Thomas Dubos
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Thomas Dubos has a total of 182 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Philippe Drobinski
École Polytechnique
11 shared publications- Christian Barthlott
Institute of Meteorology and Climate Research Troposphere Research, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Karlsruhe, Germany
4 shared publications - Frédéric Hourdin
LMD/IPSL/Sorbonne Université, CNRS, Paris 75005, France
4 shared publications - Hiba Omrani
École Polytechnique
4 shared publications - Marine Tort
Laboratoire de Météorologie Dynamique, Université Pierre et Marie Curie, École Normale Supérieure and École Polytechnique, 91120 Palaiseau, France
4 shared publications - Étienne Vignon
Laboratoire de Météorologie Dynamique-IPSL, Sorbonne Université/CNRS/ Ecole Normale Supérieure-PSL Université/Ecole Polytechnique-Institut Polytechnique de Paris, Paris, France
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 October 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics
- p. 1-22
An energetically and thermodynamically consistent Boussinesq model
- 20 October 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics
- p. 1-22
Open AccessAn energetically and thermodynamically consistent Boussinesq model
- Open Access
- 28 February 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres
- Vol. 130 (5)
Antarctic Water Stable Isotopes in the Global Atmospheric Model LMDZ6: From Climatology to Boundary Layer Processes
Observations of water stable isotopes in Antarctic surface snow, precipitation and water vapor are key for improving our understanding of the atmospheric water cycle and past climate reconstructions from ice cores. In this study, we use isotopic observations in Antarctica to assess the skill of the isotope‐enabled atmospheric general circulation model LMDZ6, nudged to ERA5 above the boundary layer (1980–2023 period). The model has no significant bias for time‐mean temperature and snow accumulation over the ice sheet. Sensitivity test on parameterized supersaturation strength highlights its opposite effect on precipitation O and d‐excess. Selecting an intermediate supersaturation strength resulted in a minimal bias for surface snow O across the continent, with a reduced but systematic positive bias in surface snow d‐excess (5‰). We then assessed seasonal and diurnal isotope variability with daily precipitation and continuous vapor isotopes at Dumont d’Urville (DDU, coastal station) and Concordia (inland station). On a seasonal scale, LMDZ6iso accurately reproduces the seasonal cycle of precipitation O and d‐excess at both stations. Moving from statistical evaluation to physical analysis, we use the individual process contributions to boundary‐layer water vapor isotopes to identify the main drivers controlling the clear‐sky isotopic daily cycles. At Concordia, daily isotope variations are mainly driven by surface sublimation, whereas at DDU they are driven by surface sublimation and advection by the katabatic flow. Our results suggest that to further improve water isotopes in LMDZ6iso, fractionation during surface sublimation should be included and fractionation at condensation for low temperature should be better constrained.
- 28 February 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres
- Vol. 130 (5)
Open AccessAntarctic Water Stable Isotopes in the Global Atmospheric Model LMDZ6: From Climatology to Boundary Layer Processes
Observations of water stable isotopes in Antarctic surface snow, precipitation and water vapor are key for improving our understanding of the atmospheric water cycle and past climate reconstructions from ice cores. In this study, we use isotopic observations in Antarctica to assess the skill of the isotope‐enabled atmospheric general circulation model LMDZ6, nudged to ERA5 above the boundary layer (1980–2023 period). The model has no significant bias for time‐mean temperature and snow accumulation over the ice sheet. Sensitivity test on parameterized supersaturation strength highlights its opposite effect on precipitation O and d‐excess. Selecting an intermediate supersaturation strength resulted in a minimal bias for surface snow O across the continent, with a reduced but systematic positive bias in surface snow d‐excess (5‰). We then assessed seasonal and diurnal isotope variability with daily precipitation and continuous vapor isotopes at Dumont d’Urville (DDU, coastal station) and Concordia (inland station). On a seasonal scale, LMDZ6iso accurately reproduces the seasonal cycle of precipitation O and d‐excess at both stations. Moving from statistical evaluation to physical analysis, we use the individual process contributions to boundary‐layer water vapor isotopes to identify the main drivers controlling the clear‐sky isotopic daily cycles. At Concordia, daily isotope variations are mainly driven by surface sublimation, whereas at DDU they are driven by surface sublimation and advection by the katabatic flow. Our results suggest that to further improve water isotopes in LMDZ6iso, fractionation during surface sublimation should be included and fractionation at condensation for low temperature should be better constrained.
- Open Access
- 28 January 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 17 (1)
Energetically Consistent Eddy‐Diffusivity Mass‐Flux Convective Schemes: 1. Theory and Models
This paper presents a self‐contained derivation, from first principles, of a convective vertical mixing scheme based on the Eddy‐Diffusivity Mass‐Flux (EDMF) approach. This type of closure separates vertical turbulent fluxes into two components: an eddy‐diffusivity (ED) which accounts for local small‐scale mixing in a nearly isotropic environment, and a mass‐flux (MF) transport term, which represents the non‐local transport driven by vertically coherent plumes. Using the multi‐fluid averaging underlying the MF concept, we review consistent energy budgets between resolved and subgrid scales for seawater and dry atmosphere, in anelastic and Boussinesq frameworks. We demonstrate that when using an EDMF scheme, closed energy budgets can be recovered if: (a) bulk production terms of turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) by shear buoyancy include MF contributions; (b) boundary conditions are consistent with EDMF, to avoid spurious energy fluxes at the boundary. Furthermore, we show that lateral mixing, due to either entrainment or detrainment induces a net production of TKE via the shear term, with enhanced production under increased horizontal drag. We also provide constraints on boundary conditions to ensure mathematical consistency. Throughout the theoretical development, we maintain transparency regarding underlying assumptions. In a companion paper (Perrot and Lemarié (2024, https://hal.science/hal‐04666049); hereafter Part II) we assess the validity of these hypotheses, and analyze the sensitivity of the scheme to modeling choices against Large Eddy Simulations (LES) and observational data on oceanic convection. Part II also details an energy‐conserving discretization and quantifies energy biases in inconsistent formulations.
- 28 January 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 17 (1)
Open AccessEnergetically Consistent Eddy‐Diffusivity Mass‐Flux Convective Schemes: 1. Theory and Models
This paper presents a self‐contained derivation, from first principles, of a convective vertical mixing scheme based on the Eddy‐Diffusivity Mass‐Flux (EDMF) approach. This type of closure separates vertical turbulent fluxes into two components: an eddy‐diffusivity (ED) which accounts for local small‐scale mixing in a nearly isotropic environment, and a mass‐flux (MF) transport term, which represents the non‐local transport driven by vertically coherent plumes. Using the multi‐fluid averaging underlying the MF concept, we review consistent energy budgets between resolved and subgrid scales for seawater and dry atmosphere, in anelastic and Boussinesq frameworks. We demonstrate that when using an EDMF scheme, closed energy budgets can be recovered if: (a) bulk production terms of turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) by shear buoyancy include MF contributions; (b) boundary conditions are consistent with EDMF, to avoid spurious energy fluxes at the boundary. Furthermore, we show that lateral mixing, due to either entrainment or detrainment induces a net production of TKE via the shear term, with enhanced production under increased horizontal drag. We also provide constraints on boundary conditions to ensure mathematical consistency. Throughout the theoretical development, we maintain transparency regarding underlying assumptions. In a companion paper (Perrot and Lemarié (2024, https://hal.science/hal‐04666049); hereafter Part II) we assess the validity of these hypotheses, and analyze the sensitivity of the scheme to modeling choices against Large Eddy Simulations (LES) and observational data on oceanic convection. Part II also details an energy‐conserving discretization and quantifies energy biases in inconsistent formulations.
- 11 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 151 (766)
Geometric approximations for global atmospheres on moderately oblate planets
Certain geometric approximations, such as the widely used traditional shallow‐atmosphere, spherical‐geoid (TSA‐SG) and deep‐atmosphere, spherical‐geoid (DA‐SG) approximations, boil down to the specification of a spatial metric tensor. In order to eliminate the leading‐order errors due to the SG and TSA approximations, a sequence of four geometric approximations of decreasing accuracy at high altitudes is obtained. Their Lagrangians possess a simple, closed‐form analytical expression. The approximations capture to leading order the oblateness of the planet, the widening of atmospheric columns with height, the horizontal and vertical variations of gravity, and the non‐traditional part of the Coriolis force. Furthermore, for the last two approximations, the horizontal metric is conformal (proportional) to the spherical metric, which may simplify analytical and numerical formulations of the equations of motion.
- 11 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 151 (766)
Geometric approximations for global atmospheres on moderately oblate planets
Certain geometric approximations, such as the widely used traditional shallow‐atmosphere, spherical‐geoid (TSA‐SG) and deep‐atmosphere, spherical‐geoid (DA‐SG) approximations, boil down to the specification of a spatial metric tensor. In order to eliminate the leading‐order errors due to the SG and TSA approximations, a sequence of four geometric approximations of decreasing accuracy at high altitudes is obtained. Their Lagrangians possess a simple, closed‐form analytical expression. The approximations capture to leading order the oblateness of the planet, the widening of atmospheric columns with height, the horizontal and vertical variations of gravity, and the non‐traditional part of the Coriolis force. Furthermore, for the last two approximations, the horizontal metric is conformal (proportional) to the spherical metric, which may simplify analytical and numerical formulations of the equations of motion.
- Open Access
- 14 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 16 (10)
Designing a Fully‐Tunable and Versatile TKE‐l Turbulence Parameterization for the Simulation of Stable Boundary Layers
This study presents the development of a so‐called Turbulent Kinetic Energy (TKE)‐l, or TKE‐l, parameterization of the diffusion coefficients for the representation of turbulent diffusion in neutral and stable conditions in large‐scale atmospheric models. The parameterization has been carefully designed to be completely tunable in the sense that all adjustable parameters have been clearly identified and the number of parameters has been minimized as much as possible to help the calibration and to thoroughly assess the parametric sensitivity. We choose a mixing length formulation that depends on both static stability and wind shear to cover the different regimes of stable boundary layers. We follow a heuristic approach for expressing the stability functions and turbulent Prandlt number in order to guarantee the versatility of the scheme and its applicability for planetary atmospheres composed of an ideal and perfect gas such as that of Earth and Mars. Particular attention has been paid to the numerical stability and convergence of the TKE equation at large time steps, an essential prerequisite for capturing stable boundary layers in General Circulation Models (GCMs). Tests, parametric sensitivity assessments and preliminary tuning are performed on single‐column idealized simulations of the weakly stable boundary layer. The robustness and versatility of the scheme are assessed through its implementation in the Laboratoire de Météorologie Dynamique Zoom GCM and the Mars Planetary Climate Model and by running simulations of the Antarctic and Martian nocturnal boundary layers.
- 14 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 16 (10)
Open AccessDesigning a Fully‐Tunable and Versatile TKE‐l Turbulence Parameterization for the Simulation of Stable Boundary Layers
This study presents the development of a so‐called Turbulent Kinetic Energy (TKE)‐l, or TKE‐l, parameterization of the diffusion coefficients for the representation of turbulent diffusion in neutral and stable conditions in large‐scale atmospheric models. The parameterization has been carefully designed to be completely tunable in the sense that all adjustable parameters have been clearly identified and the number of parameters has been minimized as much as possible to help the calibration and to thoroughly assess the parametric sensitivity. We choose a mixing length formulation that depends on both static stability and wind shear to cover the different regimes of stable boundary layers. We follow a heuristic approach for expressing the stability functions and turbulent Prandlt number in order to guarantee the versatility of the scheme and its applicability for planetary atmospheres composed of an ideal and perfect gas such as that of Earth and Mars. Particular attention has been paid to the numerical stability and convergence of the TKE equation at large time steps, an essential prerequisite for capturing stable boundary layers in General Circulation Models (GCMs). Tests, parametric sensitivity assessments and preliminary tuning are performed on single‐column idealized simulations of the weakly stable boundary layer. The robustness and versatility of the scheme are assessed through its implementation in the Laboratoire de Météorologie Dynamique Zoom GCM and the Mars Planetary Climate Model and by running simulations of the Antarctic and Martian nocturnal boundary layers.
- 10 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 150 (764) , 4567-4579
On the thermodynamic invariance of fine‐grain and coarse‐grain fluid models
Thermodynamics is an essential ingredient of fine‐grain and coarse‐grain models of oceanic and atmospheric flows. Thermodynamic functions and conservative variables, for a given set of observable quantities such as pressure, temperature, and composition, may be defined up to a certain degree of arbitrariness, in the sense that the predictions of the fine‐grain model are insensitive to, for example, some reference enthalpies, entropies, or pressures. Since the compressible Navier–Stokes model, regarded as a “mother” fine‐grain model, is invariant with respect to arbitrary changes in reference enthalpies and entropies, restricted only by phase change, any coarse‐grain model obtained from it, even conceptually, must be invariant at least to the same extent. A framework is devised that enables the systematic examination of this invariance. It is found that the dependence of usual conservative variables on a reference pressure propagates to their fluxes and gradients, and to downgradient closures based on them. To resolve this issue, it is shown how to construct invariant “reduced” gradients and fluxes of enthalpy and entropy. Closure relationships between such “reduced” fluxes and gradients are then guaranteed to be invariant. More work is required to address the invariance of more sophisticated closures, especially shallow and deep convective closures.
- 10 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 150 (764) , 4567-4579
On the thermodynamic invariance of fine‐grain and coarse‐grain fluid models
Thermodynamics is an essential ingredient of fine‐grain and coarse‐grain models of oceanic and atmospheric flows. Thermodynamic functions and conservative variables, for a given set of observable quantities such as pressure, temperature, and composition, may be defined up to a certain degree of arbitrariness, in the sense that the predictions of the fine‐grain model are insensitive to, for example, some reference enthalpies, entropies, or pressures. Since the compressible Navier–Stokes model, regarded as a “mother” fine‐grain model, is invariant with respect to arbitrary changes in reference enthalpies and entropies, restricted only by phase change, any coarse‐grain model obtained from it, even conceptually, must be invariant at least to the same extent. A framework is devised that enables the systematic examination of this invariance. It is found that the dependence of usual conservative variables on a reference pressure propagates to their fluxes and gradients, and to downgradient closures based on them. To resolve this issue, it is shown how to construct invariant “reduced” gradients and fluxes of enthalpy and entropy. Closure relationships between such “reduced” fluxes and gradients are then guaranteed to be invariant. More work is required to address the invariance of more sophisticated closures, especially shallow and deep convective closures.
- Open Access
- 26 April 2024
- Published by Wiley
Designing a fully-tunable and versatile TKE-l turbulence parameterization for atmospheric models
This study presents the development of a TKE-l parameterization of the diffusion coefficients for the representation of turbulent diffusion in neutral and stable conditions in large-scale atmospheric models. The parameterization has been carefully designed to be completely tunable in the sense that all adjustable parameters have been clearly identified and their number minimized as much as possible to help the calibration and to thoroughly assess the parametric sensitivity. We choose a mixing length formulation that depends on both static stability and wind shear to cover the different regimes of stable boundary layers. We follow a heuristic approach for expressing the stability functions and turbulent Prandlt number in order to guarantee the versatility of the scheme and its applicability for planetary atmospheres composed of an ideal and perfect gas such as that of Earth and Mars. Particular attention has also been paid to the numerical stability at typical time steps used in General Circulation Models. Test, parametric sensitivity assessment and preliminary tuning are performed on single-column idealized simulations of the weakly stable boundary layer. The robustness and versatility of the scheme are also assessed through its implementation in the LMDZ General Circulation Model and the Mars Planetary Climate Model and by running simulations of the Antarctic and Martian nocturnal boundary layers.
- 26 April 2024
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessDesigning a fully-tunable and versatile TKE-l turbulence parameterization for atmospheric models
This study presents the development of a TKE-l parameterization of the diffusion coefficients for the representation of turbulent diffusion in neutral and stable conditions in large-scale atmospheric models. The parameterization has been carefully designed to be completely tunable in the sense that all adjustable parameters have been clearly identified and their number minimized as much as possible to help the calibration and to thoroughly assess the parametric sensitivity. We choose a mixing length formulation that depends on both static stability and wind shear to cover the different regimes of stable boundary layers. We follow a heuristic approach for expressing the stability functions and turbulent Prandlt number in order to guarantee the versatility of the scheme and its applicability for planetary atmospheres composed of an ideal and perfect gas such as that of Earth and Mars. Particular attention has also been paid to the numerical stability at typical time steps used in General Circulation Models. Test, parametric sensitivity assessment and preliminary tuning are performed on single-column idealized simulations of the weakly stable boundary layer. The robustness and versatility of the scheme are also assessed through its implementation in the LMDZ General Circulation Model and the Mars Planetary Climate Model and by running simulations of the Antarctic and Martian nocturnal boundary layers.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by OpenEdition in Histoire de la recherche contemporaine
- Vol. Tome XIII (Tome XIII )
Climats régionaux et régionalisation du climat
Une très grande variété de climats existe sur la Terre et des méthodes dédiées sont nécessaires pour comprendre leur variabilité et évolution dans un contexte de réchauffement climatique global. Au LMD, sont développées des approches numériques pour étudier les climats régionaux. Il s’agit historiquement du modèle global zoomé LMDZ et plus récemment du modèle régional du système Terre Reg-IPSL. Ces modèles ont permis l’étude de climats de nombreuses régions du globe, telles que l’Afrique de l’Ouest, la Méditerranée, l’Amérique du Sud, l’Asie, l’Antarctique et bien d’autres. Seules les études sur la région Méditerranée ont appliqué et comparé toutes les méthodes de régionalisation développées au laboratoire et sont développées dans cet article.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by OpenEdition in Histoire de la recherche contemporaine
- Vol. Tome XIII (Tome XIII )
Climats régionaux et régionalisation du climat
Une très grande variété de climats existe sur la Terre et des méthodes dédiées sont nécessaires pour comprendre leur variabilité et évolution dans un contexte de réchauffement climatique global. Au LMD, sont développées des approches numériques pour étudier les climats régionaux. Il s’agit historiquement du modèle global zoomé LMDZ et plus récemment du modèle régional du système Terre Reg-IPSL. Ces modèles ont permis l’étude de climats de nombreuses régions du globe, telles que l’Afrique de l’Ouest, la Méditerranée, l’Amérique du Sud, l’Asie, l’Antarctique et bien d’autres. Seules les études sur la région Méditerranée ont appliqué et comparé toutes les méthodes de régionalisation développées au laboratoire et sont développées dans cet article.
- Open Access
- 16 September 2022
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 14 (9)
Reconciling and Improving Formulations for Thermodynamics and Conservation Principles in Earth System Models (ESMs)
This paper provides a comprehensive derivation of the total energy equations for the atmospheric components of Earth System Models (ESMs). The assumptions and approximations made in this derivation are motivated and discussed. In particular, it is emphasized that closing the energy budget is conceptually challenging and hard to achieve in practice without resorting to ad hoc fixers. As a concrete example, the energy budget terms are diagnosed in a realistic climate simulation using a global atmosphere model. The largest total energy errors in this example are spurious dynamical core energy dissipation, thermodynamic inconsistencies (e.g., coupling parameterizations with the host model) and missing processes/terms associated with falling precipitation and evaporation (e.g., enthalpy flux between components). The latter two errors are not, in general, reduced by increasing horizontal resolution. They are due to incomplete thermodynamic and dynamic formulations. Future research directions are proposed to reconcile and improve thermodynamics formulations and conservation principles.
- 16 September 2022
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 14 (9)
Open AccessReconciling and Improving Formulations for Thermodynamics and Conservation Principles in Earth System Models (ESMs)
This paper provides a comprehensive derivation of the total energy equations for the atmospheric components of Earth System Models (ESMs). The assumptions and approximations made in this derivation are motivated and discussed. In particular, it is emphasized that closing the energy budget is conceptually challenging and hard to achieve in practice without resorting to ad hoc fixers. As a concrete example, the energy budget terms are diagnosed in a realistic climate simulation using a global atmosphere model. The largest total energy errors in this example are spurious dynamical core energy dissipation, thermodynamic inconsistencies (e.g., coupling parameterizations with the host model) and missing processes/terms associated with falling precipitation and evaporation (e.g., enthalpy flux between components). The latter two errors are not, in general, reduced by increasing horizontal resolution. They are due to incomplete thermodynamic and dynamic formulations. Future research directions are proposed to reconcile and improve thermodynamics formulations and conservation principles.
- Open Access
- 9 June 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 943
Local stability analysis of homogeneous and stratified Kelvin–Helmholtz vortices
We perform a three-dimensional short-wavelength linear stability analysis of numerically simulated two-dimensional Kelvin–Helmholtz vortices in homogeneous and stratified environments at a fixed Reynolds number of $Re = 300$ . For the homogeneous case, the elliptic instability at the vortex core dominates at early times, before being taken over by the hyperbolic instability at the vortex edge. For the stratified case of Richardson number $ Ri = 0.08$ , the early-time instabilities comprise a dominant elliptic instability at the core and a hyperbolic instability influenced strongly by stratification at the vortex edge. At intermediate times, the local approach shows a new branch of (convective) instability that emerges at the vortex core and subsequently moves towards the vortex edge. A few more convective instability bands appear at the vortex core and move away, before coalescing to form the most unstable region inside the vortex periphery at large times. In addition, the stagnation point instability is also recovered outside the periphery of the vortex at intermediate times. The dominant instability characteristics from the local approach are shown to be in good qualitative agreement with the results based on global instability studies for both homogeneous and stratified cases. A systematic study of the dependence of the dominant instability characteristics on $ Ri $ is then presented. While $ Ri = 0.1$ is identified as most unstable (with convective instability being dominant), another growth rate maximum at $ Ri = 0.025$ is not far behind (with the hyperbolic instability influenced by stratification being dominant). Finally, the local stability approach is shown to predict the potential orientation of the flow structures that would result from hyperbolic and convective instabilities, which is found to be consistent with three-dimensional numerical simulations reported previously.- 9 June 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 943
Open AccessLocal stability analysis of homogeneous and stratified Kelvin–Helmholtz vortices
We perform a three-dimensional short-wavelength linear stability analysis of numerically simulated two-dimensional Kelvin–Helmholtz vortices in homogeneous and stratified environments at a fixed Reynolds number of $Re = 300$ . For the homogeneous case, the elliptic instability at the vortex core dominates at early times, before being taken over by the hyperbolic instability at the vortex edge. For the stratified case of Richardson number $ Ri = 0.08$ , the early-time instabilities comprise a dominant elliptic instability at the core and a hyperbolic instability influenced strongly by stratification at the vortex edge. At intermediate times, the local approach shows a new branch of (convective) instability that emerges at the vortex core and subsequently moves towards the vortex edge. A few more convective instability bands appear at the vortex core and move away, before coalescing to form the most unstable region inside the vortex periphery at large times. In addition, the stagnation point instability is also recovered outside the periphery of the vortex at intermediate times. The dominant instability characteristics from the local approach are shown to be in good qualitative agreement with the results based on global instability studies for both homogeneous and stratified cases. A systematic study of the dependence of the dominant instability characteristics on $ Ri $ is then presented. While $ Ri = 0.1$ is identified as most unstable (with convective instability being dominant), another growth rate maximum at $ Ri = 0.025$ is not far behind (with the hyperbolic instability influenced by stratification being dominant). Finally, the local stability approach is shown to predict the potential orientation of the flow structures that would result from hyperbolic and convective instabilities, which is found to be consistent with three-dimensional numerical simulations reported previously.