Martina van Heerden
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Martina van Heerden has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Sharita Bharuthram
University of the Western Cape
3 shared publications - Sherran Clarence
Rhodes University
3 shared publications Sharita Bharuthram
English for Educational Development, University of the Western Cape, Cape Town, South Africa
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 June 2026
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 14 (1)
Editorial
Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning (CriSTaL) is an open access journal publishing critical scholarship on teaching and learning in higher education, with a focus on South African, African and international contexts.
- 27 June 2026
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 14 (1)
Open AccessEditorial
Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning (CriSTaL) is an open access journal publishing critical scholarship on teaching and learning in higher education, with a focus on South African, African and international contexts.
- Open Access
- 30 September 2025
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 13 (2) , 98-118
“It’s the lecturers to lose”: Examining ‘trust’ in the feedback dialogue
“Feedback trust” is an important, though often take-for-granted component of the feedback dialogue. If not maintained, it may be easily lost or broken, which may impact the effectiveness of feedback. In this paper, I unpack the notion of feedback trust by examining what are the factors that enable (or constrain) it, whether feedback trust is automatic, and whether feedback trust can be repaired. The paper is framed by Tschannen-Moran and Hoy’s (2000) conceptualisation of trust. Qualitative data were collected from Honours students in an Arts and Humanities Faculty at a South African university using questionnaires (15) and interviews (6); data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. The results broadly indicate that there are three main factors that influence feedback trust: the feedback itself, the feedback giver, and the feedback community. In addition, the results show that feedback trust is to some degree automatic, as it is tied to the role of feedback giver, but that it may strengthen or weaken over time, depending on experience. Lastly, the results show that feedback trust can be repaired through communication, though it depends on how it was broken or lost. This paper outlines that there are four Cs necessary to build, maintain, and repair feedback trust between students and educators: connection, communication, care, and comments.
- 30 September 2025
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 13 (2) , 98-118
Open Access“It’s the lecturers to lose”: Examining ‘trust’ in the feedback dialogue
“Feedback trust” is an important, though often take-for-granted component of the feedback dialogue. If not maintained, it may be easily lost or broken, which may impact the effectiveness of feedback. In this paper, I unpack the notion of feedback trust by examining what are the factors that enable (or constrain) it, whether feedback trust is automatic, and whether feedback trust can be repaired. The paper is framed by Tschannen-Moran and Hoy’s (2000) conceptualisation of trust. Qualitative data were collected from Honours students in an Arts and Humanities Faculty at a South African university using questionnaires (15) and interviews (6); data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. The results broadly indicate that there are three main factors that influence feedback trust: the feedback itself, the feedback giver, and the feedback community. In addition, the results show that feedback trust is to some degree automatic, as it is tied to the role of feedback giver, but that it may strengthen or weaken over time, depending on experience. Lastly, the results show that feedback trust can be repaired through communication, though it depends on how it was broken or lost. This paper outlines that there are four Cs necessary to build, maintain, and repair feedback trust between students and educators: connection, communication, care, and comments.
- Open Access
- 20 July 2025
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in The Independent Journal of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 15 (2) , 24-35
To use or not to use? Understanding the connection between using peer and tutor feedback and self-regulated learning
Peer and tutor feedback can play a significant role in developing self-regulated learners. It is generally perceived that giving peer feedback is more useful to students. However, the extent to which peer feedback is used is relatively under-researched. This paper examines the use of peer and tutor feedback by undergraduate students. Data were collected qualitatively by means of a student questionnaire. The results show that most students passively and uncritically implemented all the tutor feedback, mostly because they regarded the tutor as the expert. However, the validity of feedback from peers was questioned and challenged, implying that more engagement occurred when implementing peer feedback than tutor feedback. The results suggest that although using tutor feedback may have resulted in better quality essays, using peer feedback led to more critical engagement with the feedback and in so doing enabled greater self-regulated learning.
- 20 July 2025
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in The Independent Journal of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 15 (2) , 24-35
Open AccessTo use or not to use? Understanding the connection between using peer and tutor feedback and self-regulated learning
Peer and tutor feedback can play a significant role in developing self-regulated learners. It is generally perceived that giving peer feedback is more useful to students. However, the extent to which peer feedback is used is relatively under-researched. This paper examines the use of peer and tutor feedback by undergraduate students. Data were collected qualitatively by means of a student questionnaire. The results show that most students passively and uncritically implemented all the tutor feedback, mostly because they regarded the tutor as the expert. However, the validity of feedback from peers was questioned and challenged, implying that more engagement occurred when implementing peer feedback than tutor feedback. The results suggest that although using tutor feedback may have resulted in better quality essays, using peer feedback led to more critical engagement with the feedback and in so doing enabled greater self-regulated learning.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Innovations in Education and Teaching International
- Vol. 62 (6) , 1890-1904
Whose ‘useful’ is it anyway? Considering the complexity of ‘useful feedback’ to improve the feedback dialogue
- 4 December 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Innovations in Education and Teaching International
- Vol. 62 (6) , 1890-1904
Open AccessWhose ‘useful’ is it anyway? Considering the complexity of ‘useful feedback’ to improve the feedback dialogue
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by University of the Western Cape Library Service in Multilingual Margins: A journal of multilingualism from the periphery
- Vol. 11 (1)
A/part: Writing retreats as spaces fostering a sense of belonging for academic staff
In June 2022, I attended a teaching and learning writing retreat with other early career researchers, the deputy dean of teaching and learning of the faculty, and the teaching and learning specialist for our faculty. I had recently completed my teaching portfolio as part of my probationary requirements and had been asked to join the retreat to guide and assist the other early career researchers who were working on their teaching portfolios at the time. At this specific retreat, we had quite a few frank discussions about our teaching and learning background experiences and we were given the space to be vulnerable and open with one another. At the time, I was working on a paper on student belonging, and I noted the parallel between what I was reading about student belonging and what I was experiencing at the retreat: a profound sense of being a part of a group, of belonging.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by University of the Western Cape Library Service in Multilingual Margins: A journal of multilingualism from the periphery
- Vol. 11 (1)
Open AccessA/part: Writing retreats as spaces fostering a sense of belonging for academic staff
In June 2022, I attended a teaching and learning writing retreat with other early career researchers, the deputy dean of teaching and learning of the faculty, and the teaching and learning specialist for our faculty. I had recently completed my teaching portfolio as part of my probationary requirements and had been asked to join the retreat to guide and assist the other early career researchers who were working on their teaching portfolios at the time. At this specific retreat, we had quite a few frank discussions about our teaching and learning background experiences and we were given the space to be vulnerable and open with one another. At the time, I was working on a paper on student belonging, and I noted the parallel between what I was reading about student belonging and what I was experiencing at the retreat: a profound sense of being a part of a group, of belonging.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 11 (1) , 96-119
Doctor who? Developing a translation device for exploring successful doctoral being and becoming
Doctoral training and education tends to focus on how to research and write a thesis, which can take many forms. However, a thesis is not the only valued outcome of a doctorate: the emerging Doctor is important too. Being and becoming a Doctor implies identity work and engaging affective dimensions of researcher development alongside researching and writing a thesis. These are not always explicit in doctoral education, though. Thus, we contend that their role in researcher development needs to be named, described, and understood. In this paper we use Constellations from Legitimation Code Theory to make visible two valued doctoral attributes and dispositions as exemplars. We have used published papers in the field of doctoral studies as data. Within increasingly diverse doctoral student cohorts, it is important to actively foreground the development of valued affective dispositions through doctoral education to enable more candidates to achieve success in their doctorates.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 11 (1) , 96-119
Open AccessDoctor who? Developing a translation device for exploring successful doctoral being and becoming
Doctoral training and education tends to focus on how to research and write a thesis, which can take many forms. However, a thesis is not the only valued outcome of a doctorate: the emerging Doctor is important too. Being and becoming a Doctor implies identity work and engaging affective dimensions of researcher development alongside researching and writing a thesis. These are not always explicit in doctoral education, though. Thus, we contend that their role in researcher development needs to be named, described, and understood. In this paper we use Constellations from Legitimation Code Theory to make visible two valued doctoral attributes and dispositions as exemplars. We have used published papers in the field of doctoral studies as data. Within increasingly diverse doctoral student cohorts, it is important to actively foreground the development of valued affective dispositions through doctoral education to enable more candidates to achieve success in their doctorates.
- 16 February 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Innovations in Education and Teaching International
- Vol. 60 (3) , 379-389
The affective effect: Exploring undergraduate students’ emotions in giving and receiving peer feedback
While the peer feedback process has an important role to play in student learning and has many benefits, it is not without its challenges. One of these is the effect that emotions may have on the way that students engage with the feedback. Yet, the specific emotions experienced during peer feedback is relatively under-explored. Therefore, this exploratory qualitative study unpacks the range of emotions experienced by students during peer feedback. Using Plutchnik’s Wheel of Emotions to analyse students’ questionnaire responses, the study found that students largely exhibited positive emotions, which may be due to their perceptions of themselves in relation to the process, as well as the various scaffolds put in place. Knowing which emotions students experienced during peer feedback may enable a greater understanding of the role of emotions in peer feedback, as well as enabling student feedback literacy development.
- 16 February 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Innovations in Education and Teaching International
- Vol. 60 (3) , 379-389
The affective effect: Exploring undergraduate students’ emotions in giving and receiving peer feedback
While the peer feedback process has an important role to play in student learning and has many benefits, it is not without its challenges. One of these is the effect that emotions may have on the way that students engage with the feedback. Yet, the specific emotions experienced during peer feedback is relatively under-explored. Therefore, this exploratory qualitative study unpacks the range of emotions experienced by students during peer feedback. Using Plutchnik’s Wheel of Emotions to analyse students’ questionnaire responses, the study found that students largely exhibited positive emotions, which may be due to their perceptions of themselves in relation to the process, as well as the various scaffolds put in place. Knowing which emotions students experienced during peer feedback may enable a greater understanding of the role of emotions in peer feedback, as well as enabling student feedback literacy development.
- 3 January 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 46 (8) , 1191-1201
Knowing me, knowing you: the effects of peer familiarity on receiving peer feedback for undergraduate student writers
Anonymity has been suggested as a way to mitigate the possible negative effects of interpersonal variables that may arise during the peer review process. However, since anonymity is not always possible, it is important to consider how the level of familiarity between peers may influence the peer review process. This study therefore explores the effect that peer familiarity has on receiving feedback from peers. A qualitative and quantitative analysis of the data, collected via a questionnaire, reveals that the majority of the students knew their peers very or fairly well and felt comfortable and enjoyed working with them. The process was less confrontational, with more honesty and trust, and better communication. The few students who did not know their peers well felt that they could be more objective in their feedback. The authors conclude that the level of peer familiarity provides a different perspective to the peer review process, especially in contexts where anonymity is not possible.
- 3 January 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 46 (8) , 1191-1201
Knowing me, knowing you: the effects of peer familiarity on receiving peer feedback for undergraduate student writers
Anonymity has been suggested as a way to mitigate the possible negative effects of interpersonal variables that may arise during the peer review process. However, since anonymity is not always possible, it is important to consider how the level of familiarity between peers may influence the peer review process. This study therefore explores the effect that peer familiarity has on receiving feedback from peers. A qualitative and quantitative analysis of the data, collected via a questionnaire, reveals that the majority of the students knew their peers very or fairly well and felt comfortable and enjoyed working with them. The process was less confrontational, with more honesty and trust, and better communication. The few students who did not know their peers well felt that they could be more objective in their feedback. The authors conclude that the level of peer familiarity provides a different perspective to the peer review process, especially in contexts where anonymity is not possible.
- 30 June 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Innovations in Education and Teaching International
- Vol. 58 (5) , 555-564
(How) do written comments feed-forward? A translation device for developing tutors’ feedback-giving literacy
In order for feedback to effectively facilitate learning and development, it needs to feed-forward from one assignment to the next. Yet, it is not always clear how to determine if feedback is actually feeding forward. This paper, therefore, presents a translation device, using Legitimation Code Theory, and specifically, semantic gravity, to help tutors better understand whether, and to what extent, their feedback is feeding forward. The aim is to help tutors better develop their feedback-giving literacy.
- 30 June 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Innovations in Education and Teaching International
- Vol. 58 (5) , 555-564
(How) do written comments feed-forward? A translation device for developing tutors’ feedback-giving literacy
In order for feedback to effectively facilitate learning and development, it needs to feed-forward from one assignment to the next. Yet, it is not always clear how to determine if feedback is actually feeding forward. This paper, therefore, presents a translation device, using Legitimation Code Theory, and specifically, semantic gravity, to help tutors better understand whether, and to what extent, their feedback is feeding forward. The aim is to help tutors better develop their feedback-giving literacy.
- 27 May 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 145-161
Changing curriculum and teaching practice
An underdeveloped aspect of academic staff development research in higher education is using theory to help academic lecturers to understand and inform their practices, so as to better enable student development and learning. This chapter illustrates how a theorized way of talking about teaching and learning, specifically using the LCT dimension of Semantics, both semantic waves and the semantic plane, may create exciting and productive conversations with academic lecturers. Using two ‘vignettes’ drawn from English Studies and Political Studies, the chapter illustrates how teaching practice and curriculum design can be enhanced by using LCT in academic staff development work, and by extension in curriculum design, teaching and assessment practice.
- 27 May 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 145-161
Changing curriculum and teaching practice
An underdeveloped aspect of academic staff development research in higher education is using theory to help academic lecturers to understand and inform their practices, so as to better enable student development and learning. This chapter illustrates how a theorized way of talking about teaching and learning, specifically using the LCT dimension of Semantics, both semantic waves and the semantic plane, may create exciting and productive conversations with academic lecturers. Using two ‘vignettes’ drawn from English Studies and Political Studies, the chapter illustrates how teaching practice and curriculum design can be enhanced by using LCT in academic staff development work, and by extension in curriculum design, teaching and assessment practice.