Ugo Niccolò Di Carlo
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Ugo Niccolò Di Carlo has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Michela Mapelli
Università di Padova
17 shared publications - Mario Spera
46 INFN, Sezione di Trieste, I-34127 Trieste, Italy
12 shared publications - Sara Rastello
Universitat de Barcelona (UB)
11 shared publications - Alessandro Ballone
Physics and Astronomy Department Galileo Galilei University of Padova Vicolo dell'Osservatorio 3 I-35122 Padova Italy
10 shared publications - Giuliano Iorio
Departament de Física Quàntica i Astrofísica, Institut de Ciències del Cosmos, Universitat de Barcelona
10 shared publications - Nicola Giacobbo
Physics and Astronomy Department Galileo Galilei, University of Padova, Vicolo dell’Osservatorio 3, I-35122 Padova, Italy
9 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 3 September 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 713, A44
The impact of envelope binding energies on the merger rate density of binary compact objects
The common envelope (CE) phase plays a key role in the formation of binary compact object systems. Its final outcome strongly depends on the envelope binding energy, but this quantity is often estimated using fitting formulas that are not fully consistent with the underlying stellar evolution models adopted in population-synthesis codes. Here, we investigate envelope binding energies across the most extensive stellar grid considered to date. Our stellar tracks, evolved with PARSEC v2.0, include hydrogen (H)-rich stars with metallicities ranging from Z = 10 −11 (Population III stars) to Z = 0.03, and initial masses between 2 and 2000 M ⊙ , as well as pure-helium stars with masses from 0.36 to 350 M ⊙ . We examine the sensitivity of the envelope binding energies to the selected core-envelope boundary definition and to different internal energy source contributions. For H-rich stars, we find that internal energy sources can alter the envelope binding energy by more than an order of magnitude, whereas the core boundary criteria play a secondary role. In contrast, for pure helium stars, the core-boundary criterion becomes the dominant factor. The envelope binding energies derived from different stellar tracks can show deviations of several orders of magnitude, with larger differences for more massive stars and higher metallicities. Finally, by implementing our new envelope binding energy prescriptions into the binary population synthesis code SEVN , we show that the predicted merger rate densities of compact binaries can differ by more than an order of magnitude compared to previous models. Our results highlight the importance of using envelope binding energies that are consistent with the underlying stellar evolution models and caution against extrapolating empirical fits beyond the considered parameter space.
- 3 September 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 713, A44
Open AccessThe impact of envelope binding energies on the merger rate density of binary compact objects
The common envelope (CE) phase plays a key role in the formation of binary compact object systems. Its final outcome strongly depends on the envelope binding energy, but this quantity is often estimated using fitting formulas that are not fully consistent with the underlying stellar evolution models adopted in population-synthesis codes. Here, we investigate envelope binding energies across the most extensive stellar grid considered to date. Our stellar tracks, evolved with PARSEC v2.0, include hydrogen (H)-rich stars with metallicities ranging from Z = 10 −11 (Population III stars) to Z = 0.03, and initial masses between 2 and 2000 M ⊙ , as well as pure-helium stars with masses from 0.36 to 350 M ⊙ . We examine the sensitivity of the envelope binding energies to the selected core-envelope boundary definition and to different internal energy source contributions. For H-rich stars, we find that internal energy sources can alter the envelope binding energy by more than an order of magnitude, whereas the core boundary criteria play a secondary role. In contrast, for pure helium stars, the core-boundary criterion becomes the dominant factor. The envelope binding energies derived from different stellar tracks can show deviations of several orders of magnitude, with larger differences for more massive stars and higher metallicities. Finally, by implementing our new envelope binding energy prescriptions into the binary population synthesis code SEVN , we show that the predicted merger rate densities of compact binaries can differ by more than an order of magnitude compared to previous models. Our results highlight the importance of using envelope binding energies that are consistent with the underlying stellar evolution models and caution against extrapolating empirical fits beyond the considered parameter space.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific
- Vol. 137 (4) , 044202
Realistic Predictions for Gaia Black Hole Discoveries: Comparison of Isolated Binary and Dynamical Formation Models
Astrometry from Gaia has enabled discovery of three dormant black holes (BHs) in au-scale binaries. Numerous models have been proposed to explain their formation, including several that have forecasted Gaia detections. However, previous works have used simplified detectability metrics that do not capture key elements of the Gaia astrometric orbit selection function. We apply a realistic forward-model of Gaia astrometric orbit catalogs to BH binary populations generated through (a) isolated binary evolution (IBE) and (b) dynamical formation in star clusters. For both formation channels, we analyze binary populations in a simulated Milky Way-like galaxy with a realistic metallicity-dependent star formation history and 3D dust map. We generate epoch astrometry for each binary from the Gaia scanning law and fit it with the cascade of astrometric models used in Gaia DR3. The IBE model of Chawla et al. predicts that no BH binaries should have been detected in DR3 and thus significantly underpredicts the formation rate of Gaia BHs. In contrast, the dynamical model of Di Carlo et al. overpredicts the number of BHs receiving DR3 orbital solutions by a factor of ∼8. The two models predict very different orbital period distributions, with the IBE model predicting only binaries that avoided common envelope evolution and have P orb ≳ 2000 days to be detectable, and the dynamical formation model predicting a period distribution that is roughly log-uniform. Adopting the dynamical channel as a fiducial model and rescaling by a factor of 1/8 to match DR3, we predict that ∼30 BH binaries will be detected in Gaia DR4, representing ∼0.1% of Milky Way BHs with luminous companions in au-scale orbits.
- 1 April 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific
- Vol. 137 (4) , 044202
Open AccessRealistic Predictions for Gaia Black Hole Discoveries: Comparison of Isolated Binary and Dynamical Formation Models
Astrometry from Gaia has enabled discovery of three dormant black holes (BHs) in au-scale binaries. Numerous models have been proposed to explain their formation, including several that have forecasted Gaia detections. However, previous works have used simplified detectability metrics that do not capture key elements of the Gaia astrometric orbit selection function. We apply a realistic forward-model of Gaia astrometric orbit catalogs to BH binary populations generated through (a) isolated binary evolution (IBE) and (b) dynamical formation in star clusters. For both formation channels, we analyze binary populations in a simulated Milky Way-like galaxy with a realistic metallicity-dependent star formation history and 3D dust map. We generate epoch astrometry for each binary from the Gaia scanning law and fit it with the cascade of astrometric models used in Gaia DR3. The IBE model of Chawla et al. predicts that no BH binaries should have been detected in DR3 and thus significantly underpredicts the formation rate of Gaia BHs. In contrast, the dynamical model of Di Carlo et al. overpredicts the number of BHs receiving DR3 orbital solutions by a factor of ∼8. The two models predict very different orbital period distributions, with the IBE model predicting only binaries that avoided common envelope evolution and have P orb ≳ 2000 days to be detectable, and the dynamical formation model predicting a period distribution that is roughly log-uniform. Adopting the dynamical channel as a fiducial model and rescaling by a factor of 1/8 to match DR3, we predict that ∼30 BH binaries will be detected in Gaia DR4, representing ∼0.1% of Milky Way BHs with luminous companions in au-scale orbits.
- Open Access
- 12 March 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 695, A122
The initial mass-remnant mass relation for core collapse supernovae
Context. The first direct detection of gravitational waves in 2015 marked the beginning of a new era for the study of compact objects. Upcoming detectors, such as the Einstein Telescope, are expected to add thousands of binary coalescences to the list. However, from a theoretical perspective, our understanding of compact objects is hindered by many uncertainties, and a comprehensive study of the nature of stellar remnants from core-collapse supernovae is still lacking. Aims. In this work, we investigate the properties of stellar remnants using a homogeneous grid of rotating and non-rotating massive stars at various metallicities. Methods. We simulated the supernova explosion of the evolved progenitors using the HYdrodynamic Ppm Explosion with Radiation diffusION (HYPERION) code, assuming a thermal bomb model calibrated to match the main properties of SN1987A. Results. We find that the heaviest black hole that can form depends on the initial stellar rotation, metallicity, and the assumed criterion for the onset of pulsational pair-instability supernovae. Non-rotating progenitors at [Fe/H] = −3 can form black holes up to ∼87, M⊙, thus falling within the theorized pair-instability mass gap. Conversely, enhanced wind mass loss prevents the formation of BHs more massive than ∼41.6 M⊙ from rotating progenitors. We used our results to study the black hole mass distribution from a population of 106 isolated massive stars following a Kroupa initial mass function. Finally, we provide fitting formulas to compute the mass of compact remnants as a function of stellar progenitor properties. Our up-to-date prescriptions can be easily implemented in rapid population synthesis codes.
- 12 March 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 695, A122
Open AccessThe initial mass-remnant mass relation for core collapse supernovae
Context. The first direct detection of gravitational waves in 2015 marked the beginning of a new era for the study of compact objects. Upcoming detectors, such as the Einstein Telescope, are expected to add thousands of binary coalescences to the list. However, from a theoretical perspective, our understanding of compact objects is hindered by many uncertainties, and a comprehensive study of the nature of stellar remnants from core-collapse supernovae is still lacking. Aims. In this work, we investigate the properties of stellar remnants using a homogeneous grid of rotating and non-rotating massive stars at various metallicities. Methods. We simulated the supernova explosion of the evolved progenitors using the HYdrodynamic Ppm Explosion with Radiation diffusION (HYPERION) code, assuming a thermal bomb model calibrated to match the main properties of SN1987A. Results. We find that the heaviest black hole that can form depends on the initial stellar rotation, metallicity, and the assumed criterion for the onset of pulsational pair-instability supernovae. Non-rotating progenitors at [Fe/H] = −3 can form black holes up to ∼87, M⊙, thus falling within the theorized pair-instability mass gap. Conversely, enhanced wind mass loss prevents the formation of BHs more massive than ∼41.6 M⊙ from rotating progenitors. We used our results to study the black hole mass distribution from a population of 106 isolated massive stars following a Kroupa initial mass function. Finally, we provide fitting formulas to compute the mass of compact remnants as a function of stellar progenitor properties. Our up-to-date prescriptions can be easily implemented in rapid population synthesis codes.
- Open Access
- 11 October 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 690, A274
A machine learning framework to generate star cluster realisations
Context. Computational astronomy has reached the stage where running a gravitational N-body simulation of a stellar system, such as a Milky Way star cluster, is computationally feasible, but a major limiting factor that remains is the ability to set up physically realistic initial conditions. Aims. We aim to obtain realistic initial conditions for N-body simulations by taking advantage of machine learning, with emphasis on reproducing small-scale interstellar distance distributions. Methods. The computational bottleneck for obtaining such distance distributions is the hydrodynamics of star formation, which ultimately determine the features of the stars, including positions, velocities, and masses. To mitigate this issue, we introduce a new method for sampling physically realistic initial conditions from a limited set of simulations using Gaussian processes. Results. We evaluated the resulting sets of initial conditions based on whether they meet tests for physical realism. We find that direct sampling based on the learned distribution of the star features fails to reproduce binary systems. Consequently, we show that physics-informed sampling algorithms solve this issue, as they are capable of generating realisations closer to reality.
- 11 October 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 690, A274
Open AccessA machine learning framework to generate star cluster realisations
Context. Computational astronomy has reached the stage where running a gravitational N-body simulation of a stellar system, such as a Milky Way star cluster, is computationally feasible, but a major limiting factor that remains is the ability to set up physically realistic initial conditions. Aims. We aim to obtain realistic initial conditions for N-body simulations by taking advantage of machine learning, with emphasis on reproducing small-scale interstellar distance distributions. Methods. The computational bottleneck for obtaining such distance distributions is the hydrodynamics of star formation, which ultimately determine the features of the stars, including positions, velocities, and masses. To mitigate this issue, we introduce a new method for sampling physically realistic initial conditions from a limited set of simulations using Gaussian processes. Results. We evaluated the resulting sets of initial conditions based on whether they meet tests for physical realism. We find that direct sampling based on the learned distribution of the star features fails to reproduce binary systems. Consequently, we show that physics-informed sampling algorithms solve this issue, as they are capable of generating realisations closer to reality.
- Open Access
- 4 October 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 690, A144
The boring history of Gaia BH3 from isolated binary evolution
Gaia BH3 is the first observed dormant black hole (BH) with a mass of ≈30 M⊙, and it represents the first confirmation that such massive BHs are associated with metal-poor stars. Here, we explore the isolated binary formation channel for Gaia BH3, focusing on the old and metal-poor stellar population of the Milky Way halo. We used the MIST stellar models and our open-source population synthesis code SEVN to evolve 5.6 × 108 binaries, exploring 20 sets of parameters that encompass different natal kicks, metallicities, common envelope efficiencies and binding energies, and models for the Roche-lobe overflow. We find that systems such as Gaia BH3 form preferentially from binaries initially composed of a massive star (40–60 M⊙) and a low-mass companion ( 103 days) and eccentric orbit (e > 0.6). Such progenitor binary stars do not undergo any Roche-lobe overflow episode during their entire evolution, so the final orbital properties of the BH-star system are essentially determined at the core collapse of the primary star. Low natal kicks (≲ 10 km/s) significantly favour the formation of Gaia BH3-like systems, but high velocity kicks up to ≈220 km/s are also allowed. We estimated the formation efficiency for Gaia BH3-like systems in old (t >10 Gyr) and metal-poor (Z < 0.01) populations to be ∼4 × 10−8 M⊙−1 (for our fiducial model), representing ~3% of the whole simulated BH-star population. We expect up to ≈4000 BH-star systems in the Galactic halo formed through isolated evolution, of which ≈100 are compatible with Gaia BH3. Gaia BH3-like systems represent a common product of isolated binary evolution at low metallicity (Z < 0.01), but given the steep density profile of the Galactic halo, we do not expect more than one at the observed distance of Gaia BH3. Our models show that even if it was born inside a stellar cluster, Gaia BH3 is compatible with a primordial binary star that escaped from its parent cluster without experiencing significant dynamical interactions.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 690, A144
Open AccessThe boring history of Gaia BH3 from isolated binary evolution
Gaia BH3 is the first observed dormant black hole (BH) with a mass of ≈30 M⊙, and it represents the first confirmation that such massive BHs are associated with metal-poor stars. Here, we explore the isolated binary formation channel for Gaia BH3, focusing on the old and metal-poor stellar population of the Milky Way halo. We used the MIST stellar models and our open-source population synthesis code SEVN to evolve 5.6 × 108 binaries, exploring 20 sets of parameters that encompass different natal kicks, metallicities, common envelope efficiencies and binding energies, and models for the Roche-lobe overflow. We find that systems such as Gaia BH3 form preferentially from binaries initially composed of a massive star (40–60 M⊙) and a low-mass companion ( 103 days) and eccentric orbit (e > 0.6). Such progenitor binary stars do not undergo any Roche-lobe overflow episode during their entire evolution, so the final orbital properties of the BH-star system are essentially determined at the core collapse of the primary star. Low natal kicks (≲ 10 km/s) significantly favour the formation of Gaia BH3-like systems, but high velocity kicks up to ≈220 km/s are also allowed. We estimated the formation efficiency for Gaia BH3-like systems in old (t >10 Gyr) and metal-poor (Z < 0.01) populations to be ∼4 × 10−8 M⊙−1 (for our fiducial model), representing ~3% of the whole simulated BH-star population. We expect up to ≈4000 BH-star systems in the Galactic halo formed through isolated evolution, of which ≈100 are compatible with Gaia BH3. Gaia BH3-like systems represent a common product of isolated binary evolution at low metallicity (Z < 0.01), but given the steep density profile of the Galactic halo, we do not expect more than one at the observed distance of Gaia BH3. Our models show that even if it was born inside a stellar cluster, Gaia BH3 is compatible with a primordial binary star that escaped from its parent cluster without experiencing significant dynamical interactions.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 965 (1) , 22
Young Star Clusters Dominate the Production of Detached Black Hole–Star Binaries
The recent discovery of two detached black hole–star (BH–star) binaries from Gaia’s third data release has sparked interest in understanding the formation mechanisms of these systems. We investigate the formation of these systems by dynamical processes in young star clusters (SCs) and via isolated binary (IB) evolution, using a combination of direct N-body and population synthesis simulations. We find that dynamical formation in SCs is nearly 50 times more efficient per unit of star formation at producing BH–star binaries than IB evolution. We expand this analysis to the full Milky Way (MW) using a FIRE-2 hydrodynamical simulation of an MW-mass galaxy. Even assuming that only 10% of star formation goes into SCs, we find that approximately four out of every five BH–star systems are formed dynamically, and that the MW contains a total of ∼2 × 105 BH–star systems. Many of these dynamically formed systems have longer orbital periods, greater eccentricities, and greater black hole masses than their isolated counterparts. For binaries older than 100 Myr, we show that any detectable system with e ≳ 0.5 or M BH ≳ 10 M ⊙ can only be formed through dynamical processes. Our MW model predicts between 64 and 215 such detections from the complete DR4 Gaia catalog, with the majority of systems being dynamically formed in massive and metal-rich SCs. Finally, we compare our populations to the recently discovered Gaia BH1 and Gaia BH2, and conclude that the dynamical scenario is the most favorable formation pathway for both systems.
- 1 April 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 965 (1) , 22
Open AccessYoung Star Clusters Dominate the Production of Detached Black Hole–Star Binaries
The recent discovery of two detached black hole–star (BH–star) binaries from Gaia’s third data release has sparked interest in understanding the formation mechanisms of these systems. We investigate the formation of these systems by dynamical processes in young star clusters (SCs) and via isolated binary (IB) evolution, using a combination of direct N-body and population synthesis simulations. We find that dynamical formation in SCs is nearly 50 times more efficient per unit of star formation at producing BH–star binaries than IB evolution. We expand this analysis to the full Milky Way (MW) using a FIRE-2 hydrodynamical simulation of an MW-mass galaxy. Even assuming that only 10% of star formation goes into SCs, we find that approximately four out of every five BH–star systems are formed dynamically, and that the MW contains a total of ∼2 × 105 BH–star systems. Many of these dynamically formed systems have longer orbital periods, greater eccentricities, and greater black hole masses than their isolated counterparts. For binaries older than 100 Myr, we show that any detectable system with e ≳ 0.5 or M BH ≳ 10 M ⊙ can only be formed through dynamical processes. Our MW model predicts between 64 and 215 such detections from the complete DR4 Gaia catalog, with the majority of systems being dynamically formed in massive and metal-rich SCs. Finally, we compare our populations to the recently discovered Gaia BH1 and Gaia BH2, and conclude that the dynamical scenario is the most favorable formation pathway for both systems.
- 12 September 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 526 (1) , 740-749
Dynamical formation of Gaia BH1 in a young star cluster
Gaia BH1, the first quiescent black hole (BH) detected from Gaia data, poses a challenge to most binary evolution models: its current mass ratio is ≈0.1, and its orbital period seems to be too long for a post-common envelope system and too short for a non-interacting binary system. Here, we explore the hypothesis that Gaia BH1 formed through dynamical interactions in a young star cluster (YSC). We study the properties of BH-main sequence (MS) binaries formed in YSCs with initial mass 3 × 102 − 3 × 104 M⊙ at solar metallicity, by means of 3.5 × 104 direct N-body simulations coupled with binary population synthesis. For comparison, we also run a sample of isolated binary stars with the same binary population synthesis code and initial conditions used in the dynamical models. We find that BH-MS systems that form via dynamical exchanges populate the region corresponding to the main orbital properties of Gaia BH1 (period, eccentricity, and masses). In contrast, none of our isolated binary systems matches the orbital period and MS mass of Gaia BH1. Our best matching Gaia BH1–like system forms via repeated dynamical exchanges and collisions involving the BH progenitor star, before it undergoes core collapse. YSCs are at least two orders of magnitude more efficient in forming Gaia BH1–like systems than isolated binary evolution.
- 12 September 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 526 (1) , 740-749
Dynamical formation of Gaia BH1 in a young star cluster
Gaia BH1, the first quiescent black hole (BH) detected from Gaia data, poses a challenge to most binary evolution models: its current mass ratio is ≈0.1, and its orbital period seems to be too long for a post-common envelope system and too short for a non-interacting binary system. Here, we explore the hypothesis that Gaia BH1 formed through dynamical interactions in a young star cluster (YSC). We study the properties of BH-main sequence (MS) binaries formed in YSCs with initial mass 3 × 102 − 3 × 104 M⊙ at solar metallicity, by means of 3.5 × 104 direct N-body simulations coupled with binary population synthesis. For comparison, we also run a sample of isolated binary stars with the same binary population synthesis code and initial conditions used in the dynamical models. We find that BH-MS systems that form via dynamical exchanges populate the region corresponding to the main orbital properties of Gaia BH1 (period, eccentricity, and masses). In contrast, none of our isolated binary systems matches the orbital period and MS mass of Gaia BH1. Our best matching Gaia BH1–like system forms via repeated dynamical exchanges and collisions involving the BH progenitor star, before it undergoes core collapse. YSCs are at least two orders of magnitude more efficient in forming Gaia BH1–like systems than isolated binary evolution.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2022
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 924 (2) , 56
The Black Hole Mass Function Across Cosmic Times. I. Stellar Black Holes and Light Seed Distribution
This is the first paper in a series aimed at modeling the black hole (BH) mass function, from the stellar to the intermediate to the (super)massive regime. In the present work, we focus on stellar BHs and provide an ab initio computation of their mass function across cosmic times; we mainly consider the standard, and likely dominant, production channel of stellar-mass BHs constituted by isolated single/binary star evolution. Specifically, we exploit the state-of-the-art stellar and binary evolutionary code SEVN, and couple its outputs with redshift-dependent galaxy statistics and empirical scaling relations involving galaxy metallicity, star formation rate and stellar mass. The resulting relic mass function dN / dVd log m • as a function of the BH mass m • features a rather flat shape up to m • ≈ 50 M ⊙ and then a log-normal decline for larger masses, while its overall normalization at a given mass increases with decreasing redshift. We highlight the contribution to the local mass function from isolated stars evolving into BHs and from binary stellar systems ending up in single or binary BHs. We also include the distortion on the mass function induced by binary BH mergers, finding that it has a minor effect at the high-mass end. We estimate a local stellar BH relic mass density of ρ • ≈ 5 × 107 M ⊙ Mpc−3, which exceeds by more than two orders of magnitude that in supermassive BHs; this translates into an energy density parameter Ω• ≈ 4 × 10−4, implying that the total mass in stellar BHs amounts to ≲1% of the local baryonic matter. We show how our mass function for merging BH binaries compares with the recent estimates from gravitational wave observations by LIGO/Virgo, and discuss the possible implications for dynamical formation of BH binaries in dense environments like star clusters. We address the impact of adopting different binary stellar evolution codes (SEVN and COSMIC) on the mass function, and find the main differences to occur at the high-mass end, in connection with the numerical treatment of stellar binary evolution effects. We highlight that our results can provide a firm theoretical basis for a physically motivated light seed distribution at high redshift, to be implemented in semi-analytic and numerical models of BH formation and evolution. Finally, we stress that the present work can constitute a starting point to investigate the origin of heavy seeds and the growth of (super)massive BHs in high-redshift star-forming galaxies, that we will pursue in forthcoming papers.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 924 (2) , 56
Open AccessThe Black Hole Mass Function Across Cosmic Times. I. Stellar Black Holes and Light Seed Distribution
This is the first paper in a series aimed at modeling the black hole (BH) mass function, from the stellar to the intermediate to the (super)massive regime. In the present work, we focus on stellar BHs and provide an ab initio computation of their mass function across cosmic times; we mainly consider the standard, and likely dominant, production channel of stellar-mass BHs constituted by isolated single/binary star evolution. Specifically, we exploit the state-of-the-art stellar and binary evolutionary code SEVN, and couple its outputs with redshift-dependent galaxy statistics and empirical scaling relations involving galaxy metallicity, star formation rate and stellar mass. The resulting relic mass function dN / dVd log m • as a function of the BH mass m • features a rather flat shape up to m • ≈ 50 M ⊙ and then a log-normal decline for larger masses, while its overall normalization at a given mass increases with decreasing redshift. We highlight the contribution to the local mass function from isolated stars evolving into BHs and from binary stellar systems ending up in single or binary BHs. We also include the distortion on the mass function induced by binary BH mergers, finding that it has a minor effect at the high-mass end. We estimate a local stellar BH relic mass density of ρ • ≈ 5 × 107 M ⊙ Mpc−3, which exceeds by more than two orders of magnitude that in supermassive BHs; this translates into an energy density parameter Ω• ≈ 4 × 10−4, implying that the total mass in stellar BHs amounts to ≲1% of the local baryonic matter. We show how our mass function for merging BH binaries compares with the recent estimates from gravitational wave observations by LIGO/Virgo, and discuss the possible implications for dynamical formation of BH binaries in dense environments like star clusters. We address the impact of adopting different binary stellar evolution codes (SEVN and COSMIC) on the mass function, and find the main differences to occur at the high-mass end, in connection with the numerical treatment of stellar binary evolution effects. We highlight that our results can provide a firm theoretical basis for a physically motivated light seed distribution at high redshift, to be implemented in semi-analytic and numerical models of BH formation and evolution. Finally, we stress that the present work can constitute a starting point to investigate the origin of heavy seeds and the growth of (super)massive BHs in high-redshift star-forming galaxies, that we will pursue in forthcoming papers.
- 1 October 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 508 (2) , 3045-3054
GW190521 formation via three-body encounters in young massive star clusters
GW190521 is the most massive binary black hole (BBH) merger observed to date, and its primary component lies in the pair-instability (PI) mass gap. Here, we investigate the formation of GW190521-like systems via three-body encounters in young massive star clusters. We performed 2 × 105 simulations of binary-single interactions between a BBH and a massive $\ge {60}\,$M⊙ black hole (BH), including post-Newtonian terms up to the 2.5 order and a prescription for relativistic kicks. In our initial conditions, we take into account the possibility of forming BHs in the PI mass gap via stellar collisions. If we assume that first-generation BHs have low spins, $\sim {0.17}{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ of all the simulated BBH mergers have component masses, effective and precessing spin, and remnant mass and spin inside the $90{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ credible intervals of GW190521. Seven of these systems are first-generation exchanged binaries, while five are second-generation BBHs. We estimate a merger rate density $\mathcal {R}_{\rm GW190521}\sim {0.03}\,$Gpc$^{-3}\,$yr−1 for GW190521-like binaries formed via binary-single interactions in young star clusters. This rate is extremely sensitive to the spin distribution of first-generation BBHs. Stellar collisions, second-generation mergers and dynamical exchanges are the key ingredients to produce GW190521-like systems in young star clusters.- 1 October 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 508 (2) , 3045-3054
GW190521 formation via three-body encounters in young massive star clusters
GW190521 is the most massive binary black hole (BBH) merger observed to date, and its primary component lies in the pair-instability (PI) mass gap. Here, we investigate the formation of GW190521-like systems via three-body encounters in young massive star clusters. We performed 2 × 105 simulations of binary-single interactions between a BBH and a massive $\ge {60}\,$M⊙ black hole (BH), including post-Newtonian terms up to the 2.5 order and a prescription for relativistic kicks. In our initial conditions, we take into account the possibility of forming BHs in the PI mass gap via stellar collisions. If we assume that first-generation BHs have low spins, $\sim {0.17}{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ of all the simulated BBH mergers have component masses, effective and precessing spin, and remnant mass and spin inside the $90{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ credible intervals of GW190521. Seven of these systems are first-generation exchanged binaries, while five are second-generation BBHs. We estimate a merger rate density $\mathcal {R}_{\rm GW190521}\sim {0.03}\,$Gpc$^{-3}\,$yr−1 for GW190521-like binaries formed via binary-single interactions in young star clusters. This rate is extremely sensitive to the spin distribution of first-generation BBHs. Stellar collisions, second-generation mergers and dynamical exchanges are the key ingredients to produce GW190521-like systems in young star clusters.- 1 September 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 507 (4) , 5224-5235
New insights on binary black hole formation channels after GWTC-2: young star clusters versus isolated binaries
With the recent release of the Second Gravitational Wave Transient Catalog (GWTC-2), which introduced dozens of new detections, we are at a turning point of gravitational wave astronomy, as we are now able to directly infer constraints on the astrophysical population of compact objects. Here, we tackle the burning issue of understanding the origin of binary black hole (BBH) mergers. To this effect, we make use of state-of-the-art population synthesis and N-body simulations, to represent two distinct formation channels: BBHs formed in the field (isolated channel) and in young star clusters (dynamical channel). We then use a Bayesian hierarchical approach to infer the distribution of the mixing fraction f, with f = 0 (f = 1) in the pure dynamical (isolated) channel. We explore the effects of additional hyperparameters of the model, such as the spread in metallicity σZ and the parameter σsp, describing the distribution of spin magnitudes. We find that the dynamical model is slightly favoured with a median value of f = 0.26, when σsp = 0.1 and σZ = 0.4. Models with higher spin magnitudes tend to strongly favour dynamically formed BBHs (f ≤ 0.1 if σsp = 0.3). Furthermore, we show that hyperparameters controlling the rates of the model, such as σZ, have a large impact on the inference of the mixing fraction, which rises from 0.18 to 0.43 when we increase σZ from 0.2 to 0.6, for a fixed value of σsp = 0.1. Finally, our current set of observations is better described by a combination of both formation channels, as a pure dynamical scenario is excluded at the |$99{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$| credible interval, except when the spin magnitude is high.
- 1 September 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 507 (4) , 5224-5235
New insights on binary black hole formation channels after GWTC-2: young star clusters versus isolated binaries
With the recent release of the Second Gravitational Wave Transient Catalog (GWTC-2), which introduced dozens of new detections, we are at a turning point of gravitational wave astronomy, as we are now able to directly infer constraints on the astrophysical population of compact objects. Here, we tackle the burning issue of understanding the origin of binary black hole (BBH) mergers. To this effect, we make use of state-of-the-art population synthesis and N-body simulations, to represent two distinct formation channels: BBHs formed in the field (isolated channel) and in young star clusters (dynamical channel). We then use a Bayesian hierarchical approach to infer the distribution of the mixing fraction f, with f = 0 (f = 1) in the pure dynamical (isolated) channel. We explore the effects of additional hyperparameters of the model, such as the spread in metallicity σZ and the parameter σsp, describing the distribution of spin magnitudes. We find that the dynamical model is slightly favoured with a median value of f = 0.26, when σsp = 0.1 and σZ = 0.4. Models with higher spin magnitudes tend to strongly favour dynamically formed BBHs (f ≤ 0.1 if σsp = 0.3). Furthermore, we show that hyperparameters controlling the rates of the model, such as σZ, have a large impact on the inference of the mixing fraction, which rises from 0.18 to 0.43 when we increase σZ from 0.2 to 0.6, for a fixed value of σsp = 0.1. Finally, our current set of observations is better described by a combination of both formation channels, as a pure dynamical scenario is excluded at the |$99{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$| credible interval, except when the spin magnitude is high.