APAnnalise B. Paaby

Annalise B. Paaby

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Annalise B. Paaby has a total of 137 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Population structure and punctuated genomic hyper-diversity in Caenorhabditis briggsae

    by Nicolas D Moya, Bowen Wang, Robyn E Tanny, Michael E G Sauria, Lance M O’COnnor, Ayeh Khorshidian, Ryan McKeown, Charlie Gosse, Clayton M Dilks, Timothy A Crombie, et al.

    Comparative genomics provides a powerful framework to uncover the molecular and evolutionary mechanisms that shape genetic diversity, revealing how shared or lineage-specific processes influence their evolutionary trajectories. The nematode Caenorhabditis briggsae is distributed world-wide and is a comparative model to Caenorhabditis elegans in the biology of development, cellular mechanisms, neurobiology, complex trait mappings, and evolution. Following massive collection efforts by the nematode research community, we present the isolation of over 1,900 wild strains and analyses of genome sequences that catalog over six million single-nucleotide and insertion–deletion variants. These resources provide a powerful means to interrogate the causal genetic bases of phenotypic variation. Additionally, we describe C. briggsae population structure and discover new, genetically distinct groups within this primarily self-fertilizing species, including groups of highly related strains sampled across entire continents. We leveraged expansive genetic variation to decipher the effects of linkage and selection on the distribution of genetic diversity across the genome and across geographic regions. Within the species, we find genomic regions with extremely high levels of genetic variation similar to hyper-divergent regions found in C. elegans and other species. These regions harbor new genes and variation enriched for environmental sensing and pathogen responses. Based on comparisons to the outbreeding sister species Caenorhabditis nigoni, we conclude that long-term balancing selection has maintained substantial functional variation, likely associated with ecological variation, within C. briggsae since its divergence from an outbreeding ancestor. Overall, this massive strain resource enables future comparative genetics studies, including genome-wide association study contrasts between Caenorhabditis species.

  • Open Access

    How Does Transcription-Associated Mutagenesis Shape tRNA Microevolution?

    by Hector Baños, Ling Wang, Corinne Simonti, Annalise B Paaby, Christine Heitsch

    Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are among the most highly conserved and frequently transcribed genes. Recent studies have demonstrated that tRNAs experience exceptionally high rates of transcription-associated mutagenesis (TAM) as well as strong purifying selection. How the mutational input of TAM, which induces a non-uniform distribution of nucleotide substitutions, affects the fitness of tRNA molecules is unclear. Secondary structure in tRNAs is strongly conserved over macro-evolutionary time, suggesting that mutations that disrupt paired sites may be especially deleterious, and TAM-induced mutations primarily involve nucleotide transitions, which tend to preserve base-pairing stability. To examine how TAM affects tRNA molecule fitness and shapes tRNA evolution over short timescales, we analyzed tRNA allelic variation in contemporary Caenorhabditis elegans strains. We propose a model of tRNA microevolution driven by TAM and demonstrate that the observed secondary structure characteristics align with our predicted TAM-biased patterns. Furthermore, we developed a continuous Markov substitution model that incorporates TAM-specific mutational biases. This TAM-biased model fits the C.elegans tRNA data more effectively than standard models, such as the general time-reversible (GTR) model. Based on these results, we conclude that tRNAs in natural populations carry substantial levels of structure-destabilizing mutations, which may be tolerated but nevertheless likely induce meaningful fitness costs. Our findings are consistent with recent experimental studies on tRNA fitness in yeast, but challenge prior theoretical and computational analyses that emphasize RNA base-pairing as a primary determinant in genotype-phenotype systems.


  • Open Access

    Allelic Variation at tRNA Genes in Three Nematode Species Indicates Mutation Load Despite Strong Purifying Selection

    by Avery Davis Bell, Corinne Simonti, Hector Baños, Ling Wang, Christine Heitsch, Joseph Lachance, Annalise B Paaby

    Cytosolic transfer RNAs, which are encoded as hundreds of genes in nuclear genomes, experience exceptionally high mutation rates and have been hypothesized to confer substantial mutational load in natural populations. Although this phenomenon appears universal across multicellular eukaryotes, a comprehensive characterization of standing variation in tRNA repertoires is still lacking in any system. Here, we resolve within-species allelic variation in nuclear-encoded tRNAs in three nematode species: Caenorhabditis elegans, C. briggsae, and C. tropicalis. We show that these genes carry signatures of high rates of historical transcription-associated mutagenesis and of purifying selection, resulting in allelic variation that includes pervasive instances of within-gene mismatches between the amino acid recognized by the tRNA backbone and that indicated by the anticodon. Furthermore, patterns of tRNA genomic organization and variation differ markedly from those of protein-coding regions. Individual genomes harbor distinct complements of tRNA genes with predicted functional differences, an observation that coincides with recent evidence that variation in tRNA expression and regulation contributes to human disease. Our findings offer an entry point for identifying the micro-evolutionary processes that act on tRNA repertoires, and in turn connecting those processes to the macro-evolutionary patterns that have more frequently been the focus of study.


  • Open Access

    Caenorhabditis briggsae ancestral genomic hyper-diversity contrasts with globally distributed genome-wide haplotypes

    by Nicolas D. Moya, Bowen Wang, Robyn E. Tanny, Michael E.G. Sauria, Lance M. O'COnnor, Ayeh Khorshidian, Ryan McKeown, Charlie Gosse, Clayton M. Dilks, Timothy A. Crombie, et al.

    Comparative genomics provides a powerful framework to uncover the molecular and evolutionary mechanisms that shape genetic diversity within and across species, revealing how shared and lineage-specific processes influence their evolutionary trajectories through time. The nematode Caenorhabditis briggsae is distributed world-wide and is a comparative model to Caenorhabditis elegans in the biology of development, cellular mechanisms, neurobiology, genetic mappings of complex traits, and genome evolution. Following massive collection efforts by the nematode research community, we present the isolation of over 2,000 wild strains and analyses of genome sequences that catalog over six million single-nucleotide and insertion-deletion variants. This genome and strain resource provide a powerful means to interrogate the causal genetic bases of phenotypic variation for diverse traits. Additionally, we describe its global population structure and discover new and genetically distinct groups within this primarily self-fertilizing species, including groups of highly related strains that were sampled across different continents. We leverage expansive genetic variation to decipher the effects of linkage and selection on the distribution of genetic diversity across the genome and across geographic regions. Within the species, we find genomic regions with extremely high levels of genetic variation similar to hyper-divergent regions found in C. elegans and other species. These regions harbor new genes and variation enriched for environmental sensing and pathogen responses. In comparison to the outbreeding sister species Caenorhabditis nigoni , we conclude that long-term balancing selection has maintained substantial functional variation since the divergence from their outbreeding ancestor, likely in response to differences in the ecological niche. Overall, this massive strain resource enables future comparative genetics and genomics studies, including genome-wide association studies between Caenorhabditis species.


  • Open Access

    Allelic variation at tRNA genes in three nematode species indicates mutation load despite strong purifying selection

    by Avery Davis Bell, Corinne Simonti, Hector Baños, Ling Wang, Christine Heitsch, Joseph Lachance, Annalise B. Paaby

    Cytosolic transfer RNAs, which are encoded as hundreds of genes in nuclear genomes, experience exceptionally high mutation rates and have been hypothesized to confer substantial mutational load in natural populations. Although this phenomenon appears universal across multicellular eukaryotes, a comprehensive characterization of standing variation in tRNA repertoires is still lacking in any system. Here, we resolve within-species allelic variation in nuclear-encoded tRNAs in three nematode species: Caenorhabditis elegans , C. briggsae , and C. tropicalis . We show that these genes carry signatures of high rates of historical transcription-associated mutagenesis and of purifying selection, resulting in allelic variation that includes pervasive instances of within-gene mismatches between the amino acid recognized by the tRNA backbone and that indicated by the anticodon. Furthermore, patterns of tRNA genomic organization and variation differ markedly from those of protein-coding regions. Individual genomes harbor distinct complements of tRNA genes with predicted functional differences, an observation that coincides with recent evidence that variation in tRNA expression and regulation contributes to human disease. Our findings offer an entry point for identifying the micro-evolutionary processes that act on tRNA repertoires, and in turn connecting those processes to the macro-evolutionary patterns that have more frequently been the focus of study. Significance statement: Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are ancient and essential molecules that deliver amino acids to the growing polypeptide chain during protein synthesis. Despite their importance, little is known about how the genes encoding tRNAs vary among individuals, even though they accumulate large numbers of mutations due to their high rates of expression. Here, we report that three nematode species, including the model organism C. elegans , show within-species variation in their tRNA gene repertoires, which may cause differences in protein synthesis across individuals. Our findings may represent patterns common across multicellular species and they set the stage for future investigation into how this diversity influences cellular function and organismal fitness.

  • Open Access

    Variation in inbreeding depression within and among Caenorhabditis species

    by Matthew V Rockman, Max R Bernstein, Derin Çağlar, M Victoria Cattani, Audrey S Chang, Taniya Kaur, Luke M Noble, Annalise B Paaby

    Outbreeding populations harbor large numbers of recessive deleterious alleles that reduce the fitness of inbred individuals, and this inbreeding depression potentially shapes the evolution of mating systems, acting as a counterweight to the inherent selective advantage of self-fertilization. The population biological factors that influence inbreeding depression are numerous and often difficult to disentangle. We investigated the utility of obligately outcrossing Caenorhabditis nematodes as models for inbreeding depression. By systematically inbreeding lines from 10 populations and tracking line extinction, we found that inbreeding depression is universal but highly variable among species and populations. Inbreeding depression was detected across the life cycle, from mating to embryo production to embryonic viability and larval growth, and reciprocal crosses implicated female-biased effects. In most cases, the surviving inbred lines have dramatically reduced fitness, but the variance among inbred lines is substantial and compatible with the idea that inbreeding depression need not be an obstacle to the evolution of selfing in these worms. Populations of some species, including Caenorhabditis becei, exhibited modest inbreeding depression and could be tractable laboratory models for obligately outcrossing Caenorhabditis.


  • The regulatory architecture of gene expression variation in Caenorhabditis elegans revealed by multi-strain allele-specific analysis

    by Avery Davis Bell, Francisco Valencia, Annalise B Paaby

    An outstanding question in the evolution of gene expression is the composition of the underlying regulatory architecture and the processes that shape it. Mutations affecting a gene's expression may reside locally in cis or distally in trans; the accumulation of these changes, their interactions, and their modes of inheritance influence how traits are expressed and how they evolve. Here, we interrogated gene expression variation in Caenorhabditis elegans, including the first allele-specific expression analysis in this system, capturing effects in cis and in trans that govern gene expression differences between the reference strain N2 and 7 wild strains. We observed extensive compensatory regulation, in which opposite effects in cis and trans at individual genes mitigate expression differences among strains, and that genes with expression differences exhibit strain specificity. As the genomic distance increased between N2 and each wild strain, the number of genes with expression differences also increased. We also report for the first time that expression-variable genes are lower expressed on average than genes without expression differences, a trend that may extend to humans and Drosophila melanogaster and may reflect the selection constraints that govern the universal anticorrelation between gene expression and rate of protein evolution. Together, these and other observed trends support the conclusion that many C. elegans genes are under stabilizing selection for expression level, but we also highlight outliers that may be biologically significant. To provide community access to our data, we introduce an easily accessible, interactive web application for gene-based queries: https://wildworm.biosci.gatech.edu/ase/.


  • Open Access

    Variation in inbreeding depression within and among Caenorhabditis species

    by Matthew V. Rockman, Max R. Bernstein, Derin Çağlar, M. Victoria Cattani, Audrey S. Chang, Taniya Kaur, Luke M. Noble, Annalise B. Paaby

    Outbreeding populations harbor large numbers of recessive deleterious alleles that reduce the fitness of inbred individuals, and this inbreeding depression potentially shapes the evolution of mating systems, acting as a counterweight to the inherent selective advantage of self-fertilization. The population biological factors that influence inbreeding depression are numerous and often difficult to disentangle. We investigated the utility of obligately-outcrossing (gonochoristic) Caenorhabditis nematodes as models for inbreeding depression. By systematically inbreeding lines from ten populations and tracking line extinction, we found that inbreeding depression is universal but highly variable among species and populations. Inbreeding depression was detected across the life cycle, from mating to embryo production to embryonic viability and larval growth, and reciprocal crosses implicated female-biased effects. In most cases, the surviving inbred lines have dramatically reduced fitness, but the variance among inbred lines is substantial and compatible with the idea that inbreeding depression need not be an obstacle to the evolution of selfing in these worms. Populations of some species, including Caenorhabditis becei , exhibited modest inbreeding depression and could be tractable laboratory models for gonochoristic Caenorhabditis .

  • Open Access

    How Does Transcription-Associated Mutagenesis Shape tRNA Microevolution?

    by Hector Baños, Ling Wang, Corinne Simonti, Annalise B Paaby, Christine Heitsch

    Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are among the most highly conserved and frequently transcribed genes. Recent studies have demonstrated that tRNAs experience exceptionally high rates of transcription-associated mutagenesis (TAM) as well as strong purifying selection. How the mutational input of TAM, which induces a non-uniform distribution of nucleotide substitutions, affects the fitness of tRNA molecules is unclear. Secondary structure in tRNAs is strongly conserved over macro-evolutionary time, suggesting that mutations that disrupt paired sites may be especially deleterious, but TAM-induced mutations primarily involve nucleotide transitions, which tend to preserve base-pairing stability. To examine how TAM affects tRNA molecule fitness and shapes tRNA evolution over short timescales, we analyzed tRNA allelic variation in contemporary Caenorhabditis elegans strains. We propose a model of tRNA microevolution driven by TAM and demonstrate that the observed secondary structure characteristics align with our predicted TAM-biased patterns. Furthermore, we developed a continuous Markov substitution model that incorporates TAM-specific mutational biases. This TAM-biased model fits the C. elegans tRNA data more effectively than standard models, such as the general time-reversible (GTR) model. Based on these results, we conclude that tRNAs in natural populations carry substantial levels of structure-destabilizing mutations, which may be tolerated but nevertheless likely induce meaningful fitness costs. Our findings are consistent with recent experimental studies on tRNA fitness in yeast but challenge prior theoretical and computational analyses that emphasize RNA base-pairing as a primary determinant in genotype-phenotype systems. 1 Significance Statement: Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are ancient molecules, encoded as genes in all living systems. tRNA genes are known to experience exceptionally high rates of both mutation and purifying selection, but how these opposing evolutionary forces shape tRNA evolution is unclear. We developed a sequence substitution model specific to tRNA mutagenesis and applied it to standing variation in a natural population in order to infer how mutation and selection affect the structural stability of tRNA molecules.


  • Open Access

    The regulatory architecture of gene expression variation in C. elegans revealed by multi-strain allele-specific analysis

    by Avery Davis Bell, Francisco Valencia, Annalise B. Paaby

    An outstanding question in the evolution of gene expression is the composition of the underlying regulatory architecture and the processes that shape it. Mutations affecting a gene’s expression may reside locally in cis or distally in trans ; the accumulation of these changes, their interactions, and their modes of inheritance influence how traits are expressed and how they evolve. Here, we interrogated gene expression variation in C. elegans , including the first allele-specific expression analysis in this system, capturing effects in cis and in trans that govern gene expression differences between the reference strain N2 and seven wild strains. We observed extensive compensatory regulation, in which opposite effects in cis and trans at individual genes mitigate expression differences among strains, and that genes with expression differences exhibit strain specificity. As the genomic distance increased between N2 and each wild strain, the number of genes with expression differences also increased. We also report for the first time that expression-variable genes are lower expressed on average than genes without expression differences, a trend that may extend to humans and Drosophila melanogaster and may reflect the selection constraints that govern the universal anticorrelation between gene expression and rate of protein evolution. Together, these and other observed trends support the conclusion that many C. elegans genes are under stabilizing selection for expression level, but we also highlight outliers that may be biologically significant. To provide community access to our data, we introduce an easily accessible, interactive web application for gene-based queries: https://wildworm.biosci.gatech.edu/ase/ . Author Summary: Genes are first expressed as RNAs, which act as templates in the synthesis of proteins, the workhorse molecules of the cell. Naturally-occurring mutations can influence how RNA expression occurs; to evaluate how RNA expression varies among individuals and how such patterns evolve, the authors measured expression in wild strains of the nematode C. elegans and in offspring derived from crosses between them. This study describes the architecture of RNA expression variation in this essential model organism and reports novel patterns that may extend to insects and humans.