Iryna Nadtochii
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Iryna Nadtochii has a total of 90 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alla V. Rusnak
Kherson Educational-Scientific Institute of Admiral Makarov National University of Shipbuilding
13 shared publications - Iryna Kramarenko
Admiral Makarov National University of Shipbuilding
10 shared publications - Nataliya Hryshyna
Admiral Makarov National Shipbuilding University
7 shared publications - Inna Irtyshcheva
Admiral Makarov National University of Shipbuilding
5 shared publications - Tetiana Cherniavska
State University of Applied Sciences in Konin
5 shared publications - Bohdan Cherniavskyi
State University of Applied Sciences in Konin
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 8 October 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in Business Navigator
- No. 5(88)
INTERNAL EDUCATION QUALITY ASSURANCE SYSTEM AS A TOOL FOR EFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT OF AN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION
The article examines the internal system of education quality assurance as a tool for effective management of an educational institution in modern Ukrainian and European conditions. The relevance of the topic is due to the transition from the administrative control model to the model of evidence-based, partnership and resultoriented management, enshrined in Ukrainian educational legislation and supported by European standards for ensuring the quality of education. The regulatory and legal principles for the formation of the internal system of education quality assurance in Ukraine are analyzed, in particular the provisions of the Laws of Ukraine “On Education”, “On Complete General Secondary Education”, “On Higher Education”, the Procedure for Conducting Institutional Audits of General Secondary Education Institutions, methodological recommendations of the Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine, the State Education Quality Service of Ukraine, the National Agency for Higher Education and Higher Education, as well as ESG 2015 and individual analytical documents of the OECD and the European Commission. Scientific approaches to the interpretation of education quality, quality management, monitoring, self-assessment and quality culture in the works of Ukrainian and foreign authors are systematized. It has been established that the internal education quality assurance system is effective when it is integrated into the institution's development strategy, is based on transparent procedures, covers academic integrity, fair assessment of learning outcomes, personnel development, resource provision, inclusiveness, a safe environment, information systems, and stakeholder participation. The distinction between self-assessment as a tool for the development of a particular institution and institutional audit as an external evaluation procedure according to unified rules is substantiated. It is proven that the managerial value of the internal system lies in reducing decision uncertainty, identifying risks, forming an evidence base for planning, increasing trust in the institution, and ensuring a cycle of continuous improvement. A comparative characteristic of models of the internal education quality assurance system, a system of management-significant quality indicators, and a phased implementation algorithm at the level of an educational institution are proposed. The practical significance of the article lies in formulating recommendations for heads of educational institutions on building a quality policy, identifying responsible persons and structures, streamlining self-assessment, using digital tools, forming public reporting, and transforming assessment results into specific management decisions. It is summarized that the internal system of quality assurance of education should be considered as the core of modern educational management, which combines legal regulation, quality culture, institutional autonomy, stakeholder participation, and evidence-based management logic.
- 8 October 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in Business Navigator
- No. 5(88)
INTERNAL EDUCATION QUALITY ASSURANCE SYSTEM AS A TOOL FOR EFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT OF AN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION
The article examines the internal system of education quality assurance as a tool for effective management of an educational institution in modern Ukrainian and European conditions. The relevance of the topic is due to the transition from the administrative control model to the model of evidence-based, partnership and resultoriented management, enshrined in Ukrainian educational legislation and supported by European standards for ensuring the quality of education. The regulatory and legal principles for the formation of the internal system of education quality assurance in Ukraine are analyzed, in particular the provisions of the Laws of Ukraine “On Education”, “On Complete General Secondary Education”, “On Higher Education”, the Procedure for Conducting Institutional Audits of General Secondary Education Institutions, methodological recommendations of the Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine, the State Education Quality Service of Ukraine, the National Agency for Higher Education and Higher Education, as well as ESG 2015 and individual analytical documents of the OECD and the European Commission. Scientific approaches to the interpretation of education quality, quality management, monitoring, self-assessment and quality culture in the works of Ukrainian and foreign authors are systematized. It has been established that the internal education quality assurance system is effective when it is integrated into the institution's development strategy, is based on transparent procedures, covers academic integrity, fair assessment of learning outcomes, personnel development, resource provision, inclusiveness, a safe environment, information systems, and stakeholder participation. The distinction between self-assessment as a tool for the development of a particular institution and institutional audit as an external evaluation procedure according to unified rules is substantiated. It is proven that the managerial value of the internal system lies in reducing decision uncertainty, identifying risks, forming an evidence base for planning, increasing trust in the institution, and ensuring a cycle of continuous improvement. A comparative characteristic of models of the internal education quality assurance system, a system of management-significant quality indicators, and a phased implementation algorithm at the level of an educational institution are proposed. The practical significance of the article lies in formulating recommendations for heads of educational institutions on building a quality policy, identifying responsible persons and structures, streamlining self-assessment, using digital tools, forming public reporting, and transforming assessment results into specific management decisions. It is summarized that the internal system of quality assurance of education should be considered as the core of modern educational management, which combines legal regulation, quality culture, institutional autonomy, stakeholder participation, and evidence-based management logic.
- 24 September 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in Business Navigator
- No. 4(87)
ECONOMIC-MATHEMATICAL MODELING OF THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON THE EFFICIENCY OF CROSS-BORDER FREIGHT TRANSPORT DISPATCHING
The article investigates the pressing issues and practical implementation of artificial intelligence technologies for optimizing the dispatching processes of cross-border freight transport. This is particularly relevant in the context of Ukrainian transport and logistics companies actively entering and expanding within the highly competitive market of the European Union. The study comprehensively analyzes the primary operational bottlenecks and systemic challenges inherent in international logistics. Specifically, it addresses the high volatility of freight rates on the European spot market, persistent linguistic and legal barriers in daily communications with foreign freight brokers, and unpredictable, prolonged infrastructural delays at customs checkpoints. The research scientifically substantiates the critical necessity of transitioning away from traditional, labor-intensive manual fleet management paradigms. Instead, it advocates for the strategic integration of innovative predictive analytics systems, machine learning routing algorithms, and automated broker communication protocols powered by Natural Language Processing (NLP). To quantitatively assess the financial viability of this technological shift, an advanced, multi-variable economic-mathematical model has been developed. This comprehensive model evaluates the synergistic economic impact of AI integration by meticulously calculating several key performance indicators: the significant reduction of operational transaction costs, the minimization of financial opportunity costs associated with infrastructure-induced downtime, the strategic reduction of empty mileage (deadhead), and the automated identification and securement of the most profitable freight contracts in real-time. The research methodology incorporates system-structural analysis, economic-mathematical modeling, and comparative scenario analysis. Through rigorous computer simulation modeling based on aggregated market data, three distinct operational scenarios were evaluated (baseline, optimistic, and crisis management). The empirical results of the simulation conclusively demonstrate that utilizing generative AI and machine learning for routine document processing, dynamic route optimization, and proactive rate negotiation can fundamentally transform the operational efficiency of transport enterprises. Ultimately, the integration of these advanced algorithmic dispatching tools is proven to be capable of increasing the overall operational profitability of a commercial motor fleet on international routes by a substantial margin of 20% to 30%, thereby ensuring long-term competitiveness in the integrated European transport network.
- 24 September 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in Business Navigator
- No. 4(87)
ECONOMIC-MATHEMATICAL MODELING OF THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON THE EFFICIENCY OF CROSS-BORDER FREIGHT TRANSPORT DISPATCHING
The article investigates the pressing issues and practical implementation of artificial intelligence technologies for optimizing the dispatching processes of cross-border freight transport. This is particularly relevant in the context of Ukrainian transport and logistics companies actively entering and expanding within the highly competitive market of the European Union. The study comprehensively analyzes the primary operational bottlenecks and systemic challenges inherent in international logistics. Specifically, it addresses the high volatility of freight rates on the European spot market, persistent linguistic and legal barriers in daily communications with foreign freight brokers, and unpredictable, prolonged infrastructural delays at customs checkpoints. The research scientifically substantiates the critical necessity of transitioning away from traditional, labor-intensive manual fleet management paradigms. Instead, it advocates for the strategic integration of innovative predictive analytics systems, machine learning routing algorithms, and automated broker communication protocols powered by Natural Language Processing (NLP). To quantitatively assess the financial viability of this technological shift, an advanced, multi-variable economic-mathematical model has been developed. This comprehensive model evaluates the synergistic economic impact of AI integration by meticulously calculating several key performance indicators: the significant reduction of operational transaction costs, the minimization of financial opportunity costs associated with infrastructure-induced downtime, the strategic reduction of empty mileage (deadhead), and the automated identification and securement of the most profitable freight contracts in real-time. The research methodology incorporates system-structural analysis, economic-mathematical modeling, and comparative scenario analysis. Through rigorous computer simulation modeling based on aggregated market data, three distinct operational scenarios were evaluated (baseline, optimistic, and crisis management). The empirical results of the simulation conclusively demonstrate that utilizing generative AI and machine learning for routine document processing, dynamic route optimization, and proactive rate negotiation can fundamentally transform the operational efficiency of transport enterprises. Ultimately, the integration of these advanced algorithmic dispatching tools is proven to be capable of increasing the overall operational profitability of a commercial motor fleet on international routes by a substantial margin of 20% to 30%, thereby ensuring long-term competitiveness in the integrated European transport network.
- 4 September 2026
- Published by Drukarnia Madryd in Ukrainian Journal of Applied Economics and Technology
- Vol. 2026 (3) , 326-330
Development of territorial communities and infrastructure recovery on the principles of the circular economy
The article aims to examine the relationship between the restoration of territorial community infrastructure in the Black Sea region and the principles of the circular economy, and to substantiate directions for integrating these principles into communities’ development strategies. The methodological basis of the study is a combined approach that integrates content analysis of the development strategies of 12 territorial communities in the Mykolaiv, Odesa, and Kherson regions, a case study of the restoration of water supply in the city of Mykolaiv, and conceptual modeling using structural equation modeling (SEM). As a result of the study, a gap emerged between the large-scale needs for infrastructure restoration and the level of integration of circular principles into communities’ strategic planning. It was determined that infrastructure issues are present in 92% of the analyzed strategies, sustainable development in 75%, energy efficiency in 58%, and waste management in 42%. At the same time, the circular economy, as a holistic approach, is present in only 17%. The example of restoring water supply in the city of Mykolaiv demonstrates the practical feasibility of resource-efficiency principles for reconstructing critical infrastructure under wartime conditions. The scientific novelty lies in the application of a combined methodology to study circular restoration and the development of a conceptual SEM model that formalizes the relationships among circular practices, infrastructure restoration, municipal governance, and socio-economic dynamics. The practical significance of the results lies in their potential use by local governments to develop strategies and programs for the comprehensive restoration of communities based on the principles of the circular economy. Prospects for further research include the empirical verification of the proposed SEM model in a representative sample of territorial communities and the quantitative assessment of the relationships among circular practices, the quality of infrastructure restoration, municipal governance, and socio-economic development. Keywords: institutional and societal resilience, public governance, infrastructure provision; development of territorial communities; circular economy; municipal governance; regional economy; sustainable development; socio-economic dynamics; content analysis.
- 4 September 2026
- Published by Drukarnia Madryd in Ukrainian Journal of Applied Economics and Technology
- Vol. 2026 (3) , 326-330
Development of territorial communities and infrastructure recovery on the principles of the circular economy
The article aims to examine the relationship between the restoration of territorial community infrastructure in the Black Sea region and the principles of the circular economy, and to substantiate directions for integrating these principles into communities’ development strategies. The methodological basis of the study is a combined approach that integrates content analysis of the development strategies of 12 territorial communities in the Mykolaiv, Odesa, and Kherson regions, a case study of the restoration of water supply in the city of Mykolaiv, and conceptual modeling using structural equation modeling (SEM). As a result of the study, a gap emerged between the large-scale needs for infrastructure restoration and the level of integration of circular principles into communities’ strategic planning. It was determined that infrastructure issues are present in 92% of the analyzed strategies, sustainable development in 75%, energy efficiency in 58%, and waste management in 42%. At the same time, the circular economy, as a holistic approach, is present in only 17%. The example of restoring water supply in the city of Mykolaiv demonstrates the practical feasibility of resource-efficiency principles for reconstructing critical infrastructure under wartime conditions. The scientific novelty lies in the application of a combined methodology to study circular restoration and the development of a conceptual SEM model that formalizes the relationships among circular practices, infrastructure restoration, municipal governance, and socio-economic dynamics. The practical significance of the results lies in their potential use by local governments to develop strategies and programs for the comprehensive restoration of communities based on the principles of the circular economy. Prospects for further research include the empirical verification of the proposed SEM model in a representative sample of territorial communities and the quantitative assessment of the relationships among circular practices, the quality of infrastructure restoration, municipal governance, and socio-economic development. Keywords: institutional and societal resilience, public governance, infrastructure provision; development of territorial communities; circular economy; municipal governance; regional economy; sustainable development; socio-economic dynamics; content analysis.
- 28 August 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in Business Navigator
- No. 3(86)
THEORETICAL AND METHODOLOGICAL PRINCIPLES OF MANAGING THE DEVELOPMENT OF A MODERN HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTION
The article presents a comprehensive theoretical and methodological study of the management of the development of a modern higher education institution in the context of military challenges, European integration, digital transformation, and increasing requirements for the quality of educational, scientific, and innovative activities. The relevance of the topic is due to the fact that a modern university operates in a multifactorial environment, where strategic decisions can no longer be based solely on administrative inertia, regulatory compliance, or local experience. They must be based on an integrated methodology that combines strategic vision, institutional autonomy, quality culture, results-oriented approach, data management, and internal self-regulation mechanisms. It is proven that the development of a higher education institution is a managed process of institutional changes aimed at balancing the mission, educational portfolio, human resources, research capacity, resource base, and social relevance of the university. The article highlights and characterizes the key approaches that form the theoretical basis of HEI development management: systemic, competency-based, strategic, institutional, and quality management approaches. The systemic approach allows us to consider the university as an open multilevel social and organizational system; competency-based – focuses management on learning outcomes, studentcenteredness, and labor market requirements; strategic – provides the institution’s positioning, prioritization, and resource concentration; institutional – explains the influence of autonomy, regulatory frameworks, academic norms, and external expectations; quality management approach – links development with an internal quality assurance system, regular monitoring, feedback, and a culture of continuous improvement. A special emphasis is placed on applied HEI development tools: SWOT and PESTLE analysis as means of strategic diagnostics; KPI and Balanced Scorecard as mechanisms for translating strategy into a system of measurable results; logical model as a tool for linking resources, actions, products and short-, medium- and long-term results. It is shown that the modern model of effective management of university development is based on a combination of strategic KPIs, regular public reporting, internal review of educational programs, extensive use of student feedback and corrective decisions at the level of programs, departments and management. Practical recommendations for heads of higher education institutions of Ukraine are substantiated: institutionally combine the development strategy with the internal quality assurance system; form a single scorecard for education, science, internationalization, finance and the third mission; build a cycle of "data – decisions – evaluation – correction"; strengthen the participation of the academic community and education seekers in strategy making; use public data and benchmarking to verify the realism of goals and development rates.
- 28 August 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in Business Navigator
- No. 3(86)
THEORETICAL AND METHODOLOGICAL PRINCIPLES OF MANAGING THE DEVELOPMENT OF A MODERN HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTION
The article presents a comprehensive theoretical and methodological study of the management of the development of a modern higher education institution in the context of military challenges, European integration, digital transformation, and increasing requirements for the quality of educational, scientific, and innovative activities. The relevance of the topic is due to the fact that a modern university operates in a multifactorial environment, where strategic decisions can no longer be based solely on administrative inertia, regulatory compliance, or local experience. They must be based on an integrated methodology that combines strategic vision, institutional autonomy, quality culture, results-oriented approach, data management, and internal self-regulation mechanisms. It is proven that the development of a higher education institution is a managed process of institutional changes aimed at balancing the mission, educational portfolio, human resources, research capacity, resource base, and social relevance of the university. The article highlights and characterizes the key approaches that form the theoretical basis of HEI development management: systemic, competency-based, strategic, institutional, and quality management approaches. The systemic approach allows us to consider the university as an open multilevel social and organizational system; competency-based – focuses management on learning outcomes, studentcenteredness, and labor market requirements; strategic – provides the institution’s positioning, prioritization, and resource concentration; institutional – explains the influence of autonomy, regulatory frameworks, academic norms, and external expectations; quality management approach – links development with an internal quality assurance system, regular monitoring, feedback, and a culture of continuous improvement. A special emphasis is placed on applied HEI development tools: SWOT and PESTLE analysis as means of strategic diagnostics; KPI and Balanced Scorecard as mechanisms for translating strategy into a system of measurable results; logical model as a tool for linking resources, actions, products and short-, medium- and long-term results. It is shown that the modern model of effective management of university development is based on a combination of strategic KPIs, regular public reporting, internal review of educational programs, extensive use of student feedback and corrective decisions at the level of programs, departments and management. Practical recommendations for heads of higher education institutions of Ukraine are substantiated: institutionally combine the development strategy with the internal quality assurance system; form a single scorecard for education, science, internationalization, finance and the third mission; build a cycle of "data – decisions – evaluation – correction"; strengthen the participation of the academic community and education seekers in strategy making; use public data and benchmarking to verify the realism of goals and development rates.
- Open Access
- 25 June 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in РОЗВИТОК МІСТА
- No. 2 (10),p. 171-175
ORGANIZATIONAL AND LEGAL ASPECTS OF MUNICIPAL GOVERNANCE: INNOVATIVE AND DIGITAL DEVELOPMENT, REGIONAL REGENERATION, GLOBAL INSTABILITY
The article is devoted to the analysis of the organizational and legal foundations of municipal governance in the context of ensuring innovative and digital development, as well as the restoration of regions in conditions of global instability. It is substantiated that the current legal model of local self-government is mainly based on a procedural and regulatory approach, focused primarily on the separation of powers, which, in turn, limits its ability to effectively stimulate development processes at the level of territorial communities. It has been established that the existing regulatory and legal structures do not ensure the proper institutionalization of the intangible assets of the community - knowledge, competencies , digital resources, which are a key factor in innovative and digital transformation. The article identifies three critical areas of interaction between the organizational and legal mechanism of municipal management and intellectual potential: the formation of the human resource potential of executive bodies, the management of digital assets of territorial communities, and the development of intermunicipal partnerships in the field of knowledge exchange. Directions for improving regulatory and legal support are proposed, aimed at expanding the institutional capacity of local governments as subjects of innovative and digital development and regional renewal.
- 25 June 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in РОЗВИТОК МІСТА
- No. 2 (10),p. 171-175
Open AccessORGANIZATIONAL AND LEGAL ASPECTS OF MUNICIPAL GOVERNANCE: INNOVATIVE AND DIGITAL DEVELOPMENT, REGIONAL REGENERATION, GLOBAL INSTABILITY
The article is devoted to the analysis of the organizational and legal foundations of municipal governance in the context of ensuring innovative and digital development, as well as the restoration of regions in conditions of global instability. It is substantiated that the current legal model of local self-government is mainly based on a procedural and regulatory approach, focused primarily on the separation of powers, which, in turn, limits its ability to effectively stimulate development processes at the level of territorial communities. It has been established that the existing regulatory and legal structures do not ensure the proper institutionalization of the intangible assets of the community - knowledge, competencies , digital resources, which are a key factor in innovative and digital transformation. The article identifies three critical areas of interaction between the organizational and legal mechanism of municipal management and intellectual potential: the formation of the human resource potential of executive bodies, the management of digital assets of territorial communities, and the development of intermunicipal partnerships in the field of knowledge exchange. Directions for improving regulatory and legal support are proposed, aimed at expanding the institutional capacity of local governments as subjects of innovative and digital development and regional renewal.
- 10 June 2026
- Published by OU Scientific Route
Pattern recognition in surveillance systems and diagnostics
- 10 June 2026
- Published by OU Scientific Route
Pattern recognition in surveillance systems and diagnostics
- Open Access
- 5 March 2026
- Published by NGO "Eastern European Union of Scientists" in Public Management and Policy
- No. 3(19)
THE ROLE OF MUNICIPAL GOVERNANCE IN THE INNOVATIVE REVITALIZATION OF REGIONAL BUSINESS PROCESSES AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF INTELLECTUAL CAPITAL
This article examines the role of municipal governance in the innovative revitalization of regional business processes and the development of intellectual potential. The dynamics of the renewal and development of regional business structures are analyzed. The main factors hindering the renewal of regional business structures are identified, including: a lack of funding and investment support; nearly 84% of business entities in Ukraine are individual entrepreneurs who lack sufficient resources to join business associations; the largest share of scientific personnel works for the government, while the business sector has more resources but fewer highly qualified personnel; the lack of transparent mechanisms to protect the rights of investors in large integrated structures deters partners from establishing joint ventures. Research has shown that the content of regional strategies and their implementation plans differ significantly from one another, yet they are all aimed at strengthening and developing the regions. It has been determined that the role of municipal government in shaping development strategies is crucial and should be focused on ensuring the well-being of the local population through programs that promote sustainable socioeconomic growth. It has been demonstrated that a significant portion of regions possess intellectual potential which, with the support of local municipalities and international funding, can develop development programs and tools. The analysis revealed that a significant portion of the intellectual potential of the scientific workforce is concentrated in the regions but is not being fully utilized, as evidenced by statistical disparities. It was emphasized that at the regional level, it is necessary to develop appropriate strategies, programs, and plans for development and recovery with the involvement of scientific personnel, the expert community, and business representatives, which will contribute to the formation of well-founded management decisions and the improvement of the effectiveness of regional policy.
- 5 March 2026
- Published by NGO "Eastern European Union of Scientists" in Public Management and Policy
- No. 3(19)
Open AccessTHE ROLE OF MUNICIPAL GOVERNANCE IN THE INNOVATIVE REVITALIZATION OF REGIONAL BUSINESS PROCESSES AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF INTELLECTUAL CAPITAL
This article examines the role of municipal governance in the innovative revitalization of regional business processes and the development of intellectual potential. The dynamics of the renewal and development of regional business structures are analyzed. The main factors hindering the renewal of regional business structures are identified, including: a lack of funding and investment support; nearly 84% of business entities in Ukraine are individual entrepreneurs who lack sufficient resources to join business associations; the largest share of scientific personnel works for the government, while the business sector has more resources but fewer highly qualified personnel; the lack of transparent mechanisms to protect the rights of investors in large integrated structures deters partners from establishing joint ventures. Research has shown that the content of regional strategies and their implementation plans differ significantly from one another, yet they are all aimed at strengthening and developing the regions. It has been determined that the role of municipal government in shaping development strategies is crucial and should be focused on ensuring the well-being of the local population through programs that promote sustainable socioeconomic growth. It has been demonstrated that a significant portion of regions possess intellectual potential which, with the support of local municipalities and international funding, can develop development programs and tools. The analysis revealed that a significant portion of the intellectual potential of the scientific workforce is concentrated in the regions but is not being fully utilized, as evidenced by statistical disparities. It was emphasized that at the regional level, it is necessary to develop appropriate strategies, programs, and plans for development and recovery with the involvement of scientific personnel, the expert community, and business representatives, which will contribute to the formation of well-founded management decisions and the improvement of the effectiveness of regional policy.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by OU Scientific Route
- p. 102-131
From pattern recognition to remediation management in a closed digital loop architecture for post-war logistics
- 1 January 2026
- Published by OU Scientific Route
- p. 102-131
From pattern recognition to remediation management in a closed digital loop architecture for post-war logistics
- 30 December 2025
- Published by Admiral Makarov National University of Shipbuilding in Collection of Scientific Publications NUS
- No. 4 (502),p. 404-415
STRATEGIC APPROACHES TO CIRCULAR BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT
- 30 December 2025
- Published by Admiral Makarov National University of Shipbuilding in Collection of Scientific Publications NUS
- No. 4 (502),p. 404-415
STRATEGIC APPROACHES TO CIRCULAR BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT