AKAlexey Aleksandrovich Kazarnizki

Alexey Aleksandrovich Kazarnizki

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Alexey Aleksandrovich Kazarnizki has a total of 10 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Artificial cranial deformation: typology and geometric morphometrics

    by Andrey Gromov, Aleksey Kazarnitsky, Ekaterina Pugacheva, Evgenia Uchaneva

    There are various classifications of artificial cranial deformations. Among Russian anthropologists, the scheme of E.V. Zhirov (1940) is popular. As reference carriers of parietal deformation, he described samples from the Okunevo burials in Southern Siberia (Bronze Age), Zoroastrian and Nestorian medieval burials in Central Asia. However, later conclusions by E.V. Zhirov and other researchers concerning the deformation type in these series are contradictory: occipital, parietal, and occipital-parietal were noted. We evaluated the morphology of deformed male skulls using 3D geometric morphometrics, using the same samples as E.V. Zhirov, as well as other collections with the si­mi­lar braincase structural features in the cerebral region. 3D-models of skulls were obtained using RangeVision Spectrum scanner. On the cerebral section of each model, 42 equidistant semilandmarks were placed using 3D Slicer plug-in in the form of triangular patches bounded by three fixed landmarks in the craniometric points of bregma, right and left asterions. Procrustes and Principal Component ana­lyses were performed in the R-Studio. The analysis revealed that all of the late Okunevo and part of the Zoroastrian samples indeed have skulls with parietal deformation, characterized by a lowering of the cranial vault starting from bregma. In contrast, a part of the Zoroastrian and Nestorian skulls have the lowering of the vault, which begins in a more dorsal part — this variant can be called occipital-parietal. The remaining Nestorian skulls have occipital deformation. The usual typological terms are still convenient for descriptions, but they are subjective, and their correct/meaningful application requires methodological support using geometric morphometrics.


  • On craniological markers of western migrations to Eastern Europe in the bronze age (the case of the Abashevo culture)

    by Alexey A. Kazarnitsky, Казарницкий А. А.

    Craniological materials from the Abashevo culture are rare. A selection of skulls from the Pepkino mound in Chuvashia has long been known. Relatively recently, craniometric data of Abashevo culture bearers from the territory between the Volga and the Urals have been published. These are all the samples available today, with the exception of a few individual skulls from other sites. The origin of the Abashevo culture based on archaeological data is ambiguous: it may go back to the preceding Fatyanovo culture of the Upper Volga region or to some local groups of the Pit Grave (Yamnaya) culture, or else it may be the result of western migrations. The article deals with the question which of the archaeological hypotheses does not contradict the patterns of craniological variability of the European population of the Neolithic, Chalcolithic and Bronze Ages. The author employs craniometric data on a large number of European groups to search for the influence of migrations on the composition of the Abashevo population and other Bronze Age populations of Eastern Europe. It is argued that there are similarities between the series of skulls from the Fatyanovo sites and the eastern local groups of the Corded Ware culture. At the same time, there are no Western features in the craniometric characteristics of the two Abashevo series. The closest analogies of the latter can be observed among the population of the steppe and forest-steppe zones of Eastern Europe of the Chalcolithic and Bronze Ages.

  • Variants of fixing a deformed area on 3D models of neurocranium

    by Alexey Kazarnitsky, Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (the Kunstkamera) of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Ekaterina Pugacheva, Andrey Gromov, Evgenia Uchaneva, L’école Normale Supérieure

    The morphology of skulls with occipito-parietal deformation is mainly influenced by two factors: the artificial deformation itself and the natural morphology of the skull. Basing on morphometric methods our study is focused on identifying possible interaction between these two factors. We suggested that reduction the analyzed area to the deformed region of the skull may provide a more precise understanding of the variation in occipitoparietal flattening. This study aims to test this hypothesis and new software. Three male samples of deformed skulls from different chronological horizons of the Okunev culture (Minusinsk Basin) and the Early Bronze Age of the northwestern Caspian Sea region (35 skulls) were analyzed. 3D Slicer and Landmark IDAV software were used to place landmarks and patches and two packages in R (Morpho and Geomorph) for statistical analysis and visualization. The number of landmarks varies during the analyses. The minimum number is 15 along the sagittal contour and maximum is 76 setting over three rectangular patches along the median line. In all cases, when data on full contours of the skulls were used the results of PCA show rather interpopulation variation instead of the variations in skull deformation itself. On the next stage the studied area was reduced to a triangular region covering the occipitoparietal area directly (with vertices at the Bregma and Asterions). In this case the analysis reveals actual differences in the degree of flattening between the groups. Therefore, we confirm the hypothesis that it is important to restrict topography of the study region of the skull. Analysis of the deformed region allows avoiding influence of the interpopulation differences. The 3D Slicer software is effective and suitable for studying variations in the shape of the neurocranium, including those with artificial deformation.


  • Craniological data on migrations from the West to Eastern Europe in the Post-Catacomb period

    by Alexander Kazarnitsky, Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (the Kunstkamera) of the Russian Academy of Sciences

    In the article the craniology of the post-Catacomb and Middle Volga Abashevo populations in the context of cranial metric characteristics of Neolithic and Bronze Age groups of continental Europe is discussed. The data on 2100 male skulls belonging to 95 samples was analyzed by means of Mahalanobis distances (D²) matrix. The results reveal high level of similarity between the post-Catacomb series and Catacomb East-Manych, Eastern Caucasus (Gintchi) and Fatyanovo-Balanovo samples. Basically these results are in line with archaeological reconstructions of cultural processes in Middle and Late Bronze Age. The most western series, which displays morphologic similarity with the Babino sample, is the Globular Amphora series, while the Corded Ware sample from the Baltic region is similar to the Lolino culture sample. We suggest that the series of skulls from the Pepkino kurgan may be unrepresentative for the Middle Volga Abashevo population, since analogies to its cranial metric profile can be traced only in the late Fatyanovo and Balanovo samples and in one local Yamnaya sample, but are absent in other European populations, including Bell Beaker sample, which is in contradiction with archaeological data.


  • Cranial deformation in the northwestern Caspian Sea region in the Bronze Age: Siberian parallels

    by Aleksey A. Kazarnitsky, Andrey V. Gromov, Evgeniia N. Uchaneva, Ekaterina V. Pugacheva


  • Open Access

    Analysis of 3D-Models of Artificially Deformed Crania, Using Geometric Morphometry

    by E. V. Pugacheva, E. N. Uchaneva, A. A. Kazarnitsky, A. V. Gromov

    The study of artificially deformed crania is complicated by difficulties in analyzing curvilinear shapes without reliable reference points for measurement. Methods of geometric morphometrics (GM) help to solve this problem. We generated 3D-models of deformed crania (26 male and 19 female) from burials of different chronological periods of the Okunev archaeological culture (Verkhniy Askiz I, Uybat III and V, Uybat-Charkov, Itkol I and II), Southern Siberia (2600–1700 BC). Using the Landmark IDAV software, each model was transformed into a set of six traditional craniometric landmarks and 450 semi-landmarks regularly distributed over the entire surface of the braincase. For further processing with the Procrustes and principal component analysis, functions of several R-packages (Morpho, Geomorph, and Arothron) were employed. Crania from early Okunev burials were found to have a small deformed area around lambda, spanning the posterior parts of parietal bones and the upper part of the occipital squama. In crania from later Okunev burials, the deformation extends on the parietal area, causing the reduction of cranial height owing to a lesser curvature of the parietal segment. The lateral walls of the braincase, the frontal squama, and the lower part of the occipital squama in such crania are more convex.


  • Analysis of 3D-Models of Artificially Deformed Crania, Using Geometric Morphometry

    by E. V. Pugacheva, European University at St. Petersburg, E. N. Uchaneva, A. A. Kazarnitsky, A. V. Gromov

    Изучение искусственно деформированных черепов осложнено неудобством анализа криволинейных форм без надежных ориентиров для измерения. Методы геометрической морфометрии позволяют решить эту проблему. В статье анализируются 3D-модели деформированных черепов из погребений разных хронологических горизонтов окуневской археологической культуры (XXVI-XVIII вв. до н.э., Южная Сибирь): 26 мужских и 19 женских из памятников Верхний Аскиз I, Уйбат III, V, Уйбат-Чарков, Итколь I, II. С помощью программы Landmark IDAV каждая модель была преобразована в комплекс координат из шести точек, соответствующих классическим краниометрическим, и 450 полуточек, расположенных равномерно по всей поверхности мозгового отдела черепа. Для дальнейшей обработки материалов с помощью прокрустова анализа и метода главных компонент были привлечены отдельные функции нескольких пакетов программ — Morpho, Geomorph и Arothron — в рамках программной среды R. В результате установлено, что черепа из ранних погребений окуневской культуры имеют небольшой деформированный участок в области краниометрической точки лямбда, охватывающий заднюю часть теменных костей и верхнюю часть чешуи затылочной кости. Для черепов из более поздних погребений характерно усиление деформации в теменной области, в результате чего снижалась высота мозгового отдела из-за уменьшения высоты изгиба теменного сегмента, увеличивалась выпуклость боковых стенок черепа, чешуи лобной кости и нижней части чешуи затылочной кости.

  • The Ratio of Indigenous to Immigrant Populations in the Western Steppe During the Bronze Age (Based on Cranial Data)

    by A. A. Kazarnitsky

    В статье приведены результаты анализа краниометрических данных ок. 730 мужских черепов из погребений носителей степных и лесостепных культур (преимущественно ямной, катакомбной, полтавкинской, бабинской, лолинской и срубной) эпохи бронзы Восточной Европы. Межгрупповое сравнение проводится в основном с помощью вычисления квадратов расстояний Махаланобиса и многомерного неметрического шкалирования. Проведен анализ соотношения местных и пришлых популяций в составе населения четырех хронологических периодов: ранней бронзы, средней бронзы, рубежа средней и поздней бронзы, поздней бронзы. Обсуждается вопрос о популяционном разнообразии носителей ямной культуры: различия между ее региональными выборками черепов сопоставимы с таковыми между краниологическими выборками современного населения, проживающего на обширных территориях Восточной Европы от Карелии до Северного Кавказа. Отмечено значительное влияние субстратных групп на формирование населения ранней и средней бронзы. Популяционная преемственность на рубеже средней и поздней бронзы в период сложения посткатакомбных культур, напротив, почти отсутствует. Однако черты местных жителей эпохи средней бронзы снова обнаруживаются в краниологических выборках завершающего этапа бронзового века — среди носителей срубной культуры. В их краниологической характеристике сочетаются признаки катакомбных и посткатакомбных групп населения. Предполагается, что причинами исчезновения и появления одних и тех же популяций могли быть либо «маятниковые миграции», либо периодический отказ жителей эпохи бронзы от подкурганного захоронения умерших в пользу «невидимых» грунтовых могильников.

  • О ПОЗАХ «СПЯЩИХ» В ПОГРЕБЕНИЯХ ЭПОХИ БРОНЗЫ

    by Казарницкий А.а., Туркина И.с.

    Авторы предлагают проверить трактовку скорченной на боку скелетной позы как символа спящего человека в погребениях эпохи ранней бронзы степной зоны Восточной Европы. В выборке из 77 изображений современных людей в состоянии утреннего сна летом в полупустынном климате юга России отмечено безусловное доминирование встречаемости скорченных поз, несмотря на возможность сна в вытянутой позе. Сравнение поз современных спящих людей с положением скелетов в погребениях эпохи ранней бронзы Прикубанья выявило ряд совпадений в соотношении основных типов поз, в частоте скорченных поз в целом и в более мелких деталях положения рук и поворота туловища. Трактовка скорченной позы как типичной позы спящего человека признана допустимой. The authors propose to check the interpretation of the contracted position of the skeleton lying on the side as a symbol of a sleeping individual in the Early Bronze Age burials in the steppe belt of Eastern Europe. The sample of 77 images featuring modern people in the state of morning dream in summer from the areas in the Russian South with a semi-desert climate demonstrates indisputable prevalence of contracted positions despite the fact that people can sleep in an extended posture. Comparison of positions in which modern persons sleep with the positions of the skeletons found in the Early Bronze Age burials of the Kuban region revealed a number of coincidences regarding the main types of positions, incidence of contracted positions as a whole and minor details of hand and arm positions as well as the turn of the body. The interpretation of the contracted position as a typical posture of a sleeping person has been recognized as acceptable.