Tuulikki Laes
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Tuulikki Laes has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Heidi Westerlund
University of the Arts Helsinki, Finland
4 shared publications - Gert Biesta
The University of Melbourne
3 shared publications - Patrick Schmidt
ISNI: Western University
2 shared publications - Andrea Creech
ISNI: McGill University
1 shared publication Anna Kuoppamäki
Faculty of Music education, Jazz and Folk Music, Sibelius Academy, University of the Arts Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland
1 shared publication- Anniina Suominen
Aalto University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 19 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Research Studies in Music Education
Toward a Sustainable Musical Lifecourse Framework in Later-Life Music Education
This article proposes the Sustainable Musical Lifecourse framework as a theoretical orientation for addressing the challenges that lifelong music education faces in rapidly aging societies. Situated within the broader interconnections of lifelong learning and music education, the article builds on policy reflections from two distinct national contexts: Finland and China. By reframing the concept of later-life and examining current music learning opportunities for older adults, the study reveals that existing policy structures are often shaped by economic demands and the discourse of successful aging. These structures overlook the deeper pedagogical and existential possibilities of later-life music education. To address these limitations, the Sustainable Musical Lifecourse framework integrates four interrelated conceptual dimensions – lifecourse theory, transformative learning, sustainable aging, and gerotranscendence – to expand and envision personal transformation and social sustainability through music education in later life. This article contributes to developing practical approaches to lifelong music education by advancing a forward-looking perspective for envisioning alternative futures and more sustainable ways of living and learning through music in later life.
- 19 June 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Research Studies in Music Education
Toward a Sustainable Musical Lifecourse Framework in Later-Life Music Education
This article proposes the Sustainable Musical Lifecourse framework as a theoretical orientation for addressing the challenges that lifelong music education faces in rapidly aging societies. Situated within the broader interconnections of lifelong learning and music education, the article builds on policy reflections from two distinct national contexts: Finland and China. By reframing the concept of later-life and examining current music learning opportunities for older adults, the study reveals that existing policy structures are often shaped by economic demands and the discourse of successful aging. These structures overlook the deeper pedagogical and existential possibilities of later-life music education. To address these limitations, the Sustainable Musical Lifecourse framework integrates four interrelated conceptual dimensions – lifecourse theory, transformative learning, sustainable aging, and gerotranscendence – to expand and envision personal transformation and social sustainability through music education in later life. This article contributes to developing practical approaches to lifelong music education by advancing a forward-looking perspective for envisioning alternative futures and more sustainable ways of living and learning through music in later life.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Research Studies in Music Education
- Vol. 48 (2) , 149-165
Higher music education as a site of public pedagogy: Identifying institutional change in the Nordic countries
This study explores how higher music education institutions position themselves in relation to wider social and political forces and the expanding professional responsibilities of musicians in increasingly complex Nordic societies, which in this study includes Finland, Sweden, Norway and Denmark. By asking how the political—including various local and global social-ecological values, relations and power structures—is manifested in contemporary higher music performance study programs, the study aims to identify the challenges and possibilities of institutional change within higher music education in the Nordic context. Theoretically, we engage with Gert Biesta’s understanding of public pedagogy as an intrinsic part of educational endeavors that engage with the political and societal, thus promoting and serving as a catalyst for transformative change within higher music education. The data consists of five focus group interviews ( n = 13) and a questionnaire ( n = 29) addressed to the teachers and leaders of music performance programs in four higher music education institutions. We identified five emerging change identifications in the Nordic higher music institutions: (a) changing teacher roles, (b) students as change agents, (c) artists and/as citizens, (d) aesthetic and epistemic paradigm shifts, (5) negotiating institutional boundaries. The findings suggest that although the concept of public pedagogy is not yet fully established within these institutions, all three forms, (a) pedagogy for the public, (b) pedagogy of the public, and (c) pedagogy of publicness, are emerging. However, resistance to change could hinder higher music education from staying relevant amid current societal challenges and turbulence. By integrating public pedagogy into the daily practices and discourse of higher music education, both the necessary adaptation to political upheaval and the pedagogical and artistic identities of teachers and students could be strengthened.
- 10 September 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Research Studies in Music Education
- Vol. 48 (2) , 149-165
Open AccessHigher music education as a site of public pedagogy: Identifying institutional change in the Nordic countries
This study explores how higher music education institutions position themselves in relation to wider social and political forces and the expanding professional responsibilities of musicians in increasingly complex Nordic societies, which in this study includes Finland, Sweden, Norway and Denmark. By asking how the political—including various local and global social-ecological values, relations and power structures—is manifested in contemporary higher music performance study programs, the study aims to identify the challenges and possibilities of institutional change within higher music education in the Nordic context. Theoretically, we engage with Gert Biesta’s understanding of public pedagogy as an intrinsic part of educational endeavors that engage with the political and societal, thus promoting and serving as a catalyst for transformative change within higher music education. The data consists of five focus group interviews ( n = 13) and a questionnaire ( n = 29) addressed to the teachers and leaders of music performance programs in four higher music education institutions. We identified five emerging change identifications in the Nordic higher music institutions: (a) changing teacher roles, (b) students as change agents, (c) artists and/as citizens, (d) aesthetic and epistemic paradigm shifts, (5) negotiating institutional boundaries. The findings suggest that although the concept of public pedagogy is not yet fully established within these institutions, all three forms, (a) pedagogy for the public, (b) pedagogy of the public, and (c) pedagogy of publicness, are emerging. However, resistance to change could hinder higher music education from staying relevant amid current societal challenges and turbulence. By integrating public pedagogy into the daily practices and discourse of higher music education, both the necessary adaptation to political upheaval and the pedagogical and artistic identities of teachers and students could be strengthened.
- 27 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 11-25
Pedagogies of Hope in Times of Crises: Meanings of Arts Education Throughout the Lifespan
- 27 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 11-25
Pedagogies of Hope in Times of Crises: Meanings of Arts Education Throughout the Lifespan
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 134-136
A manifesto for transformative politics in music education
This book has aimed to present the complex questions that are connected and intertwined with music education as a social and political practice; a practice that continues to make some things possible for some, and excludes others and other possibilities at the same time. These questions go beyond ‘best practices’, established methods, and new models that aim to provide solutions for all situations, contexts, countries, and groups of people. Rather, they are questions that have no settled solutions and that require ‘staying with the trouble’. To support the message of the chapters in this book, we invite music educators to recognise, engage, and enact with difficult issues, problems, and paradoxes as part of the continuous effort of democratic experiments by imagining together what would, or could, music education look like if the following statements were the starting point for all thinking and action within the field.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 134-136
A manifesto for transformative politics in music education
This book has aimed to present the complex questions that are connected and intertwined with music education as a social and political practice; a practice that continues to make some things possible for some, and excludes others and other possibilities at the same time. These questions go beyond ‘best practices’, established methods, and new models that aim to provide solutions for all situations, contexts, countries, and groups of people. Rather, they are questions that have no settled solutions and that require ‘staying with the trouble’. To support the message of the chapters in this book, we invite music educators to recognise, engage, and enact with difficult issues, problems, and paradoxes as part of the continuous effort of democratic experiments by imagining together what would, or could, music education look like if the following statements were the starting point for all thinking and action within the field.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
The Transformative Politics of Music Education
This book introduces a unique approach to the interconnections between music education and politics. By taking a broader, more diverse, and explicitly ethico-political philosophical and theoretical stance, the book challenges institutional and structural conditions that may be resistant to change and expands the understanding of the professional responsibility of music educators in the 21st century to meet a variety of societal and ecological challenges. Emerging from a collaboration between international music education scholars and prominent contemporary educational theorist Gert Biesta, this book connects contemporary educational theories with music education to unlock its transformational capacity. In eight chapters, the contributors show how music education can move towards ways of being and doing that are attuned to social justice and to the broader social and ecological responsibility of music professionals. Strengthening the interdisciplinary connections between music education and education, philosophy, sociology, policy, systems thinking, and more, the volume offers a renewed vision of the scope and boundaries of both music teacher education and professional work in music more widely. Connecting the decades-long work of internationally established music educator scholars and ideas from large-scale research projects with a shared interest in transformative theorisation, this book fills a knowledge gap and reframes the philosophy of music education as a vibrantly multidisciplinary, theory-generating field. Relevant to researchers and students across music teacher education and performance studies, this book speaks to both conservatoires and university contexts across Europe and North America, helping us unlock the transformative capacity of music education.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
The Transformative Politics of Music Education
This book introduces a unique approach to the interconnections between music education and politics. By taking a broader, more diverse, and explicitly ethico-political philosophical and theoretical stance, the book challenges institutional and structural conditions that may be resistant to change and expands the understanding of the professional responsibility of music educators in the 21st century to meet a variety of societal and ecological challenges. Emerging from a collaboration between international music education scholars and prominent contemporary educational theorist Gert Biesta, this book connects contemporary educational theories with music education to unlock its transformational capacity. In eight chapters, the contributors show how music education can move towards ways of being and doing that are attuned to social justice and to the broader social and ecological responsibility of music professionals. Strengthening the interdisciplinary connections between music education and education, philosophy, sociology, policy, systems thinking, and more, the volume offers a renewed vision of the scope and boundaries of both music teacher education and professional work in music more widely. Connecting the decades-long work of internationally established music educator scholars and ideas from large-scale research projects with a shared interest in transformative theorisation, this book fills a knowledge gap and reframes the philosophy of music education as a vibrantly multidisciplinary, theory-generating field. Relevant to researchers and students across music teacher education and performance studies, this book speaks to both conservatoires and university contexts across Europe and North America, helping us unlock the transformative capacity of music education.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 81-98
Policy entrepreneurship
Looking back at the 2020s, there is no doubt that we live in a VUCA world (the acronym VUCA stands for volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity). First coined by the US Army, the acronym is now widely applied to society, describing how the world is constantly changing, becoming more unstable every day – albeit at different paces and volumes in different parts of the world. There is no doubt that the COVID-19 pandemic crisis alone has demonstrated the vulnerability of our global structures and the surprising interconnectedness between different economic, social, and educational systems. The pandemic’s unexpected threat led to the overload of health systems worldwide, the turmoil of economic and governmental structures, and the overwhelming mental burden, fear, and misery of individuals in all parts of the world. This will not be the last sudden crisis in the global world, with climate change, demographic transitions, and economic overload being just a few arenas of concern. While human life and education cannot focus simply on how to survive and adapt to such circumstances (Biesta, 2022, p. 11), today’s essential task for individuals and politically responsible governance is to consider not only how to manage risks by adjusting regulations but also how to respond to change more broadly and structurally and through collective action. Moreover, as anthropologist Arturo Escobar (2020) reminds us, the university itself is in crisis in a world that is in crisis. Consequently, in order to transform its conceptualisations and processes, higher education must deal with complexity in society while providing a sense of agency for its actors.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 81-98
Policy entrepreneurship
Looking back at the 2020s, there is no doubt that we live in a VUCA world (the acronym VUCA stands for volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity). First coined by the US Army, the acronym is now widely applied to society, describing how the world is constantly changing, becoming more unstable every day – albeit at different paces and volumes in different parts of the world. There is no doubt that the COVID-19 pandemic crisis alone has demonstrated the vulnerability of our global structures and the surprising interconnectedness between different economic, social, and educational systems. The pandemic’s unexpected threat led to the overload of health systems worldwide, the turmoil of economic and governmental structures, and the overwhelming mental burden, fear, and misery of individuals in all parts of the world. This will not be the last sudden crisis in the global world, with climate change, demographic transitions, and economic overload being just a few arenas of concern. While human life and education cannot focus simply on how to survive and adapt to such circumstances (Biesta, 2022, p. 11), today’s essential task for individuals and politically responsible governance is to consider not only how to manage risks by adjusting regulations but also how to respond to change more broadly and structurally and through collective action. Moreover, as anthropologist Arturo Escobar (2020) reminds us, the university itself is in crisis in a world that is in crisis. Consequently, in order to transform its conceptualisations and processes, higher education must deal with complexity in society while providing a sense of agency for its actors.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-10
Why music education needs transformative politics
The chapters brought together in this book collectively seek to make the case that music education today needs transformative politics. Transformative politics is used to describe work done “in order to introduce politics and policies that may enhance people’s chances of improving democracy as well as their capacity to make better use of it to foster their aims” (Stokke and Törnquist, 2013, p. 6). Transformative politics requires systemwide change that is not simply adding cultural change to existing practices but rather is about new social organisation and institutional reconfiguration, experimentation, and reconstructed understandings and rationales. Putting forward this claim, including arguing why there is such a need in contemporary music education, is one of the main ambitions of this book.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-10
Why music education needs transformative politics
The chapters brought together in this book collectively seek to make the case that music education today needs transformative politics. Transformative politics is used to describe work done “in order to introduce politics and policies that may enhance people’s chances of improving democracy as well as their capacity to make better use of it to foster their aims” (Stokke and Törnquist, 2013, p. 6). Transformative politics requires systemwide change that is not simply adding cultural change to existing practices but rather is about new social organisation and institutional reconfiguration, experimentation, and reconstructed understandings and rationales. Putting forward this claim, including arguing why there is such a need in contemporary music education, is one of the main ambitions of this book.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 63-80
The paradox of social innovations within music schools
Benevolence and equity have historically been among the founding values of the European music school system. The earliest forms of music schools (Conservatorio) in 16th-century Italy offered orphan children shelter, food, and music tuition while conserving the musical components of the church and sacred education (Kuha, 2017). Today, most European music schools are under governmental subsidy and regulation and organise music instrument tuition for those who apply as a supplement for basic music tuition given in comprehensive schools. The established position allows for advocacy and continuity of wide, cross-nation music school networks that state their mission objective as strengthening opportunities for qualified music training, 1 which, to some extent, seems to overshadow broader equity values. For example, in the Nordic countries where equality and access are general values of all education, music schools have been identified as elitist (Jordhus-Lier, Graabræk Nielsen and Karlsen, 2021; Väkevä, Westerlund and Ilmola-Sheppard, 2017; Väkevä, Westerlund and Ilmola-Sheppard, 2022) as they concentrate primarily on Western classical music and serve mainly white, middle-class children, thus reproducing inequalities (e.g. Galmiche et al., 2024; Ilmola-Sheppard et al., 2021; Westerlund et al., 2021). This criticism relates to unequal educational opportunities recognised on the governmental level (e.g. EU Youth Strategy, 2018), creating pressure also for music schools to improve and update their practices, access strategies and policies. Consequently, Nordic music school research has recently focused on diversity and inclusion policies (e.g. Rønningen et al., 2019, 2023) and expanding discussions from producing adequate musicians for the professional fields (e.g. Kuha, 2017) to reflecting on the social responsibilities of music schools (Laes et al., 2021; Westerlund, Väkevä and Ilmola-Sheppard, 2019).
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 63-80
The paradox of social innovations within music schools
Benevolence and equity have historically been among the founding values of the European music school system. The earliest forms of music schools (Conservatorio) in 16th-century Italy offered orphan children shelter, food, and music tuition while conserving the musical components of the church and sacred education (Kuha, 2017). Today, most European music schools are under governmental subsidy and regulation and organise music instrument tuition for those who apply as a supplement for basic music tuition given in comprehensive schools. The established position allows for advocacy and continuity of wide, cross-nation music school networks that state their mission objective as strengthening opportunities for qualified music training, 1 which, to some extent, seems to overshadow broader equity values. For example, in the Nordic countries where equality and access are general values of all education, music schools have been identified as elitist (Jordhus-Lier, Graabræk Nielsen and Karlsen, 2021; Väkevä, Westerlund and Ilmola-Sheppard, 2017; Väkevä, Westerlund and Ilmola-Sheppard, 2022) as they concentrate primarily on Western classical music and serve mainly white, middle-class children, thus reproducing inequalities (e.g. Galmiche et al., 2024; Ilmola-Sheppard et al., 2021; Westerlund et al., 2021). This criticism relates to unequal educational opportunities recognised on the governmental level (e.g. EU Youth Strategy, 2018), creating pressure also for music schools to improve and update their practices, access strategies and policies. Consequently, Nordic music school research has recently focused on diversity and inclusion policies (e.g. Rønningen et al., 2019, 2023) and expanding discussions from producing adequate musicians for the professional fields (e.g. Kuha, 2017) to reflecting on the social responsibilities of music schools (Laes et al., 2021; Westerlund, Väkevä and Ilmola-Sheppard, 2019).
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 119-133
The transformative politics of music education research
Due to rapid changes in diversifying societies, there is a need to create new transformative practices and policies that support systemic interconnectedness, including institutional music education. This need also transposes what is expected from music education research. Engaging with future-oriented, transformative research that aims towards a larger societal shift takes music education researchers beyond their traditional disciplinary boundaries and comfort zones. Even the wider methodological scholarship suggests that the social impact of research, including qualitative approaches, can only be constructed with a future-altering insight, not simply through illuminating existing societal problems (Gergen, 2015; see also Cairney, 2016). In Finland, which is the context of the authors of this chapter, the weak signals also include the altered status of the public use of scientific knowledge and criteria for competitive research funding, indicating, for example, how governmental funders and policymakers aim to bring research out from the silos and “ivory towers” towards inter-, trans-, and multi-disciplinarity that serves contemporary polycentric societies. At the same time, since contemporary academic work is conducted under a neoliberal political climate, evaluation, public trust, and valuation of research are increasingly affected by economically driven, quantifiable criteria leading to simplified impact measures and requirements towards intensified stakeholder collaboration. The shift thus requires music education researchers to have the capacity to navigate the complexities of political steering of funding systems and educational cultures while expanding their professionalism towards a socially responsible public scholarship.
- 3 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 119-133
The transformative politics of music education research
Due to rapid changes in diversifying societies, there is a need to create new transformative practices and policies that support systemic interconnectedness, including institutional music education. This need also transposes what is expected from music education research. Engaging with future-oriented, transformative research that aims towards a larger societal shift takes music education researchers beyond their traditional disciplinary boundaries and comfort zones. Even the wider methodological scholarship suggests that the social impact of research, including qualitative approaches, can only be constructed with a future-altering insight, not simply through illuminating existing societal problems (Gergen, 2015; see also Cairney, 2016). In Finland, which is the context of the authors of this chapter, the weak signals also include the altered status of the public use of scientific knowledge and criteria for competitive research funding, indicating, for example, how governmental funders and policymakers aim to bring research out from the silos and “ivory towers” towards inter-, trans-, and multi-disciplinarity that serves contemporary polycentric societies. At the same time, since contemporary academic work is conducted under a neoliberal political climate, evaluation, public trust, and valuation of research are increasingly affected by economically driven, quantifiable criteria leading to simplified impact measures and requirements towards intensified stakeholder collaboration. The shift thus requires music education researchers to have the capacity to navigate the complexities of political steering of funding systems and educational cultures while expanding their professionalism towards a socially responsible public scholarship.
- Open Access
- 27 September 2023
- Published by AccScience Publishing in International Journal of Population Studies
- Vol. 9 (3) , 15
Re-conceptualizing music education in the older adult life course: A qualitative meta-synthesis
The Seoul Agenda by UNESCO has set goals to develop arts education, ensuring that learners from all social backgrounds have lifelong access to arts education in a wide range of community and institutional settings. However, the purpose of lifelong learning for individuals beyond labor-market age has been largely overlooked, making it challenging to convince institutions, funders, and policymakers of its worth. The value accorded to the complex forms of lifelong learning in later life and the widely recognized health impacts of music on aging body and brain are the principal considerations to take into account when studying the effects of music education on older adults. In this study, we address the state-of-the-art research concerning older adults and music education in studies published in major peer-reviewed music education journals since the Seoul Agenda by UNESCO. We present the findings from a systematic literature review, followed by a qualitative meta-synthesis, focusing on the values, beliefs, and key concepts conveyed in the included studies. The findings of this study indicate that older adults are often portrayed narrowly and stereotypically, corroborating the issues in the sociology of aging. Our study highlights insights into the conceptualizations of music learning and participation in later life course and what these might mean for the policy and practice of later-life music education and the educational opportunities for older adults more broadly.
- 27 September 2023
- Published by AccScience Publishing in International Journal of Population Studies
- Vol. 9 (3) , 15
Open AccessRe-conceptualizing music education in the older adult life course: A qualitative meta-synthesis
The Seoul Agenda by UNESCO has set goals to develop arts education, ensuring that learners from all social backgrounds have lifelong access to arts education in a wide range of community and institutional settings. However, the purpose of lifelong learning for individuals beyond labor-market age has been largely overlooked, making it challenging to convince institutions, funders, and policymakers of its worth. The value accorded to the complex forms of lifelong learning in later life and the widely recognized health impacts of music on aging body and brain are the principal considerations to take into account when studying the effects of music education on older adults. In this study, we address the state-of-the-art research concerning older adults and music education in studies published in major peer-reviewed music education journals since the Seoul Agenda by UNESCO. We present the findings from a systematic literature review, followed by a qualitative meta-synthesis, focusing on the values, beliefs, and key concepts conveyed in the included studies. The findings of this study indicate that older adults are often portrayed narrowly and stereotypically, corroborating the issues in the sociology of aging. Our study highlights insights into the conceptualizations of music learning and participation in later life course and what these might mean for the policy and practice of later-life music education and the educational opportunities for older adults more broadly.