal fixed point
We initiate the study of a three dimensional disordered supersymmetric field theory. Specifically, we consider a $\mathcal{N}=2$ large $N$ Wess-Zumino like model with cubic superpotential involving couplings drawn from a Gaussian random ensemble. Taking inspiration from analyses of lower dimensional SYK like models we demonstrate that the theory flows to a strongly coupled superconformal fixed point in the infra-red. In particular, we obtain leading large $N$ spectral data and operator product coefficients at the critical point. Moreover, the analytic control accorded by the model allows us to compare our results against those derived in the conformal bootstrap program and demonstrate consistency with general expectations. - Open Access
- 31 August 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2021 (8) , 1-54
Real-time gravitational replicas: low dimensional examples
We continue the study of real-time replica wormholes initiated in [1]. Previously, we had discussed the general principles and had outlined a variational principle for obtaining stationary points of the real-time gravitational path integral. In the current work we present several explicit examples in low-dimensional gravitational theories where the dynamics is amenable to analytic computation. We demonstrate the computation of Rényi entropies in the cases of JT gravity and for holographic two-dimensional CFTs (using the dual gravitational dynamics). In particular, we explain how to obtain the large central charge result for subregions comprising of disjoint intervals directly from the real-time path integral.
- 31 August 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2021 (8) , 1-54
Open AccessReal-time gravitational replicas: low dimensional examples
We continue the study of real-time replica wormholes initiated in [1]. Previously, we had discussed the general principles and had outlined a variational principle for obtaining stationary points of the real-time gravitational path integral. In the current work we present several explicit examples in low-dimensional gravitational theories where the dynamics is amenable to analytic computation. We demonstrate the computation of Rényi entropies in the cases of JT gravity and for holographic two-dimensional CFTs (using the dual gravitational dynamics). In particular, we explain how to obtain the large central charge result for subregions comprising of disjoint intervals directly from the real-time path integral.