Richard A. Suss
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Richard A. Suss has a total of 38 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
A E Rosenbaum
1 shared publicationA J Kumar
1 shared publicationAnwar Haq
1 shared publicationArthur E. Rosenbaum
The Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions
1 shared publicationAshok J. Kumar
The Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions
1 shared publicationDavid P. Chason
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 26 December 2024
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery
- Vol. 98 (2) , e8
Re: Leichtle et al. Blunt cerebrovascular injury: The case for universal screening (J Trauma Acute Care Surg 2020;89(5):880–886)
- 26 December 2024
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery
- Vol. 98 (2) , e8
Re: Leichtle et al. Blunt cerebrovascular injury: The case for universal screening (J Trauma Acute Care Surg 2020;89(5):880–886)
- Open Access
- 22 November 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
First Do No Harm Is Proverbial, Not Hippocratic
The inherent risks of effective medical treatments might seem incompatible with“First do no harm” and “Primum non nocere.” We know not to take these mottosliterally, yet they lurk to potentially inhibit care or foster blame. Classical authoritieswho caution against harm qualify its proscription by intent and prioritize beneficence.Distorting presumed Hippocratic sources, the mottos would mistranslate a passage fromhis Oath or misrepresent a maxim from his Epidemics Book I whose full meaning is,essentially, “Help or don’t harm.” In commentaries on Epidemics, Galen of Pergamonand Hunayn ibn Ishâq successively expand upon Hippocrates’s terse maxim as itprioritizes “Help” and concords with his Oath. An extensive survey of translationsand commentary finds no basis for the mottos in ancient medical authority. Insteadthey apparently developed proverbially. Rather than literal dicta, proverbs and the likeare a motley contradictory collection of facile ideas that are wise only when well chosenafter deliberation on the issue at hand. Overemphasis on “no harm” may come fromexcess risk aversion and fear of regret, which the active side of a choice augments.The mottos might then excuse or promote therapeutic nihilism and work against acourse with probable or net expected benefit. Passing up this kind of benefit defiesclassical authority since Hippocrates. An initial Synopsis and a brief Conclusionreflect on a detailed compilation and analysis set forth between them that is offeredfor intensive inspection or for eclectic curiosity.
- 22 November 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessFirst Do No Harm Is Proverbial, Not Hippocratic
The inherent risks of effective medical treatments might seem incompatible with“First do no harm” and “Primum non nocere.” We know not to take these mottosliterally, yet they lurk to potentially inhibit care or foster blame. Classical authoritieswho caution against harm qualify its proscription by intent and prioritize beneficence.Distorting presumed Hippocratic sources, the mottos would mistranslate a passage fromhis Oath or misrepresent a maxim from his Epidemics Book I whose full meaning is,essentially, “Help or don’t harm.” In commentaries on Epidemics, Galen of Pergamonand Hunayn ibn Ishâq successively expand upon Hippocrates’s terse maxim as itprioritizes “Help” and concords with his Oath. An extensive survey of translationsand commentary finds no basis for the mottos in ancient medical authority. Insteadthey apparently developed proverbially. Rather than literal dicta, proverbs and the likeare a motley contradictory collection of facile ideas that are wise only when well chosenafter deliberation on the issue at hand. Overemphasis on “no harm” may come fromexcess risk aversion and fear of regret, which the active side of a choice augments.The mottos might then excuse or promote therapeutic nihilism and work against acourse with probable or net expected benefit. Passing up this kind of benefit defiesclassical authority since Hippocrates. An initial Synopsis and a brief Conclusionreflect on a detailed compilation and analysis set forth between them that is offeredfor intensive inspection or for eclectic curiosity.
- Open Access
- 4 October 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
The Prosecutor's Fallacy Framed as a Sample Space Substitution
The Prosecutor’s Fallacy has been described as a particular error in statistical reasoning that exaggerates a defendant’s probability of guilt, although it also occurs in other settings. When it occurs at trial, the listener must quickly detect and deflect it. This article reviews the Fallacy’s form and history (§§1-3), explains logical errors that may be imputed to it involving Bayes’s theorem with base and incidence rates, likelihood ratios, and logical form (§§4-5), and recasts them graphically (§6). But the logical and graphical errors are too abstruse to be psychologically real or to call out in a trial courtroom. Something is operating closer to consciousness, more easily exposed and rebuffed (§§7-10). Often an opportunistic subtraction from 1 sets up complementary numerical probabilities. With or without explicit subtraction, in all cases of the Prosecutor’s Fallacy and of the fallacy of the transposed conditional a probability substitution fallacy acts as an inverse straw man to illicitly shift an empirical or complementary numerical probability onto one of a different pair of complementary outcomes. Revealing the correct complement exposes this substitution and breaks any direct link to guilt. Synthesis of narrow (transposition) and broad (subtraction) paradigms into a coherent entity unites diverse, including personal, cases. Analytical and synthetic modes prepare witnesses and attorneys to avert or correct this fallacy. Probability symbols and formulas, and tabular diagrams, are offered not for courtroom use but as background to inspire readers and listeners to efficiently recognize and neutralize the Prosecutor’s Fallacy in any of its guises.
- 4 October 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessThe Prosecutor's Fallacy Framed as a Sample Space Substitution
The Prosecutor’s Fallacy has been described as a particular error in statistical reasoning that exaggerates a defendant’s probability of guilt, although it also occurs in other settings. When it occurs at trial, the listener must quickly detect and deflect it. This article reviews the Fallacy’s form and history (§§1-3), explains logical errors that may be imputed to it involving Bayes’s theorem with base and incidence rates, likelihood ratios, and logical form (§§4-5), and recasts them graphically (§6). But the logical and graphical errors are too abstruse to be psychologically real or to call out in a trial courtroom. Something is operating closer to consciousness, more easily exposed and rebuffed (§§7-10). Often an opportunistic subtraction from 1 sets up complementary numerical probabilities. With or without explicit subtraction, in all cases of the Prosecutor’s Fallacy and of the fallacy of the transposed conditional a probability substitution fallacy acts as an inverse straw man to illicitly shift an empirical or complementary numerical probability onto one of a different pair of complementary outcomes. Revealing the correct complement exposes this substitution and breaks any direct link to guilt. Synthesis of narrow (transposition) and broad (subtraction) paradigms into a coherent entity unites diverse, including personal, cases. Analytical and synthetic modes prepare witnesses and attorneys to avert or correct this fallacy. Probability symbols and formulas, and tabular diagrams, are offered not for courtroom use but as background to inspire readers and listeners to efficiently recognize and neutralize the Prosecutor’s Fallacy in any of its guises.
- 2 April 2020
- Published by American Society of Neuroradiology (ASNR) in American Journal of Neuroradiology
- Vol. 41 (5) , E28
ASPECTS Distorts Infarct Volume Measurement
- 2 April 2020
- Published by American Society of Neuroradiology (ASNR) in American Journal of Neuroradiology
- Vol. 41 (5) , E28
ASPECTS Distorts Infarct Volume Measurement
- Open Access
- 2 December 2019
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
ASPECTS, The Mismeasure of Stroke: A Metrological Investigation
ASPECTS (Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score) is an irregular scoring systemthat reads out as 10 to 0 points. It was originally conceived to reflect acute MCA (middle cerebral artery) territory infarct volume on (plain) CT, but it is equally applicable to and testable by MRI.Background material prepares the reader by explaining pertinent measurement principles and ASPECTS’s genesis, definitions, claims, and quirks. This report investigates ASPECTS as a volume surrogate without independently advocating for or against the therapies it might help plan.Method: The original authors of four publications provided their unpublished primary numerical data for further analysis. A CT study expands on the ACCESS database, which compares ASPECTS with two other subjective infarct scales: the legacy 1/3 MCA estimate and the multivariate IST-3 scale. An MRI study pools three diffusion-weighted (DWI) series as a patient-level meta-analysis unifying their comparisons of ASPECTS to the volumes that were found by semiautomated measurement.CT results: ASPECTS is unreliable, showing wide interrater variation with three quantifiable effects. It delivers little more than half as much entropy reduction as the IST-3 scale shows CT can support. Its large standard deviation (SD) takes up much of the scale width. Converting SD to a loss function with respect to a reference standard neuroradiologist gives an alarming weighted measure of error in ratings.MRI results: There are many-fold ranges of volume per ASPECTS and of ASPECTS per volume, causing sometimes large misclassifications one or both ways by any ASPECTS dichotomization. Looking past the ranges to averages, an estimate of 1/3 of the MCA territory corresponds best to ASPECTS cutting between 6 and 5 (6//5) and a volume of 65 mL (<1/4 of the average MCA territory).Discussion: There is already a simple, quick, and reliable manual volume measure (ABC/2, 2Sh/3). An attempt to salvage ASPECTS by reinterpreting its purpose does not hold up under scrutiny. ASPECTS can be replaced in stroke guidelines: the guideline cutting at ASPECTS 6//5 is consistent on average with the increasingly commonly stated, and better defined, 70 mL threshold. Arguments defending ASPECTS are rebutted by the evidence herein and by literature citations.Conclusion: ASPECTS subtracts value from the more objective direct volume measurements that are universally available by manual calculation and are becoming available by automatic software. ASPECTS inherently risks clinically significant misclassification (harm) for many patients.
- 2 December 2019
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessASPECTS, The Mismeasure of Stroke: A Metrological Investigation
ASPECTS (Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score) is an irregular scoring systemthat reads out as 10 to 0 points. It was originally conceived to reflect acute MCA (middle cerebral artery) territory infarct volume on (plain) CT, but it is equally applicable to and testable by MRI.Background material prepares the reader by explaining pertinent measurement principles and ASPECTS’s genesis, definitions, claims, and quirks. This report investigates ASPECTS as a volume surrogate without independently advocating for or against the therapies it might help plan.Method: The original authors of four publications provided their unpublished primary numerical data for further analysis. A CT study expands on the ACCESS database, which compares ASPECTS with two other subjective infarct scales: the legacy 1/3 MCA estimate and the multivariate IST-3 scale. An MRI study pools three diffusion-weighted (DWI) series as a patient-level meta-analysis unifying their comparisons of ASPECTS to the volumes that were found by semiautomated measurement.CT results: ASPECTS is unreliable, showing wide interrater variation with three quantifiable effects. It delivers little more than half as much entropy reduction as the IST-3 scale shows CT can support. Its large standard deviation (SD) takes up much of the scale width. Converting SD to a loss function with respect to a reference standard neuroradiologist gives an alarming weighted measure of error in ratings.MRI results: There are many-fold ranges of volume per ASPECTS and of ASPECTS per volume, causing sometimes large misclassifications one or both ways by any ASPECTS dichotomization. Looking past the ranges to averages, an estimate of 1/3 of the MCA territory corresponds best to ASPECTS cutting between 6 and 5 (6//5) and a volume of 65 mL (<1/4 of the average MCA territory).Discussion: There is already a simple, quick, and reliable manual volume measure (ABC/2, 2Sh/3). An attempt to salvage ASPECTS by reinterpreting its purpose does not hold up under scrutiny. ASPECTS can be replaced in stroke guidelines: the guideline cutting at ASPECTS 6//5 is consistent on average with the increasingly commonly stated, and better defined, 70 mL threshold. Arguments defending ASPECTS are rebutted by the evidence herein and by literature citations.Conclusion: ASPECTS subtracts value from the more objective direct volume measurements that are universally available by manual calculation and are becoming available by automatic software. ASPECTS inherently risks clinically significant misclassification (harm) for many patients.
- 1 March 2015
- Published by Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) in RadioGraphics
- Vol. 35 (2) , 498-499
CT Angiography of the Cerebral Venous System: Anatomic Structure, Pathologic Features, and Pitfalls:Resident and Fellow Education Feature
- 1 March 2015
- Published by Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) in RadioGraphics
- Vol. 35 (2) , 498-499
CT Angiography of the Cerebral Venous System: Anatomic Structure, Pathologic Features, and Pitfalls:Resident and Fellow Education Feature
- 31 October 2010
- Published by Elsevier in Current Problems in Diagnostic Radiology
- Vol. 39 (5) , 212-226
How Will You Need Me, How Will You Read Me, When I'm 64 (or More!)?: Volume Computed Tomographic Scanning and Information Overload in the Emergency Department
- 31 October 2010
- Published by Elsevier in Current Problems in Diagnostic Radiology
- Vol. 39 (5) , 212-226
How Will You Need Me, How Will You Read Me, When I'm 64 (or More!)?: Volume Computed Tomographic Scanning and Information Overload in the Emergency Department
- Open Access
- 1 January 2000
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in Archives of Neurology
- Vol. 57 (1) , 114-118
St Louis Encephalitis
Research from JAMA Neurology — St Louis Encephalitis — A Review of 11 Cases in a 1995 Dallas, Tex, Epidemic
- 1 January 2000
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in Archives of Neurology
- Vol. 57 (1) , 114-118
Open AccessSt Louis Encephalitis
Research from JAMA Neurology — St Louis Encephalitis — A Review of 11 Cases in a 1995 Dallas, Tex, Epidemic
- 1 November 1985
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in JAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery
- Vol. 111 (11) , 730-734
Magnetic Resonance Imaging vs Computed Tomography: Comparison in Imaging Oral Cavity and Pharyngeal Carcinomas
Research from JAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery — Magnetic Resonance Imaging vs Computed Tomography — Comparison in Imaging Oral Cavity and Pharyngeal Carcinomas
- 1 November 1985
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in JAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery
- Vol. 111 (11) , 730-734
Magnetic Resonance Imaging vs Computed Tomography: Comparison in Imaging Oral Cavity and Pharyngeal Carcinomas
Research from JAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery — Magnetic Resonance Imaging vs Computed Tomography — Comparison in Imaging Oral Cavity and Pharyngeal Carcinomas