Jonathan K. P. Shonk
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Jonathan K. P. Shonk has a total of 87 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Robin James Hogan
European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts, Reading, UK
5 shared publications Thomas Toniazzo
NORCE Climate, NORCE Norwegian Research Centre AS, Bergen, Norway
4 shared publications- Gerald G. Mace
Department of Atmospheric Science, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, 84112, USA
3 shared publications - Laura J. Wilcox
National Centre for Atmospheric Science University of Reading Reading UK
3 shared publications Alexander Marshak
NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Maryland, USA
2 shared publications- Amulya Chevuturi
UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, Benson Lane, Crowmarsh Gifford, Wallingford, OX10 8BB, UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 3 November 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research: Climate
- Vol. 5 (4) , 045021
Distinct climate responses to regional aerosol reductions: an overview of the regional aerosol model intercomparison project
Changes in emissions of anthropogenic aerosols and their precursors made strong contributions to trends in global and regional climate over the historical era. Further strong and rapid changes are either underway or anticipated, and are expected to continue to influence global and regional climate in the coming decades. However, large uncertainties in both emission pathways and climate responses make anthropogenic aerosols a key factor in the spread of near-term climate projections, especially on regional scales. The regional aerosol model intercomparison project (RAMIP) is designed to quantify the climate and air quality impacts of feasible near-future changes in anthropogenic aerosol emissions, providing information that can directly link regional climate policies to regional climate change. We present high-level results from Phase 1 of RAMIP, documenting climate responses to regional aerosol perturbations in 10 CMIP6 generation Earth System Models. If aerosol emissions are reduced globally, following SSP1-2.6 instead of remaining high under SSP3-7.0, it results in effective radiative forcing of 0.71 ± 0.27 W m − 2 in 2050, and a 0.31 ± 0.12 K increase in global-mean annual-mean temperature. Warming occurs largely over the Northern Hemisphere, causing a northward shift of the Intertropical Convergence Zone and intensifying the Northern Hemisphere monsoons. RAMIP reveals distinct spatial patterns in the climate response to regional aerosol reductions. Reductions over North America and East Asia have hemisphere-wide impacts, accounting for most of the global-mean response. South Asian reductions have a predominantly local impact, while reductions over Africa and the Middle East have significant impacts on precipitation throughout the tropics. The regional experiments also reveal that regional climate can be as strongly influenced by remote emission reductions as those made locally. These results highlight a need to consider local and external policies when designing adaptation plans, and motivate work to better represent spatial responses aerosol in regional climate models, emulators, and impact models.
- 3 November 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research: Climate
- Vol. 5 (4) , 045021
Open AccessDistinct climate responses to regional aerosol reductions: an overview of the regional aerosol model intercomparison project
Changes in emissions of anthropogenic aerosols and their precursors made strong contributions to trends in global and regional climate over the historical era. Further strong and rapid changes are either underway or anticipated, and are expected to continue to influence global and regional climate in the coming decades. However, large uncertainties in both emission pathways and climate responses make anthropogenic aerosols a key factor in the spread of near-term climate projections, especially on regional scales. The regional aerosol model intercomparison project (RAMIP) is designed to quantify the climate and air quality impacts of feasible near-future changes in anthropogenic aerosol emissions, providing information that can directly link regional climate policies to regional climate change. We present high-level results from Phase 1 of RAMIP, documenting climate responses to regional aerosol perturbations in 10 CMIP6 generation Earth System Models. If aerosol emissions are reduced globally, following SSP1-2.6 instead of remaining high under SSP3-7.0, it results in effective radiative forcing of 0.71 ± 0.27 W m − 2 in 2050, and a 0.31 ± 0.12 K increase in global-mean annual-mean temperature. Warming occurs largely over the Northern Hemisphere, causing a northward shift of the Intertropical Convergence Zone and intensifying the Northern Hemisphere monsoons. RAMIP reveals distinct spatial patterns in the climate response to regional aerosol reductions. Reductions over North America and East Asia have hemisphere-wide impacts, accounting for most of the global-mean response. South Asian reductions have a predominantly local impact, while reductions over Africa and the Middle East have significant impacts on precipitation throughout the tropics. The regional experiments also reveal that regional climate can be as strongly influenced by remote emission reductions as those made locally. These results highlight a need to consider local and external policies when designing adaptation plans, and motivate work to better represent spatial responses aerosol in regional climate models, emulators, and impact models.
- Open Access
- 25 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 152 (776)
UCanWBGT: urban street canyon heat stress calculation for weather and climate models
We present UCanWBGT, a heat stress model for estimating wet‐bulb globe temperature (WBGT) in an infinitely long street canyon. Radiative transfer within the canyon is calculated analytically from downward fluxes and surface temperature to determine the mean radiant temperature for a black globe. In combination with a standard set of meteorological fields, WBGT is determined via an empirical equation, resulting in a computationally efficient approach suitable for inclusion in numerical weather prediction (NWP) and climate models. For validation, we apply UCanWBGT to high‐resolution NWP output over Paris during a heatwave event and compare this with WBGT values derived from black‐globe thermometer observations made in street canyons during the PANAME project. UCanWBGT performs well, capturing daily variations in WBGT and representing transitions between sunlit and shaded conditions. Discrepancies are linked to forecast errors in meteorological fields and assumptions associated with the street canyon. Sensitivity tests reveal that modifying the canyon geometry affects the degree (and timing) of shading experienced in the canyon, and neglecting the urban geometry (representing it as a flat plane) eliminates the representation of daytime shading and reduces WBGT enhancement via reflections within the canyon. WBGT is also highly sensitive to meteorological fields, particularly temperature and humidity, although less so to the albedo and emissivity of the canyon facets. We conclude by demonstrating a practical application of UCanWBGT. Using NWP simulations for August 10, 2024, we estimate WBGT along the marathon route at the 2024 Paris Olympics and, using published safety thresholds, identify timing and routing strategies that minimise heat‐stress risks for athletes. We identify a period of high risk through the middle of the day, noting that the event would best be scheduled outside this period. Also, for daytime events, increased routing through urban areas and forest roads reduces risk, while for nighttime events rural areas are preferable.
- 25 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 152 (776)
Open AccessUCanWBGT: urban street canyon heat stress calculation for weather and climate models
We present UCanWBGT, a heat stress model for estimating wet‐bulb globe temperature (WBGT) in an infinitely long street canyon. Radiative transfer within the canyon is calculated analytically from downward fluxes and surface temperature to determine the mean radiant temperature for a black globe. In combination with a standard set of meteorological fields, WBGT is determined via an empirical equation, resulting in a computationally efficient approach suitable for inclusion in numerical weather prediction (NWP) and climate models. For validation, we apply UCanWBGT to high‐resolution NWP output over Paris during a heatwave event and compare this with WBGT values derived from black‐globe thermometer observations made in street canyons during the PANAME project. UCanWBGT performs well, capturing daily variations in WBGT and representing transitions between sunlit and shaded conditions. Discrepancies are linked to forecast errors in meteorological fields and assumptions associated with the street canyon. Sensitivity tests reveal that modifying the canyon geometry affects the degree (and timing) of shading experienced in the canyon, and neglecting the urban geometry (representing it as a flat plane) eliminates the representation of daytime shading and reduces WBGT enhancement via reflections within the canyon. WBGT is also highly sensitive to meteorological fields, particularly temperature and humidity, although less so to the albedo and emissivity of the canyon facets. We conclude by demonstrating a practical application of UCanWBGT. Using NWP simulations for August 10, 2024, we estimate WBGT along the marathon route at the 2024 Paris Olympics and, using published safety thresholds, identify timing and routing strategies that minimise heat‐stress risks for athletes. We identify a period of high risk through the middle of the day, noting that the event would best be scheduled outside this period. Also, for daytime events, increased routing through urban areas and forest roads reduces risk, while for nighttime events rural areas are preferable.
- Open Access
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Building and Environment
- Vol. 275
Microscale to neighbourhood scale: Impact of shading on urban climate
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Building and Environment
- Vol. 275
Open AccessMicroscale to neighbourhood scale: Impact of shading on urban climate
- Open Access
- 12 March 2024
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 150 (760) , 1771-1790
Utility of thermal remote sensing for evaluation of a high‐resolution weather model in a city
Progress in high‐resolution numerical weather prediction (NWP) for urban areas will require new modelling approaches and extensive evaluation. Here, we exploit land surface temperature (LST) data from Landsat‐8 to assess 100 m resolution NWP for London (UK) on four cloud‐free days. The LST observations are directional radiometric temperatures with non‐negligible uncertainties. We consider the challenges of informative comparison between the Landsat LST and the NWP scheme's internal characterisation of the complete surface temperature. The LST spatial coverage allows large‐scale observation–model differences to be explored. In one case, obvious spatial artifacts in the NWP surface temperature are observed relative to the Landsat LST. These are found to be related to the NWP's initial method of downscaling of soil moisture using soil properties. Updated model runs have higher spatial correlation between model and Landsat LST. In cases where meteorological conditions favour the formation of horizontal convective rolls, warmer air temperatures associated with updraughts in the mixed layer extend inappropriately to the urban surface. This manifests as warm stripes in the model surface temperature that are not present in the Landsat LST. NWP–Landsat LST differences are larger in more built‐up areas on days nearer summer solstice. This is largely attributed to urban thermal anisotropy, as Landsat preferentially views warmer urban surfaces, whereas the model LST represents all surfaces. We evaluate two approaches to quantify this sampling effect, but further work is needed to fully constrain it and facilitate more informative model evaluation.
- 12 March 2024
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 150 (760) , 1771-1790
Open AccessUtility of thermal remote sensing for evaluation of a high‐resolution weather model in a city
Progress in high‐resolution numerical weather prediction (NWP) for urban areas will require new modelling approaches and extensive evaluation. Here, we exploit land surface temperature (LST) data from Landsat‐8 to assess 100 m resolution NWP for London (UK) on four cloud‐free days. The LST observations are directional radiometric temperatures with non‐negligible uncertainties. We consider the challenges of informative comparison between the Landsat LST and the NWP scheme's internal characterisation of the complete surface temperature. The LST spatial coverage allows large‐scale observation–model differences to be explored. In one case, obvious spatial artifacts in the NWP surface temperature are observed relative to the Landsat LST. These are found to be related to the NWP's initial method of downscaling of soil moisture using soil properties. Updated model runs have higher spatial correlation between model and Landsat LST. In cases where meteorological conditions favour the formation of horizontal convective rolls, warmer air temperatures associated with updraughts in the mixed layer extend inappropriately to the urban surface. This manifests as warm stripes in the model surface temperature that are not present in the Landsat LST. NWP–Landsat LST differences are larger in more built‐up areas on days nearer summer solstice. This is largely attributed to urban thermal anisotropy, as Landsat preferentially views warmer urban surfaces, whereas the model LST represents all surfaces. We evaluate two approaches to quantify this sampling effect, but further work is needed to fully constrain it and facilitate more informative model evaluation.
- Open Access
- 29 November 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 50 (23)
The Indian Easterly Jet During the Pre‐Monsoon Season in India
We identify for the first time an Indian Easterly Jet (IEJ) in the mid‐troposphere during the pre‐monsoon using reanalysis data. The IEJ is weaker and smaller than the African Easterly Jet over West Africa, with a climatological location of 10°N, 60–90°E, 700 hPa, and strength 6–7 m s−1 during March–May. The IEJ is a thermal wind associated with low‐level meridional gradients in temperature (positive) and moisture (negative), resulting from equatorward moist convection and poleward dry convection. The IEJ is associated with a negative meridional potential vorticity gradient, therefore satisfying the Charney‐Stern necessary condition for instability. However, no wave activity is detected, suggesting that the potential for combined barotropic‐baroclinic instability is not often realized. IEJ strong (weak) years feature increased (reduced) near‐surface temperatures and drier (wetter) conditions over India. This study provides an introduction to the IEJ's role in pre‐monsoon dynamics, and a platform for further research.
- 29 November 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 50 (23)
Open AccessThe Indian Easterly Jet During the Pre‐Monsoon Season in India
We identify for the first time an Indian Easterly Jet (IEJ) in the mid‐troposphere during the pre‐monsoon using reanalysis data. The IEJ is weaker and smaller than the African Easterly Jet over West Africa, with a climatological location of 10°N, 60–90°E, 700 hPa, and strength 6–7 m s−1 during March–May. The IEJ is a thermal wind associated with low‐level meridional gradients in temperature (positive) and moisture (negative), resulting from equatorward moist convection and poleward dry convection. The IEJ is associated with a negative meridional potential vorticity gradient, therefore satisfying the Charney‐Stern necessary condition for instability. However, no wave activity is detected, suggesting that the potential for combined barotropic‐baroclinic instability is not often realized. IEJ strong (weak) years feature increased (reduced) near‐surface temperatures and drier (wetter) conditions over India. This study provides an introduction to the IEJ's role in pre‐monsoon dynamics, and a platform for further research.
- Open Access
- 12 October 2020
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Supplementary material to "Future changes in Beijing haze events under different anthropogenic aerosol emission scenarios"
- 12 October 2020
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSupplementary material to "Future changes in Beijing haze events under different anthropogenic aerosol emission scenarios"
- Open Access
- 28 November 2019
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Uncertainty in aerosol radiative forcing impacts the simulated global monsoon in the 20th century
Anthropogenic aerosols are dominant drivers of historical monsoon rainfall change. However, large uncertainties in the radiative forcing associated with anthropogenic aerosol emissions, and the dynamical response to this forcing, lead to uncertainty in the simulated monsoon response. We use historical simulations in which aerosol emissions are scaled by factors from 0.2 to 1.5 to explore the monsoon sensitivity to aerosol forcing uncertainty (−0.3 W m to −1.6 W m). Hemispheric asymmetry in emissions generates a strong relationship between scaling factor and both hemispheric temperature contrast and meridional location of tropical rainfall. Increasing the scaling from 0.2 to 1.5 reduces the global monsoon area by 3% and the global monsoon intensity by 2% over 1950–2014, and changes the dominant influence on the 1950–1980 monsoon rainfall trend from greenhouse gas to aerosol. Regionally, aerosol scaling has a pronounced effect on Northern Hemisphere monsoon rainfall.
- 28 November 2019
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Open AccessUncertainty in aerosol radiative forcing impacts the simulated global monsoon in the 20th century
Anthropogenic aerosols are dominant drivers of historical monsoon rainfall change. However, large uncertainties in the radiative forcing associated with anthropogenic aerosol emissions, and the dynamical response to this forcing, lead to uncertainty in the simulated monsoon response. We use historical simulations in which aerosol emissions are scaled by factors from 0.2 to 1.5 to explore the monsoon sensitivity to aerosol forcing uncertainty (−0.3 W m to −1.6 W m). Hemispheric asymmetry in emissions generates a strong relationship between scaling factor and both hemispheric temperature contrast and meridional location of tropical rainfall. Increasing the scaling from 0.2 to 1.5 reduces the global monsoon area by 3% and the global monsoon intensity by 2% over 1950–2014, and changes the dominant influence on the 1950–1980 monsoon rainfall trend from greenhouse gas to aerosol. Regionally, aerosol scaling has a pronounced effect on Northern Hemisphere monsoon rainfall.
- Open Access
- 23 September 2019
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 12 (9) , 5087-5099
The impact of neglecting ice phase on cloud optical depth retrievals from AERONET cloud mode observations
Clouds present many challenges to climate modelling. To develop and verify the parameterisations needed to allow climate models to represent cloud structure and processes, there is a need for high-quality observations of cloud optical depth from locations around the world. Retrievals of cloud optical depth are obtainable from radiances measured by Aerosol Robotic Network (AERONET) radiometers in “cloud mode” using a two-wavelength retrieval method. However, the method is unable to detect cloud phase, and hence assumes that all of the cloud in a profile is liquid. This assumption has the potential to introduce errors into long-term statistics of retrieved optical depth for clouds that also contain ice. Using a set of idealised cloud profiles we find that, for optical depths above 20, the fractional error in retrieved optical depth is a linear function of the fraction of the optical depth that is due to the presence of ice cloud (“ice fraction”). Clouds that are entirely ice have positive errors with magnitudes of the order of 55 % to 70 %. We derive a simple linear equation that can be used as a correction at AERONET sites where ice fraction can be independently estimated. Using this linear equation, we estimate the magnitude of the error for a set of cloud profiles from five sites of the Atmospheric Radiation Measurement programme. The dataset contains separate retrievals of ice and liquid retrievals; hence ice fraction can be estimated. The magnitude of the error at each location was related to the relative frequencies of occurrence in thick frontal cloud at the mid-latitude sites and of deep convection at the tropical sites – that is, of deep cloud containing both ice and liquid particles. The long-term mean optical depth error at the five locations spans the range 2–4, which we show to be small enough to allow calculation of top-of-atmosphere flux to within 10 % and surface flux to about 15 %.
- 23 September 2019
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 12 (9) , 5087-5099
Open AccessThe impact of neglecting ice phase on cloud optical depth retrievals from AERONET cloud mode observations
Clouds present many challenges to climate modelling. To develop and verify the parameterisations needed to allow climate models to represent cloud structure and processes, there is a need for high-quality observations of cloud optical depth from locations around the world. Retrievals of cloud optical depth are obtainable from radiances measured by Aerosol Robotic Network (AERONET) radiometers in “cloud mode” using a two-wavelength retrieval method. However, the method is unable to detect cloud phase, and hence assumes that all of the cloud in a profile is liquid. This assumption has the potential to introduce errors into long-term statistics of retrieved optical depth for clouds that also contain ice. Using a set of idealised cloud profiles we find that, for optical depths above 20, the fractional error in retrieved optical depth is a linear function of the fraction of the optical depth that is due to the presence of ice cloud (“ice fraction”). Clouds that are entirely ice have positive errors with magnitudes of the order of 55 % to 70 %. We derive a simple linear equation that can be used as a correction at AERONET sites where ice fraction can be independently estimated. Using this linear equation, we estimate the magnitude of the error for a set of cloud profiles from five sites of the Atmospheric Radiation Measurement programme. The dataset contains separate retrievals of ice and liquid retrievals; hence ice fraction can be estimated. The magnitude of the error at each location was related to the relative frequencies of occurrence in thick frontal cloud at the mid-latitude sites and of deep convection at the tropical sites – that is, of deep cloud containing both ice and liquid particles. The long-term mean optical depth error at the five locations spans the range 2–4, which we show to be small enough to allow calculation of top-of-atmosphere flux to within 10 % and surface flux to about 15 %.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2019
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 19 (17) , 11383-11399
A double ITCZ phenomenology of wind errors in the equatorial Atlantic in seasonal forecasts with ECMWF models
Modern coupled general circulation models produce systematic biases in the tropical Atlantic that hamper the reliability of long-range predictions. This study focuses on a common springtime westerly wind bias in the equatorial Atlantic in seasonal hindcasts from two coupled models – ECMWF System 4 and EC-Earth v2.3 – and in hindcasts also based on System 4, but with prescribed sea-surface temperatures. The development of the equatorial westerly bias in early April is marked by a rapid transition from a wintertime easterly, cold tongue bias to a springtime westerly bias regime that displays a marked double intertropical convergence zone (ITCZ). The transition is a seasonal feature of the model climatology (independent of initialisation date) and is associated with a seasonal increase in rainfall where a second branch of the ITCZ is produced south of the Equator. Excess off-equatorial convergence redirects the trade winds away from the Equator. Based on arguments of temporal coincidence, the results of our analysis contrast with those from previous work, and alleged causes hereto identified as the likely cause of the equatorial westerly bias in other models must be discarded. Quite in general, we find no evidence of remote influences on the development of the springtime equatorial bias in the Atlantic in the IFS-based models. Limited evidence however is presented that supports the hypothesis of an incorrect representation of the meridional equatorward flow in the marine boundary layer of the southern Atlantic as a contributing factor. Erroneous dynamical constraints on the flow upstream of the Equator may generate convergence and associated rainfall south of the Equator. This directs attention to the representation of the properties of the subtropical boundary layer as a potential source for the double ITCZ bias.
- 10 September 2019
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 19 (17) , 11383-11399
Open AccessA double ITCZ phenomenology of wind errors in the equatorial Atlantic in seasonal forecasts with ECMWF models
Modern coupled general circulation models produce systematic biases in the tropical Atlantic that hamper the reliability of long-range predictions. This study focuses on a common springtime westerly wind bias in the equatorial Atlantic in seasonal hindcasts from two coupled models – ECMWF System 4 and EC-Earth v2.3 – and in hindcasts also based on System 4, but with prescribed sea-surface temperatures. The development of the equatorial westerly bias in early April is marked by a rapid transition from a wintertime easterly, cold tongue bias to a springtime westerly bias regime that displays a marked double intertropical convergence zone (ITCZ). The transition is a seasonal feature of the model climatology (independent of initialisation date) and is associated with a seasonal increase in rainfall where a second branch of the ITCZ is produced south of the Equator. Excess off-equatorial convergence redirects the trade winds away from the Equator. Based on arguments of temporal coincidence, the results of our analysis contrast with those from previous work, and alleged causes hereto identified as the likely cause of the equatorial westerly bias in other models must be discarded. Quite in general, we find no evidence of remote influences on the development of the springtime equatorial bias in the Atlantic in the IFS-based models. Limited evidence however is presented that supports the hypothesis of an incorrect representation of the meridional equatorward flow in the marine boundary layer of the southern Atlantic as a contributing factor. Erroneous dynamical constraints on the flow upstream of the Equator may generate convergence and associated rainfall south of the Equator. This directs attention to the representation of the properties of the subtropical boundary layer as a potential source for the double ITCZ bias.
- Open Access
- 21 May 2019
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2019, 1-20
The Impact of Neglecting Ice Phase on Cloud Optical Depth Retrievals from AERONET Cloud Mode Observations
Cloud optical depth remains a difficult variable to represent in climate models, and hence there is a need for high-quality observations of cloud optical depth from locations around the world. Such observations could be readily obtained from Aerosol Robotic Network (AERONET) radiometers using a two-wavelength retrieval method. However, the method requires an assumption that all of the cloud in a profile is liquid, and this has the potential to introduce errors into long-term statistics of retrieved optical depth. Using a set of idealised cloud profiles, we find that the fractional error in retrieved optical depth is a linear function of the fraction of the optical depth that is due to the presence of ice cloud (“ice fraction”), with a magnitude of order 55 % to 70 % for clouds that are entirely ice. We derive a simple linear equation that could potentially be used as a correction at AERONET sites where ice fraction can be independently estimated. The greatest contribution to error statistics arises from optically thick cloud that is either mostly or entirely ice. Using this linear equation, we estimate the magnitude of the error for a set of cloud profiles measured at five sites of the Atmospheric Radiation Measurement programme. Instances of such clouds are not frequent, with less than 15 % of cloud profiles at each location showing an error of greater than 10. However, differences in the frequency of such clouds from one location to another affect the magnitude of the overall mean error, with sites dominated by deep tropical convection and thick frontal mixed-phase cloud showing greater errors than sites where deep clouds are less frequent. The mean optical depth error at the five locations spans the range 2.5 to 5.5, which we show to be small enough to allow calculation of top-of-atmosphere flux to within 10 %, and surface flux to about 15 %.
- 21 May 2019
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2019, 1-20
Open AccessThe Impact of Neglecting Ice Phase on Cloud Optical Depth Retrievals from AERONET Cloud Mode Observations
Cloud optical depth remains a difficult variable to represent in climate models, and hence there is a need for high-quality observations of cloud optical depth from locations around the world. Such observations could be readily obtained from Aerosol Robotic Network (AERONET) radiometers using a two-wavelength retrieval method. However, the method requires an assumption that all of the cloud in a profile is liquid, and this has the potential to introduce errors into long-term statistics of retrieved optical depth. Using a set of idealised cloud profiles, we find that the fractional error in retrieved optical depth is a linear function of the fraction of the optical depth that is due to the presence of ice cloud (“ice fraction”), with a magnitude of order 55 % to 70 % for clouds that are entirely ice. We derive a simple linear equation that could potentially be used as a correction at AERONET sites where ice fraction can be independently estimated. The greatest contribution to error statistics arises from optically thick cloud that is either mostly or entirely ice. Using this linear equation, we estimate the magnitude of the error for a set of cloud profiles measured at five sites of the Atmospheric Radiation Measurement programme. Instances of such clouds are not frequent, with less than 15 % of cloud profiles at each location showing an error of greater than 10. However, differences in the frequency of such clouds from one location to another affect the magnitude of the overall mean error, with sites dominated by deep tropical convection and thick frontal mixed-phase cloud showing greater errors than sites where deep clouds are less frequent. The mean optical depth error at the five locations spans the range 2.5 to 5.5, which we show to be small enough to allow calculation of top-of-atmosphere flux to within 10 %, and surface flux to about 15 %.