ISIryna Mykolayivna Shopina

Iryna Mykolayivna Shopina

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Iryna Mykolayivna Shopina has a total of 47 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Information security of artificial intelligence use by executive authorities

    by I. M. Shоpina

    This article examines the issues of information security related to the use of artificial intelligence technologies by executive authorities of Ukraine. The study analyzes scholarly approaches to assessing the opportunities and risks associated with the use of artificial intelligence in public administration, particularly in the areas of information security, public procurement, and administrative decision-making. It has been established that contemporary research emphasizes both the positive potential of artificial intelligence in enhancing the efficiency of governance processes and the existence of significant risks associated with personal data protection, algorithmic transparency, the possibility of data bias, and the growing dependence of public institutions on technology companies. The current state of legal regulation governing the use of artificial intelligence in Ukraine is also examined. The provisions of the Concept for the Development of Artificial Intelligence in Ukraine, the action plans for its implementation, and several advisory documents concerning the safe use of artificial intelligence are analyzed. The study identifies a number of organizational and legal gaps, including the insufficient systemic nature of state policy in ensuring the information security of artificial intelligence use by executive authorities, the lack of an adequate level of legal regulation governing the activities of public servants when using such tools, and the predominance of advisory rather than binding regulatory mechanisms. The article substantiates the author’s understanding of the information security of artificial intelligence use by executive authorities as a set of legal, organizational and managerial, technical, technological, economic, socio-psychological, and educational measures aimed at preventing, detecting, and neutralizing risks and threats associated with the application of artificial intelligence systems in the preparation, adoption, and implementation of managerial decisions. The necessity of improving the legal regulation of artificial intelligence use within the system of executive authorities is demonstrated through the specification of rules for working with relevant technologies, the introduction of mechanisms for verifying the reliability of information, and the establishment of restrictions on the use of certain types of information. The article concludes that it is advisable to adopt a special law on artificial intelligence that would establish the legal framework for the safe use of these technologies in the activities of public authorities.


  • Open Access

    Problems of defining gender parity in the academic environment of Ukraine

    by I.M. Shopina

    The article addresses the problems of forming gender parity in the academic environment. The concept of the academic environment is defined as a set of educational institutions, research facilities, scientific self-governing organizations, and their personnel who are in a legal relationship with specific organizations (institutions) and bear legal responsibility for complying with the requirements established for their positions (types of activity). The possibilities of applying the UNESCO Gender Parity Index (GPI) to assess gender disparities in the academic environment are analyzed. It has been established that the concept of gender parity in the academic environment can be understood in several aspects. In the statistical-quantitative aspect, it represents a state of balance between the number of women and men in educational and research institutions, measured using the Gender Parity Index (GPI) as the ratio of females to males, where a value of 1.0 signifies complete equality. The concept of gender parity in the hierarchical-structural aspect can be understood as the absence of vertical segregation and glass ceiling barriers, which ensures proportional representation of both sexes at all levels of professional development: from students and junior academic staff to senior management positions in higher education and research institutions, as well as membership in the presidiums of national academies of sciences. In the legal aspect, gender parity should be understood as the existence of a legal framework for forming and maintaining gender balance in the academic environment, which involves the use of differentiated indicators at various levels of management in the fields of education and science. The main problems associated with the formation of gender parity in the academic environment include: the imperfection of the existing legal and methodological toolkit, which does not provide for differentiation according to the levels of the academic hierarchy; the presence of vertical gender segregation trends, for which obtaining valid and reliable information requires covering all subjects of the academic environment; and the lack of open information on the results of gender analysis of academic subjects conducted during the evaluation of their activities by authorized public authorities.

  • Open Access

    DIRECTIONS FOR COUNTERACTING LEGAL NIHILISM AND ENHANCING LEGAL CULTURE IN CONDITIONS OF HIGH-INTENSITY ARMED CONFLICT

    by Iryna Shopina

    The purpose of the article is to determine the directions for counteracting legal nihilism and enhancing legal culture in the conditions of a high-intensity armed conflict. It is stated that the impact of legal culture and legal nihilism on all aspects of personality development (its worldview, value orientations, legal behavior) is difficult to overestimate, as it is the foundation of the stability of a democratic state. It is determined that in order to preserve the democratic achievements of Ukrainian society currently and to ensure the sustainable development of the state after the termination of the martial law regime, it is extremely important to prevent the dominance of legal nihilism. It is established that the level of legal consciousness of Ukrainian society is negatively affected by a number of factors that have been active for a long time, and their characteristics are provided. Attention is focused on a group of factors that arose as a result of the full-scale aggression and are related to general tendencies of devaluation of non-coercive methods of resolving social conflicts. This is due both to the nihilistic policy of the Russian aggressor, which destroys international law, and to the extreme weakness of the international security architecture, which is incapable of restraining the aggressor through legal methods. The internal factors that also intensify the contempt for law in the context of a high-intensity armed conflict are characterized. The position is substantiated that a great role in preserving legal culture during the full-scale Russian armed aggression belongs to civil society and the scientific community, whose task is to provide objective feedback to government bodies regarding the compliance of their activities with the principle of the rule of law. It is determined that reducing the level of legal nihilism during the decision-making process by government bodies is one of the important tasks of public control over the legality of the functioning of the public administration system and the compliance of its decisions with the principle of the rule of law. Метою статті є визначення напрямів протидії правовому нігілізму й підвищення правової культури в умовах збройного конфлікту високої інтенсивності. Установлено, що на рівень правової свідомості українського суспільства негативно впливають чотири групи факторів, які діють протягом тривалого часу, та надано їх характеристику. Особливу увагу приділено факторам, пов’язаним з повномасштабною російською збройною агресією. Обґрунтовано, що велика роль у збереженні правової культури в умовах повномасштабної російської збройної агресії належить громадянському суспільству та науковій спільноті.

  • Open Access

    Improvement of the Military Ombudsman’s activity: experience of reviewing service complaints in the United Kingdom

    by I. M. Shopina

    The article characterizes the features of the experience of reviewing service complaints by the Service Complaints Ombudsman for the Armed Forces of the United Kingdom (SCOAF) and determines the expediency of certain aspects of this experience for the legal regulation of the Military Ombudsman’s activity in Ukraine. It is established that the British experience demonstrates a high degree of detail in the relations between SCOAF and the Defence Council, the Secretary of State, and other entities. Such detailed regulation acts as an effective guarantee of SCOAF’s legal status, as all situations typical for its activity are algorithmized, which minimizes the possibility of subjective factors influencing the processes of protecting servicemen’s rights. It is determined that the approach of tracking the implementation of every SCOAF recommendation deserves support and implementation. The paper positively evaluates the regulation of various SCOAF report types and the requirements for their structure and content, which unifies law enforcement practice and allows for comparing different periods of activity. Attention is drawn to the conferral upon SCOAF of powers identical to those of the High Court of the United Kingdom for the purposes of investigation, concerning the attendance and questioning of witnesses, and the submission of documents. It is found that the Law of Ukraine «On the Military Ombudsman» contains a large number of general provisions that do not correspond to the principles of legal certainty and do not create clear algorithms for the Ombudsman and heads of military command bodies when reviewing service complaints and making decisions based on their results. It is determined that the problem of the Ombudsman’s interaction with the National Security and Defence Council of Ukraine, as well as the role of this official in control measures carried out by the Office of the President of Ukraine within the Armed Forces of Ukraine, requires legal regulation. Emphasis is placed on the existence of a contradiction between the duty of law enforcement agencies to cooperate with the Military Ombudsman, providing him with access to materials and documents, and the norms of procedural legislation. The absence of a rule regarding the submission of reports by the Military Ombudsman based on the results of inspections is highlighted. It is concluded that the use of certain elements of the British model in national practice would make it possible to improve the quality of legal regulation in the studied field and strengthen the level of legal guarantees for the Military Ombudsman to exercise their powers.

  • Open Access

    DIRECTIONS FOR IMPROVING THE LEGAL REGULATION OF ALTERNATIVE NON-MILITARY SERVICE IN UKRAINE

    by I. Shopina

    The purpose of the article is to determine the directions for improving the legal regulation of alternative non-military service in Ukraine during Russia’s full-scale armed aggression. The article examines the legal problems arising in Ukraine due to gaps in the legal regulation of alternative non-military service. It is established that the judicial practice in this area is quite contradictory. Attention is focused on the provisions of the Amicus Curiae Brief on Alternative (Non-Military) Service of the European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice Commission), adopted at its 142nd Plenary Session on March 14–15, 2025. It is stated that the absence of legal liability for persons who are required to perform the investigated type of service significantly reduces the effectiveness of the legal mechanism for its performance. The establishment of different levels of fitness for alternative non-military service based on health status is proposed. It is concluded that the legal regulation of alternative non-military service in Ukraine during the martial law regime must be carried out in inseparable connection with ensuring national security. It is substantiated that the primary goal of introducing the constitutional military duty is first and foremost the protection of the lives of the citizens of our state, including those belonging to pacifist religious denominations. Therefore, in the new law on alternative military service, the necessity of which is conditioned by many factors, it is appropriate to create a model for replacing military service with alternative service that would allow for a proportional and fair distribution of the wartime burden between those who defend Ukraine with weapons in hand and those who have chosen alternative non-military service. It is argued that the terms of service (until the President of Ukraine announces demobilization), the possible increase in working hours, and legal liability for unauthorized abandonment of the place of service and for negligence should apply to both categories, which will take into account the Venice Commission’s position on the proportionality of state measures in the sphere under study. У статті розглянуто правові проблеми в Україні у зв’язку із прогалинами у правовому регулюванні альтернативної невійськової служби. Констатовано, що відсутність юридичної відповідальності осіб, які мають проходити досліджуваний вид служби, значно знижує ефективність правового механізму її проходження. Запропоновано визначення різних рівнів придатності за станом здоров’я до проходження альтернативної невійськової служби. Зроблено висновок, що правове регулювання проходження альтернативної невійськової служби в Україні під час дії правового режиму воєнного стану має здійснюватися в нерозривному зв’язку з гарантуванням національної безпеки.

  • Open Access

    Legal status of the Military Ombudsman

    by Iryna Shopina

    Стаття присвячена аналізу правового статусу Військового омбудсмана, визначеному Законом України від 17 вересня 2025 року № 4603-IX. Акцентовано увагу на тому, що повномасштабна російська збройна агресія спричинила суттєві зміни у секторі безпеки й оборони, зокрема зростання чисельності військовослужбовців, ускладнення ротації, підвищення фізичного та психологічного наван- таження на особовий склад, а також посилення інформаційно-психологічного тиску. Сукупність цих фак- торів вплинула на дотримання прав військовослужбовців і призвела до збільшення кількості звернень щодо порушення прав і свобод. У статті узагальнено наукові напрацювання, присвячені інституту військового омбудсмана, та під- креслюється, що більшість досліджень охоплювали період до ухвалення Закону України «Про Військо- вого омбудсмана». Обґрунтовано, що аналіз його положень виявив прогалини та суперечності, які пере- шкоджають ефективному функціонуванню досліджуваного інституту. Зокрема, закон містить розмиті формулювання щодо взаємодії Військового омбудсмана з іншими суб’єктами захисту прав військово- службовців, не визначає критеріїв і процедур призначення та звільнення цієї посадової особи, не вста- новлює вимог щодо юридичної освіти або досвіду правозахисної діяльності. Особливою проблемою є відсутність чітко визначених заходів юридичної відповідальності за невико- нання законних вимог омбудсмана, що нівелює його повноваження та перешкоджає реальному понов- ленню порушених прав військовослужбовців. Зроблено висновок, що стан захисту прав військовослужбовців у воюючій державі напряму впливає на морально-психологічний клімат військових підрозділів, виконання планів мобілізації та настрої в україн- ському суспільстві. Тому наділення Військового омбудсмана необхідними для виконання його обов’язків повноваженнями, а також встановлення кореспондуючих цим повноваженням обов’язків та відповідаль- ності інших осіб, є запорукою реального позитивного впливу на захист прав особового складу Збройних Сил України та інших військових формувань. Існуючі у правовому статусі Військового омбудсмана прога- лини та суперечності мають бути усунені, тоді діяльність цієї посадової особи зможе реально вплинути на стан дотримання прав військовослужбовців та збільшити ефективність процесів військового управління

  • Open Access

    Improvement of legislation on alternative non-military (civilian) service: the experience of Switzerland

    by I. M. Shоpina

    The purpose of the article is to identify current trends in the modification of the Swiss model of alternative civilian service in systemic connection with the reform of Ukrainian legislation on alternative non-military service. The historical aspects of the establishment of alternative civilian service in Switzerland are explored. Attention is focused on the provisions of the Federal Constitution of the Swiss Confederation, with particular attention paid to the provisions of the Federal Law on Civilian Service. It is established that civilian service operates in areas where resources are insufficient or absent for the performance of important community tasks. It serves civilian purposes and takes place outside the institutional framework of the army. The areas where civilian service can be performed, and the restrictions on its performance, are defined. The specific features of the amendments to the Federal Law on Civilian Service in 2025 are clarified. It is determined that the analysis of Switzerland’s experience in the legal regulation of alternative civilian service indicates a tendency to tighten the requirements for persons who can perform such service, reduce the grounds for its performance, and return the conscience assessment procedure abolished in 2009. At the same time, the goal of such legislative novelties is openly proclaimed as reducing the number of persons who can perform civilian service, diminishing its attractiveness, and thereby strengthening the state’s armed forces. Attention is focused on the fact that the parliamentary discussions were preceded by the preparation of analytical reports by government bodies, including military administration bodies. In the face of the existential threat posed by aggressive Russian policy to the entire European continent, such measures appear completely logical. It is concluded that the system of requirements for military service of a training nature in an economically developed state that has not engaged in hostilities on its territory for more than 300 years has its differences, which are inapplicable to the current situation in Ukraine (in particular, the duration of both military and alternative service, as well as the conditions for its performance). However, what may be useful for Ukraine is not the direct borrowing of legal norms, but attention to the procedures for amending military legislation, as well as their analytical and communication preparation, which can optimize the public perception of such changes.

  • Open Access

    Activity of executive authorities in the information sphere during the period of martial law: problems and prospects

    by I.M. Shopina

    The purpose of the article is to identify the problems arising in the activities of executive authorities in the information sphere during martial law and to outline ways for their resolution. The study identifies legal, organizational, and methodological problems characterizing the activity of executive authorities in the information sphere following the start of Russia’s full-scale armed aggression. To optimize the work of executive authorities in the information sphere during martial law, it is proposed to establish, at the legislative level, criteria and an exhaustive list of information rights and freedoms that may be restricted, taking into account the balance between national security needs and the requirements for transparency and openness of public information. It is ascertained that the information policy requires strengthened consistency, continuity, and focus, particularly through the renewal and adaptation of the Information Security Strategy to the realities of a prolonged, high- intensity armed conflict. The new edition of the Strategy should include the development of targeted programs for the informational support of Ukrainian citizens abroad with the aim of maintaining their connection with Ukraine and facilitating future return. It is argued that special attention must be paid to the informational support of Ukrainian citizens in the temporarily occupied territories. The issue of safe and interchangeable communication channels with them requires legal regulation, and an executive body must be designated to systematically inform Ukrainian citizens in the temporarily occupied territories about the safest evacuation routes. Special attention should also be given to activities aimed at counteracting the indoctrination of Ukrainian children and youth. The conclusion is drawn that preserving the democratic achievements of our state under the legal regime of martial law necessitates the compliance of executive authorities with the requirements for the disclosure of public information about their activities (provided it does not contradict national security requirements), as the regular updating of such information is a key source for ensuring public scrutiny and enhancing trust in the system of public administration.

  • Open Access

    Alternative (non-military) service: problems and prospects

    by I.M. Shopina

    The purpose of the article is to define the legal principles of alternative (non-military) service in the modern conditions of Russia’s full-scale armed aggression against Ukraine. The article clarifies what problems arise in the field of legal support for alternative (non-military) service during Russia’s full-scale armed aggression. The legal grounds for undergoing alternative service are analyzed. The conflict that arises between the religious beliefs of some citizens and the defense needs of the state under martial law is identified and analyzed. The need to harmonize national legislation on alternative non-military service with international standards established by the European Court of Human Rights, the Venice Commission, and the UN Human Rights Committee is examined. Particular attention is paid to the proportionality of the duration of alternative and military service, as well as overcoming discrimination against non-believers whose convictions also preclude the use of weapons. The problems of the lack of adequate legal responsibility for violating the procedure for alternative service and the outdated list of activities for its performance, which do not correspond to modern challenges and needs of society, are highlighted. It is stated that the existing legal mechanisms do not fully meet the needs of the martial law regime. Directions for legislative reform are proposed, including: establishing a balanced procedure for the exercise of the right to alternative non-military service; developing an updated list of activities taking into account the needs of a warring state; implementing effective mechanisms of responsibility that would be proportionate to the measures of responsibility for military personnel. It is emphasized that the normalization of these issues is important not only from a legal standpoint but also for supporting social harmony, strengthening trust in state institutions, and creating a new architecture of international security. It is stressed that changes in the legislation and practice of alternative service will have not only national but also universal civilizational value.