Naoto Shinohara
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Naoto Shinohara has a total of 39 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Akira Yamawo
Kyoto University
3 shared publications Keita Nishizawa
Research Center for Advanced Science and Technology, The University of Tokyo Meguro Japan
3 shared publications- Koki R. Katsuhara
Okayama University
3 shared publications Takehito Yoshida
Research Inst. for Humanity and Nature Kamigamo, Kita‐ku Kyoto Japan
3 shared publicationsAkane Kusano
Fisheries Division Environment and Agriculture Bureau Kanagawa Prefectural Government Yokohama Japan
2 shared publications- Akira S. Mori
Research Center for Advanced Science and Technology, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Coexistence of annual plants under competition and reproductive interference
In natural ecosystems, community dynamics are driven by diverse interactions operating through both ecological and reproductive processes. Although theory predicts that these processes jointly generate complex and contingent dynamics through the interplay of stabilizing (negative frequency dependence arising from niche differences) and destabilizing effects (positive frequency dependence caused by reproductive interference), empirical tests of this prediction remain scarce. Here, we combined experimental and theoretical approaches to investigate the dynamics of two congeneric annual plant species ( Commelina ) experiencing both ecological competition and reproductive interference. Our empirically parameterized model revealed a large niche difference and mutual reproductive interference. However, the reproductive interference was not strong enough to generate pronounced contingency of community dynamics on initial conditions. Instead, coexistence was the most likely outcome regardless of initial species composition. Parameter exploration indicated that the weak contingency arose because reproductive assurance strategies of Commelina species buffered the minority disadvantage caused by reproductive interference. These findings provide empirical evidence that reproductive interference does not necessarily destabilize coexistence and that it may be outweighed by ecological niche and fitness differences. Our study highlights the importance of integrating ecological and reproductive processes towards better prediction of community dynamics. Significant statement: Species interactions can both promote and undermine coexistence. Ecological niche differences can promote coexistence by favoring rare species, whereas reproductive interference can favor more abundant species and destabilize coexistence. How these opposing forces jointly shape community dynamics remains poorly understood. We combined experiments and mathematical approaches to examine their simultaneous effects on the coexistence of two closely related annual plants. Despite mutual reproductive interference, our empirically calibrated model showed that coexistence was the most likely outcome irrespective of initial species abundance. Reproductive interference had limited effects, likely because selfing before interspecific pollination provided reproductive assurance. Our findings demonstrate that reproductive interference does not necessarily destabilize coexistence and highlight the importance of integrating ecological and reproductive processes to predict community dynamics.
Open AccessCoexistence of annual plants under competition and reproductive interference
In natural ecosystems, community dynamics are driven by diverse interactions operating through both ecological and reproductive processes. Although theory predicts that these processes jointly generate complex and contingent dynamics through the interplay of stabilizing (negative frequency dependence arising from niche differences) and destabilizing effects (positive frequency dependence caused by reproductive interference), empirical tests of this prediction remain scarce. Here, we combined experimental and theoretical approaches to investigate the dynamics of two congeneric annual plant species ( Commelina ) experiencing both ecological competition and reproductive interference. Our empirically parameterized model revealed a large niche difference and mutual reproductive interference. However, the reproductive interference was not strong enough to generate pronounced contingency of community dynamics on initial conditions. Instead, coexistence was the most likely outcome regardless of initial species composition. Parameter exploration indicated that the weak contingency arose because reproductive assurance strategies of Commelina species buffered the minority disadvantage caused by reproductive interference. These findings provide empirical evidence that reproductive interference does not necessarily destabilize coexistence and that it may be outweighed by ecological niche and fitness differences. Our study highlights the importance of integrating ecological and reproductive processes towards better prediction of community dynamics. Significant statement: Species interactions can both promote and undermine coexistence. Ecological niche differences can promote coexistence by favoring rare species, whereas reproductive interference can favor more abundant species and destabilize coexistence. How these opposing forces jointly shape community dynamics remains poorly understood. We combined experiments and mathematical approaches to examine their simultaneous effects on the coexistence of two closely related annual plants. Despite mutual reproductive interference, our empirically calibrated model showed that coexistence was the most likely outcome irrespective of initial species abundance. Reproductive interference had limited effects, likely because selfing before interspecific pollination provided reproductive assurance. Our findings demonstrate that reproductive interference does not necessarily destabilize coexistence and highlight the importance of integrating ecological and reproductive processes to predict community dynamics.
- Open Access
Competitive ability underpins the effect of spatial aggregation on plant performance
Most plant species exhibit spatially clustered distributions. Theory suggests such conspecific aggregation can delay competitive exclusion by sparing weak competitors. However, the extent to which spatial aggregation increases species performance and which species are likely to benefit from it remain largely unknown. In this study, we asked (1) whether spatial aggregation enhances plant performance and (2) whether the effects are biologically predictable. For the second question, we focused on “the competition‐relatedness hypothesis” and the “competitive asymmetry hypothesis,” which relate the effect of spatial arrangement to niche and competitive ability differences between species, respectively. We performed phylogenetic meta‐analyses to investigate whether phylogenetic and ecological differences among competitors explain the effect of spatial arrangement. We found idiosyncratic responses of plant species to spatial aggregation. While some species performed better when conspecific individuals were aggregated, others did so when conspecifics and heterospecifics were randomly distributed. The non‐negligible number of species benefiting more from intraspecific aggregation indicates that intraspecific competition is sometimes weaker than interspecific competition. Further, the result contrasts with the assumption of the competition‐relatedness hypothesis, which postulates the strongest competition among conspecifics, suggesting that this hypothesis does not hold for at least these species. Although phylogeny did not predict the effect of spatial arrangement, interspecific plant height differences did: Species performed better in an aggregation treatment when they were smaller than competitors. Collectively, our results lend more support for the competitive asymmetry hypothesis that interspecific differences in competitive ability underpin the effect of spatial arrangement on plant performance. Moreover, they suggest that spatial processes, such as dispersal limitation, may play an important role in plant coexistence.
Open AccessCompetitive ability underpins the effect of spatial aggregation on plant performance
Most plant species exhibit spatially clustered distributions. Theory suggests such conspecific aggregation can delay competitive exclusion by sparing weak competitors. However, the extent to which spatial aggregation increases species performance and which species are likely to benefit from it remain largely unknown. In this study, we asked (1) whether spatial aggregation enhances plant performance and (2) whether the effects are biologically predictable. For the second question, we focused on “the competition‐relatedness hypothesis” and the “competitive asymmetry hypothesis,” which relate the effect of spatial arrangement to niche and competitive ability differences between species, respectively. We performed phylogenetic meta‐analyses to investigate whether phylogenetic and ecological differences among competitors explain the effect of spatial arrangement. We found idiosyncratic responses of plant species to spatial aggregation. While some species performed better when conspecific individuals were aggregated, others did so when conspecifics and heterospecifics were randomly distributed. The non‐negligible number of species benefiting more from intraspecific aggregation indicates that intraspecific competition is sometimes weaker than interspecific competition. Further, the result contrasts with the assumption of the competition‐relatedness hypothesis, which postulates the strongest competition among conspecifics, suggesting that this hypothesis does not hold for at least these species. Although phylogeny did not predict the effect of spatial arrangement, interspecific plant height differences did: Species performed better in an aggregation treatment when they were smaller than competitors. Collectively, our results lend more support for the competitive asymmetry hypothesis that interspecific differences in competitive ability underpin the effect of spatial arrangement on plant performance. Moreover, they suggest that spatial processes, such as dispersal limitation, may play an important role in plant coexistence.
- 19 February 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 21 (2) , 20240537
The effects of anisotropic dispersal on species coexistence in a metacommunity
Dispersal is a ubiquitous process occurring in any ecosystem, with a critical role in the regional coexistence of species that cannot coexist locally. However, previous studies have typically focused on a specific scenario where dispersal is isotropic, leaving the consequence of anisotropic, directionally skewed dispersal largely unexplored, despite its prevalence in natural ecosystems. In this study, we used simulations to study whether the anisotropy of dispersal promotes or hinders species coexistence in a metacommunity. We found that dispersal anisotropy plays a decisive role in species coexistence—with coexistence promoted when dispersal is more directed orthogonally to an environmental gradient, while it is less likely when dispersal is primarily parallel with the gradient. This occurred because dispersal directed orthogonally to the background environmental gradient transports individuals produced in ‘good’ habitats to other good habitats, creating conditions that favour several spatial coexistence mechanisms, such as spatial storage effects and fitness–density covariance. We conclude that the effect of anisotropic dispersal could be diverse, and therefore, it is necessary to consider the anisotropy and the distribution of environments for a better understanding of species coexistence in a metacommunity.
- 19 February 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 21 (2) , 20240537
The effects of anisotropic dispersal on species coexistence in a metacommunity
Dispersal is a ubiquitous process occurring in any ecosystem, with a critical role in the regional coexistence of species that cannot coexist locally. However, previous studies have typically focused on a specific scenario where dispersal is isotropic, leaving the consequence of anisotropic, directionally skewed dispersal largely unexplored, despite its prevalence in natural ecosystems. In this study, we used simulations to study whether the anisotropy of dispersal promotes or hinders species coexistence in a metacommunity. We found that dispersal anisotropy plays a decisive role in species coexistence—with coexistence promoted when dispersal is more directed orthogonally to an environmental gradient, while it is less likely when dispersal is primarily parallel with the gradient. This occurred because dispersal directed orthogonally to the background environmental gradient transports individuals produced in ‘good’ habitats to other good habitats, creating conditions that favour several spatial coexistence mechanisms, such as spatial storage effects and fitness–density covariance. We conclude that the effect of anisotropic dispersal could be diverse, and therefore, it is necessary to consider the anisotropy and the distribution of environments for a better understanding of species coexistence in a metacommunity.
- Open Access
- 25 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Research
- Vol. 40 (4) , 463-474
Nationwide diversity of symbolic “city flowers” in Japan is increasing
Recognizing and maintaining locally rooted human–nature interactions is essential for utilizing ecosystem services. Although the general public's awareness of biodiversity and ecosystem services has been examined using various proxies, it remains unclear how local governments—key sectors in creating conservation policies—appreciate them within a solid local context. Here, we focused on the “city flower,” an official symbolic species of Japanese cities, as a new proxy for measuring governmental attitudes toward biota and its services. We aimed to capture temporal changes in the awareness of species with locally relevant value at the city government level by examining the changes in city flowers over more than half a century. Data from the official websites of municipalities, including the names, the adoption years, and the reasons for adoption, revealed two major periods of adoption, with a notable increase in species diversity in and after 1993. This increase could be attributed to a recent reduction in bias toward popular flowers and growing interest in alternative, less popular flowers. Analysis of the reasons for adoption suggested that the temporal change in adopted flower species was related to the increasing emphasis on species with an explicit local context, especially those with instrumental value to the city. Our findings indicate the tendency for local governments to increasingly recognize their biocultural backgrounds and the ecosystem services of plants within their regions. The growing awareness of the local governments regarding their biocultural background is a positive sign for the conservation of biodiversity and ecosystem services.
- 25 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Research
- Vol. 40 (4) , 463-474
Open AccessNationwide diversity of symbolic “city flowers” in Japan is increasing
Recognizing and maintaining locally rooted human–nature interactions is essential for utilizing ecosystem services. Although the general public's awareness of biodiversity and ecosystem services has been examined using various proxies, it remains unclear how local governments—key sectors in creating conservation policies—appreciate them within a solid local context. Here, we focused on the “city flower,” an official symbolic species of Japanese cities, as a new proxy for measuring governmental attitudes toward biota and its services. We aimed to capture temporal changes in the awareness of species with locally relevant value at the city government level by examining the changes in city flowers over more than half a century. Data from the official websites of municipalities, including the names, the adoption years, and the reasons for adoption, revealed two major periods of adoption, with a notable increase in species diversity in and after 1993. This increase could be attributed to a recent reduction in bias toward popular flowers and growing interest in alternative, less popular flowers. Analysis of the reasons for adoption suggested that the temporal change in adopted flower species was related to the increasing emphasis on species with an explicit local context, especially those with instrumental value to the city. Our findings indicate the tendency for local governments to increasingly recognize their biocultural backgrounds and the ecosystem services of plants within their regions. The growing awareness of the local governments regarding their biocultural background is a positive sign for the conservation of biodiversity and ecosystem services.
- 24 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in Ecology Letters
- Vol. 27 (10) , e14554
A Parasite Plant Promotes the Coexistence of Two Annual Plants
Consumers can influence the competitive outcomes of prey species in various ways. Modern coexistence theory predicts that consumers can promote prey coexistence by preferably targeting a competitively superior one, thereby reducing fitness differences. However, previous studies yielded mixed conclusions. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that a parasitic annual plant, Cuscuta campestris, facilitates the coexistence of two common annual plants. We performed field surveys and parasitism experiments to parameterize a plant competition dynamics model. The model suggested a competition–defence tradeoff: the legume Lespedeza striata was a better competitor than the grass Setaria faberi, while it was more susceptible to the parasite. Moreover, an empirical host–parasite dynamics model, extended from the plant competition model, predicted their coexistence within broad, biologically reasonable ranges of parameters. This work provides field evidence of the coexisting–promoting role of a parasitic plant, as caused by stabilising feedback between host and parasite densities.
- 24 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in Ecology Letters
- Vol. 27 (10) , e14554
A Parasite Plant Promotes the Coexistence of Two Annual Plants
Consumers can influence the competitive outcomes of prey species in various ways. Modern coexistence theory predicts that consumers can promote prey coexistence by preferably targeting a competitively superior one, thereby reducing fitness differences. However, previous studies yielded mixed conclusions. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that a parasitic annual plant, Cuscuta campestris, facilitates the coexistence of two common annual plants. We performed field surveys and parasitism experiments to parameterize a plant competition dynamics model. The model suggested a competition–defence tradeoff: the legume Lespedeza striata was a better competitor than the grass Setaria faberi, while it was more susceptible to the parasite. Moreover, an empirical host–parasite dynamics model, extended from the plant competition model, predicted their coexistence within broad, biologically reasonable ranges of parameters. This work provides field evidence of the coexisting–promoting role of a parasitic plant, as caused by stabilising feedback between host and parasite densities.
Plant–mycorrhizal associations may explain the latitudinal gradient of plant community assembly
Biogeographical variation in community assembly processes forms the basis of the latitudinal gradient of biodiversity by driving β‐diversity. Classical studies on community assembly predict environmental filtering affecting β‐diversity more strongly at higher latitudes, where productivity is lower and abiotic stress is stronger. Contrary to this prediction, recent evidence indicates that plant community composition at higher latitudes exhibits more spatially clustered distributions independently of background environments, suggesting the importance of spatial processes, such as priority effects. In this study, we propose a hypothesis that resolves this paradox by considering plant–soil feedback and biogeographic variations in the dominant mycorrhizal type: we predict that the increasing prevalence of ectomycorrhizal (EcM) trees with latitude contributes to the spatially clustered distribution of plants, as EcM trees tend to exhibit positive plant–soil feedback. We analyzed a large‐scale standardized dataset of Japanese forests covering a latitudinal gradient of >10° and found that 1) the proportion of EcM trees was higher at higher latitudes, and 2) EcM tree‐rich communities exhibited more spatially clustered distributions likely due to positive plant–soil feedback. Consequently, 3) tree species composition at higher latitudes was better explained by spatial variables suggesting the importance of priority effects. Consistent with the predictions of the plant–soil feedback theory, these patterns were more pronounced in understory than in canopy communities. Taken together, our results lend support to our hypothesis that biogeographic variation in tree community assembly patterns is defined by mycorrhizal types and plant–soil feedback, thereby resolving a paradox in the latitudinal gradient of plant community assembly. Our work highlights that plant mycorrhizal type underlies the determinants of β‐diversity which is a critical component of the latitudinal gradient of diversity.
Plant–mycorrhizal associations may explain the latitudinal gradient of plant community assembly
Biogeographical variation in community assembly processes forms the basis of the latitudinal gradient of biodiversity by driving β‐diversity. Classical studies on community assembly predict environmental filtering affecting β‐diversity more strongly at higher latitudes, where productivity is lower and abiotic stress is stronger. Contrary to this prediction, recent evidence indicates that plant community composition at higher latitudes exhibits more spatially clustered distributions independently of background environments, suggesting the importance of spatial processes, such as priority effects. In this study, we propose a hypothesis that resolves this paradox by considering plant–soil feedback and biogeographic variations in the dominant mycorrhizal type: we predict that the increasing prevalence of ectomycorrhizal (EcM) trees with latitude contributes to the spatially clustered distribution of plants, as EcM trees tend to exhibit positive plant–soil feedback. We analyzed a large‐scale standardized dataset of Japanese forests covering a latitudinal gradient of >10° and found that 1) the proportion of EcM trees was higher at higher latitudes, and 2) EcM tree‐rich communities exhibited more spatially clustered distributions likely due to positive plant–soil feedback. Consequently, 3) tree species composition at higher latitudes was better explained by spatial variables suggesting the importance of priority effects. Consistent with the predictions of the plant–soil feedback theory, these patterns were more pronounced in understory than in canopy communities. Taken together, our results lend support to our hypothesis that biogeographic variation in tree community assembly patterns is defined by mycorrhizal types and plant–soil feedback, thereby resolving a paradox in the latitudinal gradient of plant community assembly. Our work highlights that plant mycorrhizal type underlies the determinants of β‐diversity which is a critical component of the latitudinal gradient of diversity.
- Open Access
Plant-mycorrhizal associations may explain the latitudinal gradient of plant community assembly
Biogeographical variation in community assembly patterns forms the basis of large-scale biodiversity gradients. Previous studies on community assembly have suggested the dominant role of environmental filtering at higher latitudes. However, recent evidence indicates that plant community distributions at higher latitudes exhibit more spatial clustering, suggesting the importance of spatial assembly processes. In this study, we propose a hypothesis that resolves this paradox by incorporating biogeographic variations in dominant mycorrhizal types: the increasing prevalence of ectomycorrhizal (EcM) trees with latitude contributes to the spatially clustered distribution of plants, as EcM trees tend to exhibit positive plant-soil feedback. We analyzed a large-scale standardized dataset of Japanese forests covering a latitudinal gradient of >10° and found that (i) the proportion of EcM trees was higher at higher latitudes, and (ii) EcM tree-rich communities exhibited more spatially clustered distributions. Consequently, (iii) the tree species composition at higher latitudes was better explained by spatial variables. Moreover, consistent with predictions derived from the plant-soil feedback theory, these findings were particularly evident in the understory rather than the canopy communities. This study demonstrates that plant-soil feedback influences plant community distributions at metacommunity scales, thereby giving rise to a paradox within the latitudinal gradient of plant community assembly.
Open AccessPlant-mycorrhizal associations may explain the latitudinal gradient of plant community assembly
Biogeographical variation in community assembly patterns forms the basis of large-scale biodiversity gradients. Previous studies on community assembly have suggested the dominant role of environmental filtering at higher latitudes. However, recent evidence indicates that plant community distributions at higher latitudes exhibit more spatial clustering, suggesting the importance of spatial assembly processes. In this study, we propose a hypothesis that resolves this paradox by incorporating biogeographic variations in dominant mycorrhizal types: the increasing prevalence of ectomycorrhizal (EcM) trees with latitude contributes to the spatially clustered distribution of plants, as EcM trees tend to exhibit positive plant-soil feedback. We analyzed a large-scale standardized dataset of Japanese forests covering a latitudinal gradient of >10° and found that (i) the proportion of EcM trees was higher at higher latitudes, and (ii) EcM tree-rich communities exhibited more spatially clustered distributions. Consequently, (iii) the tree species composition at higher latitudes was better explained by spatial variables. Moreover, consistent with predictions derived from the plant-soil feedback theory, these findings were particularly evident in the understory rather than the canopy communities. This study demonstrates that plant-soil feedback influences plant community distributions at metacommunity scales, thereby giving rise to a paradox within the latitudinal gradient of plant community assembly.
- Open Access
Large scale eDNA database reveals latitudinal diversity gradients with seasonal variations
Withdrawal Statement: The authors have withdrawn their manuscript owing to conflicts regarding the use of data. Therefore, the authors do not wish this work to be cited as reference for the project. The revised version will be updated once this issue has been resolved. If you have any questions, please contact the corresponding author.
Open AccessLarge scale eDNA database reveals latitudinal diversity gradients with seasonal variations
Withdrawal Statement: The authors have withdrawn their manuscript owing to conflicts regarding the use of data. Therefore, the authors do not wish this work to be cited as reference for the project. The revised version will be updated once this issue has been resolved. If you have any questions, please contact the corresponding author.
- 13 January 2023
- Published by Wiley in Global Ecology and Biogeography
- Vol. 32 (3) , 397-407
Dominant temperate and subalpine Japanese trees have variable photosynthetic thermal optima according to site mean annual temperature
- 13 January 2023
- Published by Wiley in Global Ecology and Biogeography
- Vol. 32 (3) , 397-407
Dominant temperate and subalpine Japanese trees have variable photosynthetic thermal optima according to site mean annual temperature
- Open Access
- 1 December 2022
- Published by Wiley in Population Ecology
- Vol. 65 (1) , 5-16
Spatiotemporal dimensions of community assembly
Ecological communities are assembled through a series of multiple processes, including dispersal, abiotic and biotic filtering, and ecological drift. Although these assembly processes act in concert to structure local communities, their relative importance is considerably variable among study systems. While such contingency of community assembly has been widely appreciated, the empirical and theoretical evidence is scattered around in the literature, and few efforts have been made to synthesize it. In this mini‐review, we summarize the accumulated evidence of the context‐dependency of community assembly rules, to reach a rough generalization of the contingency. Specifically, we argue that spatial and temporal dimensions can serve as general axes that regulate the relative importance of assembly processes. To this end, we synthesize the current understanding of how the relative importance of multiple assembly processes changes with spatial scales and complexity, and with time in the long and short terms. This review concludes that spatial and temporal dimensions can be common currencies of community assembly rules that are shared across various systems.
- 1 December 2022
- Published by Wiley in Population Ecology
- Vol. 65 (1) , 5-16
Open AccessSpatiotemporal dimensions of community assembly
Ecological communities are assembled through a series of multiple processes, including dispersal, abiotic and biotic filtering, and ecological drift. Although these assembly processes act in concert to structure local communities, their relative importance is considerably variable among study systems. While such contingency of community assembly has been widely appreciated, the empirical and theoretical evidence is scattered around in the literature, and few efforts have been made to synthesize it. In this mini‐review, we summarize the accumulated evidence of the context‐dependency of community assembly rules, to reach a rough generalization of the contingency. Specifically, we argue that spatial and temporal dimensions can serve as general axes that regulate the relative importance of assembly processes. To this end, we synthesize the current understanding of how the relative importance of multiple assembly processes changes with spatial scales and complexity, and with time in the long and short terms. This review concludes that spatial and temporal dimensions can be common currencies of community assembly rules that are shared across various systems.