Christian G. Winkler
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Christian G. Winkler has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kenneth Mori McElwain
University of Tokyo
2 shared publications - Shusei Eshima
Harvard University
2 shared publications - Ai Takahashi
Harvard Kennedy Sch, Cambridge, MA USA
1 shared publication - Johannes Bieser
Institute of Coastal Research, Helmholtz-Centre Hereon, Max-Planck-Straße 1, Geesthacht, 21502, Germany
1 shared publication Ken Victor Hijino
Kyoto University
1 shared publicationKenneth Mori McElwain
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal of Constitutional Law
- Vol. 22 (3) , 680-709
Constitutional design preferences: An experimental approach
A rich literature links the survival of national constitutions to their legitimacy among citizens. However, most studies examine constitutions as a bundle of rights and institutions, and few test the micro-foundations of constitutional preferences explicitly. This article examines how individuals evaluate both the content and flexibility of discrete constitutional elements using a conjoint experiment in Japan. Respondents were asked to rate twenty-six hypothetical constitutions that varied randomly in their enumeration of twelve rights and institutions. We find that citizens generally prefer constitutions that enumerate more provisions, with greater weight placed on human rights than political institutions. This result largely confirms theoretical expectations from earlier work on comparative constitutional design. In addition, political factors, such as partisanship, moderate preferences on issues that have long divided progressives and conservatives in Japan, such as constraints on the military and establishing national emergency provisions. By contrast, socioeconomic characteristics such as income, age, and education do not, suggesting broad demographic consensus on the merits of distinct provisions. Importantly, we further demonstrate that citizens do not trade off constitutional detail and flexibility, as suggested by existing research. Respondents who prefer the enumeration of more provisions do not necessarily want a lower amendment hurdle to facilitate adaptation to new circumstances. Preferences about constitutional flexibility appear to be based on strategic imperatives, notably the desire to cement preferred provisions and prevent changes by future majorities.
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal of Constitutional Law
- Vol. 22 (3) , 680-709
Open AccessConstitutional design preferences: An experimental approach
A rich literature links the survival of national constitutions to their legitimacy among citizens. However, most studies examine constitutions as a bundle of rights and institutions, and few test the micro-foundations of constitutional preferences explicitly. This article examines how individuals evaluate both the content and flexibility of discrete constitutional elements using a conjoint experiment in Japan. Respondents were asked to rate twenty-six hypothetical constitutions that varied randomly in their enumeration of twelve rights and institutions. We find that citizens generally prefer constitutions that enumerate more provisions, with greater weight placed on human rights than political institutions. This result largely confirms theoretical expectations from earlier work on comparative constitutional design. In addition, political factors, such as partisanship, moderate preferences on issues that have long divided progressives and conservatives in Japan, such as constraints on the military and establishing national emergency provisions. By contrast, socioeconomic characteristics such as income, age, and education do not, suggesting broad demographic consensus on the merits of distinct provisions. Importantly, we further demonstrate that citizens do not trade off constitutional detail and flexibility, as suggested by existing research. Respondents who prefer the enumeration of more provisions do not necessarily want a lower amendment hurdle to facilitate adaptation to new circumstances. Preferences about constitutional flexibility appear to be based on strategic imperatives, notably the desire to cement preferred provisions and prevent changes by future majorities.
- 8 November 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of East Asian Studies
- Vol. 22 (3) , 503-523
Only Right Makes Might? Center-Right Policy Competition Among Major Japanese Parties After Electoral Reform
The effects of the 1990s reforms to the electoral system of Japan's House of Representatives have been among the most frequently discussed topics in political science research on the country. These reforms saw the replacement of a hitherto single nontransferable vote (SNTV) system by a mixed-member majoritarian (MMM) system with a strong Single Member District (SMD) and a weaker Proportional Representation (PR) component. Many studies have suggested that the reforms may have had significant impact on the strategies of political parties. Generally, SMD systems have been widely thought to favor larger parties, while PR systems are more beneficial to small and medium-sized parties. On the content side, larger parties seeking control of the government would try to win the support of large numbers of floating voters by campaigning on universal/programmatic policy appeals, as opposed to particularistic interests. In contrast, smaller parties would cater towards their core supporters’ preferences. Previous studies have noted that the old SNTV system in Japan had produced results similar to PR systems (Reed 2003). Japan's electoral reform may have thus changed the strategy of large parties, which would need to win more seats in the SMDs to gain (or hold onto) power, while smaller parties have continued to try and win seats via the PR tier. Therefore, the reform provides valuable research material in so far as we can simultaneously observe different effects by the SMD and the PR systems on parties of different sizes.
- 8 November 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of East Asian Studies
- Vol. 22 (3) , 503-523
Only Right Makes Might? Center-Right Policy Competition Among Major Japanese Parties After Electoral Reform
The effects of the 1990s reforms to the electoral system of Japan's House of Representatives have been among the most frequently discussed topics in political science research on the country. These reforms saw the replacement of a hitherto single nontransferable vote (SNTV) system by a mixed-member majoritarian (MMM) system with a strong Single Member District (SMD) and a weaker Proportional Representation (PR) component. Many studies have suggested that the reforms may have had significant impact on the strategies of political parties. Generally, SMD systems have been widely thought to favor larger parties, while PR systems are more beneficial to small and medium-sized parties. On the content side, larger parties seeking control of the government would try to win the support of large numbers of floating voters by campaigning on universal/programmatic policy appeals, as opposed to particularistic interests. In contrast, smaller parties would cater towards their core supporters’ preferences. Previous studies have noted that the old SNTV system in Japan had produced results similar to PR systems (Reed 2003). Japan's electoral reform may have thus changed the strategy of large parties, which would need to win more seats in the SMDs to gain (or hold onto) power, while smaller parties have continued to try and win seats via the PR tier. Therefore, the reform provides valuable research material in so far as we can simultaneously observe different effects by the SMD and the PR systems on parties of different sizes.
- 4 August 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Social Science Japan Journal
- Vol. 26 (1) , 133-136
Tōchi no dezain: Nihon no kenpō kaisei o kangaeru tame ni
Tōchi no dezain (Constitutional Design of Government) is a substantial volume focusing on the perennially contentious and thus popular topic of the Constitution of Japan (COJ) and the seven-decades-old debate about constitutional change. In many ways, this book is a sequel to and extension of 2016’s Kenpō kaisei no hikaku seijigaku by the same duo of editors, Keio University’s Komamura Keigo and Kyoto University’s Machidori Satoshi. The new book’s goal is to analyse the content of the supreme law under the premise of their earlier publication’s conclusion, i.e. that constitutional change had de facto happened, despite the absence of a formal amendment to the 75-year-old COJ. The underlying argument is that the highly flexible institutional stipulations of the COJ have allowed the government to carry out substantial and far-reaching reforms that are amendments in all but name. These include the 1994 changes to the Lower House’s electoral system and...
- 4 August 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Social Science Japan Journal
- Vol. 26 (1) , 133-136
Tōchi no dezain: Nihon no kenpō kaisei o kangaeru tame ni
Tōchi no dezain (Constitutional Design of Government) is a substantial volume focusing on the perennially contentious and thus popular topic of the Constitution of Japan (COJ) and the seven-decades-old debate about constitutional change. In many ways, this book is a sequel to and extension of 2016’s Kenpō kaisei no hikaku seijigaku by the same duo of editors, Keio University’s Komamura Keigo and Kyoto University’s Machidori Satoshi. The new book’s goal is to analyse the content of the supreme law under the premise of their earlier publication’s conclusion, i.e. that constitutional change had de facto happened, despite the absence of a formal amendment to the 75-year-old COJ. The underlying argument is that the highly flexible institutional stipulations of the COJ have allowed the government to carry out substantial and far-reaching reforms that are amendments in all but name. These include the 1994 changes to the Lower House’s electoral system and...
- Open Access
- 25 March 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Japanese Journal of Political Science
- Vol. 22 (1) , 15-39
The proposer or the proposal? An experimental analysis of constitutional beliefs
In many countries, constitutional amendments require the direct approval of voters, but the consequences of fundamental changes to the powers and operations of the state are difficult to anticipate. The referendums literature suggests that citizens weigh their prior beliefs about the merits of proposals against the heuristic provided by the partisanship of the proposer, but the relative salience of these factors across constitutional issue areas remains underexplored. This paper examines the determinants of citizen preferences on 12 diverse constitutional issues, based on a novel survey experiment in Japan. We show that support for amendments is greater when its proposer is described as non-partisan. However, constitutional ideology moderates this effect. Those who prefer idealistic constitutions that elevate national traditions tend to value proposals that expand government powers, compared to those who prefer pragmatic constitutions that constrain government authority. These results highlight the significance of constitutional beliefs that are independent of partisanship.
- 25 March 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Japanese Journal of Political Science
- Vol. 22 (1) , 15-39
Open AccessThe proposer or the proposal? An experimental analysis of constitutional beliefs
In many countries, constitutional amendments require the direct approval of voters, but the consequences of fundamental changes to the powers and operations of the state are difficult to anticipate. The referendums literature suggests that citizens weigh their prior beliefs about the merits of proposals against the heuristic provided by the partisanship of the proposer, but the relative salience of these factors across constitutional issue areas remains underexplored. This paper examines the determinants of citizen preferences on 12 diverse constitutional issues, based on a novel survey experiment in Japan. We show that support for amendments is greater when its proposer is described as non-partisan. However, constitutional ideology moderates this effect. Those who prefer idealistic constitutions that elevate national traditions tend to value proposals that expand government powers, compared to those who prefer pragmatic constitutions that constrain government authority. These results highlight the significance of constitutional beliefs that are independent of partisanship.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment
- Vol. 87, 102536
Modelling road transport emissions in Germany – Current day situation and scenarios for 2040
- 1 October 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment
- Vol. 87, 102536
Open AccessModelling road transport emissions in Germany – Current day situation and scenarios for 2040
- 1 September 2020
- Published by University of California Press in Asian Survey
- Vol. 60 (5) , 882-904
A Historical Analysis of the LDP's 2018 Constitutional Amendment Proposals Mission: Moderation?
In 2018 Japan's Liberal Democratic Party announced four new proposals to amend the seven-decades-old and thus-far unamended constitution of Japan. These include adding a third paragraph to Article 9, as well as state-of-emergency provisions, support for students in need, and changes to the electoral system. By analyzing each proposal's place in the debate on amendments dating back to the 1950s, I show that these very different proposals share one important feature that sets them apart from recent drafts aiming for wholesale reform of the constitution: they are relatively minimalist in nature. This new modesty is due to the necessity to win over other parties and voters, but it is also an attempt to cement rather than to change the LDP-made status quo.
- 1 September 2020
- Published by University of California Press in Asian Survey
- Vol. 60 (5) , 882-904
A Historical Analysis of the LDP's 2018 Constitutional Amendment Proposals Mission: Moderation?
In 2018 Japan's Liberal Democratic Party announced four new proposals to amend the seven-decades-old and thus-far unamended constitution of Japan. These include adding a third paragraph to Article 9, as well as state-of-emergency provisions, support for students in need, and changes to the electoral system. By analyzing each proposal's place in the debate on amendments dating back to the 1950s, I show that these very different proposals share one important feature that sets them apart from recent drafts aiming for wholesale reform of the constitution: they are relatively minimalist in nature. This new modesty is due to the necessity to win over other parties and voters, but it is also an attempt to cement rather than to change the LDP-made status quo.
- 30 August 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Asian Studies Review
- Vol. 42 (4) , 586-606
Party Ideologies and Regional Inequality: An Analysis of Party Manifestos in Japan
Regional inequality within Japan has been a key political issue in Japanese politics throughout the entire postwar period. In this analysis, we examine how Japanese parties have positioned themselves on the question of regional inequality, focusing on how the party system response has been shaped by ideas and ideologies. The article analyses two 15-year periods separated by a quarter of a century (1960–75 and 2000–15) during which regional inequalities became a particularly salient and pressing issue. We compare institutional and socioeconomic contexts, broader governing ideas, and policy responses to this issue by major parties in their election platforms (manifestos). We find that party ideology and broader paradigms continued to shape party responses to regional inequality during both periods.
- 30 August 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Asian Studies Review
- Vol. 42 (4) , 586-606
Party Ideologies and Regional Inequality: An Analysis of Party Manifestos in Japan
Regional inequality within Japan has been a key political issue in Japanese politics throughout the entire postwar period. In this analysis, we examine how Japanese parties have positioned themselves on the question of regional inequality, focusing on how the party system response has been shaped by ideas and ideologies. The article analyses two 15-year periods separated by a quarter of a century (1960–75 and 2000–15) during which regional inequalities became a particularly salient and pressing issue. We compare institutional and socioeconomic contexts, broader governing ideas, and policy responses to this issue by major parties in their election platforms (manifestos). We find that party ideology and broader paradigms continued to shape party responses to regional inequality during both periods.
- 1 August 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Social Science Japan Journal
- Vol. 20 (2) , 203-224
Right On? The LDP’s Drift to the Right and the Persistence of Particularism
Since Prime Minister Abe’s return to power in 2012, there has been an ongoing discussion about whether and if so to what extent the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) had drifted to the ‘right’. This article argues that it is important to distinguish between conservative and neoliberal policy appeals, as those two ideologies often clash with each other, despite being united under the casual ‘right’ banner. Using a newly coded, comprehensive database of LDP election platforms dating back to the 1950s, the analysis presented here shows that electoral reform alone cannot explain the development of these policy appeals since the 1990s. By comparing the LDP to its center-right counterparts in Western countries, I show that external shocks such as the Oil Crisis and the end of the Cold War have influenced neoliberal and conservative policy pledges in Japan and elsewhere. While these trends are similar, the LDP has placed a comparatively lower priority on conservative, and even more so neoliberal policy appeals. The article argues that this is due to the continued relevance of particularistic policy appeals, which are less important in the US, Germany or Great Britain.
- 1 August 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Social Science Japan Journal
- Vol. 20 (2) , 203-224
Right On? The LDP’s Drift to the Right and the Persistence of Particularism
Since Prime Minister Abe’s return to power in 2012, there has been an ongoing discussion about whether and if so to what extent the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) had drifted to the ‘right’. This article argues that it is important to distinguish between conservative and neoliberal policy appeals, as those two ideologies often clash with each other, despite being united under the casual ‘right’ banner. Using a newly coded, comprehensive database of LDP election platforms dating back to the 1950s, the analysis presented here shows that electoral reform alone cannot explain the development of these policy appeals since the 1990s. By comparing the LDP to its center-right counterparts in Western countries, I show that external shocks such as the Oil Crisis and the end of the Cold War have influenced neoliberal and conservative policy pledges in Japan and elsewhere. While these trends are similar, the LDP has placed a comparatively lower priority on conservative, and even more so neoliberal policy appeals. The article argues that this is due to the continued relevance of particularistic policy appeals, which are less important in the US, Germany or Great Britain.
- 3 July 2015
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Japan Forum
- Vol. 27 (3) , 405-410
Those were the days: the rise and fall of the LDP's factions
(2015). Those were the days: the rise and fall of the LDP's factions. Japan Forum: Vol. 27, Excavating the Power of Memory, pp. 405-410.
- 3 July 2015
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Japan Forum
- Vol. 27 (3) , 405-410
Those were the days: the rise and fall of the LDP's factions
(2015). Those were the days: the rise and fall of the LDP's factions. Japan Forum: Vol. 27, Excavating the Power of Memory, pp. 405-410.
- 1 June 2015
- Published by Project MUSE in The Journal of Japanese Studies
- Vol. 41 (2) , 249-280
What’s Unique about the Japanese Constitution?: A Comparative and Historical Analysis
Japan has the oldest unamended constitution in the world. We examine the determinants of its longevity and recent proposals seeking its amendment. While traditional revision attempts have focused on ideological provisions such as Article 9 and the imperial system, changes to political institutions, particularly bicameralism and local governance, have become a focal point since 2005. Our comparative analysis demonstrates that the constitution’s enumeration of institutions is uncommonly vague, leaving room for significant reforms. However, we also show that the most recent (2012) amendment proposal by the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) would not “fix” this lacuna, leaving the constitution an international outlier.
- 1 June 2015
- Published by Project MUSE in The Journal of Japanese Studies
- Vol. 41 (2) , 249-280
What’s Unique about the Japanese Constitution?: A Comparative and Historical Analysis
Japan has the oldest unamended constitution in the world. We examine the determinants of its longevity and recent proposals seeking its amendment. While traditional revision attempts have focused on ideological provisions such as Article 9 and the imperial system, changes to political institutions, particularly bicameralism and local governance, have become a focal point since 2005. Our comparative analysis demonstrates that the constitution’s enumeration of institutions is uncommonly vague, leaving room for significant reforms. However, we also show that the most recent (2012) amendment proposal by the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) would not “fix” this lacuna, leaving the constitution an international outlier.