Min-Ho Kim
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Min-Ho Kim has a total of 82 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Hyun-Wook Lee
Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology (UNIST)
8 shared publications Jeongwoo Seo
School of Energy and Chemical Engineering, UNIST Ulsan 44919 Korea
3 shared publications- Chihyun Hwang
Advanced Batteries Research Center Korea Electronics Technology Institute
2 shared publications - Dong-Hwa Seo
Department of Materials Science and Engineering Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology Daejeon Republic of Korea
2 shared publications Eunryeol Lee
Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology
2 shared publications- Haeseong Jang
Department of Advanced Materials Engineering, Chung-Ang University, Anseong-si, Republic of Korea
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 15 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Advanced Science
Decoding Electro‐Chemo‐Mechanical Coupled Failure in Silicon Monoxide‐Based Anodes via Operando Pressure Monitoring for All‐Solid‐State Batteries
All‐solid‐state batteries (ASSBs) require high‐energy‐density anodes that operate under practical low stack pressures. Although silicon‐based anodes are promising, most studies rely on stack pressures exceeding 50 MPa. Here, operando pressiometry reveals that areal‐capacity‐normalized stress serves as a comparative indicator of reaction uniformity in silicon monoxide (SiO)‐based anodes. While incorporating solid electrolyte (SE) and conductive carbon improves percolation pathways, SE content paradoxically promotes severe side reactions or lithium plating. Based on insights into the electro‐chemo‐mechanical behavior of SiO‐based anodes, a mixed ionic‐electronic conductor (MIEC) composite architecture combining low‐volume‐expansion SiO with a prelithiated Li 21 Si 5 phase (SiO/PreLiSi) is introduced. The SiO/PreLiSi anode provides continuous ionic and electronic pathways, reduces irreversible capacity loss, and enhances interfacial contact through plastic deformation, enabling uniform lithiation under low stack pressure without external SE and carbon additives. Compared to Si/PreLiSi counterparts, the SiO/PreLiSi composite forms stable buffering phases that mitigate volume changes and suppress stress accumulation. Consequently, the SiO/PreLiSi anode demonstrates reduced pressure variation, improved capacity retention, and prolonged cycling stability under low stack pressure. This work provides a fundamental design principle for next‐generation ASSB anodes capable of practical low‐pressure operation.
- 15 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Advanced Science
Open AccessDecoding Electro‐Chemo‐Mechanical Coupled Failure in Silicon Monoxide‐Based Anodes via Operando Pressure Monitoring for All‐Solid‐State Batteries
All‐solid‐state batteries (ASSBs) require high‐energy‐density anodes that operate under practical low stack pressures. Although silicon‐based anodes are promising, most studies rely on stack pressures exceeding 50 MPa. Here, operando pressiometry reveals that areal‐capacity‐normalized stress serves as a comparative indicator of reaction uniformity in silicon monoxide (SiO)‐based anodes. While incorporating solid electrolyte (SE) and conductive carbon improves percolation pathways, SE content paradoxically promotes severe side reactions or lithium plating. Based on insights into the electro‐chemo‐mechanical behavior of SiO‐based anodes, a mixed ionic‐electronic conductor (MIEC) composite architecture combining low‐volume‐expansion SiO with a prelithiated Li 21 Si 5 phase (SiO/PreLiSi) is introduced. The SiO/PreLiSi anode provides continuous ionic and electronic pathways, reduces irreversible capacity loss, and enhances interfacial contact through plastic deformation, enabling uniform lithiation under low stack pressure without external SE and carbon additives. Compared to Si/PreLiSi counterparts, the SiO/PreLiSi composite forms stable buffering phases that mitigate volume changes and suppress stress accumulation. Consequently, the SiO/PreLiSi anode demonstrates reduced pressure variation, improved capacity retention, and prolonged cycling stability under low stack pressure. This work provides a fundamental design principle for next‐generation ASSB anodes capable of practical low‐pressure operation.
- 11 August 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Surface Science
- Vol. 713
Unveiling the real-time impact of intrinsic binding energy on TMO electrocatalytic performance
- 11 August 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Surface Science
- Vol. 713
Unveiling the real-time impact of intrinsic binding energy on TMO electrocatalytic performance
- Open Access
- 13 June 2025
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 11 (24) , eadv3191
Trapping and imaging dynamic battery nanointerfaces via electrified cryo-EM
The electrified interface between a liquid and a solid underpins diverse phenomena, from ion-transfer during battery operation to action potentials enabling biological communication. However, conventional tools are blind to the nanoscale dynamics of this metastable interface. Here, we leverage electrified cryo–electron microscopy (eCryo-EM), a technique that rapidly freezes and kinetically traps these dynamic, nonequilibrium states during battery operation for nanoscale characterization. Collective snapshots of the electrified interface at controlled time intervals quantifies early-stage growth kinetics of the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI), a passivation film that governs electron and ion transport. Unexpectedly, the diffusivity of charged species of the two SEI films with differing chemistry and performance are estimated to be within 10% of the other, indicated by the slope of their diffusion-limited SEI growth regimes. Instead, the slope of the reaction-limited SEI growth regimes differs by a factor of 3, suggesting that lowered reactivity of the high-performance electrolyte is largely responsible for its high coulombic efficiency.
- 13 June 2025
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 11 (24) , eadv3191
Open AccessTrapping and imaging dynamic battery nanointerfaces via electrified cryo-EM
The electrified interface between a liquid and a solid underpins diverse phenomena, from ion-transfer during battery operation to action potentials enabling biological communication. However, conventional tools are blind to the nanoscale dynamics of this metastable interface. Here, we leverage electrified cryo–electron microscopy (eCryo-EM), a technique that rapidly freezes and kinetically traps these dynamic, nonequilibrium states during battery operation for nanoscale characterization. Collective snapshots of the electrified interface at controlled time intervals quantifies early-stage growth kinetics of the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI), a passivation film that governs electron and ion transport. Unexpectedly, the diffusivity of charged species of the two SEI films with differing chemistry and performance are estimated to be within 10% of the other, indicated by the slope of their diffusion-limited SEI growth regimes. Instead, the slope of the reaction-limited SEI growth regimes differs by a factor of 3, suggesting that lowered reactivity of the high-performance electrolyte is largely responsible for its high coulombic efficiency.
- Open Access
- 21 February 2025
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 11 (8) , eadt0232
Metal-to-metal charge transfer for stabilizing high-voltage redox in lithium-rich layered oxide cathodes
Apart from conventional redox chemistries, exploring high-voltage anionic redox processes, such as pure oxygen or high-valent transition metal ion redox, poses challenges due to the instability of O nonbonding or O-dominant energy states. These states are associated with destructive behaviors in layered oxide cathodes, including local structural distortion, cationic disordering, and oxygen gas evolution. In this study, we suppress first-cycle voltage hysteresis and irreversible O 2 evolution in Li-rich oxide cathodes through covalency competition induced by the substitution of electropositive groups. We found that the nonequivalent electron distribution within an asymmetric M A -O-M B backbone (metal-to-metal charge transfer via oxygen ligands) increases electron density on electronegative transition metal ions, preventing them from reaching unstable oxidation states within an operating voltage range. This phenomenon is observed across diverse transition metal combinations, providing insights into controlling unnecessary oxygen redox activity. Our findings open new avenues for controlling intrinsic redox chemistry and enabling the rational design of high–energy density Li-rich oxide cathodes.
- 21 February 2025
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 11 (8) , eadt0232
Open AccessMetal-to-metal charge transfer for stabilizing high-voltage redox in lithium-rich layered oxide cathodes
Apart from conventional redox chemistries, exploring high-voltage anionic redox processes, such as pure oxygen or high-valent transition metal ion redox, poses challenges due to the instability of O nonbonding or O-dominant energy states. These states are associated with destructive behaviors in layered oxide cathodes, including local structural distortion, cationic disordering, and oxygen gas evolution. In this study, we suppress first-cycle voltage hysteresis and irreversible O 2 evolution in Li-rich oxide cathodes through covalency competition induced by the substitution of electropositive groups. We found that the nonequivalent electron distribution within an asymmetric M A -O-M B backbone (metal-to-metal charge transfer via oxygen ligands) increases electron density on electronegative transition metal ions, preventing them from reaching unstable oxidation states within an operating voltage range. This phenomenon is observed across diverse transition metal combinations, providing insights into controlling unnecessary oxygen redox activity. Our findings open new avenues for controlling intrinsic redox chemistry and enabling the rational design of high–energy density Li-rich oxide cathodes.
- 27 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Angewandte Chemie
- Vol. 135 (48)
Guaiacol as an Organic Superoxide Dismutase Mimics for Anti‐ageing a Ru‐based Li‐rich Layered Oxide Cathode
High‐capacity Li‐rich layered oxides using oxygen redox as well as transition metal redox suffer from its structural instability due to lattice oxygen escaped from its structure during oxygen redox and the following electrolyte decomposition by the reactive oxygen species. Herein, we rescued a Li‐rich layered oxide based on 4d transition metal by employing an organic superoxide dismutase mimics as a homogeneous electrolyte additive. Guaiacol scavenged superoxide radicals via dismutation or disproportionation to convert two superoxide molecules to peroxide and dioxygen after absorbing lithium superoxide on its partially negative oxygen of methoxy and hydroxyl groups. Additionally, guaiacol was decomposed to form a thin and stable cathode‐electrolyte interphase (CEI) layer, endowing the cathode with the interfacial stability.
- 27 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Angewandte Chemie
- Vol. 135 (48)
Guaiacol as an Organic Superoxide Dismutase Mimics for Anti‐ageing a Ru‐based Li‐rich Layered Oxide Cathode
High‐capacity Li‐rich layered oxides using oxygen redox as well as transition metal redox suffer from its structural instability due to lattice oxygen escaped from its structure during oxygen redox and the following electrolyte decomposition by the reactive oxygen species. Herein, we rescued a Li‐rich layered oxide based on 4d transition metal by employing an organic superoxide dismutase mimics as a homogeneous electrolyte additive. Guaiacol scavenged superoxide radicals via dismutation or disproportionation to convert two superoxide molecules to peroxide and dioxygen after absorbing lithium superoxide on its partially negative oxygen of methoxy and hydroxyl groups. Additionally, guaiacol was decomposed to form a thin and stable cathode‐electrolyte interphase (CEI) layer, endowing the cathode with the interfacial stability.
- 27 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Angewandte Chemie International Edition
- Vol. 62 (48) , e202312928
Guaiacol as an Organic Superoxide Dismutase Mimics for Anti‐ageing a Ru‐based Li‐rich Layered Oxide Cathode
High‐capacity Li‐rich layered oxides using oxygen redox as well as transition metal redox suffer from its structural instability due to lattice oxygen escaped from its structure during oxygen redox and the following electrolyte decomposition by the reactive oxygen species. Herein, we rescued a Li‐rich layered oxide based on 4d transition metal by employing an organic superoxide dismutase mimics as a homogeneous electrolyte additive. Guaiacol scavenged superoxide radicals via dismutation or disproportionation to convert two superoxide molecules to peroxide and dioxygen after absorbing lithium superoxide on its partially negative oxygen of methoxy and hydroxyl groups. Additionally, guaiacol was decomposed to form a thin and stable cathode‐electrolyte interphase (CEI) layer, endowing the cathode with the interfacial stability.
- 27 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Angewandte Chemie International Edition
- Vol. 62 (48) , e202312928
Guaiacol as an Organic Superoxide Dismutase Mimics for Anti‐ageing a Ru‐based Li‐rich Layered Oxide Cathode
High‐capacity Li‐rich layered oxides using oxygen redox as well as transition metal redox suffer from its structural instability due to lattice oxygen escaped from its structure during oxygen redox and the following electrolyte decomposition by the reactive oxygen species. Herein, we rescued a Li‐rich layered oxide based on 4d transition metal by employing an organic superoxide dismutase mimics as a homogeneous electrolyte additive. Guaiacol scavenged superoxide radicals via dismutation or disproportionation to convert two superoxide molecules to peroxide and dioxygen after absorbing lithium superoxide on its partially negative oxygen of methoxy and hydroxyl groups. Additionally, guaiacol was decomposed to form a thin and stable cathode‐electrolyte interphase (CEI) layer, endowing the cathode with the interfacial stability.
- Open Access
- 3 February 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Metal-to-metal charge transfer driven by the electropositive species for stable anionic redox chemistry
Apart from conventional redox chemistries, exploring novel anionic redox chemistry, such as pure oxygen redox or delocalized π redox, is challenging due to unstable O non-bonding or O-dominant energy states in them correlated with a destructive structural disorder in Li-rich cathode materials. Here we show a new strategy to stabilize anionic redox chemistry in 4d-based Li-rich oxides by substituting electropositive 3d transition-metal (TM) species. Metal-to-metal charge transfer, driven by covalency competition within asymmetric TM3d-O-TM4d backbone, induces larger charge density on electronegative Ru species and stabilizes its high-voltage redox by lowering oxidation states. Furthermore, we reveal that the t2g occupancy of 3d TM substituents is indicative of polarity on the bonding between Ru and O, where high t2g occupancy gives rise to electron repulsion toward Ru, making b1* states more cationic. These insights open new perspectives for the control of intrinsic redox chemistry and enable rational designs for high-energy-density Li-rich cathodes.
- 3 February 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessMetal-to-metal charge transfer driven by the electropositive species for stable anionic redox chemistry
Apart from conventional redox chemistries, exploring novel anionic redox chemistry, such as pure oxygen redox or delocalized π redox, is challenging due to unstable O non-bonding or O-dominant energy states in them correlated with a destructive structural disorder in Li-rich cathode materials. Here we show a new strategy to stabilize anionic redox chemistry in 4d-based Li-rich oxides by substituting electropositive 3d transition-metal (TM) species. Metal-to-metal charge transfer, driven by covalency competition within asymmetric TM3d-O-TM4d backbone, induces larger charge density on electronegative Ru species and stabilizes its high-voltage redox by lowering oxidation states. Furthermore, we reveal that the t2g occupancy of 3d TM substituents is indicative of polarity on the bonding between Ru and O, where high t2g occupancy gives rise to electron repulsion toward Ru, making b1* states more cationic. These insights open new perspectives for the control of intrinsic redox chemistry and enable rational designs for high-energy-density Li-rich cathodes.
- 1 September 2019
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2019-02 (2) , 73
The Chemical Stability of Nasicon As a Solid Electrolyte for Seawater Batteries
Seawater batteries have attracted significant attention for use as grid-scale energy storage systems (ESSs) due to the effective utilization of abundant resources of seawater as a catholyte. Sodium ions in seawater selectively transfer through a solid electrolyte to the anode for saving the chemical energy. For the selective transfer of sodium ions, NASICON (Na3Zr2Si2PO12) electrolytes are one of the suitable candidates for the solid electrolyte to prevent a short circuit between the catholyte and anode. However, NASICON powder is known to be dissolved in water because of the structural instability, leading to catastrophic failure of the system, while NASICON solid electrolytes are stable in seawater during the battery operation. In this regard, we have carefully compared the stability of NASICON powder and pellets in both DI water and seawater associated with different degradation mechanism. Figure shows the structural stability of NASICON pellets after the immersion tests in DI water and seawater indicative of the chemical stability of NASICON in seawater. In addition, the electrochemical performance shows higher stability of the seawater-immersed electrolyte than the DI water-immersed electrolyte. The corresponding analyses are carried out to confirm the effect of the investigation. Furthermore, we have employed polymer coating methods to enhance stability and performance as a seawater battery system. The coating layer enables to prevent direct contact with seawater, resulting in longer stability during operation without compromising ionic conductivity. These results reveal that NASICON solid electrolytes can be operated in seawater with high stability and performance. Figure. The chemical stability comparison of NASICON in seawater and DI water References Mauvy, F., Siebert, E., & Fabry, P. (1999). Reactivity of NASICON with water and interpretation of the detection limit of a NASICON based Na+ion selective electrode. Talanta , 48(2), 293–303. Fuentes, R. O., Figueiredo, F., Marques, F. M. B., & Franco, J. I. (2001). Reaction of NASICON with water, Solid State Ionics , 263, 309–314. Kim, Y., Kim, H., Park, S., Seo, I., & Kim, Y. (2016). Na ion- Conducting Ceramic as Solid Electrolyte for Rechargeable Seawater Batteries. Electrochimica Acta , 191, 1–7. Jung, J. Il, Kim, D., Kim, H., Jo, Y. N., Park, J. S., & Kim, Y. (2017). Progressive Assessment on the Decomposition Reaction of Na Superionic Conducting Ceramics. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces , 9(1), 304–310. Figure 1
- 1 September 2019
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2019-02 (2) , 73
The Chemical Stability of Nasicon As a Solid Electrolyte for Seawater Batteries
Seawater batteries have attracted significant attention for use as grid-scale energy storage systems (ESSs) due to the effective utilization of abundant resources of seawater as a catholyte. Sodium ions in seawater selectively transfer through a solid electrolyte to the anode for saving the chemical energy. For the selective transfer of sodium ions, NASICON (Na3Zr2Si2PO12) electrolytes are one of the suitable candidates for the solid electrolyte to prevent a short circuit between the catholyte and anode. However, NASICON powder is known to be dissolved in water because of the structural instability, leading to catastrophic failure of the system, while NASICON solid electrolytes are stable in seawater during the battery operation. In this regard, we have carefully compared the stability of NASICON powder and pellets in both DI water and seawater associated with different degradation mechanism. Figure shows the structural stability of NASICON pellets after the immersion tests in DI water and seawater indicative of the chemical stability of NASICON in seawater. In addition, the electrochemical performance shows higher stability of the seawater-immersed electrolyte than the DI water-immersed electrolyte. The corresponding analyses are carried out to confirm the effect of the investigation. Furthermore, we have employed polymer coating methods to enhance stability and performance as a seawater battery system. The coating layer enables to prevent direct contact with seawater, resulting in longer stability during operation without compromising ionic conductivity. These results reveal that NASICON solid electrolytes can be operated in seawater with high stability and performance. Figure. The chemical stability comparison of NASICON in seawater and DI water References Mauvy, F., Siebert, E., & Fabry, P. (1999). Reactivity of NASICON with water and interpretation of the detection limit of a NASICON based Na+ion selective electrode. Talanta , 48(2), 293–303. Fuentes, R. O., Figueiredo, F., Marques, F. M. B., & Franco, J. I. (2001). Reaction of NASICON with water, Solid State Ionics , 263, 309–314. Kim, Y., Kim, H., Park, S., Seo, I., & Kim, Y. (2016). Na ion- Conducting Ceramic as Solid Electrolyte for Rechargeable Seawater Batteries. Electrochimica Acta , 191, 1–7. Jung, J. Il, Kim, D., Kim, H., Jo, Y. N., Park, J. S., & Kim, Y. (2017). Progressive Assessment on the Decomposition Reaction of Na Superionic Conducting Ceramics. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces , 9(1), 304–310. Figure 1
- 1 September 2019
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2019-02 (2) , 102
(Invited) Nanocrevasse-Rich Carbon Fibers for Scalable Production and Stable Performance of Lithium and Sodium Metal Anodes
The metallic lithium (Li) and sodium (Na) anodes have long been considered as ideal anodes for high energy density batteries due to its high theoretical capacity and lowest reduction potential. However, the challenges induced by dendritic growth on metallic Li and Na anodes hinder the practical applications. Finding a stable host structure with polar functional groups is an essential strategy to prevent the Li and Na dendrite growth with improved electrochemical performance. Recently, many researchers have concentrated on development of host structure for storing the Li/Na metal. Nevertheless, complexity and inconvenience of the synthetic process still require further improvement of Li/Na metal anodes. In this talk, we will introduce a facile synthetic method to fabricate alkali metal/carbon composites which contain nanocrevasses in carbon fibers to facilitate the penetration of molten alkali metal via capillary forces. When the molten alkali metal is contacted to the carbon fibers with rGO-like crevasses, the metallic liquid infiltrates into the fine gaps within a few seconds. As well, the nanocrevasses provide a pretty large surface area which is enough to lower the specific current, ultimately leading to suppression of dendritic formation. The resulting alkali metal/carbon composites exhibit stable long-term cycling over hundreds of cycles. In addition, Unlike previous studies that focused on improving the performance of metal batteries, we carried out the test after applying the composite to actual equipment with scalable production process using recycled metal waste. Thus, the addition of nanocrevasses to carbon fiber as a scaffold for alkali metals can generate environmentally friendly and cost-effective composites for practical electrode applications References Go, W.; Kim, M.-H.; Park, J.; Lim, C.H.; Joo, S.H.; Kim, Y.; Lee, H.-W. Nano Lett. 2019, 19, 1504-1511. Lin, D.; Liu, Y.; Liang, Z.; Lee, H.-W.; Sun, J.; Wang, H.; Yan, K.; Xie, J.; Cui, Y. Nat. Nanotechnol. 2016, 11, 626-632. Zhang, R.; Chen, X.; Chen, X.; Cheng, X.; Zhang, X.; Yan, C.; Zhang, Q. Chem. int. Ed. 2017, 56, 7764-7768. Yun, J.H.; Kim, J.H.; Kim, D.K.; Lee, H.-W. Nano Lett. 2018, 18, 475–481. Figure 1
- 1 September 2019
- Published by The Electrochemical Society in ECS Meeting Abstracts
- Vol. MA2019-02 (2) , 102
(Invited) Nanocrevasse-Rich Carbon Fibers for Scalable Production and Stable Performance of Lithium and Sodium Metal Anodes
The metallic lithium (Li) and sodium (Na) anodes have long been considered as ideal anodes for high energy density batteries due to its high theoretical capacity and lowest reduction potential. However, the challenges induced by dendritic growth on metallic Li and Na anodes hinder the practical applications. Finding a stable host structure with polar functional groups is an essential strategy to prevent the Li and Na dendrite growth with improved electrochemical performance. Recently, many researchers have concentrated on development of host structure for storing the Li/Na metal. Nevertheless, complexity and inconvenience of the synthetic process still require further improvement of Li/Na metal anodes. In this talk, we will introduce a facile synthetic method to fabricate alkali metal/carbon composites which contain nanocrevasses in carbon fibers to facilitate the penetration of molten alkali metal via capillary forces. When the molten alkali metal is contacted to the carbon fibers with rGO-like crevasses, the metallic liquid infiltrates into the fine gaps within a few seconds. As well, the nanocrevasses provide a pretty large surface area which is enough to lower the specific current, ultimately leading to suppression of dendritic formation. The resulting alkali metal/carbon composites exhibit stable long-term cycling over hundreds of cycles. In addition, Unlike previous studies that focused on improving the performance of metal batteries, we carried out the test after applying the composite to actual equipment with scalable production process using recycled metal waste. Thus, the addition of nanocrevasses to carbon fiber as a scaffold for alkali metals can generate environmentally friendly and cost-effective composites for practical electrode applications References Go, W.; Kim, M.-H.; Park, J.; Lim, C.H.; Joo, S.H.; Kim, Y.; Lee, H.-W. Nano Lett. 2019, 19, 1504-1511. Lin, D.; Liu, Y.; Liang, Z.; Lee, H.-W.; Sun, J.; Wang, H.; Yan, K.; Xie, J.; Cui, Y. Nat. Nanotechnol. 2016, 11, 626-632. Zhang, R.; Chen, X.; Chen, X.; Cheng, X.; Zhang, X.; Yan, C.; Zhang, Q. Chem. int. Ed. 2017, 56, 7764-7768. Yun, J.H.; Kim, J.H.; Kim, D.K.; Lee, H.-W. Nano Lett. 2018, 18, 475–481. Figure 1