DDDaniel Darbyshire

Daniel Darbyshire

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Daniel Darbyshire has a total of 86 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Exit Interviews in Health Professions Education: Protocol for a Scoping Review

    by Daniel Darbyshire, Tobias Gumm, James Hill

    Background: Exit interviews are structured conversations with individuals leaving an organization, training program, or educational institution, aimed at understanding their experiences, reasons for departure, and suggestions for improvement. While commonly used in workforce settings to inform recruitment, retention, and organizational development strategies, their application within health professions education remains poorly understood. Learner and trainee attrition, program transfers, and workforce transitions may provide insights into educational experiences, training environments, and career progression. However, literature examining exit interviews in health professions education is fragmented and has not been comprehensively mapped. Objective: This study aims to systematically map the available literature on the use of exit interviews in health professions education and identify evidence gaps. Methods: This review will be based on the JBI methodology and will be reported in accordance with the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items For Systematic Reviews And Meta-Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews) checklist. We will search CINAHL, MEDLINE, Embase, HMIC, Social Policy and Practice, the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, the British Medical Journal Collection, PsycInfo, Business Source Complete, ProQuest Business Database, and Emerald Business and Management Journals. Gray literature sources include HMIC, Policy Commons, Overton, and Trip Medical Database. Reference lists of all included papers will be hand-searched. All studies that use or describe exit interviews within health professions education will be eligible, with no date limit. Two independent reviewers will screen an initial 10% sample at each screening stage. Substantial agreement (κ=0.61-0.80) will be required before a single reviewer completes the remaining screening. Data will be extracted by 1 reviewer and checked by a second, with disagreements resolved by consensus. AI will provide additional verification of data extraction, with human reviewers responsible for final decisions. Quantitative and categorical characteristics will be summarized descriptively, while textual data will be descriptively categorized to map how exit interviews are defined, used, and implemented and to identify evidence gaps. Results: The protocol was prospectively registered on OSF Registries on January 22, 2026. At the time of manuscript submission, we had developed and pilot-tested search strategies and data extraction procedures. The review is scheduled to run from October through December 2026. We expect to submit the completed review for publication in late 2026 or early 2027. Conclusions: This review will clarify how exit interviews have been conceptualized, implemented, and used in health professions education, identify evidence gaps, and inform future research and practice. Trial Registration: OSF Registries osf.io/pt2rx; https://osf.io/pt2rx/overview International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): PRR1-10.2196/95269

  • Open Access

    The effects of Balint groups on creating a sustainable working environment for doctors: a scoping review protocol (Preprint)

    by Ziyu Jiang, Daniel Darbyshire

    BACKGROUND Balint groups are a form of peer-reflective learning practice which has an established use in both general practice and psychiatry training. The sessions aim to facilitate the processing of difficult consultations by encouraging the participants to reflect upon the emotional experience of both the patient and the clinician during their interaction.The increasing pressures on healthcare provision across different specialities are reflected in a growing number of physicians leaving medicine. This scoping review aims to identify existing implementation of Balint groups across different specialities in the literature and the resulting impact this practice has on the working environment for doctors. Additionally, the scoping review aims to highlight gaps within the literature to support future research. OBJECTIVE This protocol describes the scoping review process, with the primary research question: What are the current applications of Balint groups, and how do they impact the working environment of participating clinicians? METHODS The proposed review will follow the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology and will report the findings using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR) checklist. A systematic search of both academic and grey literature databases will be conducted. The review will include studies which feature physicians and clinicians participating in Balint groups. Screening will comprise a three stage process of the title, abstract , full text and citations if necessary. Two reviewers will utilise the systematic review management program Rayyan and any disagreements will be noted and discussed. The subsequent data extraction will be performed by one reviewer and checked by the second, any disagreements will be discussed. Within the analysis, the review aims to highlight gaps in the literature to inform future research. RESULTS No results as this is a protocol. CONCLUSIONS No conclusions as this is a protocol. CLINICALTRIAL This protocol is registered on the Open Science Framework DOI: 10.17605/OSF.IO/EDS7W

  • Open Access

    Exit Interviews Use in Integrated Clinical Academic Training Programmes: An Online Survey to Elicit Current Practice in England and Wales

    by Daniel Darbyshire, Hanan Basheer

    Background: Exit interviews are widely used in human resources practice to understand employee experiences and inform organisational improvement. In academic medicine, trainees frequently transition between clinical and academic roles during integrated clinical academic training pathways, including Academic Clinical Fellowships (ACFs) and Academic Clinical Lectureships (ACLs). However, the use of exit interviews in this context is not well described. Objective: To explore the use of exit interviews within integrated clinical academic training (ICAT) programmes in England and Wales, and to identify existing practices, themes, and alternative approaches to trainee feedback. Methods: An online survey was distributed to ICAT leads across England and Wales via the InterACt network in May 2025. The survey addressed whether exit interviews were offered, their structure and content, and other feedback mechanisms. Responses were collected via email, collated using Microsoft Forms, and analysed descriptively. Results: Twenty responses were received. Only 4/20 (20%) programmes reported offering exit interviews for both ACFs and ACLs, while half (10/20) had no formal process. Practices ranged from structured, mandatory interviews to informal discussions. Where conducted, some programmes used templates or checklists, while others employed semi-structured approaches. Common themes included challenges in balancing clinical and academic responsibilities, delays in initiating research, and uncertainty around clinical academic career pathways. For ACLs, lack of bridging funding and limited post-CCT opportunities were key concerns. Positive experiences included strong institutional support, networking opportunities, and the value of induction and interim reviews. Most programmes (13/20) used alternative methods to collect feedback, particularly surveys (annual, exit, and alumni), alongside ARCP discussions and informal meetings. Conclusions: Exit interviews are not routinely implemented across ICAT programmes, although interest in their adoption is evident. Practices vary considerably, with surveys commonly used as an alternative feedback mechanism. Findings support development of a standardised exit interview approach tailored to clinical academic training.

  • Journal update monthly top five

    by Michael Dover, Mohammed Mokhtar, Catja Van Der Westhuizen, Mansour Mansour, Honora MacNamara, Mohammed Hamza, John Ryan, Daniel Darbyshire

  • Open Access

    Exit Interviews in Health Professions Education: Protocol for a Scoping Review (Preprint)

    by Daniel Darbyshire, Tobias Gumm, James Hill

    BACKGROUND Exit interviews are structured conversations with individuals leaving an organization, training program, or educational institution, aimed at understanding their experiences, reasons for departure, and suggestions for improvement. While commonly used in workforce settings to inform recruitment, retention, and organizational development strategies, their application within health professions education remains poorly understood. Learner and trainee attrition, program transfers, and workforce transitions may provide insights into educational experiences, training environments, and career progression. However, literature examining exit interviews in health professions education is fragmented and has not been comprehensively mapped. OBJECTIVE This study aims to systematically map the available literature on the use of exit interviews in health professions education and identify evidence gaps. METHODS This review will be based on the JBI methodology and will be reported in accordance with the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items For Systematic Reviews And Meta-Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews) checklist. We will search CINAHL, MEDLINE, Embase, HMIC, Social Policy and Practice, the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, the British Medical Journal Collection, PsycInfo, Business Source Complete, ProQuest Business Database, and Emerald Business and Management Journals. Gray literature sources include HMIC, Policy Commons, Overton, and Trip Medical Database. Reference lists of all included papers will be hand-searched. All studies that use or describe exit interviews within health professions education will be eligible, with no date limit. Two independent reviewers will screen an initial 10% sample at each screening stage. Substantial agreement (κ=0.61-0.80) will be required before a single reviewer completes the remaining screening. Data will be extracted by 1 reviewer and checked by a second, with disagreements resolved by consensus. AI will provide additional verification of data extraction, with human reviewers responsible for final decisions. Quantitative and categorical characteristics will be summarized descriptively, while textual data will be descriptively categorized to map how exit interviews are defined, used, and implemented and to identify evidence gaps. RESULTS The protocol was prospectively registered on OSF Registries on January 22, 2026. At the time of manuscript submission, we had developed and pilot-tested search strategies and data extraction procedures. The review is scheduled to run from October through December 2026. We expect to submit the completed review for publication in late 2026 or early 2027. CONCLUSIONS This review will clarify how exit interviews have been conceptualized, implemented, and used in health professions education, identify evidence gaps, and inform future research and practice. CLINICALTRIAL OSF Registries osf.io/pt2rx; https://osf.io/pt2rx/overview INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT PRR1-10.2196/95269

  • Qualitative study of reflective practice groups for emergency medicine resident doctors

    by Daniel Darbyshire, Geoff Haynes, Rhiannon Conway, Harriet Kennedy, Jade Baker, Alex Johnston, Richard Parris

    Aim Resident doctors in their 3rd year of emergency medicine training in the UK face multiple challenges, leading to very high levels of burnout and exodus from the training programme. The North West School of Emergency Medicine trialled reflective practice (Balint) groups to try and help this. This involves regular small group meetings focusing on case-based reflections on the emotional aspects of practice. We aimed to explore the impact of Balint groups on emergency medicine resident doctors. Methods Qualitative study involving semistructured interviews with resident doctors in their 3rd year of training (ST3) in the UK. Participants included those who had undertaken Balint group sessions, ST3s who did not participate, and Balint group facilitators. Interviews were recorded, transcribed and analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Findings 12 participants were included between September 2023 and May 2024. They reported Balint groups to be a hugely positive part of their training. Participants developed a psychological toolkit and a supportive community to help manage the emotional and stress-related aspects of emergency medicine. This led to improved job satisfaction, which participants believed would enhance retention. Participants felt their ability to manage the emotional needs and challenges of their patients had improved. The groups were feasible to run but required planning and communication to facilitate release from clinical work. Conclusion Balint groups for ST3 emergency medicine resident doctors are feasible. Clinicians report benefits for themselves and perceived benefits for their patients. This supports continuing and developing the programme locally and piloting similar programmes in other professional groups and localities.

  • Journal Update monthly top five

    by Gabrielle Prager, Laura Cottey, Govind Oliver, Liam Barrett, Daniel Darbyshire, Anisa Jabeen Nasir Jafar

  • Journal update monthly top five

    by Jonathan Matthews, Jenni Cooper, Tom Burt, Alexandra Pasint-Magyar, Hinal Patel, Neha Bhatia, George Taylor, Daniel Darbyshire

  • Journal update monthly top five

    by Spyridon Karageorgos, Anastasia Spartinou, Eleni Tasika, Eirini Trachanatzi, Christos Batsis, Maria Stratinaki, George Notas, Daniel Darbyshire

  • Open Access

    Retaining doctors in emergency medicine: an ethnographic study of emergency departments in England

    by Daniel Darbyshire, Liz Brewster, Rachel Isba, Richard Body, Dawn Goodwin

    Objectives To gain a deep understanding of factors driving retention in emergency medicine. To understand in detail the day-to-day lived experience of emergency medicine doctors, to identify and explore factors influencing retention, to situate these descriptions within the current educational and health policy contexts and to advance the debate and make policy and practice recommendations. Design Ethnography and semistructured interviews. Setting Two purposively sampled emergency departments in England, with additional interview participants recruited via social media and relevant stakeholder organisations. Participants 41 interview participants comprising 21 emergency physicians across 2 sites, 10 former emergency physicians and 10 stakeholders, with 132 hours of observation over 11 weeks in one emergency department in England. Results Three key themes were developed as relevant to the day-to-day lived experience of work in the emergency department, presenting challenges to retention and opportunities for change. First, emergency physicians needed to develop workarounds to mitigate the sensory and material challenges of working in a difficult environment. Second, education influences retention through valuing, fostering competence and entrustment and supporting interdependence. These were primarily observable in the workplace through senior staff prioritising the education of more junior staff. Third, community was important for retention. Linked to education through communities of practice, it was built by brief interpersonal interactions between emergency department workers. Situating these descriptions in current policy contexts identified less than full-time working, portfolio careers and mentorship as retention strategies. Self-rostering and annualisation facilitated these retention strategies. Conclusions The emergency department represents a difficult environment with many challenges, yet by focusing on how doctors navigate these difficulties, we can see the way in which retention occurs in everyday practices, and that valuing staff is critical for retention.