SBSarah Ballard

Sarah Ballard

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Sarah Ballard has a total of 490 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    An Increase in the Galactic Planet-host Fraction Fails to Reproduce the Galactic Height Trend in Planet Occurrence

    by Christopher Lam, Sarah Ballard, Sheila Sagear, Kathryne J. Daniel

    While stellar metallicity has long been known to correlate with planetary properties, the Galactic metallicity gradient alone does not account for the observed strong trend in planet occurrence with Galactic height. In this study, we investigate the observable effect of a time-dependent planet occurrence rate upon a sample of stars selected uniformly from the Kepler and K2 surveys. Using a novel planetary system population synthesis code, psps , we impose several prescriptions for a time-variable planet-host fraction, f , in which a primordial f 1 either instantaneously or gradually increased to a present-day f 2 . We then simulate the expected small planet (1–4 R ⊕ ) occurrence rate around FGK dwarfs as a function of Galactic height. Finally, we compare the modeled trends to the observed result from the missions themselves. We find that, using a joint Kepler-K2 sample with isochrone ages, an increase in f is insufficient to reproduce the strength of the observed trend between occurrence and Galactic height. We show that not all of this is due to insufficient age precision: using a synthetic stellar population from the TRILEGAL framework with very precise ages, we can rule out models of gradually increasing f . We also derive the Kepler occurrence–height relation and find that an increase in f is better able to match this trend. An analysis using more precise ages and incorporating an evolving compact multifraction could furnish a realistic relation in planet occurrence with Galactic height that matches the observed Kepler-K2 trend.

  • Open Access

    Planets in the Radius Gap Lack the Peas-in-a-pod Size Correlation

    by Quadry Chance, Sarah Ballard

    Planets in compact multitransiting systems tend to exhibit self-similarity with their neighbors, a phenomenon commonly called “peas-in-a-pod.” Previous studies have identified that this self-similarity appears independently among super-Earths and sub-Neptunes orbiting the same star. In this study, we investigate whether the peas-in-a-pod phenomenon holds for planets in the radius valley between these two categories (located at ∼1.8 R⊕). Employing the Kepler sample of planets in multitransiting systems, we construct a difference-in-differences test that compares the observed fraction of size-similar adjacent pairs to the fraction expected from the underlying radius distribution alone, computed independently for valley-inclusive and valley-exclusive pairs. We find that nonvalley pairs exhibit a 1.87× enhancement of size-similar pairs above the baseline, consistent with the well-established peas-in-a-pod phenomenon. Pairs involving a radius-valley planet show no such enhancement, and we exclude at p = 0.001 the hypothesis that the same size-similarity mechanism operates at the same strength for valley-inclusive pairs. The observed fraction of size-similar valley-inclusive pairs is consistent with independent draws from the radius distribution, with no additional intrasystem correlation. We further compare the period-ratio distributions for the two pair classes. While globally indistinguishable (KS p = 0.848), valley-inclusive pairs cluster near the 3:2 mean-motion resonance at more than twice the rate of the parent population, while avoiding the tightest orbital spacings entirely. The convergence of disrupted size-similarity and anomalous resonance architecture, together with independently measured elevated eccentricities among valley planets, is consistent with a stochastic process such as late-stage giant impacts contributing to the population of planets in the radius valley.

  • Open Access

    The Orbital Eccentricities of Planets in the Kinematic Thin and Thick Galactic Disks

    by Sheila Sagear, Sarah Ballard, Kathryne J. Daniel, Adrian M. Price-Whelan, Sóley Ó. Hyman, Gregory J. Gilbert, Christopher Lam

    The orbital eccentricity distribution of exoplanets is shaped by a combination of dynamical processes, reflecting both formation conditions and long-term evolution. Probing the orbital dynamics of planets in the kinematic thin and thick Galactic disks provides insight into the degree to which stellar and Galactic environmental factors affect planet formation and evolution pathways. The classification of host stars in Galactic kinematic terms constitutes a potentially useful axis for the interpretation of orbital eccentricity, when included together with stellar metallicity and age. Leveraging the photoeccentric effect, we constrain orbital eccentricities for the sample of Kepler planets and candidates orbiting F, G, K, and M dwarf stars. With Gaia astrometry, inferred Galactic phase space information, and kinematic disk criteria calibrated on stellar chemical abundances, we implement a machine learning approach to associate each planet host with the kinematic thin or thick Galactic disks. We then fit the underlying eccentricity distributions for the single- and multitransit populations. We find that for single-transiting planets, kinematic thick-disk planets exhibit higher eccentricities than thin-disk planets, yet we find no such difference among multitransiting planets. We determine that the difference in eccentricity is unlikely to be caused solely by the effects of host stellar metallicity or giant planet occurrence. We situate these findings in the context of known eccentricity relations, including their relationships with planet multiplicity, radius, and metallicity. We suggest comprehensive analyses to disentangle these results from the effects of poorly understood star–planet relationships, such as those between stellar age and planetary orbital dynamics.

  • Open Access

    The Orbital Eccentricity–Radius Relation for Planets Orbiting M Dwarfs

    by Sheila Sagear, Sarah Ballard, Gregory J. Gilbert, Mariangel Albornoz, Christopher Lam

    The orbital eccentricity–radius relation for small planets is indicative of the predominant dynamical sculpting processes during late-stage orbital evolution. Previous studies have shown that planets orbiting Sun-like stars exhibit an eccentricity–radius trend such that larger planets have higher orbital eccentricities, and that radius gap planets may have modestly higher orbital eccentricities than planets on either side of the radius gap. In this work, we investigate the trend for a sample of smaller M dwarf stars. For a sample of 236 single- and multitransit confirmed planets or candidates discovered by the TESS and Kepler missions, we constrain orbital eccentricity for each planet from the transit photometry together with a stellar density prior. We investigate the binned eccentricity–planet radius relation for the combined planet sample and present evidence for a positive eccentricity–radius relationship with elevated eccentricities for planets larger than 3.5 R ⊕ , similar to the trend for planets orbiting Sun-like stars. We find modest evidence that single-transit M dwarf planets near the radius gap exhibit higher eccentricity, consistent with trends for Sun-like stars. However, we see no evidence for an increased eccentricity near the radius gap among multitransit M dwarf planets. We discuss implications for these results in the context of predominant atmospheric loss mechanisms: namely, supporting evidence for photoevaporation in M dwarf planets versus planet–planet collisions or giant impacts in FGK dwarf planets.


  • Open Access

    A Search for Transit Duration Variations in M dwarf Multi-Planet Systems

    by Kohhei Bessho, Sarah Ballard, Natalia Guerrero

    The nominal habitable zone for exoplanets orbiting M dwarfs lies close to the host star, making dynamical considerations especially important. One consequence of this proximity is the expectation of spin synchronization, with implications for atmospheric circulation. Several mechanisms can maintain non-zero obliquities over long timescales in compact multi-planet systems, including capture into Cassini State 2 (CS2) and other forms of secular spin-orbit coupling; such pathways are plausible in the orbital architectures of close-in M-dwarf planets. In this study, we search for transit duration variations (TDVs) consistent with the nodal precession rates predicted by Laplace-Lagrange secular theory in compact M-dwarf multi-planet systems. Our sample includes 23 exoplanets orbiting 12 stars. We compare recent, high-precision transit durations obtained from JWST white-light curves with measurements published at the discovery epoch and afterward. The resulting transit duration variation ranges from seconds to minutes, and we fit a linear trend to duration versus time for each planet. All systems are consistent with flat (no TDV) at the 3σ level. The strongest candidate is TRAPPIST-1d, whose fitted slope differs from zero with 2.2σ confidence. We calculate the expected TDV signals predicted by secular precession and compare them to the observed limits. Our null detection is consistent with the low-impact-parameter regime, where theoretical TDVs are only a few seconds per decade and below our sensitivity. Higher-impact-parameter configurations predict substantially larger TDVs and are disfavored: under uniformly distributed geometries, at least half of the allowed configurations would be excluded.

  • Open Access

    paired: A Statistical Framework for Detecting Stellar Binarity with Gaia RVs. I. Sensitivity to Unresolved Binaries

    by Quadry Chance, Daniel Foreman-Mackey, Sarah Ballard, Andrew R. Casey, Trevor J. David, Adrian M. Price-Whelan

    Data Release 3 (DR3) from the Gaia Mission includes radial velocity measurements of over 33 million targets. Among many scientific applications, the overlap of this stellar sample with targeted exoplanet transit survey stars presents an opportunity to understand planet occurrence in the context of stellar multiplicity on a large scale. Yet, any interpretation of occurrence relies upon an understanding of survey sensitivity. While the sensitivity to planets in transit surveys is well-understood, a characterization of the sensitivity of Gaia to unresolved binaries is also critical. We describe here a statistical framework called paired, which we developed to enable the forward modeling of Gaia radial velocity observables for large samples of stars. The paired machinery links the reported radial velocity noise for a given star from Gaia to the probability of a spatially unresolved stellar companion. We demonstrate how this enables the user, given an observed distribution of individual binary “probabilities” for a set of stars, to understand this distribution within the sensitivity limits of Gaia. For the subset of stars with the highest probability of excess radial velocity noise, we describe the ability of paired to constrain the semi-amplitude of the stellar binary. Where possible, we benchmark our inferred radial velocity semi-amplitudes against those from ground-based radial velocity surveys, as well as the subset published by Gaia DR3 itself. We aim for paired to be a community tool for the exploration of the effects of binarity on planets at a population level, but also for any user interested in stellar populations.


  • Open Access

    Updated Masses for the Gas Giants in the Eight-planet Kepler-90 System Via Transit-timing Variation and Radial Velocity Observations

    by David E. Shaw, Lauren M. Weiss, Eric Agol, Karen A. Collins, Khalid Barkaoui, Cristilyn N. Watkins, Richard P. Schwarz, Howard M. Relles, Chris Stockdale, John F. Kielkopf, et al.

    The eight-planet Kepler-90 system exhibits the greatest multiplicity of planets found to date. All eight planets are transiting and were discovered in photometry from the NASA Kepler primary mission. The two outermost planets, g (P g = 211 days) and h (P h = 332 days), exhibit significant transit-timing variations (TTVs), but were only observed six and three times, respectively, by Kepler. These TTVs allow for the determination of planetary masses through dynamical modeling of the pair’s gravitational interactions, but the paucity of transits allows a broad range of solutions for the masses and orbital ephemerides. To determine accurate masses and orbital parameters for planets g and h, we combined 34 radial velocities (RVs) of Kepler-90, collected over a decade, with the Kepler transit data. We jointly modeled the transit times of the outer two planets and the RV time series, then used our two-planet model to predict their future times of transit. These predictions led us to recover a transit of Kepler-90 g with ground-based observatories in 2024 May. We then combined the 2024 transit and several previously unpublished transit times of planets g and h with the Kepler photometry and RV data to update the masses and linear ephemerides of the planets, finding masses for g and h of 15.0 ± 1.3 M ⊕ and 203 ± 16 M ⊕, respectively, from a Markov Chain Monte Carlo analysis. These results enable further insights into the architecturally rich Kepler-90 system and pave the way for atmospheric characterization with space-based facilities.


  • Open Access

    Updated Masses for the Gas Giants in the Eight-Planet Kepler-90 System Via Transit-Timing Variation and Radial Velocity Observations

    by David E. Shaw, Lauren M. Weiss, Eric Agol, Karen A. Collins, Khalid Barkaoui, Cristilyn N. Watkins, Richard P. Schwarz, Howard M. Relles, Chris Stockdale, John F. Kielkopf, et al.

    The eight-planet Kepler-90 system exhibits the greatest multiplicity of planets found to date. All eight planets are transiting and were discovered in photometry from the NASA Kepler primary mission. The two outermost planets, g ($P_g$ = 211 d) and h ($P_h$ = 332 d) exhibit significant transit-timing variations (TTVs), but were only observed 6 and 3 times respectively by Kepler. These TTVs allow for the determination of planetary masses through dynamical modeling of the pair's gravitational interactions, but the paucity of transits allows a broad range of solutions for the masses and orbital ephemerides. To determine accurate masses and orbital parameters for planets g and h, we combined 34 radial velocities (RVs) of Kepler-90, collected over a decade, with the Kepler transit data. We jointly modeled the transit times of the outer two planets and the RV time series, then used our two-planet model to predict their future times of transit. These predictions led us to recover a transit of Kepler-90 g with ground-based observatories in May 2024. We then combined the 2024 transit and several previously unpublished transit times of planets g and h with the Kepler photometry and RV data to update the masses and linear ephemerides of the planets, finding masses for g and h of $15.0 \pm 1.3\, M_\oplus$, and $203 \pm 16\, M_\oplus$ respectively from a Markov Chain Monte Carlo analysis. These results enable further insights into the architecturally rich Kepler-90 system and pave the way for atmospheric characterization with space-based facilities.

  • Open Access

    Quantifying the Effect of Short-timescale Stellar Activity Upon Transit Detection in M Dwarfs

    by Dana Clarice Yaptangco, Sarah Ballard, Jason Dittmann, Mariangel Albornoz

    M dwarf stars comprise 70%–80% of the galaxy's stars and host most of its rocky planets. They also differ from Sunlike stars in that they are “active” for billions of years or more: rotating quickly, flaring often, and emitting large amounts of UV and X-ray light. The effects of stellar activity upon both photometry and spectroscopy make their exoplanets more difficult to detect. While activity signals such as flaring and stellar rotation can be more readily modeled or removed from photometry, the contribution of unresolved stellar activity to transit sensitivity is harder to quantify. We investigate the difference in the detectability of planetary transits around a sample of M dwarfs observed by NASA's Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) Mission, characterized by a common stellar radius, effective temperature, and TESS magnitude. Our sample is classified as either “active” or “inactive” based upon the presence of Hα in emission. After removing more readily identifiable signatures of activity: stellar rotation and large flares, we perform an injection-and-recovery analysis of transits for each star. We extract detection sensitivity as a function of planetary radius and orbital period for each star. Then, we produce averaged sensitivity maps for the “active” stars and the “inactive” stars, for the sake of comparison. We quantify the extent to which signal-to-noise ratio is degraded for transit detection, when comparing an active star to an inactive star of the same temperature and apparent brightness. We aim for these sensitivity maps to be useful to the exoplanet community in future M dwarf occurrence-rate studies.


  • Open Access

    zoomies: A Tool to Infer Stellar Age from Vertical Action in Gaia Data

    by Sheila Sagear, Adrian M. Price-Whelan, Sarah Ballard, Yuxi (Lucy) Lu, Ruth Angus, David W. Hogg

    Stellar age measurements are fundamental to understanding a wide range of astronomical processes, including Galactic dynamics, stellar evolution, and planetary system formation. However, extracting age information from main-sequence stars is complicated, with techniques often relying on age proxies in the absence of direct measurements. The Gaia data releases have enabled detailed studies of the dynamical properties of stars within the Milky Way, offering new opportunities to understand the relationship between stellar age and dynamics. In this study, we leverage high-precision astrometric data from Gaia DR3 to construct a stellar age prediction model based only on stellar dynamical properties, namely the vertical action. We calibrate two distinct, hierarchical stellar age–vertical action relations, first employing asteroseismic ages for red-giant-branch stars, then isochrone ages for main-sequence turn-off stars. We describe a framework called zoomies based on this calibration, by which we can infer ages for any star given its vertical action. This tool is open-source and intended for community use. We compare dynamical age estimates from zoomies with age measurements from open clusters and asteroseismology. We use zoomies to generate and compare dynamical age estimates for stars from the Kepler, K2, and TESS exoplanet transit surveys. While dynamical age relations are associated with large uncertainty, they are generally mass independent and depend on homogeneously measured astrometric data. These age predictions are uniquely useful for large-scale demographic investigations, especially in disentangling the relationship between planet occurrence, metallicity, and age for low-mass stars.