BHBenedikt W. Harrer

Benedikt W. Harrer

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Benedikt W. Harrer has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Using representational gesture to enact instants in collaborative problem solving in physics

    by Emma Teresa Booth, Virginia J. Flood, Benedikt W. Harrer

    Embodied forms of representation like gesture have been shown to play an important role in how learners conceptualize phenomena in physics; however, we know little about how students use gesture to capture the idea of . Drawing on multimodal microanalysis of interaction, we examine how undergraduate physics students use representational gesture to make sense of instants or single moments in time while modeling energy dynamics. Our analysis demonstrates how students use four different forms of representational gesture to capture instantaneity: These include (i) looping and replaying a physical action, (ii) showing a tiny subinterval of time, (iii) freezing a frame of an action, and (iv) marking a boundary location on an imaginary timeline. Implications for physics learning are discussed.

  • Open Access

    Characterizing representational gestures in collaborative sense-making of vectors in introductory physics

    by Stacy M. Scheuneman, Virginia J. Flood, Benedikt W. Harrer

    An understanding of vectors and vector operations is crucial for success in physics, as this serves as the foundation for various essential concepts, including motion and forces. Previous research indicates that only a fraction of introductory physics students have a usable knowledge of vectors and vector operations, and that more attention should be given to how students make sense of vectors. We examined classroom video data from an introductory physics course wherein students worked collaboratively through learning activities to introduce vectors and vector operations. During these activities, students' employment of gesture as a representational mode facilitated group sense-making. We propose a preliminary taxonomy of gestures for representing vector magnitudes, directions, and initial and terminal points. By identifying and characterizing the gestures used by students, we can gain insights into their learning processes and conceptual understanding of vectors, which can inform instructional design and teaching practices.


  • Teachers’ responsiveness to students’ gestured candidate responses in whole-class STEM interactions

    by Virginia J. Flood, Benedikt W. Harrer

    We contribute a previously unidentified way representational gestures are used to organise participation and the co-construction of knowledge in whole-class interactions in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) classrooms. Drawing on ethnomethodology and conversation analysis (EMCA), we characterise students’ gestured candidate responses and how teachers respond to them. To answer teachers’ questions, students sometimes use representational gestures to provide silent, ‘off-the-record’ tentative responses that we call gestured candidate responses (GCRs). Teachers can respond to GCRs by ratifying or declining students’ responses. Teachers’ responses to GCRs include (1) ratifying the GCR by nominating students to share the response, (2) ratifying the GCR by repeating the gestured response for the class, (3) declining the GCR by not publicly pursuing the contribution, or (4) declining the GCR by publicly rejecting the contribution. Our analysis contributes to a better understanding of how students use gesture and how teachers attend and respond to students’ gestures in STEM classroom discourse.


  • Open Access

    Editorial: Focused Collection: Curriculum Development: Theory into Design

    by Benedikt W. Harrer, Eleanor C. Sayre, Leslie Atkins Elliott

    DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.16.020002


  • Modeling Energy Dynamics with the Energy-Interaction Diagram

    by Benedikt Harrer, Cassandra Paul

    Energy is an important crosscutting concept in all science disciplines, and energy conservation is widely regarded as one of the most important principles in physics. Over the years, numerous graphical representations have been proposed that allow learners of physics to visualize energy states and dynamics in a particular situation. Each diagram highlights different aspects of energy and therefore may represent different conceptualizations of energy. Bar charts, or example, foreground the idea of multiple categories of energy to account for the distribution of energy in a system across those energy types. Similarly, pie charts highlight relative distribution of energy among different energy types. While bar charts are able to represent negative energy, pie charts emphasize that there is a certain, total amount of energy available that is distributed over different types. Various energy tracking diagrams (e.g., PET energy source-receiver diagrams, Energy Tracking Diagrams) foreground the localization of energy along a chain of energy transfer processes and within the involved objects.


  • Energy-interaction diagrams: Fostering resources for productive disciplinary engagement with energy

    by Benedikt W. Harrer

    The use of graphical representations structures students' reasoning about a physical scenario or problem. Different graphical representations for energy in physical situations highlight different aspects of energy and therefore may represent and foster different conceptualizations of energy. One particular representation of energy dynamics in a physical system, the Energy-Interaction Diagram, embodies a Stores and Transfer model of energy. In this paper, I show how the Energy-Interaction Diagram can evoke productive resources for disciplinary engagement with energy. In the presented example, students in an introductory college physics course activated the resources indicator reasoning, systems thinking, and substance metaphor while employing the Energy-Interaction Diagram to make sense of a puzzling scenario: Two billiard balls on parallel incline tracks with different widths—why does one ball roll down the ramp faster than the other?


  • Open Access

    The multimodal interactional work of having wonderful ideas

    by Benedikt W. Harrer

    Learning physics is socially organized through interactions with peers and more competent others. Instructors' and peers' assessment of and responsiveness to learners' ideas in the moment is critical for the collaborative construction of knowledge in physics. However, we still know little about how instructors and learners negotiate the value and productiveness of ideas. While to an outsider, some of the ideas physics learners discuss do not seem immediately valuable or productive for the problem being solved, Duckworth encourages us to pursue an "insider's view" on how learners experience their ideas. Building on this notion, I pursue an "insider's view" to better understand how peers and teachers experience each other's ideas. In particular, I examine the interactional methods and resources physics students use to express their ideas and to mark their own or others' ideas as wonderful or not-so-wonderful. I demonstrate how participants rely on a variety of multimodal communicational tools, including speech, words, gestures, and whiteboard inscriptions to negotiate wonderfulness, extending our current understanding of how peers and instructors are responsive to physics ideas in the moment.


  • On the origin of energy: Metaphors and manifestations as resources for conceptualizing and measuring the invisible, imponderable

    by Benedikt W. Harrer

    This article explores the origins of metaphorical language to describe energy by reviewing the historical development of the concept by physicists since the early 19th century. In addition to examples of historical and contemporary use of metaphors in academic writing, observable manifestations of energy are identified as the origin of energy “forms.” The historical-philosophical review and presentation of examples from contemporary physics literature contribute a disciplinary foundation to recent claims about the productiveness of physics learners' use of metaphors and indicators to describe energy.


  • Energy Tracking Diagrams

    by Rachel E. Scherr, Benedikt W. Harrer, Hunter G. Close, Abigail R. Daane, Lezlie S. DeWater, Amy D. Robertson, Lane Seeley, Stamatis Vokos

    Energy is a crosscutting concept in science and features prominently in national science education documents. In the Next Generation Science Standards, the primary conceptual learning goal is for learners to conserve energy as they track the transfers and transformations of energy within, into, or out of the system of interest in complex physical processes. As part of tracking energy transfers among objects, learners should (i) distinguish energy from matter, including recognizing that energy flow does not uniformly align with the movement of matter, and should (ii) identify specific mechanisms by which energy is transferred among objects, such as mechanical work and thermal conduction. As part of tracking energy transformations within objects, learners should (iii) associate specific forms with specific models and indicators (e.g., kinetic energy with speed and/or coordinated motion of molecules, thermal energy with random molecular motion and/or temperature) and (iv) identify specific mechanisms by which energy is converted from one form to another, such as incandescence and metabolism. Eventually, we may hope for learners to be able to optimize systems to maximize some energy transfers and transformations and minimize others, subject to constraints based in both imputed mechanism (e.g., objects must have motion energy in order for gravitational energy to change) and the second law of thermodynamics (e.g., heating is irreversible). We hypothesize that a subsequent goal of energy learning—innovating to meet socially relevant needs—depends crucially on the extent to which these goals have been met.