Sara Vima-Grau
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Sara Vima-Grau has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Còssima Cornadó
Architectural Technology Department, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya—Barcelona TECH, 08028 Barcelona, Spain
10 shared publications - Pilar Garcia-Almirall
Barcelona School of Architecture, Polytechnic University of Catalonia, 08028 Barcelona, Spain
8 shared publications - Pere-Joan Ravetllat
Architectural Design Department (ETSAB), Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya BarcelonaTech, 08028 Barcelona, Spain
5 shared publications - Cesar Diaz Gomez
Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya
4 shared publications Angel Uzqueda
Institut Municipal de l'Habitatge i Rehabilitació de Barcelona. Barcelona City Council. Doctor Aiguader, 26-36. 08003 Barcelona, Spain
2 shared publications- Angel Uzqueda
Municipal Institute of Housing and Renovation, Ajuntament de Barcelona, 08003 Barcelona, Spain
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 May 2025
- Published by Universitat Politecnica de Valencia in Loggia, Arquitectura & Restauración
- No. 38
Rehabilitación frente a demolición: el caso de DeFlat Kleiburg en Ámsterdam
El presente artículo plantea una reflexión en torno al legado arquitectónico residencial en Europa posterior a la Segunda Guerra Mundial, a través del estudio de la rehabilitación del edificio DeFlat Kleiburg, ubicado en el barrio Bijlmermeer de Ámsterdam (2017). En particular, se propone una revisión crítica sobre la obsolescencia de las grandes actuaciones residenciales modernas concebidas como respuesta a la necesidad de provisión masiva de vivienda en el período de posguerra, así como sobre las estrategias y motivaciones contemporáneas para su rehabilitación. El texto profundiza en el estudio de los debates y prácticas que entienden el entorno habitado como un componente crucial del patrimonio construido, subrayando la necesidad de preservar los conjuntos residenciales como instrumento para fortalecer la cohesión social. Asimismo, se analiza en detalle la transformación llevada a cabo en Kleiburg, basada en una estrategia de rehabilitación interior orientada a salvaguardar la composición, los acabados y la estructura original, al tiempo que promueve la flexibilidad funcional y la diversificación tipológica y de usos.
- 9 May 2025
- Published by Universitat Politecnica de Valencia in Loggia, Arquitectura & Restauración
- No. 38
Open AccessRehabilitación frente a demolición: el caso de DeFlat Kleiburg en Ámsterdam
El presente artículo plantea una reflexión en torno al legado arquitectónico residencial en Europa posterior a la Segunda Guerra Mundial, a través del estudio de la rehabilitación del edificio DeFlat Kleiburg, ubicado en el barrio Bijlmermeer de Ámsterdam (2017). En particular, se propone una revisión crítica sobre la obsolescencia de las grandes actuaciones residenciales modernas concebidas como respuesta a la necesidad de provisión masiva de vivienda en el período de posguerra, así como sobre las estrategias y motivaciones contemporáneas para su rehabilitación. El texto profundiza en el estudio de los debates y prácticas que entienden el entorno habitado como un componente crucial del patrimonio construido, subrayando la necesidad de preservar los conjuntos residenciales como instrumento para fortalecer la cohesión social. Asimismo, se analiza en detalle la transformación llevada a cabo en Kleiburg, basada en una estrategia de rehabilitación interior orientada a salvaguardar la composición, los acabados y la estructura original, al tiempo que promueve la flexibilidad funcional y la diversificación tipológica y de usos.
- Open Access
- 22 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Housing and the Built Environment
- Vol. 40 (2) , 845-874
A look at micro-scale spatial inequalities: housing conditions in the vulnerable areas of Barcelona’s historic center
This research presents a study of housing conditions in a context of extreme socio-residential vulnerability in the historic center of Barcelona that sheds light on important spatial inequalities that persist at the smallest scale. It is based on a mixed method design that combines database analysis based on primary data collected through an extensive fieldwork and qualitative study cases, using the dwelling as the unit of analysis. As a result, it offers a close look at a residential reality that cannot usually be described in larger scale geographic studies that are often based on insufficiently disaggregated data, especially in relation to spatial aspects. The analysis of housing conditions with a broader multi-scale approach highlights significant inequalities within the studied city block and its multifamily buildings. Generally, socio-spatial and dynamic aspects tied to the relationship between inhabitants and space, as well as conservation and maintenance actions carried out over time, are found to be more relevant than aspects merely tied to morphology. Quantifying and localizing the most critical cases is essential to observe some patterns of spatialization that question the role of exclusively physical morphologic and typological characteristics. These results are useful for understanding the role of housing conditions in the heterogeneous and complex realities of vulnerable areas, and they can be useful in detecting where and why certain housing rehabilitation policies based on large-scale socio-urban studies have difficulty making an impact. This research contributes both to the methods of analysis for the existing housing stock in vulnerable areas, and the current critical debates on housing rehabilitation and urban regeneration policy.
- 22 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Housing and the Built Environment
- Vol. 40 (2) , 845-874
Open AccessA look at micro-scale spatial inequalities: housing conditions in the vulnerable areas of Barcelona’s historic center
This research presents a study of housing conditions in a context of extreme socio-residential vulnerability in the historic center of Barcelona that sheds light on important spatial inequalities that persist at the smallest scale. It is based on a mixed method design that combines database analysis based on primary data collected through an extensive fieldwork and qualitative study cases, using the dwelling as the unit of analysis. As a result, it offers a close look at a residential reality that cannot usually be described in larger scale geographic studies that are often based on insufficiently disaggregated data, especially in relation to spatial aspects. The analysis of housing conditions with a broader multi-scale approach highlights significant inequalities within the studied city block and its multifamily buildings. Generally, socio-spatial and dynamic aspects tied to the relationship between inhabitants and space, as well as conservation and maintenance actions carried out over time, are found to be more relevant than aspects merely tied to morphology. Quantifying and localizing the most critical cases is essential to observe some patterns of spatialization that question the role of exclusively physical morphologic and typological characteristics. These results are useful for understanding the role of housing conditions in the heterogeneous and complex realities of vulnerable areas, and they can be useful in detecting where and why certain housing rehabilitation policies based on large-scale socio-urban studies have difficulty making an impact. This research contributes both to the methods of analysis for the existing housing stock in vulnerable areas, and the current critical debates on housing rehabilitation and urban regeneration policy.
- Open Access
- 11 April 2025
- Published by Ciudad y Territorio Estudios Territoriales in Ciudad Y Territorio Estudios Territoriales
- Vol. 57 (223)
Nueva vida en la azotea: promoviendo estrategias de sostenibilidad social en Barcelona
Revivir las azoteas es un proyecto desarrollado por la Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, Universitat de Barcelona y OasiUrbà (2021-2023). Su objetivo principal es mejorar la calidad de vida durante el envejecimiento de comunidades residenciales de Ciutat Vella, Barcelona, transformando las azoteas comunitarias en espacios de cuidados, socialmente responsables, a través de codiseñar y prototipar soluciones de bajo coste, sostenibles y desmontables. El principal resultado es remarcar las azoteas comunitarias como infraestructuras sociales clave en el avance hacia la ecologización urbana. Generar espacios de pacificación y socialización contribuyendo a la calidad de vida de la ciudadanía, especialmente en contextos con alta densidad demográfica y dinámicas de intensa turistificación.
- 11 April 2025
- Published by Ciudad y Territorio Estudios Territoriales in Ciudad Y Territorio Estudios Territoriales
- Vol. 57 (223)
Open AccessNueva vida en la azotea: promoviendo estrategias de sostenibilidad social en Barcelona
Revivir las azoteas es un proyecto desarrollado por la Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, Universitat de Barcelona y OasiUrbà (2021-2023). Su objetivo principal es mejorar la calidad de vida durante el envejecimiento de comunidades residenciales de Ciutat Vella, Barcelona, transformando las azoteas comunitarias en espacios de cuidados, socialmente responsables, a través de codiseñar y prototipar soluciones de bajo coste, sostenibles y desmontables. El principal resultado es remarcar las azoteas comunitarias como infraestructuras sociales clave en el avance hacia la ecologización urbana. Generar espacios de pacificación y socialización contribuyendo a la calidad de vida de la ciudadanía, especialmente en contextos con alta densidad demográfica y dinámicas de intensa turistificación.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2023
- Published by Universitat Politecnica de Valencia in VITRUVIO - International Journal of Architectural Technology and Sustainability
- Vol. 8 (1) , 70-83
Review of socio-residential vulnerability identification methodologies. Application to the cities of Bilbao and Barcelona
This article presents the most widely used methodologies to measure, analyse and assess the state of the building stock and the life conditions of people living in vulnerable neighbourhoods, in an attempt to identify limitations and opportunities within the design of more suitable instruments that will allow us to identify residential communities in a vulnerable situation, residential exclusion or at difficulty to access rehabilitation subsidies or allowances. The methodology adopted is based on the obtention of a first vulnerability index constructed from quantitative data that allows us to focus on the most vulnerable areas of the cities under study. Later, it is complemented with qualitative analysis, interviews to technical officers, entities’ representatives, and site visits and observations. The main obtained results consist of different methodological approaches and analytic and geospatial measurements of the residential vulnerability in the cities of Barcelona and Bilbao: from quantitative large-scale multicriterial analysis, geospatial analysis on specific aspects, to small-scale qualitative study cases, fieldwork and interviews to different actors. In conclusion, by applying those different methodologies in the same specific areas, we were able to determine how data disaggregation and specificity in relation to urban and building form and location provide relevant differential results that help to qualify certain patterns that can be detected but not explained by quantitative larger-scale integrative analysis. Besides, the qualitative information provided by key local agents of different networks was crucial to explain and understand the nature of geographical and time-changing patterns of residential vulnerability.
- 30 June 2023
- Published by Universitat Politecnica de Valencia in VITRUVIO - International Journal of Architectural Technology and Sustainability
- Vol. 8 (1) , 70-83
Open AccessReview of socio-residential vulnerability identification methodologies. Application to the cities of Bilbao and Barcelona
This article presents the most widely used methodologies to measure, analyse and assess the state of the building stock and the life conditions of people living in vulnerable neighbourhoods, in an attempt to identify limitations and opportunities within the design of more suitable instruments that will allow us to identify residential communities in a vulnerable situation, residential exclusion or at difficulty to access rehabilitation subsidies or allowances. The methodology adopted is based on the obtention of a first vulnerability index constructed from quantitative data that allows us to focus on the most vulnerable areas of the cities under study. Later, it is complemented with qualitative analysis, interviews to technical officers, entities’ representatives, and site visits and observations. The main obtained results consist of different methodological approaches and analytic and geospatial measurements of the residential vulnerability in the cities of Barcelona and Bilbao: from quantitative large-scale multicriterial analysis, geospatial analysis on specific aspects, to small-scale qualitative study cases, fieldwork and interviews to different actors. In conclusion, by applying those different methodologies in the same specific areas, we were able to determine how data disaggregation and specificity in relation to urban and building form and location provide relevant differential results that help to qualify certain patterns that can be detected but not explained by quantitative larger-scale integrative analysis. Besides, the qualitative information provided by key local agents of different networks was crucial to explain and understand the nature of geographical and time-changing patterns of residential vulnerability.
- Open Access
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Universitat Politecnica de Valencia in Loggia, Arquitectura & Restauración
- No. 35,p. 94-113
La arquitectura de la industria textil catalana: Can Bagaria y las técnicas constructivas en hierro
El presente artículo se centra en la fábrica histórica de Can Bagaria en Cornellà de Llobregat, Barcelona. A partir de su contextualización y caracterización constructiva se ejemplifica el momento culmen de la construcción en una época marcada por el auge industrial y la innovación tecnológica que experimenta Cataluña (cambio del s. XIX al s. XX). El desarrollo de las estructuras de hierro y fundición, en combinación con las tradicionales fábricas de ladrillo, llevaron a la gestación de un nuevo tipo arquitectónico porticado, bidireccional e isostático, del cual Can Bagaria representa uno de los ejemplos más evolucionados, tal como se constata a través del análisis de sus componentes estructurales y del conocimiento de sus precedentes tipológicos y tecnológicos.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Universitat Politecnica de Valencia in Loggia, Arquitectura & Restauración
- No. 35,p. 94-113
Open AccessLa arquitectura de la industria textil catalana: Can Bagaria y las técnicas constructivas en hierro
El presente artículo se centra en la fábrica histórica de Can Bagaria en Cornellà de Llobregat, Barcelona. A partir de su contextualización y caracterización constructiva se ejemplifica el momento culmen de la construcción en una época marcada por el auge industrial y la innovación tecnológica que experimenta Cataluña (cambio del s. XIX al s. XX). El desarrollo de las estructuras de hierro y fundición, en combinación con las tradicionales fábricas de ladrillo, llevaron a la gestación de un nuevo tipo arquitectónico porticado, bidireccional e isostático, del cual Can Bagaria representa uno de los ejemplos más evolucionados, tal como se constata a través del análisis de sus componentes estructurales y del conocimiento de sus precedentes tipológicos y tecnológicos.
- Open Access
Decision-Making Tool for the Selection of Priority Areas for Building Rehabilitation in Barcelona
The promotion of rehabilitation is an urgent necessity in today’s consolidated cities, both due to the need to update their buildings to achieve habitability and safety standards that are required nowadays, as well as to stop the deterioration of buildings in vulnerable environments, where paradoxically the obtainment of economic resources to invest in building maintenance and upgrade is scarcer. Decision making on the delimitation of areas in which the need to invest is higher is extremely complex and often relies on large secondary data studies that are contrasted with local stakeholders’ intuition and knowledge on the ground. Usually, rehabilitation aids are directed to relatively large areas, where a certain need may be found. However, these areas are often excessively wide and specific needs that would require special focus can be diluted in the whole. The current trend of area-based and site-specific rehabilitation programs calls for precise and focused data studies and methodologies. The research presented here provides a methodology for the selection of priority areas to promote rehabilitation in the context of Barcelona’s vulnerable neighborhoods. The selection methodology combines primary and secondary data with a very high level of disaggregation that identifies where the needs are greatest, and it also provides a tool that is still based on primary disaggregated data for the delimitation of areas. The results obtained highlight specific priority areas such as parts of the Raval, Carmel and Besòs-Maresme neighborhoods within larger zones that had been previously defined as vulnerable. The proposed methodology seeks to provide tools to foster evidence-based decision making, thus improving both the understanding of reality and its spatial distribution through data mining techniques and data visualization.
Open AccessDecision-Making Tool for the Selection of Priority Areas for Building Rehabilitation in Barcelona
The promotion of rehabilitation is an urgent necessity in today’s consolidated cities, both due to the need to update their buildings to achieve habitability and safety standards that are required nowadays, as well as to stop the deterioration of buildings in vulnerable environments, where paradoxically the obtainment of economic resources to invest in building maintenance and upgrade is scarcer. Decision making on the delimitation of areas in which the need to invest is higher is extremely complex and often relies on large secondary data studies that are contrasted with local stakeholders’ intuition and knowledge on the ground. Usually, rehabilitation aids are directed to relatively large areas, where a certain need may be found. However, these areas are often excessively wide and specific needs that would require special focus can be diluted in the whole. The current trend of area-based and site-specific rehabilitation programs calls for precise and focused data studies and methodologies. The research presented here provides a methodology for the selection of priority areas to promote rehabilitation in the context of Barcelona’s vulnerable neighborhoods. The selection methodology combines primary and secondary data with a very high level of disaggregation that identifies where the needs are greatest, and it also provides a tool that is still based on primary disaggregated data for the delimitation of areas. The results obtained highlight specific priority areas such as parts of the Raval, Carmel and Besòs-Maresme neighborhoods within larger zones that had been previously defined as vulnerable. The proposed methodology seeks to provide tools to foster evidence-based decision making, thus improving both the understanding of reality and its spatial distribution through data mining techniques and data visualization.
- Open Access
- 10 December 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (24) , 13659
Residential Vulnerability of Barcelona: Methodology Integrating Multi-Criteria Evaluation Systems and Geographic Information Systems
This article presents the methodology and results of a pioneering investigation in the determination and mapping of socio-residential vulnerability in the city of Barcelona according to a multi-criteria synthetic analysis. The methodology followed is based on a system of indicators elaborated from the exploitation of habitual statistical Open Data complemented with specific unprecedented data elaborated and supplied by the Barcelona City Council. The analysis is based on secondary data and it is structured in georeferenced axes, components, and indicators, which allow determination of the sociodemographic, socioeconomic, and urban and residential space characteristics at neighborhood, population census unit, and urban block level. The objective of the research was to detect, determine, and establish a measure of differentiation relative to the degree of residential vulnerability of some neighborhoods with respect to others, in order to seek prioritization measures for action in the most vulnerable areas. The results of the research provide a series of maps that allow us to define the areas where the highest levels of vulnerability indicators coincide according to a synthetic multi-criteria analysis.
- 10 December 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (24) , 13659
Open AccessResidential Vulnerability of Barcelona: Methodology Integrating Multi-Criteria Evaluation Systems and Geographic Information Systems
This article presents the methodology and results of a pioneering investigation in the determination and mapping of socio-residential vulnerability in the city of Barcelona according to a multi-criteria synthetic analysis. The methodology followed is based on a system of indicators elaborated from the exploitation of habitual statistical Open Data complemented with specific unprecedented data elaborated and supplied by the Barcelona City Council. The analysis is based on secondary data and it is structured in georeferenced axes, components, and indicators, which allow determination of the sociodemographic, socioeconomic, and urban and residential space characteristics at neighborhood, population census unit, and urban block level. The objective of the research was to detect, determine, and establish a measure of differentiation relative to the degree of residential vulnerability of some neighborhoods with respect to others, in order to seek prioritization measures for action in the most vulnerable areas. The results of the research provide a series of maps that allow us to define the areas where the highest levels of vulnerability indicators coincide according to a synthetic multi-criteria analysis.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2021
- Published by University of Deusto in Inguruak. Revista Vasca de Sociología y Ciencia Política
- No. 70
Brechas y oportunidades en el diseño y la gestión de políticas de regeneración urbana. Estudio de 5 barrios vulnerables de Barcelona.
En el marco de una investigación sobre políticas de regeneración urbana, este trabajo se propone realizar un análisis crítico de la manera en que ciertos programas “aterrizan” en 5 barrios de alta vulnerabilidad de la ciudad de Barcelona. A través de una estrategia de análisis cualitativo, busca captar posibles brechas entre lo que las políticas se proponen, y las realidades de los territorios en los que las intervenciones tienen lugar. Finalmente concluye mostrando cómo ciertos elementos como una clara voluntad política, una perspectiva integral y no compartimentada, una actitud proactiva en la promoción de procesos de organización y sobre todo de acompañamiento de las comunidades, una mirada atenta sobre los grupos vulnerables a los que las ayudas y programas tradicionales no llegan, entre otras, serían algunos de los elementos clave a tener en cuenta a la hora de diseñar y gestionar actuaciones de regeneración urbana en barrios vulnerables.
- 30 June 2021
- Published by University of Deusto in Inguruak. Revista Vasca de Sociología y Ciencia Política
- No. 70
Open AccessBrechas y oportunidades en el diseño y la gestión de políticas de regeneración urbana. Estudio de 5 barrios vulnerables de Barcelona.
En el marco de una investigación sobre políticas de regeneración urbana, este trabajo se propone realizar un análisis crítico de la manera en que ciertos programas “aterrizan” en 5 barrios de alta vulnerabilidad de la ciudad de Barcelona. A través de una estrategia de análisis cualitativo, busca captar posibles brechas entre lo que las políticas se proponen, y las realidades de los territorios en los que las intervenciones tienen lugar. Finalmente concluye mostrando cómo ciertos elementos como una clara voluntad política, una perspectiva integral y no compartimentada, una actitud proactiva en la promoción de procesos de organización y sobre todo de acompañamiento de las comunidades, una mirada atenta sobre los grupos vulnerables a los que las ayudas y programas tradicionales no llegan, entre otras, serían algunos de los elementos clave a tener en cuenta a la hora de diseñar y gestionar actuaciones de regeneración urbana en barrios vulnerables.
- Open Access
- 21 April 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (9) , 4598
Multiscale Integral Assessment of Habitability in the Case of El Raval in Barcelona
The understanding of habitability conditions of existing housing stock plays a central role in the quantification and qualification of sustainability from the architectural field. This research assessed habitability as a fundamental social benefit by means of a multiscale approach to the case study of the Raval neighborhood that can be replicated in other settings. We described a sample of six hundred dwellings located in two urban blocks spatially and typologically. This analysis of architectural features incorporated information on the current occupancy and use of spaces and the assessment of the state of conservation and maintenance of building envelopes and common elements. Although the scale of most analyzed aspects was larger (building, urban block or urban fabric), the discussion of results by housing unit provided a close picture of the existing diversity and heterogeneity of socio-spatial and architectural realities within buildings and urban blocks. Results from this paper allow for the valuation and discussion of substandard housing cases that call for an immediate improvement and adaptation, while providing evidence that most dwellings fail to fulfill residents’ right to adequate housing. In conclusion, the results obtained highlight the importance of designing rehabilitation programs and instruments to improve existing spaces with a focus on current use, occupancy, and residents’ needs.
- 21 April 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (9) , 4598
Open AccessMultiscale Integral Assessment of Habitability in the Case of El Raval in Barcelona
The understanding of habitability conditions of existing housing stock plays a central role in the quantification and qualification of sustainability from the architectural field. This research assessed habitability as a fundamental social benefit by means of a multiscale approach to the case study of the Raval neighborhood that can be replicated in other settings. We described a sample of six hundred dwellings located in two urban blocks spatially and typologically. This analysis of architectural features incorporated information on the current occupancy and use of spaces and the assessment of the state of conservation and maintenance of building envelopes and common elements. Although the scale of most analyzed aspects was larger (building, urban block or urban fabric), the discussion of results by housing unit provided a close picture of the existing diversity and heterogeneity of socio-spatial and architectural realities within buildings and urban blocks. Results from this paper allow for the valuation and discussion of substandard housing cases that call for an immediate improvement and adaptation, while providing evidence that most dwellings fail to fulfill residents’ right to adequate housing. In conclusion, the results obtained highlight the importance of designing rehabilitation programs and instruments to improve existing spaces with a focus on current use, occupancy, and residents’ needs.
- Open Access
Critical Review of Public Policies for the Rehabilitation of Housing Stock: The Case of Barcelona
This article reviews rehabilitation programs in Barcelona, focusing on aspects such as the intervention model, actual public investment, and results. Programs of this type are not exclusive to Barcelona; however, similar examples can be found in other European cities, especially where European Union (EU) funding is present. After analyzing these models, we reached a series of general conclusions that may be of interest. Thus, an eminently practical and reflective analysis is presented, aimed at technicians and those responsible for the design of intervention policies in urban regeneration. Rehabilitation programs are increasingly focused on vulnerable settings, and in this context, the participation and service function of public administrations are particularly relevant. The general model for rehabilitation subsidies rarely takes into account the specific characteristics of disadvantaged urban settings, as the article will show. After analyzing the different policies presented in this research, we identified two essential requirements: detailed knowledge of the affected neighborhood, and ongoing evaluation of the development of programs—beyond simple management indicators—so negative effects can be corrected in time such as gentrification, real estate speculation, and other by-products that the intervention itself can promote. This study confirms that not all public investments have the expected results.
Open AccessCritical Review of Public Policies for the Rehabilitation of Housing Stock: The Case of Barcelona
This article reviews rehabilitation programs in Barcelona, focusing on aspects such as the intervention model, actual public investment, and results. Programs of this type are not exclusive to Barcelona; however, similar examples can be found in other European cities, especially where European Union (EU) funding is present. After analyzing these models, we reached a series of general conclusions that may be of interest. Thus, an eminently practical and reflective analysis is presented, aimed at technicians and those responsible for the design of intervention policies in urban regeneration. Rehabilitation programs are increasingly focused on vulnerable settings, and in this context, the participation and service function of public administrations are particularly relevant. The general model for rehabilitation subsidies rarely takes into account the specific characteristics of disadvantaged urban settings, as the article will show. After analyzing the different policies presented in this research, we identified two essential requirements: detailed knowledge of the affected neighborhood, and ongoing evaluation of the development of programs—beyond simple management indicators—so negative effects can be corrected in time such as gentrification, real estate speculation, and other by-products that the intervention itself can promote. This study confirms that not all public investments have the expected results.