CSCynthia Schuck-Paim

Cynthia Schuck-Paim

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Cynthia Schuck-Paim has a total of 138 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The pain echo chamber: how barren environments amplify pain in captive animals

    by Cynthia Schuck-Paim, Wladimir J. Alonso, Kate Hartcher, Chiawen Chiang, Patricia Alves Pereira, Walter Veit, Michael Mendl, Christine J. Nicol, Benjamin Lecorps

    Pain is not solely a function of tissue damage but can be strongly shaped by environmental context. Its perceived intensity, duration, and likelihood—the core features of affective experience—are modulated by factors including opportunities for behavioral engagement, control over environmental conditions, social environment, physical activity, sleep quality, maternal stress and pain early in life. All of these factors affect pain responses of captive animals, yet most welfare assessments and mitigation protocols treat pain as if it were context-invariant. Here, we review multiple lines of evidence indicating that environmental and rearing conditions modulate pain processing and healing in captive animals. We show that barren, confined environments disable multiple endogenous analgesic mechanisms, while simultaneously activating several neurobiological pathways that intensify nociceptive signaling and delay healing. Pain perception amplification and impaired healing are particularly likely when captivity is associated with intensive and barren environments. The implications of these findings are substantial. First, they highlight the need for animal welfare assessment models, and animal welfare research in general, to take environmental modulation of pain explicitly into account. Likewise, certification and regulatory frameworks must acknowledge that seemingly identical ailments or procedures can produce fundamentally different welfare experiences depending on the environment where they take place. Additionally, analgesic dosing protocols and laboratory-based pain models must be reevaluated for translational validity. More broadly, these findings challenge the acceptability of barren housing systems ubiquitous in farms, laboratories, and other settings. Given the substantial evidence that barren environments amplify and prolong painful states from common routine procedures and ailments, the transition to higher welfare housing systems becomes an ethical and scientific imperative.

  • Open Access

    The Welfare Impact of Heat Stress in South American Beef Cattle and the Cost-Effectiveness of Shade Provision

    by Cynthia Schuck-Paim, Wladimir Jimenez Alonso, Anielly de Paula Freitas, Camila Pereira de Oliveira, Vinicius de França Carvalho Fonseca, Tâmara Duarte Borges

    Heat stress represents a pervasive welfare challenge for beef cattle and other species in tropical and subtropical regions. While its physiological and production impacts are well-documented, quantitative measures of the welfare impact of heat stress remain absent. This study provides the first quantification of the welfare impact of heat stress in beef cattle (mostly Nelore), estimated as cumulative time in thermal discomfort of four intensities (Annoying, Hurtful, Disabling, Excruciating) using the Welfare Footprint Framework. We analyzed climate data from 636 locations over five years across major beef production areas in Brazil, Argentina, Colombia, Paraguay, and Uruguay. Daily heat stress episodes and chronic heat stress exposure were assessed, respectively, using Comprehensive Climate Index (CCI) levels and the Annual Thermal Load metric, which sums daily excesses above a threshold of thermal comfort (CCI = 30 °C) throughout the year, classifying locations into five risk categories. Welfare impacts were estimated for thirteen heat stress scenarios modeled by considering each CCI level within each thermal risk category. Beef cattle in moderate-risk regions were estimated to experience primarily mild thermal discomfort for an average of 5 h daily. This duration increased to an average of 7 h daily in high-risk areas, of which 4.5 h in moderate to intense thermal discomfort (Hurtful or higher). Very high-risk regions reached 10 h of daily thermal discomfort, while extreme-risk regions showed beef cattle facing heat stress for over 11 h on 307 days annually, including over 3 h per day under severe thermoregulatory effort. Overall, 65% of animals were in regions of high thermal risk or above, experiencing between 280 and 2800 h annually in moderate to intense thermal discomfort—a magnitude that places heat stress among the most significant welfare challenges in animal production. Shade provision reduced time in severe discomfort of Disabling intensity by 85% (from 578 to 83 h annually), with economic returns of US$12–16 per animal and payback periods of approximately 16 months. By quantifying welfare impacts as cumulative time in thermal discomfort, shade provision emerges as one of the most effective welfare interventions available for beef cattle, and likely other grazing ruminants, in tropical and subtropical regions.


  • Open Access

    Quantifying the welfare impact of air asphyxia in rainbow trout slaughter for policy and practice

    by Cynthia Schuck-Paim, Wladimir J. Alonso, Patricia Alves Pereira, João L. Saraiva, Marco Cerqueira, Chiawen Chiang, Lynne U. Sneddon

    The effective improvement of animal welfare requires quantitative methods to compare diverse impacts across practices and policies on a common, relatable scale. The Welfare Footprint Framework (WFF) fulfills this need by providing a standardized welfare impact measure: cumulative time in affective states of varying intensities. To this end, WFF estimates rely on documented syntheses of existing research, including behavioral, neurophysiological and pharmacological indicators. We apply this framework to quantify the welfare impact of air asphyxia during fish slaughter, using rainbow trout as a case study. Based on a review of research on stress responses during asphyxiation, we estimate 10 (1.9–21.7) min of moderate to intense pain per trout or 24 (3.5–74) min/kg. Cost-effectiveness modelling shows that electrical stunning could avert 60–1200 min of moderate to extreme pain per US dollar of capital expenditure, but commercial performance remains variable. Percussive stunning demonstrates reliable effectiveness, but still faces implementation challenges. These findings provide transparent, evidence-grounded and comparable metrics to guide cost–benefit decisions and inform slaughter regulations and practices in trout (and potentially other species). With over a trillion fish slaughtered annually, they also demonstrate the potential scale of welfare improvements achievable with effective stunning methods.


  • Open Access

    Cumulative Pain: An Evidence-Based, Easily Interpretable and Interspecific Metric of Welfare Loss

    by Wladimir J. Alonso, Cynthia Schuck-Paim

    We describe a recently developed approach to quantify welfare loss in animals, the Cumulative Pain metric. It combines the two most relevant dimensions of negative affective experiences: intensity and duration. The metric enables estimating the time individuals spend in negative affective states of a physical or psychological nature (operationally referred to simply as ‘pain’) of different intensities as the result of one or more challenges (e.g., diseases, injuries, deprivations). A new notation protocol (the Pain-Track) is used in which the duration of the experience is represented along the horizontal axis and intensity is represented by four categories in the vertical axis. Pain experiences are partitioned into temporal segments, where hypotheses for the experienced duration and intensity are proposed based on existing welfare indicators (e.g., neurophysiological, behavioral, anatomical, evolutionary). This structure forces transparency about assumptions and uncertainties, highlights knowledge gaps, and enables estimates to be continuously adjusted. Because the Cumulative Pain metric is based on parameters with a broadly common biological meaning, it provides the much needed interoperability among assessments of animal welfare. It enables comparing the impact of practices and living conditions, policies and interventions, and the calculation of welfare footprints of animal-sourced products using a universal measurement unit.


  • Open Access

    Productivity of mother pigs is lower in countries that still confine them in gestation crates

    by Cynthia Schuck-Paim, Wladimir J. Alonso

    Background: For decades, pig farmers have used gestation crates — small metal enclosures about two feet wide — to confine pregnant sows (female breeding pigs). Gestation crates physically restrain sows for most of their life, preventing them from walking or even turning around. Millions of females are still housed in these systems. Growing societal concern about animal welfare has been pressuring the industry for change, with recent legislation in the European Union and California restricting the use of crates. Still, the notion that gestation crates negatively affect sow welfare has been challenged by producers in regions where crates are widely used, who argue that, by facilitating health monitoring and preventing aggression, crates lead to lower sow mortality and higher piglet outputs per sow. We address these claims by comparing sow mortality and performance across countries with different housing systems. Methods: To this end, we use publicly available data from InterPig, a network of pig production economists in 17 countries that provides internationally harmonized methods for meaningful comparisons of national production data. Results: The results show that sow mortality is significantly higher, and annual pig production per sow significantly lower, in those countries where gestation crates are still the norm compared to countries in the European Union, where use of gestation crates is restricted to up to four weeks after insemination. Conclusions: Claims of higher mortality and reduced productivity per sow in crate-free systems are not substantiated by this data. This evidence should be considered in policies affecting the welfare of breeding pigs.


  • Open Access

    Pain-Track: a time-series approach for the description and analysis of the burden of pain

    by Wladimir J. Alonso, Cynthia Schuck-Paim

    Objective: To present the Pain-Track, a novel framework for the description and analysis of the pain experience based on its temporal evolution, around which intensity and other attributes of pain (texture, anatomy), interventions and clinical symptoms can be registered. This time-series approach can provide valuable insight on the expected evolution of the pain typically associated with different medical conditions and on time-varying (risk) factors associated with the temporal dynamics of pain.Results: We illustrate the use of the framework to explore hypotheses on the temporal profile of the pain associated with an acute injury (bone fracture), and the magnitude of the pain burden it represents. We also show that, by focusing on the critical dimensions of the pain experience (intensity and time), the approach can help map different conditions to a common scale directly relating to the experiences of those who endure them (time in pain), providing the basis for the quantification of the burden of pain inflicted upon individuals or populations. An electronic version for data entry and interpretation is also presented.


  • Open Access

    Laying hen mortality in different indoor housing systems: a meta-analysis of data from commercial farms in 16 countries

    by Cynthia Schuck-Paim, Elsa Negro-Calduch, Wladimir J. Alonso

    Societal concern with the welfare of egg laying hens housed in conventional cages is fostering a transition towards cage-free systems in many countries. However, although cage-free facilities enable hens to move freely and express natural behaviours, concerns have also been raised over the possibility that cage-free flocks experience higher mortality, potentially compromising some aspects of their welfare. To investigate this possibility, we conducted a large meta-analysis of laying hen mortality in conventional cages, furnished cages and cage-free aviaries using data from 6040 commercial flocks and 176 million hens from 16 countries. We show that except for conventional cages, mortality gradually drops as experience with each system builds up: since 2000, each year of experience with cage-free aviaries was associated with a 0.35–0.65% average drop in cumulative mortality, with no differences in mortality between caged and cage-free systems in more recent years. As management knowledge evolves and genetics are optimized, new producers transitioning to cage-free housing may experience even faster rates of decline. Our results speak against the notion that mortality is inherently higher in cage-free production and illustrate the importance of considering the degree of maturity of production systems in any investigations of farm animal health, behaviour and welfare.


  • Intensive animal farming conditions are a major threat to global health

    by Cynthia Schuck-Paim

    Wiebers & Feigin accurately propose that reducing the risks posed by infectious disease outbreaks and other global health challenges will depend critically on transitioning away from intensive animal farming practices. Creating the right incentive structure for this transition to happen is one of the great challenges in the years to come, but a much-needed step to ensure the health and well-being of current and future generations.


  • Open Access

    Covid-19 em contexto: comparação com a mortalidade mensal por causas respiratórias nos estados brasileiros

    by Wladimir Jimenez Alonso, Cynthia Schuck-Paim, André Ricardo Ribas Freitas, Emil Kupek, Cristiano Rossetto Wuerzius, Elsa Negro-Calduch, Roberto Men Fernandes, Elier Broche Cristo, Ana Beatriz Gorini Veiga, Ricardo Giglio, et al.

    Decisões críticas no combate à pandemia causada pelo SARS-CoV-2 têm sido realizadas frequentemente com dados e informações ainda incompletas. Enquanto os órgãos pertinentes não solucionam os gargalos no fluxo de informações de vital importância, epidemiólogos e outros pesquisadores devem produzir subsídios técnicos para o enfrentamento da crise contornando essas limitações. No presente estudo, focado no Brasil, comparamos os óbitos pelo SARS-CoV-2, disponibilizados diariamente, com os dados de óbitos por doenças respiratórias e outras doenças nos anos de 2014 a 2018 (os últimos cinco anos completos para os quais os dados estão disponíveis). Adicionalmente, extraímos os sinais temporais anuais dos óbitos por doenças respiratórias para que o período típico de pico na mortalidade por essas doenças possa ser considerado em cada estado Brasileiro. A porcentagem de óbitos pelo SARS-CoV-2 até o dia 15 de abril equivale a 24% da mortalidade esperada por causas respiratórias no mesmo período, com base em anos anteriores, com grande variação entre os estados (desde o Amazonas, 151%, até o Tocantins, com 3%). Estamos na época típica de pico de mortalidade associada a doenças respiratórias em grande parte do Norte e Nordeste (com exceção de Roraima). Nas regiões Sudeste e Sul, esse pico é mais tardio (junho–agosto). A evolução da pandemia em cada estado dependerá, no entanto, de vários outros fatores, como o comportamento do patógeno – ainda não conhecido suficientemente. Ressaltamos a necessidade de ações para aumento da agilidade na disponibilização dos dados atuais de mortalidade (por diversas causas), para que equipes de pesquisa com diferentes abordagens analíticas possam se somar no combate a este desafio sanitário global.