Charlotte E. Blattner
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Charlotte E. Blattner has a total of 17 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Ana M. Vicedo-Cabrera
1 shared publication- Angela Kathrin Martin
Environmental Sciences and Humanities Institute, University of Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland
1 shared publication - Bernice Simonne Elger
Institute for Biomedical Ethics University of Basel Basel Switzerland
1 shared publication - Christian Rodriguez Perez
Institute for Biomedical Ethics, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland
1 shared publication Christoph C. Raible
1 shared publicationE. Meijer
Department of Social Sciences, University of Wageningen, Hollandseweg 1, 6700 EW Wageningen, the Netherlands
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy
- Vol. 29 (4) , 1125-1138
How ignoring the harm of killing undermines the ethical legitimacy of animal research: a case study from Switzerland
The most established approach to legitimizing animal research worldwide is through Harm-Benefit Analyses (HBAs), which require that the expected benefits of research be compared to and outweigh the harms done to animals. For this process to be ethically sound, all relevant harms must be considered. However, HBAs leave one fundamental harm insufficiently considered: killing, i.e., the deliberate termination of animals’ lives as part of the research project. This article argues that the law’s ignorance of the harm of killing leads to its trivialization in practice and, consequently, undermines the ethical legitimacy of deadly animal research projects. While our argument applies broadly, we use Switzerland as an illustrative case example. We first disentangle, from an ethical standpoint, the harms that killings inflict on animals in research. Second, we show that most harms of killing, both to the inherent worth and wellbeing of animals, are not accounted for in law, allowing killings to be trivialized. Third, we propose that killing should always (a) be subject to ethical and legal scrutiny by animal research commissions, (b) have to pass the necessity test (i.e., killing should be permitted if, and only if, it is necessary to achieve the purpose of the experiment), and (c) be included in HBAs. Fourth, we consider common objections to our arguments, and, in concluding, show why recognizing the harm of killing is essential to upholding the ethical legitimacy of animal research.
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy
- Vol. 29 (4) , 1125-1138
Open AccessHow ignoring the harm of killing undermines the ethical legitimacy of animal research: a case study from Switzerland
The most established approach to legitimizing animal research worldwide is through Harm-Benefit Analyses (HBAs), which require that the expected benefits of research be compared to and outweigh the harms done to animals. For this process to be ethically sound, all relevant harms must be considered. However, HBAs leave one fundamental harm insufficiently considered: killing, i.e., the deliberate termination of animals’ lives as part of the research project. This article argues that the law’s ignorance of the harm of killing leads to its trivialization in practice and, consequently, undermines the ethical legitimacy of deadly animal research projects. While our argument applies broadly, we use Switzerland as an illustrative case example. We first disentangle, from an ethical standpoint, the harms that killings inflict on animals in research. Second, we show that most harms of killing, both to the inherent worth and wellbeing of animals, are not accounted for in law, allowing killings to be trivialized. Third, we propose that killing should always (a) be subject to ethical and legal scrutiny by animal research commissions, (b) have to pass the necessity test (i.e., killing should be permitted if, and only if, it is necessary to achieve the purpose of the experiment), and (c) be included in HBAs. Fourth, we consider common objections to our arguments, and, in concluding, show why recognizing the harm of killing is essential to upholding the ethical legitimacy of animal research.
- Open Access
- 19 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Laboratory Animals
Advancing the 3Rs? Researchers’ perspectives on institutional facilitation in Switzerland – Part 1: originative facilitation
The implementation of the 3R principles (Replace, Reduce, Refine) requires a comprehensive understanding of the various levels at which they operate, as well as the factors that may hinder or support their advancement. Central to this process is incorporating the perspectives of stakeholders in biomedical research to develop practical and relevant strategies for action. In a qualitative study, we conducted 35 semi-structured interviews with Swiss researchers working on the 3Rs or animal experimentation. Interviews were analysed following a reflexive thematic analysis, and we identified two categories of facilitation: originative facilitation, which concerns epistemic aspects of the 3Rs, and executive facilitation, which concerns interventionist aspects of the 3Rs. In this article, we report on the former dimension, which can be further divided into the conceptualisation of the 3Rs on the one hand, and the education of researchers on the other hand. Although grounded in the Swiss context, these findings reveal key insights for researchers, policymakers, and institutional stakeholders internationally. As efforts to align animal research practices with ethical standards continue to grow globally, understanding how the 3Rs are conceptualised and taught is essential for creating coherent, cross-border strategies that foster responsible scientific practice. Clarifying definitions and reinforcing researcher education are critical steps in ensuring the consistent and meaningful implementation of the 3Rs across national boundaries.
- 19 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Laboratory Animals
Open AccessAdvancing the 3Rs? Researchers’ perspectives on institutional facilitation in Switzerland – Part 1: originative facilitation
The implementation of the 3R principles (Replace, Reduce, Refine) requires a comprehensive understanding of the various levels at which they operate, as well as the factors that may hinder or support their advancement. Central to this process is incorporating the perspectives of stakeholders in biomedical research to develop practical and relevant strategies for action. In a qualitative study, we conducted 35 semi-structured interviews with Swiss researchers working on the 3Rs or animal experimentation. Interviews were analysed following a reflexive thematic analysis, and we identified two categories of facilitation: originative facilitation, which concerns epistemic aspects of the 3Rs, and executive facilitation, which concerns interventionist aspects of the 3Rs. In this article, we report on the former dimension, which can be further divided into the conceptualisation of the 3Rs on the one hand, and the education of researchers on the other hand. Although grounded in the Swiss context, these findings reveal key insights for researchers, policymakers, and institutional stakeholders internationally. As efforts to align animal research practices with ethical standards continue to grow globally, understanding how the 3Rs are conceptualised and taught is essential for creating coherent, cross-border strategies that foster responsible scientific practice. Clarifying definitions and reinforcing researcher education are critical steps in ensuring the consistent and meaningful implementation of the 3Rs across national boundaries.
- 16 September 2025
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 15-34
From constitutional animal law toward interspecies constitutionalizing
- 16 September 2025
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 15-34
From constitutional animal law toward interspecies constitutionalizing
- Open Access
- 17 June 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The American Journal of Comparative Law
- Vol. 72 (1) , 1-32
For Whose Sake and Benefit? A Critical Analysis of Leading International Treaty Proposals to Protect Nonhuman Animals
Despite the considerable expansion of international law into virtually all areas of modern life, to date there is no international treaty in force to protect the interests of nonhuman animals. The lack of regulation and coordination at the international level comes at a considerable cost for animals, first and foremost, but also for humans, as the recent pandemic and ongoing climate crisis emphatically demonstrate. Proposals to fill this gap have proliferated in recent years, notably with the UN Convention on Animal Health and Protection (UNCAHP) and the Convention on Animal Protection for Public Health, Animal Welfare, and the Environment (CAP). This Article is the first of its kind to provide a critical legal analysis of the two draft treaties in order to assess their likely impacts on nonhuman animals, but also on human groups affected by their consequences. It first analyzes the draft treaties’ preambular language and broader setting to determine whether the treaties are embedded in arguments about human health, environmental protection, or mitigation of climate change, or whether animals are identified as direct beneficiaries of the treaty, and what the promises and dangers of each of these approaches are. The Article then looks to the treaties’ operative clauses, uncovering two problematic dynamics of the bedrock principle of “unnecessary suffering”: First, the maintenance of anthropocentric interest prioritization; and, second, its likely promotion of “Western” ways of using animals and the concomitant framing of “non-Western” practices as “culturally backward” and “uncivilized.” The Article concludes by offering guidance on how a progressive treaty could succeed at advancing human and nonhuman animals’ interests in tandem.
- 17 June 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The American Journal of Comparative Law
- Vol. 72 (1) , 1-32
Open AccessFor Whose Sake and Benefit? A Critical Analysis of Leading International Treaty Proposals to Protect Nonhuman Animals
Despite the considerable expansion of international law into virtually all areas of modern life, to date there is no international treaty in force to protect the interests of nonhuman animals. The lack of regulation and coordination at the international level comes at a considerable cost for animals, first and foremost, but also for humans, as the recent pandemic and ongoing climate crisis emphatically demonstrate. Proposals to fill this gap have proliferated in recent years, notably with the UN Convention on Animal Health and Protection (UNCAHP) and the Convention on Animal Protection for Public Health, Animal Welfare, and the Environment (CAP). This Article is the first of its kind to provide a critical legal analysis of the two draft treaties in order to assess their likely impacts on nonhuman animals, but also on human groups affected by their consequences. It first analyzes the draft treaties’ preambular language and broader setting to determine whether the treaties are embedded in arguments about human health, environmental protection, or mitigation of climate change, or whether animals are identified as direct beneficiaries of the treaty, and what the promises and dangers of each of these approaches are. The Article then looks to the treaties’ operative clauses, uncovering two problematic dynamics of the bedrock principle of “unnecessary suffering”: First, the maintenance of anthropocentric interest prioritization; and, second, its likely promotion of “Western” ways of using animals and the concomitant framing of “non-Western” practices as “culturally backward” and “uncivilized.” The Article concludes by offering guidance on how a progressive treaty could succeed at advancing human and nonhuman animals’ interests in tandem.
- 23 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 628 (8009) , 691
European ruling linking climate change to human rights could be a game changer — here’s how
- 23 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 628 (8009) , 691
European ruling linking climate change to human rights could be a game changer — here’s how
- 11 September 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 621 (7978) , 255-257
How science bolstered a key European climate-change case
- 11 September 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 621 (7978) , 255-257
How science bolstered a key European climate-change case
- 13 September 2022
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Society & Animals
- Vol. 31 (1) , 131-135
Toward Inclusive Health and Environmental Policy
"Toward Inclusive Health and Environmental Policy" published on 13 Sep 2022 by Brill.
- 13 September 2022
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Society & Animals
- Vol. 31 (1) , 131-135
Toward Inclusive Health and Environmental Policy
"Toward Inclusive Health and Environmental Policy" published on 13 Sep 2022 by Brill.
- 17 August 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Transnational Environmental Law
- Vol. 11 (1) , 201-214
The Swiss Primate Case: How Courts Have Paved the Way for the First Direct Democratic Vote on Animal Rights
A citizens’ initiative was launched in 2016 in the Swiss canton of Basel-Stadt, demanding that the rights catalogue in the Cantonal Constitution be complemented by a fundamental right to life and a right to bodily and mental integrity for non-human primates. This initiative became the subject of a three-year legal dispute that ended with a decision of the Swiss Federal Supreme Court in September 2020, ruling that the initiative is legally valid and must be put to the people for a vote. This case note discusses the key developments in the dispute, including the groundbreaking decision by the Constitutional Court of Basel-Stadt, which held that cantons are free to ‘expand the circle of rights holders beyond the anthropological barrier’. The authors, who were involved in the drafting of the initiative and acted as legal advisers in the judicial proceedings, offer first-hand insights into legal strategies and shed light on the importance of the case in the context of the ongoing efforts to secure rights for primates around the world.
- 17 August 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Transnational Environmental Law
- Vol. 11 (1) , 201-214
The Swiss Primate Case: How Courts Have Paved the Way for the First Direct Democratic Vote on Animal Rights
A citizens’ initiative was launched in 2016 in the Swiss canton of Basel-Stadt, demanding that the rights catalogue in the Cantonal Constitution be complemented by a fundamental right to life and a right to bodily and mental integrity for non-human primates. This initiative became the subject of a three-year legal dispute that ended with a decision of the Swiss Federal Supreme Court in September 2020, ruling that the initiative is legally valid and must be put to the people for a vote. This case note discusses the key developments in the dispute, including the groundbreaking decision by the Constitutional Court of Basel-Stadt, which held that cantons are free to ‘expand the circle of rights holders beyond the anthropological barrier’. The authors, who were involved in the drafting of the initiative and acted as legal advisers in the judicial proceedings, offer first-hand insights into legal strategies and shed light on the importance of the case in the context of the ongoing efforts to secure rights for primates around the world.
- 13 June 2021
- Published by Brill
- p. 349-355
54. Food security and symbolic legislation in Switzerland: a false sense of security?
- 13 June 2021
- Published by Brill
- p. 349-355
54. Food security and symbolic legislation in Switzerland: a false sense of security?