Bethan Mair Treadgold
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Bethan Mair Treadgold has a total of 82 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- John L. Campbell
University of Exeter
7 shared publications - Emma Pitchforth
Faculty of Health and Life Sciences, University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
6 shared publications - Gary A. Abel
Department of Health and Community Sciences, University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
4 shared publications - Helen Atherton
Primary Care Research Centre, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
4 shared publications - Carol Bryce
University of Warwick
3 shared publications - Christine Marriott
NIHR Applied Research Collaboration South West Peninsula
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 2 April 2026
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (771) , e836-e846
Sustaining a career in general practice: a qualitative study of experienced GPs in South West England
Background: General practice in the UK faces a growing retention crisis, with many experienced GPs reducing hours or leaving patient care amid rising workload and system strain. Understanding what sustains GP careers is crucial to stabilising the workforce. Aim: To explore how experienced GPs’ career intentions have evolved since the 2016 ReGROUP study and to identify factors influencing decisions to stay, reduce, or leave clinical work. Design and setting: A qualitative interview study was undertaken with experienced GPs in South West England, and analysed using the Job Demands–Resources (JD–R) model. Method: We conducted 19 semi-structured interviews with GPs who had previously completed the ReGROUP survey. Transcripts were analysed thematically with input from public and professional stakeholders. Results: GPs described escalating clinical and administrative workloads, moral distress, and reduced control as key pressures driving burnout and exit. Hybrid access models, secondary care workload transfer, and punitive regulatory processes intensified strain. Retention was supported by clear workload boundaries, continuity of care, supportive practice systems, portfolio careers, and collective advocacy. Some GPs maintained engagement by reshaping their roles or practice structures to regain control and sustain meaning. Conclusion: Retention depends not only on reducing workload but also on restoring the conditions that make being a ‘good GP’ feel possible, through continuity, manageable demand, and supportive organisational culture. Creating space for flexibility, autonomy, and role redesign may help sustain experienced GPs and strengthen workforce resilience.
- 2 April 2026
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (771) , e836-e846
Open AccessSustaining a career in general practice: a qualitative study of experienced GPs in South West England
Background: General practice in the UK faces a growing retention crisis, with many experienced GPs reducing hours or leaving patient care amid rising workload and system strain. Understanding what sustains GP careers is crucial to stabilising the workforce. Aim: To explore how experienced GPs’ career intentions have evolved since the 2016 ReGROUP study and to identify factors influencing decisions to stay, reduce, or leave clinical work. Design and setting: A qualitative interview study was undertaken with experienced GPs in South West England, and analysed using the Job Demands–Resources (JD–R) model. Method: We conducted 19 semi-structured interviews with GPs who had previously completed the ReGROUP survey. Transcripts were analysed thematically with input from public and professional stakeholders. Results: GPs described escalating clinical and administrative workloads, moral distress, and reduced control as key pressures driving burnout and exit. Hybrid access models, secondary care workload transfer, and punitive regulatory processes intensified strain. Retention was supported by clear workload boundaries, continuity of care, supportive practice systems, portfolio careers, and collective advocacy. Some GPs maintained engagement by reshaping their roles or practice structures to regain control and sustain meaning. Conclusion: Retention depends not only on reducing workload but also on restoring the conditions that make being a ‘good GP’ feel possible, through continuity, manageable demand, and supportive organisational culture. Creating space for flexibility, autonomy, and role redesign may help sustain experienced GPs and strengthen workforce resilience.
- Open Access
Protocol for a systematic review assessing the role of digital health technology in optimising medication adherence in older patients with asthma or COPD
Introduction: An estimated 262 million people lived with asthma globally in 2019. Similarly, in 2021, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) was responsible for 3.5% million global deaths. They are usually distinct disorders, but the Global Initiative Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (GOLD) 2024 strategy document asserts that asthma and COPD are conditions that may coexist in an individual and may require specific personalised approaches and treatments. It is acknowledged that they may share some common treatable traits and clinical features There are many challenges to manage asthma and COPD in the older population, including poor adherence to prescribed medications and poor inhaler techniques. The overall aim of this systematic review is to identify, appraise and synthesise available evidence around digital health interventions used to improve medication adherence in older people with asthma or COPD. Methods and analysis: This systematic review will examine studies that evaluated digital health interventions for asthma or COPD in any setting (eg, primary or secondary care). To be included, studies must be reported in English, Arabic or French and published from the year 2000 onwards. A literature search will be performed in MEDLINE via Ovid, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), CINAHL, EMBASE and PsycINFO via Ovid to identify relevant articles published since 2000 and up to December 2024. No language restrictions will be applied. The Cochrane risk-of-bias tool for randomised trials will be used to assess the quality of retrieved randomised controlled trials and quasi-experimental studies. The quality of cross-sectional, cohort and case-control studies will be assessed using the Newcastle Ottawa Scale. Mixed-methods studies will be assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). The quality of qualitative studies will be assessed using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) qualitative checklist. Data will be synthesised using a convergent segregated approach, which involves an independent synthesis of quantitative and qualitative data leading to the generation of quantitative and qualitative evidence, which will then be integrated. Ethics and dissemination: Ethics approval is not applicable for this study since no original data will be collected. The results will be disseminated through a peer-reviewed publication and conference presentations. Findings will be used in a bigger project aimed to answer the question on how to embed a pharmacist-led digital health service to support older people with asthma or COPD into the NHS (National Health Service) usual care. Prospero registration number: CRD42024575924.
Open AccessProtocol for a systematic review assessing the role of digital health technology in optimising medication adherence in older patients with asthma or COPD
Introduction: An estimated 262 million people lived with asthma globally in 2019. Similarly, in 2021, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) was responsible for 3.5% million global deaths. They are usually distinct disorders, but the Global Initiative Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (GOLD) 2024 strategy document asserts that asthma and COPD are conditions that may coexist in an individual and may require specific personalised approaches and treatments. It is acknowledged that they may share some common treatable traits and clinical features There are many challenges to manage asthma and COPD in the older population, including poor adherence to prescribed medications and poor inhaler techniques. The overall aim of this systematic review is to identify, appraise and synthesise available evidence around digital health interventions used to improve medication adherence in older people with asthma or COPD. Methods and analysis: This systematic review will examine studies that evaluated digital health interventions for asthma or COPD in any setting (eg, primary or secondary care). To be included, studies must be reported in English, Arabic or French and published from the year 2000 onwards. A literature search will be performed in MEDLINE via Ovid, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), CINAHL, EMBASE and PsycINFO via Ovid to identify relevant articles published since 2000 and up to December 2024. No language restrictions will be applied. The Cochrane risk-of-bias tool for randomised trials will be used to assess the quality of retrieved randomised controlled trials and quasi-experimental studies. The quality of cross-sectional, cohort and case-control studies will be assessed using the Newcastle Ottawa Scale. Mixed-methods studies will be assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). The quality of qualitative studies will be assessed using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) qualitative checklist. Data will be synthesised using a convergent segregated approach, which involves an independent synthesis of quantitative and qualitative data leading to the generation of quantitative and qualitative evidence, which will then be integrated. Ethics and dissemination: Ethics approval is not applicable for this study since no original data will be collected. The results will be disseminated through a peer-reviewed publication and conference presentations. Findings will be used in a bigger project aimed to answer the question on how to embed a pharmacist-led digital health service to support older people with asthma or COPD into the NHS (National Health Service) usual care. Prospero registration number: CRD42024575924.
- Open Access
- 5 June 2025
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (760) , e768-e776
Practitioners’ views on the measurement and management of postural hypotension in general practice: a qualitative inquiry
Background: Postural hypotension is associated with cognitive decline, falls, and all-cause mortality, representing a substantial burden on the NHS. Postural hypotension is often asymptomatic, making detection and treatment difficult. Currently, there is no systematic approach to measuring and managing postural hypotension in UK general practice. Aim: To explore barriers to and facilitators of improving postural hypotension measurement and management. Design and setting: This was a qualitative interview study with healthcare practitioners (HCPs) in general practices in England. Method: Individual, remote, semi-structured interviews were conducted with a range of HCPs who measure blood pressure in general practice to explore their views and experiences of measuring and managing postural hypotension. Participants were identified from expressions of interest during a national survey. Interviews were video- and audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim, and analysed thematically. Results: In total, 26 HCPs in 24 practices across nine clinical research networks in England were interviewed between March and July 2023. HCPs checked for postural hypotension when patients were older, reported dizziness, fatigue, or had chronic conditions. Despite awareness of clinical guidelines, various diagnostic definitions were provided and measurement protocols varied between participants. Sit-to-stand rather than supine-to-stand measurements were considered more feasible owing to time constraints and patient mobility. Education and training, as well as incentives and specialist clinics, were suggested as methods to improve postural hypotension measurement and management. Conclusion: This is the first study, to our knowledge, to explore barriers to and facilitators of postural hypotension measurement in English general practice. Findings suggest a more systematic approach to measurement is needed to improve detection and management of postural hypotension in general practice.
- 5 June 2025
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (760) , e768-e776
Open AccessPractitioners’ views on the measurement and management of postural hypotension in general practice: a qualitative inquiry
Background: Postural hypotension is associated with cognitive decline, falls, and all-cause mortality, representing a substantial burden on the NHS. Postural hypotension is often asymptomatic, making detection and treatment difficult. Currently, there is no systematic approach to measuring and managing postural hypotension in UK general practice. Aim: To explore barriers to and facilitators of improving postural hypotension measurement and management. Design and setting: This was a qualitative interview study with healthcare practitioners (HCPs) in general practices in England. Method: Individual, remote, semi-structured interviews were conducted with a range of HCPs who measure blood pressure in general practice to explore their views and experiences of measuring and managing postural hypotension. Participants were identified from expressions of interest during a national survey. Interviews were video- and audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim, and analysed thematically. Results: In total, 26 HCPs in 24 practices across nine clinical research networks in England were interviewed between March and July 2023. HCPs checked for postural hypotension when patients were older, reported dizziness, fatigue, or had chronic conditions. Despite awareness of clinical guidelines, various diagnostic definitions were provided and measurement protocols varied between participants. Sit-to-stand rather than supine-to-stand measurements were considered more feasible owing to time constraints and patient mobility. Education and training, as well as incentives and specialist clinics, were suggested as methods to improve postural hypotension measurement and management. Conclusion: This is the first study, to our knowledge, to explore barriers to and facilitators of postural hypotension measurement in English general practice. Findings suggest a more systematic approach to measurement is needed to improve detection and management of postural hypotension in general practice.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 16 May 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 27, e71140
Quality and Misinformation About Health Conditions in Online Peer Support Groups: Scoping Review
Background: The use of health-related online peer support groups to support self-management of health issues has become increasingly popular. The quality of information and advice may have important implications for public health and for the utility of such groups. There is some evidence of variable quality of web-based health information, but the extent to which misinformation is a problem in online peer support groups is unclear. Objective: We aimed to gain insight into the quality of information and advice about health conditions in online peer support groups and to review the tools available for assessing the quality of such information. Methods: A scoping review was undertaken following the Joanna Briggs Institute scoping review methodology. We searched electronic databases (MEDLINE [Ovid], CINAHL, Web of Science, ASSIA, ProQuest Dissertation and Theses, and Google Scholar) for literature published before November 2023, as well as citations of included articles. Primary research studies, reviews, and gray literature that explored the quality of information and advice in online peer support groups were included. Title and abstracts were independently screened by 2 reviewers. Data were extracted and tabulated, and key findings were summarized narratively. Results: A total of 14 (0.45%) relevant articles, from 3136 articles identified, were included. Of these, 10 (71%) were primary research articles comprising diverse quality appraisal methodologies, and 4 (29%) were review articles. All articles had been published between 2014 and 2023. Across the literature, there was more evidence of poor quality information and misinformation than of good quality information and advice, particularly around long-term and life-threatening conditions. There were varying degrees of misinformation about non–life-threatening conditions and about mental health conditions. Misinformation about noncommunicable diseases was reported as particularly prevalent on Facebook. Fellow online peer support group users often played an active role in correcting misinformation by replying to false claims or providing correct information in subsequent posts. Quality appraisal tools were reported as being used by researchers and health care professionals in appraising the quality of information and advice, including established tools for the appraisal of health-related information (eg, DISCERN, HONcode criteria, and Journal of the American Medical Association benchmark criteria). No tools reported were specifically designed to appraise online peer support group content. Conclusions: While there is good quality information and advice exchanged between users in online peer support groups, our findings show that misinformation is a problem, which is a matter of public health concern. Confidence in the quality of information shared may determine the utility of online peer support groups for patients and health care professionals. Our review suggests that clinical and academic experts in health conditions could play a valuable role in ensuring the quality of content. Several quality appraisal tools are available to support such an initiative.
- 16 May 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 27, e71140
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessQuality and Misinformation About Health Conditions in Online Peer Support Groups: Scoping Review
Background: The use of health-related online peer support groups to support self-management of health issues has become increasingly popular. The quality of information and advice may have important implications for public health and for the utility of such groups. There is some evidence of variable quality of web-based health information, but the extent to which misinformation is a problem in online peer support groups is unclear. Objective: We aimed to gain insight into the quality of information and advice about health conditions in online peer support groups and to review the tools available for assessing the quality of such information. Methods: A scoping review was undertaken following the Joanna Briggs Institute scoping review methodology. We searched electronic databases (MEDLINE [Ovid], CINAHL, Web of Science, ASSIA, ProQuest Dissertation and Theses, and Google Scholar) for literature published before November 2023, as well as citations of included articles. Primary research studies, reviews, and gray literature that explored the quality of information and advice in online peer support groups were included. Title and abstracts were independently screened by 2 reviewers. Data were extracted and tabulated, and key findings were summarized narratively. Results: A total of 14 (0.45%) relevant articles, from 3136 articles identified, were included. Of these, 10 (71%) were primary research articles comprising diverse quality appraisal methodologies, and 4 (29%) were review articles. All articles had been published between 2014 and 2023. Across the literature, there was more evidence of poor quality information and misinformation than of good quality information and advice, particularly around long-term and life-threatening conditions. There were varying degrees of misinformation about non–life-threatening conditions and about mental health conditions. Misinformation about noncommunicable diseases was reported as particularly prevalent on Facebook. Fellow online peer support group users often played an active role in correcting misinformation by replying to false claims or providing correct information in subsequent posts. Quality appraisal tools were reported as being used by researchers and health care professionals in appraising the quality of information and advice, including established tools for the appraisal of health-related information (eg, DISCERN, HONcode criteria, and Journal of the American Medical Association benchmark criteria). No tools reported were specifically designed to appraise online peer support group content. Conclusions: While there is good quality information and advice exchanged between users in online peer support groups, our findings show that misinformation is a problem, which is a matter of public health concern. Confidence in the quality of information shared may determine the utility of online peer support groups for patients and health care professionals. Our review suggests that clinical and academic experts in health conditions could play a valuable role in ensuring the quality of content. Several quality appraisal tools are available to support such an initiative.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2025
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (759) , e703-e711
Evolution of the general practice receptionist role and online services: a qualitative study
Background: General practice receptionists are perceived as the ‘gatekeepers’ to primary care services and are central to managing patient demand and facilitating patient care. This role is evolving and becoming increasingly complex in a digital world. Aim: To consider the growing role of patient-facing online services and the impact these services have on the role of the general practice receptionist. Design and setting: A focused ethnographic case study was undertaken in eight general practices across England and 19 stakeholder interviews took place. Method: Focused ethnographic case study and stakeholder interviews were conducted between September 2021 and July 2022. Results: The receptionist role looks different across practices, but is now more varied and less repetitive than it has been historically. The volume of patients and number of channels by which patients contact the practice means that receptionists are dealing with increasingly complex demand management and navigation to appropriate services. This now includes online services, which has created a new element to the receptionist role — digital facilitation. The role is also largely navigated by the receptionists without any formal training and staff are mostly expected to learn on the job from other receptionists, leading to inconsistent practices. Conclusion: The digitalisation of healthcare services impacts the workflow and consistency in task completion of general practice receptionist staff and has potential implications regarding job satisfaction and retention. In addition, the knowledge and skills required to fulfil this role are evolving and therefore may have recruitment and training implications.
- 6 May 2025
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (759) , e703-e711
Open AccessEvolution of the general practice receptionist role and online services: a qualitative study
Background: General practice receptionists are perceived as the ‘gatekeepers’ to primary care services and are central to managing patient demand and facilitating patient care. This role is evolving and becoming increasingly complex in a digital world. Aim: To consider the growing role of patient-facing online services and the impact these services have on the role of the general practice receptionist. Design and setting: A focused ethnographic case study was undertaken in eight general practices across England and 19 stakeholder interviews took place. Method: Focused ethnographic case study and stakeholder interviews were conducted between September 2021 and July 2022. Results: The receptionist role looks different across practices, but is now more varied and less repetitive than it has been historically. The volume of patients and number of channels by which patients contact the practice means that receptionists are dealing with increasingly complex demand management and navigation to appropriate services. This now includes online services, which has created a new element to the receptionist role — digital facilitation. The role is also largely navigated by the receptionists without any formal training and staff are mostly expected to learn on the job from other receptionists, leading to inconsistent practices. Conclusion: The digitalisation of healthcare services impacts the workflow and consistency in task completion of general practice receptionist staff and has potential implications regarding job satisfaction and retention. In addition, the knowledge and skills required to fulfil this role are evolving and therefore may have recruitment and training implications.
- Open Access
- 30 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (3) , 161-170
Use of digital facilitation to support the use of digital services in general practice in England: An interview study with key stakeholders
Objective: Digital services in primary care are becoming more common, yet access to and use of services can create inequities. Our aim was to explore the drivers, priorities, and evolving policy context influencing digital facilitation in primary care as reported by national, regional and local level stakeholders in England. Methods: We conducted online semi-structured qualitative interviews with stakeholders, including those in NHS England organisations, local commissioners for health care, statutory and third sector organisations, those working within the research community, and digital platform providers. Interviews were analysed using a thematic approach. Results: The majority of stakeholders worked in national level roles, in commissioning or statutory and third sector organisations working in relation to digital inclusion and patient access. Demographic inequalities, poor usability of digital primary care services, and low digital skills were perceived to comprise some of the barriers facing patients in accessing and using digital primary care services. Demand pressures in general practice, inconsistent training opportunities in digital services for staff, and conflicting perceptions around who should be responsible in organising digital facilitation were reported as barriers in the organisation and provision of digital facilitation in primary care. Stakeholders shared future visions for digital primary care and recommended focusing on establishing the concept of digital facilitation and promoting the benefits in its adoption. Conclusions: Policy that is specific to digital facilitation and not just to digital services is required to establish clear lines of responsibility, investment in staff time and training, and the development of digital services that work well for various groups of patients and practice staff. A multi-organisational working team involving decision-makers and those working on the ground in general practice is encouraged to establish principles for supporting patients and staff in accessing and using digital primary care services in the NHS in England.
- 30 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (3) , 161-170
Open AccessUse of digital facilitation to support the use of digital services in general practice in England: An interview study with key stakeholders
Objective: Digital services in primary care are becoming more common, yet access to and use of services can create inequities. Our aim was to explore the drivers, priorities, and evolving policy context influencing digital facilitation in primary care as reported by national, regional and local level stakeholders in England. Methods: We conducted online semi-structured qualitative interviews with stakeholders, including those in NHS England organisations, local commissioners for health care, statutory and third sector organisations, those working within the research community, and digital platform providers. Interviews were analysed using a thematic approach. Results: The majority of stakeholders worked in national level roles, in commissioning or statutory and third sector organisations working in relation to digital inclusion and patient access. Demographic inequalities, poor usability of digital primary care services, and low digital skills were perceived to comprise some of the barriers facing patients in accessing and using digital primary care services. Demand pressures in general practice, inconsistent training opportunities in digital services for staff, and conflicting perceptions around who should be responsible in organising digital facilitation were reported as barriers in the organisation and provision of digital facilitation in primary care. Stakeholders shared future visions for digital primary care and recommended focusing on establishing the concept of digital facilitation and promoting the benefits in its adoption. Conclusions: Policy that is specific to digital facilitation and not just to digital services is required to establish clear lines of responsibility, investment in staff time and training, and the development of digital services that work well for various groups of patients and practice staff. A multi-organisational working team involving decision-makers and those working on the ground in general practice is encouraged to establish principles for supporting patients and staff in accessing and using digital primary care services in the NHS in England.
- Open Access
- 13 January 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Quality and Misinformation About Health Conditions in Online Peer Support Groups: Scoping Review (Preprint)
BACKGROUND The use of health-related online peer support groups to support self-management of health issues has become increasingly popular. The quality of information and advice may have important implications for public health and for the utility of such groups. There is some evidence of variable quality of web-based health information, but the extent to which misinformation is a problem in online peer support groups is unclear. OBJECTIVE We aimed to gain insight into the quality of information and advice about health conditions in online peer support groups and to review the tools available for assessing the quality of such information. METHODS A scoping review was undertaken following the Joanna Briggs Institute scoping review methodology. We searched electronic databases (MEDLINE [Ovid], CINAHL, Web of Science, ASSIA, ProQuest Dissertation and Theses, and Google Scholar) for literature published before November 2023, as well as citations of included articles. Primary research studies, reviews, and gray literature that explored the quality of information and advice in online peer support groups were included. Title and abstracts were independently screened by 2 reviewers. Data were extracted and tabulated, and key findings were summarized narratively. RESULTS A total of 14 (0.45%) relevant articles, from 3136 articles identified, were included. Of these, 10 (71%) were primary research articles comprising diverse quality appraisal methodologies, and 4 (29%) were review articles. All articles had been published between 2014 and 2023. Across the literature, there was more evidence of poor quality information and misinformation than of good quality information and advice, particularly around long-term and life-threatening conditions. There were varying degrees of misinformation about non–life-threatening conditions and about mental health conditions. Misinformation about noncommunicable diseases was reported as particularly prevalent on Facebook. Fellow online peer support group users often played an active role in correcting misinformation by replying to false claims or providing correct information in subsequent posts. Quality appraisal tools were reported as being used by researchers and health care professionals in appraising the quality of information and advice, including established tools for the appraisal of health-related information (eg, DISCERN, HONcode criteria, and Journal of the American Medical Association benchmark criteria). No tools reported were specifically designed to appraise online peer support group content. CONCLUSIONS While there is good quality information and advice exchanged between users in online peer support groups, our findings show that misinformation is a problem, which is a matter of public health concern. Confidence in the quality of information shared may determine the utility of online peer support groups for patients and health care professionals. Our review suggests that clinical and academic experts in health conditions could play a valuable role in ensuring the quality of content. Several quality appraisal tools are available to support such an initiative.
- 13 January 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessQuality and Misinformation About Health Conditions in Online Peer Support Groups: Scoping Review (Preprint)
BACKGROUND The use of health-related online peer support groups to support self-management of health issues has become increasingly popular. The quality of information and advice may have important implications for public health and for the utility of such groups. There is some evidence of variable quality of web-based health information, but the extent to which misinformation is a problem in online peer support groups is unclear. OBJECTIVE We aimed to gain insight into the quality of information and advice about health conditions in online peer support groups and to review the tools available for assessing the quality of such information. METHODS A scoping review was undertaken following the Joanna Briggs Institute scoping review methodology. We searched electronic databases (MEDLINE [Ovid], CINAHL, Web of Science, ASSIA, ProQuest Dissertation and Theses, and Google Scholar) for literature published before November 2023, as well as citations of included articles. Primary research studies, reviews, and gray literature that explored the quality of information and advice in online peer support groups were included. Title and abstracts were independently screened by 2 reviewers. Data were extracted and tabulated, and key findings were summarized narratively. RESULTS A total of 14 (0.45%) relevant articles, from 3136 articles identified, were included. Of these, 10 (71%) were primary research articles comprising diverse quality appraisal methodologies, and 4 (29%) were review articles. All articles had been published between 2014 and 2023. Across the literature, there was more evidence of poor quality information and misinformation than of good quality information and advice, particularly around long-term and life-threatening conditions. There were varying degrees of misinformation about non–life-threatening conditions and about mental health conditions. Misinformation about noncommunicable diseases was reported as particularly prevalent on Facebook. Fellow online peer support group users often played an active role in correcting misinformation by replying to false claims or providing correct information in subsequent posts. Quality appraisal tools were reported as being used by researchers and health care professionals in appraising the quality of information and advice, including established tools for the appraisal of health-related information (eg, DISCERN, HONcode criteria, and Journal of the American Medical Association benchmark criteria). No tools reported were specifically designed to appraise online peer support group content. CONCLUSIONS While there is good quality information and advice exchanged between users in online peer support groups, our findings show that misinformation is a problem, which is a matter of public health concern. Confidence in the quality of information shared may determine the utility of online peer support groups for patients and health care professionals. Our review suggests that clinical and academic experts in health conditions could play a valuable role in ensuring the quality of content. Several quality appraisal tools are available to support such an initiative.
- Open Access
- 21 November 2024
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (755) , e382-e389
Supporting patients to use online services in general practice: focused ethnographic case study
Background: In England online services in general practice encompass a range of provision from ordering repeat medication to having a consultation. Some groups of individuals may find accessing and/or using such services difficult and may require ‘digital facilitation’, that is the range of processes, procedures, and personnel which seeks to support NHS patients in their uptake and use of online services. Aim: To gain insight, from the perspective of general practice staff and patients/carers, into how and why digital facilitation might lead to benefits, and the key processes involved in supporting patients to use online services. Design and setting: Eight general practices across England with varied geographical and sociodemographic characteristics were included in the study. Method: This was a focused ethnographic case study of observations and interviews ( N = 69). Results: Typically, digital facilitation was delivered in an ad hoc fashion to individual patients. Online services were delivered via multiple systems each working differently and creating a need for support so that patients could access them. Younger practice staff were expected to deliver support on account of their age, despite there being no evidence of age-related training and experience. It was understood by practice staff that patients with challenging personal circumstances may require specific support to access online services. Conclusion: At present patient use of online services is supported by digital facilitation that is primarily delivered by reception staff. Supporting patients to use online services requires review of how many services are provided and what for, and consideration for the time and effort needed to support patients to use them.
- 21 November 2024
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (755) , e382-e389
Open AccessSupporting patients to use online services in general practice: focused ethnographic case study
Background: In England online services in general practice encompass a range of provision from ordering repeat medication to having a consultation. Some groups of individuals may find accessing and/or using such services difficult and may require ‘digital facilitation’, that is the range of processes, procedures, and personnel which seeks to support NHS patients in their uptake and use of online services. Aim: To gain insight, from the perspective of general practice staff and patients/carers, into how and why digital facilitation might lead to benefits, and the key processes involved in supporting patients to use online services. Design and setting: Eight general practices across England with varied geographical and sociodemographic characteristics were included in the study. Method: This was a focused ethnographic case study of observations and interviews ( N = 69). Results: Typically, digital facilitation was delivered in an ad hoc fashion to individual patients. Online services were delivered via multiple systems each working differently and creating a need for support so that patients could access them. Younger practice staff were expected to deliver support on account of their age, despite there being no evidence of age-related training and experience. It was understood by practice staff that patients with challenging personal circumstances may require specific support to access online services. Conclusion: At present patient use of online services is supported by digital facilitation that is primarily delivered by reception staff. Supporting patients to use online services requires review of how many services are provided and what for, and consideration for the time and effort needed to support patients to use them.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2024
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 12 (32) , 1-197
Current experience and future potential of facilitating access to digital NHS primary care services in England: the Di-Facto mixed-methods study
Background: Current National Health Service policy in England encourages enhanced digital access in primary care service provision. In this study, we investigate ‘digital facilitation’ – that range of processes, procedures and personnel which seeks to support National Health Service primary care patients in their uptake and use of online services. Objectives: Identify, characterise and explore the potential benefits and challenges associated with different models of digital facilitation currently in use in general practice which are aimed at improving patient access to online services in general practice in England. Use the resulting intelligence to design a framework for future evaluations of the effectiveness and cost effectiveness of such interventions. Explore how patients with mental health conditions experience digital facilitation and gauge their need for this support. Design: Observational mixed-methods study (literature review, surveys, ethnographic observation and interviews); formal synthesis of findings. Setting: General practice in four regions of England. Participants: Practice survey: 156 staff. Patient survey: 3051 patients. Mental health survey: 756 patients. General practitioner patient survey: 3 million responders. Ethnographic case-studies: 8 practices; interviews with 36 staff, 33 patients and 10 patients with a mental health condition. Stakeholder interviews: 19 participants. Intervention: Digital facilitation as undertaken in general practice. Main outcome measures: Patient and practice staff reported use of, and views of, digital facilitation. Data sources: Surveys, qualitative research; national General Practitioner Patient Survey (2019–22). Review methods: Scoping-review methodology applied to academic and grey literature published 2015–20. Results: While we did find examples of digital facilitation in routine practice, these often involved using passive or reactive modes of support. The context of COVID, and the necessary acceleration (at that time) of the move to a digital-first model of primary care, shaped the way digital facilitation was delivered. There was lack of clarity over where the responsibility for facilitation efforts lay; it was viewed as the responsibility of ‘others’. Patients living with mental health conditions had similar needs and experiences regarding digital facilitation to other patients. Limitations: The context of the COVID pandemic placed limitations on the project. Fewer practices responded to the practice survey than anticipated; reconfiguration of general practices to support COVID measures was a key consideration during non-participant observation with social distancing and other measures still in place during fieldwork. Conclusions: Digital facilitation, while not a widely recognised concept, is important in supporting the move to a National Health Service with enhanced digital opportunities and enhanced digital access. General practice staff are allocating resources to provide such efforts in general practices in England. The establishment of clear lines of responsibility, the development of digital tools and platforms that work for patients and practice staff, and investment in staff time and training are needed if digital facilitation is to support the intended digital revolution. Future work: We did not find one single dominant or preferred model of digital facilitation which might reasonably be considered to form the basis of an intervention to be tested. Rather, there is a need to co-develop such an intervention with patients, general practice staff and relevant policy experts. We outline a framework for a future evaluation of such an intervention. Study registration: This study is registered as ResearchRegistry6523 (www.researchregistry.com/browse-the-registry#home/?view_2_search=Di-Facto&view_2_page=1) and PROSPERO CRD42020189019 (www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=189019). Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme (NIHR award ref: NIHR128268) and is published in full in Health and Social Care Delivery Research; Vol. 12, No. 32. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 12 (32) , 1-197
Open AccessCurrent experience and future potential of facilitating access to digital NHS primary care services in England: the Di-Facto mixed-methods study
Background: Current National Health Service policy in England encourages enhanced digital access in primary care service provision. In this study, we investigate ‘digital facilitation’ – that range of processes, procedures and personnel which seeks to support National Health Service primary care patients in their uptake and use of online services. Objectives: Identify, characterise and explore the potential benefits and challenges associated with different models of digital facilitation currently in use in general practice which are aimed at improving patient access to online services in general practice in England. Use the resulting intelligence to design a framework for future evaluations of the effectiveness and cost effectiveness of such interventions. Explore how patients with mental health conditions experience digital facilitation and gauge their need for this support. Design: Observational mixed-methods study (literature review, surveys, ethnographic observation and interviews); formal synthesis of findings. Setting: General practice in four regions of England. Participants: Practice survey: 156 staff. Patient survey: 3051 patients. Mental health survey: 756 patients. General practitioner patient survey: 3 million responders. Ethnographic case-studies: 8 practices; interviews with 36 staff, 33 patients and 10 patients with a mental health condition. Stakeholder interviews: 19 participants. Intervention: Digital facilitation as undertaken in general practice. Main outcome measures: Patient and practice staff reported use of, and views of, digital facilitation. Data sources: Surveys, qualitative research; national General Practitioner Patient Survey (2019–22). Review methods: Scoping-review methodology applied to academic and grey literature published 2015–20. Results: While we did find examples of digital facilitation in routine practice, these often involved using passive or reactive modes of support. The context of COVID, and the necessary acceleration (at that time) of the move to a digital-first model of primary care, shaped the way digital facilitation was delivered. There was lack of clarity over where the responsibility for facilitation efforts lay; it was viewed as the responsibility of ‘others’. Patients living with mental health conditions had similar needs and experiences regarding digital facilitation to other patients. Limitations: The context of the COVID pandemic placed limitations on the project. Fewer practices responded to the practice survey than anticipated; reconfiguration of general practices to support COVID measures was a key consideration during non-participant observation with social distancing and other measures still in place during fieldwork. Conclusions: Digital facilitation, while not a widely recognised concept, is important in supporting the move to a National Health Service with enhanced digital opportunities and enhanced digital access. General practice staff are allocating resources to provide such efforts in general practices in England. The establishment of clear lines of responsibility, the development of digital tools and platforms that work for patients and practice staff, and investment in staff time and training are needed if digital facilitation is to support the intended digital revolution. Future work: We did not find one single dominant or preferred model of digital facilitation which might reasonably be considered to form the basis of an intervention to be tested. Rather, there is a need to co-develop such an intervention with patients, general practice staff and relevant policy experts. We outline a framework for a future evaluation of such an intervention. Study registration: This study is registered as ResearchRegistry6523 (www.researchregistry.com/browse-the-registry#home/?view_2_search=Di-Facto&view_2_page=1) and PROSPERO CRD42020189019 (www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=189019). Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme (NIHR award ref: NIHR128268) and is published in full in Health and Social Care Delivery Research; Vol. 12, No. 32. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.
- Open Access
- 14 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in JRSM Open
- Vol. 15 (1)
Informing the development of a scoring system for National Health Service Clinical Impact Awards; a Delphi process and simulated scoring exercise
Objectives: To establish principles informing a new scoring system for the UK's Clinical Impact Awards and pilot a system based on those principles. Design: A three-round online Delphi process was used to generate consensus from experts on principles a scoring system should follow. We conducted a shadow scoring exercise of 20 anonymised, historic applications using a new scoring system incorporating those principles. Setting: Assessment of clinical excellence awards for senior doctors and dentists in England and Wales. Participants: The Delphi panel comprised 45 members including clinical excellence award assessors and representatives of professional bodies. The shadow scoring exercise was completed by 24 current clinical excellence award assessors. Main outcome measures: The Delphi panel rated the appropriateness of a series of items. In the shadow scoring exercise, a novel scoring system was used with each of five domains rated on a 0–10 scale. Results: Consensus was achieved around principles that could underpin a future scoring system; in particular, a 0–10 scale with the lowest point on the scale reflecting someone operating below the expectations of their job plan was agreed as appropriate. The shadow scoring exercise showed similar levels of reliability between the novel scoring system and that used historically, but with potentially better distinguishing performance at higher levels of performance. Conclusions: Clinical excellence awards represent substantial public spending and thus far the deployment of these funds has lacked a strong evidence base. We have developed a new scoring system in a robust manner which shows improvements over current arrangements.
- 14 January 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in JRSM Open
- Vol. 15 (1)
Open AccessInforming the development of a scoring system for National Health Service Clinical Impact Awards; a Delphi process and simulated scoring exercise
Objectives: To establish principles informing a new scoring system for the UK's Clinical Impact Awards and pilot a system based on those principles. Design: A three-round online Delphi process was used to generate consensus from experts on principles a scoring system should follow. We conducted a shadow scoring exercise of 20 anonymised, historic applications using a new scoring system incorporating those principles. Setting: Assessment of clinical excellence awards for senior doctors and dentists in England and Wales. Participants: The Delphi panel comprised 45 members including clinical excellence award assessors and representatives of professional bodies. The shadow scoring exercise was completed by 24 current clinical excellence award assessors. Main outcome measures: The Delphi panel rated the appropriateness of a series of items. In the shadow scoring exercise, a novel scoring system was used with each of five domains rated on a 0–10 scale. Results: Consensus was achieved around principles that could underpin a future scoring system; in particular, a 0–10 scale with the lowest point on the scale reflecting someone operating below the expectations of their job plan was agreed as appropriate. The shadow scoring exercise showed similar levels of reliability between the novel scoring system and that used historically, but with potentially better distinguishing performance at higher levels of performance. Conclusions: Clinical excellence awards represent substantial public spending and thus far the deployment of these funds has lacked a strong evidence base. We have developed a new scoring system in a robust manner which shows improvements over current arrangements.