Robert Francis Kunz
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Robert Francis Kunz has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Xiang I. A. Yang
The Pennsylvania State University
22 shared publications - Stephen T. McClain
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Baylor University, One Bear Place # 97356, Waco, TX 76798-7356, USA
7 shared publications Samuel Altland
5 shared publications- David R. Hanson
Applied Research Laboratory, Pennsylvania State University, State College, PA 16802, USA
4 shared publications - Jiaqi J. L. Li
Department of Mechanical Engineering, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA
4 shared publications - Xinyi L. D. Huang
California Institute of Technology
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 8 June 2026
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Fluids
- Vol. 11  (6)
Physical meaning of k in the logarithmic layer for Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes models
- 8 June 2026
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Fluids
- Vol. 11  (6)
Physical meaning of k in the logarithmic layer for Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes models
- Open Access
- 4 June 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1036
The role of the law of the wall in cross-scenario generalisation of data-driven models
An objective of turbulence model calibration or recalibration is to train a model on one flow and achieve improved performance across a broad class of flows that share similar underlying physics. Such cross-scenario generalisation remains a major challenge in data-driven turbulence modelling. Existing considerations – such as model-consistent training and Galilean invariance – have enabled only scenario-specific generalisation to cases resembling the training dataset. In this work, we demonstrate that preserving the law of the wall (LoW) enables the expected transfer of the learned physics from the training flow to a target flow that shares relevant physics with the training flow. We adopt the field inversion and machine learning (FIML) framework, using the one-equation Spalart–Allmaras (SA) model as the baseline. Two strategies are examined: a conventional, unconstrained FIML approach, and a constrained FIML framework. Both strategies use the full flow field without shielding; the constrained version deploys the learned coefficient on a LoW-preserving manifold. Training is limited to periodic-hill flows, while extrapolation tests include channel flow, periodic hills of different slopes, a backward-facing step, and the three-dimensional BeVERLI hill. For periodic-hill cases, unconstrained and constrained FIML exhibit comparable performance, indicating that LoW preservation is not essential for scenario-specific generalisation. In contrast, significant errors arise with unconstrained FIML in the very-high-Reynolds-number plane-channel case, whereas constrained FIML, by design, maintains the logarithmic law. This demonstrates that conventional FIML disrupts baseline model calibrations and may explain the lack of cross-scenario generalisation. Finally, in the backward-facing step and BeVERLI hill cases – two separated flows that share certain physical features with periodic hills but are absent from the training data – the constrained FIML framework delivers improved predictions over the baseline SA model, whereas unconstrained FIML results in no improvement and, in some cases, deterioration. These findings underscore that preserving the LoW can be important for achieving cross-scenario generalisability.
- 4 June 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1036
Open AccessThe role of the law of the wall in cross-scenario generalisation of data-driven models
An objective of turbulence model calibration or recalibration is to train a model on one flow and achieve improved performance across a broad class of flows that share similar underlying physics. Such cross-scenario generalisation remains a major challenge in data-driven turbulence modelling. Existing considerations – such as model-consistent training and Galilean invariance – have enabled only scenario-specific generalisation to cases resembling the training dataset. In this work, we demonstrate that preserving the law of the wall (LoW) enables the expected transfer of the learned physics from the training flow to a target flow that shares relevant physics with the training flow. We adopt the field inversion and machine learning (FIML) framework, using the one-equation Spalart–Allmaras (SA) model as the baseline. Two strategies are examined: a conventional, unconstrained FIML approach, and a constrained FIML framework. Both strategies use the full flow field without shielding; the constrained version deploys the learned coefficient on a LoW-preserving manifold. Training is limited to periodic-hill flows, while extrapolation tests include channel flow, periodic hills of different slopes, a backward-facing step, and the three-dimensional BeVERLI hill. For periodic-hill cases, unconstrained and constrained FIML exhibit comparable performance, indicating that LoW preservation is not essential for scenario-specific generalisation. In contrast, significant errors arise with unconstrained FIML in the very-high-Reynolds-number plane-channel case, whereas constrained FIML, by design, maintains the logarithmic law. This demonstrates that conventional FIML disrupts baseline model calibrations and may explain the lack of cross-scenario generalisation. Finally, in the backward-facing step and BeVERLI hill cases – two separated flows that share certain physical features with periodic hills but are absent from the training data – the constrained FIML framework delivers improved predictions over the baseline SA model, whereas unconstrained FIML results in no improvement and, in some cases, deterioration. These findings underscore that preserving the LoW can be important for achieving cross-scenario generalisability.
- Open Access
- 29 May 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1036, A11
Integral-analysis-based diagnostics of turbulence model errors in skin friction
Error diagnostics for turbulence models have traditionally focused on engineering quantities of interest, such as the skin-friction coefficient $C_{\!f}$ , most often by comparing the predicted $C_{\!f}$ against reference data. In wall-bounded turbulent boundary layers, however, $C_{\!f}$ results from several physical mechanisms – viscous effects, turbulence, pressure gradients and mean-flow development – whose relative importance depends on the flow conditions. Modelling errors in these mechanisms vary across turbulence closures, and identifying them offers valuable physical insight for model evaluation and improvement. We propose a diagnostics framework that systematically isolates and quantifies such errors using the angular momentum integral formulation. The method is applied to five transport-type Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes models in two test cases: a canonical zero-pressure-gradient flat-plate boundary layer, and flow over a three-dimensional hill. For the flat-plate case, comparison with direct numerical simulations data shows that all models reproduce $C_{\!f}$ reasonably well, but often through strong error cancellation, particularly between the turbulent torque and mean-flux contributions; individual terms can deviate by more than 20 % of $C_{\!f}$ . For the hill case, where wall-resolved large-eddy simulations are used as the reference, errors are significantly larger. The dominant erroneous contribution differs by model and may exceed several times the local $C_{\!f}$ , depending on streamwise position. In separated-flow regions, the error cancellation that was observed in the flat-plate case largely disappears for the hill case, and the leading source of error shifts between mechanisms. These results highlight the value of mechanism-resolved diagnostics, and provide guidance for targeted turbulence model improvements.- 29 May 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1036, A11
Open AccessIntegral-analysis-based diagnostics of turbulence model errors in skin friction
Error diagnostics for turbulence models have traditionally focused on engineering quantities of interest, such as the skin-friction coefficient $C_{\!f}$ , most often by comparing the predicted $C_{\!f}$ against reference data. In wall-bounded turbulent boundary layers, however, $C_{\!f}$ results from several physical mechanisms – viscous effects, turbulence, pressure gradients and mean-flow development – whose relative importance depends on the flow conditions. Modelling errors in these mechanisms vary across turbulence closures, and identifying them offers valuable physical insight for model evaluation and improvement. We propose a diagnostics framework that systematically isolates and quantifies such errors using the angular momentum integral formulation. The method is applied to five transport-type Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes models in two test cases: a canonical zero-pressure-gradient flat-plate boundary layer, and flow over a three-dimensional hill. For the flat-plate case, comparison with direct numerical simulations data shows that all models reproduce $C_{\!f}$ reasonably well, but often through strong error cancellation, particularly between the turbulent torque and mean-flux contributions; individual terms can deviate by more than 20 % of $C_{\!f}$ . For the hill case, where wall-resolved large-eddy simulations are used as the reference, errors are significantly larger. The dominant erroneous contribution differs by model and may exceed several times the local $C_{\!f}$ , depending on streamwise position. In separated-flow regions, the error cancellation that was observed in the flat-plate case largely disappears for the hill case, and the leading source of error shifts between mechanisms. These results highlight the value of mechanism-resolved diagnostics, and provide guidance for targeted turbulence model improvements. - 3 June 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Fluids
- Vol. 10  (6)
Rough-wall modeling on a low-dimensional manifold
- 3 June 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Fluids
- Vol. 10  (6)
Rough-wall modeling on a low-dimensional manifold
- 9 May 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Computers & Fluids
- Vol. 298
A distributed element roughness model for generalized surface morphologies
- 9 May 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Computers & Fluids
- Vol. 298
A distributed element roughness model for generalized surface morphologies
- Open Access
- 3 April 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1008, A36
Budget analysis of Reynolds stresses in temporally evolving stratified wakes
This paper presents detailed analyses of the Reynolds stresses and their budgets in temporally evolving stratified wakes using direct numerical simulation. Ensemble averaging is employed to mitigate statistical errors in the data, and the results are presented as functions of both the transverse and vertical coordinates – at time instants across the near-wake, non-equilibrium, and quasi-two-dimensional regimes for wakes in weakly and strongly stratified environments. Key findings include the identification of dominant terms in the Reynolds stress transport equations and their spatial structures, the generation and destruction processes of the Reynolds stresses, and the energy transfer between the Reynolds stress and the mean flow. The study also clarifies the effects of the Reynolds number and the Froude number. Additionally, we assess the validity of the eddy-viscosity type models and some existing closures for the Reynolds stress model, highlighting the limitations of isotropy and return-to-isotropy hypotheses in stratified flows.
- 3 April 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1008, A36
Open AccessBudget analysis of Reynolds stresses in temporally evolving stratified wakes
This paper presents detailed analyses of the Reynolds stresses and their budgets in temporally evolving stratified wakes using direct numerical simulation. Ensemble averaging is employed to mitigate statistical errors in the data, and the results are presented as functions of both the transverse and vertical coordinates – at time instants across the near-wake, non-equilibrium, and quasi-two-dimensional regimes for wakes in weakly and strongly stratified environments. Key findings include the identification of dominant terms in the Reynolds stress transport equations and their spatial structures, the generation and destruction processes of the Reynolds stresses, and the energy transfer between the Reynolds stress and the mean flow. The study also clarifies the effects of the Reynolds number and the Froude number. Additionally, we assess the validity of the eddy-viscosity type models and some existing closures for the Reynolds stress model, highlighting the limitations of isotropy and return-to-isotropy hypotheses in stratified flows.
- Open Access
- 19 November 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 999, A78
Rough surfaces in underexplored surface morphology space and their implications on roughness modelling
We report direct numerical simulations results of the rough-wall channel, focusing on roughness with high $k_{rms}/k_a$ statistics but small to negative $Sk$ statistics, and we study the implications of this new dataset on rough-wall modelling. Here, $k_{rms}$ is the root mean square, $k_a$ is the first-order moment of roughness height, and $Sk$ is the skewness. The effects of packing density, skewness and arrangement of roughness elements on mean streamwise velocity, equivalent roughness height ( $z_0$ ) and Reynolds and dispersive stresses have been studied. We demonstrate that two-point correlation lengths of roughness height statistics play an important role in characterizing rough surfaces with identical moments of roughness height but different arrangements of roughness elements. Analysis of the present as well as historical data suggests that the task of rough-wall modelling is to identify geometric parameters that distinguish the rough surfaces within the calibration dataset. We demonstrate a novel feature selection procedure to determine these parameters. Further, since there is no finite set of roughness statistics that distinguish between all rough surfaces, we argue that obtaining a universal rough-wall model for making equivalent sand-grain roughness ( $k_s$ ) predictions would be challenging, and that each rough-wall model would have its applicable range. This motivates the development of group-based rough-wall models. The applicability of multi-variate polynomial regression and feedforward neural networks for building such group-based rough-wall models using the selected features has been shown.- 19 November 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 999, A78
Open AccessRough surfaces in underexplored surface morphology space and their implications on roughness modelling
We report direct numerical simulations results of the rough-wall channel, focusing on roughness with high $k_{rms}/k_a$ statistics but small to negative $Sk$ statistics, and we study the implications of this new dataset on rough-wall modelling. Here, $k_{rms}$ is the root mean square, $k_a$ is the first-order moment of roughness height, and $Sk$ is the skewness. The effects of packing density, skewness and arrangement of roughness elements on mean streamwise velocity, equivalent roughness height ( $z_0$ ) and Reynolds and dispersive stresses have been studied. We demonstrate that two-point correlation lengths of roughness height statistics play an important role in characterizing rough surfaces with identical moments of roughness height but different arrangements of roughness elements. Analysis of the present as well as historical data suggests that the task of rough-wall modelling is to identify geometric parameters that distinguish the rough surfaces within the calibration dataset. We demonstrate a novel feature selection procedure to determine these parameters. Further, since there is no finite set of roughness statistics that distinguish between all rough surfaces, we argue that obtaining a universal rough-wall model for making equivalent sand-grain roughness ( $k_s$ ) predictions would be challenging, and that each rough-wall model would have its applicable range. This motivates the development of group-based rough-wall models. The applicability of multi-variate polynomial regression and feedforward neural networks for building such group-based rough-wall models using the selected features has been shown. - 23 October 2024
- Published by ASME International in Journal of Fluids Engineering
- Vol. 147  (2) , 1-32
Data-Guided Low-Reynolds-Number Corrections for Two-Equation Models
The baseline Launder–Spalding k−ε model cannot be integrated to the wall. This paper seeks to incorporate the entire law of the wall into the model while preserving the original k−ε framework structure. Our approach involves modifying the unclosed dissipation terms in the k and ε equations specifically within the wall layer according to direct numerical simulation (DNS) data. The resulting model effectively captures the mean flow characteristics in both the buffer layer and the logarithmic layer, resulting in robust predictions of skin friction for zero-pressure-gradient (ZPG) flat-plate boundary layers and plane channels. To further validate our formulation, we apply our model to boundary layers under varying pressure gradients, channels experiencing sudden deceleration, and flow over periodic hills, with highly favorable results. Although not the focus of this study, the methodology here applies equally to the k–ω formulation and yields improved predictions of the mean flow in the viscous sublayer and buffer layer.
- 23 October 2024
- Published by ASME International in Journal of Fluids Engineering
- Vol. 147  (2) , 1-32
Data-Guided Low-Reynolds-Number Corrections for Two-Equation Models
The baseline Launder–Spalding k−ε model cannot be integrated to the wall. This paper seeks to incorporate the entire law of the wall into the model while preserving the original k−ε framework structure. Our approach involves modifying the unclosed dissipation terms in the k and ε equations specifically within the wall layer according to direct numerical simulation (DNS) data. The resulting model effectively captures the mean flow characteristics in both the buffer layer and the logarithmic layer, resulting in robust predictions of skin friction for zero-pressure-gradient (ZPG) flat-plate boundary layers and plane channels. To further validate our formulation, we apply our model to boundary layers under varying pressure gradients, channels experiencing sudden deceleration, and flow over periodic hills, with highly favorable results. Although not the focus of this study, the methodology here applies equally to the k–ω formulation and yields improved predictions of the mean flow in the viscous sublayer and buffer layer.
- Open Access
- 25 August 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 993, A1
Predictive near-wall modelling for turbulent boundary layers with arbitrary pressure gradients
The mean flow in a turbulent boundary layer (TBL) deviates from the canonical law of the wall (LoW) when influenced by a pressure gradient. Consequently, LoW-based near-wall treatments are inadequate for such flows. Chen et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 970, 2023, A3) derived a Navier–Stokes-based velocity transformation that accurately describes the mean flow in TBLs with arbitrary pressure gradients. However, this transformation requires information on total shear stress, which is not always readily available, limiting its predictive power. In this work, we invert the transformation and develop a predictive near-wall model. Our model includes an additional transport equation that tracks the Lagrangian integration of the total shear stress. Particularly noteworthy is that the model introduces no new parameters and requires no calibration. We validate the developed model against experimental and computational data in the literature, and the results are favourable. Furthermore, we compare our model with equilibrium models. These equilibrium models inevitably fail when there are strong pressure gradients, but they prove to be sufficient for boundary layers subjected to weak, moderate and even moderately high pressure gradients. These results compel us to conclude that history effects in mean flow, which negatively impact the validity of equilibrium models, can largely be accounted for by the material time derivative term and the pressure gradient term, both of which require no additional modelling.
- 25 August 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 993, A1
Open AccessPredictive near-wall modelling for turbulent boundary layers with arbitrary pressure gradients
The mean flow in a turbulent boundary layer (TBL) deviates from the canonical law of the wall (LoW) when influenced by a pressure gradient. Consequently, LoW-based near-wall treatments are inadequate for such flows. Chen et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 970, 2023, A3) derived a Navier–Stokes-based velocity transformation that accurately describes the mean flow in TBLs with arbitrary pressure gradients. However, this transformation requires information on total shear stress, which is not always readily available, limiting its predictive power. In this work, we invert the transformation and develop a predictive near-wall model. Our model includes an additional transport equation that tracks the Lagrangian integration of the total shear stress. Particularly noteworthy is that the model introduces no new parameters and requires no calibration. We validate the developed model against experimental and computational data in the literature, and the results are favourable. Furthermore, we compare our model with equilibrium models. These equilibrium models inevitably fail when there are strong pressure gradients, but they prove to be sufficient for boundary layers subjected to weak, moderate and even moderately high pressure gradients. These results compel us to conclude that history effects in mean flow, which negatively impact the validity of equilibrium models, can largely be accounted for by the material time derivative term and the pressure gradient term, both of which require no additional modelling.
- 1 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Experiments in Fluids
- Vol. 65  (4) , 1-29
Tomographic flow measurements over additively manufactured cooling channel roughness
- 1 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Experiments in Fluids
- Vol. 65  (4) , 1-29
Tomographic flow measurements over additively manufactured cooling channel roughness