VGVladimir Ilych Gorbachev

Vladimir Ilych Gorbachev

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Vladimir Ilych Gorbachev has a total of 345 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Reforms in the training system of anesthesiologists in the Russian Federation: a regulatory and legal analytical review

    by O. E. Mitkinov, Vladimir I. Gorbachev

    An analysis of the legal framework governing the training of anesthesiologists in the Russian Federation was conducted. In 2022, due to anti-Russian sanctions imposed by several foreign countries, the Russian Government amended many aspects of licensing procedures, particularly in medicine, to reduce the shortage of personnel in the specialty of anesthesiology. The National Medical Chamber noted the negative effects of the simplified form of physician training, requiring changes to the regulatory framework. Since 2026, a large-scale reform of the medical education system has been undertaken: specialty programs, residency training, professional retraining, and advanced training courses for physicians. The main changes include a ban on distance learning, the approval of standard programs, and stricter requirements for practical training.

  • Training of anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists in the Russian Federation

    by O.E. Mitkinov, V.I. Gorbachev

    Training of anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists is an important element of healthcare system, as these specialists are essential for safe management of critically ill patients. Objective. To analyze regulations for training of anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists in the Russian Federation. Material and methods. We analyzed changes in regulatory framework governing the training of anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists in the Russian Federation over the past 3 years. Results. Regulations governing the training of anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists in the Russian Federation were analyzed. In 2022, the Government of the Russian Federation amended many aspects of regulatory activities, including those related to medicine due to anti-Russian sanctions imposed by several foreign countries. This was necessary to reduce personnel shortage in anesthesiology and intensive care. Conclusion. There is still the need for changes in regulatory framework.

  • Open Access

    “Physician on board”: legal aspects of providing first aid and medical assistance by a physician on board a civil aircraft. A narrative review

    by V. A. Konnov, Владимир Ильич Горбачев, K. G. Shapovalov

    INTRODUCTION: The legal status of a physician — a passenger on a civil aircraft when providing medical assistance and/or first aid to other passengers or the crew is not fully regulated. OBJECTIVE: Assess the legal regulation of first aid and medical assistance by a physician who is a passenger on a civil aircraft. The article presents analysis of Federal Laws, orders, a review of literature. MAIN PART: According to Federal Law No 323-FZ, first aid is not considered medical assistance, but first aid kits and sets approved by orders of the Russian Ministry of Health are equipped with medical devices and pharmaceutical preparations. In a passenger aircraft, flight attendants are required to provide first aid according to their job descriptions, are required to provide first aid, using medical devices and pharmaceutical preparations from a first aid kit, as regulated by an order of the Russian Ministry of Transport. No other persons are required to provide first aid on a passenger aircraft, including passengers registered with the airline as a “physician on board”. This service is intended to identify passengers who, according to the order of the Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation, have medical competencies and can use medical devices and pharmaceutical preparations both from the first aid kit and first aid set when providing first aid. The conditions for which first aid is provided are approved in the list of the First Aid Procedure of the Russian Ministry of Health, but they do not list natural childbirth and many life-threatening conditions for the relief of which first aid sets are equipped. The use of medical devices and pharmaceutical preparations from the first aid set and pharmaceutical preparations from the first aid kit, except for those prescribed to the passenger by the attending physician in accordance with the Procedure, do not refer to first aid, but to medical assistance provided without a licensure, which falls under the administrative and criminal liability in the Russian Federation. CONCLUSIONS: A medical professional may provide first aid on board a civil aircraft. To regulate the relationship of an aircraft passenger with a medical diploma, valid accreditation in any specialty with other passengers or the crew of the aircraft in case they have developed conditions that are imperative to provide not only first aid, but also medical assistance, it is necessary to urgently adopt the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation of orders on the provision of extended first aid by physicians with a more complete list of life-threatening conditions and measures to eliminate them, management of natural childbirth and the ability to use all medical devices and pharmaceutical preparations from first aid kits and first aid sets approved by the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation.

  • Open Access

    Nutritional support and metabolic control technologies in intensive care units. Results of a multicenter prospective screening study

    by Ilya N. Leyderman, E. A. Kokarev, С.м. Ефремов С.м. Ефремов, A. A. Astakhov, D. V. Belsky, R. R. Bogdanov, E. Y. Vashukova, S. V. Voevodin, N. V. Govorova, V. I. Gorbachev, et al.

    INTRODUCTION: Nutritional support is an integral part of the treatment process in the intensive care unit (ICU). Patients in critical care receive some methods of enteral or parenteral nutrition based on often conflicting guidelines and controversial strategies. OBJECTIVE: To identify key trends in the use of metabolic control and nutritional support technologies in ICUs of different profiles. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The project of this screening study was developed by members of the FAR RF Committee on Nutritional Support and Metabolic Control. The design trial was simple random sampling. The study included 569 ICU patients. Results. The mean age of the patients was 59.22 ± 17.93 years. APACHE II scale — 1.3 ± 3.9 points, according to SOFA scale — 3.7 ± 1.5 points. 56 % of patients underwent surgical interventions, 45 % were on mechanical ventilation, 28-day mortality — 24 %. In 25 % of oncological patients the total protein was below 50 g\l. Serum albumin level was statistically significantly lower (p = 0,013) in the group of patients with acute cerebral insufficiency (ACI) in comparison with oncosurgical patients. In 25 % of multidisciplinary ICU patients albumin concentration was below 25 g/l. Energy requirement was determined empiricaly in 44 % of oncologic patients, in 50 % of patients with ACI the method of c equations was used, and indirect calorimetry was used in all groups in no more than 1 % of cases. Protein requirements were empirically determined in 20 % of cases in all groups. 35 % of physicians estimated the protein requirement based on the value of 1.2–1.5 g/kg/day. Enteral tube feeding was more frequently used by 70 % of ACI patients and 29 % in the oncology group. In contrast, 29 % of oncologic patients received parenteral nutrition. Only 5 % of patients with ACI required parenteral nutrition. CONCLUSIONS: The majority of ICU patients are characterized by such manifestations of protein-energy deficiency as hypoproteinemia, hypoalbuminemia, hypotransferrinemia. Enteral tube feeding is the prevailing method of nutritional support in ICU. The main problem identified in the course of screening should be considered the very rare use of metabolic monitoring technologies and the lack of a personalized approach to the selection of the nutritional support program.


  • Open Access

    On the first court decisions after the abolition of the application of Article 238 of the Criminal Code in relation to medical workers. Brief message

    by Константин Геннадьевич Шаповалов, V. I. Gorbachev, S. A. Sumin, R. A. Yaroslavkin, E. S. Netesin

    Since 2018, Article 238 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation has been actively used in the Russian Federation in cases of unfavorable outcomes in the provision of medical care. This has led to dissatisfaction among medical workers, especially in "risky" specialties (obstetrics, anesthesiologist-intensive care specialist), exacerbating the personnel crisis. In 2024, amendments to the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (Federal Law No. 514-FZ) were adopted, excluding medical care from Article 238. Medical workers, including anesthesiologist-intensive care specialist, were given the opportunity to review their sentences and return to professional activities. However, the success of the defense depends on knowledge of legal nuances and analysis of judicial practice, especially in the context of reclassification of cases and the application of statutes of limitations. Awareness of the medical community remains critically important for minimizing legal risks.


  • Mortality Predictors in Stroke Patients Requiring Mechanical Ventilation: A Multicenter Prospective Observational Study

    by Vadim Ershov, Andrey Belkin, Vladimir Gorbachev, Alexey Gritsan, Igor Zabolotskikh, Konstantin Lebedinsky, Ilya Leiderman, Sergey Petrikov, Denis Protsenko, Alexander Solodov, et al.

    Background: Patients with acute severe stroke requiring mechanical ventilation represent a significant clinical challenge. Identification of mortality predictors is necessary to improve outcomes. Methods: Fourteen hospitals located around Russia participated in this prospective multicenter observational clinical study. Patients admitted to ICU between November 1, 2017, and November 1, 2019 with confirmed cerebral stroke, aged 18 to 90 years, and requiring mechanical ventilation were included. The impact of various clinical factors on mortality during the 28-day period after stroke was assessed. Results: A total of 1289 patients were included in the registry, and 1144 met the study criteria. The 28-day mortality rate for stroke patients on mechanical ventilation was 64.3%. The most common indications for mechanical ventilation were impaired consciousness (75.7%) and hypoxemia (60.9%). In the cohort of strokes with NIHSS severity greater than 20 points, hypoxemia at the start of ventilation (OR 1.85 [1.21; 2.81], P = 0.004) and the use of hyperventilation mode (OR 1.46 [1.02; 2.06], P = 0.0336) were associated with increased mortality. Pressure-controlled mode as the primary ventilation method (OR 0.36 [0.21; 0.60], P < 0.001) and ICP monitoring (OR 0.23 [0.12; 0.44], P < 0.001) were associated with decreased mortality. Infectious complications were associated with longer mechanical ventilation and ICU stay (P < 0.001). The relationship between probable mortality and the severity of neurological deficit on the NIHSS scale at the start of mechanical ventilation is non-linear. A critical threshold was reached at 16 points NIHSS, where a trend of increasing probable mortality emerged. Conclusion: The identified predictors of mortality in stroke patients requiring mechanical ventilation are essential for decision-making in this cohort. They include hypoxemia, hyperventilation (used to control intracranial hypertension), volume-controlled (VC) versus pressure-controlled (PC) initial ventilation, and the use of clinical methods for monitoring ICP alone versus invasive monitoring.

  • Open Access

    Сomments on the restriction of the application of Article 238 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation in relation to medical workers when they provide medical care: expert opinion

    by Владимир Ильич Горбачев, E. S. Netesin, Yu. V. Ershova, S. V. Gorbachev, I. B. Zabolotskikh

    The presented article discusses the Federal Law of 28.12.2024 N 514-FZ "On Amendments to the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation", which supplemented Article 238 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation with the note "Note. This article does not apply to cases of medical care provided by medical workers." This means that from 08.01.2025, the day of entry into force of Federal Law-514, a medical worker when providing medical care cannot be subject to criminal liability for the provision of services (work) that do not meet safety requirements. Data on the criminal prosecution of doctors in the Russian Federation is presented.


  • Open Access

    ON THE MOST SIGNIFICANT DEFECTS IN INTENSIVE CARE FOR PATIENTS WITH THE NEW CORONAVIRUS INFECTION COVID-19 BASED ON AN EXPERT ASSESSMENT

    by N. N. Utkin, V. I. Gorbachev, E. S. Netesin, S. V. Gorbachev

    Background. There are now a sufficient number of published papers devoted to the study of various factors influencing theoutcomeofthe disease. The significance of these predictors in thenewcoronavirus infection varies depending on various anthropological factors: including regional, age, gender and medical characteristics.The objective. To assess the significance of defects in the provision of intensive care to patients with a new coronavirus infection, presented on the basis of expert opinions, and to determine their impact on the outcome of the disease.Materials and methods. An analysis of 93 inpatient records with the primary diagnosis of "Community- acquired bilateral polysegmental viral pneumonia, ARDS" was conducted. A simple blind sampling method was used of the medical records of patients who were treated in the intensive care unit from 01.04.2021 to 31.10.2021. A power analysis showed that a minimum sample size of 15 patients per group is sufficient to detect significant differences between the groups of survivors and deceased (power 95% and α = 0.05). The presented study was carried out as a cohort retrospective single-center study stratified into groups by the following criterion: survivors and deceased. Statistical data processing was performed using STATISTICA 10.0 and MedCalc programs. The following statistical analysis methods were used: odds ratio method, Kaplan-Meier survival analysis, log-rank test, ROC analysis.Results. The study did not reveal any effect on the timing of death of the area of lung tissue damage upon admission. The most significant defects of intensive care affecting the chance of death in patients with a new coronavirus infection were identified. Untimely testing of a number of laboratory parameters leads to late administration of the necessary corrective therapy. The chance of an unfavorable outcome increases with a late test for ferritin, d-dimer, and procalcitonin levels. The ROC analysis showed that increased mortality is affected by: irrational and untimely antibacterial therapy – AUC equal to 0,7 with a sensitivity of 45,83% and a specificity of 94,2%, as well as untimely targeted therapy, AUC was 0.967, with a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 92,75%.Conclusion. The development of an unfavorable outcome during intensive care is influenced by factors such as the untimely prescription of targeted and antibacterial therapy to patients with COVID-19 and untimely diagnostic measures, which occurred due to the incomplete material and technical equipment of medical organizations.

  • Open Access

    Errors when conducting a forensic medical expert assessment in the field of anesthesiology and resuscitation in criminal cases: a case series

    by E. S. Netesin, K. G. Shapovalov, Владимир Ильич Горбачев, S. A. Sumin, S. V. Gorbachev, R. A. Yaroslavkin

    INTRODUCTION: The forensic medical examination of “medical criminal cases” is the “cornerstone” on the conclusions of which the results of the trial and the further fate of our colleagues largely depend. Therefore, the medical community wants the conclusion of experts (including anesthesiologists and ICU physicians) to be completely objective, scientifically based, not biased and based not on the subjective opinion of an expert, but on specific regulatory documents. OBJECTIVE: To identify typical errors and improve the quality of expert assessment of medical care in the field of “anesthesiology-intensive care”. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The analysis of some forensic medical examinations in criminal cases with the participation of an anesthesiologist and ICU physicians part of the experts was carried out. RESULTS: As a result of the analysis of the conclusions of the forensic medical examinations under consideration, significant shortcomings were identified that could have a significant impact on the results of the consideration of criminal cases and contribute to the imposition of unjustified convictions. CONCLUSIONS: It is necessary to create a legal mechanism for certification of doctors of specialties to allow them as experts to conduct complex forensic medical examinations and state control over the quality of their work.

  • Open Access

    Criminal cases against anesthesiologists and intensivists in Russia for 2019–2022: a retrospective observational study

    by Владимир Ильич Горбачев, N. N. Utkin, E. S. Netesin, S. V. Gorbachev, A. V. Malygina, A. M. Lavrentiev, A. A. Urbazaev

    INTRODUCTION: The number of criminal cases brought against doctors — anesthesiologists and resuscitators in the Russian Federation is not decreasing. However, a detailed analysis has not been carried out in recent years, and this was primarily due to the pandemic of the new coronavirus infection COVID-19 and the restrictions that were associated with it. OBJECTIVE: To analyze criminal cases against anesthesiologists and resuscitators initiated under various articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation over the past four years, from 2019 to 2022. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The search for criminal cases was carried out in the following electronic databases: “Court decisions of the Russian Federation” and the State Automated System of the Russian Federation “Justice”. Based on the search results, 66 criminal cases against anesthesiologists and resuscitators were considered. RESULTS: The main articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation were identified, under which anesthesiologists and resuscitators are most often held accountable. The gender and territorial distribution of criminal cases by region of the Russian Federation is presented. The most significant and frequently committed defects in the provision of medical care have been identified. Examples of the most complex criminal cases are given. CONCLUSIONS: It seems that the number of criminal cases against anesthesiologists and resuscitators has decreased slightly after 2019, however, we believe that this is due to the pandemic of the new coronavirus infection, and for this reason many court cases are still under investigation and have not been completed on time.