Jawad Haqbeen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Jawad Haqbeen has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Takayuki Ito
Department of Social Informatics, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
11 shared publications - Sofia Sahab
Department of Social Informatics, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
7 shared publications - Mohammad Arifuzzaman
Department of Mathematics, Statistics & Computer Science, University of Wisconsin-Stout, Menomonie, WI 54751, USA
5 shared publications Takayuki Ito
Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
5 shared publications- Sofia Sahab
Department of Computer Science Nagoya Institute of Technology Nagoya Japan
4 shared publications Takanobu Otsuka
Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Nagoya Institute of Technology Gokiso, Showa-ku, Nagoya, 466-8555, Japan
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Discover Psychology
AI facilitation and affective dynamics of online deliberation
Artificial intelligence systems are increasingly used to facilitate online group discussion, yet their influence on the affective conditions of collective interaction remains poorly understood. Existing research has largely focused on participation, efficiency, or content quality, leaving the emotional dynamics of AI-mediated deliberation underexamined. This paper investigates how AI facilitation relates to the expressed sentiment in online group discussion, understood as one measurable dimension of its affective dynamics. Drawing on two empirical studies conducted in different discussion settings in Afghanistan, one involving a rule-based facilitator and the other a large language model-based facilitator, we analyze differences in expressed sentiment between AI-facilitated and non-AI discussions. Across both datasets, participant sentiment was modestly higher under AI facilitation, although the mixed-effects analyses did not establish statistically significant condition differences. In addition, AI-generated facilitation messages exhibited higher sentiment than participant-authored messages, with a statistically reliable overall gap in both studies and a consistent direction across all five city-specific boards in the first study and all four AI-facilitated groups in the second, suggesting that AI facilitators introduced more positive affective signals into the discussion environment. Rather than treating increased positivity as an unqualified improvement, we interpret these findings as suggesting that AI systems may act as affective mediators, potentially influencing the emotional norms and tone of collective interaction. This raises normative questions about emotional regulation, power, and democratic deliberation, particularly regarding whether affective smoothing may constrain disagreement or reconfigure deliberative agency. By foregrounding affect as a dimension of AI-mediated discussion, this study contributes empirical evidence to debates on the societal implications of AI facilitation and highlights the need for greater attention to the affective norms and expressive patterns introduced by AI facilitation.
- 30 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Discover Psychology
Open AccessAI facilitation and affective dynamics of online deliberation
Artificial intelligence systems are increasingly used to facilitate online group discussion, yet their influence on the affective conditions of collective interaction remains poorly understood. Existing research has largely focused on participation, efficiency, or content quality, leaving the emotional dynamics of AI-mediated deliberation underexamined. This paper investigates how AI facilitation relates to the expressed sentiment in online group discussion, understood as one measurable dimension of its affective dynamics. Drawing on two empirical studies conducted in different discussion settings in Afghanistan, one involving a rule-based facilitator and the other a large language model-based facilitator, we analyze differences in expressed sentiment between AI-facilitated and non-AI discussions. Across both datasets, participant sentiment was modestly higher under AI facilitation, although the mixed-effects analyses did not establish statistically significant condition differences. In addition, AI-generated facilitation messages exhibited higher sentiment than participant-authored messages, with a statistically reliable overall gap in both studies and a consistent direction across all five city-specific boards in the first study and all four AI-facilitated groups in the second, suggesting that AI facilitators introduced more positive affective signals into the discussion environment. Rather than treating increased positivity as an unqualified improvement, we interpret these findings as suggesting that AI systems may act as affective mediators, potentially influencing the emotional norms and tone of collective interaction. This raises normative questions about emotional regulation, power, and democratic deliberation, particularly regarding whether affective smoothing may constrain disagreement or reconfigure deliberative agency. By foregrounding affect as a dimension of AI-mediated discussion, this study contributes empirical evidence to debates on the societal implications of AI facilitation and highlights the need for greater attention to the affective norms and expressive patterns introduced by AI facilitation.
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 60-69
The Effects of an AI Participant on Online Group Deliberation: Evidence from a Controlled Study with Afghan Youth
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 60-69
The Effects of an AI Participant on Online Group Deliberation: Evidence from a Controlled Study with Afghan Youth
- Open Access
- 19 May 2025
- Published by TU Delft OPEN Publishing
- Vol. 1
Assessment of the LLM-based Chatbots on Student Engagement and Learning Outcomes in Afghanistan
The integration of Generative AI (GenAI) technologies, such as ChatGPT, into online education is accelerating; however, their effectiveness in under-resourced contexts remains insufficiently studied. This paper investigates the impact of a Large Language Model (LLM)-based conversational agent on student engagement and learning outcomes in Afghanistan, where access to formal education—particularly for women—is severely restricted or banned. We conducted an experimental study involving 80 undergraduate computer science students (40 male, 40 female) in Afghanistan, randomly assigned to control and treatment groups. All participants attended identical 50-minute online lectures followed by 40-minute post-lecture discussions moderated by a human instructor, and completed a follow-up self-report questionnaire. The treatment group additionally engaged in AI-facilitated discussions using a GPT-4-based chatbot during post-lecture discussion. Analysis of discussion logs and post-intervention surveys revealed that the treatment group demonstrated significantly higher participation rates, with more posts and replies, during post-lecture discussion and reported greater confidence in their understanding of the course material. These findings highlight the potential of LLM-based chatbots to enhance interactive learning and foster educational inclusion, particularly for marginalized populations in low-resource environments.
- 19 May 2025
- Published by TU Delft OPEN Publishing
- Vol. 1
Open AccessAssessment of the LLM-based Chatbots on Student Engagement and Learning Outcomes in Afghanistan
The integration of Generative AI (GenAI) technologies, such as ChatGPT, into online education is accelerating; however, their effectiveness in under-resourced contexts remains insufficiently studied. This paper investigates the impact of a Large Language Model (LLM)-based conversational agent on student engagement and learning outcomes in Afghanistan, where access to formal education—particularly for women—is severely restricted or banned. We conducted an experimental study involving 80 undergraduate computer science students (40 male, 40 female) in Afghanistan, randomly assigned to control and treatment groups. All participants attended identical 50-minute online lectures followed by 40-minute post-lecture discussions moderated by a human instructor, and completed a follow-up self-report questionnaire. The treatment group additionally engaged in AI-facilitated discussions using a GPT-4-based chatbot during post-lecture discussion. Analysis of discussion logs and post-intervention surveys revealed that the treatment group demonstrated significantly higher participation rates, with more posts and replies, during post-lecture discussion and reported greater confidence in their understanding of the course material. These findings highlight the potential of LLM-based chatbots to enhance interactive learning and foster educational inclusion, particularly for marginalized populations in low-resource environments.
- Open Access
- 11 June 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 312-320
Assessing the Impact of AI-mediation on Changing Extreme Perception in Online Discussion: Post-Intervention Responses in Post-2021 Afghanistan
Fair and diverse perspectives discussion, aided by reliable AI intervention, can effectively burst filter bubbles and transform undemocratic behaviors into functional democratic processes in online forums. However, the impact of AI intervention on individuals may vary depending on the persona and social attributes of the AI. Here we conducted a two-timepoint online experiment to examine whether AI-mediated discussions on sensitive topics can form moderate perceptions. Our study focused on the impact of AI-intervention on participants' perceptions and attitudes towards engagement with AI technology, access to democracy and gender equality, and interethnic marriage rights in Afghanistan. We assigned 168 individuals with conservative, moderate, and liberal perspectives to three different settings in two experimental groups, with and without AI-mediation. Participants engaged in three-day online discussions, after which we measured their personality profiles through a self-reported survey. Our findings suggest that while AI intervention had a significant impact on participants' perceptions of AI chatbot as facilitator, but the participants' positions remained largely unaffected towards access to democracy and gender equality, and interethnic marriage rights, possibly due to the lack of contextual knowledge and human touch in the chatbot's responses. Our study provides insight into creating effective chatbot personas to address illiberal practices in online discussions.
- 11 June 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 312-320
Open AccessAssessing the Impact of AI-mediation on Changing Extreme Perception in Online Discussion: Post-Intervention Responses in Post-2021 Afghanistan
Fair and diverse perspectives discussion, aided by reliable AI intervention, can effectively burst filter bubbles and transform undemocratic behaviors into functional democratic processes in online forums. However, the impact of AI intervention on individuals may vary depending on the persona and social attributes of the AI. Here we conducted a two-timepoint online experiment to examine whether AI-mediated discussions on sensitive topics can form moderate perceptions. Our study focused on the impact of AI-intervention on participants' perceptions and attitudes towards engagement with AI technology, access to democracy and gender equality, and interethnic marriage rights in Afghanistan. We assigned 168 individuals with conservative, moderate, and liberal perspectives to three different settings in two experimental groups, with and without AI-mediation. Participants engaged in three-day online discussions, after which we measured their personality profiles through a self-reported survey. Our findings suggest that while AI intervention had a significant impact on participants' perceptions of AI chatbot as facilitator, but the participants' positions remained largely unaffected towards access to democracy and gender equality, and interethnic marriage rights, possibly due to the lack of contextual knowledge and human touch in the chatbot's responses. Our study provides insight into creating effective chatbot personas to address illiberal practices in online discussions.
- Open Access
- 11 June 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1026-1029
From Interactive Idea Development to Solution Planning: An AI-assisted Discussion Facilitation Timeline for Collaborative Planning
The recent advancements in AI technology have shown the potential for chatbots to facilitate discussions. However, current chatbots mainly focus on discussion development and do not effectively synthesize idea development into solution planning. This is due to the need for better alignment between facilitation and discussion. To address this issue, we propose an AI-assisted discussion facilitation timeline that merges discussion development and planning in a water-flow-friendly manner. Our paper investigates the effect of this approach on critical thinking in developing informed opinions or positions. In a comparative study with 48 participants, we found that chatbots with a facilitation timeline induced critical thinking more effectively, leading to more informed decision-making. Our findings provide a basis for designing tools that synthesize idea development into solution planning in online communities.
- 11 June 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1026-1029
Open AccessFrom Interactive Idea Development to Solution Planning: An AI-assisted Discussion Facilitation Timeline for Collaborative Planning
The recent advancements in AI technology have shown the potential for chatbots to facilitate discussions. However, current chatbots mainly focus on discussion development and do not effectively synthesize idea development into solution planning. This is due to the need for better alignment between facilitation and discussion. To address this issue, we propose an AI-assisted discussion facilitation timeline that merges discussion development and planning in a water-flow-friendly manner. Our paper investigates the effect of this approach on critical thinking in developing informed opinions or positions. In a comparative study with 48 participants, we found that chatbots with a facilitation timeline induced critical thinking more effectively, leading to more informed decision-making. Our findings provide a basis for designing tools that synthesize idea development into solution planning in online communities.
- Open Access
- 21 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Psychology
- Vol. 2 (1) , 1-11
E-contact facilitated by conversational agents reduces interethnic prejudice and anxiety in Afghanistan
Intergroup contact occurring through indirect means such as the internet has the potential to improve intergroup relationships and may be especially beneficial in high conflict situations. Here we conducted a three-timepoint online experiment to ascertain whether the use of a conversational agent in E-contact platforms could mitigate interethnic prejudices and hostility among Afghanistan’s historically segregated and persistently conflictual ethnic groups. 128 Afghans of Pashtun, Tajik, and Hazara backgrounds were assigned to one of four E-contact conditions (control with no conversational agent and three experimental groups that varied in the conversational agent settings). Participants in the experimental conditions contributed more ideas and longer opinions and showed a greater reduction in outgroup prejudice and anxiety than those in the control group. These findings demonstrate that E-contact facilitated by a conversational agent can improve intergroup attitudes even in contexts characterized by a long history of intergroup segregation and conflict.
- 21 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Psychology
- Vol. 2 (1) , 1-11
Open AccessE-contact facilitated by conversational agents reduces interethnic prejudice and anxiety in Afghanistan
Intergroup contact occurring through indirect means such as the internet has the potential to improve intergroup relationships and may be especially beneficial in high conflict situations. Here we conducted a three-timepoint online experiment to ascertain whether the use of a conversational agent in E-contact platforms could mitigate interethnic prejudices and hostility among Afghanistan’s historically segregated and persistently conflictual ethnic groups. 128 Afghans of Pashtun, Tajik, and Hazara backgrounds were assigned to one of four E-contact conditions (control with no conversational agent and three experimental groups that varied in the conversational agent settings). Participants in the experimental conditions contributed more ideas and longer opinions and showed a greater reduction in outgroup prejudice and anxiety than those in the control group. These findings demonstrate that E-contact facilitated by a conversational agent can improve intergroup attitudes even in contexts characterized by a long history of intergroup segregation and conflict.
- Open Access
- 11 July 2023
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 654-656
Facilitating the Problems that lie within the Solutions using Conversational AI
Conversational Artificial Intelligence (CAI) has revolutionized human communication by enabling social and problem-solving conversations using natural language processing and generation technologies. However, while CAI-powered discussion platforms like D-Agree have been effective in promoting online discussions, general consensus facilitation policies have limitations in identifying the problems within proposed solutions. To address this issue, we propose a new facilitation policy in which the CAI interacts with the author of proposed solutions while raising the possibility of issues within the proposed solutions. We conduct experiments in a real-life setting in post-2021 Afghanistan, which demonstrate that the proposed approach is effective in collecting a higher number of objections raised for proposed solutions compared to the previous facilitation approach used in D-Agree.
- 11 July 2023
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 654-656
Open AccessFacilitating the Problems that lie within the Solutions using Conversational AI
Conversational Artificial Intelligence (CAI) has revolutionized human communication by enabling social and problem-solving conversations using natural language processing and generation technologies. However, while CAI-powered discussion platforms like D-Agree have been effective in promoting online discussions, general consensus facilitation policies have limitations in identifying the problems within proposed solutions. To address this issue, we propose a new facilitation policy in which the CAI interacts with the author of proposed solutions while raising the possibility of issues within the proposed solutions. We conduct experiments in a real-life setting in post-2021 Afghanistan, which demonstrate that the proposed approach is effective in collecting a higher number of objections raised for proposed solutions compared to the previous facilitation approach used in D-Agree.
- Open Access
- 11 July 2023
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 639-641
In Solidarity with Ukraine through Conversational AI via Facebook Ads: A Case Study of Online Discussion in 15 Countries
The world is facing increasing volatility due to ongoing geopolitical instabilities, which pose threats to international peace and democracy. In this unstable world, togetherness is considered to be the most important form of civic involvement. Therefore, online discussion forums are posed to be the next-generation platforms for democratic human communication. However, research argues that a publicly virtual social conversation alone cannot guarantee meaningful discussions and consultations because it fails to provide supportive means to facilitate problem-solving conversations. Incentive and facilitation mechanisms required to stimulate efficient communication and collaboration among online users within online forums. This paper focuses on the problem of managing crowdsourced deliberation in online communities, with the aim of human solidarity with Ukraine. Specifically, we targeted online communities in capital cities of 15 countries using Facebook Ads and directed them to an online discussion site, hosted by D-Agree, an online discussion forum. We first provide an overview of the deliberative initiative that is being used to facilitate deliberation in solidarity with Ukraine through conversational AI via Facebook Ads. We present a process for collecting the wisdom of the crowd on “how to collect and spend the collected aids in Ukraine '' for Ukraine solidarity good, by providing the public with an AI-facilitated online environment to post their opinions. The collected insights can be used as a planning tool for authorities.
- 11 July 2023
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 639-641
Open AccessIn Solidarity with Ukraine through Conversational AI via Facebook Ads: A Case Study of Online Discussion in 15 Countries
The world is facing increasing volatility due to ongoing geopolitical instabilities, which pose threats to international peace and democracy. In this unstable world, togetherness is considered to be the most important form of civic involvement. Therefore, online discussion forums are posed to be the next-generation platforms for democratic human communication. However, research argues that a publicly virtual social conversation alone cannot guarantee meaningful discussions and consultations because it fails to provide supportive means to facilitate problem-solving conversations. Incentive and facilitation mechanisms required to stimulate efficient communication and collaboration among online users within online forums. This paper focuses on the problem of managing crowdsourced deliberation in online communities, with the aim of human solidarity with Ukraine. Specifically, we targeted online communities in capital cities of 15 countries using Facebook Ads and directed them to an online discussion site, hosted by D-Agree, an online discussion forum. We first provide an overview of the deliberative initiative that is being used to facilitate deliberation in solidarity with Ukraine through conversational AI via Facebook Ads. We present a process for collecting the wisdom of the crowd on “how to collect and spend the collected aids in Ukraine '' for Ukraine solidarity good, by providing the public with an AI-facilitated online environment to post their opinions. The collected insights can be used as a planning tool for authorities.
- Open Access
Meeting the SDGs : Enabling the Goals by Cooperation with Crowd using a Conversational AI Platform
In this paper, we report about a large-scale online discussion with 1099 citizens on the Afghanistan Sustainable Development Goals.
Open AccessMeeting the SDGs : Enabling the Goals by Cooperation with Crowd using a Conversational AI Platform
In this paper, we report about a large-scale online discussion with 1099 citizens on the Afghanistan Sustainable Development Goals.
- 25 May 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Systems Science and Systems Engineering
- Vol. 30 (4) , 450-464
Argumentative Conversational Agents for Online Discussions
Artificial Intelligence is revolutionising our communication practices and the ways in which we interact with each other. This revolution does not only impact how we communicate, but it affects the nature of the partners with whom we communicate. Online discussion platforms now allow humans to communicate with artificial agents in the form of socialbots. Such agents have the potential to moderate online discussions and even manipulate and alter public opinions. In this paper, we propose to study this phenomenon using a constructed large-scale agent platform. At the heart of the platform lies an artificial agent that can moderate online discussions using argumentative messages. We investigate the influence of the agent on the evolution of an online debate involving human participants. The agent will dynamically react to their messages by moderating, supporting, or attacking their stances. We conducted two experiments to evaluate the platform while looking at the effects of the conversational agent. The first experiment is a large-scale discussion with 1076 citizens from Afghanistan discussing urban policy-making in the city of Kabul. The goal of the experiment was to increase the citizen involvement in implementing Sustainable Development Goals. The second experiment is a small-scale debate between a group of 16 students about globalisation and taxation in Myanmar. In the first experiment, we found that the agent improved the responsiveness of the participants and increased the number of identified ideas and issues. In the second experiment, we found that the agent polarised the debate by reinforcing the initial stances of the participant.
- 25 May 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Systems Science and Systems Engineering
- Vol. 30 (4) , 450-464
Argumentative Conversational Agents for Online Discussions
Artificial Intelligence is revolutionising our communication practices and the ways in which we interact with each other. This revolution does not only impact how we communicate, but it affects the nature of the partners with whom we communicate. Online discussion platforms now allow humans to communicate with artificial agents in the form of socialbots. Such agents have the potential to moderate online discussions and even manipulate and alter public opinions. In this paper, we propose to study this phenomenon using a constructed large-scale agent platform. At the heart of the platform lies an artificial agent that can moderate online discussions using argumentative messages. We investigate the influence of the agent on the evolution of an online debate involving human participants. The agent will dynamically react to their messages by moderating, supporting, or attacking their stances. We conducted two experiments to evaluate the platform while looking at the effects of the conversational agent. The first experiment is a large-scale discussion with 1076 citizens from Afghanistan discussing urban policy-making in the city of Kabul. The goal of the experiment was to increase the citizen involvement in implementing Sustainable Development Goals. The second experiment is a small-scale debate between a group of 16 students about globalisation and taxation in Myanmar. In the first experiment, we found that the agent improved the responsiveness of the participants and increased the number of identified ideas and issues. In the second experiment, we found that the agent polarised the debate by reinforcing the initial stances of the participant.