Dewi Sulistianingsih
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Dewi Sulistianingsih has a total of 107 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Martitah Martitah
Faculty of Law, Universitas Negeri Semarang, Indonesia
9 shared publications Pujiono Pujiono
Faculty of Law, Universitas Negeri Semarang
7 shared publications- Yuli Prasetyo Adhi
Faculty of Law, Universitas Diponegoro
7 shared publications - Rahmawati Mohd Yusoff
Department of Law, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM)
5 shared publications Rini Fidiyani
Faculty of Law, Universitas Negeri Semarang
4 shared publications- Mohammad Reza Fachruddin
Faculty of Law, Universitas Negeri Semarang
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 August 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Pandecta: Research Law Journal
- Vol. 21 (2) , 229-254
Personal Data Protection in the Digital Age: An Analysis of Constitutionalism in E-Commerce Towards Harmonization of Regulations
The advancement of the digital era has brought significant changes to trade activities, particularly in the shift from conventional trading systems to faster and more precise electronic commerce (e-commerce). The study has revealed this new information regarding personal data protection information. As a result, the national legal system must control the growth of e-commerce while adhering to the strictest constitutional law requirements. adhere to the strictest requirements of constitutional law while being governed by the national legal system. Law is essential to ensure that consumer rights are upheld and that businesses operate transparently and ethically. This balance will foster trust in e-commerce platforms and encourage their growth in a secure environment. This study uses normative juridical and conducts descriptive-analytical data analysis. It also uses theories, concepts, and principles of digital constitutionalism. This study aims to ascertain and evaluate the degree to which existing legislation offers legal certainty for safeguarding personal information in the context of online transactions. This study will look at current legal frameworks and how well they handle the problems brought on by the quick advancement of e-commerce technology. The results demonstrate that e-commerce rules are still dispersed throughout many laws and regulations, which raises questions about legal ambiguity and the security of personal information in e-commerce transactions. In order to resolve this difficulty and construct a cohesive and legally sound regulatory framework based on constitutionalism, a special statute that fully regulates electronic commerce must be established.
- 10 August 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Pandecta: Research Law Journal
- Vol. 21 (2) , 229-254
Open AccessPersonal Data Protection in the Digital Age: An Analysis of Constitutionalism in E-Commerce Towards Harmonization of Regulations
The advancement of the digital era has brought significant changes to trade activities, particularly in the shift from conventional trading systems to faster and more precise electronic commerce (e-commerce). The study has revealed this new information regarding personal data protection information. As a result, the national legal system must control the growth of e-commerce while adhering to the strictest constitutional law requirements. adhere to the strictest requirements of constitutional law while being governed by the national legal system. Law is essential to ensure that consumer rights are upheld and that businesses operate transparently and ethically. This balance will foster trust in e-commerce platforms and encourage their growth in a secure environment. This study uses normative juridical and conducts descriptive-analytical data analysis. It also uses theories, concepts, and principles of digital constitutionalism. This study aims to ascertain and evaluate the degree to which existing legislation offers legal certainty for safeguarding personal information in the context of online transactions. This study will look at current legal frameworks and how well they handle the problems brought on by the quick advancement of e-commerce technology. The results demonstrate that e-commerce rules are still dispersed throughout many laws and regulations, which raises questions about legal ambiguity and the security of personal information in e-commerce transactions. In order to resolve this difficulty and construct a cohesive and legally sound regulatory framework based on constitutionalism, a special statute that fully regulates electronic commerce must be established.
- Open Access
- 1 August 2026
- Published by Badan Penerbitan Universitas Widyagama Malang in Widya Yuridika
- Vol. 9 (2) , 365-373
Trump’s Tariff Policy According to The World Trade Organization (WTO) and Its Impact on Indonesia
On April 2nd, 2025, President Donald Trump implemented an import tariff policy of 32% on Indonesia, which then, on July 9th, 2025, decreased by 19% due to a negotiation meeting between representatives of Indonesia and representatives of the United States of America in Washington, District of Columbia (D.C.). This scientific article will discuss Trump’s Tariff policy, which violates the Most Favored Nation principle of the World Trade Organization (WTO), the impact of Trump’s Tariff policy, on Indonesia, and the author’s stance on Trump’s Tariff policy. This scientific article employs a normative juridical research method with the Most Favored Nations principle and The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT 1994) as primary legal materials and scientific articles, internet articles, and books as secondary legal materials. Trump’s Tariff Policy is considered to have violated the Most Favored Nations principle of the World Trade Organization (WTO), which stipulates that an international trade policy must be implemented in accordance with the principle of non-discrimination so that all countries in the world must be treated equally between one country and another. Furthermore, the impact of Trump’s tariff policy on Indonesia are as follows: the threat of losing all export trade activities in the footwear, electronics, furniture, and textile, and textile product sectors in the United States of America market. Furthermore, the author strongly disagrees with Trump’s tariff policy, as it is considered to violate the Most Favored Nation principle of the World Trade Organization (WTO).
- 1 August 2026
- Published by Badan Penerbitan Universitas Widyagama Malang in Widya Yuridika
- Vol. 9 (2) , 365-373
Open AccessTrump’s Tariff Policy According to The World Trade Organization (WTO) and Its Impact on Indonesia
On April 2nd, 2025, President Donald Trump implemented an import tariff policy of 32% on Indonesia, which then, on July 9th, 2025, decreased by 19% due to a negotiation meeting between representatives of Indonesia and representatives of the United States of America in Washington, District of Columbia (D.C.). This scientific article will discuss Trump’s Tariff policy, which violates the Most Favored Nation principle of the World Trade Organization (WTO), the impact of Trump’s Tariff policy, on Indonesia, and the author’s stance on Trump’s Tariff policy. This scientific article employs a normative juridical research method with the Most Favored Nations principle and The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT 1994) as primary legal materials and scientific articles, internet articles, and books as secondary legal materials. Trump’s Tariff Policy is considered to have violated the Most Favored Nations principle of the World Trade Organization (WTO), which stipulates that an international trade policy must be implemented in accordance with the principle of non-discrimination so that all countries in the world must be treated equally between one country and another. Furthermore, the impact of Trump’s tariff policy on Indonesia are as follows: the threat of losing all export trade activities in the footwear, electronics, furniture, and textile, and textile product sectors in the United States of America market. Furthermore, the author strongly disagrees with Trump’s tariff policy, as it is considered to violate the Most Favored Nation principle of the World Trade Organization (WTO).
- Open Access
- 23 July 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Indonesian Journal of Advocacy and Legal Services
- Vol. 8 (2) , 749-796
From Courtroom to Self-Decision: ADR as Mechanism for E-Commerce Consumer Protection in Nigeria and Indonesia
The expansion of digital commerce has transformed consumer transactions while generating new challenges for the protection and enforcement of consumer rights in online marketplaces. Conventional court litigation is often ill-suited to resolving e-commerce disputes due to its cost, procedural complexity, and limited accessibility, particularly for low-value consumer claims. This study examines the legal frameworks governing ADR as a mechanism for advancing consumer protection and improving access to justice in Nigeria and Indonesia. Employing a normative doctrinal legal research method with a qualitative approach, the study analyzes legislation, regulations, judicial decisions, policy documents, international legal instruments, and relevant literature. It evaluates how both jurisdictions incorporate ADR into their consumer protection regimes and assesses the extent to which their legal and institutional frameworks facilitate the resolution of e-commerce disputes. It demonstrates that Indonesia has established a more integrated legal framework by combining consumer protection, electronic transactions, and ADR legislation within a coordinated regulatory structure. By contrast, Nigeria provides statutory recognition for ADR through its consumer protection legislation, but the legal and institutional framework for resolving online consumer disputes remains comparatively fragmented. The study argues that ADR serves not only as a dispute resolution mechanism but also as an important instrument of consumer legal protection by enhancing access to justice, reducing procedural barriers, and strengthening consumer confidence in the digital economy. It concludes by recommending legal harmonization, stronger institutional coordination, and policy reforms to reinforce consumer protection and expand the role of ADR as an accessible legal service in the evolving digital marketplace.
- 23 July 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Indonesian Journal of Advocacy and Legal Services
- Vol. 8 (2) , 749-796
Open AccessFrom Courtroom to Self-Decision: ADR as Mechanism for E-Commerce Consumer Protection in Nigeria and Indonesia
The expansion of digital commerce has transformed consumer transactions while generating new challenges for the protection and enforcement of consumer rights in online marketplaces. Conventional court litigation is often ill-suited to resolving e-commerce disputes due to its cost, procedural complexity, and limited accessibility, particularly for low-value consumer claims. This study examines the legal frameworks governing ADR as a mechanism for advancing consumer protection and improving access to justice in Nigeria and Indonesia. Employing a normative doctrinal legal research method with a qualitative approach, the study analyzes legislation, regulations, judicial decisions, policy documents, international legal instruments, and relevant literature. It evaluates how both jurisdictions incorporate ADR into their consumer protection regimes and assesses the extent to which their legal and institutional frameworks facilitate the resolution of e-commerce disputes. It demonstrates that Indonesia has established a more integrated legal framework by combining consumer protection, electronic transactions, and ADR legislation within a coordinated regulatory structure. By contrast, Nigeria provides statutory recognition for ADR through its consumer protection legislation, but the legal and institutional framework for resolving online consumer disputes remains comparatively fragmented. The study argues that ADR serves not only as a dispute resolution mechanism but also as an important instrument of consumer legal protection by enhancing access to justice, reducing procedural barriers, and strengthening consumer confidence in the digital economy. It concludes by recommending legal harmonization, stronger institutional coordination, and policy reforms to reinforce consumer protection and expand the role of ADR as an accessible legal service in the evolving digital marketplace.
- Open Access
- 20 July 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in The Indonesian Journal of International Clinical Legal Education
- Vol. 8 (2) , 139-166
Traffic Regulation Dissemination by the Transportation Department to Reduce Accidents: A Legal-Political Perspective
This study examines the dissemination of traffic regulations by the Purbalingga Regency Transportation Agency as a legal-political strategy for enhancing public legal awareness and reducing traffic accidents. It addresses the limited scholarly attention given to legal dissemination as a preventive instrument of traffic governance, particularly within local government institutions. Employing a qualitative case study approach, the research draws on data obtained through semi-structured interviews with officials of the Transportation Agency, including the Head of the Transportation Division, the Head of the Traffic and Road Transportation Control and Enforcement Section, and technical staff, as well as public transportation users, including minibus, bus, and truck drivers. Documentary analysis was used to complement and triangulate the interview findings. The study identifies three principal findings. First, traffic regulation dissemination is implemented through a collaborative governance model based on the 3E principles, namely Engineering, Education, and Enforcement, involving the Transportation Agency, the Traffic Police, the Indonesian National Armed Forces, and the Public Order Agency. Second, legal awareness is promoted through direct educational activities and digital communication platforms, particularly social media, which broaden public access to traffic law information. Third, the effectiveness of dissemination efforts is constrained by structural limitations, including budgetary constraints and limited human resources, as well as cultural challenges reflected in the persistence of low levels of traffic discipline. The findings demonstrate that the effectiveness of legal dissemination depends not only on regulatory enforcement but also on sustained educational engagement between government institutions and the community. From a legal-political perspective, this study advances the understanding of law as a preventive and educative instrument that fosters compliance through legal consciousness rather than coercion alone. It recommends strengthening inter-agency collaboration, optimizing institutional resources, and expanding digital-based public legal education to improve the effectiveness of traffic governance at the local level.
- 20 July 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in The Indonesian Journal of International Clinical Legal Education
- Vol. 8 (2) , 139-166
Open AccessTraffic Regulation Dissemination by the Transportation Department to Reduce Accidents: A Legal-Political Perspective
This study examines the dissemination of traffic regulations by the Purbalingga Regency Transportation Agency as a legal-political strategy for enhancing public legal awareness and reducing traffic accidents. It addresses the limited scholarly attention given to legal dissemination as a preventive instrument of traffic governance, particularly within local government institutions. Employing a qualitative case study approach, the research draws on data obtained through semi-structured interviews with officials of the Transportation Agency, including the Head of the Transportation Division, the Head of the Traffic and Road Transportation Control and Enforcement Section, and technical staff, as well as public transportation users, including minibus, bus, and truck drivers. Documentary analysis was used to complement and triangulate the interview findings. The study identifies three principal findings. First, traffic regulation dissemination is implemented through a collaborative governance model based on the 3E principles, namely Engineering, Education, and Enforcement, involving the Transportation Agency, the Traffic Police, the Indonesian National Armed Forces, and the Public Order Agency. Second, legal awareness is promoted through direct educational activities and digital communication platforms, particularly social media, which broaden public access to traffic law information. Third, the effectiveness of dissemination efforts is constrained by structural limitations, including budgetary constraints and limited human resources, as well as cultural challenges reflected in the persistence of low levels of traffic discipline. The findings demonstrate that the effectiveness of legal dissemination depends not only on regulatory enforcement but also on sustained educational engagement between government institutions and the community. From a legal-political perspective, this study advances the understanding of law as a preventive and educative instrument that fosters compliance through legal consciousness rather than coercion alone. It recommends strengthening inter-agency collaboration, optimizing institutional resources, and expanding digital-based public legal education to improve the effectiveness of traffic governance at the local level.
- Open Access
- 14 June 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Indonesian Journal of Pancasila and Global Constitutionalism
- Vol. 5 (1) , 239-259
The Role of Students in Actualizing Pancasila Values to Prevent Intolerance and Discrimination in Higher Education
Universities should be safe spaces for the growth of diversity, but the reality on the ground shows a tendency towards exclusive and discriminatory attitudes among students. This often manifests as divisions based on ethnicity, religion, or political views, eroding the spirit of unity. This paper argues that Pancasila should not remain merely theoretical memorization but should be revitalized through everyday practices on campus. It explains how students can be at the forefront of mitigating potential conflicts. The discussion demonstrates that Pancasila values require critical awareness to reject radical narratives and build an inclusive culture. Students have a moral responsibility to translate Pancasila's principles into concrete actions, from classroom interactions to student organizations. Thus, the nation's noble values serve as a primary bulwark in maintaining academic and social integrity amidst the changing times.
- 14 June 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Indonesian Journal of Pancasila and Global Constitutionalism
- Vol. 5 (1) , 239-259
Open AccessThe Role of Students in Actualizing Pancasila Values to Prevent Intolerance and Discrimination in Higher Education
Universities should be safe spaces for the growth of diversity, but the reality on the ground shows a tendency towards exclusive and discriminatory attitudes among students. This often manifests as divisions based on ethnicity, religion, or political views, eroding the spirit of unity. This paper argues that Pancasila should not remain merely theoretical memorization but should be revitalized through everyday practices on campus. It explains how students can be at the forefront of mitigating potential conflicts. The discussion demonstrates that Pancasila values require critical awareness to reject radical narratives and build an inclusive culture. Students have a moral responsibility to translate Pancasila's principles into concrete actions, from classroom interactions to student organizations. Thus, the nation's noble values serve as a primary bulwark in maintaining academic and social integrity amidst the changing times.
- Open Access
- 10 June 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Pandecta: Research Law Journal
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-34
Building an Integrated Foreclosure Enforcement System in the Post-Auction Eviction Execution of Mortgage Rights
The post-auction eviction execution of Mortgage Rights objects constitutes a crucial stage in the enforcement of security rights because it determines the effectiveness of the auction winner’s physical possession of the property. However, the Indonesian civil procedural law system still separates auction proceedings and eviction execution into two distinct processes, resulting in procedural uncertainty, additional litigation, and obstacles to enforcement implementation. This study aims to analyze the normative weaknesses and practical problems in the implementation of post-auction eviction execution and to formulate a reform model through the concept of an Integrated Foreclosure Enforcement System. This research employs normative legal research methods using statutory, conceptual, case, and comparative approaches. Legal materials are analyzed qualitatively through systematic, historical, and teleological interpretation. The findings indicate that the use of HIR and RBg as the legal basis for eviction execution is no longer compatible with the needs of modern foreclosure enforcement because they fail to integrate auction proceedings, transfer of rights, and physical possession of the object into a unified enforcement mechanism. Furthermore, weak institutional coordination, the absence of limitations on procedural abuse, and social resistance also contribute to the ineffectiveness of post-auction eviction execution. Based on a comparative analysis with the Netherlands and South Korea, this study proposes the concept of an Integrated Foreclosure Enforcement System emphasizing procedural integration, strengthening enforcement institutions, digitalization of execution administration, limitations on obstructive lawsuits and derden verzet, and a human-rights-based enforcement approach. Such reforms are necessary to establish a foreclosure enforcement system that is effective, certain, equitable, and supportive of the modernization of Indonesian civil procedural law.
- 10 June 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Pandecta: Research Law Journal
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-34
Open AccessBuilding an Integrated Foreclosure Enforcement System in the Post-Auction Eviction Execution of Mortgage Rights
The post-auction eviction execution of Mortgage Rights objects constitutes a crucial stage in the enforcement of security rights because it determines the effectiveness of the auction winner’s physical possession of the property. However, the Indonesian civil procedural law system still separates auction proceedings and eviction execution into two distinct processes, resulting in procedural uncertainty, additional litigation, and obstacles to enforcement implementation. This study aims to analyze the normative weaknesses and practical problems in the implementation of post-auction eviction execution and to formulate a reform model through the concept of an Integrated Foreclosure Enforcement System. This research employs normative legal research methods using statutory, conceptual, case, and comparative approaches. Legal materials are analyzed qualitatively through systematic, historical, and teleological interpretation. The findings indicate that the use of HIR and RBg as the legal basis for eviction execution is no longer compatible with the needs of modern foreclosure enforcement because they fail to integrate auction proceedings, transfer of rights, and physical possession of the object into a unified enforcement mechanism. Furthermore, weak institutional coordination, the absence of limitations on procedural abuse, and social resistance also contribute to the ineffectiveness of post-auction eviction execution. Based on a comparative analysis with the Netherlands and South Korea, this study proposes the concept of an Integrated Foreclosure Enforcement System emphasizing procedural integration, strengthening enforcement institutions, digitalization of execution administration, limitations on obstructive lawsuits and derden verzet, and a human-rights-based enforcement approach. Such reforms are necessary to establish a foreclosure enforcement system that is effective, certain, equitable, and supportive of the modernization of Indonesian civil procedural law.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Journal of Private and Commercial Law
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-41
Why Hasn't Indonesia Ratified The Hague System? What's The Problem?
Despite its membership in key international intellectual property (IP) agreements, Indonesia has not yet acceded to the Hague System for the International Registration of Industrial Designs. This article employs a doctrinal, principle-based legal analysis to examine the alignment of Indonesia’s industrial design regime, particularly Law No. 31 of 2000, with international standards under the TRIPS Agreement, the Paris Convention, and the Geneva Act of 1999. The study analyses statutory provisions, international instruments, and case law, and is complemented by a comparative overview of jurisdictions such as Japan, Singapore, the Republic of Korea, and Viet Nam that have already joined the Hague System. The findings reveal persistent structural issues in the Indonesian framework, including ambiguity in the novelty requirement, overlapping protection between industrial designs, copyright, and three-dimensional trademarks, as well as limited substantive examination and territorial fragmentation of protection. These legal and administrative constraints hinder the effective use of an international registration system, even though the Hague System offers procedural efficiency, cost reduction, and broader market access for designers. The article argues that targeted legislative reform and regulatory harmonization are essential preconditions for accession and contends that such reforms would enhance legal certainty, strengthen design protection, and improve Indonesia’s competitiveness in the global creative economy.
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Journal of Private and Commercial Law
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-41
Open AccessWhy Hasn't Indonesia Ratified The Hague System? What's The Problem?
Despite its membership in key international intellectual property (IP) agreements, Indonesia has not yet acceded to the Hague System for the International Registration of Industrial Designs. This article employs a doctrinal, principle-based legal analysis to examine the alignment of Indonesia’s industrial design regime, particularly Law No. 31 of 2000, with international standards under the TRIPS Agreement, the Paris Convention, and the Geneva Act of 1999. The study analyses statutory provisions, international instruments, and case law, and is complemented by a comparative overview of jurisdictions such as Japan, Singapore, the Republic of Korea, and Viet Nam that have already joined the Hague System. The findings reveal persistent structural issues in the Indonesian framework, including ambiguity in the novelty requirement, overlapping protection between industrial designs, copyright, and three-dimensional trademarks, as well as limited substantive examination and territorial fragmentation of protection. These legal and administrative constraints hinder the effective use of an international registration system, even though the Hague System offers procedural efficiency, cost reduction, and broader market access for designers. The article argues that targeted legislative reform and regulatory harmonization are essential preconditions for accession and contends that such reforms would enhance legal certainty, strengthen design protection, and improve Indonesia’s competitiveness in the global creative economy.
- Open Access
- 7 May 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Lex Scientia Law Review
- Vol. 10 (1) , 137-172
Reconstruction of the Legal Framework for Consumer Protection in ESG-Based Digital Investment and Blockchain Technology: A Legal Study
This study analyzes the regulatory framework for consumer protection in digital investment based on ESG principles and blockchain technology in Indonesia. The method used is juridical-normative with a statutory, conceptual, and comparative approach. The results of the study indicate a significant regulatory gap, including the non-recognition of the legality of smart contracts, the absence of a digital ESG claim verification mechanism, the absence of a blockchain-based dispute resolution model, and the fragmentation of supervision coordination between national authorities. As a contribution, this study offers a new legal framework model that integrates the recognition of smart contracts, the establishment of a digital ESG verification institution, the development of blockchain-based ADR, and regulatory harmonization. This innovation is expected to strengthen consumer protection in the sustainable investment ecosystem based on blockchain technology. In practice, this study recommends the formulation of the Digital and ESG Consumer Protection Law, the establishment of an independent ESG verification institution, and strengthening regulatory coordination in Indonesia. The novelty of this article is its focus on three areas of analysis: ESG, blockchain, and consumer protection. All three are analyzed from a legal perspective. The limitation of this study is the absence of empirical data; future research is recommended to use a quantitative or mix-method approach to evaluate consumer behavior in the ESG blockchain platform.
- 7 May 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Lex Scientia Law Review
- Vol. 10 (1) , 137-172
Open AccessReconstruction of the Legal Framework for Consumer Protection in ESG-Based Digital Investment and Blockchain Technology: A Legal Study
This study analyzes the regulatory framework for consumer protection in digital investment based on ESG principles and blockchain technology in Indonesia. The method used is juridical-normative with a statutory, conceptual, and comparative approach. The results of the study indicate a significant regulatory gap, including the non-recognition of the legality of smart contracts, the absence of a digital ESG claim verification mechanism, the absence of a blockchain-based dispute resolution model, and the fragmentation of supervision coordination between national authorities. As a contribution, this study offers a new legal framework model that integrates the recognition of smart contracts, the establishment of a digital ESG verification institution, the development of blockchain-based ADR, and regulatory harmonization. This innovation is expected to strengthen consumer protection in the sustainable investment ecosystem based on blockchain technology. In practice, this study recommends the formulation of the Digital and ESG Consumer Protection Law, the establishment of an independent ESG verification institution, and strengthening regulatory coordination in Indonesia. The novelty of this article is its focus on three areas of analysis: ESG, blockchain, and consumer protection. All three are analyzed from a legal perspective. The limitation of this study is the absence of empirical data; future research is recommended to use a quantitative or mix-method approach to evaluate consumer behavior in the ESG blockchain platform.
- Open Access
- 12 April 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in The Indonesian Journal of International Clinical Legal Education
- Vol. 8 (1) , 111-138
The Dynamics of Secondary Rules in Constitutional Adjudication: An Analysis of H.L.A. Hart’s Theory on Indonesia’s Constitutional Court Decision Number 90/PUU-XXI/2023
This study aims to examine the constitutional validity and theoretical implications of Constitutional Court Decision Number 90/PUU-XXI/2023 concerning the age limit for presidential and vice-presidential candidates in Indonesia. The main issues raised are the inconsistency of legal reasoning and the shift in the role of the Constitutional Court, which acts as a positive legislator, triggering a substantive legitimacy crisis behind formal validity. The research method employed is a juridical-normative approach with a qualitative doctrinal orientation. The analysis was conducted using H.L.A. Hart’s theoretical instrument regarding the dual rule system to dissect the relationship between primary and secondary rules. The research findings indicate that procedurally, the decision is a valid application of the rule of adjudication and the rule of change, as it is sourced from the highest rule of recognition, namely the 1945 Constitution. However, a substantial rift exists between the internal aspects of legal authority and the external aspects of public acceptance due to the open-ended nature of the legal language used by the judge. This study concludes that although the decision has binding legal force, this phenomenon indicates an expansion of secondary authority that can threaten legal certainty if not limited by objective parameters. The results of this study contribute to clinical legal education by enhancing understanding of the dynamics of norm change through judicial channels during the democratic transition process.
- 12 April 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in The Indonesian Journal of International Clinical Legal Education
- Vol. 8 (1) , 111-138
Open AccessThe Dynamics of Secondary Rules in Constitutional Adjudication: An Analysis of H.L.A. Hart’s Theory on Indonesia’s Constitutional Court Decision Number 90/PUU-XXI/2023
This study aims to examine the constitutional validity and theoretical implications of Constitutional Court Decision Number 90/PUU-XXI/2023 concerning the age limit for presidential and vice-presidential candidates in Indonesia. The main issues raised are the inconsistency of legal reasoning and the shift in the role of the Constitutional Court, which acts as a positive legislator, triggering a substantive legitimacy crisis behind formal validity. The research method employed is a juridical-normative approach with a qualitative doctrinal orientation. The analysis was conducted using H.L.A. Hart’s theoretical instrument regarding the dual rule system to dissect the relationship between primary and secondary rules. The research findings indicate that procedurally, the decision is a valid application of the rule of adjudication and the rule of change, as it is sourced from the highest rule of recognition, namely the 1945 Constitution. However, a substantial rift exists between the internal aspects of legal authority and the external aspects of public acceptance due to the open-ended nature of the legal language used by the judge. This study concludes that although the decision has binding legal force, this phenomenon indicates an expansion of secondary authority that can threaten legal certainty if not limited by objective parameters. The results of this study contribute to clinical legal education by enhancing understanding of the dynamics of norm change through judicial channels during the democratic transition process.
- Open Access
- 12 April 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in The Indonesian Journal of International Clinical Legal Education
- Vol. 8 (1) , 1-26
Muhammadiyah as an Agent of Social Engineering in Perspective of Development Law Theory
The existence of Muhammadiyah as Indonesia’s largest socio-religious organization has evolved from a religious purification movement into a comprehensive legal reform force that aligns with national development. This study aims to analyzes Muhammadiyah’s role through the lens of Mochtar Kusumaatmadja’s Theory of Developmental Law, which positions law as a "tool of social engineering" to steer societal change toward modernization. Using a normative-empirical legal research method with a qualitative approach, this study examines how Muhammadiyah bridges the gap between formal regulations (law in books) and social reality (law in action). The analysis focuses on three primary pillars: Social Engineering: Through the Majelis Tarjih dan Tajdid, Muhammadiyah transforms traditional mindsets into modern, rational, and law-conscious behavior by issuing responsive fatwas that regulate social interactions (muamalah). Legal Culture: In accordance with Lawrence M. Friedman’s theory, Muhammadiyah internalizes values of discipline, integrity, and legal literacy through its vast network of thousands of educational and health institutions (AUM). Welfare State & Constitutional Jihad: The organization acts as a strategic partner to the state by providing inclusive public services and conducting "Constitutional Jihad" through judicial reviews to ensure national laws remain aligned with public interest and social justice. The study concludes that Muhammadiyah's concept of Darul Ahdi wa Syahadah provides a theological and ethical foundation for viewing the state as a field of service. This synergy between socio-religious movements and developmental law creates a sustainable model for inclusive national legal development in Indonesia.
- 12 April 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in The Indonesian Journal of International Clinical Legal Education
- Vol. 8 (1) , 1-26
Open AccessMuhammadiyah as an Agent of Social Engineering in Perspective of Development Law Theory
The existence of Muhammadiyah as Indonesia’s largest socio-religious organization has evolved from a religious purification movement into a comprehensive legal reform force that aligns with national development. This study aims to analyzes Muhammadiyah’s role through the lens of Mochtar Kusumaatmadja’s Theory of Developmental Law, which positions law as a "tool of social engineering" to steer societal change toward modernization. Using a normative-empirical legal research method with a qualitative approach, this study examines how Muhammadiyah bridges the gap between formal regulations (law in books) and social reality (law in action). The analysis focuses on three primary pillars: Social Engineering: Through the Majelis Tarjih dan Tajdid, Muhammadiyah transforms traditional mindsets into modern, rational, and law-conscious behavior by issuing responsive fatwas that regulate social interactions (muamalah). Legal Culture: In accordance with Lawrence M. Friedman’s theory, Muhammadiyah internalizes values of discipline, integrity, and legal literacy through its vast network of thousands of educational and health institutions (AUM). Welfare State & Constitutional Jihad: The organization acts as a strategic partner to the state by providing inclusive public services and conducting "Constitutional Jihad" through judicial reviews to ensure national laws remain aligned with public interest and social justice. The study concludes that Muhammadiyah's concept of Darul Ahdi wa Syahadah provides a theological and ethical foundation for viewing the state as a field of service. This synergy between socio-religious movements and developmental law creates a sustainable model for inclusive national legal development in Indonesia.