María Teresa Flórez Petour
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
María Teresa Flórez Petour has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- José Miguel Olave Astorga
Facultad de Filosofía y Humanidades, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso, Valparaíso 2340025, Chile
3 shared publications - Astrid Tolo
Department of Education, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway
1 shared publication - Fabiano Antonio dos Santos
Universidade Federal de Mato Grosso do Sul
1 shared publication Jacqueline Gysling
University of Chile, Centre for Studies on Educational Assessment, Santiago, Chile
1 shared publication- Javier Campos-Martínez
Universidad Austral de Chile
1 shared publication - Luis Felipe De la Vega
Universidad Andres Bello
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 4 March 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Oxford Review of Education
- Vol. 51 (2) , 250-280
Emerging horizons for social justice in assessment: can assessment move beyond competence, competition, content and control?
- 4 March 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Oxford Review of Education
- Vol. 51 (2) , 250-280
Emerging horizons for social justice in assessment: can assessment move beyond competence, competition, content and control?
- 14 February 2023
- Published by Universidade Federal do Parana in Jornal de Políticas Educacionais
- Vol. 17 (2)
A MÁS DE 30 AÑOS DE EVALUACIÓN DE ALTAS CONSECUENCIAS EN CHILE: LA NECESIDAD DE UN CAMBIO DE PARADIGMA
Jornal de Políticas Educacionais
- 14 February 2023
- Published by Universidade Federal do Parana in Jornal de Políticas Educacionais
- Vol. 17 (2)
A MÁS DE 30 AÑOS DE EVALUACIÓN DE ALTAS CONSECUENCIAS EN CHILE: LA NECESIDAD DE UN CAMBIO DE PARADIGMA
Jornal de Políticas Educacionais
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Universidad Mariana
- p. 104-121
De la incertidumbre a la transformación: experiencias para pensar un cambio de paradigma en evaluación educativa
La presente ponencia tiene por objetivo ilustrar, por medio de casos concretos, las implicancias y posibles caminos para una transformación de las culturas evaluativas, actualmente predominantes, en el marco de una larga disputa histórica entre visiones de la educación, en la cual la evaluación, en un sentido tradicional, ha tenido un rol más relevante del que habitualmente se le asigna. En contraposición a una visión de la evaluación que enfatiza su sentido de calificación, clasificación, estandarización, certificación y valor de cambio, en el actual marco de modelos de rendición de cuentas de mercado, se presentan tres experiencias en las cuales la autora ha participado en Chile, que ofrecen alternativas en diferentes niveles (evaluación a gran escala, evaluación de aula y evaluación en educación superior), que promueven visiones más centradas en lo formativo, contextualizado, significativo, democrático y diverso. Finalmente, se ofrecen conclusiones acerca de los aspectos comunes entre estas iniciativas, como elementos a tener en cuenta en la concreción de un cambio paradigmático en la evaluación educativa, que en el actual contexto se dibuja como un horizonte posible y necesario.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Universidad Mariana
- p. 104-121
De la incertidumbre a la transformación: experiencias para pensar un cambio de paradigma en evaluación educativa
La presente ponencia tiene por objetivo ilustrar, por medio de casos concretos, las implicancias y posibles caminos para una transformación de las culturas evaluativas, actualmente predominantes, en el marco de una larga disputa histórica entre visiones de la educación, en la cual la evaluación, en un sentido tradicional, ha tenido un rol más relevante del que habitualmente se le asigna. En contraposición a una visión de la evaluación que enfatiza su sentido de calificación, clasificación, estandarización, certificación y valor de cambio, en el actual marco de modelos de rendición de cuentas de mercado, se presentan tres experiencias en las cuales la autora ha participado en Chile, que ofrecen alternativas en diferentes niveles (evaluación a gran escala, evaluación de aula y evaluación en educación superior), que promueven visiones más centradas en lo formativo, contextualizado, significativo, democrático y diverso. Finalmente, se ofrecen conclusiones acerca de los aspectos comunes entre estas iniciativas, como elementos a tener en cuenta en la concreción de un cambio paradigmático en la evaluación educativa, que en el actual contexto se dibuja como un horizonte posible y necesario.
- Open Access
- 25 July 2022
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Journal of Education
- No. 87,p. 1-20
Voice and voicelessness in the construction of assessment policies: Participation as a relevant dimension in the potential impact on teaching and learning
This article critically analyses the currently predominant processes of construction of large-scale assessment policies by applying Bowe et al.'s (1992)policy cycle framework in the analysis of the national curriculum assessment system in Chile. Based on qualitative evidence that includes media and policy texts analysis, ethnographic work, and interviews with key policy actors, it aims at illustrating the disparity of participation in policy design as a potential reason for the lack of impact of these policies on teaching and learning. The findings point to a need for reconceptualising our framework for the understanding of the processes of construction of large-scale assessment policies by overcoming the rationale of market-oriented accountability systems that predominate nowadays. Alternatives are explored through examples of large-scale assessment systems with a higher parity of participation of stakeholders in policy design and policy enactment.
- 25 July 2022
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Journal of Education
- No. 87,p. 1-20
Open AccessVoice and voicelessness in the construction of assessment policies: Participation as a relevant dimension in the potential impact on teaching and learning
This article critically analyses the currently predominant processes of construction of large-scale assessment policies by applying Bowe et al.'s (1992)policy cycle framework in the analysis of the national curriculum assessment system in Chile. Based on qualitative evidence that includes media and policy texts analysis, ethnographic work, and interviews with key policy actors, it aims at illustrating the disparity of participation in policy design as a potential reason for the lack of impact of these policies on teaching and learning. The findings point to a need for reconceptualising our framework for the understanding of the processes of construction of large-scale assessment policies by overcoming the rationale of market-oriented accountability systems that predominate nowadays. Alternatives are explored through examples of large-scale assessment systems with a higher parity of participation of stakeholders in policy design and policy enactment.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2022
- Published by SciELO Agencia Nacional de Investigacion y Desarrollo (ANID) in Estudios Pedagógicos (Valdivia)
- Vol. 48 (4) , 357-376
La investigación en educación en las Universidades del Estado de Chile: nudos críticos y propuestas para trascender las lógicas de la performatividad y el mercado
El estudio se enmarca en la iniciativa Red de Universidades del Estado de Chile, orientada a promover la investigación asociativa, de colaboración y reciprocidad entre universidades. En este artículo se visibiliza el estado del arte de la investigación en educación y las condiciones de operación de 10 Universidades Estatales chilenas que imparten carreras de Educación. La investigación se emprende desde un diseño mixto, exploratorio secuencial de modalidad derivativa, que implicó una fase de levantamiento y recolección de información y de aplicación de una encuesta con componentes cuantitativos y cualitativos. Los resultados dan cuenta de nudos críticos relacionados con lógicas de mercado en educación superior que distorsionan la naturaleza del trabajo académico, generando desigualdades territoriales, de género y de circulación de conocimiento en educación. Se demandan políticas de Estado, que disminuyan las brechas entre universidades que lideran en investigación y las que presentan un bajo nivel de desarrollo.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by SciELO Agencia Nacional de Investigacion y Desarrollo (ANID) in Estudios Pedagógicos (Valdivia)
- Vol. 48 (4) , 357-376
Open AccessLa investigación en educación en las Universidades del Estado de Chile: nudos críticos y propuestas para trascender las lógicas de la performatividad y el mercado
El estudio se enmarca en la iniciativa Red de Universidades del Estado de Chile, orientada a promover la investigación asociativa, de colaboración y reciprocidad entre universidades. En este artículo se visibiliza el estado del arte de la investigación en educación y las condiciones de operación de 10 Universidades Estatales chilenas que imparten carreras de Educación. La investigación se emprende desde un diseño mixto, exploratorio secuencial de modalidad derivativa, que implicó una fase de levantamiento y recolección de información y de aplicación de una encuesta con componentes cuantitativos y cualitativos. Los resultados dan cuenta de nudos críticos relacionados con lógicas de mercado en educación superior que distorsionan la naturaleza del trabajo académico, generando desigualdades territoriales, de género y de circulación de conocimiento en educación. Se demandan políticas de Estado, que disminuyan las brechas entre universidades que lideran en investigación y las que presentan un bajo nivel de desarrollo.
- Open Access
- 6 July 2020
- Published by Revista Eletronica Politica e Gestao Educacional in Periferia
- Vol. 24 (esp. 1) , 867-890
Hacia una construcción participativa de la política educacional: la propuesta alternativa del proyecto de éxito escolar en Valparaíso
The article adresses currently predominant means of construction of education policy from a critical perspective, drawing on the results of a study that analyses the case of the national curriculum assessment system in Chile (SIMCE). In particular, we focus on those findings that reveal the predominance of a top-down approach to the understanding of education policy. We argue that this approach raises issues related to social justice, especifically in the dimension of parity of participation. As an alternative approach, a case related to a second project is presented, which consists of the participatory construction of the bases for a large-scale assessment system with a formative purpose, developed in the Municipality of Valparaíso, Chile. On the basis of this experience, the need for more democratic and, therefore, more socially just processes of policy construction is highlighted.
- 6 July 2020
- Published by Revista Eletronica Politica e Gestao Educacional in Periferia
- Vol. 24 (esp. 1) , 867-890
Open AccessHacia una construcción participativa de la política educacional: la propuesta alternativa del proyecto de éxito escolar en Valparaíso
The article adresses currently predominant means of construction of education policy from a critical perspective, drawing on the results of a study that analyses the case of the national curriculum assessment system in Chile (SIMCE). In particular, we focus on those findings that reveal the predominance of a top-down approach to the understanding of education policy. We argue that this approach raises issues related to social justice, especifically in the dimension of parity of participation. As an alternative approach, a case related to a second project is presented, which consists of the participatory construction of the bases for a large-scale assessment system with a formative purpose, developed in the Municipality of Valparaíso, Chile. On the basis of this experience, the need for more democratic and, therefore, more socially just processes of policy construction is highlighted.
- 5 December 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Educational Change
- Vol. 21 (1) , 157-182
Accountability from a social justice perspective: Criticism and proposals
- 5 December 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Educational Change
- Vol. 21 (1) , 157-182
Accountability from a social justice perspective: Criticism and proposals
- Open Access
- 26 October 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Educational Change
- Vol. 21 (1) , 59-82
Intelligent accountability in schools: A study of how school leaders work with the implementation of assessment for learning
In response to accountability systems dominated by external inspections and achievement data, calls are being made forintelligentaccountability or a new accountability paradigm that focuses onmeaningfullearning, enabled by professionally skilled and committed educators within the system. In such systems, the actors are encouraged to strive for continuous development in learning organisations based on teamwork, distributed leadership, and professional learning communities. School leaders are positioned between district level administrators and teachers in such processes and have the responsibility to secure professional development. Using the implementation of the national program ‘Assessment for Learning’ in Norway as a case, the article shows that leaders approach professional development differently. Analyses of interviews with leaders from 7 schools reveal three distinct approaches related to how school leaders perceive knowledge. Some school leaders assume that teachers have the necessary knowledge and skills and trust them to manage the implementation process without leader support. Other school leaders distrust teachers’ knowledge and skills and assume that the proper knowledge exists outside the school. These leaders seek external support when they meet teacher resistance. In a third approach, school leaders assume that knowledge develops through collaboration and thereby engage with teachers in continuous judgment about the implementation procedure. In the discussion, questions of trust and distrust are analysed in relation to how professional knowledge is developed and how professional discretion can support the development of intelligent accountability in schools.
- 26 October 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Educational Change
- Vol. 21 (1) , 59-82
Open AccessIntelligent accountability in schools: A study of how school leaders work with the implementation of assessment for learning
In response to accountability systems dominated by external inspections and achievement data, calls are being made forintelligentaccountability or a new accountability paradigm that focuses onmeaningfullearning, enabled by professionally skilled and committed educators within the system. In such systems, the actors are encouraged to strive for continuous development in learning organisations based on teamwork, distributed leadership, and professional learning communities. School leaders are positioned between district level administrators and teachers in such processes and have the responsibility to secure professional development. Using the implementation of the national program ‘Assessment for Learning’ in Norway as a case, the article shows that leaders approach professional development differently. Analyses of interviews with leaders from 7 schools reveal three distinct approaches related to how school leaders perceive knowledge. Some school leaders assume that teachers have the necessary knowledge and skills and trust them to manage the implementation process without leader support. Other school leaders distrust teachers’ knowledge and skills and assume that the proper knowledge exists outside the school. These leaders seek external support when they meet teacher resistance. In a third approach, school leaders assume that knowledge develops through collaboration and thereby engage with teachers in continuous judgment about the implementation procedure. In the discussion, questions of trust and distrust are analysed in relation to how professional knowledge is developed and how professional discretion can support the development of intelligent accountability in schools.
- Open Access
- 30 August 2019
- Published by Revista Ibero-Americana de Estudos em Educacao in Revista Ibero-Americana de Estudos em Educação
- Vol. 14 (esp3) , 1829-1846
Internacionalização dos sistemas de avaliação: evidências de Brasil e Chile
Internacionalização dos sistemas de avaliação: evidências de Brasil e Chile
- 30 August 2019
- Published by Revista Ibero-Americana de Estudos em Educacao in Revista Ibero-Americana de Estudos em Educação
- Vol. 14 (esp3) , 1829-1846
Open AccessInternacionalização dos sistemas de avaliação: evidências de Brasil e Chile
Internacionalização dos sistemas de avaliação: evidências de Brasil e Chile
- 3 September 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Oxford Review of Education
- Vol. 44 (5) , 651-667
The consequences of metrics for social justice: tensions, pending issues, and questions
In the current scenario of expansion of neo-liberal and market-oriented policies, large-scale assessment has become an increasingly pervasive technology of power. Given their consequences, and the high stakes derived from them, assessment systems put pressure on schools to an extent where their practices and internal policies adapt to the logic of these mechanisms. The behaviours that emerge from this adaptation are seen as ‘gaming the system’ and are often portrayed as the responsibility of test users. However, the article aims at pushing the question around the consequences of metrics further, in terms of what these strategic gaming behaviours are adapting to and to what extent predominant metrics are accomplishing their assumptions of social justice. Through theoretically discussing the concept of social justice in connection with educational assessment, the paper problematises whether current metrics and their consequences, on the one hand, are able to respond to their underlying principles of equality of opportunity, which are characteristic of justice as distribution, and, on the other hand, highlights the insufficiency of these principles to respond to current developments of the concept of social justice with regard to the dimensions of recognition and participation, with considerations for their potential inclusion in future assessment systems.
- 3 September 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Oxford Review of Education
- Vol. 44 (5) , 651-667
The consequences of metrics for social justice: tensions, pending issues, and questions
In the current scenario of expansion of neo-liberal and market-oriented policies, large-scale assessment has become an increasingly pervasive technology of power. Given their consequences, and the high stakes derived from them, assessment systems put pressure on schools to an extent where their practices and internal policies adapt to the logic of these mechanisms. The behaviours that emerge from this adaptation are seen as ‘gaming the system’ and are often portrayed as the responsibility of test users. However, the article aims at pushing the question around the consequences of metrics further, in terms of what these strategic gaming behaviours are adapting to and to what extent predominant metrics are accomplishing their assumptions of social justice. Through theoretically discussing the concept of social justice in connection with educational assessment, the paper problematises whether current metrics and their consequences, on the one hand, are able to respond to their underlying principles of equality of opportunity, which are characteristic of justice as distribution, and, on the other hand, highlights the insufficiency of these principles to respond to current developments of the concept of social justice with regard to the dimensions of recognition and participation, with considerations for their potential inclusion in future assessment systems.