BLBarry Lyons

Barry Lyons

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Barry Lyons has a total of 71 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Courts, rights and the critically brain-injured patient

    by Barry Lyons, Mary Donnelly

    The reality of current clinical practice in the UK is that where a patient’s family refuses to agree to testing for brain stem death (BD), such cases will ultimately end up in court. This situation is true of both adults and children and reinforced by recent legal cases. While recourse to the courts might be regrettable in such tragic cases, if public trust in the medical diagnosis of BD is to be maintained all aspects of the process must be conducted in a way that is transparent and open to scrutiny. This is not an ‘ineffective expenditure’ of resources, but an essential element of a human rights-compliant legal system.

  • Puzzles of the Liminal Dead: St George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust v Casey

    by Mary Donnelly, Barry Lyons

    St George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust v Casey 1 is the latest in a growing line of cases before the UK courts concerning objections to the determination of brain stem death (BD). 2 The case is distinguishable from most of the earlier jurisprudence because it concerned an adult 3 and, in this respect, it provides helpful clarity regarding the procedural framework to be applied in such situations. However, as we will see below, in other respects the case serves to increase confusion. One particular problem that arises from the judgment in Casey is how we conceptualise the legal status of an individual who has been found to be brain dead by clinicians, but this finding is disputed by families, either in respect of procedure or substance, and the courts have been asked to rule on the matter. The case also raises new questions about the operationalization of testing for BD, which questions assume particular significance given the ongoing work to revise the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges’ Code of Practice for the Diagnosis and Confirmation of Death (2008) (hereafter ‘the Code’). This commentary will explore both of these aspects of the case. First, however, we outline the facts and identify those areas in which the legal position has been clarified.

  • Life without Gillick: Adolescent sexual and reproductive healthcare in Ireland

    by Barry Lyons, Mary Donnelly

    The decision of the House of Lords in Gillick v West Norfolk Area Health Authority carved out a safe space for competent minors to confidentially access sexual and reproductive health care and advice in the UK. Ireland is one of the few common law jurisdictions that has not endorsed Gillick or a similar mature minor doctrine, nor has it securely legislated for the right to consent of those aged 16 and 17 years. The legal lacuna created by this deficiency has left young persons in Ireland seeking sexual and reproductive healthcare, and the clinicians who provide this, in a challenging place. While this void has been partially filled with policy statements by bodies such as the Irish College of General Practitioners and the Health Service Executive, nonetheless the legal shortcomings leave both a sense of insecurity, and real world difficulties for adolescents seeking to access to sexual and reproductive healthcare.


  • Open Access

    Shame, health literacy and consent

    by Barry Lyons, Luna Dolezal

    This paper is particularly concerned with shame, sometimes considered the ‘master emotion’, and its possible role in affecting the consent process, specifically where that shame relates to the issue of diminished health literacy. We suggest that the absence of exploration of affective issues in general during the consent process is problematic, as emotions commonly impact upon our decision-making process. Experiencing shame in the healthcare environment can have a significant influence on choices related to health and healthcare, and may lead to discussions of possibilities and alternatives being closed off. In the case of impaired health literacy we suggest that it obstructs the narrowing of the epistemic gap between clinician and patient normally achieved through communication and information provision. Health literacy shame prevents acknowledgement of this barrier. The consequence is that it may render consent less effective than it otherwise might have been in protecting the person's autonomy. We propose that the absence of consideration of health literacy shame during the consent process diminishes the possibility of the patient exerting full control over their choices, and thus bodily integrity.


  • Open Access

    Consent to testing for brain death

    by Barry Lyons, Mary Donnelly

    Canada has recently published a new Clinical Practice Guideline on the diagnosis and management of brain death. It states that consent is not necessary to carry out the interventions required to make the diagnosis. A supporting article not only sets out the arguments for this but also contends that ‘UK laws similarly carve out an exception, excusing clinicians from a prima facie duty to get consent’. This is supplemented by the claim that recent court decisions in the UK similarly confirm that consent is not required, referencing two judgements inBattersbee. We disagree with the authors’ interpretation of the law on consent in the UK and argue that there is nothing inBattersbeeto support the conclusion that consent to testing is not necessary. Where there is a disagreement about testing for brain death in the UK, court authorisation is required.


  • Taking the long view

    by Mary Donnelly, Barry Lyons

    This chapter concerns David Rothman’s origin story of the incursion of ‘outsiders’ (lawyers and bioethicists) into the world of medicine. Strangers at the Bedside: A History of How Law and Bioethics Transformed Medical Decision Making explains the how and why of this incursion and provides a meditation on the merits of the changes wrought. Written by an outsider and an insider, this chapter argues that the legacy of Strangers is not that it tells the ‘truth’ of the origins of contemporary health law, but, rather, lies in the methodological and evaluative approach which it employs. By asking questions about what bioethics and law have achieved, Strangers invites us to ponder their contemporary role and to critically evaluate their capacity to make a future meaningful contribution to the rights, health, and security of the public in their interactions with healthcare.

  • Open Access

    Disputing death: brain death in the courts

    by Mary Donnelly, Barry Lyons

    Death by neurological criteria (DNC) has remained controversial since its introduction over 50 years ago. Objections to the diagnosis of DNC have been coming before the courts in various jurisdictions, including at least seven recent challenges before the UK courts. In responding to these challenges, the UK courts have expressed no doubts as to the status of DNC and have affirmed that following a diagnosis of DNC, the matter of best interests is no longer relevant. Yet, the courts have also, tacitly, acknowledged that DNC is not quite the same as cardio-pulmonary death.This paper begins by setting out the origins of DNC as a medico-legal construction, and its ongoing controversies. It then analyses the treatment of DNC, including authorisation of DNC testing, by the UK courts. It shows that the courts have been operating a form of ad hoc reasonable accommodation of different views of DNC but have done so without normative engagement. The paper argues that the courts should recognise that DNC disputes are not simply concerned with whether, as a matter of fact, DNC has been correctly diagnosed, but also raise profound questions about rights and interests, both of families and of the DNC dead.


  • Open Access

    A different kind of death? Barts NHS Trust v Dance and Battersbee

    by Barry Lyons, Mary Donnelly

    The case of Archie Battersbee, a 12-year-old boy who suffered a catastrophic hypoxic brain injury, was the subject of several Family Division and Appeal Court hearings between April and August 2022. During the protracted legal process, appeals were made by the family to the Supreme Court, the European Court of Human Rights, and the United Nations’ Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD Committee). These were unsuccessful in achieving a stay on the withdrawal of life-sustaining interventions, whose continuance the Family Division of the High Court had found not to be in Archie’s best interests. This commentary focuses on two novel aspects of the proceedings: the Court of Appeal’s overturning of Arbuthnot J’s conclusion that Archie was brainstem dead, and the CRPD Committee’s intervention in response to the family’s appeal.