Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Galym Zhussipbek has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Feminism Under Capture: Power, Voice, and the Reconstitution of Feminist Futures

    by Shumaila Yousafzai, Bettina Bastian, Bronwyn Wood, Ainash Mustoyapova, Mairead Dunne, Naureen Durrani, Galym Zhussipbek, Nurlykhan Aljanova

    What happens to feminism when it stops challenging power and starts circulating within it? As feminist language enters government agendas, global indicators, and market strategy, it becomes harder to tell whether feminism is transforming those systems or being absorbed by them. This editorial argues that the two are not sequential. Across contributions from Central Asia and beyond, we show feminist voice, agency, and solidarity being produced and constrained in the same moment they are exercised; not first captured, then resisted, but reshaped and redirected at once, through the very terms power extends. A woman using entrepreneurial visibility to gain legitimacy in a male‐dominated market is not complying and then subverting; she is doing both in a single gesture. Tracing this dynamic across Soviet and post‐Soviet Kazakhstan, global development governance, education, women's entrepreneurship, and decolonial epistemology, we ask what forms of feminist voice become legitimate, whose knowledge counts, and what survives translation into policy, indicator, and curriculum. We turn to the margins not as places where feminism is absent, but as the sites where its capture and its reinvention are most visible at once, where empowerment is relational rather than individual, solidarity is built through care and interdependence rather than declared as a political stance, and feminist theory is not applied to lived experience but built from it. The task this editorial sets is not to recover feminism from power, but to rethink what feminism becomes once the distinction between the two no longer holds.


  • Open Access

    Primacy of Care and Human Dignity: Decolonial Turn Versus Anti-Social Neoliberal Capitalism and Positivist and Postmodern Epistemologies

    by Galym Zhussipbek

    Background: This article discusses the primacy of care, empathy, and dignity in human life and social relations. There is a connection among care, connection, and human dignity that forms the value-based foundation of human rights. Conversely, there is a nexus between the rise of neoliberalism and the relativisation of fundamental human rights values, including respect for equal moral human dignity, which can be recognised through empathy. Non-positivist approaches such as critical realism and decolonial perspectives critique neoliberal capitalism, as well as positivist and postmodern epistemologies, for dismissing the importance of values and separating reason and emotions. The violation of human dignity due to the denial of social rights is a global problem inherent in contemporary neoliberal capitalism, which tends to reject a universalistic understanding of human dignity. Legal minimalism in legal systems illustrates how the adverse effects of neoliberalism can undermine the development of health rights. The neoliberal mindset has led not only to the instrumentalisation of human rights but also to the relativisation of gross violations of international law, for example, by “normalising” full-scale aggression against Ukraine, reducing everything to a “capitalistic deal” and disregarding war crimes. Methods: This research is interdisciplinary and conceptual-normative. Epistemologically, it is based on the assumptions of meta-theoretical critical realism, the ethics of care, and the decolonial approach, as conceptualised in recent years by authors from post-socialist countries. The prioritisation of empathy, which is key to perceiving equal moral human dignity, is central to this understanding of the decolonial turn. Therefore, this article adopts conceptual, normative, and hermeneutical methods, including critical analysis of neoliberal capitalism, positivist, and postmodern epistemologies. As an example from judicial practice, the influence of the neoliberal mindset on the implementation of health rights is addressed conceptually. Results and conclusions: This paper proposes a solution to the multiple problems generated by neoliberalism and positivist and postmodern epistemologies: a cultural change and mental revival that can be achieved through a decolonial approach, which precedes the transformation of hierarchical neoliberal economic, judicial, and political systems. Overall, it is important to frame discussions about the nature of the state, law, democracy, and security by focusing on the concepts of human dignity, care, and empathy, which go beyond conventional positivist and postmodern approaches in the social sciences and legal studies, as well as the “conventional normal” in academia.

  • Open Access

    Human Right to Health, Social Rights and Human Dignity versus Relativist Challenge of Neoliberal Capitalism

    by Galym Zhussipbek

    Human rights to health and health care have developed considerably since they were first codified after World War Two and now, they are regulated in many international and national legal documents. Nevertheless, health rights still face many challenges. They are among the most contested, incompletely conceptualized human rights and the least enforceable rights. This paper argues that the greatest challenges and difficulties in health rights stem from the global expansion of neoliberal capitalism to which positivist epistemology is complacent. These problems entail the relativist challenge to the universality of human dignity and the neglect of fundamental values such as caring, empathy and respect for human dignity. The neoliberal capitalist mindset leads to an erosion of empathy, which translates into hostility towards, or at least neglect of, social human rights. All this contributes to the normalization of narrow understandings of health and the human right to health and to the problematic development of health rights. The commodification of health care led to a paradigm shift in the health sector creating an impersonal, profit-centric relationship. The insufficient role of the World Health Organization is one of the main reasons for the underdevelopment of health rights. Nor can the concept of sustainable development be seen as truly inclusive and conducive to the development of viable health rights, as the problems in the development of universal health coverage show. This paper suggests that the creation of fully-fledged health rights is not a problem of resource scarcity or lack of legal norms — but primarily a problem of scarcity of care and empathy, and a lack of understanding of the universality of human dignity. To make health and health care full-fledged human rights requires, first and foremost, a cultural transformation and mental revival, which would revive care, empathy, and dignity; the development of social rights that are indispensable for the protection of human dignity; and the implementation of a solidaristic perspective with full decommodification of health care.


  • Open Access

    The Human Right to Health: Empathy and Universal Human Dignity Versus Apathetic Capitalism

    by Galym Zhussipbek

    The human right to health as a concept continues to face many challenges. The ineffective role of the World Health Organization in previous decades and the rise of neoliberal capitalism have contributed significantly to the "shaky foundations" of the human right to health and the "conventional reluctance" to accept the so-called broad understanding of health, depicted in this paper as the social determination of health. This concept means that health (like positive and negative health outcomes) results from structural, racial, and class differences. On the other hand, the separation of reason and emotions in today's prevailing positivistic epistemology in social sciences is another crucial factor in the slow development of the human right to health. This separation has manifested itself in human rights studies by overlooking the concept of empathy in legitimizing the universality of human rights, even though empathy is a critical concept in understanding the universal moral dignity of human beings. Furthermore, these epistemological problems are compounded by the capitalist ethos, which leads to the hardening of personality and an empathy gap that contributes to the challenges in developing the human right to health. Empathy is necessary to understand health's social determination and fully develop the human right to health, but positivistic social sciences and capitalism-driven reason undermine it. Take-home message: Policymakers are urged to integrate empathy and a broader understanding of health determinants into their strategies to ensure the universal realization of health rights and address the underlying social and economic disparities.


  • Open Access

    Interdisciplinary Approach to Overcoming the Persistence of Patriarchal Islamic Interpretations: Gender Equality, the Development of Empathy and Children’s Rights, and Insights from the Reformist Eurasian Scholars of Early Twentieth Century

    by Galym Zhussipbek, Assyltay Tasbolat, Zhanar Nagayeva

    Gender equality and women’s rights are among the most discussed issues in the context of Islam. Any thorough analysis of the persistence of conservative patriarchal religious interpretations in Muslim communities should also consider social factors. The conservative appropriation of Islam is not only the result of theological factors but also a manifestation of a conservative and patriarchal habitus. This article draws attention to the vitality of empathy in establishing universal equal human dignity. It dwells on the idea of the universal innate nature of the child to offer some solutions to overcome the persistence of conservative religious interpretations and develop gender equality in the Muslim context. Also, the reformist views of the Jadids and Alash intellectuals, the Eurasian Muslim reformists of the early twentieth century, are analyzed as authentic historical and conceptual precedents to develop gender-egalitarian Islamic interpretations. Overall, this article establishes a connection between women’s rights in Islam, the universal innate nature of the child (and the universality of children’s right-friendly parenting and education that fosters empathy and critical thinking), and the intellectual legacy of the Jadids and Alash intellectuals, who wanted to transform the conservative and patriarchal habitus through educational reform, literary works, and a rationalistic, thematico-holistic approach to Islam.


  • “Strictness is a Virtue” – Social Determination of Authoritarian Parenting and Political Authoritarianism

    by Galym Zhussipbek, Zhanar Nagayeva

    Parenting and children’s rights are intimately related. The parenting styles characterised by low responsiveness to children’s needs, including authoritarian-paternalistic and those of neglect, are harmful to child’s development and contradict the main principles of children’s rights. The slow development of children’s rights in Kazakhstan and, in general, in the Eurasian1 context, derives from the social norms justifying authoritarian-paternalistic parenting, specifically, the widespread belief that “strictness is a virtue”. This article proposes and discusses the concepts of “social determination of authoritarian parenting” and “social determination of political authoritarianism”. The former concept denotes an embodiment of social norms that shape the parenting styles with low responsiveness to children’s needs, especially authoritarian-paternalistic. The latter suggests that authoritarianism is a product of social and cultural contexts, including parenting. These concepts, being mutually supportive phenomena, create the vicious circle of the persistency of authoritarianism in both politics and in child-rearing.


  • The social state, active citizen and empowering education: contribution of Montessori’s humanistic philosophy of education

    by Galym Zhussipbek, Zhanar Nagayeva

    The social state, the phenomenon of the active citizen, and empowering education are the actual goals of what ‘New Kazakhstan’ has to achieve. Maria Montessori is a globally known, leading thinker and practitioner of humanistic education philosophy and positive social transformations. Montessori believed in and practiced the principles of developing non-commercialized and accessible to all quality education, which is not just child-centric but is also conducive to creating global citizens with an inclusive outlook who perceive themselves as the integral parts of the whole, called Universe. Montessori’s education philosophy helps children develop a way of thinking based on the unity of the Universe, awakens and sustains in them an unrestrained interest in exploring the Universe, evokes creativity, and induces them to see everything in interconnectedness. Overall, an analysis of Cosmic education, a fundamental concept in Montessori’s humanistic philosophy of education, which also can be depicted as empowering education, shows some concrete ways how to form active citizens, create a vital social state and build an inclusive society.


  • Open Access

    The Need to Bridge the Gap between Research on Children’s Rights and Parenting Styles: Authoritative/Democratic Style as an Acultural Model for the Child’s Well-Being

    by Galym Zhussipbek, Zhanar Nagayeva

    The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child contains specific provisions on parent–child relations and parenting, but these provisions can be described as elusive. Furthermore, the Convention does not explicitly specify a children’s rights-friendly parenting style. On the other hand, there is a disconnect between research on children’s rights and parenting styles. Based on the insights of the meta-theoretical critical realist approach, this paper argues that universal human flourishing is inconceivable without the development of a children’s rights-friendly parenting style. It is argued that the Convention’s provisions on parent–child relations can be adapted to the perceptions of average parents, especially living in paternalistic societies, by adapting the conceptualizations of parenting styles developed by Baumrind and Lakoff. Overall, research on children’s rights, supported by literature on children’s rights-friendly parenting, can show that children’s rights do not alienate parental rights and responsibilities. Instead, children’s rights give appropriate direction to parental authority and responsibility to realize the child’s well-being.